THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLES
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Tuesday, October 20, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples met this day at 9 a.m. [ET] to examine and report on any matters relating to the Indigenous Peoples of Canada.
Senator Michèle Audette (Chair) in the chair.
[English]
The Chair: Welcome.
[Innu-aimun spoken]
Senator Greenwood: What language was just spoken?
The Chair: It was Innu-aimun.
Senator Greenwood: No wonder I didn’t understand it.
The Chair: It is okay. It proves that you are very involved.
Before we proceed with our work today, I would like to take a moment to acknowledge the tragic event that happened this past weekend at the Canadian Forces Base at Wainwright, Alberta, as you know. To our sister and colleague from Alberta, we send love and prayers, of course, for the youths who passed away: Sergeant Morgan Wong, Private Shaun Farrell, Private Aidan Goulding and Private Hayden Lykkemark.
[Translation]
We are sending our love to the families and all those who lost loved ones in this tragedy. Of course, that includes everyone who was injured. We are with you.
We will observe a minute of silence. You may stand or stay seated. In certain nations, it is not considered an insult to stay seated. I invite committee members, witnesses and colleagues to join me in observing a moment of silence.
(Honourable senators then stood in silent tribute.)
Thank you.
Let us now take a deep breath and proceed with the meeting.
I would like to ask all senators and, of course, witnesses to keep in mind the cards on the table, which contain the guidelines to ensure the health and safety of those providing simultaneous interpretation. I call them superstars, because they turn my French into flawless English. Please make sure to keep your earpiece, cellphone, laptop and other such devices away from all microphones. It’s important that we take care of everyone in the Senate family.
[English]
I would also like to ask my colleagues to introduce themselves.
Senator Prosper: Senator Prosper, Nova Scotia, Mi’kma’ki territory.
Senator Pate: Kim Pate. I live here on the unceded, unsurrendered, unreturned territories of the Algonquin Anishinaabeg.
Senator Karetak-Lindell: Nancy Karetak-Lindell, Nunavut.
Senator Clement: Bernadette Clement, the traditional Mohawk territory, Cornwall, Ontario.
Senator Francis: Brian Francis from Epekwitk, Prince Edward Island.
Senator Sorensen: Karen Sorensen, Banff National Park, Alberta, Treaty 7 territory.
Senator Greenwood: Margo Greenwood. I am Cree, originally from Alberta, but I live in and represent British Columbia.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. I will now introduce myself. I am Michèle Audette, an Innu woman from the southeastern part of Nitassinan, which we call [Innu-aimun spoken], Quebec.
Welcome to all of you and to everyone watching on ParlVU.
We are meeting today pursuant to our ongoing order of reference from the Senate, which authorizes the committee to examine a process initiated by the Office of the Indian Registrar revoking registration status from different groups of people.
This morning, we have the pleasure of welcoming to our table, from the Association Tahishpuatenan and Adélaïde Matshiragan Advocacy Group, Jérémie Roussel, President, and Audrey Mayrand, lawyer. Joining them are Guillaume St-Gelais Dubé and Ryan Beaton, lawyer, appearing as individuals.
Thank you for being here. You are from a territory we know by the name of Essipit, which is an eight-hour drive or more away. It’s a privilege to have you with us.
We will start with your comments or opening statements. Then my fellow senators will ask you questions.
Go ahead, Mr. Roussel.
Jérémie Roussel, President, Tahishpuatenan Association and Adélaïde Matshiragan Advocacy Group: Good morning, Madam Chair. Good morning, senators. My name is Jérémie Roussel. Thank you for this opportunity to explain our situation. I appear before you not just as president of the association, but also as a member who is affected.
Tahishpuatenan means “we stand up for our rights” in English.
Every member of the association is a descendant of an Innu woman named Christine Kichera and her daughter Béatrice Tremblay St-Gelais, as in my case. The association was created in 2024, when we realized that hundreds of us had received review letters. Our mission is simple: stand up for our members’ rights and ensure that no one goes through this alone.
In order for you to understand what this letter means for us, I need to explain where I’m from.
I grew up in the town of Les Escoumins, which encompasses the community of Essipit. As a youngster, I often spent weekends with my godfather, who lived in the community. That’s where my friends were from. We grew up together. In my eyes, there was no difference between Les Escoumins and Essipit. It was all the same.
However, I was made to feel different. In school, I wasn’t allowed to learn Innu. I had to do arts and crafts. In daycare, I had two Innu friends. When they would leave to participate in cultural activities with the community, I had to stay behind.
A child doesn’t understand the law. All they know is that they are being left out.
You can imagine, then, how I felt on February 22, 2022, when my status was finally recognized. My family had been waiting for generations. I’d always been told that I was Indigenous.
In 2024, I received the letter calling into question my registration. In one fell swoop, more than 700 people received that same letter. This was not a review of specific cases. It was a block review. Our files weren’t being examined individually. All of us, as a whole, were being called into question.
What’s worse, not everyone received the letter at the same time. Some got it a week or even months later. Others still haven’t received it. This decision affects the identity of hundreds of people, so the way it’s been handled is very concerning, in my view.
We received a second letter, dated November 5, 2025, telling us that our names had been removed from the Indian Register. A number of us already knew, finding out from our pharmacist. In late October, members of our association went to pick up their prescriptions as usual only to have their pharmacist tell them that they would no longer be entitled to coverage as of November 5. Done.
Think about that for a moment: finding out at the pharmacy that you’re losing your rights, from a pharmacist, in front of strangers, even before you’ve been formally notified. Your pharmacist is told before you are, even though you are the first to suffer.
In my case, even my employment has been impacted. I co-own an Indigenous business with two Innu partners. We had big plans to grow the business, including building a large garage. Overnight, we had to put everything on hold. I don’t know whether I’ll still be able to go into the community and work there, if my partners decide that it’s no longer possible, that I have to own the business alone, that I no longer have access to the community, that I’m no longer allowed to keep my property. I’ve even thought about selling my shares. I love my work, but now I have to go into a community where, on paper, I no longer belong.
Our members are going through the same thing I am. Some have lived in the community for decades, and now, they feel like strangers in their own homes. Band council employees had to leave or take months off just to come to terms with the news. People who put their entire savings into building homes in their community could end up having to leave. People who built cottages under Innu leases may have to knock them down or sell them to another Innu.
The worst part is the impact on people’s health. When our drug coverage ended, the RAMQ, Quebec’s public drug insurance plan, hadn’t been notified of the new guideline and wasn’t able to take over the responsibility right away. All that time, no one would cover our drugs. People had to pay out of pocket, but others couldn’t afford to do that. People with health conditions had to go without treatment, not because of the decision itself, but because of the way it was implemented. No one in Canada should have to go without medical treatment.
Today, we know that we aren’t alone in this situation. At least four families, all of whom received recognition under Bill S-3, are in the same boat we are. The government gave us our rights and is now taking them away.
That is why I am here today. I’m not asking for favours. I am asking the government not to make a decision affecting 700 people with the stroke of a pen, when it has not given every person the right to be heard or measured the human cost of the decision beforehand. An administrative block review should not determine something as fundamental as a person’s identity, a matter that should be considered and determined by the courts.
Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Roussel, for that powerful testimony on this federal policy and its impact on individual people and whole communities. Thank you very much.
Ms. Mayrand, the floor is yours.
Audrey Mayrand, lawyer, Association Tahishpuatenan and Adélaïde Matshiragan Advocacy Group: Good morning, honourable senators. My name is Audrey Mayrand. I am a lawyer representing the Association Tahishpuatenan and Adélaïde Matshiragan Advocacy Group. The Adélaïde Matshiragan Advocacy Group is an association of members who are all descendants of Adélaïde Matshiragan, an Innu woman, and who are in the same situation as members descended from Christine Kichera.
My understanding is that you received the brief we prepared for the committee. It includes suggested questions for the Office of the Indian Registrar, as well as a number of appendices.
At this time, I’d like to highlight two elements of a more legal nature.
The first thing that is important to understand is that this isn’t about an incorrect document or fraudulent activity. It’s about the Office of the Indian Registrar changing its mind. Quite simply, the acting registrar seems to have taken a different view than her predecessor regarding the evidentiary value of the General Catalogue of the Montagnais of 1795.
I would like to draw your attention to one issue in particular. If you look at paragraph 25 of our brief, you’ll see an excerpt from the registrar’s letter explaining what appears to be a new burden of proof. The registrar distinguishes between “primary” evidence, mainly government-related documents, band registers and historic petitions to the government, and “secondary” evidence, such as church records and census records collected by missionaries. The registrar indicates that so-called secondary evidence is not sufficient to entitle a person to registration. In our view, this burden of proof is simply incompatible with the objectives of Bill S-3, which sought to establish a favourable burden of proof and remedy historical injustices experienced by Indigenous Peoples.
My second point has already been raised: the Innu of Essipit are not the only ones affected by this new burden of proof. Similar reviews are under way in relation to the descendants of Marie Connolly, an Innu woman from the Mashteuiatsh reserve. Her descendants advised us that they had received a letter, which you’ll find attached to our brief. In addition, descendants of an ancestor of the Mi’kmaq of Gespeg also appear to be the subject of an administrative review.
A document obtained by one of our members through an access to information request reveals a special projects list of files to be reviewed by the registrar. According to the document, up to 1,200 people could be affected by the review projects. The list is heavily redacted, so we do not know whether it is up to date or which families or descendants are affected, but the total number of affected files appears at the end. The list is attached at Appendix L.
In short, the acting registrar seems to be of the view that she can change her mind at any time regarding the sufficiency of the evidence supporting registration and has undertaken an extensive process to revoke the status of hundreds of people. That is extremely worrisome.
We urge the committee to help shed light on this situation and ensure that the objectives of Bill S-3 are met.
Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you very much, Ms. Mayrand.
We will now hear from Mr. Beaton.
Ryan Beaton, lawyer, as an individual: Honourable senators, my name is Ryan Beaton. I am a lawyer and a colleague of Ms. Mayrand’s.
I will say a few words in English before handing things over to Mr. St-Gelais Dubé, who will share some of what he’s experienced as a result of this block review.
[English]
The acting registrar’s block review for status members of Essipit remains shrouded in mystery for the hundreds of individuals and families whose lives have been turned upside down by it. As members of the Senate know very well, it took a long, hard fight to secure the changes in Bill S-3 to finally address the violation of rights that separated many families from their home First Nations communities. Those now caught up in this block review went through the application process following the adoption of Bill S-3. They had all their documents reviewed by the registrar, and they were granted status or, in some cases, were still awaiting decisions on their applications.
Only a few years later, for reasons that remain unclear, the new acting registrar announced a block review process for hundreds of people who had begun making their lives as registered members of Essipit. Perhaps most disturbing, the correspondence from the registrar betrays seemingly fundamental confusion about the legal principles governing status. The correspondence entirely ignores the extensive historical evidence and analysis submitted as part of the review process, which covers several generations of ancestors.
The correspondence largely dismisses what it calls “secondary sources” of evidence, contrary to Bill S-3 itself, and the correspondence dismisses, in baffling terms that speak of not recognizing the lateral transmission of rights, clear evidence that an ancestor’s siblings belonged to the relevant band. That should be considered evidence that the individuals themselves were likely recognized as Indigenous and not be caught up in this confusion about the lateral transmission of rights.
We would be happy to answer any questions committee members may have on these and related topics after Mr. St-Gelais Dubé shares his experience with this situation.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Beaton.
Guillaume St-Gelais Dubé, as an individual: Good morning. I am a descendant of Christine Kichera and her daughter, Béatrice Tremblay St-Gelais, two Innu women from the Tadoussac band, now known as Innu Essipit First Nation.
I have always lived in Les Escoumins. I went to elementary school there and high school in Les Bergeronnes. I had friends who were status Indians and others who weren’t. We all grew up together. We were all the same.
I was raised with Innu values such as respect for the land. I would go fishing, trapping, and hunting and gathering in the woods with my father.
I worked for the council of Essipit when I was young. I was a reserve lifeguard at the Essipit pool. I took care of the ball diamond.
Growing up in Les Escoumins without status was like missing a part of my identity, because deep down, I felt the same and I was the same as them. We all went to the same school, but they took Innu classes and I did not.
Receiving status recognition was a tremendous relief. Finally having my true identity recognized felt like being set free.
Since the age of 18, I’ve been working on sites far from home to save up enough money to realize my dream of building my own home.
In 2023, I obtained my status. I formally applied to the council of Essipit for a piece of land in the community. It felt as though I was making up for lost time being so close to my community. Finally.
I put all my savings into making my dream a reality. I cleared the land myself. I hired a company to do the house framing, and the rest, I did myself.
When the registrar revoked my status along with everyone else’s, it was the first time in my life my belonging to the community had been questioned. I have felt judged since my status was revoked, and I never used to.
The Chair: Take your time. As I said, this space belongs to you.
Mr. St-Gelais Dubé: On December 2, 2025, I got a letter from the council informing me that I had three years to leave or sell my home, but I can’t sell it to anyone except a member of Essipit. Everyone knows I have to sell within three years. No one’s going to give me fair market value for my home. All my savings went into that home.
In an instant, my dream turned sour: the anxiety, the sleepless nights, the questioning. The worrying never stops.
This spring, my partner’s seven-year-old son was told he could no longer attend the Essipit day camp, because I was no longer a member of the community. They told me to go to Les Escoumins, where they told me that I wasn’t a member of Les Escoumins, that I lived in Essipit. My seven-year-old didn’t have a spot at daycare. I had to get angry and make a fuss, and finally we found a place in Essipit.
In the face of my partner’s growing fears, I finally decided not to accept the decision and to pressure the leadership.
My story is one of many. People have been going through things like this every day since they got the letter.
The Chair: I sincerely thank you for being courageous enough to relive this experience. Your humanity has illustrated the human toll of a policy that seeks to dehumanize us. There is no doubt that your emotions resonate with what many are feeling in the face of this injustice. Thank you for your courage. Would you like to take a moment, or is it all right if we proceed to senators’ questions?
Mr. St-Gelais Dubé: That’s fine.
The Chair: [Innu-aimun spoken]
Thank you.
[English]
Senator Prosper: Thank you to all our witnesses for coming before us and sharing their stories. It’s important for parliamentarians and senators, like ourselves, to hear the direct impacts of decisions that have largely been made without your involvement.
Mr. Beaton, you outlined the distinction between primary and secondary evidence that seems to come to the fore from the registrar. You reference the lateral transmission of a right. I hope you can further get into that, but, in addition to that, I’d like to discuss the Gehl decision from the Ontario Court of Appeal, which delved into a finding of “unreasonableness.”
Part of that decision is that, and I’ll read from the briefing note:
. . . the Registrar acknowledged on cross-examination – solely because of their inability to satisfy an unreasonable evidential demand not mandated by the Act.
So there is a principle of reasonableness. Could you further elaborate on that a bit?
Mr. Beaton: Thank you, Senator Prosper.
In fact, since Gehl, we see, in Bill S-3 itself, a statement that all reasonable inferences should be drawn in favour of the applicant, so it is hard to understand the new direction the registrar has taken where they say that they will treat any secondary sources on their own as insufficient and that the only primary sources they recognize are band lists themselves or petitions to the government, which just don’t exist or exist for very few people in some regions of the country and in parts of Quebec. So it would be impossible for those like Mr. St-Gelais Dubé, Mr. Roussel and other members of the association to meet that burden if secondary sources, as the registrar has indicated by letter, are not sufficient on their own. It creates, as we would say, an impossible evidentiary burden of the kind the Court of Appeal for Ontario said in Gehl is not acceptable. It is even less acceptable in light of Bill S-3.
On the lateral transmission of rights, we shared the appendices to our brief with members of the committee. In Appendix K — it is in French, but we understand that it will be translated — there is one particular ancestor where the registrar accepts that her brothers were certainly members of the band in question, and you would think that would be evidence that likely she was as well, but the registrar says in the letter that there is no such thing as lateral transmission of rights between siblings.
Again, we say this is a fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose of the evidence. No one is asking that the right be transmitted laterally from sibling to sibling. They’re just saying, consider the evidence that the siblings are recognized by the registrar as members of a certain First Nation. Surely that’s good evidence that the sister was as well. It’s a very confusing approach to assessing the evidence, and it puts an impossible burden on the applicants, all in the context of a block review, and we don’t know what triggered it. You have people in the situation who have gone through the process of giving the documents, have been assessed by one registrar as sufficient, get registered, remake their lives and, then, for reasons that are extremely unclear, we have this new burden imposed on them, and they have seemingly no opportunity to possibly meet it.
Senator Prosper: Thank you for explaining that, Mr. Beaton. One would think that there would be a bit of dialogue and clarification with respect to a decision of that nature, certainly for those members whose status was revoked. I think there would be numerous reasons for that.
Can you provide any details on the disclosure or the dialogue or the sharing of information further to this from the registrar, or from the federal government, generally?
Mr. Beaton: Members started receiving letters in 2024 saying, “We are questioning your registration status.” One thing that a letter said was, “We have some doubts now about the value of the secondary source, the Catalogue général de toute la nation montagnaise.” The registrar invited further evidence to be submitted, and extensive historical evidence about several generations was submitted to the registrar as part of that as a process. Yet, when they received letters a year later saying, “We have completed the process, and we’re striking you from the registry,” there was no engagement whatsoever. There was simply a repetition that they didn’t think the Catalogue des montagnaise had the value that the previous registrar thought. There was no engagement with the rest of the evidence and no engagement with the other generations addressed. This is, for us, one of the most shocking parts of the process. Why invite a submission of further evidence if you’re not even going to touch on it when you finally strike the people from the role? Further, it was in a block; it was not a case-by-case analysis. It was just a common letter to everyone without any engagement with the evidence that was submitted. I don’t know if my colleague wants to add anything to that. For us, it was a very perplexing process to see how it played out.
Ms. Mayrand: On the question of whether there has been further dialogue, since the status of many members was revoked, and for members who were waiting for a decision, many have since received letters saying that their status applications have been refused. There has been an application made in federal court purely to address the effects during the protest process provided for under the Indian Act to contest the revocations because there are obviously some imminent impacts on members, and the protest process is lengthy. A similar case in Quebec took 12 years.
There is a process happening in federal court to try to provide for transitional measures so that members don’t have to leave the reserve while this is being worked out. The Government of Canada and the Attorney General brought a motion to strike, and we’re awaiting a decision on that at the moment. Those are the latest updates on that.
Mr. Beaton: You can just imagine the turmoil if the protest is successful. These people have to sell their homes and leave the reserve amid all the disruption in the meantime. They might be successful at the end of the protest or on appeal and then would get their status back. The tensions this creates in the community itself are destructive.
Senator Prosper: Thank you.
Senator Pate: Thank you to the witnesses, in particular Mr. Roussel and Mr. St-Gelais Dubé. Thank you for coming to share. I’m very sorry to hear about what is happening in your lives and to your families because it’s emblematic of all of the work that many of us have been trying to do to stop. It’s on us and on this government to rectify this, so, thank you for coming here. I’m sorry you had to come to have this discussion.
I just want to say, on the record, Madam Chair, that many of us have been asking for en bloc reviews of the systemic discrimination experienced by Indigenous Peoples in this country for many years. Those have been refused. It’s particularly enraging to hear that an en bloc process is used to dismiss what is clearly systemic bias. In a moment when sex-based discrimination is being challenged, I can almost guarantee you that the fact that it’s two men here arguing will be trotted out as evidence that this is not sex-based discrimination. But in actual fact, it goes back generations to your grandmothers and great-grandmothers being disenfranchised. The fact that that keeps getting dismissed and obfuscated by the government, I think, is shameful. I just needed to put that on the record.
In addition — these are questions for the lawyers, although I’m happy for anybody to jump in — the Superior Court of Quebec found that Canada’s registration regime perpetuated sex-based discrimination across generations, as we have just identified. Bill S-3 included measures like section 9 that were supposed to address evidentiary barriers to equality for descendants of women. Are the evidentiary requirements now imposed on descendants of the two women you have talked about — Christine Kichera and Adélaïde Matshiragan — effectively creating the same sex-based discrimination that Bill S-3 was intended to eliminate? I think it is. I would like to hear what you think. Can you describe the approach to evidence that is needed to uphold the intention of Bill S-3, and ensure that evidentiary issues do not continue to create discrimination for descendants of women who have married out historically?
Ms. Mayrand: I’ll offer a first response to that. It’s very clear that the evidentiary burden that is being imposed on descendants today is perpetuating gender-based discrimination. The way that we see that is that Tahishpuatenan and Adélaïde Matshiragan were alive in the 1700s. There is ample evidence that their parents were Innu and that their brothers and sisters were Innu, and there is evidence of them living a very Innu way of life. Adélaïde Matshiragan, throughout her lifetime, married three Innu men and between two of those marriages, had children with a non-Indigenous man.
I could go on and on. The conclusion we come to is that, really, it seems as though the burden of proof that is expected is positive proof that, after a woman married a non-Indigenous man, she was still Indigenous. That’s ultimately what it comes down to, because that appears to be the only thing that was missing from the record. If that’s the case, then how are families today able to meet that burden of proof? They can’t.
We have to keep in mind that this is a period of time where the north shore of the St. Lawrence River was not open to colonization. The only people documenting events were priests and fur traders — very few non-Indigenous women, I might point out. So the fact that there is this type of burden being imposed can only have one effect, which is to perpetuate that discrimination.
Mr. Beaton: On that, you might think when the registrar says, “We want to see actual band lists or petitions to the government,” how often would Indigenous women themselves have been the ones to write a petition? Sex-based discrimination, to your point, senator, is pervasive because the type of evidence being asked for is just the kind of evidence you would not find typically for Indigenous women themselves. As my colleague said, it’s just an impossible burden in the circumstances.
Moreover, there was no engagement with the subsequent generation. As my colleague was saying, once there is some indication of Indigenous women partnering with or marrying a non-Indigenous man, the subject seems to be that we don’t even look at the next generations. That’s where it’s cut off unless you can show us she was subsequently on a band list, petitioned the government or in some other form of very high evidentiary burden remained Indigenous after this relationship with a non-Indigenous man.
Senator Pate: If you could both elaborate, I wanted to then pick up on the point that you made, Ms. Mayrand. What other forms of documentation were there at that time that would have existed that would have met a colonial expectation or record? What other records existed at that time that would have been created in that area?
Ms. Mayrand: In that area, the reserve was only created after the deaths of both of these ancestors. So there wouldn’t have been colonial records of band lists kept for that purpose.
The Indian Act bands, as we know them today, were not yet constituted. It was a time when there was only mission activity and fur trading, and there are documents showing that the fathers of Christine Kichera and Adélaïde Matshiragan were on the list of people transacting with the fur trade posts and were indicated in those records as being Innu. The Catalogue de la nation montagnaise is a register that was kept by a priest, which has been recognized by a number of experts, including one who was retained by the Government of Canada in litigation previously and is considered a reliable source.
In the circumstances, I have difficulty seeing what types of primary sources could have been available.
Senator Pate: Just to be crystal clear — I don’t want to put words in your mouth — when it benefits the government, they recognize those records as legitimate, but when it doesn’t benefit them, they do not. Is that what I’m hearing you saying?
Ms. Mayrand: In this situation, yes. There is a reliance on former band lists the government might have after the deaths of the two ancestors and no reliance on records that would reflect their belonging.
Senator Francis: This question is for Mr. Roussel and Mr. St-Gelais Dubé. Beyond the impact of this decision on your overall well-being and that of your family, could you speak about the legal, financial and other barriers involved with leading a case such as this one? Not everyone who finds themselves in your situation has the knowledge or the means to lead this fight. I want you to speak to that point.
Also, I commend you for leading this fight, especially because we do not know how many others in Quebec or across Canada have been affected by these block decisions.
[Translation]
Mr. Roussel: There are many impacts. As I mentioned in my opening statement, there are cottages. Nowadays, building a cottage in the woods can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. These people have invested their own money, money they earned while working. We don’t know how long it will take for them to lose those cottages, since an official decision has yet to be made. They will have to sell to another Innu or redevelop the land in a natural manner, so they will lose all their property.
Then, there’s the issue of medications. It’s not a financial issue, but even today, people stop taking certain types of comfort medication because they can’t afford them.
Finally, from a financial stand point, I think the example of Guillaume St-Gelais Dubé represents the pinnacle of financial loss. He has two years plus a day before he has to leave his house. In exactly two years, an Innu can offer him $50,000, $25,000 or even $10,000 for his house, which might be worth $500,000 today. There are incredible financial impacts, especially since he earned that money through hard work. He didn’t ask to be forced out of his home. Those are the main impacts.
Mr. St-Gelais Dubé: I left home when I was 18 to work on remote sites at the Romaine complex and in Amaruq, Nunavut, to make a living.
I made a $77,000 down payment using the money I earned at the lunch box, I borrowed $232,000 from the Caisse, and then I paid several thousand dollars to the hardware store with my card.
Also, I built my garage at a cost of $45,000. It’s important to know that when a garage isn’t attached to the house, the building costs can’t be financed, because you’re on a reserve, so I used my debit card to pay for it.
And I did all the work: the lawn, the yard. It cost a lot.
I can’t supply all the invoices, because I never thought I would need to. Today, it is certainly worth around $500,000.
Since I can only sell to someone on the reserve, I’ll only get a nominal price. On December 2, 2028, in three years, that’ll be it. That’s the impact.
Mr. Roussel: There are also litigation costs. As of today, we’ve spent at least $400,000 to $500,000 on litigation costs. We did the revision and prepared a historical document to prove lineage. Then, with the help of Mr. Mayrand and Mr. Beaton, we sought a judicial review to reclaim our rights while we wait for the end of the litigation process. The government has decided to try and strike the judicial review, which led to more costs. You have to understand that these are people who work — as Guillaume said — at the lunch box, who deposit their money in the association to defend themselves against the government. It’s not easy. We are talking about hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. It’s hard to manage.
Thank you.
[English]
Senator Francis: You have answered my second question regarding legal fees. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: People listening and watching might not understand the difference between living on and off reserve. Under the Indian Act, at 17, you’re a minor. The department has a land and fiduciary responsibility to us, as if we were the Crown’s children. That is why we can’t be seized, because you can’t seize children. I say that so that Canadians understand the questions being asked and answers being given about homes in the communities.
It is rather ironic that the children of the Crown have to pay lawyers in a context where lawyers are funded by the Crown. I will stop here.
Senator Clement: Good morning. Thank you for joining us. I was in your region this summer, Les Escoumins, Essipit. It’s extraordinary. It’s so beautiful.
Thank you for your remarks this morning. They are very valuable. It’s hard to talk about experiences like that, but it’s worth it.
I’d like to ask you about trust. You are sitting here, Mr. St-Gelais Dubé and Mr. Roussel, with two lawyers who use words like
[English]
— “perplexing” and “shrouded in mystery.”
[Translation]
It’s remarkable. That said, things are not clear. You obviously received this letter. We are in a country where we must build and rebuild trust between us all to move forward. How do you feel about your government? Let’s say you are successful and this issue is resolved, how much confidence will you have in your government going forward?
Mr. Roussel: It’s not easy. I don’t think I believe in the system anymore. You can’t treat a human being this way; it makes no sense. I am a little speechless when I receive insensitive letters telling us that, from one day to the next, it is over. There’s no transition period. There’s no jury to decide who I am. Only one person who works for the government can decide who I am. I don’t know if I still have confidence.
Mr. St-Gelais Dubé: Of course, it’s hard to have confidence when people who don’t know you tell you who you are. Who am I? I don’t know. I don’t know you. Come to my home and you’ll see who I am. An identity is not a piece of paper; it is who you are. It’s hard to trust people who judge you by a piece of paper. Being told who you are. It’s hard to trust the government after having things like that taken away, stripped of everything. How can you trust the people who handle your situation after that? I don’t know if I’m clear enough, but that’s how I feel.
Senator Clement: That’s very well put. You are eloquent. Thank you.
[English]
Senator Prosper: I have a further question for you, Mr. Beaton. I’m not sure if you ever saw the video from Indigenous Services Canada. A major theme of that is “You decide.” They are running this idea that communities decide who should receive status within their respective communities and nations. Is there any evidence of the registrar or Indigenous Services Canada going to the respective communities and nations and saying, “In this particular situation with those persons who had their status revoked, the community should decide whether they should be members or not”?
Mr. Beaton: To my knowledge, in this situation, there is no evidence of that. One of the big questions we have is this: What triggered this? What triggered the block review process? Is there a directive from somewhere? Is it just that a new acting registrar came in, and they decided they had a different approach to evidence? Can they reopen anyone’s registration status at any time of their volition? What is it that triggers this?
To my knowledge, no, the registrar never did. I don’t think anyone in the community is aware of the registrar asking those questions. If they did, we would like to hear from the registrar. Is that what happened? In any case, we have no answers to that. We would like to know what triggers this process within the office of the registrar.
Senator Prosper: I have a further question: Regarding your correspondence to me and your reference to the general catalogue of the Montagnais people, in 1785, it was not, according to the registrar, found to be a reliable primary source of evidence when, in fact, Ms. Mayrand, you mentioned that this particular source has been subject to litigation, and it was found to be a credible source of documentation. Am I correct on that?
Ms. Mayrand: Experts have studied this source and have used it in historical texts, and one of those experts who relies on the Catalogue de la nation montagnaise was also an expert for the Government of Canada in a case regarding the Innue Essipit. I’m not sure whether, in that case, the catalogue was considered, so I don’t know if I can go that far. Suffice to say that this is a record that recognized historians consider to be reliable and accurate — as accurate as anything from this time period can be — and that the missionary who prepared it was a reliable and fastidious person in recording names.
Just to be clear, what we understand from the correspondence of the registrar about this distinction between primary and secondary sources is that there is a list of primary sources, which includes band lists, band registers, adding or removing persons from the reserve, historical petitions to the Government of Canada by individuals interested in the land and correspondence between the government at the time and individuals where it is evident that the person is Indian. That’s it. The list of secondary sources that is indicated in the letter includes census records, church records, family histories and genealogical reports and any documents that suggest that a person was Indian.
That, to me, is a very concerning division. It sounds like there is an exclusion off the bat of a whole host of sources that may be, in fact, very reliable and useful.
Mr. Beaton: Not only, in the litigation, did the government’s own expert find the catalogue reliable, but also it seems the previous registrar did as well. Part of the basis for granting the applications of these hundreds of individuals was that they had provided the evidence. So, again, if the next acting registrar comes in and takes a different approach, should everyone who is on the register be worried that, on any given day, a new registrar or maybe the same registrar later in their term could decide they are going to review this regislation?
Senator Greenwood: Thank you to the witnesses for being here today. It’s very informative. I had a couple of comments I wanted to make, then a thought came to me. As I was listening to the testimony, I was curious about who is actually implementing this on the ground. You received a letter, but I heard in the testimony about the real life impact of that. Who actually implements that? Is it the community itself? What is the role of the federal government in that? I think it’s difficult for people in the actual implementation.
It’s clear that there has been an uneven application of uneven laws since the beginning of time. Clearly, we’re seeing that again now. We have one registrar of one opinion and another registrar of another opinion, and that plays out in what is accepted and what is not accepted as credible evidence, as I understand what you’re saying to me.
What my question is this: Are there to be pieces of legislation in Canada beyond this — that is, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Article 9 and Article 33 in particular — that speak to membership and the right of Indigenous Peoples to have their own membership and their own codes to determine that?
There is also the concept of reconciliation that has clearly been brought forward in this country, and we have taken steps toward that. Can those pieces and ideas also be useful to you in your arguments for membership?
Mr. Beaton: Regarding the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, of course, we recognize that the Indian Act defines who receives status, and that has to be administered, but to the question of how you go about that, if you are going to trigger or undertake this process of a block review, there should be some communication about where this is coming from, what has triggered it and what community and individual engagement you’ve had, both before you started this and throughout the process. It just didn’t happen here. At a minimum, the UN declaration and the principle of reconciliation should inform how you go about this process. As Mr. Roussel said, some of the hardest impacts of this are not even about the underlying decision. They are about how it was implemented and the shock that it created.
Ms. Mayrand: This is a community that has, for the moment, chosen not to adopt its own membership code, and their membership is still managed by the registrar. That is the choice they are making for the time being. I agree that the ultimate goal is for communities to have real control over these decisions. But in the meantime, how is the Government of Canada handling its remaining role in membership? Is it doing it in a way that is consistent with values of reconciliation? Is it being respectful of the history behind these provisions and the lived experiences of people who are affected by its decisions?
That’s the real question. How does the government choose to fulfill that role that is still there for the time being? It should be done, in our view, in a way that applies a standard of proof that enables us to truly remedy the gender-based discrimination that Bill S-3 was meant to remedy.
Senator Greenwood: I have a quick follow-up. It comes down to a fundamental question for both the community and the government about what constitutes evidence. I say that because evidence to the community is often not accepted as evidence by the federal government. It is just a comment.
Senator McCallum: I am sorry I was late. I am from a senator from Manitoba, Treaty 10 territory. I want to go into the legality of oral history, which carries the history of the people before contact and even into contact. You said the reserve was created after the woman had passed on. So it was unceded territory with customary law that was in application at that time.
When you look at the oral history — the strength of it — versus the lack of documentation, has anyone addressed that? Are there court cases that have looked at that?
Ms. Mayrand: Increasingly, case law is giving value to oral history evidence, and they are developing techniques for judges to take oral history into account. The registration process has not kept up with that. We see that in the disconnect between what you heard today from, for example, Mr. Roussel, who, as an intergenerational matter, has known that his family was Indigenous, and that they were just not recognized by law, and the decision being made by the registrar. But I have to say, this is not even a case where there is a lack of documentation; this is a case where there is a debate about the values of certain types of sources.
Senator McCallum: So you actually have both then: oral history and documentation?
Ms. Mayrand: We certainly have family remembrance, yes.
Senator McCallum: You know what? When I look at my history, I would take oral history over anything. That’s in us. It is in our language. That’s why you say, “Who are your ancestors? Who are your parents?”
What if there were a private member’s bill, or PMB to amend the Indian Act that would go back to the original form of membership that occurred with adoption? There were four criteria before the Indian Act that determined who our people were. There was adoption of people from outside. There were three of them, and it was a one-parent rule at that time. That still occurs. If a PMB were tabled, would that help your situation? It may not pass, but it’s a challenge to the government saying, “We need to deal with this issue.”
Mr. Beaton: We already see elements in the amendments to the Indian Act after Gehl v. Canada and in Bill S-3 — not going into oral history, which might be an important extra piece — requiring that the registrar consider all credible evidence and draw all reasonable inferences in favour of the applicant.
Certainly, a bill that went further, making that even clearer, might be necessary in light of what is happening, but what is already there should be sufficient. For reference, paragraph 25 of the brief we submitted reproduces what the registrar has said is acceptable primary source evidence, and it is so limited, essentially throwing away census and church records as well as family history, which could be recorded forms of oral history, genealogical reports or any documents suggesting that the person was a member of an Indian tribe or people at the time. All of that is classified as secondary, and all of it on its own is insufficient to establish entitlement to registration.
You would think that what is already in Bill S-3 and the Indian Act is sufficient to require consideration of this evidence, but maybe a further bill is necessary to make it even clearer that what the registrar is doing in this form of review is not acceptable.
Ms. Mayrand: I would add briefly that we think the Indian Act and the changes already in Bill S-3 are already clear that the burden of proof should be favourable to applicants and also that the effects of Indian status are meant to stay in place until such time as a final decision is made on a protest. But at the moment, the registrar has taken the position — as you’ve seen — that the burden of proof is different than what we have suggested to you and has also taken the position that, as soon as the registrar changes their opinion under section 5 of the Indian Act, the effects are immediate.
As I said, we take issue with that interpretation of the Indian Act, but if there was a private member’s bill that had clarifying language or express language to make clear that the effects of Indian status can’t be removed until such time that a final decision is made at the end of all the appeals process, that might be helpful.
[Translation]
The Chair: This discussion is very important and interesting. However, we have to stop here out of respect for our next panel.
On behalf of my colleagues, [Innu-aimun spoken], thank you for coming to this space where we have the opportunity to make recommendations on federal government policies. I think we are doing our work properly, respectfully. Thank you very much.
We will continue this meeting with our second panel. We are pleased to welcome, from Indigenous Services Canada, Lori Doran, Director General, Individual Affairs Branch; and Claire Thie, Indian Registrar.
[English]
Welcome and thank you for being here with us at APPA.
[Translation]
You have some time for your opening remarks.
[English]
Afterward, we will have a round table — even though it’s not that round — with questions and answers. You come here often, so you know how it goes. Thank you for coming. You may begin.
[Translation]
Lori Doran, Director General, Individual Affairs Branch, Indigenous Services Canada: Thank you very much.
[English]
Good morning, honourable senators. I begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the traditional, unceded territory of the Algonquin people. I want to acknowledge the testimony of witnesses in the first panel and the impacts of this process. It is clear that we need to move to a future where First Nations decide who their members are.
As mentioned, I am Lori Doran, Director General of the Individual Affairs Branch, Indigenous Services Canada. I am with Claire Thie, the Indian Registrar, the legislated official responsible for upholding sections 5 through 14 of the Indian Act.
Registration is not automatic. It is voluntary through application. Given the volume of applications received each year — almost 40,000 in 2025 — the registrar relies on delegated entitlement officers to render decisions on their behalf through a devolved authority. Ultimately, the registrar is responsible for all decisions made by anyone using their authority.
While processing applications for registration in a timely fashion is an important and much discussed aspect of registration under the act, the registrar has another legislated responsibility: keeping the Indian Register accurate. Subsection 5(3) of the act is both the provision that provides the power and ability of the registrar to add or delete names from the register while maintaining its integrity and accuracy.
[Translation]
The duty to add or remove names based on whether or not one is entitled means the Registrar must both register those who are entitled, and remove registration from those who are not.
This provision requires the accuracy and integrity of the Indian Register to be held paramount. Beyond the Registrar’s legal duty to ensure its integrity, the Register serves as a foundational source of information used by federal departments, provinces and territories to assess eligibility for various 78programs, services and benefits.
The department does not determine whether an individual is First Nations. Registration decisions are limited to determining entitlement under section 6 of the Indian Act and are not determinations of identity.
[English]
As applications are processed, new information may emerge that affects previous registration decisions. The registrar is required to assess this information and make any necessary corrections. These corrections may involve changes to a registration category, band affiliation or, in some cases, a determination that an individual is not entitled to registration.
An error involving one ancestor can affect many descendants or a family cluster, as entitlement is based on the degree of descent from ancestors who are registered or entitled to be registered. Since entitlement may vary among family members, each affected individual must be reviewed separately to determine the correct registration status. I will attest that the registrar does not administer removals as a block.
The registrar’s obligation under the Indian Act is to ensure that decisions are accurate and supported by the available evidence.
[Translation]
The integrity of the Indian Register is essential to ensuring that registration decisions are accurate and that programs, benefits, rights and services are provided to eligible individuals in accordance with legislative and policy requirements.
The department has strengthened training, quality assurance and oversight measures to support accurate registration decisions and reduce the risk of errors. It continues to improve its processes and controls while maintaining its commitment to service standards.
[English]
These situations can be complex and require careful review. Before decisions are finalized, affected individuals are provided tailored notice, an explanation of the information relied upon and an opportunity to submit additional evidence. Evidence is also reviewed for possible entitlement from other branches of the family tree. Individuals who disagree with a decision have recourse under the Indian Act, including protest and appeal mechanisms.
In closing, I would like to reiterate the department’s commitment to advancing First Nations self-determination and moving beyond the Indian Act. Ensuring the accuracy and integrity of the Indian Register is a significant part of that work. The register represents a critical foundation for future membership, citizenship and governance decisions led by First Nations themselves. The department remains committed to maintaining that integrity while working in partnership with First Nations toward a future in which they exercise control over these matters.
Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you very much, Ms. Doran.
Ms. Thie does not have an opening statement, but senators can ask questions to both Ms. Doran and the registrar.
Senator Pate: Thank you to our witnesses for being here. I notice, Ms. Doran, that you said that First Nations should decide who their members are. There has been a lot of discussion by the minister and others recently about conflating status and membership in a way that is very unhelpful.
What steps is the department taking to disentangle that conflation? As you know, the Indian Act was put in place, and part of its objective, as a result of sex-based discrimination in particular, was to extinguish the rights of First Nations in this country.
Status is a legal determination. The legislation is designed to end discrimination. How communities then decide who becomes part of their community is very much up to them.
How would you define that to make sure that this conflation is removed? What is the department doing to address that issue?
Ms. Doran: Thank you for the question. Under the act currently, there are two provisions for membership: sections 10 and 11. Section 10 is an option for nations whereby they determine their own membership based on a code they themselves develop. In instances where an individual applies for registration and is affiliated to a section 10 band, they need to apply for membership in that band; whereas with section 11, the Indian Registrar automatically adds people to the band list.
We are trying to find ways to make section 10 more attainable to nations so that, while we’re working to move outside the Indian Act to a place where First Nations fully determine their citizens and members, under the Indian Act, there is a provision for some greater flexibility over membership.
Senator Pate: Sorry, perhaps I wasn’t clear. I am asking what the department is doing to end the conflation that the minister’s words have actually created in the minds of many folks. It is actually not accurate that membership equals status. If you need to send us something in writing, I would appreciate that because what we need is a clear delineation of how you are disentangling the legally incorrect information that is currently being put out.
Secondly, I would like to know what the evidentiary basis was for the decision to take the 700 people off the rolls that we just heard about. I know you were here for the first panel. It is clear that, in some cases, that kind of evidence is accepted. We now have more than 20 years of jurisprudence accepting oral history, and we thank Senator McCallum for putting that on the record. What is the basis for first accepting one piece of information and then discrediting it at a time when there were no other forms of colonial documentation?
Claire Thie, Indian Registrar, Indigenous Services Canada: Thank you for the question. Through the Indian Act, I am bound by law. The first iteration and definition of an Indian was established in 1850, so generally, our view and policy have been that we don’t go beyond 1850. We did a very in-depth review of the evidence that was provided. We became aware when somebody wrote in through correspondence. So then when we reviewed the file, we noted that there was very limited evidence.
Senator Pate: Could you provide that documentation about what evidence was written in to you? It’s very important that the committee has it on the record. Thank you.
Senator Prosper: Thank you to our witnesses. Ms. Doran, it is good to see you again. You mentioned earlier in your testimony that one of the central features of the register is accuracy and ensuring that there is careful review before decisions are formalized. You also mentioned that, at times, new information may emerge that might affect previous decisions. I would imagine, through careful review, when entitlement was initially granted for many of these individuals, whom we’ve heard from in earlier testimony, that something new emerged from the evidence.
Can you highlight specifically what new evidence emerged? Is it a new document, or is it a new interpretation of a similar document that was previously provided? Could you provide further clarity on that?
Ms. Doran: I will start, and then I will turn it to Claire. The review started as a result of an applicant calling in asking about the status of their own application. Through the course of reviewing and preparing a response to that applicant, the source evidence was called into question.
The individual who made the initial entitlement decision had training to exercise or devolve administrative authority but ought to have escalated this particular application to the office of the registrar for the registrar to get involved directly to determine whether this evidence was sufficient for entitlement. That’s really where this started. Once this application was called into question, because of the link in entitlement among family members, the family, as a whole, was required to be reviewed.
Ms. Thie: We don’t work in silos. We have a strong team of genealogists, researchers as well as subject matter experts. We don’t take these decisions lightly. We worked on this family for a year before we notified individuals. We were unable to find any additional primary solid evidence that would help us ensure that the registration was sufficient under the Indian Act.
Senator Prosper: Thank you for that. To follow up on what you just mentioned there, Ms. Thie, you mentioned that you couldn’t find any additional, solid primary evidence. We heard in previous testimony that if one were to look for additional, solid primary evidence, it would basically impose an impossible burden on individuals such as those who were before us today. There is a principle in law where, in the absence of compelling definitive information, that you would go with the best available evidence. Is there a principle within your department where you would go with the best available evidence in light of the inability of these clients to meet what is deemed to be an impossible burden?
Ms. Thie: Thank you for the question. I would like to come back to that and provide it in writing.
Ms. Doran: I might, though, add that this is exactly the practice that we apply in unknown, unstated paternity under the Gehl decision. We do consider evidence with the balance of probabilities in favour of the applicant.
Senator Prosper: Was it a finding through a balance of probability, more likely than not, considering the evidence that was before you?
Ms. Doran: In this situation, the evidence was reviewed. As Ms. Thie mentioned, with other experts involved, the determination was that it was insufficient to affirm entitlement. No additional information came forward. I would add that, when individuals were first notified, there was an offer for additional information to come forward. A full 120 days were provided, and it was extended a number of times. The additional information that came forward was reviewed and was determined insufficient to support the entitlement.
The Chair: You don’t need to respond to this question now; it can be in a written response. Does the definition of “expert” also include Elders, people from the community or from the territory, family members affected, those who received the letter or who received a second letter? Was that expertise considered, and was it a part of the decision? You can respond in writing.
Senator Sorensen: My question is for Ms. Thie. I appreciate both the explanations on what happened. As the lawyers were saying, we don’t know why this even happened. We heard that. I’m not sure why that would be the first time it would have been explained to the community or to the lawyers, but thank you for that answer.
Ms. Thie, I want to say to you that this is hard testimony to hear. What would you say to those who just testified about the process: the block review, being notified by letter, health benefits being cut off and people’s lives being turned upside down with immediate, severe consequences to these lives?
I wouldn’t know what to say. What would you say to the testimony you heard today?
Ms. Thie: Exactly. I don’t know what to say, but I have an obligation. I have a duty. I have no choice but to make corrective actions when they are brought to my attention. It may sound cold. It may sound unsympathetic, which I’m not. That’s the reality of working in this role.
Senator McCallum: Why did the registrar not provide any response to the evidence relating to descendants of Christine Kichera and Adélaïde Matshiragan that evidence goes well beyond 1850 and into the 1900s?
Ms. Thie: I’m not sure I follow the question.
Senator McCallum: Did the registrar provide a response to evidence relating beyond 1850?
Ms. Thie: Yes, we communicated with them. We had several communications with the First Nations of Innus Essipit. We also communicated via letter. We sent three letters, and then, any time an individual who was impacted wrote in, we provided details.
Senator McCallum: Thank you. I want to go back to Ms. Doran’s statement. You said that registration refers to entitlement and not determination of identity.
A gap exists there. With that gap, people have been told that they have to leave. They live peaceably on their land, where their ancestors have lived since pre-contact. How can they be expected to leave their homes and lands?
If you do not have a determination of identity, then they have the right to remain there beyond the time when they are told to leave. People have the right to remain there.
Ms. Doran: Yes, l would agree. That would be for the nation to determine. The nation would determine membership rights and entitlements beyond a decision made about entitlement under the Indian Act. I understand the two work together in many instances, in particular, for nations that are under section 11 of the Indian Act. That is why we really want to lower the barriers for nations to move into section 10 of the Indian Act, while we work to move beyond the Indian Act to a future where First Nations determine citizens and members.
Senator McCallum: Can you talk about that gap where you’re registering but it’s not identity? I don’t understand that.
Ms. Doran: Ms. Thie can explain this in more detail. Right now, we’re bound to assess an application for registration under the terms and conditions of the Indian Act and the law. There are people who have Indigenous ancestry who don’t meet the criteria for entitlement of registration under the Indian Act. We’re not questioning their Indigenous identity. It is simply that, the way the law is written right now, they are not entitled to registration under the Indian Act.
That is an issue. For many, registration under the Indian Act is an important confirmation of their Indigenous identity; we understand that. But the Indian Act registration process is really about assessing an application based on the terms and conditions of that law.
The Chair: If I may, Ms. Doran, we heard that earlier. We have other senators, but I have a yes-or-no question quickly.
Is it written in the Indian Act that you do consider the Catalogue général des Montagnais? Yes or no? It is not written in the Indian Act, to my understanding.
Ms. Doran: The secondary evidence, because it’s broad, isn’t described in detail, but it would be considered under protest or appeal.
The Chair: Then it’s a policy; it’s not the Indian Act.
Senator Greenwood: Thank you to the witnesses on this panel. I ask you to do this in writing for me just because the answers are thoughtful and could take long. Forgive me if I’m being naive, but I really want to understand the difference between entitlement and registration.
Now, I can read that in the act itself, but I want to understand as it’s implemented and as you use it in your decision-making.
You have talked about this, but I really want to understand the level of evidence required for each of these. You’re saying you need “this kind of evidence” for this. We’re hearing alot of talk about evidence, but what are you accepting for this? What are you not accepting? We have some picture of that, but I would like to understand that and see that in writing, if I could, please. It may be useful to others who want to apply so that they are not wasting your time and others’ time.
You mentioned in your opening remarks that you take the law from 1850. That’s your base place. Do you think that should be changed? Do you think that should be thought about in a more contemporary way, other than to use section 10 saying, “First Nations, you take on your own registration”?
What could you do? Do you think that would be important? I ask because we’re not living in 1850. It’s 2026. What would look different? There may be nations who do not want to take over that. What would look different and be more reasonable in 2026?
Can you give that some thought? I would like all of these answers in writing.
People can be registered but not access programs. Did I understand that correctly?
Ms. Doran: Registration provides eligibility and access to many programs, services and benefits. However, it’s a voluntary action, so people can be registered and choose not to access non-insured health benefits or other programs and services. But it certainly offers them eligibility, so it’s a personal choice.
It depends on the policy or the legislative requirement to access programs, services and benefits: from border crossing to tax exemptions to non-insured health benefits.
Senator Greenwood: Thank you.
The Chair: I know you are both bound by the Indian Act. Following the Indian Act is something, but things are still happening in the community. For example, if there is a young girl who is 9 or 11 years old, but Bill C-31 or Bill C-85 are being used by men and women saying, “You’re not Indian. You should be out. You’re going to steal the jobs.” That girl is now the woman in front of you today.
So what do you do when leaders or people tell you how they feel but maybe didn’t mention that they are also facing racism in the communities and from the people. The law is the law, but the social human impact is huge.
How do you bring partners together across your ministry to ensure that when you bring this answer, there is an answer at the same time that is trauma-informed and ensures that the impact is not only legal but also addresses how to survive this violence?
That is my first question.
Do you speak to the leadership and the band office, saying, “Oh, by the way, you’ll have 700 more new members”? What was the process of telling the Essipit government and other affected communities? What are the social and economic aspects of supporting the leadership to ensure that they are citizens? They are people. They are human beings. So, that is my second question.
Of course, if we don’t have enough time, we will invite you again because it’s very important. I would like a written response also. Please answer in a few seconds if you can.
Ms. Doran: Sure. We recognize the impacts, and it’s heartbreaking to hear about them. We did what we could with what we had to mitigate some of the immediate impacts, for example, on non-insured health benefits.
The reason we gave pharmacists and other health providers a bit of advance notice was so they could potentially refill medications or order supplies in advance while the individual was still entitled as a mitigation to being eventually non-eligible.
We also worked closely with the regional office, which has a close relationship with the leadership of the nation, to offer open communication and supports, to the degree we could, to assist them through this difficult process.
We did what we could. There could be more. We acknowledge that. A removal of this size is very rare. We have never done a removal of a family cluster this large.
Since 2010, the removals have been roughly 1,400 people, which are a few per year. This is an exceptional situation, and with it comes great impacts, which we acknowledge.
As a regular measure, when individuals are added to the register under section 11 — a nation under section 11 — regular updates are provided to the band so that they know. They shouldn’t be surprised to learn of people being added to their membership list.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much, director.
[English]
Senator Clement: Good morning.
[Translation]
I didn’t understand your answer to Senator Sorensen’s question. Maybe I did, in the sense that the Indian Act is there to always cause harm and you’re caught up in it.
[English]
You have described this as being an exceptional circumstance. According to the way you described the process, though, this could easily happen again. Do you expect this to happen again? When? Communities need to get ready to get lawyers ready. The only thing the government seems to understand is being taken to court. Can you comment?
Ms. Doran: Removals are a measure of absolute last resort. I’ll make that point clear. We really did take time and offered an opportunity for additional evidence to come forward before a decision was made.
There is not a systematic review of files to find errors or possible places where corrections need to be made. They come about through the normal course of assessing applications. Since applications for registration are assessed based on ancestral ties, new information for one individual could impact what we have on file for other individuals. As Ms. Thie mentioned, when issues come to her attention, under the law, she does have an obligation to review those situations.
Ms. Thie: As Ms. Doran mentioned, I don’t have a choice when corrective measures come to my attention. We don’t take them lightly. As I mentioned, we did take a year to do the review before reaching out to obtain any additional evidence that we couldn’t find, and unfortunately, we just were not provided what we were looking for.
Senator Clement: Do you expect to have more corrective measures and to do this again?
Ms. Doran: We don’t expect it. We don’t have a plan. As I mentioned, corrective measures can be a removal, as a measure of last resort. Most commonly, they are corrections to band affiliation or corrections to the category under which an individual is registered, so there are different types of corrections. Removals are a measure of last resort. There is not a systematic process to look for these situations.
[Translation]
Senator Clement: Thank you.
The Chair: I’m trying to remember a term you used. It starts with “ancestral.”
[English]
Ms. Doran: Ancestral ties.
The Chair: Ancestral ties, which is the case we have here: brothers of the same family. Thank you.
Senator Pate: I’m happy to have my answers in writing if that would help.
First of all, thank you, Ms. Doran. You said the way the law is written right now is part of what is limiting you. I can’t think of a better reason for this committee, and hopefully the government, to consider the amendments we made to Bill S-2 as part of the very reason those amendments need to persist and why we need the one-parent rule; and how it complies with the government’s own decision with Bill C-3 to allow Canadians, where one parent has children born outside the country to have those children registered as Canadian citizens able to pass down citizenship. So it would bring us into compliance if that Bill S-2 amendment was accepted. That’s more of a comment.
Ms. Thie, could you provide details as to what information the registrar considered in terms of the collective consequence of the decision to revoke the status of 700 members of the Innu First Nation of Essipit, which represents approximately a third of the community? Could you provide in writing the assessment that was done?
Also, what consultations and what assessments did you make with respect to the cancellation of statuses and how that impacted the honour of the Crown? There is the Indian Act, but there are also the prior responsibility and honour of the Crown that need to be acknowledged. If you could provide all of that in writing, that would be very helpful. Thank you.
Senator Prosper: Please feel free to respond in writing.
I want to go back to the definitive test of the balance of probabilities, which is the standard by which status is determined. As I understand it, there are primary sources and secondary sources that you rely on. Secondary may not be as persuasive, but they are there; they are sources of evidence.
In the Gehl decision, there appears to be a certain standard of reasonableness that should be followed when one looks at the totality of the evidence.
We have heard from testimony earlier that, in order to meet some of the primary areas that you require, it’s imposing an impossible evidentiary burden on these individuals.
There are specifics with respect to the descendants of Marie Connally where her brothers were found to have status, but she wasn’t. There is this presumption or suggestion that there isn’t a lateral transmission of status through sibling relationships and that it has to be a transmission of a parent, like a mother.
Do you not consider that evidence of status with the two brothers to affect what the balance of probabilities might be for the clients who have had their status revoked on the basis of the difference between Marie and her brothers?
Ms. Thie: In this particular situation, the brothers were found on Treaty pay lists or on a pay list. There were other siblings who weren’t. We did a deep dive into their parents, and we were unable to find any substantial evidence to suggest that they were part of the band.
Senator Prosper: So you couldn’t find evidence that she didn’t have the same parents as her brothers. Am I correct about that?
Ms. Thie: We found evidence that, more likely than not, the brothers married into the community.
Senator Prosper: Into which community? Is it an established community — a recognized band?
Ms. Thie: Yes.
Senator Prosper: Okay. But she still has the same blood, correct? Does she not? Does she have the same parents? Shouldn’t it flow that she has the same entitlement?
Ms. Thie: If we were able to find evidence regarding her parents, yes. Again, that was another situation where we spent a solid six, seven or eight months reviewing and looking for evidence.
Senator Prosper: You found evidence to the contrary, that she wasn’t —
Ms. Thie: We were unable to find evidence —
Senator Prosper: — to the contrary? Okay.
The Chair: After a huge, national inquiry into missing and murdered Indigenous women, there is legislation in Quebec for children who never came back after a hospitalization. There are 300 kids now that the spirit can go back. In those days, they called our parents “savages” on the birth certificate or documents. We didn’t choose that. So, I hope that part is considered. This is why the definition of “expert” lies with people who know our history and Oral Traditions. I’m anxious to read the definition of an expert, and maybe the inquiry can support what an expert is.
Senator McCallum: I want to put into evidence the inconsistent application of the one-parent rule when you look at the Métis, Inuit and First Nations who are lumped into that group. Métis and Inuit are allowed the one-parent rule. Is that Charter compliant? How do you work with that in the work that you do?
You can put this in writing. I wanted to go to the people who have lost their benefits. You essentially moved this group of people into the non-status group; non-status people are also covered under the Indian Act. What are the benefits that they have? How have you looked at the non-status people and the benefits that they have so that you can apply it to them because they are still First Nations people? How did you determine that?
Ms. Doran: For the non-insured health benefits program and eligibility for First Nations, there is a requirement that you are registered under the Indian Act. So non-insured health benefits are not available to non-status or Métis individuals. Inuit have their own rules for determining eligibility. I just wanted to make that point clear for the record.
Non-insured health benefits were the area of most concern going forward with this process. In my earlier comment, we did do what we could to mitigate those harms. We did have evidence that about a third of the individuals who were removed had other health benefit insurance because we had evidence of them coordinating benefits. We did offer support by having benefits available through other providers. But it still had an impact, most definitely. But there are different rules for eligibility for that program.
Senator McCallum: I’ll have a written answer, please. Could you let us know, when you move people to non-status, how are you going to determine that they are eligible for non-insured health benefits and that they are eligible for other benefits? They are under the role of the government; they are still under their protection. Could you put that in writing? Thank you.
The Chair: Ladies, I have to acknowledge that you carry a system, but you are still here. I want to say thank you. Can we have five minutes more of your time? There is one more question and we will close after that question. You’re allowed to say no. It’s okay? Thank you.
Senator Pate: Thank you again. We recognize you are making decisions that are not always ones that you might make if you had your own ability to make a decision that is not based on the policy you’re given by the government.
I want to come back to the question that Senator Prosper asked. I became confused. It may be because I’m not Indigenous, and I’m just not understanding.
My understanding is that men can’t marry into First Nations. You mentioned that the two brothers may have become members of the band. Could you provide in writing that documentation, all of the evidence about that, that you base that decision on. Maybe it’s just me who is confused about how that could happen, but to my knowledge, that’s not possible under the Indian Act. Given that you are governed by the Indian Act, could you provide all of the evidence about how that happened? If you could provide any other evidence that I personally have not had the wit to ask for regarding how you came to this decision in addition to the other questions we’ve asked, that would be helpful. Thank you.
The Chair: Do you want to say a few words to conclude?
Ms. Doran: Thank you for the questions. Thank you to the witnesses from the first panel. It’s a heavy subject. It’s a lot to consider. Clearly, the solution here is to move beyond the Indian Act to a future where First Nations determine who their members are.
Ms. Thie: Thank you for the opportunity. This is my first time here, so it is a little nerve-racking. Just on a personal note, I should have mentioned this in the beginning, but I am Mohawk from the Mohawks of Akwesasne. I come from the Snye region. I was also part of the Sixies Scoop. I grew up outside my community and didn’t get registered until much later in life, so I don’t take these decisions lightly. On a personal note, I also suffered lateral violence, so I just hope that we can move forward. It’s not an easy job to do.
The Chair: I knew who you were and where you were from. I prayed this morning — this is very personal, but I am transparent — that we would make sure that you didn’t feel that, or you, Ms. Doran, but we have a job to do. We have a responsibility. We are bound to legislation. We were appointed to change the system and to improve the system or to propose things to make sure that your life can be a normal life or a decent life.
Knowing that we have Indigenous people working for the government — I used to call it “the beast” when I was younger, and, now, as a senator, I call it the government — we ask how we can improve things in 2026 so that we can consider not only Oral Traditions and the expertise from our nations but also this colonial lateral violence, which has been proven through many reports. We must also consider that other departments work in parallel because we don’t want you to become the only people that we want to question, but it is circular. Thank you. We will invite you back.
[Translation]
This concludes our meeting.
(The committee adjourned.)