Skip to content

QUESTION PERIOD — Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources

Business of Committee

May 8, 2019


Hon. Yuen Pau Woo [ + ]

My question is for the chair of the Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources. Senator Galvez, I was surprised and disappointed that the Whip of the Opposition has denied leave for this committee to meet on Monday with extended hours in order to deal with clause by clause on a bill that all of this country is looking at very closely and looking to us to move important amendments to improve the bill.

Can you tell us the basis for the motion that you moved and whether it had support from the committee at the meeting held last night?

Thank you very much for the question, Senator Woo.

I was very surprised, because, as you know, we passed this motion unanimously at committee. Right before the sitting, I confirmed with Senator MacDonald, the deputy chair of the committee, who assured me it was going to be granted.

I am also really disappointed.

Hon. Donald Neil Plett [ + ]

Your Honour, if I could.

Senator Galvez, as you clearly know, if you and Senator Woo were paying attention, the Opposition Whip did not deny you leave to sit; he denied leave for this to be considered this day. A notice of motion is that you can make this motion tomorrow, and there is nothing that the Whip of the Opposition party can do in that regard.

Is that not correct?

I think what you are saying is that I just have to do it tomorrow, and then you will agree.

What is the difference between doing it today or tomorrow?

Senator Plett [ + ]

That is not what I said. I’m the one asking the question —

The Hon. the Speaker [ + ]

Senator Plett, please.

Honourable senators, this is Question Period. There are questions for the Representative of the Government in the Senate or for chairs of committees. We’re not into a debate about what happened earlier today.

Just for clarity, if leave is not granted to hear a motion now, any senator can give notice of that exact same motion to be heard the next day. Since neither senator who was denied leave asked for that today, there still is an option to ask for the consent of the house to revert to Notices of Motions and ask to do it later on today —

Senator Plett [ + ]

That will also require leave.

The Hon. the Speaker [ + ]

— or tomorrow. That can be done, as well.

There are lots of options open to senators if leave was not granted, but leave was just not granted that it be heard later today.

We now carry on with Question Period.

Back to top