THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATIONAL FINANCE
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Tuesday, September 29, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on National Finance met with videoconference this day at 9 a.m. [ET] to study and report on matters relating to federal estimates generally and other financial matters.
Senator Claude Carignan (Chair ) in the chair.
[Translation]
The Chair: Good morning. Welcome to all the senators. I hope you had a good summer and that everyone is up to continue the work that awaits us. We have some robust bills to look at, which will require long days of work in the coming weeks. I would also like to thank everyone who is joining us on sencanada.ca.
Before we begin, I would like to ask senators and in-person participants to consult the cards on the table for guidelines to prevent audio feedback incidents. Please make sure to keep your earpiece away from all microphones at all times.
Do not touch your microphone. It will be turned on and off by the console operator. Avoid handling your earpiece while your microphone is on; you can either keep it on your ear or place it on the designated sticker. Thank you for your cooperation.
My name is Claude Carignan, senator from Quebec and chair of the Standing Senate Committee on National Finance. I would like to ask my colleagues to introduce themselves.
Senator Forest: Welcome back, everyone. Éric Forest from the Gulf region of Quebec.
[English]
Senator Pupatello: Good morning. Sandra Pupatello from Ontario.
[Translation]
Senator Gignac: Clément Gignac, Kennebec division, Quebec.
Senator Galvez: Rosa Galvez from Quebec.
Senator Cardozo: Good morning. Andrew Cardozo from Ontario.
Senator Dalphond: Pierre J. Dalphond, De Lorimier division, Quebec.
[English]
Senator Ross: Good morning. Krista Ross from New Brunswick.
Senator MacAdam: Jane MacAdam from Prince Edward Island.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. Honourable senators, our meeting today will focus on a general financial and economic update on the state of the country. We wanted to start in the fall with an update on the situation.
[English]
For our first panel, we have the pleasure of welcoming, from the Centre for Future Work and joining us very early in the morning from British Columbia via video conference, Jim Stanford, Economist and Director. Thank you for being with us, particularly at this time this morning.
[Translation]
From the Business Council of Canada, Theo Argitis, Senior Vice-President, Public Policy. Welcome and thank you for accepting our invitation. We will now begin with opening remarks from Mr. Stanford, followed by Mr. Argitis. Mr. Stanford, you have the floor.
[English]
Jim Stanford, Economist and Director, Centre for Future Work: Thank you very much, senators, for the opportunity to meet and share my views on Canada’s economic and fiscal situation.
It is early here in Vancouver, as the chair mentioned, so please forgive me if I have a sip of coffee every now and then during my presentation.
Today, I will provide short comments on the current state of Canada’s economy, how it is withstanding the uncertainty caused by U.S. trade policy and themes that I think the federal government should emphasize in its future actions. Then, I will welcome your questions and comments.
The good news is that recent economic indicators confirm that Canada’s economy is maintaining its stability and momentum despite the disruptions from U.S. tariffs and other uncertainty on the international front.
Second-quarter growth was both strong and very well balanced. All major cylinders in our economic engine were firing: consumer spending, government expenditure, both current and capital, business, non-residential investment, residential investment and exports. Our growth would have been much stronger except for a major drawdown in inventories, which portends well for future growth.
In the labour market, job creation has been decent, if not spectacular. Over 200,000 have been created in the last 12 months, most of them full-time. Even manufacturing, which is the target of U.S. trade actions, has seen year-over-year growth of about 20,000 jobs. Of course, within manufacturing, there are sectors that are suffering, including auto and steel, which I think you’ll hear about later this morning.
Ironically, the weakest employment numbers we see right now are arising from the public sector: from education, post‑secondary education, in particular, colleges, and also public administration, mostly due to headcount reductions in the federal civil service. I will note I think this public sector downsizing is unnecessary. The public sector is relatively insulated from President Trump’s trade actions. They should be a source of stability as we adjust to global changes, and I think the federal government, in particular, should rethink its commitment to downsizing, which, on top of the macroeconomic impacts, will also affect the quality of federal services delivered to Canadians.
One warning sign from the labour market I want to draw your attention to is wage growth, which has been decelerating. We had seen, after the COVID pandemic and the inflation shock of 2022 and 2023, a pickup in wage growth in Canada. Real wages are now higher than they were before the pandemic, which means the damage done to purchasing power during that initial inflationary episode has been repaired and then some. That is a success story for Canada’s labour market institutions. It was essential in helping Canadians address affordability challenges after the pandemic.
However, right now, a combination of slower wage growth and a rebound in inflation, driven solely by President Trump’s war in Iran, is threatening that real-wage success. Hourly nominal wages in the latest data were up only 2% year-over-year in August. That is the slowest in five years and not enough to keep up with current inflation. We want to see continued priority on wage gains and empowering Canadian workers to win wages that more than keep up with inflation.
In this context, I must express my concern regarding the federal government’s intention to codify restrictions on normal collective bargaining rights in its proposed changes to the Canada Labour Code included in Bill C-39. Codifying the government’s right to interfere arbitrarily in collective bargaining and suppress normal constitutional rights, including the right to withhold labour, on the basis of vague and subjective measures of national interest, in my judgment, is a step in the wrong direction. It would heighten the risk of future deterioration in real wages in Canada, which would not help our macroeconomic recovery.
Canada’s trade performance has also been surprisingly robust since the end of 2024, when President Trump won the election. Canada’s exports to countries other than the United States have grown by 18% up to the second quarter of 2026. Even our exports to the U.S. are up 9%. The share of our exports of goods and services going to the U.S. has fallen to below two thirds now, which is a significant and welcome change. This makes it clear that efforts to diversify Canadian trade ties are paying off.
Let me conclude with some high-level thoughts on the broad task facing Canada’s economy in the coming years. Mr. Trump’s actions have forced us to redefine how we orient our economic and social development. Yes, that means attracting more investment in Canada, not only from foreign investors but also from our own money, our own pension funds included. However, it’s not just the quantity of investment and exports that matters. It’s also the composition of those flows and the quality of the economy and the society that we build.
I think right now there is a current temptation in facing Mr. Trump to double down on anything we can do. This has contributed to a great rush to build many projects, of course, including resource extraction and exports, but there are risks to becoming overly dependent on the extraction and export of unprocessed natural resources. It exposes us to global demand and geopolitical risks, as well as environmental risks. Our vision should remain to build an economy that not just is viable in the face of what is happening but also retains the core values which motivate Canadians to defend our country as a distinct entity from that south of the border.
I would urge senators to ensure that the federal government’s response to this moment does not dismiss the values, including inclusion and sustainability, that make Canada Canada, which is why we want to defend Canada’s economy in the first place.
I’ll leave it at that. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your questions and discussion. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much.
[English]
Theo Argitis, Senior Vice-President, Policy, Business Council of Canada: Mr. Chair and honourable senators, thank you for the invitation to appear before this committee.
I am here today on behalf of the Business Council of Canada, which represents the CEOs and entrepreneurs of over 170 leading Canadian enterprises across all sectors of the economy. Together, our members employ more than 2 million Canadians, and their companies are responsible for most of this country’s private sector exports, investments and corporate philanthropy.
I will echo some of the same messaging on the economy as Jim Stanford. Over the past year and a half or two years, Canada’s economy has proven to be much more resilient than many of us expected. Our economy has grown, in real terms, by about 2% per year, and it grew, anyways, in 2024 and 2025. It is slowing down slightly this year, in 2026, as the economy began to feel the full impacts of the trade war with the United States as well as much slower population growth. Growth is widely expected to move back to near 2% next year.
By historical standards, I wouldn’t call this exceptional, but given the shocks we’ve been experiencing, it is actually quite reassuring that the Canadian economy has shown this degree of resilience. That said, the picture remains fragile.
Employment fell by 42,000 in August, and the unemployment rate remains at 6.4%. That’s too high. There are too many unemployed workers in this country. There is a lot of slack in the economy, particularly in the labour market, and we need to bring that unemployment rate down.
In addition to everything, renewed trade tensions with the United States have also injected another large dose of uncertainty into business planning and investment. There are still plenty of headwinds to growth, and that is coming at a time when inflation remains very elevated. Because of energy prices, headline inflation is around 3%, with gasoline prices up more than 20% over the past year or so.
We have two forces pulling in opposite directions: You have tariffs and trade uncertainty that are dragging down activity, and you have higher oil and fuel prices that are putting upward pressure on inflation. That’s a dangerous cocktail of factors because you have weaker growth at the same time as interest rates are rising because the expectation is that central banks will tighten monetary policy to help dampen inflationary expectations. The near-term outlook remains uncertain for all of these reasons, even as the economy has done reasonably well.
What I would like to emphasize here, though, is that, in terms of a longer-term economic policy agenda, things are looking very encouraging. There is a much greater focus on investment, infrastructure, major projects, internal trade and building the productive capacity of the Canadian economy. The direction is something that the business community is very encouraged by and welcomes.
In our conversations with business leaders, there is more optimism right now about Canada’s economic potential than there has been in a very long time. We are no longer, as a country, spending most of our time talking about needing greater ambition. I think the ambition is here. The question now — and I think this is a very important question for this committee — is how we execute. What do we need to do to turn that ambition into results, into real projects, infrastructure, productive capacity and stronger growth? The big question today is whether we, as a country, have the capacity to deliver on our ambitions. Can we get the job done?
Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
The Chair: Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Forest: Thank you to our witnesses for joining us this morning, albeit early.
My first question is for Mr. Stanford. You’ve argued that we need to diversify not only where we export but also what we export. What do you think this means in practical terms for Canada’s economic policy?
[English]
Mr. Stanford: Thank you, senator. That’s a great question. I agree. You put it very well. We need to worry about the diversity of where we sell, but we also need diversity in what we sell.
There is, obviously, a long, historical challenge facing Canada to become more than — as it is said — a hewer of wood and drawer of water, that is to say, more than just an extractor of unprocessed natural resources that are then sold to other countries in the world who take those resources, manufacture them into value-added goods and services and sell them back to us at, obviously, much higher prices. That’s not a winning formula.
From the beginning of Confederation, Canadian governments have been concerned with how we add value to our natural resources, including various measures to stimulate industrialization and value-added manufacturing, nowadays including, of course, technology, digital services and so on.
I think this is going to be important because there is a tendency, when you’re facing a challenge — as we are — to say, “Well, let’s just double down on what we do best.” That could be extracting and exporting resources, and we have seen a major emphasis — I would suggest an overemphasis — on new resource projects, with some of the attendant risks, especially environmental risks, in the case of fossil fuel projects.
It is interesting to note that while our dependence on the U.S. market has shrunk to 67%, as I said, our dependence on extraction of primary resources has grown. Last year, unprocessed resources accounted for 50% of our merchandise exports, much higher than at the turn of the century. Many things are happening there, including the challenges in exporting to the U.S., but we need to keep that need to maintain value-added activity in Canada, including our manufacturing and technology sectors, at the top of our priority list.
[Translation]
Senator Forest: Thank you.
Mr. Argitis, you concluded by saying that we are at the stage of knowing what to do.
In your opinion, how do we strike a balance between the need to respond firmly to the U.S. and the risk of having Canadian businesses and consumers pay for that response? How do we strike the right balance between our measures and countermeasures?
[English]
Mr. Argitis: Are you referring to counter-tariffs?
This is not a fight we asked for, right? We’re being forced into situations where our largest market for manufactured goods is no longer as accessible to our manufacturers. It’s largely a manufacturing sector issue. The Americans are not going to impose any serious tariffs on our resources. Among things, they are trying to reindustrialize, and, clearly, they are trying to reindustrialize by bringing some of those manufacturing jobs from other countries into the U.S., including from Canada.
This is a situation that is a very complex situation. The question is how we deal with the challenge faced by manufacturers, primarily. We’re in the thick of it right now. We’re trying to figure out how we respond. There are short-term issues, there are medium-term issues, and there are long-term issues. In the short term, you’re hoping to deter the other side. One way you can deter is through counter-tariffs. The medium‑term issue is adapting whatever you can adapt as this dispute plays out.
The longer-term issue is more transformational. If we see that the Americans don’t want to have the integration in the manufacturing sector that they wanted to, how do we reinvent our manufacturing sector to make sure that we continue to have an industrial sector, which is important? As a share of the economy, Canada has one of the smaller manufacturing sectors in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, or OECD. I think it’s very important that we figure out how we sustain good factory jobs and an industrial sector in this country.
To answer your question, you’re in the middle of it right now, so it’s very easy to nitpick and raise concerns about affordability and this sort of thing, and these are all legitimate concerns — no question about it. But the game is afoot, and we can’t be overly judgmental on tactics. Let’s put the tactics to the side and look at the bigger picture.
Senator Cardozo: Thank you both for being here, even though it’s 6 a.m. on the West Coast. The two of you are wonderful economists to talk about the big picture that we’re looking at. I have two questions. I’ll start with the question you posed at the end, Mr. Argitis: How do we execute? What are your ideas of where we should spend? Where does the private sector come in, and what should they be focusing on?
My second question is with regard to youth unemployment. One of the issues I’ve been following is the idea of expanding the Canada Summer Jobs program, which employed about 100,000 young people this last summer. The proposal is to expand the program to run throughout the year, in the summer and fall.
I would like to know your thoughts on those two things.
Mr. Argitis: On the second one, I think it’s a good idea. The unemployment rate for youth is too high. The labour market slack that I talked about early on is largely an issue of younger workers, and that creates a lot of problems. We need to get our youth working and trained and optimistic, as well. We need to give them a reason to be optimistic. I think anything that keeps young people either employed or in school is a great idea.
On the execution front, this is something that we think about quite a lot. The government is working hard on that, too. The government is focused on the execution issues. Bill C-39 is about execution. We’re in a world right now where we’re demanding more from government, right? That’s the sovereignty agenda. We need the government to do more for us than it has in the past.
How effective the government is matters because government effectiveness — because we’re asking more of government — will have a real impact on our competitiveness. So everything from approvals to permitting, to procurement and risk-taking in government matters. There is a whole slew of things that the government can do to be more effective and to make sure that the government decides one thing and that, at the other end, you actually have an output that is not just bogged down in “proceduralism” or coordination failures, because coordination is a big problem as well.
We can go through the permitting. We can go through the jurisdictional issues that governments need to overcome, internal trade —
Senator Cardozo: I want to get Mr. Stanford’s opinion in as well. Thank you for that.
Mr. Stanford: Senator, let me take this moment to thank you and your office for working with other senators to inquire into the youth unemployment problem, in particular. I think you have shown tremendous initiative and gathered some great research and ideas.
Of course, youth unemployment is the sharp end of any labour market downturn. Young people are the last hired and the first fired, so it is always youth unemployment that shows the greatest strain when the labour market comes under pressure, as it has been. Typically, the youth unemployment rate is twice the overall rate. We have to have targeted measures to some extent. Of course, a stronger labour market tends to bring down the youth unemployment rate, among others, but we do need measures targeted at young people to help them get that first position and find some footing in the labour market. Extending the summer jobs program throughout the year and expanding its size are great ideas. Thank you again for your initiative on that, senator.
Senator Cardozo: Could you also comment on the first question about where the public and private sectors need to invest?
Mr. Stanford: Basically, all of the above. There is no doubt that investments throughout the economy, including in public infrastructure, can play a role. Affordable housing is another area where public capital can and should play a role. Having public capital in all its forms, both direct federal and provincial government funding and pension funding, playing a role — even on the industrial development side of things — will be important in showing that we’re putting our own money to work.
It is surprising and, in a way, disappointing to see that so much Canadian capital is invested abroad, including in the United States, at a moment when we’re marshalling all of our resources to try to defend our prosperity and our viability as a country, so finding innovative ways to put public capital to work outside of the normal sphere of public services and public infrastructure, I think, is an important priority at this moment.
Senator Cardozo: Thank you.
Senator Ross: Welcome to both of you. Mr. Argitis, you mentioned elevated inflation at around 3% and unemployment at 6.4%, and Mr. Stanford told us that an early warning sign is decelerating wages. With increased unemployment, do you see wages accelerating or continuing to decelerate, and why? What do you think the impact of that will be?
Mr. Argitis: With decreased unemployment? If we can manage to lower unemployment, that, naturally, will provide some momentum for wages. A tighter labour market typically does.
The numbers that I have seen are that wages are growing between 3% and 4% right now. There are various indicators for wages. I think Mr. Stanford mentioned one, but the numbers that I have seen are more like 3% to 4%, which is actually a slowdown from the rate of about 4% to 5% that we saw just after the inflation surge.
That has left real wages, as Jim mentioned, increasing. Fundamentally, an economy that is doing well, particularly one that is shifting resources into capital-intensive sectors, capital goods — one of the reasons we’ve had such lagging productivity in Canada is because our investment record has been so poor over the last decade or so. I think the more we invest in this economy, the faster wages will grow.
Mr. Stanford: The wage measure I mentioned was the most recent one from August, the Labour Force Survey. That was the average hourly wage growing at 2% year over year. It was growing at 3% to 4%, as Mr. Argitis mentioned, until about two or three months ago. We saw a significant slowdown over the summer.
Now, that could reflect various things. It does not immediately reflect any change in the balance of labour supply and demand. Our unemployment rate actually came down in that period. It probably reflects the lagged effects of uncertainty in the face of Trump and employers being more resistant to offering wage increases when they are not sure where the economy is going.
I do think it is a success story. I know there is a lot of concern about affordability in Canada, and rightly so. However, I do think it is a success story and that we should take a moment to appreciate that real wages in Canada were repaired after the inflationary shock of 2022-23. That is not true in many other industrial countries. It is a testament to the institutions that we have in Canada that empowered workers to say, “Look, prices are growing. I’ve got to have income that keeps up with prices.” That includes everything from strong improvements in the minimum wage that we have seen in most jurisdictions, including the federal minimum wage, and our strong collective bargaining system, which, again, gives workers a chance to collectively say, “We need to catch up here.”
This is where I come back to saying that we should appreciate the collective bargaining institutions, even though they cause inconvenience at times, not often though. You know 98% of collective agreements are resolved without work stoppages, but understand that they play a very important role in ensuring that workers defend their share of the economic pie.
Senator Ross: That leads to a second question. You mentioned your concern with the section of Bill C-39 that relates to labour. I’m interested in getting Mr. Argitis’ take on this. It seems to be contentious. However, it does correlate and correspond to a study completed by the Standing Senate Committee on Transport and Communications in June of this year. What is your take on that?
Mr. Argitis: I think there is a bigger picture with these changes. I don’t think you can isolate the changes that the government is proposing in this legislation. You can isolate it and remove it from the bigger economic picture, which is trying to generate some certainty and increase investment in the economy. It’s a three-pronged strategy. It’s the permitting and approval; it’s the supply chain issues and governance of things like ports; it’s the labour issues. That’s the one point I would say about that.
The measures that have been announced in Bill C-39 are moving in the right direction, for sure. It’s adding some transparency into collective bargaining, particularly in sectors where we have, actually, seen quite a few strikes. In 2024 and 2025, we saw more person-hours lost to work stoppages in those two years than we had seen in the previous 20 years combined. We are coming off a period of very heavy strike activity, particularly in what I would call chokepoints of the economy, and I think the government recognized that and are responding to it, and they are trying to do it in a way where they are not undermining collective bargaining.
Senator Ross: Thank you.
Any comments from Mr. Stanford?
Mr. Stanford: I think both sides in any collective agreement process would love to see it settled without work stoppages. The people who bear the costs first are any workers who have lost their work and their pay while it happens. In order for that to happen successfully, I think the integrity of the process has to be preserved.
There are some positive aspects of the Labour Code changes that have been proposed, but the key issue is that when the minister has the authority to intervene on a very arbitrary and subjective basis — the so-called national interest test — it throws the integrity of the whole process into doubt, and the parties start to game the process, knowing or guessing that the minister will come in at the end of the day and order an end to any work stoppage. Experience has shown that that’s very destructive to the long-run process.
Senator Ross: Thank you, both of you.
Senator Galvez: Thank you so much for your presence here and for answering our questions.
Mr. Argitis, you mentioned several times the short term, the medium term and the long term, and I think that the strategies must be different for each one of them. Right now, there is a big problem with our neighbour, and it’s immediate, and we have to solve it. But I was listening to Mr. Stanford talk about the types of projects.
Mr. Stanford, you are right when you say that we send our raw materials — take oil — and we sell it at $16, $20, $40 or $60 a barrel, and then it comes back as jet fuel or diesel at $300 or $400 a barrel. For sure, we are not doing this efficiently.
Because this infrastructure that we are planning to build has a lifespan of 60 if not 70 years, what type of infrastructure should we be building in order to ensure that, in 50 years, Canada is stronger than today and has passed the emergency of today in the short term?
We’re going to start with Mr. Stanford.
Mr. Stanford: Thank you, senator. You’re right; we have to be looking down the road. This is, obviously, a crisis that we are facing in our relationship with the United States, and it has put us under pressure on all fronts.
Certainly, we want to do everything that we can to promote more investment and more work, but we also have to be thinking about where the economy is headed. That’s certainly clear in the energy sector. This is where the knee-jerk focus on fossil fuel export infrastructure as a way of stimulating new investment and new work while we’re facing Mr. Trump is, I think, one-sided. We know that the global energy system is changing, and it is still going to keep changing.
Even though Donald Trump denies that climate change is a problem and has eliminated many of the U.S. policies to try and adjust to that, the rest of the world is still carrying on, and we are going to see a significant shift. We’re already seeing a significant shift towards renewable and non-emitting sources of energy, but Canada has to be front and centre.
Canada has enormous potential in that area as well, and, to be sure, some of the projects on that deal book that was handed out at the recent investment summit are about renewable energy, including investments in renewable energy infrastructure, critical minerals, battery manufacturing, et cetera, but I do think there has been an overemphasis in the immediate response to Mr. Trump on doubling down on fossil fuels as a source of future investment.
They have their role, of course, in the interim, but you’re quite right, senator; they’re an industry that’s on the way out. If Canada wants to be successful as that energy transition occurs, we need to have more foresight and more balance, I think, in the types of projects that we’re moving forward with.
Senator Galvez: Thank you.
Do you want to add anything?
Mr. Argitis: Sure. The only thing I would say there is that resources are Canada’s competitive advantage, and we are doubling down on our competitive advantage, especially at a time when we are facing threats that we weren’t facing two or three years ago. So, yes, you shore up your strengths when you’re under threat, and that’s what these industries are. They are Canada’s strength.
We talked about the short term, the immediate, the crisis. This is a crisis situation where our sovereignty is potentially threatened. What nation in the world would forgo the opportunity to have as leverage its most powerful asset at a time like this?
Senator Galvez: You have been talking about 1.8% and 2% growth. Where do these rates of growth come from? What is a good rate of growth, and why is it a good rate of growth?
Mr. Argitis: A good rate of growth is probably around 2%. It’s not exceptional. In today’s world, given some of the longer‑term structural forces, including slowing population growth, I think Canada would be happy with a sustainable 2% rate of growth.
But the issue that we’re talking about here in terms of doubling down on resources is not about growth; it’s about sovereignty. They align, but they’re not the same thing, right? There are times where you have to do things that might actually run counter to maximizing growth. We’re in the post-growth agenda. We’re in the era of sovereignty. These are two different things.
Senator Galvez: Thank you.
Senator MacDonald: Thank you, witnesses. My first question will be for Mr. Stanford.
You mentioned that wage growth is not keeping up with inflation, yet we often hear concerns that rising wages can themselves fuel inflation, creating a wage-price spiral. How do we distinguish between wage increases that restore workers’ purchasing power and those that add to inflationary pressures, and what role does productivity growth play in allowing wages to rise sustainably?
Mr. Stanford: That’s a great question, senator. Thank you very much.
In general, you want nominal wages to grow a little bit faster than inflation so that real wages are growing at a slow but sustainable pace over time, maybe by 1% a year.
What we saw in the post-pandemic inflation episode, starting in 2022, was that inflation initially declined during the pandemic lockdowns, but then, coming out of the lockdowns, for various reasons — including shortages, supply chain disruptions, the energy price shock arising from the invasion of Ukraine and, to be frank, a significant amount of profit-taking by companies that were opportunistically taking advantage of that moment to increase their profit margins — we saw, in 2022, when inflation reached 8%, corporate profits as a share of GDP reach their highest level in Canadian history. While Canadians were grappling with an affordability crisis, profits had never been higher. All of those factors drove that uptick in inflation.
Wages were not one of them. You can see in the data very clearly that wages lagged the acceleration of inflation at that time. Today, we’ve had a restoration of real wages after that shock, as I mentioned, which I think is positive. We’re now in a moment where we could see that starting to come undone. At this very moment, year-over-year wage growth is below year‑over-year inflation, but year-over-year inflation has been pushed up — hopefully temporarily — by the latest energy price shock that would be from the war in Iran.
Now, if that inflationary pressure does not spread through the rest of the economy and accelerate, then we might be okay. If it does, then we’re going to see both a decline in purchasing power for workers and probably higher interest rates from the Bank of Canada, which will make everything worse. Fingers crossed that the war in the Middle East reaches a conclusion and energy prices start to come back down. But in this moment as well, it’s clear that it’s not wages leading; it’s wages following, presumably, if inflation from the Middle East continues to grow.
You have to look at the numbers, basically, to answer your question. How do you know whether it’s wages causing inflation or wages catching up to inflation? The timing is part of it and decomposing who’s capturing more of the pie as a result of inflation; these are ways to tell whether it’s wage-price inflation or something else.
Senator MacDonald: Mr. Stanford, the government is arguing that the changes to the Labour Code actually serve to implement guardrails around the government’s ability to intervene in labour disputes. From your previous comments, do I understand correctly that you disagree with this particular approach?
Mr. Stanford: I do, sir. What we’ve seen in the last handful of years is the government’s use of section 107 in the Labour Code, which had been there for decades but had not been used. It has become kind of a regular tool. In the olden days, when the government decided that a strike in a critical service area was out of hand, they would pass back-to-work legislation and go through a democratic process. Section 107 doesn’t do that. Section 107 gives the minister the power to just jump right in. So far, that has been contested. In fact, there are fundamental court challenges to the minister’s ability to do that under section 107. We can’t take it for granted that that’s a normal way of doing things.
Now, what the changes to the Labour Code would do is they do specify certain processes that have to happen before that type of power is used and set out this national interest test, along with a couple of others, that will supposedly guide the minister in doing that. But you’re taking a power that is contested and could be constitutionally overruled and codifying it. That’s what I don’t like about that aspect of the law.
Now, this law will be challenged as well, rest assured. The potential that this law will be seen by the courts to contravene Charter rights to freedom of assembly, including normal collective bargaining rights, I’d say the chances of that are quite high. This won’t settle the issue, but I do think that it codifies a practice that has been ad hoc and anti-democratic.
Senator MacDonald: Thank you.
Senator Gignac: Good morning to the witnesses. My two questions are to Mr. Stanford on two different topics.
The first one is with regard to the temporary excise tax. In early September, you released a paper mentioning that it’s another Band-Aid. You pointed out that, in fact, the refiners’ profit margins skyrocketed in the second quarter compared to the previous quarter. You referred to StatCan figures that indicate they have jumped by 80%. You proposed different options that the federal government and the Minister of Finance must consider, including one they used with Canadian banks during COVID, with special taxes and profits. Could you elaborate on that? This extension will be a significant cost to the taxpayer. Overall, it will be about $5 billion.
Mr. Stanford: Thank you, senator, for all that research. I hope you have a large research staff helping you dig out those old blogs that I wrote. That’s great. Thank you.
The excise tax, of course, that’s 10 cents per litre on gasoline and 4 cents on diesel. They’ve been around for decades. The gasoline tax has been set at 10 cents, in nominal terms, since the mid-1990s. Nobody can say that these taxes caused inflation, yet that is an argument you hear from some quarters. The government, I think, for political reasons, decided they would take this measure initially to last until Labour Day, but now it’s extended until the end of January to try and ease a bit of the pain for consumers. There is a significant cost to it. It kind of relates to Senator MacDonald’s question of what the causes of inflation were in the first place, and this was clearly an imported energy price shock, even though we produce the energy ourselves. This is another issue about how we set petroleum prices in Canada, but, rightly or wrongly, we just follow the global roller coaster today.
You have a situation where the clear driver of this are the profits in the petroleum sector. The cost of production in Canada of the energy that we use here has not changed because of the war in Iran, but the prices charged have risen by up to 50%. This has led to a record flow of profits, particularly, as you mentioned, senator, in the refining sector.
First of all, instead of the excise tax reduction to ease the pain for consumers, I proposed an expansion of the groceries and essentials credit, which I think is a fair way to distribute some assistance to people, including lower-income people, but also people who don’t drive cars. In that regard, I think it’s fair.
How would you pay for it? I would say go to where the problem started, and that is the fact that we have a petroleum pricing system in Canada that allows companies to charge world prices, even though the cost of production in Canada has not changed. You could set an excess profits tax in the petroleum sector above a certain threshold that could be defined in regard to a normal return on capital or a historical average return on capital and, in that way, pay for the cost of the improved Groceries and Essentials Benefit that is necessitated because of those high petroleum prices. I hope that answered the question.
Senator Gignac: Thank you. We will be meeting with the Minister of Finance on Thursday in the Senate. It’s my intention to raise your study.
Shifting topics, how long can Canada afford this strategy of dollar-for-dollar counter-tariffs? Our trade with the U.S. is 20% of our GDP. For the U.S., trade with Canada is only 2% of their GDP. Is it possible to maintain this kind of strategy over the long run?
Mr. Stanford: I agreed with Mr. Argitis earlier when he said that the counter-tariffs are about trying to discourage further actions from the United States. The counter-tariffs themselves won’t help the Canadian industry very much. It’s more a question of how we manage the relationship with the United States and show that we’re not just going to roll over. In that regard, I support them, but the counter-tariffs, in and of themselves, won’t solve anything.
In the long run, it is true that the Americans are less dependent on exports to Canada as a share of GDP, but I often think that’s a misleading comparison because, in aggregate terms, the number of jobs, the amount of value and the number of sales are as large as it is in Canada. Our trade was largely balanced. It’s a huge trade, almost $1 trillion in both directions, and they have as much at stake as we do. I think it’s a mistake to assume that because, proportionately, it’s smaller as a share of the U.S. economy, they aren’t feeling it. They are feeling it, and that is one of the reasons why I think Mr. Trump and his team have been so aggressive lately.
Senator Dalphond: Thank you very much to our panel members this morning. This is very interesting.
This morning, I think, in Vancouver, there will be a major announcement about the additional capacity to export liquefied natural gas toward Asia. My question is for you, Mr. Stanford, because you are based in Vancouver, so you will be watching carefully.
Would that be the wrong direction for you because this would be more raw materials being exported? And if this is a good move, isn’t it logical, then, to infer that we should also build a pipeline towards the east in order to be able to send liquefied natural gas to Europe?
Mr. Stanford: Thank you, senator. Yes, I saw that news come across first thing this morning while I was brewing that very big cup of coffee to get ready for the hearing today.
On the one hand, obviously, it’s going to be good news in terms of job creation for a while, while the LNG expansion is completed. It’s a very large number of jobs that last for a few years. The LNG plant, once it’s completed, has very little employment, so it isn’t a long-run project. There are drawbacks to the LNG export strategy.
One of them is, interestingly enough, sooner or later it will make natural gas more expensive in Canada. Right now, natural gas is historically cheap in Canada because we have much more gas than we can use and can export to the Americans. The experience of other jurisdictions like Australia shows that as you open up a significant export flow to world markets, you see some arbitrage in prices, and we will see Canadian natural gas prices grow. That’s one point that hasn’t been acknowledged.
Second, of course, the emissions, not just from the combustion of natural gas by whoever buys it, but also in the process of liquefying it. It’s a very energy-intensive process. Now, B.C. says they’re going to try to use more electricity to do the liquefaction rather than using gas, as is done at present, but even that has costs, of course, because electricity supply is going to be constrained in the future.
So there is an immediate hit in terms of investment in job creation from a big project like this. Again, Mr. Argitis mentioned that, but as a long-run strategy, we have to be very careful.
On the issue of pipelines to the East, we have got good reasons to do more pipelines to the East, first and foremost, to meet our own needs, particularly in parts of Quebec and Atlantic Canada. We aren’t using our own energy sufficiently, so that is a worthwhile direction.
For liquefied gas to Europe, that, again, is another opportunity, but with the same drawbacks as I mentioned for the LNG plants here on the West Coast.
Senator Dalphond: To try to build the industry’s capacity, don’t you think we should use — I think this is the strategy of the government — the increased military expenses to manufacture in Canada large parts of what we’re going to build in terms of new planes, new armoury and new tools we’re going to buy just to meet the NATO requirements? Maybe the question is for Mr. Argitis.
Mr. Argitis: Defence clearly is the one industry that can offset any lost market share in the U.S. Clearly, this is the government’s intention — to use defence as a way to make up for whatever losses we have in the U.S. market. That’s a longer‑term play, but if the government is going to be spending, say, $100 billion a year on defence in 10 years from now, their intention is obviously to use that money to build a defence sector in Canada that can create really good manufacturing jobs and industrial capacity.
On the issue of LNG, if I may, just one advantage of having this additional export capacity is it generates foreign exchange. It allows us to sell things and receive receipts in that revenue. Even if employment after the construction phase falls, the revenues generated from those exports get funnelled through the economy, they keep interest rates low, and they allow us to finance many other things. So there is a recurring and ongoing benefit to exporting things that people around the world want to buy, and we use that money to enhance economic growth and foster prosperity at home. So it’s not just about jobs.
Senator Dalphond: Thank you.
Senator MacAdam: Thank you to the witnesses for being here this morning. My first question is for Mr. Argitis.
When you last appeared before the committee, we discussed tax reform, the importance of improving Canada’s competitiveness and attracting investment, and I know that the council has welcomed the government’s expansion of the 100% accelerated capital cost recovery. But your September 8 pre‑budget submission asks for a corporate tax review; 100% expensing for oil and gas, mining, pipelines, power, LNG, and fibre; EIFEL repeal; and reassessed financial sector taxes. I’m wondering how much of that agenda is reflected in what has been announced since August 25 and what’s outstanding.
Mr. Argitis: Yes, the one big tax announcement was the accelerated capital cost and the full expensing of capital cost expenses, which is a very important tax measure. It will have an impact on the appetite for companies to make these massive investments in major projects. There’s no question about it. And it actually may make a huge difference in the oil sector, in particular.
If our objective is to increase oil production, Premier Danielle Smith’s objective is to double oil production, and Prime Minister Mark Carney’s objective is to double exports by 2035, we’re going to need more oil production, so this is going to make a difference.
Now, on the other issues, we still want them to do a broader tax review of corporate taxation. We think the system could be simpler, more neutral and more predictable. I would classify the capital cost stuff as immediate things, but we still need a broader tax review of the corporate tax system.
Senator MacAdam: So I have a question for Mr. Stanford. The Parliamentary Budget Officer now projects Ottawa’s operating budget won’t balance until 2029-30, a year later than what the government claims. You have argued in the past that the technical recession debate is a distraction and that deficit spending through the tariff shock remains appropriate. Are there any indicators or ratios related to debt or the deficit that would cause you concern?
Mr. Stanford: The one that is worth watching in particular is the debt-to-GDP ratio, which measures the stock of debt versus the economy’s ability to service debt in a way. In that regard, I am of the view that deficits are not public enemy number one, and the government’s priority, in general, should not be to try and balance the books, even the operating books. But you do have to watch the stockpile of debt as a share of GDP, and in that regard the outlook over the coming period isn’t bad. Canada’s net debt as a share of GDP is low relative to other industrial countries and does not seem to be growing.
This relates to my opening comments about public sector downsizing and, I would say, a misplaced emphasis on cutting the civil service at a moment when civil service jobs help the economy just like any other jobs do. So in that regard, we have to be careful about a kind of knee-jerk emphasis on reducing deficits as a top priority; we have more important things to worry about right now.
Senator MacAdam: Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: My question is for Mr. Stanford. You talked earlier about Canadian pension funds investment in Canada. It sounds like you’re saying it’s not optimal. I look forward to seeing tangible results from the summit that was held. It does not seem like the government wants to adopt a coercive approach to encouraging pension funds to invest more in Canada. In fact, most of the money they invest in Canada is in Canadian bonds. There is no venture capital or significant capital investment in infrastructure. There has been some interest in buying airports already in operation, but the economic added value of a change in airport ownership would not have a major effect on the Canadian economy.
Other than asking the funds to invest, what should the government do? What more should it do to encourage pension funds to invest in Canada, particularly in infrastructure or housing, or where the investment would make it possible to launch projects and leave a mark, beyond changing airport ownership?
[English]
Mr. Stanford: Thank you, senator. That’s a great question. You’re quite right to draw a distinction between just changing ownership of an asset and calling that an investment, versus actually building something and adding to Canada’s productive capacity. Changing the ownership of airports would do nothing.
I can see why financial investors, including pension funds, like the idea because it would be a very stable, long-run, consistently profitable asset to own. That’s why even Canadian pension funds have bought airports in other countries that made the decision to privatize. From the investors’ point of view, it’s very attractive, but from the Canadian public interest point of view, I do not see any benefit in that at all.
There is an opportunity to — without being coercive — at least recognize that pension funds in Canada are tax-assisted. They get significant fiscal benefits from the way we treat pension funds and an advantage from that. I think it’s reasonable to expect a quid pro quo for that. So, if you’re going to be encouraged to invest in a pension fund and the tax benefits that come with pension funds, there is an expectation that they contribute to Canada’s future economic development, without being coercive about it. There are things you could do. For example, there was a proposal to require pension funds in their risk analysis to attribute an extra degree of risk to investments outside of Canada to reflect exchange rate volatility and other potential variables. This was one of the proposals that was tossed out a couple of years ago to try to encourage pension funds to bring more of their money back to Canada.
Part of the deal is also going to involve stimulating new investments in all of these different industries that pension funds can be part of building. It’s not just a shortage of capital; it’s a shortage of projects that probably helps to explain why pension funds haven’t invested more in Canada.
I think a combination of moving forward with many of the projects in that deal book from the investment summit, but also working with pension funds and saying we need Canadian capital being used to build and defend Canada’s economy at this point in history and think about some of the regulatory tools that could prod that — I think that would be a promising combination.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much.
For our second panel, we are pleased to welcome, from the Forest Products Association of Canada, by video conference, Derek Nighbor, Chief Executive Officer. Finally, from the Canadian Steel Producers Association, Mr. John Cuddihy, Vice‑President, Climate and Environment.
Welcome and thank you for accepting our invitation.
We will now hear opening remarks from Mr. Nighbor.
Mr. Nighbor, you have the floor.
[English]
Derek Nighbor, President and Chief Executive Officer, Forest Products Association of Canada: Thank you, chair and honourable senators, for the invitation to be with you today. I’m sorry I’m not able to be there in person.
As the leader of the Forest Products Association of Canada and the Canadian Wood Council, I’m also a proud son and grandson of unionized pulp and paper workers from the upper Ottawa Valley. I’m also somebody who worked in the sector to help pay to put myself through school.
In communities like Pembroke, Ontario, where I grew up, forest sector jobs continue to matter. Across hundreds of communities from coast to coast, nearly 200,000 Canadians are directly employed in the forest sector; that’s more than the auto, steel and aluminum sectors combined. It is why the Prime Minister has designated forestry as one of Canada’s strategic manufacturing sectors.
In 2025, Canadian forestry contributed nearly $20 billion in real GDP, and we exported over $36 billion worth of wood, pulp and paper products to the world. We are also a major customer of Canada’s railways, ports and its trucking networks. In the communities we call home, mills and woodland operations support municipal services, employees, contractors, suppliers, local businesses and those families.
Despite a growing demand for wood products and Canada’s abundant resources, this economic foundation is under serious pressure. Since 2014, at least 61 mills have permanently closed or been indefinitely idled, with approximately 12,600 direct jobs lost. I know for Senator Ross, we had difficult news in the community of Nackawic, New Brunswick; in recent days 350 jobs in that community were lost. It is a difficult time for our sector. In communities like Nackawic, a mill closure can put an entire community’s future at risk.
There is no single cause right now, but the current trade environment is making a difficult situation worse. Combined U.S. duties and tariffs place a burden of 45% now on softwood lumber from Canada going into the United States and across another over $5 billion worth of our products going to the U.S. They are facing tariffs anywhere from 25% to 85%, with some of the tariffs piling up on each other.
These unjustified measures affect primary and secondary manufactures, from sawmills to plywood panels, furniture, cabinets, other value-added products and private woodlot owners. That hurts Canadian workers, and it makes little economic sense for the United States economically.
Canada’s forest products sector supports an integrated North American economy and supplies American builders and manufacturers with needed materials for their affordable housing crisis. With both countries facing these housing shortages, making building materials more expensive is not going to help us build more homes. A durable resolution to the softwood lumber dispute and the removal of section 232 and section 338 tariffs remain top priorities for our sector.
Here at home, we also have work to do. It’s a bit of controlling the controllable. Improvements to the operating environment must apply not only to major projects, but to strategic sectors like forestry. Mills need reliable access to fibre or to wood supply, without navigating overlapping federal and provincial processes to achieve the same outcome.
Mr. Argitis talked earlier about the accelerated capital cost measures. Those are appreciated; targeted retooling can help turn private sector plans into projects and improve productivity and jobs. Those investments will only succeed if our products can reach customers. More accountable rail services and modern trade infrastructure will help us become a more reliable supplier.
And we also have an opportunity — it’s more incremental, but it’s important — to use more Canadian wood here at home, through procurement, Build Canada Homes and military housing. I know the Department of National Defence, or DND, has announced almost $4 billion in military housing. How do we get more Canadian wood into those projects? Faster product approvals, harmonized building codes — there are a lot of ways government can be a force for good here to support us domestically.
So our sector is ready to do its part. We hold much faith in the to-be-announced forest sector transformation strategy that we expect Minister Hodgson to table before the end of the year. We feel, in the face of the challenges, we still have a generational opportunity to protect and grow jobs, to strengthen communities and to build a more competitive Canadian economy.
In closing, I wanted to add our voice to the tributes to Senator Lewis these days. He was a giant of agriculture. As a committed land manager and someone who cared about the land, he cared a lot about forestry as well. There is a lot of forestry north of Saskatoon in the province of Saskatchewan. I just wanted to give my respects and salute all of the work that Senator Lewis did for us, for agriculture and for Canada. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you. Thank you very much, in particular, for your kind words regarding Senator Lewis.
[English]
John Cuddihy, Vice-President, Climate and Environment, Canadian Steel Producers Association: Good morning, and thank you for the opportunity to address the Standing Senate Committee on National Finance.
The Canadian Steel Producers Association, the CSPA, is a national voice of all primary steel producers in Canada, as well as some of the country’s largest steel consumers. Our 17 members supply essential materials to key sectors, such as automotive, energy, construction and transportation, driving jobs and economic growth across North America. Our 40‑member facilities act as local industrial anchor institutions supporting massive ecosystems of local suppliers, contractors, logistic providers and downstream manufacturers.
Steel production is vital for Canada’s sovereignty and its long‑term economic prosperity.
The previous 20 months have been challenging. Canada’s steel industry is facing growing pressures from ongoing threats to fair and open trade by the United States, declining domestic demand and limited export opportunities and high levels of import competition, frequently from unfairly traded steel, arising from global excess steel production capacity.
The Government of Canada has implemented important measures to support a level playing field for Canadian steel producers in their own domestic market, to support Canadian steel producers in pivoting their production to capture a larger share of the domestic market and to enforce trade remedies. These measures are all critical. Without them, we would be in much worse shape.
However, there remains important work to do for Canada to maintain a viable steel production sector.
For the last 30-plus years, Canadian steel producers have been operating in a fully integrated North American market, with both primary forms of steel and products containing steel, or what we call derivatives, flowing back and forth over the border, often multiple times, before finding their way to the end consumer.
Canada has historically shipped about half of its production, or 6 million tonnes, south to the United States every year. Shipments from Canada to the United States over the first half of 2026 are down almost 60% relative to 2024, the last year resembling any normalcy. Canadian steel producers have been facing 50% tariffs for almost 16 months now and faced 25% tariffs for the three months prior to that.
On September 15, three categories of structural steel were subjected to an additional stacked 50% tariff affecting a number of CSPA member companies as well as downstream steel fabricators. In addition, the United States administration has placed 50% tariffs on the total value of steel derivative products, rendering exports non-viable and placing significant pressure on fabricators and manufacturers to relocate their operations.
These are our customers. If we cannot ship to the United States and our customers cannot ship to the United States, a significant portion of our market disappears. Both steel producers and our customers are under pressure in our domestic market from offshore imports, frequently unfairly traded steel. This further erodes our and their customer base. Unfair trade refers to a suite of government interventions and market manipulation that distort normal pricing, including dumping, state subsidization and currency manipulation. The ultimate goal of unfair trade is explicitly to undermine domestic steel production capacity in export markets so as to dominate them over the longer term.
It is in response to these continuing and mounting pressures that the CSPA and its members are calling on the government to take further action. We’re seeking a deepening of Canada’s surtax on steel derivative products to 50% and an expansion of products covered to protect our domestic customer base, Canadian manufacturers, from unfairly traded imports.
We’re also calling on the government to take explicit steps to protect its right to regulate steel imports and support the domestic steel industry as Canada vigorously pursues free trade agreements.
We fully understand the need to diversify Canada’s trade, recognizing that global exports are not a viable option for steel in the context of global excess capacity. We need to ensure that our pursuit of trade relationships does not undermine the measures in place to protect Canadian steel production. A number of countries with whom we have and are pursuing free trade agreements are notorious unfair traders of steel.
We also need to do work to bolster Canada’s trade remedy system. This is a set of tools available to domestic producers to pursue unfair traders of steel under trade law. There is potential to improve both Canada’s anti-circumvention legislation and the methods by which dumping margins are calculated.
Lastly, we are calling on the Government of Canada to continue prioritizing Canadian steel in infrastructure and public projects by expanding Canadian-content requirements beyond procurement to incentive programs, federal grants and contributions and major projects receiving federal support and by working with the provinces and territories to adjust procurement requirements at all levels of government.
While the government has noted that the Buy Canadian Policy will apply across federal departments, agencies and Crown corporations, the rollout is not consistent, and the application is variable. There is strong political will and commitment, but the implementation needs further focused attention. Strong Buy Canadian measures referencing melt-and-pour provisions would help ensure that public investments maximize the economic benefits available for Canadian workers, manufacturers and communities while reinforcing the long-term competitiveness and resilience of Canada’s steel industry.
I would like to close by reiterating our thanks for the measures taken to date. Our continued call for support is not highlighting a lack of effort on the part of the government but a worsening situation that calls for deeper and more considered action.
Thank you for your interest in Canada’s steel sector. I would be more than happy to take your questions.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much.
Senator Forest: This issue is particularly close to my heart.
Mr. Nighbor, from the perspective of buying more Canadian, I would like to talk about a real champion company, Chantiers Chibougamau, which provides exceptional performance, particularly in the area of glue-laminated timber beams.
Are provincial and territorial regulations, building codes or other provisions preventing us from developing our own domestic market?
[English]
Mr. Nighbor: It’s a good question. Chantiers Chibougamau is a great example of Nordic Structures. It is a really great integrated business that they have — a pulp mill, a sawmill and a mass timber facility. They provide a lot of products right across the country and into the United States.
On building codes, I would say a couple of things. Nationally, the building code cycle is a five-year cycle, which involves a lot of very detailed technical work. That can slow the progress of opportunities to advance things. So, we have had more, in terms of innovating codes, in working with provincial building codes, which often adopt off-cycle opportunities. B.C. and Ontario are right now looking at a number of opportunities. For sure, there is an opportunity there.
It doesn’t begin and end there, though, senator. One of the challenges in talking to home builders is that they are saying, “If we want to build faster and cheaper, you can’t be piling on a lot of code changes, because we can’t keep up. We’ve got to train the people to build in certain ways.” But there are ways, through standard code harmonization measures, to get rid of some of the bureaucracy.
There are some more innovative engineered wood products that are not available to be used in Canada right now. They are sitting through one- or two-year approval cycles. How do we move faster there? Definitely, new opportunities exist, both through harmonization and very complicated technical stuff, but a real opportunity definitely exists to move forward both at the provincial and at the national level.
[Translation]
Senator Forest: What main issue would we need to address to accelerate the use of our natural resources in construction?
[English]
Mr. Nighbor: John talked a bit about it in terms of Buy Canadian. The intent there is really good. We are still in the early days of implementation here, but we must make sure we get this right. On the mass timber and engineered wood side, we are building buildings in ways we were never building them before. In some parts of the country, we can build 18 storeys of mass timber, but sometimes the way that the request-for-proposal or procurement process hits the street is not really designed in a way that is open to that.
That’s my biggest challenge to government procurement — to be thinking about some of the biggest successes we have had. I toured the Chalk River nuclear laboratories a few weeks ago. It was somebody at Natural Resources Canada who called the Chalk River Laboratories to say, “Hey, have you thought about rebuilding these buildings with mass timber?” “No, we didn’t.” That was actually a Nordic Structures project in Chalk River, Ontario.
The government needs to ensure, across departments, that we are doing everything possible to make it easier to get Canadian steel and Canadian wood products and more of our homemade stuff into government procurement.
[Translation]
Senator Forest: Thank you.
[English]
Senator Cardozo: I have three questions, and either of you can answer whichever ones you like.
First, I would like to know how your industries are faring in diversifying your trade and export. We have a number of free trade agreements; we will have some more. Are your companies able to use those agreements? Are they moving off the American trade front and seriously looking at other areas?
Second, you talked about your materials going back and forth across the border in the production process. Is there any benefit — long-term, perhaps — with their not being able to go back and forth in that we would develop more manufacturing and finishing facilities within Canada?
Third, with regard to small businesses, are they able to get a piece of the action when we are talking about major projects? I say this because we have been hearing in another committee that, in the defence industry, the small companies just aren’t able to get in there. Only the bigger ones can do that.
Maybe, Mr. Cuddihy, could you start?
Mr. Cuddihy: Sure. Thank you, senator. With regard to the steel sector’s ability to leverage free trade agreements, the steel sector is very much under the gun from a global situation where we have a global excess capacity of steel. We’re looking at probably going toward 2027 in the range of 721 million tonnes of excess capacity.
Canada’s steel market is between 12 and 15 million tonnes in any given year. We produce between 12 and 13 million tonnes. Typically, the United States needs 26 million per year. China alone produces 108 million tonnes of excess capacity, which is close to eight times our market in extra steel. That steel on the global market puts pressure on everybody to then export in the context to other markets.
When we’re looking at exporting to global markets, we’re facing that pressure from outside. It’s not generally a viable option for us, certainly in terms of commodity steel. When it comes to specialized steel, we have a number of smaller producers who are leveraging those relationships and providing exports to Europe and to other places. Typically, our trade has been in North America.
When we look at diversification right now, it’s really about reorienting toward increasing the Canadian market share — what we can capture within our borders. Typically, we can supply 80% of our demand in terms of the products we make. The CSPA members are looking at increasing that further to understand what else we can do to supply our domestic market.
The challenge is 30-plus years of integrated trade, where we are getting products from the U.S. that we don’t make, and we’re sending products there where we have excess capacity. That’s a bit of a challenge, but that’s where the government support programs, the strategic relief fund and other elements are definitely helping.
There is still more work to do in terms of working with the government to try to capture some of those opportunities. It’s a long-term game.
Senator Cardozo: Thank you.
Mr. Nighbor, I would like to hear your comments.
Mr. Nighbor: I will talk about the pivot or the diversification opportunity. It’s incremental. That is not to say that it’s not worth doing, but we need to be realistic about the opportunity. We sell about $14 billion of lumber and wood products to the U.S. every year. It took us about 50 years to build a billion-dollar business in Japan.
There is an opportunity to do more in markets like Japan, but it involves a couple of years of prime work on building codes and working with locals and working with governments over there and training their people to build with our innovative wood products. It takes time. It’s not a matter of just putting sticks on a boat and sending them somewhere else; it’s not quite that easy. But it’s an opportunity that is important to pursue.
Early on in the diversification push, our concern was that the government might be viewing diversification as being a magic bullet to avoid the carnage with the U.S. It’s not that easy, but it’s important.
What more can we do here at home? There will be opportunities in Japan, China, South Korea and looking towards the EU, but it’s not going to offset $14 billion worth of wood products annually.
Senator Cardozo: Right. Thanks.
Senator Ross: My question is for Mr. Nighbor.
As you know, 84% of New Brunswick is forested, and 1 in 17 New Brunswickers work in the forest industry, so it is critically important to New Brunswick.
You mentioned the announcement last week of AV Group that it will be idling the Nackawic pulp mill at the end of October. That will affect 350 workers. That’s half of the local tax base there. They talked about difficult market conditions and broader macroeconomic factors. They also stopped purchasing wood back in August.
I have a couple of questions. What will the hardwood producers in New Brunswick do with their hardwood, because we have seen private woodlot owners’ sales plummet. It seems that support goes to the larger players in the industry. Another 257 hectares of Crown land that was being used by AV Group will be up for grabs. What should become of that?
We export about 80% of our forest products to the U.S. That’s a huge impact. What are the solutions for New Brunswick’s forest industry?
Mr. Nighbor: I feel for that community, having visited there a couple of times as well. Having grown up in a community like that, I know what the impact is. You mentioned the tenure and who will have access. There is a significant private woodlot element there, but it will be up to Premier Holt and Minister Herron in terms of how the Province of New Brunswick wants to deal with those lands. That’s the first thing in terms of the public land components of forestry that would be happening there.
Natural Resources Canada, or NRCan, has done a good job of trying to build a one-window portal to help companies, regardless of size, navigate some of the different programs. There are so many programs; it is very overwhelming. It is tough for smaller businesses to navigate that. NRCan can be helpful. BDC has been helpful there, but we need a more sustainable solution.
Nackawic is the fifth mill we have lost in this country in the past few months. We lost a mill in Prince George; Crofton on Vancouver Island; Howe Sound on Vancouver Island; Temiscaming in the province of Quebec, not far from North Bay, Ontario; and Nackawic. We have a residuals crisis in this country now.
There are two things that we are looking to work with the federal government on. One is how we put a ring around those mills that are still remaining, that still have potential. There are some tremendous mills. Atholville still has a very good mill in your province. What can be done in Atholville to protect that mill for the future if we get the right partnership on the ground with ownership and the local community? The mills in Hinton, Alberta, and Dryden, Ontario, and Thunder Bay, Ontario, and Whitecourt — we have some great mills in this country. Unfortunately, a lot of them have boilers from the 1970s. What more do we need to do in partnership to shore up some of these assets that have a clear future?
But I am worried about the woodlot owners. I’m also worried, in our public forests, about the residuals or the chips or the low‑grade wood that continues to pile up. We have a federal government electricity strategy which isn’t talking about biomass. One of the things we can do with those residuals — and it’s faster and can be expedited in some cases — is how we turn that as part of our energy security play. There is an Indigenous engagement component here too. This is not easy. I’m not saying this is easy to do, but we need to really lean in to address this growing pulp wood and chip residuals crisis in this country. The alternative is that if it continues to pile up, the fires will get worse.
Senator Ross: Thank you.
Senator Galvez: My question is for Mr. Cuddihy. The government’s Building Canada Strong agenda is expected to generate significant domestic demand for steel in housing, shipbuilding, industry, transportation, trains. Are you saying that this will not compensate for what we are losing because of the tariff war with the U.S.? That’s more or less what I think you said in the previous question.
If that’s the case, and we don’t have Canadian content requirements and things that can facilitate more uptake of our own steel, according to you, what else can we do in order to attenuate this?
Mr. Cuddihy: The Buy Canadian policy is critical. It’s really excellent. Public Services and Procurement Canada has the gold standard in terms of what that procurement looks like: focusing on steel that is melted and poured in Canada.
There is no silver bullet, and with the volumes of steel going to the U.S. — 6 million tonnes per year — it will be difficult to find a home for all that steel in Canada. Certainly, we can do better, and we’re looking to do that. The Buy Canadian strategy and propagating the Buy Canadian strategy more broadly can certainly help that and is important. It gives a signal to the private sector as well.
What would be super helpful in that context is federal leadership working with the provinces and territories. When you think about infrastructure spending, the vast majority of that spending happens at the provincial and municipal levels. Municipalities are creatures of the provinces. There are examples where provinces are taking leadership in creating Buy Canadian provincial policies. Those initiatives are excellent. Where they are lacking right now is certainly in referencing melt and pour. Steel that is made in Canada from a 51% perspective because of the value of human labour does not necessarily necessitate steel that is produced in Canada. That melted and poured steel that is produced here is important.
Senator Galvez: Thank you. In my last conversation with people in charge of the building codes, they said we will have a cycle of three years instead of five years. That is a disappointment. I will be looking to push on this.
Because Senator Forest asked my question, I want to ask you this: What is the impact of forest fires in your industry? I had the opportunity to talk to two provincial governments, and they were really worried about this. What do you see globally?
Mr. Nighbor: It’s tough. I’m actually at international meetings with my counterparts around the world this week, which is why I can’t be with you in person. The top things being talked about globally are residuals, energy security, what can be done with fibre, fire risk mitigation and housing. Everybody is talking about this around the world.
In our industry, there is what we would call a northern cut line or a limit across the boreal forest where we would not be harvesting. We are seeing a couple of things. One is areas in the managed forest where we’re not harvesting enough, and this is where we have to have some difficult conversations about values on the land base and managing for whole ecosystems and species at risk, which are very important, but there are a lot of federal requirements around single-species interventions that could have a consequence for wildfires. We’re caught in this difficult value clash, if you will. That’s something in the managed forest. We need to change that conversation in a way that gets back to multiple values in a way that supports the push and the pursuit of supporting species at risk.
Then we have the more northern fires. I was in Thunder Bay this summer with that really big fire, but that was way above where we would even harvest. You have some Indigenous Peoples who call those communities home. Our ability to get into an area like that is very difficult. We have a lot of trees in Canada. When we talk about fire risk, we need to be thinking about the managed forest opportunity and then what is north of that and if there’s anything at all we can do about that.
Coming out of Jasper, we have seen a real shift finally, I hope, about the benefits of proactively managing and firebreaking communities. That’s expensive. Municipalities need more help there, for sure.
Senator MacAdam: Mr. Cuddihy, Ottawa’s Buy Canadian policy, which we have talked about already, requires Canadian materials on federal contracts of $25 million or more, where at least $250,000 of those materials are steel, with the Prime Minister projecting over $1 billion in new domestic demand.
How much of that $1 billion has materialized in signed contracts? What share of the federal steel purchases today is Canadian-melted?
Mr. Cuddihy: That’s very difficult to track. We don’t have numbers specifically on the number of projects. We are trying to look at what that looks like in terms of major projects coming out where they are designated or not, but, unfortunately, I don’t have numbers for you on that.
Senator MacAdam: Okay. We will soon be looking at Bill C-31, which seeks to give the Defence Investment Agency the authority, independence and resources it needs to modernize and accelerate defence and national security procurement.
From the perspective of Canada’s steel industry, what opportunities does this create for domestic steel producers? What are the significant procurement barriers preventing Canadian firms from fully participating? What steps need to be taken so that Canadian steel producers can fully participate in this defence industrial strategy?
Mr. Cuddihy: Significant focus on investment in the defence industry and looking at how to create domestic supply chains, both from a security perspective and from an economic perspective, are hugely valuable. You can’t underestimate that. I don’t have specific numbers in terms of what that looks like for Canadian steel producers. We’re definitely looking at it. There are certainly examples of individual contracts and initiatives where that seems to be super positive.
There’s a bit of “wait and see” as well. There’s a lot going on in that space right now. There’s a lot that’s coming, and I would say that there are certainly a number of different Canadian steel producers heavily engaged in that space. We look forward to it and are geared to respond to that need.
Senator MacAdam: And in terms of domestic and interprovincial transportation issues regarding steel, are there significant barriers there? There was a transportation rebate, I believe, so to what extent is that helping to grow domestic and provincial demand?
Mr. Cuddihy: Absolutely. We’re grateful to the government for implementing that program. Transportation costs are variable, so it can form up to, I believe, 20% to 25% at the high end of purchased steel costs. So it can be very important.
We can provide steel across Canada. One of the challenges we face, particularly in Western Canada, is steel coming in from offshore at prices that are 35% to 50% of the domestic market’s. That’s when we get into the space of talking about dumped steel. At that level, it’s difficult to compete, even with support from the federal government, on the transportation side.
That said, in our industry, previously, a lot of trade was north‑south, including in B.C., where there’s a significant steel provision coming from the United States to B.C. We are looking to ensure that we are able to serve our entire domestic market, and that is a commitment on the part of Canadian steel producers to do that and maintain it over the long term, so the support from the federal government in that space is certainly valuable.
Senator Gignac: Welcome to our witnesses. According to my own assistant Maxim and my AI virtual assistant, apparently, the ownership of Canadian steel production is mostly foreign. Major producers of steel in Canada are owned by foreigners, for example, if you’re talking about Stelco, ArcelorMittal Dofasco and so on, so my question is this: How much of the current Canadian production is exported to the U.S. market compared to the domestic market?
Mr. Cuddihy: Historically, we would have shipped about 6 million tonnes to the U.S. Right now, shipments are down, so that’s about 50% of our domestic production.
Senator Gignac: Did you say 50%?
Mr. Cuddihy: Yes, 50% is going south. Right now, relative to 2024, which is the last year that we had relative normalcy, we’re down 60% as of the second quarter.
Senator Gignac: In the short term — and yesterday it was the case again with the Stelco announcement — it’s very doom and gloom. With all these major investment projects by the government — we’re talking about new pipelines, high-speed trains, defence investments, so significant investment to be made — is it too optimistic or is it realistic for this to possibly shift the industry from the current lay-offs to a labour shortage in maybe four or five years? Do you see this kind of transition, or is there really no light at the end of the tunnel for the next five to eight years? How many years would it take for this transition, with all this government investment, in Canadian steel production?
Mr. Cuddihy: It’s a fair question. There are a couple points to clarify. In terms of the domestic market and how long it would take to capture an increased share of it, there are definitely additional policies that need to be put in place to help, again, protect against that dumped steel coming in from offshore to help us compete on a level playing field. That’s when we start thinking about our trade context, our trade system and the measures in place to protect the Canadian market. That’s one thing. There’s additional work to do to protect the domestic market.
In terms of individual government initiatives, like infrastructure building, expenditures on defence, et cetera, all those are incrementally important. Please don’t read me incorrectly in saying that they’re not important, but we hear about Alto, for example. That sounds like lots of steel. The reality is when we think about 6 million tonnes of steel and we’re down 60%, the amount of steel for a project like that is probably only several days to a week of production, two weeks max. I don’t have the numbers off the top of my head, but it’s surprisingly small. Any individual project, while important from an incremental perspective — the government alone cannot do it. It’s about shifting that market and shifting the private sector, ensuring that our trade context is sufficient and that we have a level playing field on which to compete.
Senator Gignac: I remember a year ago when Martin Imbleau from Alto testified here. He mentioned there were concerns that maybe they would have to import some of the rail from the U.S. because Canada was unable to produce it, so I hope things will change with this commitment.
Mr. Cuddihy: There are folks looking into that. Certainly, historically, rail of that type was one of the products we would have imported from the U.S., similarly to how we would have supplied specific products to the U.S. market. That’s the nature of an integrated market and over 35 years of free trade. However, there are also other thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of tonnes of steel elsewhere, and when you talk about projects like that in fencing or in structural construction, there are all sorts of other pieces there. It’s not just rail.
Senator Dalphond: To follow up on this, you shipped 6 billion tonnes to the U.S. in 2024-25. Now, it’s down 60%. That would be about 3 billion —
Mr. Cuddihy: Sorry, that’s 6 million tonnes.
Senator Dalphond: Does that mean that you have an excess capacity of 3 million tonnes more or less now?
Mr. Cuddihy: In terms of the first half of the year, yes.
Senator Dalphond: What number of tonnes in the Canadian market comes from overseas?
Mr. Cuddihy: Of the 13 million tonnes of the market, we provide about 6 million to 7 million of that domestically. The United States would historically provide 2 million to 3 million tonnes, and the balance of 3 million to 5 million tonnes would be coming in from overseas.
Senator Dalphond: Mostly from China?
Mr. Cuddihy: There’s diversity. About 105 different countries ship steel into Canada. China definitely has a portion of that directly, and then there’s Chinese steel indirectly pushing out through the rest of the global economy, whether that’s through transshipment or by putting pressure on other economies. There’s a significant amount of steel coming in from South Korea, Vietnam and Malaysia.
Senator Dalphond: I think the federal government decided to respond to that, in part, by imposing tariffs on Chinese steel, so we’re doing more or less what the U.S. is doing to us, but we’re doing it to the Chinese. What is the impact of that? How much capacity did that redirect to your members instead of the Chinese suppliers?
Mr. Cuddihy: We have definitely seen reductions in Chinese imports with the start of the 25% tariff, and there’s also a melt import tariff on China. That has definitely been useful.
What we’ve seen in the last six months is an incremental increase, so, basically, the graph just goes like this. It’s not a huge number at this point, but it’s on an increasing trajectory. Again, that’s where we need to look at our trade regime and what we need to tweak or calibrate to ensure that we’re not receiving dumped steel.
Senator Dalphond: The challenge is to remain competitive. What are you doing to be able to be more competitive, especially with these new tax incentives, like investments, capitalizations, the fast track and these types of things?
Are your members trying to see what they can improve in this period where there are some tax advantages and even subsidies available?
Mr. Cuddihy: Certainly. When we think about competitiveness, Canadian steel is highly competitive on a level playing field. We’re certainly competitive with the U.S. and European markets.
There has been significant and downward pressure on Canadian prices historically because of all the significant amount of imports coming in. Steel is also the product that is most subject to trade cases. I think 75% of our trade cases in Canada are on steel.
When we think about that, we’re competing in that every day in our own domestic market. We’re competitive.
Senator MacDonald: I’ll direct my first question to Mr. Nighbor. You mentioned that we may not control American trade policy, but we can address costs and barriers at home. Beyond immediate financial assistance, what two or three federal changes would make the greatest difference in keeping Canada’s mills operating and attracting investment, and which ones could the government act on immediately?
Mr. Nighbor: That is a good question. There are two things, similar to the exchange I had with Senator Galvez.
There is a regulatory mess that needs to be cleaned up in terms of overlapping regs between provinces and the federal government. We’re encouraged with the level of conversation.
Environment and Climate Change Canada has been looking at reforms to the Pulp and Paper Effluent Regulations which would add about $3 billion of additional costs on our sector after all the investments they put in on the carbon side of things. In almost all provinces, the provincial threshold is going to meet the test. It’s those kinds of things.
So I would say there is the regulatory reform agenda that is of active conversation and is meaningful because that’s going to take costs out of the system while maintaining our commitment to important and good environmental outcomes.
One of the asks we have — and we’re hopeful with the Transformation Task Force and the strategy to come out later this year — is a transformation fund, as mentioned in my exchange with Senator Ross, in terms of how we support those mills and get them ready to turn them into biorefineries and get them upscale. Those are the two biggest things right now.
Then there are a number of other things we’re working on. Similar to the steel industry, we have some challenges around rail prices and costs. Ninety per cent of our mills are served by just one railway, which is not a lot of competition and increases the costs for our members.
So that’s the cost containment piece, regulatory sensibility and targeted innovation funding to get our mills up the chain.
Senator MacDonald: Thank you.
Mr. Cuddihy, a question for you: You recommended increasing the surtax on steel-derivative products from 25% to 50%. How would you design that measure to protect Canadian steel production while managing costs for Canadian manufacturers that use these products? What additional enforcement would be needed to prevent imports from circumventing the higher surtax?
Mr. Nighbor: A fair question. When we think about protecting downstream manufacturers from costs, part of the challenge is ensuring they’re not undercut by unfairly traded products, be that steel or derivative products.
What we have seen as we talk about this global trade in steel and global excess capacity, we see manufacturers in such exporting countries shipping primary forms of steel to Canada and to other countries, but we also see them shipping fully fabricated steel, structural components, et cetera, or even manufactured goods.
The importance of increasing the surtax on derivative goods is to actually protect domestic manufacturers so they’re getting a fair price for their production that they’re producing in Canada, with the Canadian protections, the environmental regulations and laws that we’re following here — health, safety and all that — which have costs that are different than some of the spaces with which we’re competing. Having that surtax can help protect that market domestically.
Senator MacDonald: How do we differentiate then between dumped steel and steel that’s not dumped? What needs to be done to address it? If we do address it, how does it impact our economy?
Mr. Cuddihy: There’s definitely a trade law around what dumped steel is. Dumped steel, technically, is steel being brought into our market at a price lower than the market that is selling it, which the importer comes from.
Individual trade cases are pursued to demonstrate where that is happening; however, those are expensive. Just to start one is $1 million. We have situations where steel producers are working with some of their downstream customers to help advance trade cases because there’s not necessarily that same capacity downstream.
What’s helpful is when there’s that pattern and we’re able to work with the government, recognizing those patterns of trade, and then the government is able to put in measures that then protect against that type of unfair trade, and we don’t need the pursuit of legal remedies.
In terms of the things that would be required, we have talked about the increase in the derivative surtax; that’s one thing. There’s more room to look at the China melt-and-pour tax and whether or not that should increase from 25% to 50% given the recent increase in the numbers.
There are other pieces that can be looked at, as I was highlighting, in terms of our fair trade agreements: How do we protect as we join into agreements with other countries? We have what we call a tariff rate quota, or TRQ, in place on steel globally outside of CUSMA. How do we ensure that, as we join in free trade agreements with other countries, we do not undermine those measures, like the TRQ that is in place? Those are the types of measures we would be looking at to improve.
Then, once we get to that equilibrium, that’s a space where there would be a viable long-term market for steel in Canada and downstream manufacturers as well.
Senator Pupatello: It’s great to see you again, Mr. Nighbor. I recognize you from Pembroke as well. It’s great you’re leading at this time that’s so critical for the industry, and certainly our steel industry that is undergoing tremendous stress.
My question is simple. One of the plans in play is to wait until the midterms in the U.S. and see what happens because, despite all of these tax incentives, benefits and credits, companies have to be prepared to make an investment in order to gain the benefit of these initiatives. It’s hard for them to make that decision until they know their market is certain. That’s really going to be dependent on the 50% that needs to get back into the U.S. market.
What else can the government do? They’ve come up with a number of programs quickly: tax relief, tariff reimbursements, et cetera. What else can they do to wait out this storm? There seems to be a sense that, come the midterms, all of the terrible impact on the U.S. economy is finally going to push them to realize they need to go in a different direction. That’s for both sectors.
Mr. Nighbor: Maybe the starting point is things are not great in the U.S.: mortgage rates at 7.25%, diesel at over $6, or $7 to $8 a gallon if you’re on the West Coast.
One of the things we’ve observed over the years is that the U.S., on the lumber side, can only satisfy about 70% of its market domestically. Things aren’t getting built there right now. Where we’ve been losing is it’s cheaper to get wood from Sweden, Austria or Germany because it’s coming in at a 15% tariff, and we’re at over 45%. The twenty-ish per cent we normally have taken up, a good chunk of that has not been eaten by the masterful domestic manufacturing agenda of the President but, rather, European imports. We’re not seeing that bounce or opportunity because markets are so soft.
We trust Janice Charette and Minister LeBlanc. We feel we’ve been very well heard by them and they know where we’re at. We’re going to continue to be on Team Canada, as tough as it is.
Disproportionately, we’ve been hammered. Steel, auto and lumber have been hammered very hard. For us, there is a whole package of things before Minister Hodgson and that forest sector transformation piece, regulatory, investment, transportation supply chain. The playbook is there; we’re just waiting for it to get launched. That would be my abbreviated answer to give you time back.
Mr. Cuddihy: I largely agree with Mr. Nighbor in the sense that the U.S. market needs additional steel, as well. There are perverse outcomes taking place there. At some point, will there be a return to what we have historically seen as normal in the last 30 years? Probably not — not in the near term. What does that look like in the long term? We don’t know. So, we are really focusing on reorienting toward the Canadian market as much as possible.
To that point, the measures are largely in play but need tweaking and adjusting. That’s what we have submitted in terms of our pre-consultation document and several other measures we are talking to the government about.
Senator Pupatello: Is there a measure that will help the companies wait this out that the government hasn’t employed yet?
Mr. Cuddihy: Not to my awareness, off the top of my head. There are many things that are out there right now that do work. The Strategic Response Fund has been useful for a number of our companies, but my understanding is that there are more pieces in the pipeline there. The measures to support employees are also super useful.
Right now, the focus for us is on that trade context, shoring up the level playing field for Canada and then looking at how we can also incentivize the domestic market to buy Canadian.
Senator Pupatello: Is there anything that you can do to encourage any of your member companies to start making beer cans?
Mr. Cuddihy: Beer cans out of steel? When it comes to individual commercial opportunities, I leave that to them to pursue. I’m sure they will be watching this and take note.
[Translation]
The Chair: This brings us to the end of this morning’s meeting. Thank you very much to the witnesses for their interesting comments. The committee will meet again next Thursday at 9 a.m. to begin the pre-study of Bill C-31. Thank you very much.
(The committee adjourned.)