THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FORESTRY
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Tuesday, November 3, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Agriculture and Forestry met with videoconference this day at 6:30 p.m. [ET] to examine and report on the role of the agriculture and agri-food sector with regard to food security in Canada.
Senator John M. McNair (Deputy Chair) in the chair.
[English]
The Deputy Chair: Honourable senators, I call to order this meeting of the Standing Senate Committee on Agriculture and Forestry.
My name is John McNair. I am the deputy chair of this committee. Welcome to the members of the committee, our witnesses, as well as those watching this meeting online.
I wish to start by acknowledging that the land on which we gather is on the unceded, traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabe Nation.
Before we hear from our witnesses today, I wish to start by asking senators around the table to introduce themselves.
Senator Martin: Good evening. Yonah Martin, British Columbia.
Senator Sorensen: Karen Sorensen, Alberta, Banff National Park, Treaty 7 territory.
Senator Muggli: Tracy Muggli, Saskatchewan, Treaty 6 territory.
The Deputy Chair: Thank you, senators.
I would like to ask senators to consult cards on the table for guidelines to prevent audio feedback incidents. I wish to remind those participating today to refrain from switching languages mid-sentence and not to speak too quickly. Clear audio supports accurate interpretation, transcription and captioning.
Today the committee continues its study on the role of the agri-food sector with regard to food security in Canada. We have the pleasure of welcoming, from Statistics Canada, Jennifer Withington, Assistant Chief Statistician, Economic Statistics; Matthew MacDonald, Director, Consumer Prices Division; Erin Kumar, Acting Director, Agriculture; and Burton Gustajtis, Research Manager, Centre for Housing and Income Statistics.
Thank you, all, for joining us this evening. We will begin shortly with your opening remarks.
Before we move to that, I wish to let you know that you will have five minutes for your presentation. I will signal that your time is running out by trying to get your attention, perhaps by raising one hand at the one-minute mark to give you the heads-up. The floor is now yours, Ms. Withington.
[Translation]
Jennifer Withington, Assistant Chief Statistician, Economic Statistics, Statistics Canada: Honourable senators, thank you for the invitation to appear before the committee. Your study touches on many dimensions of food security, and Statistics Canada has data that can help inform several of them. I’d like to begin with the household picture.
[English]
In 2024, 24% of Canadians, or approximately 9.8 million people, lived in a household experiencing some degree of food insecurity. This was the first annual decrease after three consecutive increases, but the rate remained well above the 15.8% rate recorded in 2020.
The experience is also far from uniform. In 2024, food insecurity affected almost 45% of people living below Canada’s official poverty line, compared with about 22% of those above it. Nearly 31% of children aged 18 and younger lived in food-insecure households.
These findings point to an important distinction for this study: Canada’s ability to produce food is not the same as the ability of every household to access it.
Canada has a highly productive agricultural sector. Agricultural production has generally increased in recent years, and in 2025 Canada recorded its highest production of several commodities, including fresh vegetables, poultry meat, eggs and wheat flour.
Canada’s food supply draws on both domestic production and international trade. Canada is a major agri-food exporter, while imports also meet an important share of domestic demand. Statistics Canada’s Supply and Use Tables show that, in 2022, imports supplied about 30% of domestic food demand. The degree of reliance varies considerably by product. For example, imports supplied most domestic demand for fresh fruit and nuts.
[Translation]
Where people live also matters, as food insecurity varies across the country. In 2024, Nunavut had the highest rate among the provinces and territories, with 56.4% of people living in a household experiencing some degree of food insecurity. The cost of getting food to communities is another part of the northern picture. Statistics Canada’s supply-and-use data show that, in 2022, wholesaler, retailer and carrier margins collectively represented 61% of household spending on food products in the territories, compared with 38% in the rest of Canada. Food insecurity is particularly acute for some Indigenous populations. The 2022 Indigenous Peoples Survey found that food insecurity affected 43% of First Nations people living off reserve, 35% of Métis and 62% of Inuit. Among Inuit in Nunavut, the rate was 76%.
[English]
Finally, even when food is available nationally, household access depends on affordability and income; a relationship that household expenditure data helped put into perspective.
Between the end of 2019 and the second quarter of 2026, Canadian households’ total spending on food increased by more than 51%. Over the same period, the volume of food purchased — as measured by inflation-adjusted expenditure — increased to! 8.7%. Higher prices, therefore, accounted for much of the increase in dollar spending.
These pressures are not felt equally. Lower-income households devote a much greater share of their available income to essentials such as food, shelter and transportation, leaving them with less capacity to absorb higher prices.
Our distributional household economic accounts put this pressure into perspective. In 2025, average spending on food, shelter and transportation represented 111.1% of average disposable income for households in the lowest income quintile, compared with 31.6% for those in the highest. For the lowest-income group, spending on these essentials alone exceeded disposable income, on average.
Taken together, these findings show why food security cannot be understood through any single statistic or any single part of the food system. Food production and distribution must be examined alongside households’ ability to afford and access that food.
Mr. Chair, thank you. My colleagues and I would be pleased to answer your questions.
The Deputy Chair: Thank you for your presentation. We will start with Senator Muggli.
Senator Muggli: I will see if I can articulate this.
Do you have data specifically on farm inputs as it relates to the cost of food?
What inputs are increasing the fastest or the most in cost? I don’t know if you will have this data, but what per cent are inputs as it relates to the cost of food on the shelf? Does that make sense?
Ms. Withington: Yes.
Senator Muggli: I have another question after that.
Ms. Withington: Right now, in terms of increasing costs, fuel has had some big impacts on farms, as well as the rest of us.
In terms of what percentage, I think Ms. Kumar has information on the revenue that farms have had as well as their costs and margins.
Erin Kumar, Acting Director, Agriculture, Statistics Canada: Hello and thank you.
As Ms. Withington mentioned, in terms of expenses right now, energy costs are one of the highest. This year, fertilizer cost is an input price that has put pressure on farms. It also depends on the sector that we are talking about. We might have energy costs that would also impact greenhouses and the plant materials they use to start their production, which is an input they’ve seen increasing over the years.
We’ve seen farm expenses go up. If we look at the profitability of farms overall, margins are stable because we are not seeing price increases that are higher than the costs they are facing.
Senator Muggli: Could you repeat that last part? That does not make sense to me.
Ms. Kumar: If we look to the profitability of farms, which is a measure of their income versus expenses, the margins are staying fairly small. Even if we see an increased price for a particular farm product, the cost that the farmer has to mail out to produce that is offsetting any of the —
Senator Muggli: So the farmer is not getting more, and then they have the burden of the input costs?
Ms. Kumar: They may be seeing price increases for some commodities, but they are not seeing it significant enough to offset their profit margins.
Senator Muggli: Separating the North from the rest of Canada, could you talk about the North and rank the key drivers of food costs? What are the major drivers for rising food costs in the North?
Ms. Withington: Yes, in 2025 farm cash receipts were $100 billion and the operating expenses were $83 billion. It shows that the margins are still slim and have been consistent through time.
Senator Muggli: Can you divvy that up by sector of food production?
Ms. Withington: By different sectors, we can follow up with that.
Senator Muggli: I was thinking of the difference between fruit and vegetable production versus beef production versus pork production. I’m curious. Is anyone making money? Are inputs going up for every food-producing entity?
Ms. Withington: Entity, yes.
Senator Muggli: Yes.
Ms. Withington: In terms of the North, if you look at the supply use tables, what you are seeing are the margins. Transportation and wholesale retail are about 66% versus 33% for the rest of Canada. It is much higher, largely because it takes a long time to get there, and it is more costly.
Senator Muggli: Which it has always been like that.
Ms. Withington: Yes, 61% versus 38%.
Senator Muggli: We had a witness who spoke about us, for lack of a better word, the chaotic transportation system in Canada when it comes to the movement of food. I do not necessarily mean finished product. I mean through the supply chain.
Do you have data on the factors as it relates to transportation and costs?
Ms. Withington: We do have some data on transportation costs. We have bits and pieces through different sources of data. What we’re missing is the whole supply chain picture, so we can show you some information and tidbits here or there.
Senator Muggli: Would you recommend that we include that in the study? I’ll stop for now.
Senator Sorensen: Statistics Canada collects considerable information on food prices, household income and spending, agriculture production and food insecurity, but those indicators are often considered separately, but I will say, as I go into my question, your presentation brought everything together. My question is: Does Statistics Canada have the ability to bring these databases together to provide a more comprehensive picture? I will have you comment on that further.
In that, could you repeat those three essentials you said? It was household, food, and I forgot the other essentials. Those numbers, if you would not mind repeating them.
Ms. Withington: To your first question, we have some ability to bring together the data. We do provide, in certain cases, what we call data linkage, which means taking different data sets and putting them together to get a fuller, comprehensive picture. We do have some of the data divided into different characteristics. We look at it across the board for a comprehensive picture. We could do more of that.
Senator Sorensen: Okay.
Ms. Withington: That is something we do. It was household, shelter, food and transportation.
Senator Sorensen: I just remember, in 2025, 111%, that is as far as I got. I would like to hear those three numbers again.
Ms. Withington: Yes. It is the 111% is low income — how much they spend on food, shelter, and transportation.
Senator Sorensen: So, 111% of the money they have coming in?
Ms. Withington: Of what they have coming in. It is costing them more than what they have coming in. It raises questions. Be mindful that in certain cases, seniors could be in that category. In that case, they could be drawing down some of their accumulated income.
Senator Sorensen: And then 36% were higher income.
Ms. Withington: That budget for housing, food, and transportation would cost 36% of their budget, whereas it is taking up over 100%. The essentials take up the lowest income quintile all of their budget and more; whereas for upper income quintile, it costs —
Senator Sorensen: And what was the last one?
It was 138%. Was there a third group there, or did I mishear?
Ms. Withington: I don’t remember saying that. Was there anything that you wanted to add?
Matthew MacDonald, Director, Consumer Prices Division, Statistics Canada: Just that food security is a broad topic. A few years ago, when food prices started to escalate, we were thinking about how we can centralize and make that information more available, and so we created the Food Price Data Hub, which is accessible through our website. It tracks primarily consumer prices through inflation, but also at earlier stages of the production chain, from input prices to transportation as well, and what that is showing is the huge increase in transportation costs and fertilizers, at least recently.
Senator Sorensen: Second, following up on Senator Muggli’s comments on communities in the North, I was also going to go down that road.
Does the data adequately capture the additional costs associated with transporting food to the North. I have had a couple of experience in the North in grocery stores, quite shocking. Those are big numbers of the number of people living with food insecurity in the North. Those numbers are shocking. When you are doing those numbers, do you take the costs of transportation in there as well. Is that a part of the cost of food?
Ms. Withington: It is embedded in the cost of food. It would be taken into consideration for that. We do not break down how much is because of transportation. We do margins at the bigger level. We do have some good quality data on the North. It is always the smaller the sample, the harder it is to be perfectly accurate, but Mr. MacDonald can tell you a bit about the collection.
Mr. MacDonald: Yes, transportation and trade margins are quite high to get things to the North. A lot higher than in Canada in general.
What we are seeing on the food inflation side there is a price-level shift. Things are definitely more expensive. Sometimes the inflation rate can be higher, not always. That is not necessarily higher. There is definitely a level shift in prices because they are more expensive as a result of the transportation networks.
Our coverage in the North is the major cities for the territories and also Nunavut as well.
Senator Sorensen: Thank you.
Senator Martin: Thank you for being here this evening.
In your opening remarks, you talked about the 2024 Canadian income survey. Some of the numbers were high and concerning.
I don’t know when this national survey by the Salvation Army was released. Is that recent?
It found that 31% of Canadians skip meals or reduce meal sizes because they could not afford groceries, up from 27% a year earlier, including 41% of respondents aged 18-34.
I am trying to understand some of the discrepancies. Your data show a modest decline in food insecurity since 2023, which you mentioned, while other national surveys suggest that the situation is worsening. Could you help us understand the divergence? Are there gaps in how we measure? I know you said it’s not a simple assessment; it’s complex. But how we measure food insecurity may be understating the true extent of the issue, because I have another question about food banks as well.
Ms. Withington: Absolutely. That survey hit the media today. We did have a look at it.
I would say our data was pertaining to 2024.
When you look at food prices over the last couple of years, they’ve increased; they’ve continued to increase considerably. Maybe that explains a little bit of disparity. I’m not sure of the timing of their survey; I’m not sure it said offhand. Some other differences could take place; it depends.
Our methodologies are usually robust. We ensure we have a sample that is representative of the whole population.
I cannot speak to their methodology. There may be methodological differences on whom and how they surveyed that might explain some of the differences.
Ours has three definitions of food insecurity, whereas they were asking a slightly different question, like, did you eat less or forgo or skip a meal? There are some fundamental differences between what was being asked.
Nonetheless, we will look into it more closely to be able to explain. I do not know if Mr. Gustajtis has anything to add.
Burton Gustajtis, Research Manager, Centre for Housing and Income Statistics, Statistics Canada: I can explain how food insecurity is measured in Canada, and we can circle back to the numbers released today.
Canada’s primary validated measure of food insecurity is done through the Household Food Security Survey Module. It’s a module that contains 18 questions. It is designed to measure food insecurity, resulting from limited financial resources, and is asked to households of the last 12 months.
For context, the questions are similar to: Are you or your household members worried food would run out before you got more money? Have you or any other adults ever cut the size of your meals or skipped meals because there wasn’t enough money for food? Did you personally eat less than you felt you should because there wasn’t enough money for food?
The responses indicating a food-related hardship are counted as affirmative responses. Households are categorized into the three groupings Ms. Withington mentioned. In general, the more affirmative responses you get the more severity increases on food insecurity.
The categories are: marginal food insecurity, you worry about running out of food or limited food selection due to a lack of money for food; then you have moderate food insecurity, which is a compromise in the quality or quantity of the food due to a lack of money; then the highest or most severe is severe food insecurity, and that is when you miss meals or reduce food intake; then at the most extreme is to go without food for days at a time.
The primary source for the annual food insecurity estimates at Statistics Canada is the Canadian Income Survey. It is administered in the provinces and territories. The last data point was 2024; 2025 will be released in the spring.
It is a robust survey. Not to get into too much detail, but the survey released today online was about 1,500 respondents. The Canadian Income Survey starts at 100,000 people. With nonresponse rates it gets whittled down a little but the number of respondents in the survey is quite high.
Senator Martin: I can appreciate the numbers you’re dealing with are much higher. But in the last two years since your survey, a lot has increased. I feel it myself.
My question is: The severity of food insecurity, is it much worse than what your latest data shows? Is there a gap because it has been two years?
Ms. Withington: The food insecurity relates to two years. While food prices have tapered off in the last couple of months and are no longer higher than the headline inflation rates, they had been growing faster than the headline inflation rates for the 18 months prior to that. That is not a direct answer, but I would suspect that has not helped things.
Senator Martin: Right.
Ms. Withington: We do see, through the distributions of Household Economic Accounts, that the buying of food has been more of a hardship for the lowest income quintiles.
Senator Burey: I will follow on Senator Martin’s questions. Thank you for being here and for your expertise, and sorry to be a few minutes late.
I have gathered enough information to dig into the question. You were talking about the Canadian Income Survey and the results.
Looking at the data, I was interested to see that even though the rate was down — and with the caveat that it was two years ago so we do not have up-to-date data — the highest rates were in people with one-parent families. I don’t know if you mentioned that in your opening remarks, but it was 44.4% in one-parent families; 47.4% were parents where the parent is a woman; and, of course, in Indigenous people 34.7%; and racialized people 30.4%. Those are striking rates. Maybe that is being picked up in the other surveys: that larger population.
My question is: Do you think your models adequately capture the people who are being most severely affected, even though you have such a large catchment area?
And could you follow up on some of your wish list gaps — that you touched on — in terms of the data collection you would like to have going forward?
Ms. Withington: Thank you. Are we adequately covered? Yes, our samples are usually robust to represent the different populations, in general, from our surveys.
The finer you get down into a specific region or subcategory the fewer people there are to sample, but overall we ensure we have high-quality data that is representative.
Furthermore, some of the data we produce is based on macroeconomic aggregates. We look at the big picture and then break it down to get a fuller picture, such as through our distributions of household economic accounts.
Could we always have more? The more sample the better.
Senator Burey: What is on your wish list?
Ms. Withington: What is on our wish list?
Senator Burey: No wishes?
Ms. Withington: There is always a wish list. To keep response rates high, have the collaboration of our respondents and to get the buy-in to create timely data.
In terms of specific data gaps, I will let you all provide your wish lists.
Mr. MacDonald: We have made some improvements in food security, because there seems to be an aggregate metric that we are compiling from the survey that Mr. Gustajtis is describing. And this is an improvement in other areas; for example, housing affordability, where you have to look at a variety of statistics and dissect them. Some look good and some don’t, and you have to assess them in their entirety. Whereas with food, we have good food price and excellent price data that we use to calculate the consumer price index and measure inflation.
We have very good income data to supplement that with. And we also have disaggregated information on income by decile or quartile. Whether that’s by household composition type or age — I think young people were referenced in the study today as those who might be on the lower-income spectrum and sacrificing meals — trying to compile that all into an aggregate indicator and having the methodology to do that makes it useful for the communities is important for us.
The Deputy Chair: Do you have anything to add?
Mr. Gustajtis: Not really. I think Mr. MacDonald covered it all. In this Canadian food security sample survey, as Ms. Withington mentioned, increasing either the response rate or the sample size are the only ways to improve the quality for the food insecurity module.
Ms. Withington: I will add that we are always looking to improve what we do, and as you mentioned, the household food security survey is a couple of years old. We are always looking for administrative data sources to allow us to be more timely and to make sure we are comprehensive. That, I would say, is a data gap, like the fine-detailed spending habits of Canadians that we could access.
Senator Muggli: Mr. Gustajtis, I think we should get a copy of the survey for our record so that we actually know how it’s being measured, and we can see the question and associate —
The Deputy Chair: You’re talking about the 18-question survey?
Senator Muggli: The 18-question survey. The 2025 data release in the spring — do you have a more specific timeline?
Mr. Gustajtis: We are still processing the survey data now, so it is a little premature. Typically, we release around the end of April or the start of May.
Senator Muggli: Okay. That may be too late for our timeline. Two other questions, maybe three. Do you have any data on the impact on household food expenditures for families with children who have access to school food programs?
Mr. MacDonald: I don’t think so.
Senator Muggli: Or is that a new idea?
Ms. Withington: I don’t think — Senator Muggli just answered the question.
Senator Muggli: In theory, these families should be spending less on groceries because they are not having to pack the kids’ lunches for school, that type of thing.
Ms. Withington: The closest I could come to that, off the top of my head, if they were in specific geographies, we could see what the food expenditures or food insecurities are versus areas that don’t have those programs.
Senator Muggli: I could be wrong, but I think a lot of the school food programs may be initiated in schools where there might be lower income themes. There might be something there.
Ms. Withington: If we had a timeline of when a lot of them were implemented, we could also look through time and say, you know, has food insecurity through time diminished since that program has been—
Senator Muggli: I think that would supplement what some of the researchers who are trying to measure outcomes for the food school programs are trying to accomplish, too. When the program was initiated, there really wasn’t a lot of support put into the research side of it, so there is not really baseline data. Whatever you guys might be able to do to complement that all.
Do you have any data on large grocers’ profit margins, perhaps broken down — perhaps some themes there?
Ms. Withington: Through our Supply and Use Tables, we do have the retail margins for every industry. I think when we looked at that, they had not been going up much during this period. We do not distinguish between large grocery retailers and small grocery retailers, however.
Senator Muggli: Why not?
Ms. Withington: Because this is sort of aggregate-level data.
Senator Muggli: I think there are some very large corporations that would have a very different experience than a small, family grocer. It seems to me it would be worth distinguishing so we can see where the money is really being made and where it is not being made? I think that would be useful.
Do you track dietary changes as prices go up? Are people changing what they’re buying? Is less nutritious food being purchased? Is there any change in purchasing domestic food versus imported food?
Mr. MacDonald: We have a bit of information about this in the consumer price index, which is our monthly measure of inflation and the basket weights. Every year, we update our basket weights to be reflective of new expenditure information that becomes available, either through our survey of household spending, run on a biannual cycle, or through our system of macroeconomic accounts.
Grocery spending over time has increased. Before the pandemic, it was about $6,000 annually, and in 2023, it was up over $8,500. We’re in the processing of our latest cycle, so it will probably increase over that. What we’ve seen from food as a percentage of the basket from grocery stores is hovering around 10% or 11%. During the pandemic, it was quite high because everything else was shut down, so the proportion spent on food was much higher. That’s kind of come back now, as things have opened up and stabilized. We are seeing some shifts, definitely less meat, whether that’s for price-related reasons or environmental or health-related reasons. We are seeing slightly less fruit and vegetables. It was about 17% of the food basket five years ago, and now it’s down to 15% — a slight decline. And what we’re seeing an increase in is prepared food and confectionery: a lot of the middle of the aisle, prepackaged stuff. That’s increasing, but it has been susceptible to really high prices. These are your edible oils, olive oils and cooking oils, which have shot up. Coffee has really shot up over the last five years. That’s in that category as well. We are seeing slight changes, but we’re not sure whether that’s a reaction to dietary reasons or reacting to price pressures.
Senator Muggli: Is there a stratification by ethnicity on the data?
Mr. MacDonald: We don’t stratify the CPI by ethnicity. We do have our survey of household spending that has certain socio-demographic variables. I believe they are age, income, membership, household composition and region. I don’t think they include ethnicity or even immigration status.
Senator Muggli: Okay. Thank you. That’s good for now.
Senator Martin: I was listening to what you said in your opening remarks, that we have increased production in the agriculture sector, like fresh vegetables, meat, fruit, and we are a major agricultural food exporter. Although we are producing and exporting more, the availability of vegetables is declining. I’m trying to understand this discrepancy, and how your department’s data on agricultural production, food availability and household food security can be integrated better to identify where gaps exist between the food Canada produces and the foods Canadians can access? We are producing more, but people have less access? Please help me understand.
Ms. Withington: Yes. We do look at this holistically. We look at what we are producing, what we import, and what we export. Sometimes the mix of what we export and what we produce is not the same as what we consume. You will never find a banana grown in Canada, but people like to eat bananas. Sometimes we produce too much of certain things. I think some vegetables, we export quite a bit, but not necessarily the right mix. Ms. Kumar?
Erin Kumar, Acting Director, Agriculture, Statistics Canada: I would add to that, if you look at red meat or chicken, more than three quarters of the supply available in Canada comes from domestic supply, despite the fact that we are seeing increases for both those commodities in terms of imports. If we look at fresh vegetables, they still account for 64% of domestic supply. If we look at fresh fruit, we are seeing that that’s only about a quarter of domestic supply, but that’s because we are importing more fruit than we are producing, and that has to do more with the variety of fruit that we grow in this country. If we look at just the fruit that we can grow in the country, it represents about 42% of domestic supply.
If we look at fruit, we are seeing increases in imports for bananas, dates and apples destined for processing, for example. So the story is a mix of, and it is hard to distinguish, as Ms. Withington said, what is actually consumed because we are measuring what is available in the country.
Senator Martin: So we are exporting more, but are we importing enough? Do you have that sort of data? Do you have a detailed list of things you are looking at?
Ms. Kumar: We have our supply-disposition tables that are slightly different from the supply and use tables because they are measured by weight as opposed to by the economic unit. We have that available for a multitude of commodities, and our most recent reference period is 2025. That is something we produced using — inclusive of imports, exports and domestic production. For example, those are all accounted for in these supply and disposition tables —
Senator Martin: I know you are Statistics Canada, and you may not have the answer, but who is — does your data inform the sector, and how do we know what more we need and what’s being sent? Who keeps track of all of that so that Canadians can have access to what they need?
Ms. Withington: We do keep track of all the different elements. Where there is a nuance is that what is needed is a subjective measure. We don’t have that. We have what people are buying, what people are making, what we are exporting and how it all works out. Is there some unmet demand? That part we don’t have information on. I think that’s what you are getting at: that sort of delta.
Senator Martin: I am wondering how we make sure it all fits. You have information, but it is not all of it, and then there is the sector.
The food bank statistics are very alarming. They are setting records, year after year, and what explains the divergence between your survey findings and what food banks are actually seeing on the front lines? Why is there that discrepancy?
Ms. Withington: We are measuring two different things. Not all food-insecure households go to food banks. I’m not sure that all people who use food banks would 100% consider themselves food insecure. It may be a time-limited measure. So they are measuring slightly different things.
Mr. Gustajtis, did you have more to add?
Senator Martin: Are you referring to renters and people who are employed but still go to the food bank?
Ms. Withington: Exactly.
Senator Martin: The fact is that they are there. I am curious how these statistics or the data inform us as to what we can do for Canadians. I interrupted you, but I only had 10 seconds. Sorry.
The Deputy Chair: The longest 10 seconds in the world.
Mr. Gustajtis: It is a multitude of things. It is probably difficult to put it all into one thing. Although 2024 was a slight decrease from 2023, it was after three years of consecutive increases in food insecurity. The Canadian Income Survey is seeing similar food insecurity rate problems through its administration of the food security module. It is that one year. It is hard to tell what the discrepancies are without looking at the methodologies in a lot more detail.
Senator Sorensen: Again, I think I’m asking Senator Martin’s question in a slightly different way about imports. How well positioned is Canada to meet its own food requirements through domestic agriculture production? So understanding there will never be a banana grown in Canada, and a second part, are there food categories where Canada is becoming increasingly dependent on imports?
Let’s talk about food that we can grow in Canada that, for some reason, we are still importing. I can’t stand when I go to the grocery store, and there are apples from the U.S.A. I am like, “Why? We have so many apples.” It is kind of a Rob Black question: Are we doomed? He is not here, so I can say it. For what Canada can produce, can we continue to produce enough for our population?
Ms. Withington: I would say, overall, there will always be items that we can’t make. We do import 30% of what we consume. A lot of that is certain categories, like fruits and vegetables and nuts. That’s up to about 88%. And coffee. We’re not going to produce coffee.
Senator Sorensen: And we need it.
Ms. Withington: We need it. So can we produce enough ourselves? We’ve never been at a point that we produced enough for ourselves. Can we increase that rate? Certainly, in a lot of categories, we can cover that.
Ms. Kumar: It is hard to measure sometimes, too, because when we see production decline, it is not necessarily because the sector is in trouble. For example, in the fruit and vegetable sector — the fruit and nut sector, for example, in British Columbia, in 2024, extreme heat decimated their crops, so they couldn’t produce as much. They rebounded in 2025. Those are the stories. Even when there are declines in domestic production, we are seeing increases in the following year.
The other thing to keep in mind, too, when we talk about how imports might have an impact, when we import, that can also impact the price. Because we are getting more supply into the market, the prices can be better because we see that sort of combined production or that combined availability.
Senator Sorensen: Yes, that’s — sometimes, importing for a Canadian consumer can cost them less than using a — just because we are a big country.
Mr. MacDonald: And sometimes exporting can create more —
Senator Sorensen: Revenue.
Mr. MacDonald: — advantageous for the producer as well. Seafood is an example of that. We export a lot of seafood despite the fact that we produce a lot.
Senator Sorensen: Thank you.
Senator Burey: I will move to the agricultural world. This is the Agriculture Committee, so I am moving to the agricultural sector. In any event, a Statistics Canada analysis published in May 2026 talked about how important temporary foreign agricultural workers are to food security. The name of the analysis is “From far afield to our fields.” It counts 74,000 temporary foreign workers on Canadian farms each year since 2023. It tracks them by type of farm, farm size and country of origin, et cetera.
Does Statistics Canada have any measure of linking these workers to food production? Is there any way that you are saying — because, of course, we hear from farmers that they need — and we understand that we do need foreign temporary workers to come and help us in the agricultural sector.
Do you have any data on that, linking the workforce to food production?
Ms. Kumar: I don’t know that there is data that would directly link the number of employees to the actual production values. We can see that 48.6% of all agricultural workers are seasonal. That means they do play an important role in production. We can also see that, as you said, temporary foreign workers are playing a role, and, without those, it is possible production wouldn’t happen, but there is no direct link.
We know, as I said, that employment in the sector has declined in 2024, with the numbers that I have here, but we are seeing a sharp increase in 2023 of temporary foreign workers as well.
I would say there is no direct linkage, but given there is a huge increase in seasonal workers, yes, there is some correlation between the two.
Senator Burey: Thank you.
The Deputy Chair: Colleagues, any other questions? I have one that I will put in quickly, using my prerogative as chair.
You have prepared a bar graph that shows the rates of food insecurity, and you talked about none of it being at 56.4%. I get that. The second one is Alberta. It has always puzzled me. Do you have an explanation for why Alberta is the second highest?
Mr. Gustajtis: Any reason why? No.
The Deputy Chair: When I think of Alberta, I think of higher wages and a lot of employment.
Mr. Gustajtis: Nothing comes to mind. It does have higher rates of severe food insecurity as well. I know that doesn’t answer your question. It only reinforces that it is a high rate.
The Deputy Chair: It has always been puzzling to me when I look at the graph each week because it is in our materials. New Brunswick is at 28.2 and Manitoba at 27.9. I can rationalize that. But Alberta being the second highest? I have always struggled with that.
Ms. Withington: One thing we could maybe look at is Alberta perhaps has pockets. There are some pockets of people who have less access to food. Whereas we sometimes think of Alberta as Calgary, where there is some prosperity and there is a lot of oil work; there are other pockets.
Senator McBean: Sorry I was late this evening. I am Senator McBean from Ontario, and I don’t know if you answered my question in the last hour. If you have, please tell me you have answered it, and I will find it in the transcripts. Are there important data gaps related to food security or agricultural resilience that, if they were addressed, would help governments and stakeholders to make better-informed decisions?
Ms. Withington: We answered that a little bit, but we have a lot of information everywhere. This discussion has shown that being able to link a lot more of that information would be helpful to answering some of the questions.
Senator McBean: How do you do that? Do you need more workforce? Do you need more time? Do you need someone to say, “Please, do that?”
Ms. Withington: It is prioritization. If it comes up as a priority, that helps our ability to do it. If there are specific questions that can be asked about what they require, that would be helpful. Of course, the workforce is always important to be able to do it in a timely manner.
Senator Martin: A letter from the committee requesting — you would do that? So that’s part of the work that you would do to coordinate it. So that’s a good question, and we could follow up with the request.
Ms. Withington: Yes. Requesting and then maybe —
Senator Martin: Okay. Perfect.
The Deputy Chair: Anything you can send after combing through your data that you have around the conversation that we’ve been having tonight would be helpful. Like the 18 questions that Senator Muggli talked about, just hearing you read out some of the questions is very sobering. It is a very heavy topic.
Ms. Withington: I will allow my colleagues to see if they wanted to add anything to Senator McBean’s questions.
Mr. MacDonald: No, but sometimes it depends on the uses of the data. We have a lot of information that is parsed out, and to decide what the best way is to combine it for potentially an aggregate indicator that would serve the purposes of users. We don’t always know that methodology ourselves, and sometimes it takes consultation to see how the data would be used and what would be included.
As we mentioned earlier, food security is quite broad, similar to housing affordability. There is not one single, identifiable metric that paints the whole picture.
The Deputy Chair: On behalf of the committee, I thank you for your testimony tonight and for taking the time to be with us and for answering our questions. You are reminding us that data is very important to understanding the problem and working toward a solution to solve it. Thank you for all the work that you do.
Colleagues, for the second panel today we have the pleasure of welcoming in the room with us Irek Kusmierczyk, Senior Director, Workforce WindsorEssex, a former parliamentarian colleague of ours; and joining us online, we have Berenice Vega Rauda, Executive Director, Foreign Agricultural Resource Management Services.
Thank you, both, for joining us. We will start shortly with your opening remarks.
Before we move to that, I will let you know you will each have five minutes. I will signal your time is running out by trying to get your attention. When you have about one minute left, I will raise my right hand. It will be followed by questions from senators in the room. The floor is now yours, Mr. Kusmierczyk.
Irek Kusmierczyk, Senior Director, Workforce WindsorEssex: Thank you, chair, honourable senators, and thank you for inviting Workforce WindsorEssex to contribute and be a part of your study on Canada’s food security.
I am here to share what we have learned through the TeaMWork Project, which is a network of community organizations in Southwestern Ontario that support temporary foreign workers — primarily in the agriculture sector — across the regions of Windsor-Essex, Chatham-Kent and Sarnia-Lambton.
Southwestern Ontario is one of Canada’s agricultural powerhouses. A $6 billion farming economy that employs 40,000 workers across thousands of farms, including the largest concentration of greenhouses in North America.
Food security is often discussed in terms of land, inputs, technology, transportation and prices. All of those matter.
But food security also depends on people. In Southwestern Ontario, thousands of migrant workers help seed, grow, harvest, pack and move food. Their health, safety and ability to access support are essential to the stability and resilience of the food system.
TeaMWork began in 2022 through the federally funded Migrant Worker Support Program. Workforce WindsorEssex coordinates seven organizations with expertise in legal services, settlement and community supports, health care, occupational health and safety, language training and community inclusion.
The organizations are: South Essex Community Council; Legal Assistance of Windsor; North Lambton Community Health Centre; Chatham-Kent Community Health Centres; OHCOW; Collège Boréal; and the Migrant Worker Community Program.
Our role is not to replace employers, regulators, or public services; it is to help workers understand their rights, find the right service and navigate a system that can be difficult to access, especially in rural communities.
The model is practical. We meet workers where they are: on farms, in bunkhouses, in language classes, and at community health centres, legal clinics and community events that TeaMWork organizes.
We distribute multilingual information, provide referrals and one-on-one support, coordinate transportation and interpretation, and connect workers to health, legal, emergency and other services.
We also strengthen coordination so that a worker is not passed from one disconnected door to another. Since the project began four years ago, TeaMWork has recorded 60,000 client interactions. This shows how frequently workers need trusted points of contact.
In the process, we have learned three lessons. First, access is often the central issue. A service may technically exist, but it is not truly accessible if a worker lacks transportation, language support, time away from work, digital access, or confidence that seeking help will not put their employment at risk.
Second, trust is built through presence and consistency. A farm visit, language class or community event may be the first step that later allows a worker to raise a health, safety or legal concern.
Third, no single organization can meet the full range of needs. Coordinated local networks are more effective because the challenges workers face often overlap.
We have also learned that supporting workers and supporting the agricultural sector are not competing objectives. When workers receive accurate information, preventive health support and timely referrals, problems can be solved earlier. Employers have clear partners to call. Communities are better equipped to welcome workers. The result is a more stable workforce around a sector that is essential to Canada’s food supply.
I am not appearing today to offer policy or budget recommendations. My purpose is to place TeaMWork’s experience before the committee, which shows that the human infrastructure behind food production matters: trusted relationships, local service capacity, outreach to rural workplaces, and coordination across community organizations matter.
Canada’s food system relies on the skill, hard work and resilience of agricultural workers, including migrant workers. Recognizing that connection helps us understand food security not only as the availability of food, but also as the resilience of the people and communities that produce it. Thank you.
The Deputy Chair: The floor is now yours, Ms. Vega Rauda.
Berenice Vega Rauda, Executive Director, Foreign Agricultural Resource Management Services: Mr. Chair and honourable senators, thank you for inviting me to speak today. I am the Executive Director of Foreign Agricultural Resource Management Services, known as F.A.R.M.S. For decades, F.A.R.M.S. has supported Canadian farmers through the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program, or SAWP. We also assist employers under the Agricultural Stream.
Today, I want to share a very important message: Food security is national security. Canada’s food security depends on having the right workers, at the right time, on our farms.
Agriculture is not like other sectors. Farmers cannot delay planting because a government system is not working. They cannot postpone the harvest because a Labour Market Impact Assessment, or LMIA, is still being reviewed. Crops do not wait. Seasons do not wait. And farmers cannot afford to wait.
Canadian farmers continue to face serious labour shortages, especially in rural areas. They make efforts to hire Canadians, but, in many cases, there are simply not enough available workers to meet their needs.
This is why temporary foreign workers are important to this program, and especially this sector. These workers are not just filling jobs; they are helping Canada to produce its food.
However, farmers are facing another serious challenge: the growing administrative burden of accessing these programs. At F.A.R.M.S., we work directly with employers every day. We see their frustration with Job Bank, LMIA Online — technical problems, changing requirements, and the time spent dealing with applications.
Employers must complete multiple steps, provide documents, meet deadlines, and follow procedures that are not always clear or consistent.
When Job Bank is not working properly, access to LMIA Online can be affected. When technical support is needed, getting timely assistance can become another challenge.
Farmers should be spending their time at their farms, not struggling with government websites. We fully support clear rules, proper checks, and strong worker protections. These are necessary, but the process should not become an additional barrier to food production.
Another major concern is the uncertainty surrounding agricultural labour programs. Farmers plan their operations months in advance. They invest in production, prepare housing and organize their workforce long before the season begins. Uncertain immigration policies, possible reductions in worker numbers, and sudden changes to program requirements create serious concerns for the sector.
About two and a half years ago, for context, the Canadian government presented six discussion papers on SAWP. Employer groups provided feedback, but we are still waiting for a clear government response. This lack of follow-up adds to the uncertainty farmers already face and raises concerns about the future of the program.
Farmers cannot plan their future when they are uncertain about the rules or whether they will have enough workers.
We also recognize the importance of labour mobility and the right of workers to change employers. However, these changes must be properly organized, respecting workers’ rights and ensuring they are not placed in vulnerable situations.
Honourable senators, our farmers are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for clear rules, reliable systems, timely solutions and the support they need to grow and harvest the food that feeds Canada — our country.
The farmers who produce our food deserve our attention. The workers who help grow and harvest that food deserve our respect.
Food security starts on our farms. Without reliable labour, there is no harvest. We cannot talk about protecting Canada’s food supply without supporting farmers, workers and the systems that make food production possible.
Thank you for your time.
The Deputy Chair: Thank you, both, for your presentation.
Senator Sorensen: Thank you, both, for being here. Great to see you.
What are the main barriers and gaps in training, housing or rural infrastructure that prevent Canadians from pursuing employment and filling vacancies in agriculture?
I was going to start by saying I spent my career in the tourism industry, and now in this job I spend a lot of time advocating for the tourism industry, and I have the exact same conversation with tourism that I do with agriculture. It is very much the same story.
Just for grounding, it would be interesting to ask what the issue is with Canadians coming for these jobs.
I will start with you, Mr. Kusmierczyk, because your Workforce WindsorEssex addressed some of those questions in your consultations in your career guide that was published, which I have. I will ask you to start because you did do some consultation on what the biggest problem is.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes. I wish to be careful, as well, to stay in my lane as the lead of the TeaMWork Project, focusing our attention on the experience of migrant workers. Yes, there are challenges, for sure, in terms of Canadians taking on positions on farms and in the ag sector. One of the challenges is transportation. This is a challenge that is a common challenge for Canadian workers but also for temporary foreign workers. A lot of times these farms are located in very isolated communities, and transportation is sparse, sometimes non-existent. Transportation is a key barrier to many Canadians and many migrant workers who work in the ag space.
Senator Sorensen: Which is why we see farmers offering housing, which may be more appealing to temporary foreign workers than to residents.
Ms. Vega Rauda, did you wish to elaborate?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes. I agree with Mr. Kusmierczyk with what he had to say about transportation, but I disagree a little bit on that as well. I believe there is not enough labour around in rural areas.
There is also a problem around seasonality. As I said, employers plan in advance. As you know, they start looking for their workforce six months in advance. Sometimes they can find a few locals. Let’s say 20% from the 100 they are going to need, but that 20% is probably not going to be available by the time they are going to start harvesting, producing, planting or seeding or any of the stages of their work. That is also a big issue.
Senator Sorensen: I will ask both of you: To what extent would you state that the recent policy caps on temporary foreign workers, or TFWs, affect Canada’s food security?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: As was stated by the previous witnesses, we have seen, for example, a steady supply of workers, especially in terms of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program. Those numbers have not been impacted.
What we have heard from many employers, farmers and operators is they are looking for a steady and reliable workforce. That is the foundation of food security, having a reliable and steady workforce. On that issue, F.A.R.M.S Ontario and Workforce WindsorEssex are very much aligned.
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, correct. I agree with that.
The main issue is the administrative process that we are facing, like I said, every day.
These workers are reliable. They come to work season after season. This year we are celebrating the sixtieth anniversary of the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program. They are not the problem; the problem is the system.
With all respect, senator, in order to place a LMIA, we have to work six months in advance. Even working six months in advance, we face many challenges along the way. To post and advertise for a job that no one will apply for, we have to wait between three to six weeks for somebody from the Job Bank to approve that advertising. Then for somebody else to look at it again and to tell you that it was incomplete. You don’t even know what they were looking for. With all of my experience, sometimes I look at it, and I don’t see anything different than another one that was already approved.
There you already have eight weeks that they will miss. We will start all over again with that employer, do the advertising again and apply and try to expedite it. I can go on and on.
The program itself, the nature and the heart of this program works. It is all the administrative processes and the lack of support — the support that we do not receive, I’m sorry — from the institutions that are looking after this program.
Senator Sorensen: Thank you.
Senator Muggli: Generally speaking, obviously, we need to have the workforce available to plant, harvest and distribute.
I will start with this overarching question for both of you: Are we doing enough to develop a sustainable agricultural workforce, whether that is through Canadians or temporary foreign workers? Also, I’m interested in how you assess workers’ skills to match people in the ag sector, given the — how do you keep a workforce that is ready to operate increasingly technologically advanced equipment in this sector?
Go ahead, Mr. Kusmierczyk.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes. Both of those are excellent questions.
I would begin by stating, once again, that healthy, happy and connected workers are really the foundation for a stable, reliable and productive workforce. That is absolutely key to food security.
To take one step back, in Ontario about one out of three agricultural workers are temporary foreign workers. You have about 35,000 migrant workers working in Ontario alone. They are absolutely essential to the ag sector.
I would also say they are also net contributors to the social safety net in Canada. For example, if you take Employment Insurance, or EI, for every $1 that a temporary foreign worker pays into the EI system, they only draw anywhere between 2 and 9 cents off of that dollar. So they are net contributors and strengthen Canada’s social safety net in addition to strengthening our food security.
Again, I return to the original comment, which is, again, food security begins with having a resilient workforce.
In terms of the skills, from a temporary foreign worker standpoint, you have to separate two different streams from the TFW program. One is the SAWP program, which is based on bilateral relations with source countries, and those countries manage the recruitment of the workers. Through the SAWP program, for example, they recruit folks who are typically farmers who have experience living in rural communities and have farming skills. They are the ones who are responsible for recruiting and ensuring they have the skills required to do this work.
Senator Muggli: Are you finding gaps with technological advancements and workers who can manage some of the equipment?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: It is an interesting question. I haven’t heard complaints from our side, through our channels, that there is a gap in terms of training and technology. It is an interesting question. It bears further investigation, for sure.
Senator Muggli: Maybe it’s just the $1 million combines in Saskatchewan that I’m thinking about.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Something that I will add, senator, if I can briefly, most of the workers who come here are general labourers, and that is the NOC code specific to those workers, general labour and farm labour. It’s an interesting question that you ask.
Senator Muggli: Ms. Vega Rauda?
Ms. Vega Rauda: I wanted to add that for the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program — I don’t think there has been a lot of technological innovation. It’s still a lot of manual labour. In the agricultural stream, you can see more technology right now in the greenhouses but not with regular farms, which is probably 90% to 95% of the food produced.
For the recruitment process, yes, it’s the governments that participate in the bilateral agreements with Mexico, Jamaica and the Caribbean countries and that have a memorandum of understanding with Canada. The agricultural stream is open to any other country, but the numbers persist mainly from Mexico, with the secondary country being Guatemala, where they mainly have agricultural backgrounds.
Senator Martin: Thank you both. I feel like it’s clear from your presentations that the problem is the system, and the process is the barrier. I’m quoting you, Ms. Vega Rauda, that there is a growing administrative burden on the farmers. I will return to you.
My first question is to our former MP. You were the parliamentary secretary. When you look at the federal workforce policy we have in place and how it’s falling short of meeting the needs of the agriculture sector — we know what we need — are you able to comment? From your experience and what you are doing now with the TeaMWork Project, which is focusing on the experiences of migrant workers, if you could be at the table — your insights are valuable because you have been on the inside and you are working on the ground — what do we need to improve with the current programs and policies that you haven’t already said? Both of you have said quite a lot. I know it’s all being recorded.
If we needed to focus on improving our policies and programs, because you were at that table as the parliamentary secretary, are you able to draw from that and, based on your current experience, comment on the recommendations?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Senator, it is an excellent question. I have to say that having that experience and being able to see things both from a policy and legislative perspective, from a 30,000-foot perspective, and then seeing the experience of migrant workers on the ground provides unique insight.
Unfortunately, at this committee, I’m not authorized to speak about policy recommendations or budget. I’m happy to talk about the migrant worker experience and about the TeaMWork Project to support migrant workers and TFWs in the agricultural space. It is a very interesting question you ask.
Senator Martin: I expected that response, but I was hoping for more because you have that experience under your belt.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes.
Senator Martin: Based on your work with the employees — the migrant workers — what practical changes to training, recruitment or employment conditions could help build a more sustainable domestic agricultural workforce without compromising food production?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: That is an excellent question.
By far, one of the biggest challenges that migrant workers — temporary foreign workers — face is isolation. Many of these workers come to Canada, and they leave their families behind. They come here for eight months out of the year, sometimes for two years straight if they are on the agricultural stream. They don’t have access to transportation. Oftentimes, they are in isolated communities. There are severe language barriers as well, so they are disconnected from the community. They are also disconnected from the services available to them, and they have challenges accessing the rights they do have.
I will give you an example. Every temporary foreign worker who arrives, the moment their feet touch the ground in Ontario, they have the Ontario Health Insurance Plan, or OHIP, coverage, but it’s difficult for them to be able to access medical health care if the nearest clinic is 100 kilometres away and they have no access to transportation and language is a barrier.
Those are the gaps that TeaMWork tries to fill, which is that we try to meet the workers where they are. We try to bring services to the farm or to the bunkhouse, where the workers are. That is one of the biggest challenges.
In Ontario alone, there are 45,000 farms. Many of them are, again, in isolated and rural areas. It’s difficult for us to be able to reach all of the workers at all of the farms and be able to connect them to the services and supports that they require. That is the main challenge for us, especially reaching those workers in those hard-to-reach farms across Ontario.
Senator Martin: There is so much more that I wish to ask.
Ms. Vega Rauda, did you want to expand or say anything further regarding the problem? How do we fix it? What would you like to see, and what can you recommend?
Ms. Vega Rauda: We need more support and cooperation for the authorities that are behind this program. We need more consistent rules from Job Bank, especially more support. We are unable to receive the support we need from Service Canada and Employment and Social Development Canada, or ESDC, clarity on the rules and the protection of the program that has proven that it works. For 60 years, it has been ongoing. We need clarity. We need real support and cooperation from every single entity that is behind this program.
It cannot be possible that we have sometimes spent 10 minutes trying to log in to Job Bank and being unable to access it. It is not possible to sometimes wait six weeks to have one advertisement approved and then be rejected and have to start all over again. As I said, crops don’t wait. We can lose thousands of pounds of food production when we don’t have the labour at the right time. It has happened so many times.
Senator Martin: In the second round, I would like to provide her more time to talk about this lack of clarity. Thank you.
Senator Burey: I have to take a moment to thank former MP Irek Kusmierczyk for being here, formerly from my riding, so I may be a bit biased.
I’m so proud of Workforce WindsorEssex for the tremendous amount of work that you have done. TeaMWork is just a part of Workforce WindsorEssex, but this project should be replicated across Canada because it’s something that touches on — when I hear your passion — the human faces and infrastructure behind food security.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes.
Senator Burey: That is so powerful. I hope to have those words in our report.
Can you comment on how this could be replicated because you have touched on all the various services and the barriers. How can this be replicated because I think that would allow temporary foreign workers to feel welcome and to have a sustainable food security strategy.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Thank you so much, senator, for the warm welcome and the warm words. I really appreciate your support and your invitation to come before this committee.
Certainly, there are about 10 organizations, like Workforce WindsorEssex, that are funded through the federal Migrant Workers Support Program across Canada. These networks of networks do exist across Canada. In total, there are about 100 organizations that have been funded through this Migrant Workers Support Program in a similar fashion by working together, coordinating and leveraging the specialties and the strengths of particular organizations to support temporary foreign workers.
Certainly, there is, obviously, room to grow, for sure, but I want to highlight some of the innovations that come out of these networks and these partnerships that are developed.
Workforce WindsorEssex and the TeaMWork Project partner with consulates — with the Mexican consulate, for example — to participate in joint farm visits. The consulate will invite TeaMWork to join them on farm visits — often in hard-to-reach, rural areas — to provide information sessions, workshops and connect workers to the services and supports that they require.
This was a novel partnership between the Mexican consulate and TeaMWork to be able to deliver those services directly to workers on farm and right in their bunkhouses.
I can tell you that in the last two years that we’ve had this partnership and collaboration, we have had over 60 farm visits reaching over 2,000 migrant workers. Most of those farms were in really hard-to-reach, rural areas where the workers and the farms were really disconnected from those services and those supports.
What you see through the Migrant Workers Support Program is not just collaboration and leveraging the strengths of individual organizations. You are seeing this innovation that is taking root, and we are finding new ways to deliver those supports to workers where they are at.
Senator Burey: Ms. Vega Rauda, would you like to comment on that? Does this sort of network of community resources exist in your organization and in your area?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, I would like to add that in previous years, within our organization, we were more focused on employers and being in compliance with the rules behind the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program.
I would like to mention that, in just the past two years, we have a new president and a new vice-president, and their new mandate is also looking after the workers.
I would like to clarify and add that the former MP, Irek Kusmierczyk, was part of one of our recent operational regional meetings where they were presenting the services they provided. We have been connecting with The Neighbourhood Organization, which is also part of the Migrant Workers Support Program, to try to implement all the services that they provided across all the employers that we service in Ontario and Atlantic Canada.
Senator McBean: I have thoroughly enjoyed the testimony from both of you. You have little nuggets that I think have been really important, like supporting workers and employers is not mutually exclusive, and also that crops, seasons and farmers can’t wait. They don’t wait.
Ms. Vega Rauda, I also get the sense that Foreign Agricultural Resource Management Services is very lucky to have you. You are so passionate about this, and very much like Senator Martin, I feel like we can come to you and say, “Fix it, please,” and you have this clear idea.
I know that’s impossible, but you were saying that regulations are not always clear or consistent for employers. You said this repeatedly.
As all the labour demands evolve, what changes could be made? Where is the stop for you? You are saying that it is everywhere. It is inconsistent, and it is going to the Job Bank. But if you could magically shake up and redo three areas, where do you think you would find your biggest bang for the buck of providing clarity and consistency for the employer to find their workforce?
Ms. Vega Rauda: The Job Bank is number one. There is a lack of training. I’m sorry for what I am going to say because I don’t know how honest I can be in here, but there is no consistency.
I can probably say I feel like the expert in the field, processing LMIAs, and when I receive a rejection, it is like, “What is wrong with this LMIA? This employer has been advertising. What is the problem?”
The magic is probably training and clear and consistent rules. As long as we have it in writing what we are supposed to do and what we are supposed to follow, and somebody is looking after that, there should not be an error and the waiting times being so long to receive those application approvals.
Senator McBean: I want to interrupt because I want to focus you a little bit. Going to whom? Where do you need the consistent rules coming from?
Ms. Vega Rauda: It is going to be Employment and Social Development Canada, because they are in charge of this program, yes.
Senator McBean: Do they have regulations and rules that they are not following, or are they unclear?
Ms. Vega Rauda: They are unclear.
Senator McBean: Could you send us an example of that? That would be great for putting together our report. I get the sense that you could probably —
Senator Sorensen: Send us a book.
Ms. Vega Rauda: A lot. I can tell you quickly that we are in the middle right between employers and the government, and I do not receive the answers. I am supposed to be the person who receives those answers quickly to fix any problem and make it easier for the Job Bank or ESDC, and I do not receive it.
Just imagine an employer with a lack of internet in a rural area trying to make the advertisement several times and not being able to do it, and then just calling me, and I am also not able to give an answer.
Senator McBean: I will give you a little homework if you don’t mind. Don’t make it too long. I don’t want to give you too much homework, but if you could outline to us specifically — and this is the place where you get to tell us exactly the truth of what’s broken. For the system that’s broken, we are here to help. We are here to help you and to help the whole industry be more efficient.
If you could give us some concrete suggestions or examples, I think this committee would really appreciate that.
Senator Muggli: I feel like maybe some of this should be in Bill S-7, the cutting red tape bill.
Ms. Vega Rauda, I want to unpack the LMIA a little bit more because I would really like to know what specifically needs to change with the LMIA process.
You have identified that there are a lot of problems. Are there some ways that you think that that process, in particular, could be repaired?
Are there pieces that should just be cut out that are not efficient? Maybe it is an exception for the agriculture industry — I don’t know — but what are your thoughts?
Ms. Vega Rauda: We were exempted from advertising for the past two or three years, I believe. Then, all of a sudden, we were required. For the Labour Market Impact Assessment, the problem is the portal. The portal is slow. We think this is a technology era, and everything is working well, but it is not. I don’t know if you are familiar with this, but everything that happens at Job Bank feeds the database to Service Canada or the LMIA portal. Whenever they make a change, they do not communicate. Sometimes they do upgrades, and then the system is down and you are unable to process an LMIA. I only found out because I process like 100 LMIAs every day. I have this clear understanding of what is going on — even more sometimes.
Senator Muggli: Did you say that LMIAs used to not be required in the agriculture sector?
Ms. Vega Rauda: They have always been required. Just the advertising side of it.
Senator Muggli: So is that what needs to be changed to ensure we have a reliable workforce in our agriculture sector?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, and dedicated people to be processing LMIAs for the agricultural sector efficiently.
Senator Muggli: Irek, do you have any opinions on that?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Specifically from a migrant worker lens, I don’t have a comment on that. In terms of clarity of the rules, on the flip side, from a migrant worker’s perspective, the issue is clarity or understanding of their rights. One of the challenges we have is a lot of the migrant workers who come here — 35,000 in Ontario alone — many of them don’t have a full understanding of what their rights are. For example, they’ve never filed taxes back home. Many of them are low income. They haven’t filed taxes. They have questions about the CRA. Many of them don’t understand that they have access to WSIB. Many of them don’t understand that they can access parental benefits for EI, for example.
Senator Muggli: Are there documents provided to these workers when they come, in their own language?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: We provide a planner. Every time we have an event, a workshop, an information session, and a farm visit, we give workers a backpack that contains a planner —
Senator Muggli: You do, but does the government give anything to migrant workers in this regard?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, they do. As soon as they arrive at the airport.
Senator Muggli: In their own language?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes.
Senator Muggli: But maybe not so helpful?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: We provide it in their own language. But sometimes when travelling, documents get lost or misplaced. It is never enough to provide that information, remind them what their rights are and connect them to the organizations that would allow them to exercise those rights. Navigating the health care system for us is challenging. Obviously, for somebody who is new to the country who has a language barrier, it is double that.
To build on the point that my colleague made, for the workers, it is the clarity in terms of understanding their rights that is the challenge. That’s where the TeaMWork Project comes in.
Senator Muggli: How are you funded?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: We are funded by ESDC, through the Migrant Workers Support Program. This program began in 2022, and so we’ve been funded for over four and a half years through ESDC.
Senator Muggli: And is it adequate, you can support the workers that you need to and want to?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: I want to stay in my own lane. I would say the TeaMWork Project, the same with organizations operating across Canada, really make an impact. They help workers understand their rights, exercise their rights and help break that spell of isolation that weighs heavily on migrant workers who come here. Even from a mental health perspective, being able to connect them to the community and those services is vital. That’s the work, the mission of the TeaMWork Project.
Senator Martin: Ms. Vega Rauda, perhaps you could send us a written submission. Senator Muggli mentioned Bill S-7. I am the official critic. When is the next process? When is the next bill that will address red-tape reduction? As a committee, we need to focus on what we need to do for the agriculture sector. Ms. Vega Rauda, you might have some good suggestions for us to look at. I would invite you to submit something — the same for you, Mr. Kusmierczyk, just because it is ongoing. We are looking at Bill S-7 now, but there is an ongoing process that is overseen by the Red Tape Reduction Office. We have an opportunity to collect what is needed to clean up the process. You are saying that it is unclear that when changes are made on the Job Bank’s website, it doesn’t necessarily get transferred down to wherever it needs to go. We need to figure out how to simplify and clarify the process. That impacts you and the farmers you are working with.
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes.
Senator Martin: Any response to what I just said?
Ms. Vega Rauda: I would love to send you a statement about that and what would be a good solution. I will put together a few examples for you. We could even do one live just to show you how bad the system is to log into. It is just a shame, honestly, yes.
Senator Martin: Both of you, working with workers and farmers and employers, how essential it is that you and organizations like yours in other provinces are working. Are you coordinated in any way? Are you talking to your counterparts in other provinces to see what is working better for them?
Ms. Vega Rauda: All the time. We have a counterpart for B.C., which is the Western Agriculture Labour Initiative, or WALI, and in Quebec. We probably cover 70% of Canada because it is Ontario and Atlantic Canada. I also work with employers from New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Saskatchewan and Prince Edward Island. Yes, all of them — except B.C. and except Quebec, I attend to everyone else. So even for them —
Senator Martin: You can definitely send us, in writing, what we need to do going forward.
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, it would be —
Senator Martin: — to establish the clarity and predictability that you need and the farmers need.
Ms. Vega Rauda: Correct.
Senator Martin: Thank you so much.
Senator Burey: I wanted to ask Mr. Kusmierczyk about the TeaMWork again. The $3.6-million grant that was given for this project, is that money running out or do you have ongoing funding?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: That’s a very good question. That funding gets renewed on an annual basis. Obviously, we are waiting with bated breath in terms of that, as we do every year. That’s the life of not-for-profits across the country.
To answer the question that Senator Muggli raised as well, the South Essex Community Council is the organization in our network that does a lot of the casework, one-on-one with migrant workers. Every single year, they’ve seen a doubling of cases, of migrant workers walking through their doors asking for assistance, whether it is for EI, work permits or health navigation. You name it. Every single year we’ve seen a doubling of the demand for those services and supports. I think that’s partly a product of the outreach that we’ve done to reach more workers. But as a trusted organization, we’ve built enough trust with migrant workers, they’ve hard about the TeaMWork Project, and they seek us out to get support.
I would say demand grows year in and year out, and we’ve seen a doubling of casework and a doubling of demand each and every year.
Senator Burey: Thank you for that. I wanted to ask a question of Ms. Vega Rauda a question. You talked about worker mobility. As you know, there is a Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology. They released a report on the temporary migrant workforce, called, Act now: Solutions for temporary and migrant labour in Canada that recommended phasing out the work permits that tie work to a single employer. You had mentioned mobility. Can you comment on that for me?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes, of course. That is a very difficult topic to explain. For many months, everybody was talking about that document.
We already have a process in place for the workers to be transferred from one farm to another. So when we talk about labour mobility, we should be very careful because, as my colleague in the panel today explained, it refers to rural areas where there is no transportation and no housing. We can think about open mobility, but where will this worker be? Will he be moving to another employer without housing? Will it be without work all of a sudden?
I believe the problem is mainly through the agricultural stream and not really under the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program, SAWP. There is a lot of support through the consulates and the liaison services. We have a process in place where they are always protected. They know where they are. We have a LMIA in place. We place a transfer LMIA, so we know Employer A from Employer B, and where they are. If they don’t like that, they can always complain to the consulate or the liaison services, and they can go back to Employer A, or they can request to be repatriated to their own country within 7 days, within 96 hours, within the time frame that is specifically in the SAWP contract.
Senator Burey: Could it be strengthened? Could it be one part of the solution to strengthen those bilateral relations — or the memoranda of understanding for the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program? Should that program be strengthened?
Ms. Vega Rauda: Yes.
Senator Burey: Thank you.
Senator McBean: Thank you. I don’t know if it is always right to be thinking of the end product. I am thinking about the report we are trying to put together and how we put things together. There are different things that we are always looking for.
In my background in sport, we would do sessions with athletes before the Olympics, and we would do “what I need” sessions. I was always like, okay, that was just — excuse my language, but that was just a bitching session until you get to, “How am I going to get it?” I think we all want the report to be what Canada needs but also with some good recommendations on how we are going to get it. Sometimes we also need to put in some of the whys.
I came with this question about what trends you are observing in the recruitment, retention and training of workers for agriculture, food processing and related industries. The question was going to be what implications do those trends have for the food system in Canada? But I want to know what implications they have for Windsor-Essex.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Okay. Interesting. If I can answer the question, again, from the perspective of temporary foreign workers and migrant workers —
Senator McBean: Yes, please. You are totally all about the community and the impact on the community.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: There is a trend we are seeing. There are two streams to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program. There is the SAWP stream, the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program, that’s been around for 60 years. There are bilateral agreements with source countries. Through the SAWP, you have a layer of oversight and support that is provided by consulates, for example, and by the ministries of labour of those source countries.
The second stream is the agricultural stream, the two-year program. We are seeing a trend of more workers being recruited from the two-year ag stream program. There is less oversight there because the consulates are not involved. There is less support because of that. The ministry of labour and the consulates of the source countries are not involved, so that layer of additional support is not there.
Also, in terms of how the workers are recruited, through the SAWP, most of the workers are in their 40s, they are married and they have children, so they have a connection back home. They come for a maximum of eight months. Some of them come for two or three months, and then they head home. They are recruited because they are farmers, they come from rural communities, and they have the skills to thrive in this environment.
With the two-year program, the workers are recruited by private companies. Oftentimes, the workers are in their 20s. They don’t always come from rural communities or farming backgrounds, so when they arrive here, they struggle.
There are real challenges there that we see. It has an impact downstream because these workers do struggle. They don’t have as much support, and they find the work and the environment challenging because, again, often they don’t come from farming backgrounds or rural communities.
That is something that I would say we all need to keep an eye on. Especially in the two-year program where organizations like TeaMWork and other organizations are funded through the Migrant Workers Support Program — that’s where the need is greatest, in that two-year program, because, again, less support, less oversight and the way the workers are recruited are fundamentally different from the way that the SAWP workers are recruited. That is an important difference. We are seeing the trend going toward the two-year program in terms of recruiting workers.
Senator McBean: Are there different costs to the employer or just different access?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: There are different costs. For example, there are different costs in terms of housing or travel arrangements.
Senator McBean: Is it more or less expensive for the employer?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: It really does depend on what we are talking about, whether it is housing or, again, transportation to and from the source country. The fundamental challenge is truly the way that the workers are recruited, on what basis, presents challenges, and not just to the workers but to the communities in which those workers live. Again, having that extra layer of support and having that extra structure and infrastructure in place to support the workers do not exist to the same degree in the two-year ag stream program. That’s something worth keeping an eye on.
Senator McBean: Thank you.
Senator Muggli: Mr. Kusmierczyk.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: That was an A-plus.
Senator Muggli: Thank you. I also have a Polish background.
You mentioned that the demand was doubling for support requests from migrants.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes.
Senator Muggli: Are they doubling because you are getting more mistreatment concerns brought forward? What’s the rationale for the numbers doubling?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: From my perspective, I think the workers know that we exist and know that we are a trusted partner. Trust takes time to build. So we are a trusted partner, and word spreads. We also do significant outreach. The seven organizations really hustle. They try to get into the bunkhouses. There is an organization called North Lambton Community Health Centre, and they do about 25 bunkhouse visits to the workers every quarter. They actually go into the bunkhouse and provide information and see how the workers are doing, what their needs are and what they require. So they do the work —
Senator Muggli: Would you be able to say what the top three issues are that you are getting contacted about?
Mr. Kusmierczyk: A lot of workers want to know about their taxes. They are filing taxes for the first time. They want to pay their taxes, but they don’t want to pay more than they have to. They want to know what the deductions are coming off their payroll, for example. They want to understand it better.
Senator Muggli: The number one thing is money.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: It is key. Absolutely. Health care is important. These workers are not attached to a doctor. They don’t have access to a family doctor when they come here. Oftentimes, the distance to a clinic is truly a barrier. Language is a barrier, too. Some have health conditions that, if they had proper treatment, it would prevent them from escalating into an emergency.
That’s one of the things we do really well: We prevent manageable situations from escalating into crises, whether that’s a health care issue, for example, or whether there is friction on the farm. Sometimes there is friction between the supervisor and the worker or between a colleague at work and the worker. We can come in, and we can help to either resolve that issue on the farm directly by speaking with the supervisor.
Alternatively, getting back to the issue of mobility, we could help the worker be moved to another farm, where they could be removed from that unfortunate situation.
Senator Muggli: Maybe it is a myth, or maybe people feel that migrant workers are mistreated by their employers, so I asked the question in order to seek out how true or false that is.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: Yes. The experiences vary. It is the whole spectrum.
I was at a health fair and event organized by Chatham-Kent Community Health Centres at Conagra, and I was speaking to workers who have come from Jamaica for 35, 30, 25 years, and they keep coming back. Some have that positive experience. Some do have a negative experience and encounter abuse or mistreatment on a farm.
Obviously, there are a large number of workers who are somewhere in between. What is critical is we are there for the worker, and they know they have an open door and a trusted partner. We do not wait for them to walk through the door but rather make an effort to meet them where they are, whether it’s on a farm, in bunkhouses or at events to connect with those workers. It is important.
Mobility was raised too. It is an important tool in the toolbox for migrant workers, especially in situations on the farm where there is friction, conflict, worker abuse, or harassment — whether from a supervisor or a colleague.
We can work with that worker to get an open work permit, for example, for vulnerable workers and help that worker move to another farm so they can continue to work and build up that workforce and provide for families back home. That is something that TeaMWork does on a regular basis.
Senator Muggli: On the mobility piece, we had the same issue with the Saskatchewan Immigrant Nominee Program in 2007-08, whatever era. When workers are tied to a specific place and are being mistreated, it makes it difficult.
Mr. Kusmierczyk: It is challenging. This past summer, there were also situations where operations closed, for example. We had that situation in Windsor-Essex. An operation closed, and 55 migrant workers were impacted. They lost their jobs, and many of them were women.
It is harder to find other farms who will take on women migrant workers. One of the biggest challenges is housing infrastructure. There aren’t enough bunkhouses specifically for female migrant workers.
We worked with those workers to help them get work permits, connect with other employers who were willing to offer them a job or had an open LMIA. We were able to transfer some of those workers so they could continue to work and be part of the solution, and also be able to provide for their families back home. TeaMWork also helps with that mobility aspect.
Senator Muggli: Thank you both for your testimony.
The Deputy Chair: On behalf of our entire committee, I wish to thank our witnesses for taking the time to be with us tonight and so fully answering the questions.
I also wish to thank you for the support for the human infrastructure behind food security in Canada.
I wish to thank the committee members for your active participation and thoughtful questions.
I wish to take a moment to thank all of our staff who support the work of this committee: our clerk, Library of Parliament analysts, interpreters, the Debates team transcribing this meeting, the committee room attendant, multimedia services technician, the broadcasting team, the Recording Centre, the Information Services Directorate and, of course, our page.
(The committee adjourned.)