Transportation Modernization Bill
Bill to Amend—Message from Commons—Motion for Concurrence in Commons Amendments and Non-Insistence Upon Senate Amendments—Debate
May 9, 2018
The Honorable Senator Percy E. Downe:
I fully respect your position that you are deferring to the House of Commons, but I have been intrigued over the last couple of weeks that there have been hand-wringing and nervous concerns about the role of the Senate, what we should be doing and how we should be doing it. There have been references to the House of Lords and the British system, which we are based upon, but the House of Lords, of course, never defeats legislation the government campaigned on.
However, I’m wondering if you’re aware that, yesterday, the House of Lords defeated a Brexit amendment on which the government not only ran an election but on which it had a separate referendum. They defeated it by a vote of 335 to 244. It is all over the British media as a major defeat for Prime Minister May. She promised the house a meaningful vote, and the Lords insisted it would be a binding vote. They passed an amendment to that end.
Given we are based upon the House of Lords and given the reference to the British system I have heard over the last few weeks, would that be consideration in changing positions in this chamber, in your opinion, or should we always defer to the House of Commons?