Skip to main content
AEFA - Standing Committee

Foreign Affairs and International Trade


THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Wednesday, October 7, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade met with videoconference this day at 4:15 p.m. [ET] to examine and report on such issues as may arise from time to time relating to foreign relations and international trade generally; and, in camera, to examine the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 11 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025.

Senator Peter M. Boehm (Chair) in the chair.

[Translation]

The Chair: Honourable senators, I would like to welcome you to this meeting of the Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade. My name is Peter Boehm. I’m a senator from Ontario and the chair of this committee.

I would now like to invite the committee members here today to introduce themselves.

[English]

Senator Adler: Charles Adler, Manitoba.

Senator Downe: Percy Downe, Charlottetown.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: Amina Gerba from Quebec.

[English]

Senator McCallum: Welcome to the Senate. Senator McCallum from Manitoba, Treaty 10.

Senator Woo: Yuen Pau Woo, British Columbia.

Senator Harder: Peter Harder, Ontario.

Senator Wilson: Duncan Wilson, British Columbia.

Senator M. Deacon: Welcome back. Marty Deacon, Ontario.

Senator McNair: Welcome. John McNair from New Brunswick.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: Welcome. Martine Hébert from Quebec.

[English]

The Chair: Welcome, senators, and I would like to welcome all who may be watching us across the country on ParlVU.

Colleagues, we are meeting today to discuss Canada’s trade relationship with the United States but also the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, or CUSMA, as it comes up in the larger context of the trade agreement.

Today, we have the pleasure of welcoming to the committee, from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, Matthew Holmes, Executive Vice President, International & Chief of Public Policy, and Monika LeRoy, Senior Director, International Policy & Global Partnerships; and, from the Canadian Cattle Association, Daniela Lombardo, Policy Manager. Welcome and thank you for being with us today.

Before we hear your opening statements and proceed to questions and answers, I would like everyone in the room to please mute notifications on your devices. Also, when you do speak, I would like you to observe the instructions on the cards; in other words, be very careful with the use of your earpiece and the use of the microphone so that feedback and audio problems that could be injurious to our staff and, particularly, to our interpreters don’t result.

We are ready to hear your opening remarks. These, of course, will be followed by questions from senators. Mr. Holmes, you have the floor. You will be followed by Ms. Lombardo.

Matthew Holmes, Executive Vice President, International and Chief of Public Policy, Canadian Chamber of Commerce: Thank you, Mr. Chair and honourable senators. It is a pleasure to be with you this afternoon, and I appreciate the invitation. I will share my time with my colleague, Monika, as well.

It is also a pleasure for the Canadian Chamber of Commerce to testify alongside two of our members, the Canadian Cattle Association and, in the next panel, the Forest Products Association of Canada.

When the Canadian Chamber appeared before this committee last November, we emphasized the importance of preserving and strengthening CUSMA. That priority remains, but the environment our members are operating in has changed. Since formal negotiations were suspended in August, this pressure has widened. Section 338 tariffs now reach goods that qualify and should be compliant under CUSMA. Since September 29, Canadian motor vehicles of certain kinds and dairy and alcoholic beverages have faced outright U.S. import bans. All of this sits on top of section 232 tariffs, as you know, on steel, aluminum, autos, copper and lumber.

For a small exporter operating on tight margins, these measures are not an abstract trade policy debate, nor are they a macroeconomic rounding error. They affect orders, investment decisions, payroll and, ultimately, jobs in communities.

CUSMA underpins the uniquely integrated nature of North American economic and commercial ties. It provides the predictable market access and stable rules that businesses rely on to invest, plan and operate across the continent. I would add that it also provides the certainty important for foreign direct investment.

At the Canadian Chamber, our priority is continuity. Canada should prioritize the preservation of CUSMA and its key provisions, including its trilateral character.

Our second priority is competitiveness. A secure, resilient, North American industrial base depends on preferential treatment among the three CUSMA partners, protecting our competitiveness and keeping everyday goods more affordable. It provides the continent a stronger production base, better able to understand global overcapacity and unfair trade practices from outside the region.

Canada should use the review to strengthen the North American economic security and competitiveness by reducing regulatory barriers, improving trade facilitation and deepening critical mineral cooperation.

Our third urgent priority is addressing tariffs. Canada should press a clear path to unwind section 232 tariffs and other unilateral trade measures, restore preferential treatment for all CUSMA-compliant goods and establish a rapid-response mechanism so that future trade measures trigger ministerial consultation rather than escalation.

We remain confident both countries will return to the table and that, eventually, a trilateral deal is possible.

My colleague, Monika, will speak to what Canada can do in the meantime.

Monika LeRoy, Senior Director, International Policy & Global Partnerships, Canadian Chamber of Commerce: Honourable senators, Canada cannot control decisions made in Washington. We can control how ready our businesses are and how well we make our case.

First, the integration story must be told on both sides of the border. Canada is the top export market for more than two dozen U.S. states, and the largest overall trading partner for nearly half of all states. Our Business Data Lab, or BDL, found that Michigan’s exports to Canada fell by almost US$3.5 billion between 2024 and 2025, with an estimated 15,600 fewer export-supported jobs. This message is strongest when American businesses and chambers carry it themselves. Your relationships with your U.S. counterparts can help.

The work continues. Next month, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce will lead a business delegation to the B20 summit in Washington, which will include a trilateral round table with our U.S. counterparts.

Second, diversification is gaining ground, but it is still a long road. In July, exports beyond the U.S. reached record levels. Monthly figures will swing, but the task is about making that shift durable. Canada doesn’t just need trade; we need more traders.

On October 5, our Business Data Lab launched a trade explorer, a free tool mapping about $4 trillion in export opportunities across 182 markets, to help more firms, especially our small- and medium-sized enterprises, find where they can compete globally.

Diversification and North American integration are not mutually exclusive. Diversification grows the opportunities and adds customers; it doesn’t replace them.

Third, we need to do the work at home. Our new report with PwC, Beyond Potential, finds that Canada has real strength in energy, critical minerals, agri-food, defence and AI, but we’re missing key links in each value chain. Closing those gaps — from faster permitting to processing capacity and trade-enabling infrastructure — is all within our control. That starts with opening our internal market and keeping temporary relief measures fast and simple.

Canadian businesses have demonstrated remarkable resilience. What they need now are certainty and the conditions to invest, compete and grow. Thank you. We look forward to your questions.

The Chair: Thank you very much. Congratulations on splitting your time evenly and still staying on the mark of five minutes; that’s very impressive.

I would like to acknowledge that Senator Coyle of Nova Scotia has joined the meeting.

Now I will give the floor to Daniela Lombardo. Please go ahead.

Daniela Lombardo, Policy Manager, Canadian Cattle Association: Good afternoon, Senate members. My name is Daniela Lombardo. I am a Policy Manager with the Canadian Cattle Association, or CCA.

Today, I have the pleasure to discuss Canada-U.S. trade and the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, also known as CUSMA. Through our provincial members, CCA represents approximately 60,000 beef producers across Canada, supporting jobs, the economy, rural communities and food security.

Through Canada’s beef industry, over 350,000 jobs have been created. Trade is a critical part of our sector. The North American live cattle and beef supply chain is the largest in the world. Together, Canada, the U.S. and Mexico move cattle, beef and feed to where it is needed the most. Each year, Canada exports about half of the value of the live cattle we raise and beef we produce. The U.S. accounts for 75% of those exports, and Mexico accounts for 5%.

The beef sector in Canada and the U.S. operates as a single market. Live cattle move across the border tariff-free and relatively unimpeded, sometimes multiple times, before it becomes beef that then may be traded one more time. Our sector’s infrastructure was built on both sides of the border to support cattle movement tariff-free. From cow calf to feed lots to processors, more choice is positive for ranchers on both sides of the border.

CUSMA provides benefits for producers all the way to consumers. We’re able to keep lower food costs for consumers on both sides of the border, provide beef producers with more options to sell their cattle and increase food security across North America. The Canada-U.S. trading relationship, alongside the review of CUSMA, is a number one priority of Canada’s beef cattle sector. We work collectively with our counterparts in the U.S. and Mexico.

Broadly speaking, the North American agricultural sector is aligned in supporting the renewal and strengthening of CUSMA. CCA continues working with stakeholders in the U.S. to promote free and open trade. We continue to engage with our U.S. counterparts, other stakeholders, U.S. Congress and our embassy on the ground.

As we work toward reviewing CUSMA, CCA is committed to working with the government and stakeholders across North America to see through an agreement that keeps tariff-free trade.

As you probably recall, CCA spoke in the House and the Senate about our sector’s concerns with the ongoing Mercosur negotiations. While this is not the focus of today’s meeting, we want to highlight the relationship between Mercosur and CUSMA. Ranchers on both sides of the border are concerned about increased beef imports from Mercosur. We urge the Government of Canada to consider the impact of finalizing a Mercosur deal on our relationship with the U.S., our largest trade partner.

We encourage Canada to keep CUSMA at the top of our trade agenda. While we support strategic trade diversification, when it comes to beef production, Canada and the U.S. work together to create the best beef product in the world.

Our sector will help meet Canada’s trade diversification goals by growing our herd, rather than diversifying away from the U.S. We cannot and should not jeopardize one of the best and largest beef supply chains in the world.

Thank you for the invitation, and I look forward to your questions.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

[Translation]

I would like to remind the committee members that you each have three minutes for the first round of questions. This includes questions and answers.

[English]

I want to also note that our panels today will each be slightly shorter than usual, 55 minutes, to leave time at the end of our meeting to go in camera to consider our draft report on the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 11 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, Budget 2025 implementation act, no. 2.

Therefore, members of the committee and our witnesses, please be concise, as we don’t have that much time. We will go to a second round if there is time to do so.

We will start with the deputy chair, Senator Harder.

Senator Harder: Thank you to our panellists for your statements. I want to follow up on the statements you made and to inquire about the resilience of the North American economic space.

Your comments suggest there is an economic advantage in continuing with a North American approach to economic activities. Two points: One, is that a shared view with your counterparts in other jurisdictions? And to what extent does it become “Fortress North America”? Is that possible to sustain politically?

I’m a little worried, frankly, that the Canadian public’s attitude in reaction to the American actions will make it very it difficult to have a politically acceptable agreement. I would like your comments on that.

Mr. Holmes: Thank you for your question. First, to the counterparts, we have had and maintain regular and consistent communications with counterparts in Mexico and the United States. In March of this year, 69 different major U.S. associations wrote to Ambassador Greer; close to 200 in 2025, including a number from the aggregate food sector. It is clear and unequivocal that there is support for continued North American integrated and preferred treatment for Mexico and Canada in the form of the USMCA in the U.S. context.

My interactions with Mexican business groups are also consistently sending a similar message, whether it is sectoral, in the auto sector, or more holistic, across the business community and groups like the CCE. In fact, we just had a senior member of our team at the North Capital Forum in Mexico City, and the message of that was about the need for an integrated North American approach in the marketplace.

In terms of the political question and the social contract, if you will, for the government, I recognize that Canadians are angry, and they are also not willing, at this time, to give a lot of room to negotiating teams. That will be a delicate path for our negotiators to follow. We can’t make the perfect the enemy of the good. The amount of our trade that is currently reliant on the North American marketplace, in particular the United States marketplace, is profound. If we didn’t have the agreement, that trade wouldn’t necessarily go away, but the efficiency of that trade would, and, over time, it would seriously erode our competitiveness.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: I would like to welcome today’s witnesses.

My question is for Ms. LeRoy.

In your introduction, you explained that Canada needs more diversification and that this requires more SME exporters. You also spoke about mapping export opportunities — there are indeed many — particularly in emerging countries. What do you really expect the federal government to do to help SMEs seize these opportunities? What’s currently preventing the government from doing so? How could it better support SME exporters?

[English]

Ms. LeRoy: Thank you for your question. The trade diversification tool — the Trade Explorer — that BDL launched this week does some mapping to help understand where markets can go. One of the challenges with Canadian business is that there are a number of sectors very active in international trade and a number that are not. If we want to grow the pie and grow our economy so that diversification strengthens our economy, we need more of those businesses that are not currently trading internationally and operating outside Canada and the U.S. to get involved in that.

We have been working closely with Export Development Canada and with the Trade Commissioner Service as well on how we can take the trade agreements and tools that we are working on currently to turn that into action, rather than just kind of an agreement that companies and governments can operate. What are the tools that we can actually provide to them?

So, our first step is this Trade Explorer tool to help our businesses figure out where they can sell their products at a competitive market rate.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: Thank you.

You also spoke about a mission to Washington with businesses. Was the government involved? Or was part of the government involved? We used to have Team Canada Trade Missions. When businesses travelled abroad, the government accompanied them or took part. We also had CanExport, which supported SMEs by reimbursing their expenses. Does that still exist? Is it useful?

[English]

Ms. LeRoy: We have different relationships with the Team Canada Trade Missions. The B20 is a business sector partnership that complements the G20 organization group. This year, it is being hosted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. They are a counterpart to us. When Canada hosts the G20, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce hosts the B20 as an accompaniment to that.

The event is going to be hosted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. We have a delegation that is going down that will consist of a number of our members, including members of our chamber network, industry associations, as well as businesses. We also have some government officials and some elected officials who are considering participating in the event as well. We will be cooperating with the U.S. embassy in Washington as part of that delegation for that program.

The Chair: I’m going to have to interrupt. We are over time on that segment, but thank you. We can return to it at some point.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: I’ll keep talking about diversification, because I think that it’s an important topic. We have been talking about it for ages, but we haven’t seen many results.

As my grandmother used to say, hunger drives the wolf out of the woods. We have no choice but to diversify. We’ve talked a great deal about interprovincial trade. I would like you to discuss our progress, if there has been any. Have we made any progress? We know that we’ll never be able to replace a market of 340 million people with the Canadian market, which has 40 million people. Do you hear from your members about real progress on interprovincial trade and in removing the barriers that our businesses face?

Mr. Holmes: Thank you, senator, for the question.

[English]

On the internal trade piece, the federal government has made major moves in regard to removing almost all of the exceptions in the Canada free trade act. The provinces have established a number of different MOUs or agreements interjurisdictionally, but many of those are in different places, and a lot remains to be done there, in my opinion.

One of the things the Canadian Chamber of Commerce has asked for in the budget coming this fall is for the federal government to reintroduce language that it had proposed in 2024, which is to give it the power to make conditional federal transfers to provinces based on their commitment to dismantling internal barriers to trade. That was in a fall economic statement that did not pass because the government did not continue, and we would like to see that reintroduced.

On the matter of trade diversification, that is, of course, the long term, as my colleague said. It is a long road. We think it is an absolute priority. The results of trade diversification will take at least a decade to see. In order to achieve those and to really meet the national moment and the vision that we have, we need to invest in major trade infrastructure and major projects and also, I would say, the reliability of our supply chains. So, I hope to see this chamber support Bill C-39 when it comes to it.

The Chair: We also hope the chamber will support Bill C-39. I am the sponsor, so I have a view on this.

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you for being here. This is really helpful and so important.

This is for the Canadian Chamber to respond, if you don’t mind. You recently released a study ranking Waterloo, my city, as the fourth most vulnerable Canadian region to U.S. tariffs. Last week, our sister city, Kitchener, launched a bold action plan aimed at bolstering local businesses, which calls for more local buying and helping businesses find new markets. I will be attending those meetings next week. Do you see the utility in such action plans going on at a little more aggressive level locally? Is it a silver lining of these leading to closer relationships and the line of communication between local businesses and local government?

Mr. Holmes: I will take a first stab at it. I think, like politics, all business is local. So it is very important for local engagement for the Chamber of Commerce network across the country, major supporters of those businesses and also interlocutors with local governments on what their main street or what their community is facing.

We had Windsor, Waterloo, Kitchener, Guelph — a number of communities in that area were on that list of the most tariff-exposed cities. That was partly their historical strength in the integrated nature of their economic relationship with the United States. That strength has now become something of a weakness or an exposure point.

What you also have in that corridor, though, is an incredibly diversified economy with a lot of IP, a lot of new technology and a lot of new company start-ups. Where we see communities with a high degree of diversified economy, we also see more opportunities. Senator Wilson is here from British Columbia, and we saw Vancouver as one of the least exposed because it had avenues to other markets. It had egress, and it had diversity of the economy.

To come back to your original question, a lot of this is local. In the federal government’s response to section 338 tariffs, we have seen an engagement of the RDAs, the regional development agencies, in order to get as close to the local as the federal government can. Of course, there is a role to be played by provinces and municipalities as well.

Senator M. Deacon: I’m going to ask you about autos next. Thank you.

The Chair: We’ll come back.

Senator Woo: Thank you to the witnesses. I think I heard you say, Mr. Holmes, that in the event of further tariff actions against Canada, we should prioritize consultation over escalation. Is that to say we should eschew retaliation?

Mr. Holmes: We have supported the current approach, which has been very targeted in nature, a mix of consumer goods as well as industrial. In principle, of course, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce does not believe in tariffs. We see them as a tax on our businesses, a tax on our people, so we would prefer to see them go away entirely.

In the nature of the current trade war with the United States, sending a message that we are taking our economy seriously and we will respond, I think, is measured and precisely delivered. It is keeping us in a position where we can continue to negotiate, but, at a certain point, the Canadian public — to Senator Harder’s earlier question — will need to know that a negotiation is not just holding your ground and holding the same line for the entirety of this discussion. It will take some trade-offs, on both sides, in order to have a new agreement.

Senator Woo: So the response so far is acceptable because it is targeted and precise and so on, but there is a chance that the Americans may escalate. President Trump may put in place new and additional tariffs. What is your recommendation in terms of the type of response? Not the specific response; we can’t predict that. I think you are talking about a different approach, a different tone, maybe. Can you describe what that might look like?

Mr. Holmes: From the Canadian side, we have seen the willingness to adjust and make adjustments to the response. We saw that clearly in New Brunswick, with seafood and fisheries, and also in the approach to remissions. The federal government has been listening to industry and concerns around what the unexpected consequences or impacts of some of these responses are.

In tone, I think we have been collegial. This is my observation. As an observer, I think we have been firm but reasonable. We are arguing on principle. The United States has said that they are changing the rules of the game globally, and we will need to, as a trading nation, adjust to what the prevailing trading context is when that is settled. I don’t think it is settled yet.

Senator Woo: Thank you.

Senator Wilson: You said in your response to a question that diversification is a decade-long process, not an overnight process, which I think we all understand. If anything causes me to lose sleep at night, it would be the fact that we need to make sure that we harden and prepare, particularly, our SMEs. There is enough attention to and it is easy enough for the government to know what to do with the larger players, but with SMEs, given the granularity, it is much harder to be precise and effective.

I wonder what we need to be doing. Is what the government doing with respect to smaller businesses working? Is there anything else that we need to be paying attention to in order to keep them in business while we are trying to get them ready to diversify and get them in a place where they are diversifying their relationships?

Mr. Holmes: Thank you. Keeping them in business is the first priority, absolutely. It takes a long time to start a business and to scale a business. In many regards, these are intergenerational and multi-generational businesses, and once they are lost, they are lost.

In some of the federal government’s response to section 338 tariffs, for example, we expressed some concern around a capital liquidity and loan approach, because a lot of small businesses, as we saw from CEBA — it may sustain them in the short term, but it doesn’t help them in the longer term to have new debt. But keeping them in business is finding ways to support those businesses. That’s a hard nut to crack.

In terms of what we have seen in the data so far, our current exports are growing globally in terms of the proportion that goes to the U.S. or non-U.S. Most of that is being driven by major commodity and pricing value and by current exporters, typically larger exporters. So, our argument is we don’t only need more exports; we need more exporters and we need more of our small businesses to not see themselves solely as a local business but potentially as a global business.

That’s what my colleague was describing with our new mapping exercise. It is part of their discovery, we hope, that introduces them to new markets and the potential of their competitiveness in other markets that they may not have looked at before.

It is such a difficult challenge because to find a new market, to develop those relationships, to understand the phytosanitary or the regulatory compliance issues that they may face in that new market — even if there is a free trade agreement, there is a layer of complexity to that export practice that is difficult for a small- and medium-sized enterprise to do.

The Chair: Colleagues, I don’t want to direct the conversation, but I did notice that Ms. Lombardo could probably use a question or two. I thought I’d mention that.

Senator Downe: Thank you, chair. I may take your advice there and follow up with the mapping.

When this committee reviewed the Canada-Peru Free Trade Agreement in 2008 and then, seven years later, we did the Canada-Korea Free Trade Agreement, we heard from both of those countries that they were very prepared for the trade agreements. South Korea had identified automobiles and electronics. Peru met with their business communities. They were all set for the agreement. They were ready to take advantage of opportunities.

At the time, it seemed to many members of the committee that Canada was very good at signing their agreements and less so at developing the opportunities. Part of the criticism was the Canadian business community said, “Why should I go to Chile or South Korea when I can go to Boston, where they have a different but similar culture, and I can go to a baseball or hockey game? Why bother? I can sell to the States.” Well, that has turned on its head now.

What action can the Government of Canada take to motivate our businesses, other than the current tariffs, to be more interested in opportunities around the world, in addition to your mapping exercise?

Ms. Lombardo: Thank you for the question. I appreciate it. I will say for the Canadian Cattle Association, it took us 20 years to diversify to Japan and South Korea. That has been a huge success story for our sector. A huge part of that was the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership, or CPTPP. So that was the foundation for the diversification. Of course, we built upon that.

We have Canada Beef, which is an organization that markets our product in these markets. They tailor their programming to each market. Of course, it has been a long effort. We have been travelling there numerous times, meeting with clients and developing relationships, to the point where Canadian beef is featured in Costco Japan and Costco South Korea. So it is a success story, but it takes time.

Senator Downe: If I can just interrupt, pork to South Korea was a success story. The rest of the Canadian economy did not really take advantage of that opportunity. The question to all three of you is what recommendations you have for the Government of Canada. What does the business community need from the government to take advantage of these opportunities with these trade deals that we are not taking advantage of now?

I have personally heard a European ambassador say, “I cannot understand why Canada is not selling more to Europe.” What does the government need to do to help the business community do that?

Ms. Lombardo: I think with Europe it is a great example with beef. There are non-tariff barriers that we cannot really resolve. We have been advocating to resolve them. It is a government-to-government issue, but we are doing all that we can. There has to be that phytosanitary equivalency. All the regulations have to be in place. But we pivot. If the market is not working for us, then we can look for others that are.

I would say more partnership with industry — government sometimes gives funding for these trade missions — and partnership in looking at non-tariff barriers. We have the Indo‑Pacific Agriculture and Agri-Food Office, which has been helpful because a lot of these things are in the details. It is not the broad trade agreement. It is more in the details of what we need to get done to access these markets.

The Chair: Thank you. I would just add that there is a very important Canada-European Union summit coming up in Montreal at the end of this month and maybe agriculture and agri-food products will be on the agenda. I don’t know, but it seems to me that would be a good moment to raise some of these questions.

Senator Coyle: Apologies for being a couple of minutes tardy there.

Ms. Lombardo, I did hear your testimony. Maybe I missed it, but I didn’t hear much mention of Mexico. I think your main message is we are so integrated with the U.S., and it is so good for us, so let’s do whatever we can to keep that going. That is actually everybody’s main message. But CUSMA includes Mexico. I know we have a relationship there. I think we are also in Costco in Mexico. What is the current status of that opportunity? What is being done to grow it? What are the outstanding barriers to getting there?

Ms. Lombardo: Thank you for your question. Just last week, I was with some of our counterparts here in Toronto. They were promoting their Mexican beef in Canada. We are such great partners that we were supporting their event. I would say with Mexico, the big issue is we have the U.S. in between us. Mexican cattle crossing the border to the U.S. usually get processed in Texas or other states; for Canadian cattle it’s the same with the northern states. So geography is a huge part of why Mexico is not that big a market. However, trade numbers might not reflect that some of the beef that we sell to the U.S. might end up in Mexico. These are complicated supply chains.

But we have a really positive story. We import Mexican beef. They import Canadian beef. Overall, we are seeing that consumers like each other’s beef. We are great partners. We usually meet three times a year, the three cattle organizations. We have a positive relationship. They have been great partners. Whenever we have an issue in the trilateral relationship, Mexico has usually been a partner for Canada. I would say it is very positive. There are not a lot of non-tariff barriers. If anything, our trade is growing. We are seeing some Mexican importers prefer Canadian beef over other suppliers, so I would say it is very positive.

Senator Coyle: So there’s opportunity in spite of geography.

Ms. Lombardo: Yes, exactly.

Senator Coyle: Thank you.

Senator Adler: I want to ask the guests, and it doesn’t matter who answers or if all of you answer. I want to discuss with the panel this notion that if we wait for a long time for a deal, we’ll get a better deal. I realize that all governments and businesses do messaging. One of the messages which is out there, which I think sets us up for not getting a deal, period — and you can please assuage me of my issue with this — is this notion that no deal is better than the wrong deal. The definition of “wrong” is never submitted, but that’s the message.

Does the panel think that this business of the public being made to wait for longer and longer and getting angrier and angrier jeopardizes what, ultimately, I think most of us agree we need, which is a deal?

Mr. Holmes: My colleagues are looking at me. Thank you for the question. Again, coming to the social capital or the animus currently in the Canadian population, there is a real risk that a long-term delay could really compromise the trade relationship and the willingness to accept a deal that may not be perfect in design, in the opinion of the Canadian public.

The issue is complex, of course. The American market is of a scale. We can talk as much as we like about all the other free trade agreements we have. Mexico is our third-largest trading partner; it is 3% of our exports. Nothing compares right now to our relationship with the American economy. So, losing your number one customer is really bad for business. Only having one customer is also bad for business. So we need to diversify. We call it our three-legged stool at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce: We need to diversify our economy; we need to reaffirm our trade with America and within North America; we need to dismantle the internal barriers we are subjecting ourselves to that keep us small and fragmented as an economy.

I know it is not a direct answer. It is something of an all of the above. In terms of when or how we get to a deal, I trust in our negotiating team. The signal from the public has been that a bad deal is not worth it right now.

I would just note that 75% of our exports went to the United States before we had NAFTA. Of course, we had the auto pact in place at that point. Currently, it is more like 69% of our exports.

Senator Adler: In the real business world that you deal in —

The Chair: Senator, I am sorry. We are over time on that segment. We will probably have 10 minutes for round two.

Senator McCallum, welcome to the committee.

Senator McCallum: Thank you. It is my first time on this committee, so I don’t know if this has been brought up. Mr. Holmes said we need new exporters, but I’m looking at the local situation. When I went to Victoria, I bought a book called Saving Farmland: The Fight for Real Food. It was about the fact that if the ferry to Vancouver Island was cut off, everything in the stores would be gone in three days. I was looking then at how much we are exporting.

This question is for Ms. Lombardo: Are there some provinces that are having a harder time with the cattle supply chain? What are the obstacles that provinces face, and are there some provinces that are having an easier time? I’m looking at Manitoba, where there is a lot of support from farm to table. A lot of stores sell from the local area. There are butchers, many of them. I’m looking at that concept, because there is so much food insecurity. I know everyone is looking at exports, but I’m looking at what is happening in the local communities that is working or not working.

Ms. Lombardo: Thank you for your question. It is a very important one. What I would say is, after years of drought, our herd has contracted all across Canada. Right now, we are seeing signs that the herd is rebuilding, which means we are going to have more cattle. However, we are concerned that this process might be impeded by trade negotiations like Mercosur that could flood the market. If we can rebuild the herd nationally, including Manitoba, that would be the best-case scenario because we need trade. I will explain this. Producers earn around $1,500 per head because of trade. So trade is a key component of growing the herd and helping producers stay on the land. Right now, we are not seeing difficulties exporting to the U.S. By exporting, they increase the value.

I would say trade is part of our domestic food security because otherwise there are cuts like tongue that are not consumed in Canada but are consumed in Japan or Mexico. By having international trade, we utilize every part of the cow. That way, producers can profit and be on the land.

The one key tool we are advocating for to grow the herd is livestock price insurance. Our producers in Manitoba are very passionate about this. It means producers get a bit of a cost-share program with the federal government to help them mitigate risk. One thing with growing the herd is producers have a lot of uncertainty. They have to deal with weather, increasing costs and other variables they can’t control. By having livestock price insurance, they can increase the certainty allowing them to grow the herd and thereby increase our domestic food security and our exports at the same time.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: My question is for Ms. Lombardo.

The United States remains a key market for Canadian beef exporters. However, there has been significant growth in demand for animal protein in multiple parts of the world. Could the government do more to help and support beef exporters in their efforts to develop new markets, particularly in other emerging countries?

Ms. Lombardo: Thank you for your question.

[English]

Yes, as I mentioned, we see livestock price insurance as a key tool to help beef farmers across the country. When we go to foreign markets, we are told by importers, “We need more Canadian beef; we love your product, and we need more of it.”

Again, many of the products we export to other markets are not the same products that are consumed here in Canada, which is such a great story that we can increase both domestic and also international food security.

If I can elaborate on the livestock price insurance, it is in our budget ask. It gives equal footing to beef farmers. Right now, farmers who produce a crop have a cost-share insurance program with the federal government upwards to $1 billion. Livestock does haven’t that program, so right now the risk is on the producer to hold their cows for a few years and then sell them. In those years, a lot of things could happen. We are seeing many supply chain disruptions. It is a huge risk for farmers to keep those mother cows. We need to create the conditions for them to say they will keep the cattle. We see that program as the number one thing that can move the needle and really support our domestic food security but also our international trade.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

Senator Hébert: I’m starting to think that we’re telepathic, because our questions are so similar. That was more or less my question.

To get back to what Senator Downe was saying earlier, people really do often criticize the fact that we have agreements but aren’t taking advantage of them. Our businesses aren’t taking full advantage of the agreements for many well-known reasons. You spoke about Mercosur. Canada has no choice but to keep signing agreements if we want to diversify our exports. Unfortunately, there are always winners and losers in an agreement. The demand for Canadian processed food products — particularly animal products — is quite high in Europe and in other parts of the world. Could supporting better performance and increasing the competitiveness and productivity of our processing industry, of products processed here, also be key to achieving that goal? To that end, the food sector should be included in the strategic sectors that the government is promoting to build a strong Canada. That’s quite a few questions packed into one. I have only two minutes.

Ms. Lombardo: Thank you. Good question.

[English]

Yes, we do think there is strategic trade diversification. With Mercosur, we don’t see what the win is. It would be all risk for beef producers. Mercosur is one of the largest and lowest-cost producers in the world, and this is a concern not only for us but also for our U.S. and Mexican counterparts, that Mercosur is not an equal trade partner. There are also differences in standards, and “standards” is a key word. Beef producers are one of the most sustainable but also the most efficient producers in the world, based on genetics, grassland conservation, and I can go on. There is no real benefit with Mercosur. We’ve been supporters of other free trade agreements where there is a benefit, like CPTPP and others.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator M. Deacon: I want to come back to some of the implications and businesses being hit hard, specifically to auto, and particularly in southwestern Ontario.

If we look forward, even if Democrats take the mid-terms this fall and we get a Democratic president two years from now or down the road, from your perspective, how much damage has been done? Is it as simple as turning the car around? Should we start to accept and adapt to the fact that this industry may never come back as it was?

Mr. Holmes: The jury is still out on that in terms of the long‑term damage to the sector. I see incredible competitiveness and world-leading plants making autos here. This is advanced manufacturing. It is not just making cars and trucks. It is the talent base and the capacity that we have to make the products we will need in the future economy. That’s an important storyline we need to remind ourselves of. There may be some redeployments of some of those workers and some of those industrial outputs in time. We will see what that looks like.

The damage that will be done or that has been done is damage to the entire North American automaking supply chain. We’re feeling it in Canada. In my conversations with Mexican business counterparts, they are feeling it in a very dire way. Hundreds of thousands of jobs have recently been lost. That will cast a shadow even on automaking in America. It already has. We are seeing, for example, car makers send cars to Canada from Europe — where they used to build those in the United States — because they have a more preferential tariff agreement with us and a trade agreement with us via Europe.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator Harder: Ms. LeRoy, earlier you said we can’t control what the United States does, but we can at least try to influence or control what we can do. The other day, Quebec elected a minority PQ government. Later this month, Alberta will have a referendum on separation. Today, Elon Musk, the richest man in the world, said Saskatchewan, Alberta and Quebec should separate from Canada because they would be better off.

My comment, or what I would like you to reflect on, is to what extent these conversations are undermining your businesses’ capacity to grow and sustain themselves.

Ms. LeRoy: There are long-standing challenges within Canada about national unity. These are not new conversations. The volume has increased recently, but they are not unknown and unfamiliar to those who are involved with it.

The Canadian Chamber of Commerce has launched, particularly in relation to the Alberta referendum, a national unity campaign where we identified political leaders from both sides of the political aisle to advocate for the strength of the economy.

No province will do better economically separate from Canada. This is the challenge that falls to us as businesses. It falls to you as our political leaders in this country to find ways to communicate that with Canadians, with potential voters, and for us to communicate that with our business members, encouraging our chamber network within Alberta and Quebec to support a national unity movement and help people understand that the national project is the future of our economy. That’s the future of economic stability, and there isn’t a more financially viable option or alternative.

The Chair: Thank you. I would only make the observation that Mr. Musk did attend a Canadian university for a while, but I don’t think he graduated.

Senator Downe: I am from Prince Edward Island, home of the Atlantic Beef plant: high-quality, safe, secure food. I heard your concerns about Mercosur, and I share them, but given that they signed a trade agreement with Europe, would the farmers there not have the same concerns? How did they address them?

Ms. Lombardo: That is a great question. Actually, the EU has temporarily banned access of Brazilian beef over questions on standards, particularly antimicrobial resistance, if I recall correctly. I think sometimes Europe might be more comfortable granting access, but they have a lot more tools to sometimes prevent a product from coming in if they deem it unsafe.

Senator Downe: Great. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you. We’ve come to the end, so, on behalf of the committee, I’d like to thank Daniela Lombardo, Matthew Holmes and Monika LeRoy for joining us today. Your testimony is very valuable. It’s an important subject, and this committee will be focused on this for the next while, so I dare say we might see you again. Thank you.

Colleagues, for our second panel, we welcome — representing both the Forest Products Association of Canada and the Canadian Wood Council — Derek Nighbor, President and Chief Executive Officer of both organizations; and from the Canadian Association of Moldmakers, by video conference, Nicole Vlanich, Executive Director.

Thank you both for being with us today. We are now ready to hear your opening remarks. Mr. Nighbor, you have the floor, and you will be followed by Ms. Vlanich. Please go ahead.

Derek Nighbor, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Wood Council and Forest Products Association of Canada: Thank you, chair and all honourable senators, for having me today.

As President and CEO of the Forest Products Association of Canada and the Canadian Wood Council, I represent Canada’s wood, pulp and paper manufacturers and the wood construction industry in the country.

In addition to our priorities on the international trade file, we are an industry focused now on many critical priorities, including strengthening our wood and pulp and paper sector value chain, improving competitiveness of the industry through domestic policy fixes, growing a Canadian forest bioeconomy, building more affordable homes and infrastructure with Canadian wood and mitigating worsening catastrophic wildfire risks. All of this work is very much interconnected.

The sector is a cornerstone of the Canadian economy, directly employing nearly 200,000 Canadians, largely in rural and northern communities. In 2025, Canada exported over $26 billion in forest products to the United States. About $14 billion of that was in wood products, and $12 billion was in paper and pulp. Additional volumes were in finished wood products like furniture and kitchen cabinetry.

Our forest product exports tie the Canadian and U.S. economies together. Pulp and paper and packaging can cross the border several times during production, while Canadian wood supports American home builders, who can only access about 70% of their lumber from U.S. sources. In fact, today, they are turning to Europe to replace some of their Canadian volumes.

When Canada and the U.S. work together, we sustain and grow jobs and production on both sides of the border. Different types of wood are better suited to different jobs. Builders benefit from having access to both Canadian and American lumber, and there is room in the market for both.

With families in both countries facing housing shortages, we should be helping builders increase supply — not restricting it and adding on more costs. U.S. duties and tariffs raise the cost of building materials and put affordable homes further out of reach for the average American family.

We are hopeful that CUSMA will give businesses the predictable, rules-based trade they need to meet these shared challenges. Our sector faces mounting trade barriers, as you all know, and it undermines the very relationship that the agreement is meant to support.

Right now, our softwood lumber industry faces combined duties of about 35% and, on top of that, a 10% section 232 tariff. So it is over 45% on softwood lumber duties and tariffs going to the U.S. In the latest escalation on the section 338 tariffs, we have about $5.5 billion of our products hit as well. More than $3 billion of that is exposure in paper and paperboard, alongside panels, plywood, millwork, packaging and other wood products.

For primary producers and secondary manufacturers, these measures discourage investment, weaken our shared supply chains and, in fact, raise costs for Americans.

There was talk earlier about whether there is goodwill to get back to the table. If we can get there, this is our wish list:

First, remove the sections 232 and 338 tariffs affecting our products and then pivot to a dedicated path to resolve the softwood lumber dispute.

Second, we’d like to see CUSMA’s core duty-free structure protected and long-term certainty provided that our businesses need to invest.

Third, we want to see a strengthened dispute resolution. Chapter 10 panels need enforceable timelines, fewer procedural delays and decisions that are respected.

So, despite being one of the hardest-hit sectors in the country, Canada’s forest sector is on Team Canada, and our industry has never been more united, despite the challenges. I thank you for your time, and I look forward to your questions.

The Chair: Thank you very much. Ms. Vlanich, you have the floor — or the screen.

Nicole Vlanich, Executive Director, Canadian Association of Moldmakers: Good afternoon. Thank you for the invitation to appear before you today.

The Canadian Association of Moldmakers, or CAMM, represents Canadian mould makers and the broader network of tooling, machining, automation, plastics and advanced manufacturing companies that support production across North America.

When we talk about manufacturing, we often focus on the finished product — a vehicle component, a medical device or a consumer product. But before those products can be manufactured at scale, the moulds and tooling that make production possible must first be designed and built. Canadian mould makers are, therefore, more than exporters. They are enablers of manufacturing and an important part of Canada’s industrial capacity.

For some of our members, upwards of 90% to 95% of their business is with the United States. That did not happen because Canadian companies failed to diversify. For decades, companies were encouraged to integrate under free trade. Companies responded by investing, specializing and building customer relationships and supply chains around a North American market.

In many cases, we don’t simply trade with one another; we build things together. A mould isn’t simply built, shipped and forgotten. It requires maintenance, repairs and engineering changes throughout its life. The further we move from our customers, the more likely we are to lose that valuable downstream work to local suppliers. That’s another reason geographic diversification isn’t equivalent to replacing U.S. business.

Today, I would argue that the greatest challenge facing our industry is not simply tariffs; it is uncertainty. Tooling programs, capital investments, hiring decisions and customer sourcing strategies are often determined months — and sometimes years — before production begins.

When companies cannot confidently predict future costs, pricing or trade conditions, behaviour changes. Investment is delayed; programs are reconsidered; customers begin evaluating alternative sourcing strategies; and the financial tolerance for these additional costs is extremely limited.

Mould makers typically operate on single-digit profit margins. When a tariff of 10% or 15% is applied to a product produced by a company operating on a single-digit margin, it does not represent a small additional cost. Depending on who ultimately absorbs it, it can eliminate the profitability of the program entirely.

Our members are also being squeezed from both directions. They face tariffs when finished moulds enter the United States, while Canadian counter-tariffs and broader trade disruption can increase the cost of steel, aluminum, mould components and other inputs they need to manufacture here. Equivalent Canadian sources are not always available in the required specifications, quantities or timelines.

CAMM has heard directly from members reporting increased costs, sourcing challenges, delayed orders and production, lost business and growing concern about future material pricing and availability.

At the same time, customer relationships in this industry are not built overnight. Many have been developed over the decades through quality, reliability and trust. The concern is not just the loss of business overnight; it is the gradual erosion of customer relationships and future programs that took years to establish. When the next program is sourced somewhere else, that business can be extremely difficult to recover, and this is no longer theoretical.

Members have told me directly that they are evaluating all options as they consider their future, including where future investment should occur and, in some cases, whether operations or capacity may eventually need to move. I am not suggesting this is happening across the entire industry, but we should take seriously the fact that Canadian manufacturers are having these conversations. Because businesses cannot continue waiting for certainty; they have to create certainty for themselves.

This is also why we need to look beyond Canada versus the United States. North America is competing against manufacturing regions around the world. If we increase costs within our own integrated supply chain, the work does not necessarily move from Canada to the United States; it may leave North America altogether.

Diversification must, therefore, be part of Canada’s strategy, both geographically and into sectors such as defence, aerospace, critical infrastructure and energy. But diversification takes time; it requires investment, workforce development and new customer relationships. It should expand the opportunities available to Canadian companies, not be treated as a replacement for the United States. Diversification is a growth strategy, not a replacement strategy.

CAMM is, therefore, advocating for meaningful reductions in the tariff burden affecting Canadian moulds and tooling, and, where possible, targeted sector-specific relief. A mould should not be viewed simply as a piece of steel; its value reflects engineering, design, precision machining, technology and highly skilled Canadian labour.

Canadian mould makers are not asking the government to make them competitive. They compete globally every day. They are asking for the conditions that allow them to continue competing from Canada. For decades, Canadian mould makers have helped build one of the most integrated and productive manufacturing ecosystems in the world.

Windsor-Essex has the largest concentration of mould makers in Canada, and we would welcome representatives from the federal government for tours to see the shops and the technology they have invested in to remain globally competitive and to share the passion, drive and dedication to the industry they work within.

Our industry remains committed to investing, innovating, hiring and competing from Canada. To continue doing so successfully, we need a business environment that promotes certainty, supports long-term investment, strengthens customer confidence and reinforces the competitiveness of North American manufacturing as a whole. We need an agreement with our partners in the United States.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair: Thank you very much. Colleagues, we will go into three-minute rounds, as the last time.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: I would like to welcome our witnesses.

My question is for Mr. Nighbor, but Ms. Vlanich is also welcome to respond.

The softwood lumber dispute is one of the longest-running trade disputes between Canada and the United States. Over the decades, despite various dispute resolution procedures, the Canadian forestry industry has continued to face the uncertainty created by our neighbour to the south, as you said earlier. Given the current situation, how can the government help this industry and better protect it?

[English]

Mr. Nighbor: Yes, I think a couple of things are important. We have had a long — I think this is Lumber V, as they call it, in terms of the number of disputes we’ve had with the U.S. over time. We’ve never had a level at 45%. Just a couple of years ago, it was in low double digits.

The other side of this is not just the significance of the duties and tariffs in place; what is not being talked about is the super softness of the U.S. economy. We’ve seen — since the crisis in the Middle East — a 30-year mortgage go up 155 basis points since the beginning of the conflict; diesel at over $6. There was a Home Trust index group that surveys buyer behaviour, and right now only 6% of Americans interested in buying would be able to proceed at a 7.6% 30-year interest rate.

This is the problem. It’s not just how big the tariffs are; there is very little demand in the market. At this rate, in terms of new construction, we probably are not going to see that until 2028.

So, to your question, understanding that — similar to what Mr. Holmes talked about — it is about stabilizing the industry to try to push through this storm. I don’t think you will find anybody in our sector who will be critical of the programs — both on the business side and on the employees’ side, on the workers’ side — that we have seen rolled over out of the past few months.

The government has done a lot of very good things in a very difficult environment, but we’re dealing not only with the high levels of tariffs and duties but also with very soft markets.

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you to our guests, online and in personal, for being here today. We really appreciate it. I have a question for the Forest Products Association of Canada. I’m trying to think about the ongoing discussion with the EU. I wonder if it represents any kind of opportunity for your industry, or are there any irritants between our two economies that could be addressed?

Mr. Nighbor: There is opportunity; it is incremental. I would say Sweden, Germany and Austria are powerhouses in the EU in terms of production and can produce beyond their countries’ borders and service a lot of the EU geography.

That said, when we rebuild Ukraine, when we rebuild Gaza and other parts, that will naturally be a market for European wood. We are already thinking how we can come in behind some of that stuff.

It is not an overnight solution, but there are irritants. I think you heard in the first panel a couple of examples on the cattle side. There is a new EU deforestation-free regulation. In one part, it says they will not source products from primary forests or forests that have never been harvested before. Well, guess what? We have a lot of them in Canada, and they will burn if we don’t harvest them. So we do have some of those.

We hold some faith in the summit at the end of the month in Montreal. My colleague has just made a couple of trips to Brussels. There are irritants, and the government is aware of them and is working on them.

Senator M. Deacon: And looking one step further — you mentioned some countries there — what international markets, outside the U.S., represent the most promise for Canada’s forestry sector?

Mr. Nighbor: Japan, especially higher value. But you can’t just put more sticks on a boat and send them somewhere else. In Japan, it’s seismic building codes and teaching builders how to build. There is about a three-year priming of the pump before you can sell a new product.

The Canada Wood Group is our export arm of private-public partnership with the federal government. South Korea is an opportunity; India, longer term; China as well; a little bit in the Caribbean — we have to deal with treated wood and termites.

We are looking everywhere, but it’s similar to what Mr. Holmes talked about; there is not a fast pivot. It took us 50 years to build $1 billion worth of business in Japan.

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: You both spoke about diversification. I would like you to talk about government efforts to support your industries domestically as well.

Ms. Vlanich, in your opening remarks, you said that new opportunities are opening up for Canada, particularly in the defence and aerospace sectors. You also said that the government has plans to develop certain strategic sectors. I gather that your industry has a role to play in this. The same goes for construction in particular. With Build Canada Homes, many construction projects are on the horizon. Can the government introduce any measures, at the very least, to support your industries in these major local projects?

[English]

Mr. Nighbor: A couple of things. Yes, I think the biggest place where the federal government is supporting us right now is funding to support the Canada Wood Group and that export market development. That funding was cut a few years ago, so we are playing some catch-up. We are happy to have the funding back.

Domestically, Build Canada Homes — Department of National Defence is building about $4 billion worth of military housing in places like Petawawa, near where I grew up. It holds promise to have broader federal procurement. For us in the forestry and steel industries, those are the kinds of things we are looking at.

It is also important, with the Buy Canadian move, how the government will market those RFPs. It really matters to make it inclusive for our materials. There are a number of these domestic opportunities, for sure.

Ms. Vlanich: Right now, there is a lot of government funding available for companies to diversify, but we have to keep in mind that for companies to enter these markets, it will take upwards of two years. Hundreds of manufacturers will be competing for these contracts. One thing we hope the government could do is figure out a way to expedite the process so it doesn’t take two years. As I said in my opening remarks, we may not have these companies in two years if things keep going the way they are. Realistically, if we want to keep them here, they will need business.

Senator Woo: Thank you, witnesses. I have a question for Mr. Nighbor. Going back to your point about how the economy is soft and it is not just about tariffs, I’m thinking about the United States, where American consumers feel the pain when it comes to gasoline and diesel prices. That’s a bellwether for political discontent. Is it the same for paper and pulp products, cardboard, packaging, toilet paper? What is happening with prices in the United States in these areas?

Mr. Nighbor: Everything is going up. The pulp and paper category is facing a different dynamic. We are dealing with an oversupply of pulp production in China, which has distorted global markets. One of the reasons this matters, especially for forest health and for fire, is if we are not managing the forests and if some of the pulp wood or the chips or the low-grade wood is not getting used for some purpose, it will pile up. What can’t be lost in this trade dispute and this effort to keep our mills running is also the need to keep our forests sustainably managed and resilient as we deal with the effects of floods and fires. On the dollar side, costs on everything — diapers, anything that pulp would go into — are going up and contributing to the affordability crisis.

Senator Woo: Does that create political static in the way of gasoline prices? I would hate for my toilet paper prices to be going up.

Mr. Nighbor: This is in the hands of the American people at this point. It is clear where affordability is with gas prices and mortgage rates. At what point do people respond? I will leave that to American voters.

Senator Woo: Thank you.

Senator Coyle: I would like to thank both of our witnesses today. These are very tough times, and those are Canadians and families and communities behind these numbers we are hearing.

Mr. Nighbor, I believe I heard you say that the U.S. is even turning to Europe now for wood provision?

Mr. Nighbor: Yes.

Senator Coyle: Okay. Could you tell us, first of all, whether there is concern that the pivot to Europe could become something that is baked in?

Mr. Nighbor: I’m not sure it is sustainable. The big advantage is a 30-point advantage on the duty tariff side, because they are at a flat rate of 15% when we are at 45%. It is cheaper, even with that delta, to move the product across.

We are seeing fibre constraints, or access to the wood supply in Europe is tightening. I think they will see other opportunities. I don’t think the U.S. can rely on that, but it is northern wood, and people forget about that. In the Pacific Northwest, Americans have access to some forests like we have across the boreal in Canada. The southeast of the U.S. is very different. It’s southern yellow pine. You want to frame your house with northern wood and spruce pine. You don’t want to put a nail in southern yellow pine. This is the need.

I talked about different products working. When the U.S. starts booming again, in the next year or two, hopefully, on the housing side, they will need our wood. Hopefully, by that time, we will have that imbalance in terms of the duties and tariffs go away. Nothing is certain. It’s always a concern. We are watching it, but I think there is promise there. And when the American economy gets better, we have a greater opportunity, and when our tariffs go down or go away.

Senator Coyle: You are concerned about the softening of the American economy at the moment, but you just answered my next question: Can you see it rebounding?

Mr. Nighbor: Yes. I just read a CIBC world markets piece this morning saying 2027 is not looking great, but in 2028 we might see a bit of a bump. Many things need to happen. These are all market assessments happening, but it is going to be a slow climb back. CIBC is saying 2027 will not be that great.

Senator Coyle: Can your industry afford to wait? What are the implications now and in the next couple of years?

Mr. Nighbor: This is the big question. If you have followed our industry over the last number of decades, we have proven we are a pretty resilient bunch. There are still almost 200,000 full‑time jobs. It’s a 2-to-1 multiplier on the indirect, 300 communities. We will still be here. We will probably be a little smaller; we are already finding that.

I’m hopeful about a number of these measures. We are expecting Minister Hodgson to release a forest sector transformation strategy that I’m hopeful will be one of the largest plans for the forest sector we have ever seen in Canada. We are holding a lot of faith in that. That will be part of our effort to move forward and protect these jobs.

Senator Coyle: Thank you.

Senator Wilson: I’m going to follow up on the thread of diversification. Before I do, just some context. I’m a British Columbia senator. I grew up in B.C. I grew up with forest product disputes, with softwood lumber disputes with the U.S., so this is not our first rodeo. This is a much worse time than it has been in the past, but not the first time. Of late, I’ve been seeing all the closures in British Columbia, and it is sad to see.

The last softwood lumber dispute led us to work at diversifying, and efforts were made to mill materials to the right size for the Asian market. While the total quantum of volume being shipped to Asian markets was not huge, the percentage gain doubled or tripled, a significant jump for a small market share. I had hoped those gains would have continued over time, but it sounds like we fell right back to the U.S. dependency.

Given that, as our Prime Minister says, we treat everything they sign as if it has been signed in pencil, I’m not sure that getting a new agreement with the U.S. will solve the problem. Do you think there is an understanding of the importance of diversification, really making a serious effort and not just counting on getting back to the U.S.?

Mr. Nighbor: It’s a fair debate. There has been a serious effort; there continues to be. One of the global disruptors has been China. Our volumes in China have bottomed out because they are buying wood from Russia because nobody else will. There are these other dynamics happening in the Asian market. I mentioned the overcapacity of pulp production.

I think B.C. has been a leader. In terms of the seriousness of this, people get it. This is a moment to lean in on those opportunities. We need to be honest that we are not going to sell $8 billion of softwood lumber somewhere else tomorrow.

Senator Wilson: I know. That’s my point. This is not the first time this has happened. I’m kind of depressed that we had something like this happen before, and we didn’t stick to it. I guess that’s what I’m saying. Do we think we have now learned the lesson from the series of these events to change our behaviour?

Mr. Nighbor: I think what makes — is the magnitude of the duty tariff combination at 45% now. In a strong market, at 10% or 15%, you could probably flow some or all of that through. That’s the challenge now. We are dealing with a soft market and 45%. It’s very, very difficult. So it’s very different, I would say, from the disputes in the past, given how big the percentage is.

Senator Adler: I would like to get responses from both members of this panel. I don’t know whether Canadians, for the most part, get numbed by certain numbers. If there is a certain number that they keep hearing, I wonder if it really rings an alarm bell with the average Canadian, as much as it does with, say, an average person running a small business.

This number that I keep hearing is 75%. In the real world of small businesses and all the small businesses I have dealt with, if you lose your major customer who is buying 75% of your stock, you can wish for diversity, you can dream of diversity, or you can work on diversity — you are done. You are closing up shop. In my opinion, based on my life, 75% ought to ring severe alarm bells, but it just seems to be a number out there in the public rhetoric. So I’m asking those of you intimately involved with businesses: Isn’t 75% more than just a little bit tender?

Mr. Nighbor: Yes, but it would not correspond with what we have lost. So our volumes are down maybe 12% or 15%, and more than half of that has been eaten up by Europe. So it is not a total collapse. We are still shipping.

I do get your point, senator. For us, as I said, it is how long this has been going on, it is the magnitude and it is the soft market on the other side. If the U.S. economy was clipping along, you could probably, at a premium, be selling more product there.

That said, to Senator Wilson’s point, the diversification piece is a focus. How do we take costs out of the system at home? I think you are seeing some of that in Bill C-39 on major projects, but for any industry operating on the land base, there are — we’re 94% on provincial Crown land. There are a lot of duplicative regulations at Environment and Climate Change Canada, or ECCC, and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, or DFO, that could be recognized through provincial approvals. That is the other place we are looking at right now in terms of controlling the controllable, if you will.

Senator Adler: I wonder if our other guest would like to comment.

Ms. Vlanich: As I said in my opening statement, some of our members have 90% to 95% of their business reliant on the U.S., and I really don’t think that it is appreciated how significant that is. When we look at diversification, even picking up 10% to 15% of that, the company is still 80% reliant on the United States. It gets smaller and smaller as our customers look at us as unreliable providers. That’s when they go to low-cost countries, and we lose that business forever.

It is serious and significant. When we are looking at the entire manufacturing sector, and they are reliant on the trade with the United States, the longer we go without an agreement, the more detrimental it becomes to our industry.

Senator Adler: So where I think this conversation needs to go is to this messaging business that we brought up in the last panel. That’s the slogan that people buy — you know, no deal is better than the wrong deal. Based on how dramatic this is, would it not be more appropriate — even if it doesn’t register as well in polling with the public — but, once again, in the real world of business, isn’t it true that we need to have a deal, and while it wouldn’t be true that any deal is better than a bad deal, we need a deal?

Mr. Nighbor: Our industry is in the camp of “no deal is better than a bad deal,” as painful as that is for us, with $15 billion plus getting hit. Our industry — we are also Canadians and get the sovereignty issue. There is a bigger conversation happening at the backdrop of this.

I’m not celebrating or endorsing that this dispute drags out; don’t get me wrong. But I think there is an understanding we are dealing with a very unpredictable dance partner on the other side, and we are not about to make a dumb decision. Again, don’t misinterpret that. We want to get to a sensible deal that works for both countries. That’s how we’ve done forest products trade in North America for decades, so—

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator Harder: The previous panel talked a lot about their cooperation with the U.S. and Mexican counterparts. Certainly, Mr. Nighbor, your sector is different. This is just another context of the traditional softwood lumber disputes, and you don’t have allies in Mexico or the U.S. You have competitors who are lobbying the political process in Washington to pursue the policies that they are.

I’m not familiar with counterparts, Ms. Vlanich, to the mould makers, but it seems from your testimony that it is a more competitive market with the United States alone. I mention this because I think your strategic positioning is different than those that have shared interests across the continent. Would you comment on that?

Mr. Nighbor: I would challenge you on that.

Senator Harder: Please do.

Mr. Nighbor: Where I agree with you is that the wealthy private landowners and the U.S. softwood lumber coalition very much want to squeeze Canadian sticks out of the U.S. so they can sell — their land is worth more. But if you are a home builder in the U.S., you want access to Canadian wood so you can sell more homes so you can get —

Senator Harder: They don’t seem to have the political clout.

Mr. Nighbor: It’s a challenge. They were the original supporters of ours. We are seeing more retail distributors speaking up. We are seeing a lot of companies that use our pulp to make some of the products Senator Woo talked about. Maybe they’re not talking about it publicly, but going to D.C. —

Senator Harder: Will you be at the B20?

Mr. Nighbor: We will have somebody there. I just returned from my global meetings in Italy last week, and I’m going to be in the U.S. four times in the next six weeks. The conversations continue to happen. There is an antagonist, for sure, a big one, but we do have a lot of friends in the U.S.

Ms. Vlanich: Mainly for us, our customers are in the United States, and our competition would be mainly low-cost countries. There are mould makers, of course, in the United States, but our outlook on things is there is more than enough North American business to go around amongst all of us. Where our competition lies is mainly low-cost countries.

Senator Harder: Do you have allies in the United States or Mexico?

Ms. Vlanich: Yes, definitely. I have been in contact with a lot of our partners in the United States, including the chambers of commerce, and Mexico as well. It is important to all of them that we come to an agreement to create that certainty that we had in 2025. Things have just gotten progressively worse for us and our industry since October 2025.

Senator Harder: Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you. That brings us to the end of the first round of questions. I have only one senator who wants to ask a question in the second round. We have time for more questions. Some of you were clipped a little bit short.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: My question is for both of you.

Everyone around this table agrees that our most important relationships and partnerships are with the United States and that this won’t change anytime soon. I believe that we all agree on this. However, I also share my colleagues’ view that we need to diversify. The government has invested a great deal of money in helping our businesses diversify.

Canadian forest products are highly valued. Multiple countries are looking to increase the use of wood in sustainable construction, such as glue-laminated wood. We’re good at this in Quebec. Do you see new opportunities in these sectors outside the United States? You spoke about Japan and a number of other countries. However, I’m convinced that the possibilities go beyond this and that the government could help us reach these new markets.

[English]

Mr. Nighbor: Yes, and I think companies like Chantiers Chibougamau in northern Quebec are great examples of that innovation.

The issue with wood, as you can appreciate, is that it is very heavy, so it is very expensive to ship. The challenge is that a lot of markets around the world, especially in Europe, tend to take care of themselves. There are some niche product areas and also in bioproducts. A lot of work is being done in Canada on biochar and biofuels and sustainable aviation fuel. None of that is really at a scale right now to make a big difference, but there are those niche opportunities that we are looking at through the Canada Wood Group, and we are involved in the trade missions. We work with the Canadian Chamber of Commerce closely as well, so it is continuing to be a priority as we try to stabilize ourselves.

Senator Gerba: Thank you.

Senator M. Deacon: I have a question for you, Ms. Vlanich. I heard your introduction and whom you represent. Thank you. I’m trying to understand the work that you represent. Does it involve products that have to go to the U.S. and then go back and forth, like other markets? If you could expand on that a little, I would appreciate it.

Ms. Vlanich: It does. Mould makers sometimes ship their products back and forth multiple times before they are completely finished. That’s where diversification, geographically, becomes difficult, and having that proximity is so important. It’s not practical to ship a large mould back and forth overseas where maintenance and engineering are required.

Even when it comes to the large-sized tooling that is sent over, a lot of maintenance is required. Again, that is where proximity is important for repairs, engineering and those sorts of things. These companies would lose revenue and business if they didn’t have that proximity, like they have right now. We have a lot of members with employees for whom that is their job. Their job is to travel into Michigan, Ohio and different states to do repairs. If we don’t have that proximity, that’s not possible.

Senator M. Deacon: With that proximity, are your key markets in the northeastern states?

Ms. Vlanich: Yes and no. It is throughout the United States, but for Windsor-Essex, specifically, we are looking at that area, yes.

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you very much.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: Mr. Nighbor, you said that shipping costs are a major barrier in your industry.

[English]

Is the government doing enough? What can we do to try to compensate for that? Because that will remain a reality. If we want our industry to have a sustainable diversification approach, we must consider that. That’s not going to go away. So, what do we do?

Mr. Nighbor: It’s a great comment. Port infrastructure in the Port of Vancouver is critical for us for Asia. We are seeing developments at the Port of Belledune in New Brunswick, right? So, support capacity and investment are important.

Rail costs are a challenge for us. Almost 90% of our mills are served by just one railway, so there is not a lot of choice there. I know there are a lot of conversations across broader economic groups about how we — that’s an important relationship for us with the railways.

We have a couple of mills in the Prairies where it costs them seven times to get to the Port of Vancouver compared to get to China. These are very expensive domestic challenges where we need to lean in. The government is aware of them. I think the current bill before the House in the labour transportation space will address some of that, but there is still more work to do.

Senator Hébert: Thank you. Hopefully, we will hear you on Bill C-39 then, if you have ideas and comments.

Mr. Nighbor: We will see.

The Chair: Thank you.

Senator McCallum: I have not been on this committee before. I have been listening to the earlier panel and the panel now, and this is what I’m hearing. You said that you are in Lumber V, which means you’ve been having problems all along. My take on the conversation here is that people cannot go beyond the status quo of U.S. dependency. It seems that everything is targeting how to move beyond U.S. dependency. What will it take to move beyond that?

From the conversation I’ve heard, government funding will get us through until the situation improves. But are producers really willing to move beyond and really, truly look at diversification?

Mr. Nighbor: Yes, it will mean different things. It is a good question. It will mean different things to different sectors. In the aluminum sector, the world is hungry for aluminum, and there are some opportunities there. In some segments of agriculture, there are natural markets to pivot to at scale and in significant volumes. It’s not as easy for us in Canadian forestry, but it is not a reason not to lean in. Any growth or diversification that is incremental is a priority right now, whether that is the Department of National Defence’s housing, Build Canada Homes or any of the other domestic plays.

We have seen increased investment by our industry and the government in diversification. There is a real focus on Japan and South Korea at the top of the list. We are looking at how we can work through our new agreement with the U.K. The U.K. has a big housing shortage. That’s an opportunity for us, for sure, but it is the context of the scale of the opportunity. I need to be clear about that.

But your point remains. Any diversification needs to be taken seriously, and it is, by our industry. It just will not supplant $8 billion of softwood lumber sales to the U.S. per year.

Senator McCallum: Your remark that the lumber will burn if we don’t harvest really caused me concern because of how business looks at — a lot of businesses don’t look at sustainability. It is like, “Let’s get all the oil out,” or, “Let’s get all of this product.” That remark made me concerned.

You talked about the transformation. Will Indigenous Peoples be involved in that? When I look at the work I do, it is for the next seven generations. Canada has really not gotten serious about that.

Mr. Nighbor: Yes. The context of my remark was not in terms of harvesting all the trees but in proactive thinning and managing and building firebreaks around communities. We have been working with Indigenous partners in promoting cultural burning that we need to return to. I was in Meadow Lake, Saskatchewan, a couple of years ago. They have an Indigenous‑owned sawmill and a bioenergy facility and are leaders in sustainable forest management. We’ve seen that direct management of the wood supply by Indigenous Peoples is now at 10%. There are 1,400 plus Indigenous-owned forestry businesses.

Our obligation on the land base under provincial law is that Indigenous and non-Indigenous community consultations need to happen as part of our planning. Some communities are more engaged than others. That needs to be dealt with at the community level. I apologize if that is how you took that statement. That’s not at all how I intended it.

Senator McCallum: Thank you.

Mr. Nighbor: You are welcome.

The Chair: We have come to the end. This is my chance now to ask a question. It’s for Mr. Nighbor.

I feel like I’ve been associated with softwood lumber for most of my life. At university, I worked in a lumber yard. That was my part-time job and then full-time in the summer. We would get the big-box cars coming in from B.C. with 2-by-12 24‑footers. Those things weighed a ton. It took a few of us to lug them out, and you couldn’t do it with a forklift.

Later on, I was involved probably in Lumber II, III and IV, when I was posted in the United States, including one long discussion that was going on at the time of 9/11.

All this is to say that my understanding of the U.S. market is that the small private woodlot owners are really the tail that wags the dog in Washington through their political influence. Every time we managed to secure about one third of the market share, all the alarms would go off, and something would have to take place, and there’d be complaints, and we’d have a crisis. The answer we always had was that our inventory is different. It’s not privately managed and controlled the way it is in the United States.

Are there allies in the U.S. who really want to work with us, who don’t want to see our industry decimated and our jobs lost? Because it is a lot cheaper getting the money from Canada for housing starts — I know you spoke about that in terms of a rebound in the U.S. economy — than to import it from Norway or the Russian Federation.

Mr. Nighbor: Yes. I would say the private landowners in the United States are not unanimous. There are power circles, for sure. We are seeing on the retailer side, as Senator Harder talked about, and on the home builder side, a lot of support there as well and on further value-added manufacturers.

A lot of mills are closing in the U.S. as well. Georgia is dealing with a massive residuals problem because of many, many pulp and paper mill and sawmill closures. This is not just happening here. This discussion has been in the Canadian context, but the U.S. lumber and pulp and paper industry is really suffering right now, too, which proves the point that these measures are not supporting those industries and are not supporting the average American person.

The Chair: Thank you very much. This has been a very interesting discussion at committee today, so on behalf of the committee, I thank Derek Nighbor and Nicole Vlanich for joining us. Your testimony is very valuable. The issues will not go away, so we might be seeing you again.

With that, colleagues, we will now move in camera.

(The committee continued in camera.)

Back to top