Skip to main content
APPA - Standing Committee

Indigenous Peoples


THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLES

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Wednesday, October 21, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples met this day at 6:47 p.m. [ET] to examine and report on all matters relating to the Indigenous peoples of Canada; and examine and report on issues relating to the duty to consult and accommodate Indigenous peoples, which flows from the honour of the Crown derived from section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982.

Senator Michèle Audette (Chair) in the chair.

[Translation]

The Chair: Innu-aimun spoken.

Before we begin our discussions with our witnesses, whom I will introduce shortly, I’d like to give a reminder for the benefit of the people behind us who interpret and translate our comments and questions with great care. Please keep phones, earpieces and computers away from the microphones. All the necessary information is at your disposal.

[Innu-aimun spoken]

I’d like to thank and acknowledge the Anishinaabe people, who have always welcomed us on their unceded territory, and all those who have made it their home, the Inuit and Métis peoples and, of course, Canadians.

I’m Michèle Audette, senator from Nitassinan, Uepishtikueiau. I’ll turn it over to my colleagues to introduce themselves.

[English]

Senator Prosper: Hi, everyone, and welcome. Paul Prosper, Nova Scotia, Mi’kma’ki territory.

Senator Martin: Good evening. Yonah Martin, British Columbia.

Senator Pate: Good evening and welcome to all of you. Kim Pate. I live here in the unceded, unsurrendered and unreturned territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabeg.

Senator Karetak-Lindell: Nancy Karetak-Lindell, Nunavut.

Senator McCallum: Mary Jane McCallum from Manitoba, Treaty 10.

[Translation]

Senator Clement: Good evening. Bernadette Clement from Ontario, specifically Cornwall, on the traditional territory of the Mohawks of Akwesasne.

[English]

Senator Tannas: Scott Tannas from Alberta.

Senator Francis: Hi, everyone. Brian Francis, from Epekwitk, Prince Edward Island.

Senator Greenwood: Margo Greenwood, Treaty 6 territory originally, residing in British Columbia.

[Translation]

The Chair: I’d like to acknowledge all those listening to us on ParlVU across the great country, Turtle Island, known as Canada. This evening, we’re meeting under our general order of reference to discuss a possible comparative analysis of spending plans in the area of First Nations child and family services.

It’s a great honour for our committee to have you here, Annette Ryan, Parliamentary Budget Officer. You are, of course, accompanied by your colleagues Mark Mahabir, Director General, Costing and Budgetary Analysis and General Counsel; and Govindadeva Bernier, Director, Budgetary Analysis.

Thank you very much [Innu-aimun spoken] for being with us. You have seven precious minutes to share with us. The floor is yours.

Annette Ryan, Parliamentary Budget Officer, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer: Thank you very much, Madam Chair Audette and honourable senators, for welcoming us here on the unceded territory of the Anishinaabe people.

It’s a great honour for us to appear before you this evening.

Since you’ve already introduced my colleagues, I’ll say that the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer provides impartial, independent analysis to parliamentarians to help them properly review government spending, both at the level of the government’s overall plan and the specific programs that comprise it, as well as how they produce results for Canadians and influence the Canadian economy.

We’re very pleased to discuss the committee’s proposed options for a framework to guide a possible comparative analysis of spending plans to achieve the goals set in the area of First Nations child and family services, namely, the federal government’s national plan, the plan for loving justice proposed by the First Nations Child and Family Caring Society and the Assembly of First Nations, as well as the Ontario Final Agreement.

[English]

In order to support committee deliberations, we propose to outline a baseline comparative study of the plans that the committee may direct us in the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer to undertake. We would see this baseline study as building a shared understanding of the mechanics of the plans as a first stage of targeted work that could subsequently be followed by a consideration of the more profound and nuanced discussions of how the plans would practically address discrimination within First Nations Child and Family Services.

Briefly, under the federal government’s national plan, funding for various activities is defined by formulas that consider historical spending, population and remoteness. These proposed funding allocations are, as you know, a mixture of lump-sum amounts plus targeted use of formulas to determine funding per reserve in a way that adjusts through time.

The Loving Justice Plan also sets out funding formulas for certain activities with a greater use of adjustable allocations and in a way that would require Canada to cover more actual eligible expenditures for various purposes. Accordingly, this plan focuses on the principles and governance that will determine the eligibility of such expenditures. In order to keep focus on the committee’s direction to us for comparative analysis, we will speak less tonight of the Ontario agreement unless you choose to bring it in, in as much as we think that, by and large, it follows the elements of the government’s national plan. We would propose to include it in a comparative study if directed by the committee.

[Translation]

Our proposal for a comparative analysis would involve presenting and evaluating the funding proposed for various activities under the National Plan and the Loving Justice Plan, for the following purposes.

Prevention; operational costs and child maintenance payments; geographic remoteness; capital expenditures; support after reaching the legal age for children who are aging out of care, typically 18 years of age; and First Nations representation services.

Smaller funding amounts would also be examined in other areas, such as governance, research and technical secretariats. These figures add up to overall totals that could also be analyzed.

By comparing the plans, we can examine not only the funding amounts themselves, but also aspects related to their design, such as administrative complexity, potential inequalities between groups and unintended incentives that certain funding mechanisms might create.

[English]

We think it is important to note that the question of whether funding results in actual progress towards eliminating discrimination would be reassessed in time under either plan. For the national plan, this reassessment would be for the later years and 2034-35 onward. Under both plans, spending levels will be reassessed. The national plan provides for a reassessment of funding levels after 2028-29 and for 2034-35 onward, while the Loving Justice Plan incorporates reviews every five years.

We would view the comparative study as consistent with our mandate, which would not provide advice on legal issues as the goal of this first study.

That said, after we have completed our initial comparative study, we are at your service if senators would like to request follow-up analysis on specific metrics or analysis that could support committee assessments of these deeper objectives and whether objectives are being met.

Finally, we would suggest that the committee’s motion could include a cost comparison of Canada’s national plan for First Nations Child and Family Services (excluding Ontario), the First Nations Loving Justice Plan and the Ontario Final Agreement to reform the First Nations Child and Family Services Program that identifies the funding allocated for each purpose in each year, explains the formulas used to calculate those funding allocations and provides relevant considerations to support committee and parliamentary debate on the plans.

Thank you for your time. We look forward to hearing your views and direction.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you very much.

[English]

I also saw that you were exactly seven minutes.

Senator Pate: Thank you very much for your testimony. Canada’s national plan has been critiqued for not having actual backstops. Can you explain how the two plans compare when determining which plan funds the real and specific costs to eliminate discrimination?

Second, I’m curious as to whether your office has considered whether investing adequately in First Nations-led prevention and family supports would ultimately cost governments less than continuing to respond to the consequences of underfunding, including child apprehensions, litigation and compensation, after the harm has already occurred?

Ms. Ryan: Thank you very much, Senator Pate. I will say that we have not yet conducted the analysis and look forward to finalizing a terms of reference for this study, hopefully, tonight.

In terms of your second question, if I could start with that, we would not see the type of cost-benefit analysis, which you described, of reduced harms from a successful program as being where we would start with this first phase of the study. Rather, we would focus much more directly on the different components of the plan, setting out the different mechanics and really focusing on that as the basis of the comparative analysis.

I’m going to defer to my colleagues in terms of your question on the mechanics of the backstops and so on. We’re not presenting the analysis tonight but looking really to understand what senators would like us to focus on for a study that we would do.

Mark Mahabir, Director General, Costing and Budgetary Analysis and General Counsel, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer: Just to add, there is a backstop in the Loving Justice Plan. In the national plan, it’s really calculated differently, but there are ways for First Nations to get increases in funding through a special process.

That’s all I’ll say for now. We haven’t done a complete study of the two plans, and that would entail more work on our part.

Senator Pate: There has been an awful lot of money expended on litigation by the Canadian government not to follow through on the tribunal decisions that have been made to date. If I can suggest, the committee would find it incredibly useful to find out what the cost differential would have been had the government provided those supports upfront versus fighting all along the way and being forced, basically, to implement these plans.

I suspect the costs are available, and I suspect you would be able to also project what it would have cost to implement that immediately when the claim was initially launched versus what the costs have been on litigation and continuing to fight what, in the end, continues to be a tribunal decision.

Ms. Ryan: We are here to understand the direction of the committee. We are proposing to break the analysis into pieces to keep the discussion tractable and make sure that we’re able to deliver on the mandate or terms of reference in a timing that will be useful to the committee. Absolutely, if that is to be part of the study, we can take that under advisement.

It would be a different type of analysis than we think would be a tighter and more doable phase one, but it really is up to the committee to let us know what your interests are and what would be most useful.

Senator Pate: I speak only for myself; I haven’t had an opportunity to consult with my colleagues. It strikes me that in this moment, when there are other bills coming forward where consultation is not occurring and where likely litigation will be commenced in order to ensure rights are upheld, that kind of analysis might be incredibly useful for us to know as senators and, therefore, inform how we move forward on legislation that may be coming forth from the government.

In any event, I’m curious if you can also incorporate to what extent each plan provides funding that is adequate, needs-based and sustainable enough to achieve the substantive equality of the young people it aims to help as needs, costs, populations and service demands change.

Ms. Ryan: We’ve had a lot of discussion within the office about what the best approach is to take on these questions. We understand and respect the amount of work that’s gone into these questions over 10 years and the legal considerations that remain in play.

We really took the view that step one would be starting with a core focus on the plans, building those out in terms of what the different elements would achieve and trying to bring some specifics into play for the Loving Justice Plan, which is more general in some of its components than the national plan. That could allow us to take on questions of how that then aligns with the question of the ultimate objective, which I understand you set forward as tackling the ultimate goals of equality.

In looking at that, to us, that requires a lot of study of different contextual factors — what are the needs, what are the circumstances and what are the existing supports across a variety of situations across the country? — to then start with trying to do the gap and assess it across time. That would be a much larger exercise than taking it on in pieces and then coming back and saying, “Here’s what we’ve achieved.” Do you want us to go away and think about the metrics of how close that gets us to the goals that you’re trying to assess in terms of equality of services and so on? We would propose to do it in these ways. Does it make sense to you to do that and come back rather than take on the much wider and nuanced questions you’re asking?

I’m going to pause to see if my colleagues want to try and approach this in a different way. Is there anything else that you would say?

Mr. Mahabir: Yes, I agree. It would be a staged approach to determine substantive equality. You would have to determine formal equality first and then determine substantive equality after. I don’t know if we could do it all at once, and I don’t know what the time frame would be for us to do it for each First Nation’s agency.

Senator Pate: I’m extremely concerned, as are many across the country, especially constitutional lawyers, that the federal government on their website and, therefore, probably in terms of their analysis in the Department of Justice has redefined “equality” different from what the Supreme Court of Canada has identified over the last several decades in terms of substantive equality.

Their policy directive actually take a formal equality approach. It’s extremely concerning to me, as a legislator, that change has happened and that, therefore, people within the bureaucracy — lawyers — are obviously being given that as a way to analyze it. A formal equality analysis on this type of issue, in particular, falls short. It reveals some very obvious discrimination, but it absolutely falls short when we talk about a substantive equality analysis.

It strikes me, as you’re doing this, recognizing that the government has moved goalposts in this process, that the need for them to adhere, at the very least, to Supreme Court of Canada jurisprudence up until now is vitally important, and they should readapt their policies.

If that is what informed their plan, then some analysis of that, in light of what the law actually is and what law should be implemented, will be vitally important.

I don’t know if you’re aware of that. I only recently became aware that the policy was changed in 2024, and there’s a policy document on the Department of Justice’s website. I can certainly send it to you if it is of use.

Ms. Ryan: If I may, senator, I want to emphasize that we appreciate the depth of the question as well as the profound merit of the objective. I do want to table some cautions about our capacity as budget officials to be able to enter into these legal questions that remain outstanding and not spending so much time looking at it to build up our understanding in a way that would be useful so that, by the time we got there, the questions would be settled and passed. Also, that would be a much wider and open-ended study than we have assessed.

The aspect about whether this is a legal question that is outstanding and how to support parliamentary discussion about the issues, while being careful about not being prejudicial to open legal cases, is something that I would want to be careful about.

I think we have been looking at the issue from the sense of starting with the comparative study of the plans — what do those formulas mean in practice? — and getting everybody on the same page. What those different plans would achieve in practice is a different question from how far that gets us versus a gap of what needs to be done in a context where people disagree profoundly and deeply about what that gap is, what that target is and what resolution looks like in this space.

Again, I would say that we are here to refine those terms of reference and come up with something that would be doable in a reasonable time frame. I would have to think really hard about how we would tackle the size of the question that you are describing in a way that would be satisfying to the question that you have in a timeline that is useful to you and others. That’s a very different study than what we are thinking about with the comparative study of the plans.

Senator Tannas: Thank you for being here. Thank you for shouldering the work that you are describing.

Just to maybe close a loop on what Senator Pate was saying, I think I’m hearing you say that you would be coming close to boiling the ocean if we keep moving into qualitative kinds of questions, so if you could just comment on that one way or the other. I think it is really important that we let you do your work. You are the experts.

Are you comfortable that you know what we want based on the interaction that you have had with the committee up until now and that you can deliver on the product that was being asked for in the correspondence that you received? You are the one that has developed the work plan and is proposing it. For me, the most important thing is that you can deliver it, you think it will answer the questions we’re looking to be answered and you can do it in a timely fashion. As you said, it’s no use if it’s so far down the road that the issue has been dealt with or dealt with in a way that isn’t helpful to us. I want to make sure that you are comfortable with the methodology that you are proposing and that there is nothing you are really looking to us to say, “We could do this or this. Which one would you like?” I didn’t hear that.

The final thing is this issue, which is interesting. Are you able to be subpoenaed by lawyers for lawsuits against the federal government? That’s a question that occurred to me.

Mr. Mahabir: That’s a good question. We don’t have federal immunity like an official would. Technically, the Parliamentary Budget Officer, or PBO, works for the Speakers of the House and the Senate. If we were sued, it would be the Speakers of the House and the Senate in some cases. It would depend on the circumstances, whether or not we could be sued, and if it was a contract or if it was something that we said.

Senator Tannas: No, I was thinking subpoenaed as an expert witness in some cases on this. Is that part of what you have to watch out for?

Mr. Mahabir: That’s a good question. I would have to get back to you on whether we could be subpoenaed.

Senator Tannas: Okay. Thank you.

Senator Prosper: Again, thank you to our witnesses. I’m just curious about certain approaches within each plan. When you look at each plan, more specifically, around the area of governance and decision-making structures, do you have any thoughts or observations on how governance and decision-making structures affect fiscal accountability, transparency, the timely allocation of funds and the ability to correct funding or service gaps? Is there anything you can provide in terms of an approach in that regard?

Ms. Ryan: Thank you, senator. I would say that’s the type of direction that I think we could take on in a timely way, where we could look at the different elements of the funding formulas, break them down into pieces and say, “Based on the way this plan is structured, there’s a lump-sum payment for this funding element, and there is a possibility of applying for greater amounts of funding.” The national plan has different elements that are clarified, whereas the Loving Justice Plan is a mixture of directions of what the formula could look like, and then each plan has different governance considerations. With those aspects of different ways that the plans might be structured and then subsequently negotiated, we could bring considerations into the mix in terms of: If you structure one of the funding elements this way versus that way, what does it mean in terms of transparency, administrative complexity and differing abilities to change the allocation through time? The typical work of the PBO, I would say, is that aspect of taking the budget formula, breaking it down and bringing forward considerations. I won’t say pros and cons because that starts to get into “shoulds” or whatever, but for potential implications of how the different formulas are structured, that’s something that we would see as much more doable.

That isn’t something that we can give you advice on now, but that’s what we’re thinking would be the terms of reference that we could take on.

Senator Prosper: For another terms of reference consideration, certainly, looking at both approaches, more specifically, what resources, timelines and accountability measures does each plan provide to reform Indigenous Services Canada’s internal structures, processes and practices? As a result of that, what are the financial risks that remain if institutional reform is incomplete or delayed?

Ms. Ryan: I’m going to give my colleagues a chance to answer.

Mr. Mahabir: In the past, we have looked at what happens when there is a delay in procurement and the additional costs. It would be something similar. If there is reform required by a department, what is the cost related to the delay and the reform of the department? I think that’s something we could do.

Ms. Ryan: Which is maybe picking up on some of Senator Pate’s earlier points.

Senator Prosper: In part, yes. Thank you.

Senator Francis: My concern is that a baseline study may focus on the cost of each plan without adequately assessing the costs of an inadequate plan, including the human, social and long-term financial consequences of unmet needs and continued harm.

Could your analysis be conducted independently of the two plans and, instead, focus on identifying what is required to fully meet the needs of First Nations children and families and fulfill the objectives of Jordan’s Principle? Ultimately, I’m not sure the central question is whether one plan is better than the other. The real question is: What funding levels, services, supports and accountability measures are required to finally address the underlying problem and ensure Jordan’s Principle is fully implemented?

Ms. Ryan: Senator, I think, again, that is clear in terms of the objective. Everybody wants to know what the target is, how we can get there and how we can continue to put light on the absence of completing that objective.

It bounces back to the same kind of theme. It is a profoundly complex question for the 40 staff of the PBO, with our responsibilities to cover the wider economy and the government, on the basis that we are principally people skilled in economics, budgets, finance and so on. Many of these concepts go into wider realms.

We see the way to get there is to break it into pieces, start with the different plans and understand them well. The Loving Justice Plan, as we have been looking at it, has, I would offer, embedded many of these higher-level objectives into the specific design of specific funding elements but doesn’t take that extra step of answering who gets what under what rules and how it works.

In terms of being able to answer these wider questions, we see a lot of merit in breaking it into these pieces so that we can get on the same page. Part of it is to get our own heads around how the different plans would work in practice, come back, see how far we have gotten and then take a direction from the committee to say, “Okay, now we understand how this works in practice.” I hope that would be a contribution. Then we could take that into, “Okay, this is meant to target prevention.” Let’s think about some good metrics for prevention. How could we know what better looks like, and how could we put numbers around that? If you have a sense of what the target is and how far you are from it, then, building from what we have done on the plans, you could ask what it would cost or how you would change the formula to address a shortfall.

I respectfully and humbly know that you have all spent years on these challenges. I don’t want to say obvious things. That goes to how we would like to work with the committee: take a very big problem, start with something practical, come back and say, “Have we got it right? Is this helpful? Is this useful?” We would tackle the question of what the most important gaps are in these profound, principled objectives that the plans are meant to achieve and then say, “Okay, what would that look like to get there? How can we know if we are getting there? How can that feed into these subsequent reviews of the plans that would top up money, change money and amend the path to get towards that objective?”

I want to say that we respond to parliamentary committees. I’m trying not to be argumentative but, rather, say that that’s our assessment. This is a large, complex and layered problem.

Our preference would be to start with the plans, how they would work, the pros and cons of different elements of the plans and then take on these wider questions.

Your senator colleagues have expressed clear views that the aspect of delaying getting started on the plans is something that should be considered, and that’s well received. We could find a way to work that in as well. But with that sense of whether we are solving things and what more that would take, maybe start with what the first set of steps is and then have a baseline to work from. That is our view.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you very much. I have a question, but since it’s extremely complex, I’ll ask it in French.

Where we come from, it’s hard to compartmentalize long-held colonial roots. We understand that you have limits, a mandate or a scope of responsibility that starts here and ends there. Is it possible in your duties, in the mandate’s definition, to remember that it was the courts that said, “There is discrimination,” period? There’s discrimination when comparing children from Quebec, from Canada and from First Nations.

I think this is a crucial root cause that the courts consider when telling both parties, First Nations and the government, to agree on a strategy or a method to invest in an ongoing deficit. We, or at least I, don’t know how that might play out.

There’s a process behind this from which we’ve received 21 pages from the federal government, because it decided to take such an approach without really sitting down with the knowledge keepers, the families, the children who have become adults and so on. On the other hand, there’s been a lot of mobilization of First Nations experts, parents, children who have become adults. This mobilization will produce thousands of pages, culminating in 200 pages. In your analysis, can we sense that two different visions represent costs? Is it possible that all this will come through in your analysis, that is, that there are costs when the parties don’t agree? Not to determine the exact amount, but so that it is clear from the report or your analysis that there was a delay because they are returning to court. So it’s good for people who pay taxes to also know that there’s a system that has decided. For me, it’s valuable. I don’t know if you can do that kind of magic.

Secondly, it’s a matter of remembering the importance of your review. This will help Parliament fulfill its role in overseeing decisions made with respect to First Nations. Then it has to be informed by the analyses you’re going to do for everyone, for society. We’re fortunate to have tools in both chambers, in Parliament, experts like you, as Senator Tannas said.

I understand that we’re talking about money, but the fact is that it feels as though discrimination has led to this situation, and that this influences things or leads us to say: “Okay.” And we should not be penalized because one group has more pages in its report, as its vision is much more realistic; we realize that it may be an investment rather than an expense, if we’d listened from the outset. I know you don’t have that responsibility, but at least the minutes will keep it in the history of the Senate.

I’m sure it will help everyone. Thank you very much.

Ms. Ryan, are you able to stay longer?

Ms. Ryan: I’m at your service.

The Chair: Perfect, because there are other colleagues.

[English]

Senator McCallum: I have to tell you that I have a really hard problem trying to wrap my head around all of this. We look at the Auditor General doing reports in all areas in terms of deficient funding and what they’re supposed to deliver. The government keeps saying that they agree, and then, five years later, it’s the same thing.

With that in mind, when I look at child and family services, there is so much more involved besides funding. We have intergenerational trauma — I was in a residential school — parenting and children being taken into care.

We have a target that’s always moving. The funding was never sufficient to meet the actual and evolving needs over time, and the harm continues to increase. People want this addressed rather than the harms now, but because this is not addressed and the government is stalling, everything is building up on both ends. There is an increase in premature morbidity and mortality, and, actually, children are dying earlier than they should.

What do you take into account? We look at the other influences, like evolving needs because of the social chaos created by discrimination and by governments. In the work you do, can you do some kind of analysis to look at that, put it on the floor and have it entered as evidence? Does that make sense, or am I way off?

Ms. Ryan: I hear you, senator. It informs more, I think, Senator Pate, of where your opening thoughts were, and I’m hearing that again from Senators Francis and Audette. I think what you’re looking for is essentially a means of saying that this delay is costly.

[Translation]

As you said so well, Senator Audette, it has already been established that discrimination exists.

[English]

I want to be careful to not decide a very complex legal case that has had these proceedings for years and years. That’s where I really want to be very careful.

That being said, I think what you’re saying is something different, which is that it would be helpful for this study if, in a framing opening section, it were to do something to document the types of harms, gaps and implications that come from not addressing these discrepancies.

I won’t find all the right words, but I hope my intention is coming through.

We could find something that meets what you have expressed, but I want to keep that caution that we would want to be careful to not enter into, essentially, what are open legal challenges.

Senator McCallum: In the end, that is where it is going. So if you don’t go that route, will your analysis be less than because you’re not going in that area?

Ms. Ryan: The straight answer, senator, is that, yes, it would be less than. If we were to wade into this very complex, fraught and important debate and say that we think A plus B plus C times D equals some number, the one thing I could say about the number we would come up with is that it would be wrong. It would be too high, too low or too approximate.

I don’t think we can be definitive and give you the right answer. I’m not trying to be anything; I’m really trying to say that if the committee is looking for some sort of benchmark of how we can provide minimum ballparks of the types of financial implications of not acting, that’s an achievable direction for us.

I’ll stop there.

The Chair: I know there are already good examples in the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer’s report, Compensation for the Delay and Denial of Services to First Nations Children, from February 2021. There is already a route. Thank you.

Govindadeva Bernier, Director, Budgetary Analysis, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer: Perhaps I can add a general comment. As Ms. Ryan mentioned earlier, it’s hard for us to determine what the actual level is that would meet the needs. Typically, our work is to cost proposals, and when those proposals are more general, we often ask to get some kinds of parameters. As a parallel to that, a few months ago, we did an analysis of the funding gap of the First Nations police services. That was another question, and it’s rooted in the same issues. There are a lot of past injustices and discrimination. First Nations don’t trust the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, or RCMP, when they provide policing on-reserve because they have taken their children previously.

In that study, we couldn’t determine what the needs are in terms of police officers, service levels, et cetera. In that case, we already had the provinces working with each First Nations’ self‑administered police service and Public Safety Canada. They had already assessed what their needs would be, how many more officers they would want and how many more facilities would be needed, et cetera. We were provided with this information. Based upon those inputs, we were then able to say how much we think is still missing in terms of financing to reach those levels that seem to be agreed upon. Perhaps not everyone agreed with those levels, but at least we’re getting closer to an actual feeling of safety in these communities.

We’re missing the same element here. We can’t come up with a number as being the amount of funding needed per capita to stop these injustices. It was mentioned that a lot of experts worked on the topics, so if there is anything the committee wants to consider and believes would be needed, then perhaps it could help us in doing the analysis.

The Chair: I think the magic is happening because this is public. Now you might have some emails from First Nations leadership, who know exactly what the needs are. They might provide you with information.

Senator Greenwood: First, thank you, witnesses, for being here with us tonight.

I am not an accountant, an economist or any of those things, so forgive me if my questions are naive. I think it would be really important, having just listened to the conversation this evening, to establish what we mean by equality and what the metrics associated with that are. That’s a fundamental piece when we’re talking about this issue, I think.

I’m going to probably talk like a teacher.

It would be really important to know where we started, and I don’t mean to go back through the whole tribunal testimony. I don’t mean that at all. I’m thinking about these funding frameworks that you’ve been talking about.

Initially, what were the frameworks for Indigenous and non‑Indigenous? I’m not thinking about the money, because we know that has already been proven. It was unequal and not right. But what pieces should we take apart that were being used? I think that’s a really important thing.

Regarding needs-based funding versus allocation funding models, this isn’t the only time that needs-based funding has come up to you, I’m sure. There are ways that you have looked at this in other areas. What are the lessons learned from those areas that may apply here? I would like to know what that is because I don’t know in this particular context.

Also, you have the Ontario agreement. Are there any results from that Ontario agreement? When did that start, and are folks from Ontario saying that this is equal now?

I don’t know anything about this process, but you have one model that’s moving down the road. I think there were a couple of examples in here. What are those folks saying, and how can that inform the Loving Justice National Plan? How do we get to that place? We have to have notional funding; I know that much. But how do you determine that, and who should be determining that? How do you engage them to get the most accurate formula that you can?

Those are the kinds of questions I have that I would hope a study of this nature would start to bring out.

Of course, you spoke earlier about options. When you take the pieces apart, maybe there is a piece here and a piece there that is going to meet the needs of a community. I don’t know. I’m not a budget person, but this is from what I’ve read and listened to.

I’m not sure that’s much of a question, but would that help you move forward into what I understand we’re looking for, although not in its entirety? Those are the questions I would have.

The Chair: I know your background, so that’s very powerful. Thank you very much.

Senator Pate: I’ll try to come back at this a bit more, and it’s great to hear the processing by other colleagues to, perhaps, help refine it.

This is not so much for you, although it is directed to you, but it is also for the public watching. I’ll speak for myself, but I think I speak for my colleagues. We’re not trying to make it a really difficult process for you or, as Senator Tannas said, require you to boil the ocean, not at all.

But we are a committee that now has looked at successive decisions taken by this government, where it seems to be that a part of the strategy is to delay the inevitable, and that comes at a cost. It comes at a human cost, as Senator Francis said, a social cost and also a financial cost. And it comes at a cost to the communities. People’s lives are literally lost. Children’s needs are not met. Jordan, who this is based on, died in the hospital, never getting to his community.

I speak for myself. There is a certain level of frustration at this stage, and we’re asking you to look at this and help provide some of the — sorry; I’ll get to the question.

Given that billions of dollars have already been committed to compensating First Nations children and families for discrimination, could your assessment of the two plans account for the possibility that inadequate funding and delays today could expose Canada to further contingent liabilities in the future?

Senator Prosper: I’d certainly be happy with a response in writing; I know time is limited.

Canada proposes an initial arbitration process whose president would be appointed by order-in-council, followed by a statutory tribunal if Parliament enacts legislation. Canada’s proposed arbitration policy contains jurisdictional limits, including exclusions affecting certain recommendations and claims involving a funding commitment.

The appropriate test is not whether a dispute process exists but whether it can independently address systemic discrimination, grant effective interim and financial remedies and enforce the tribunal’s substantive equality standards.

In terms of costs, we heard Senator Audette talk about a cost when an agreement is not reached. Senator Pate talked about delay; that comes at a cost.

When I’m thinking of comparative costs, factored in within that is First Nation independence and the effectiveness of each plan in terms of monitoring, dispute resolution and enforcement mechanisms, including within that their capacity to prevent or promptly remedy non-compliance. There is a certain segment there that could have a real cost comparatively when you look at both plans.

I just note that for your reference.

Senator Tannas: I like where this is going now, where you start with the plan that you had, which is to compare two plans — one is an Indigenous-developed and Indigenous-led, et cetera, plan, and the other one is a government plan — to both achieve, allegedly, the same thing. And if, in your research, you find that one is more expensive than the other, which you may, but the more expensive one is the Indigenous-led one, let’s say, and the government one is cheaper, then there is the risk that the government is undertaking not to do it right and not respecting the Indigenous-led plan. That, to me, is a powerful piece of information that this committee will deliver to those who can’t generate it themselves.

The rest of it, in my mind, we have no business in. We have a plan that was developed by the leaders, who know what they’re doing, and with witnesses, and it was informed by all of their own lived experiences and career experiences. We’re not going to add much there.

But we could add this: The quicker, the better, and, Ms. Ryan, if you felt comfortable opining on this legal risk that will overhang a decision of the government to plow ahead and ignore a plan developed by the very people who were injured in the first place and who will be doing the solving of the injury, it seems to me that that is the most important thing that we could deliver as a committee and as representatives of the government on behalf of the people that we care about.

I hope I have not missed the plot, but I think that’s where we’re at. If that works, it’s something to think about.

I’m sorry if I am missing something.

The Chair: Senator Tannas, I don’t think you missed something. You wrapped up something that is very important, which, for me, in my understanding, could be the first phase.

Senator Tannas: Yes.

The Chair: Then, in the second phase, there are other documents that show how a denial — you know?

Senator Tannas: Sure.

The Chair: In the second phase.

[Translation]

If you agree, director, we’ll take a few minutes.

[English]

After that, we would go in camera to discuss the next step.

Ms. Ryan: Thank you, senators. Perhaps to focus on the elements of the terms of reference that you’ll go in camera for, I think that Senator Tannas has given you the wrap-up.

That model would allow us to do what Senator Greenwood suggested as well, which is to look at the lessons learned of best practices and different elements of the plans and bring that forward. I think, Senator Prosper, that was what you had touched on earlier.

That’s sort of a take-the-baseline plan but to add that flourish of bringing in the lessons learned and where things might go. That’s richer than just the cost, but I think that’s important as well.

There is widespread interest in having an assessment of the cost of delay of moving forward on a plan; that’s understood. There was past work, so that works.

There will continue to be difficulty in assessing what the target is, especially when we don’t have a definition given by the committee or the courts about substantive equality, so then what are we trying to get to? Starting with what the proposals are, the lessons learned and the cost of inaction is doable, and if there are other elements the committee directs to us, then we will do our level best to give you a timely answer.

Senator Martin: I’m returning to this committee after a long time. I’ve been listening throughout this session. I heard what Senator Tannas did in wrapping it up, so to speak. With the expertise you have, Ms. Ryan, I was curious: If this were to be in phases, do you have a suggestion of what the phases might be or should be? Those are two different words.

Ms. Ryan: It’s a great question, senator. I certainly don’t have a firm proposal to put to you as you go into committee. The aspect of moving from what the differences are in the plans to what the contextual factors are would let us start to talk about the tangible targets of what’s trying to be achieved. I think that’s the next phase of work. I don’t know if my colleagues could express it more tightly than me.

Mr. Mahabir: I think Senator Tannas explained it well with costing the two plans, looking at deficiencies in the two plans and then coming back with looking at substantive equality after. The first phase would include the cost of delay.

Senator Martin: You’re looking at it from a different perspective or maybe even through a different lens. I thought it might be helpful if you did have suggestions for what those phases could be, from your point of view, which may be something we’re missing and not thinking about. You have answered that question, in part, and it’s not like you’re telling us what to do. You’re looking for direction. I was curious if you had such insights.

I’m not a numbers person at all. When we’re looking at numbers, are there conclusions we should not draw? Do you have advice? Again, from your perspective, judgment and expertise, is it important to look at these numbers in an accurate way? Are there things you would do that we should be thinking about as we go forward?

Ms. Ryan: There is merit in considering what these review cycles are going to look like. So the basic structure is: get started, then there will be reviews every 5 years, a big review after 10 years. So, in that sense, what are the rules for doing those reviews? Better to start now and have that discussion in parallel about what the basis for those reviews will be. If you start thinking about that in 5 years, well, does that mean it’s another 5 or 10 years before the review actually happens?

Senator Martin: Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you so much. The committee can also do a substantial study of what we discussed, where the PBO has no mandate or authority or it’s not her role. We understand that.

I want to say thank you.

Now we will go in camera to reorganize this so it does fit in your mandate.

(The committee continued in camera.)

Back to top