Skip to main content
RIDR - Standing Committee

Human Rights

 

THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RIGHTS

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Monday, October 5, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights met with videoconference this day at 4 p.m. [ET] to continue its study of Bill C-234, An Act respecting the establishment and award of a Living Donor Recognition Medal; and, in camera, regarding the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 10 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025 (consideration of a draft report); and, in camera, to examine and report on the health, safety, and wellbeing of 2SLGBTQI+ youth in Canada (consideration of a draft budget).

Senator Paulette Senior (Chair) in the chair.

[English]

The Chair: Good afternoon, honourable senators. I would like to begin by acknowledging that the land on which we gather is on the traditional, ancestral and unceded territory Anishinaabe Algonquin nation.

My name is Paulette Senior. I’m a senator from Ontario and the chair of this committee. I invite my colleagues to introduce themselves, beginning on my left with our deputy chair.

Senator Bernard: I’m Wanda Thomas Bernard, senator from Nova Scotia, Mi’kmaq territory.

Senator D. M. Wells: David Wells from Newfoundland and Labrador.

Senator Robinson: Mary Robinson from Prince Edward Island.

Senator Karetak-Lindell: Nancy Karetak-Lindell, senator for Nunavut.

[Translation]

Senator Arnold: I am Dawn Arnold from New Brunswick.

[English]

Senator K. Wells: Kristopher Wells, Treaty 6 territory in Edmonton.

Senator Arnot: David Arnot, Treaty 6 territory in Saskatchewan.

The Chair: Thank you, senators.

Today our committee continues its study of Bill C-234, An Act respecting the establishment and award of a Living Donor Recognition Medal. We will hear from two panels of witnesses over the course of the next two hours.

Joining us for the first panel, we are pleased to welcome Martine Bouchard, President and CEO of Transplant Québec; by video conference from the Kidney Foundation of Canada, Craig Lindsay, Director of Programs and Public Policy, Ontario; and representing Héma-Québec, Dr. Marc Germain, Vice President, Medical Affairs and Innovation and Mélanie Dieudé, Director of Research Operations.

Thank you all for joining us. We welcome you. We will begin by inviting you to provide your opening remarks to be followed by questions from our members. We will start with Ms. Bouchard, followed by Mr. Lindsay and Dr. Germain. I remind you that you each have five minutes.

The floor is yours, Ms. Bouchard.

[Translation]

Martine Bouchard, President and CEO, Transplant Québec: Good afternoon, Madam Chair and honourable senators. Thank you for giving Transplant Québec the opportunity to participate in your study of Bill C-234.

We support the bill’s intent.

Making a living organ donation is an act of tremendous generosity. Donors agree to medical intervention and the consequences, not to better their own health, but to give another person a chance to live better and, in many cases, just to live.

Our remarks are based on more than 55 years of experience within Quebec’s organ donor and transplant system.

Transplant Québec coordinates organ donation in Quebec, ensures that organs are fairly allocated according to clinical and ethical criteria, and works with institutions, clinical teams and transplant programs.

We also play an operational role, chartering aircraft to transport organs right across the country and, since 2024, coordinating ground transportation with the help of volunteer police officers.

Since February 2026, we have partnered with Héma-Québec to host a ceremony, attended by the Lieutenant Governor of Quebec, to recognize living donors and honour donors posthumously.

In other words, Quebec already has a process in place to recognize donors.

That experience shaped our consideration of how a Canadian distinction could play a unique role.

We feel that such a distinction merits more than just another ceremony.

The value of the distinction lies in the lasting national impact, the rigour of the awarding process and the clear commitment to honourees.

Quebec’s ceremony and the federal medal fall under two distinct systems.

We don’t want to see them confused. Instead, we hope that they are promoted as complementary distinctions and that, to the extent possible, a duplication of efforts will not be required of donors.

Two aspects would benefit from greater clarity, in favour of smoother implementation.

The definition of an organ

The definition refers to any form of human tissue, including blood and bone marrow.

The definition blends clinical and regulatory realities that do not necessarily fall under the same organizations.

I will focus my remarks on Transplant Québec’s area of responsibility.

One of the areas we are responsible for is vascularized composite tissue in the context of face transplants, currently associated with donation after death.

The definition must, however, evolve as new practices emerge. These could include transplants and living donations in other forms, uterus transplantation, for instance. I would refer you to my brief.

This means that the definition needs to be specific enough to respect current responsibilities while flexible enough to keep pace with medical advances.

Shared responsibilities

Depending on the type of donation, the necessary information can be held by different organizations or clinical programs.

Other organizations appearing before the committee are better positioned to discuss their specific realities.

Transplant Québec is prepared to lend its cooperation when the required contribution aligns with its mandate, the information it legitimately holds and its ability to disclose information with proper consent.

However, in our view, overall program administration, application intake, final decisions, remedies and operation of the registry should remain the responsibility of the federal government.

Concerned stakeholders should help to define any provincial contribution.

Prior consultation, clear agreement and appropriate resources are prerequisites for any new responsibilities.

Since the medal would be awarded to recognize a donor’s outstanding contribution to society, it only makes sense for the federal government to also examine the financial consequences donors can face after their donation.

Lastly, recognition must not come with a penalty.

While Canadian data do not show that insurance premiums systematically go up, the data are limited.

International research has shown that some donors experience higher premiums and other insurance difficulties.

We don’t expect Bill C-234 alone to bring about insurance reforms.

However, we are asking that the establishment of the medal go hand in hand with a formal national review of the financial and insurance consequences of living donation. Transplant Québec is calling for three things. First, we would like to see a clear federal framework for administering the distinction, with targeted contributions from, and defined by, the appropriate actors.

Two, we are asking for prior consultation, privacy agreements and appropriate resources before any new responsibilities are set out.

Three, we want to see a formal Canada-wide examination of the financial and insurance consequences of living donation.

Recognizing a living donor means honouring them. It also means respecting their choice, protecting their privacy and ensuring that their generosity is never used against them. Thank you.

[English]

The Chair: Thank you.

Mr. Lindsay?

Craig Lindsay, Director, Programs and Public Policy, Ontario, Kidney Foundation of Canada: Honourable senators, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. I am speaking on behalf of the Kidney Foundation of Canada, but I’m also here as someone whose life was saved by organ donation.

Today, I live with a kidney-pancreas transplant from a deceased donor. Every day I spend with my family, every milestone I celebrate and every plan I make for my future is possible because one family, during an unimaginably difficult moment, chose to say, “Yes,” to donation. There is not a day that goes by that I do not think about that gift.

Before my transplant, I lived for years with diabetes and kidney failure. Like thousands of Canadians, I experienced the uncertainty of waiting for an organ and knowing that my future depended on a phone call that might come tomorrow, next month or years from now. Many Canadians, you should know, never receive that call. More than 4,300 Canadians were waiting for an organ transplant at the end of 2025, and far too many patients died while waiting. The need for organs continues to exceed the available supply.

I was fortunate; others are not. As grateful as I am for my deceased donor transplant, I still carry one regret: I wish I had been more proactive and more courageous in exploring living donation. Many patients never have that conversation. They may not understand the benefits of living donation, or they may feel uncomfortable simply asking family and friends for help.

Living donation is one of the most extraordinary acts of generosity a patient can make. For many recipients, it offers the best outcomes. Living donor kidneys often function sooner, last longer and spare patients years of dialysis and declining health.

The challenge is not a lack of generosity among Canadians. The challenge is simply awareness. People cannot consider living donation if they have never heard about it, understood its impact or seen it recognized. This, to me, is why Bill C-234 matters the most.

Some may ask whether creating an award can make a difference. I would suggest that recognition is about much more than a medal or certificate. Recognition tells stories. Recognition creates awareness. Recognition starts conversations, and conversations can save lives.

Every living donor has chosen to undergo surgery, accept minimal risk and make a profound personal sacrifice to give another person a second chance at life. They deserve our gratitude and our admiration, but the impact of an award would extend beyond the donor being honoured.

Somewhere in Canada, a person learning about that award may hear about living donation for the first time. A Canadian who learns about a recipient’s story may begin to consider becoming a donor. A family may finally have the courage to have a conversation they have been avoiding, a patient may find the courage to ask for help and a potential donor may realize they have the ability to save a life. They deserve our gratitude and our admiration. But the impact of this Bill extends beyond those being honoured. A Canadian who learns about a recipient’s story extends beyond may begin to consider becoming a donor. A family may finally have the courage to have a conservation they have been avoiding. A patient may find the courage to ask for help, and a potential donor may realize that they have the power to save a life.

At the Kidney Foundation of Canada, we see every day how awareness leads to action. When people learn about living donation, they become more open to considering it. When living donors are celebrated, others are inspired.

I know this because donation changed my life. I am here today because someone I will never meet gave me a future. Bill C-234 provides an opportunity not only to recognize remarkable acts of generosity but also to elevate an important national conversation that can help save lives. For that reason, the Kidney Foundation of Canada strongly supports this initiative.

Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you.

[Translation]

Dr. Marc Germain, Vice-President, Medical Affairs and Innovation, Héma-Québec: Thank you, Madam Chair and honourable senators. Thank you for the opportunity to contribute to your examination of Bill C-234.

I also want to start by highlighting the tremendous generosity of those who become living donors. They voluntarily agree to undergo major surgery in order to improve or often save someone else’s life, and they certainly deserve all our recognition and admiration. We at Héma-Québec fully understand what a valuable act that is. Every day, our work depends on people who freely choose to contribute to the well-being of others, without expectation of reward. We therefore applaud the intent of this bill.

We respectfully submit that other donations of body products are founded on precisely the same selflessness, solidarity and commitment. Those values are shared by blood, plasma, stem cell and breast milk donors. Their donations directly help to save or improve lives, and in many cases, those donors continue to donate, again and again, for years, sometimes decades.

That is especially true in the case of blood and plasma donations. Numerous donors exhibit incredible generosity. In Quebec alone, more than 40 people have surpassed the milestone of 1,000 donations in their lifetimes. That is thousands of hours spent travelling to and from donation sites and going through the collection process, week after week, year after year. This is more than a single act of kindness. It is one repeated hundreds of times. Therefore, we feel it would be appropriate to look beyond the recognition of living organ donors and consider donor recognition more broadly, as a way to celebrate other types of equally essential donations within Canada’s health system.

I will now turn the floor over to Mélanie Dieudé, who has spent a large part of her career in the field of organ transplantation. She will be able to shed more light on those other types of generosity.

Mélanie Dieudé, Director of Research Operations, Héma-Québec: Thank you, Dr. Germain.

I’ve spent nearly 20 years in the donation and transplant field, so I work with recipients whose lives have been transformed by the generosity of living donors. I also know many liver and kidney donors and I can attest to the magnitude of their commitment. In spite of a very gruelling process and potential personal and professional repercussions, they choose to give another person the chance of living.

That incredible generosity is also embodied in donors who make other types of body product donations. At Héma-Québec, we work alongside them every day. While the medical context may differ, the values that drive donors are the same: selflessness, commitment and the desire to help others. As Dr. Germain pointed out, some donors devote a huge part of their lives to this mission, including blood, plasma and platelet donors. Jean Bernier, Canada’s top blood donor, has made more than 1,700 donations in his lifetime, and as Marc highlighted, 44 Héma-Québec donors have surpassed the incredible milestone of 1,000 donations.

We see the same level of dedication in breast milk donors. Lyne Robert, of Gatineau, has made more than 2,000 donations, helping to give countless vulnerable newborns the crucial nutritional support they need in the first moments of life.

That dedication is also evident among stem cell donors. Every year, some 20 individuals agree to undergo what are often invasive medical procedures to give a seriously ill patient a chance for recovery. In 2019, federal minister Dominic LeBlanc received a stem cell transplant he called life-saving. His story is a reminder that, like an organ donor, a single stem cell donor can change a life, a family and a whole community.

Behind each donation is someone who freely chooses to give their time, energy and a piece of themselves to others. While they differ from a medical standpoint, these donations are all links in the same chain of human solidarity, making it possible to treat patients, cure them and save their lives. With that in mind, we invite the committee to consider inclusive ways of recognizing significant donors in Canada. Héma-Québec would welcome the opportunity to contribute to such an exercise. It is not for recognition that living donors do what they do. It is to help others. The values they embody — solidarity, selflessness and commitment — are at the heart of Canadian society, and they deserve to be recognized for their incredible contributions.

Thank you. We would be happy to answer your questions.

[English]

The Chair: Thank you for your presentations.

We will now proceed with questions. I remind my Senate colleagues that they each have five minutes for their questions, and that includes the answer. I offer the first question to our deputy chair, Senator Bernard.

Senator Bernard: Thank you to each of you for your testimony here today. My first question will be for Mr. Lindsay.

One of the things we’ve heard repeatedly is that living donations take a lot of courage. You’ve indicated that if Bill C-234 is adopted, it will encourage more Canadians to become living donors. Can you tell us how you would envision that happening? The bill passing is one step, but how would that encourage more Canadians to become living donors?

Mr. Lindsay: It starts with having the confidence to have a conversation. I know when we hear stories in the news about a living donor, we get countless inquiries the next day of people asking, “How do I start?”

We want to empower people to take that next step to reach out to the transplant centre. That’s where the gap is it right now. People don’t know where to start. They don’t understand the need. When they see themselves reflected in donor stories and can say, “That donor looks just like me” or “They look just like my father” or “They look just like my son,” it humanizes them.

Statistics are one thing. We know about the people who are waiting. We know the impact medically, but when it comes down to it, we are human. This is a human with a circle of family and friends around him, waiting.

That’s the opportunity for this bill: that we elevate the conversation and that we empower people to have honest dialogue within their families and put their hands up and say they would like to explore this further. In my mind, that’s the opportunity for this bill.

People want to do the right thing as long as they know what the right thing is. Understanding that no one donates unless it’s safe to do so. It is about mitigating fear. That’s why the Kidney Foundation of Canada believes so strongly in the potential for this bill to elevate the conversation and to celebrate stories of courage.

Senator Bernard: Thank you for that. You hinted at what the donor looks like. I see myself. Can you tell us more? What are the demographic profiles of donors? Who is more likely to be a donor? Are certain groups less likely to donate organs and therefore less likely to be recognized as a living donor? Would anyone like to respond to that question?

Mr. Lindsay: I can share briefly that we know from the data that there are inequities of access to transplants. Certain populations are not encouraged to discuss transplant, let alone living donation. We are concerned about that. We know that across the country renal providers and system leaders are looking at levelling the playing field. In Ontario, we have an Indigenous kidney health plan and a Black health and chronic kidney disease plan. We are trying to understand financial barriers, as was mentioned earlier. You need to be near a transplant centre. You are not wrong, senator, in recognizing there are inequities. Thank you.

Ms. Bouchard: I agree with Mr. Lindsay. There are inequities, and I speak for within the province of Quebec. We know there are inequities. Your first question was about who comes forward to donate. We have seen many family members. Someone in the family requires, for example, a kidney transplant. There are no kidneys available, so one family member raises their hand and says, I will donate and see if I am a correct match for you. If not, there is a Canadian program that allows for a chain of kidney donation. Let’s say, I’m your mother, and you need to have a kidney, but I am not compatible with you for whatever reason. I can still make the decision to donate. I will give my kidney to the Canadian program, and that kidney will come back to you with your requirements. But mostly what we’ve seen is people who require, within their family, an organ.

Senator Bernard: Thank you.

Senator D. M. Wells: Thank you to all the witnesses. Ms. Bouchard, in your experience, what would you say are the primary reasons that people do not donate? I wrote down a couple for prompting: lack of awareness, fear of medical complications, financial barriers — as Mr. Lindsay mentioned — or ease of location. What would you say are the primary ones?

Ms. Bouchard: All of the above, I would say. Lack of awareness, for sure. People are not sure, or are not aware. They think they are too old. They think they will not meet the proper requirements. Perhaps they are not aware of the Canadian program. Also, we have to be frank: There is a financial barrier of having an operation and of being off work. Then there is the risk of the operation altogether. There is always a risk of having an operation. There is the location barrier, so all of the above, I would say.

Senator D. M. Wells: I’m thinking about the different types of donation, and I’ve learned about some of them today. You mentioned a post mortem facial donation. I had never heard of that. I donate blood, which is fairly easy for me; it doesn’t take a lot of time, and I do it regularly, but I would be more reluctant to donate a kidney. What are some of the other considerations that could educate the public about either the ease of it, or if there are complications, about the complications around it, and some of the mitigating things that can promote donation?

Ms. Bouchard: The fact that you have two kidneys is one. You always have one left. Or it could be another organ or part of a lobe, I should say. The notion of awareness is another. People just don’t know what they are getting into. Lack of information: What is expected of you? What will come next? What happens to me if I donate a kidney, I have one left, and then I get sick? All these aspects need to be looked at.

The major issue is the lack of information and the lack of knowledge relating to organ donation.

Senator D. M. Wells: Thank you very much. I have a question for Dr. Germain as well.

Dr. Germain, you talked about the awareness aspect. Do you think that the passage of this bill in full would result in an increase in awareness and, therefore, the number of donations?

Dr. Germain: Actually, it is the primary goal of this kind of initiative, and it would serve well the issue of organ donation, but in a ricochet fashion. It would also serve very well the cause of blood and plasma donation. In Canada, we are not self-sufficient in terms of plasma donations. Plasma is used to manufacture sophisticated pharmaceutical products.

We are very much relying on imported plasma, coming from paid donors in the United States. By encouraging our population to donate more, these donations will help to secure safe and adequate supplies for patients. The impact of this type of recognition will go beyond just organ transplantation.

Senator Arnot: Thank you to all the witnesses. I have a question for Mr. Lindsay and one for Ms. Dieudé.

Mr. Lindsay, you talked about the power of education, information, awareness and recognition. You say that they are all linked, and they would all be helpful to increase the number of donations. My question is this: What do living kidney donors identify as their most significant unmet need in a donation process? I ask that in the context of this: Would a medal meaningfully address any of those needs?

Mr. Lindsay: A medal after the fact would not address any confusion prior to the surgery, but those streams of education, information and publicly celebrating stories are important. People reach out to us and say, I am curious. Can I do it safely? What’s the recovery time? What’s the financial impact?

As you are worked up for a working living organ transplant, you receive an exhaustive assessment. Many people learn about things they never otherwise would have learned. They may have a potential cardiac issue. Most living donors identify navigation as a challenge. Some renal programs only work up one potential donor at a time, for example. Some transplant programs require serial tests over many months. It is often not done in one day, so they will travel to and from a remote community. For example, a living donor in Thunder Bay could explore a transplant in London, Ontario. It is the navigation and the coordination around it that frustrates them. It is not that they regret the time off work or the time waiting in clinics. They want a sense that things are better coordinated. They know that the end is in sight.

Senator Arnot: Thank you very much. Ms. Dieudé, what evidence exists that formal honours influence a willingness to donate? I would like to know what outcome measures should be established before implementing a national medal program.

Ms. Dieudé: That’s a great point: to measure the impact and to see how many people reach out. But our message here is that there is no way we should not recognize these altruistic people. I’m aligning with Mr. Lindsay on that. People don’t know, for example, that with liver donation, your liver lobe will rejuvenate within weeks. People don’t know how much time. People don’t know that if you have too high of a risk, you are not going to go through it, but there are other ways to donate.

What a medal could bring is a lot of awareness about the culture of donation, whether it is living organ or deceased donation as well, even if it is not the first goal. Whether it be blood donation, platelets, plasma or milk, we have to deal in Canada with altruistic people.

Sometimes they just don’t know which type of donation they will be willing to make, and for different reasons: familial, professional, their health status. There are different ways of donating and bringing that up as a culture rather than specifically pinpointing, and bringing awareness would be a terrific goal for that medal.

I agree that evaluating before and after, as well as the information impacts on donations, will be key. It’s a great idea that we should implement along with that type of recognition.

Senator Arnot: Thank you.

Senator Arnold: Thank you all for being here and for the incredibly important work that you do. We have heard from other witnesses. I don’t think anyone disputes how important this is. I have a question about whether all altruism is equally good. Ms. Bouchard, thank you very much for your brief. It was excellent and provided a lot of clarity. Do you have — these might be the wrong words — a hierarchy of medals? Are they all equal?

Ms. Bouchard: That’s a great question. We don’t have a hierarchy of medals except — I’m going to speak like a lawyer — there are medals for Samaritans, whoever gives time, the volunteers. We have medals for people. Of course, the family is honoured for people who have donated, and we have medals for organ deceased and living donors. There’s no hierarchy of medals in Quebec as we speak. The notion you bring up of value for a different size of medal depending on, “If you give a kidney, is that worth more than giving your blood?” I couldn’t answer that. It’s a question of donating and a question of saving lives.

It always comes back to the aspect of giving, the aspect of talking about organ donation. I do not think people are aware of how many people are on the waitlist and the potential of people dying.

In Quebec, on a yearly basis, we have around 40 people who die because they are on the waitlist and their physical health is not good enough; they just die waiting. One is too much. Forty? That’s just in Quebec. Could you imagine pan-Canadian?

If we have that broad conversation and recognize people who donate, we can increase this donation rate and decrease the deceased rate. It’s something that’s fairly easy to do, but to answer your question — I went through barriers to answer — there’s no hierarchy of medals, as we speak.

Senator Arnold: Do they apply for this, or does someone nominate them?

Ms. Dieudé: They don’t apply. Actually, that’s not true. The family member will give their name and say that they’re interested in receiving the award. It’s an extremely emotional ceremony, as you may imagine, for the deceased donor because sometimes we have the husband with two young children, and it’s the mother who was the organ donor, so they receive the medal. Sometimes it’s the spouse, brother or mother. Very emotional.

Senator Arnold: I bet. Thank you.

Ms. Bouchard: You’re welcome.

Senator K. Wells: Just a question for the panel on your views. This bill, in addition to awarding a medal, would also entitle the recipient to use the post-nominal letters L.D.M., for “living donor medal.”

In your experience, do you feel like that would promote more recognition of organ donation on top of that, or do you see any concerns about adding a post-nominal title after someone’s name recognizing them as a living donor medal recipient?

Ms. Bouchard: I’m not sure if that would create something. It’s probably another recognition that one can use, but if we don’t speak about it and if there’s no knowledge of what that means, I’m not sure people will understand the post-nominal after a name. If you have to explain what that means every time you sign, perhaps it’s beside the point.

If there is a lot of communication, if people are aware of what that means, it sort of becomes like an MD at the end of your name. So, yes, I think that’s great.

Every effort that’s made to encourage the living donor is an effort worth looking at.

Mr. Lindsay: I’ve seen credentials that have less important impact culturally and societally than that would be. I agree: Anything that stirs a conversation, that’s what we need this bill to do.

I just wanted to quickly add: It’s a conversation. I spoke with my transplant coordinator this morning, a woman who, after I received my altruistically donated kidney, gets it. She’s lost track of the number of transplants that were cancelled because the recipient won’t accept it. I think these stories will celebrate that donors can do it. Let people be heroes.

Dr. Germain: Any form of official recognition about the exceptional altruistic gesture by someone will give more credibility when a person acts as an ambassador for the cause that he or she is promoting. I think it would help. I don’t have any proof of that, but it would be something worth considering.

Senator K. Wells: Ms. Bouchard, you mentioned some potential concerns about life insurance premiums if someone was on a living donor register. From your experience, has this been a concern in other jurisdictions around the world? You called for more study about this. You wouldn’t want to create an award that then could have unanticipated repercussions on people for something as important as being able to qualify for life insurance.

Ms. Bouchard: In the United States, they made provisions to that effect to ensure that donors will never be penalized for insurance. In Europe, some jurisdictions may be looking at that, but I’m not sure. Across Canada, I can’t speak to it. I can only speak to Quebec in having spoken to people who did give their kidneys and mentioned the fact that, yes, they were penalized from an insurance perspective. For me, it sparked an interest to say we cannot have, on the one hand, recognition and, on the other hand, have these people to be penalized. This needs to be looked at so as to ensure it doesn’t happen.

Senator K. Wells: Has the Quebec government taken any steps to prevent that from happening?

Ms. Bouchard: Not yet.

Senator K. Wells: It’s an issue you or your organizations have raised with the government?

Ms. Bouchard: We’re raising it, yes.

Senator K. Wells: Thank you very much.

The Chair: Senator Wells asked my first question. I will build on other questions I’ve heard around demographics. I’m curious about a gender breakdown. Can you speak about that in terms of how the statistics play out with respect to women and men and other genders? What does that breakdown look like?

Ms. Bouchard: That’s a very interesting question. I don’t have the answer right here, right now.

How many female donors versus how many male donors? I don’t have that statistic, but I can find out.

The Chair: That would be great. Any other responses?

Mr. Lindsay: I wouldn’t be able to speak to the exact numbers, but at first glance, more men receive transplants than women, at least in Ontario. Although I can’t speak to the reasoning behind it, it speaks to a broader gender issue across health care.

The Chair: So more men receive. What about donors?

Mr. Lindsay: I do not know that; I’m sorry.

The Chair: In terms of strategy, I’ve heard from several of you that this bill will help to promote more people stepping up to donate.

I’ve also heard that the next day after a story — I heard a similar story a few months ago on CBC, for example, that was truly deeply inspiring — you see a rise in the number of people who step up to do this.

Are there any deliberate strategies in terms of addressing what may be demographic gaps? I’m looking at you, Mr. Lindsay.

Mr. Lindsay: I can say, at least in Ontario — I’m aware of what’s happening across the country — our strategic priorities start to level that playing field. It’s outreach to communities supporting Indigenous populations, the people often at the highest risk of developing organ failure: Black Canadians; Indigenous, rural and remote; new Canadians, for example. We can’t rely on going where we’ve always gone and being welcome. It’s exploring new partnerships and building trust with communities that have seen themselves not being well served in the health care system. It’s navigation tools. Seeing providers who come from those communities creates a sense of safety. Our strategy is to build partnerships and credibility to empower people to ask the questions they’re entitled to.

The Chair: Thank you. Any other responses? Ms. Bouchard?

Ms. Bouchard: Transplant Québec is not responsible for living donors. It’s something that’s particular. We’re responsible for offering up to a certain amount. Let’s say I’m giving a kidney. Transplant Québec, through the government, will pay a certain amount of thousands of dollars for the time off work, for whatever you need to pay for parking or whatever. We’re responsible for some of the statistics, and sometimes we’re responsible for transport. But we are not responsible for communication to encourage. That is within the transplant centres throughout the province of Quebec. So it’s a little bit different.

The outreach would have an overall umbrella — an organization that is responsible for this rather than various transplant centres. I think that would allow for communication and information to the public and to ensure that we’re increasing our donation rates.

The Chair: Do you think this bill would help with that?

Ms. Bouchard: I’m not sure the bill would contribute to helping that, but I think it would promote, most definitely, the notion of speaking about it, speaking to what Mr. Lindsay was mentioning. Families will discuss this. This will create repercussions throughout society, whether it’s in one province or another. The fact that this is pan-Canadian, it has a certain notoriety. I think this is really important. I think that will help.

The repercussions of this within each of the provinces, we’ll see how that turns out. I think it’s a major conversation to have, for sure.

The Chair: Thank you. Any other responses before my time runs out?

Ms. Dieudé: I may add something. I was talking about the culture of donations. I think that if we focus on living donations, yes, but if we extend to other forms of living donations, I think it’s quite important to give people the choice and the examples of successful donations to save people’s lives. Then, depending on where you’re at in your family, your age and your health status, there’s a way to donate, perhaps for people who really want to donate, even if you don’t qualify for a living donation.

I think the message of better understanding all the forms of donation is quite important. Having that discussion with the medal and bringing that up would certainly help. Like Martine said, more coordinated information would certainly benefit not only living donations, but donations as a whole, as a culture.

Senator D. M. Wells: I’m going to ask this to all the representatives — Transplant Québec, Kidney Foundation of Canada and Héma-Québec. If this bill passes in full, would you consider having a promotional or awareness campaign built around this new initiative that you would have in hopes of attracting donors?

Mr. Lindsay: The Kidney Foundation of Canada would jump at this loud and wide. We want stories of hope and resilience, and we celebrate these broadly. We’re often seen to be the voice of kidney disease. We want opportunities to celebrate success and give hope to people not even yet diagnosed. This is part of who we are.

Senator D. M. Wells: Thank you. Dr. Germain?

Dr. Germain: Absolutely, especially if we decide to include not only living organ donations, but other types of donations that will obviously be part of our strategy to disseminate this really good news and use that as a tool to promote, like Ms. Dieudé was saying, the culture of donations across the board.

Senator D. M. Wells: Thanks. Ms. Bouchard?

Ms. Bouchard: Short answer, yes. Transplant Québec is in favour of this. This will start to create a societal movement, pan-Canadian, to finally start discussing donations and the positive aspects of donating and saving lives in Canada.

Senator D. M. Wells: Thank you.

The Chair: Seeing no other questions, just one more I’d like to insert.

One of the questions we were left with at the end of our break in June was trying to understand with this legislation coming into place, and considering where Quebec is compared to the rest of the provinces and territories, how do you see this bill being rolled out across the country, considering different provinces are at different places? What would need to be done with the provinces and territories in order to make that truly national?

Ms. Bouchard: I’ve alluded to this in the memoir a little bit. I think there needs to be criteria that are transparent. I think there needs to be conversations with the various provinces to see exactly how it’s attributed and how the information is transferred to Canada because it’s sensitive information. We’re talking about health information. There’s also the notion of confidentiality, who can transfer the medical information to Canada, who is attributed and if these criteria match what initially they were matched for.

I think there needs to be conversations with the provinces. Yes, I think it’s definitely a positive project. There need to be conversations. If there are requirements or resources that are needed, if there are investments that are needed, we need to have these conversations. If it’s just to the effect of transferring information, making sure we’re respecting confidentiality.

There’s also something I mentioned in the memoir. I think the bill refers to the fact that this could be a ceremony. I think we need to be mindful of what the donors will want. Some donors will not want to be in a ceremony. Some donors will want to have their gesture more private. I think we need to respect that as well.

Mr. Lindsay: I would agree with the last point. Donors don’t do this for homogenous reasons. It’s different everywhere. Respecting that, navigating the sharing of personal, private and medical information can be managed safely. I don’t know many provinces across the country that don’t have living donors they would like to celebrate. When I think about a pan-Canadian initiative that has the potential to pull us together around common cause, this is one.

The Chair: Thank you. Dr. Germain or Ms. Dieudé?

Dr. Germain: I can’t obviously speak specifically to the question of living organ donation, but if the project were to include the recognition of blood or plasma donation, we would definitely need to connect with our colleagues at Canadian Blood Services in order to align the manner in which we would recommend specific types of recognition of our blood donors. In the realm of tissue donation, we would need to connect with other partners across Canada that do that type of activity. Regarding stem cells, we would also need to discuss with Canadian Blood Services, who are, obviously, in discussions with the provinces in terms of aligning their policies.

Ms. Dieudé: I just wanted to add that, in terms of kidney exchange, it’s pan-Canadian. It starts with an altruistic gift of a kidney — many of those chains of kidney donation — and it’s throughout Canada and even elsewhere.

There are already links that we can build on that exist already to make that happen very smoothly. Like Dr. Germain was saying, adding the other donation — I’m going to repeat myself about the culture of donation — that’s where everybody will win with such a bill.

The Chair: Thank you so much.

Senator Bernard: Some of your responses brought a question to mind — and this would be for any of the panellists — would you worry about a medal creating external motivation for such a sensitive and vulnerable process that should really have motivation coming from within? Should we have concerns or worry about that, or do any of you have concerns or worry about that?

Mr. Lindsay: I can share what I know of the living donor workup process. It’s rigorous, and it’s a psychosocial assessment. There are already concerns that people will donate for non-altruistic reasons or for monetary gain. I would say that — at least from the programs I know — they have a very effective way of filtering that out. They can drill down to the authentic motivation, I believe. I’m curious what the other panellists believe.

Ms. Dieudé: I completely agree that the psychological for living organ donation is quite — there are ways of making sure the person is really willingly giving.

I think it’s more awareness and giving an option that some people don’t think they have or that they don’t know exists. They don’t know how much time it takes or what type of donation they could do. The gain is more there.

I’m not so afraid, because from the examples we have, people donate because they really feel like they can contribute, and they want to contribute, especially when there’s no remuneration involved.

Ms. Bouchard: I would have to agree. There’s no financial incentive to give.

I mentioned before that Transplant Québec was giving a certain amount of money. It goes up to $5,500, but it is with receipts and proof, and it needs to be approved with specific criteria. So $5,000 for going through a donation of an organ is not a financial incentive.

Senator Bernard: Thank you.

Senator Karetak-Lindell: I’m getting a little confused with the process. I’ve heard from Dr. Germain, who was considering adding different types of donations.

Does that change the actual bill itself, or is there a mechanism to add different donations, even after the approval of Bill C-234? I know blood and bone marrow have been added, but we’re also hearing different pieces now that could possibly — I’ve never heard of breast milk being a donation because in my culture, we do it willingly.

I don’t know what that would do to the bill itself. Is that a regulation that could be used to add different types of donations?

Just as a general comment, this topic is really interesting for me because we do have people in Nunavut who have donated and are live donors, but that means those families have to live down south for months to undergo the testing. Sometimes some of them have to live in Toronto. People who have never lived in a city before have to live for over two months away from their children, families and communities. It’s a very difficult procedure for people to go through.

It’s not like you could just drive to the hospital and spend some time there and do the donation. You’re leaving your community, your culture and your language. For us, it’s always the food that we eat that people make a real sacrifice to do this for someone in their family.

I’m thinking of the ones I know who have donated, whether it’s a kidney or a liver. This is something that we don’t know that much about either, and I agree with the awareness part of it, that maybe more people would get interested in giving and being a donor.

But going back, I’m just wondering how you would deal with those different pieces that could be donated that were mentioned.

Maybe, Dr. Germain, you could address some of that. Thank you.

Dr. Germain: Regarding the last point, I think Ms. Bouchard already mentioned that there are several obstacles to — especially living organ donation — that need to be addressed, and you’ve given some salient examples of that. That is, I would say, outside the scope of the current bill that is proposed, but we need to remember that those are serious issues that need to be considered.

With respect to the first part of your question, I’m not a legislator. I don’t know whether the bill would need to be amended to take into consideration other types of donations. Would it take the form of regulations that would be added to the law itself? I don’t know. I’m not an expert in that regard.

I think the important message here is that we would ask this committee to consider whether it could be incorporated eventually. Whether or not it needs a change in the current formulation of the bill is not for me to decide. We would certainly reiterate the importance of considering not just organ donation but other types of living donation.

Ms. Bouchard: For the notion that you mentioned about the difficulty of going down south for a few months, not so much in Quebec, but I saw that in Manitoba when I was president and CEO of a hospital there. We had regular difficulties with people because — you’re absolutely right, the food, the culture and the language are completely different.

Would this bill address this? I don’t think so. But is there something to that effect that we need to look at from equitable access to care in all parts of Canada? That would be, maybe, one thing to look at because it creates — as we speak — differences within different communities, and how can we address this from a donation perspective? We need to be mindful of that.

The Chair: Thank you, all. This brings us to the end of our time with this panel. I sincerely thank you for taking the time to join us today. Your assistance with our study of this division of the bill is greatly appreciated, and you’ve certainly contributed to our process.

For our second panel, we have the pleasure of welcoming Brigadier-General (retired) Marc Thériault, Director General, Chancellery and Deputy Herald Chancellor, Office of the Secretary to the Governor General — it’s a long title, but I think I got it all — Honourary Lieutenent-Colonel (retired) Solomon Rolingher, A.O.E., C.D., K.C., Chair, Board of Trustees, Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation, as an individual; and joining us by video conference, Meghan Rozema, a two-time living organ donor.

Thank you for joining us. We invite you to provide your opening remarks before we move to questions from members.

[Translation]

Marc Thériault, Director General, Chancellery and Deputy Herald Chancellor, Office of the Secretary to the Governor General: Honourable senators, good afternoon.

[English]

I would like to thank the committee for the opportunity extended to the Office of the Secretary to the Governor General to express its views on Bill C-234. I serve as the head of the Chancellery of Honours, which is the secretariat responsible for administering many aspects of the Canadian honours system. This complex system is comprised of numerous programs, ranging from national orders to decorations to medals. It also includes the granting of heraldic honours and certain awards.

The donation of organs and tissues is an act holding immense value for Canadian society. While it is appropriate to recognize this profound generosity through meaningful avenues, the mechanisms to do so must be well conceived and structurally efficient. In an optimal situation, the structure of a new honour should align with the dynamics of our national honours system.

The framework proposed for this medal is rather unconventional. Allow me to explain how it differs from those that justify the Governor General’s involvement in the management of honours. In Canada, national honours are normally created by the sovereign on the recommendation of the prime minister. They are bestowed by the Governor General, who exercises the Royal Prerogative of the Crown for honours created by the sovereign. By proposing to create a medal through an act of Parliament, this program would, therefore, not require viceregal administration. Consequently, Parliament could consider alternative delivery models better aligned with the current circumstances.

Honours administered through the Governor General have one thing in common; they involve a qualitative assessment. There is always a “good conduct” component, which is why most programs rely on advisory bodies to review nominations. As proposed, the living donor medal features no such mechanism. Its eligibility criteria include no subjective evaluation. Person X donated Y and, therefore, receives the medal.

If the proposal were to remain as it stands, it is foreseeable that Canada would or could award honours to individuals whose conduct has deviated from accepted societal standards. Instead, the program design could better operate in a streamlined fashion that would eliminate the formalities associated with most national honours.

An alternative concept would see medals or awards provided directly to key partners, with production costs borne by the department responsible for health. Clearly, the participation of organizations involved in human tissue collection is paramount to the success of this project. They are frequently the only entities capable of validating whether eligibility criteria have been met.

There is one specific component of the proposed bill that is particularly concerning: the granting of post-nominal letters.

Medals, by definition, do not carry post-nominal privileges. Even the Sacrifice Medal, which is awarded to Canadian military personnel injured or killed because of enemy action, does not confer post-nominal letters. Granting such a privilege to this medal would disrupt the structural logic upheld within the Canadian honours system.

We must also consider the critical issue of resources. Designing, regulating and manufacturing a new honour is an undertaking that takes over a year to complete. Beyond insignia production and regardless of the path chosen, the program would require ongoing funding for administrative costs and staffing. Securing these resources could be particularly challenging, given the constraints imposed on the funding of private members’ bills and the recent reductions imposed by the Comprehensive Expenditure Review.

If the goal is to honour these selfless donors with a national honour, amending an existing program might be a better alternative to building a new one from scratch. The Sovereign’s Medal for Volunteers carries a foundational philosophy that aligns seamlessly with the intended objectives of this bill. A human tissue donation division could be added to the existing program.

[Translation]

In conclusion, we look forward to working with you to make this a success. We are confident that we can come up with a solution that both celebrates the value of human tissue donation and aligns with the Canadian honours system.

On behalf of the Office of the Secretary to the Governor General, I want to thank the committee for the opportunity to share insight and provide constructive suggestions.

[English]

The Chair: Thank you.

Mr. Rolingher?

Honorary Lieutenent-Colonel (retired) Solomon Rolingher, A.O.E., C.D., K.C., Chair, Board of trustees, Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation: Thank you. I begin with a bit of a challenge to you. It’s not in my notes, but it’s this: You’ve heard this old chestnut: When is the best time to plant a tree? One hundred years ago. It’s full and blooming, and it gives you fruit and everything that you wish that it had. When is the second-best time? Today.

When was the best time to have had this bill come forth? One hundred years ago. Because, today, we would have people who are readily giving donations of their organs, and we might be beyond that with any kind of scientific knowledge that would come with it.

Why do I say that? I am going to talk about post-nominals because to get a tree to grow 100 years ago, you had to nourish it, feed it and do the right thing. I am of the firm belief that giving post-nominals is the way to go. Why? Because I have a few. What I have done with them, most importantly, was not to use them to my advantage but to use it to the advantage of the people to whom I speak, when I talk to the person next to me or to somebody else who does have that post-nominal. I say to those people, you have to listen; you have to speak to these people; you have to have a conversation and a dialogue. You have to hear what we are talking about so we can begin that process that should have happened 100 years ago. We must do it today for our children and our children’s children.

If we don’t do it, they will suffer the same angst that we are suffering right now. Sadly, some of them won’t make it, and some of us won’t make it. So we have to begin now. One hundred years has gone by, yes; enough of that. I will tell you why we are here, at least from my point of view.

I worked with boards and organizations. You heard about my work with the Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation. I am a past lawyer, now retired, and that was one of my biggest clients. They have asked me to stay on in another capacity.

I can talk to them about things that matter to them that they may not realize. Frankly, among the unwashed masses of Canadians, nobody has a good working knowledge of organ donation and what it is about, except “It’s a scary thing, and I’m not about to give up one of mine.” Wouldn’t that be your idea? I am sure many of our confrères think that way but obviously not all. We have many very altruistic people who donate, but it is nowhere near enough.

How are we going to deal with the costs of all of this and, better than that, deal with the people who are suffering and not being saved because we are not quick enough? We have not done our job. We have to do it and do it now. I believe, because of some of the examples I am about to give you, that post-nominals allow that to happen.

What would be an example? In 2010, the new Lieutenant Governor of Alberta, Donald Ethell, a retired colonel, began with creating a foundation called the Lieutenant Governor’s Circle on Mental Health & Addiction. Mental health and addictions were not talked about. If you can think back that long ago, you know it was something you left in the closet. You may have talked about it at home, but you certainly didn’t go public with it. It might affect your career. It might affect other people in your family. You didn’t talk about it.

Now we have Bell Let’s Talk. That’s one example of something we did with Colonel Ethell, the Lieutenant Governor of the day, and his post-nominals. I did it because he asked me to chair that board. We took it across the province. Everybody heard about it. Within the first five years of his term — and that was his term, of course — a dialogue had begun. It happened because he came with his stature and his post-nominals — not his medals. He didn’t wear his medals; of course not. We were talking to kids in small and large cities in Alberta. We got people to listen because they thought this man had something relevant and real to hear. And, now, the issue of mental health is not in the closet.

So many other things are like that when we address it with people. People like you can talk about it. “This is a person who went through it. Listen to them.” You can emulate what they do. We have to do that, and if we don’t do it, then we have, sadly, left this thing behind. I wouldn’t be able to live with myself when I think about my children, my grandchildren and those to follow.

I know my five minutes are about to run out. So, how can I tell you about how this happens? When I received the Alberta Order of Excellence, people spoke about it. They spoke not so much about me but about this as something to which you can aspire. You can do something good in this country, in this province, in your city, for that matter, that will make a difference to other people living around you. You can make this a better place. You can aspire to be that kind of a person, recognized by the government of the day.

The government of the day today would like to see us have the medal that we are talking about it right now. I don’t wish you not to do it. I want you to do it, and I am trying to give you the reasons why.

It is the same with the Canadian Forces’ Decoration, known as the CD. You earn it by being in the military for 12 years and not screwing up. I happened to have been there longer, 16 years, but people asked me to come and speak because they saw I had a CD. That allowed me to say to everyone, “Hey, the military is important. They are the people who are protecting us at the enemy’s gate — keep the enemies at the gates.”

I don’t want them to have to die to get a medal. I want to save people and recognize them while they are alive and give them something equally important, which is like something else for an organ donation. We talked about it, and others before me have spoken about this. I won’t profess to understand all of it, just enough that it matters.

When you can recognize what other people have done and work with them and they work with you, you can do a lot. My time is almost out; I will give you the last example.

We raised $125 million to keep the Edmonton Protocol. You may remember what that is; it involves planting islets from the pancreas into the liver. When your pancreas fails and you don’t make insulin, we can now take your islets or other people’s islets and recreate that ability. That project was going to leave and go to Miami. We took the Dean of Medicine and others with a list of post-nominals this long to talk to the premier. We said, “You have to act right now, or we will lose this program.” We got the $125 million, and we kept the program here. It is here for all of us to appreciate.

The Chair: Thank you very much. I am sorry to cut you off. Hopefully, someone will ask you a question so you can complete that.

I will now go to Ms. Rozema.

Meghan Rozema, Two-time living organ donor, As an Individual: Hello. My name is Meghan Rozema. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. I am calling from Sherwood Park, Alberta. I am Alberta’s first and only person to be a living double-organ donor, having donated part of my liver in 2021 and a kidney in 2023. These donations were done anonymously, and I have not met the recipients.

My purpose today is to support Bill C-234 and share why granting medal recipients the legal right to use the post-nominal letters, L.D.M., for Living Donor Medal, would be beneficial for living organ donation.

I respect the physical and mental sacrifices made by military personnel and am mindful of the concerns some may have with post-nominal letters. Mutual recognition can exist without undermining or minimizing the accomplishments of others. We must look beyond our own recognition to see the common goal of saving the lives of Canadians. Military personnel and altruistic donors, while not sacrificing at the same capacity, share a similar mentality — serving others at risk to self. The accomplishments of each group can be equally recognized and celebrated without diminishing the other.

This September, during Living Donation Week, my story was shared by Give Life Alberta and Alberta Health Services, followed by news and radio interviews and social media posts. I received many messages from acquaintances saying they had no idea I was an organ donor.

Being an altruistic donor, I find myself in an odd position. I didn’t donate for recognition, yet I feel a sense of responsibility to educate others about living donation. How does one bring up the topic without it coming across as bragging? I can only recall one instance where I brought up my story in conversation, and this was only after a friend shared how her brother was a deceased donor.

The need for organ donation is urgent. Over 4,300 people in Canada are waiting for organ transplants. Hundreds die each year while waiting or become too sick to be eligible for surgery. Transplants typically have better outcomes with living donors than with deceased donors.

For someone waiting for a liver transplant, the cost of a transplant is less than repeated acute hospital stays. For someone waiting for a kidney, the cost of a transplant is less than the annual cost of dialysis. High rates of job loss for these individuals contribute to an indirect economic strain via disability support.

Living donor programs have to be cautious in how they share their purpose without it being seen as soliciting for organs. The very organizations whose objective is to increase access to transplantation are limited to one promotional week per year in sharing their goal. I think we can agree that increased awareness and visibility of living organ donation is extremely valuable in saving lives and reducing health care costs.

Most altruistic donors would suggest the post-nominal letters are not even about the donors. It is about educating and inspiring others to save lives. If post-nominal letters in a donor’s email or job title can prompt others to consider the donation process, is it not worth it?

When you consider the tactfulness required when talking about one’s organ donation, the urgency for organs, the reduced health care costs from transplants and limited public educational opportunities, having an additional method to promote living organ donation would be of value to Canadians awaiting transplants. The benefit of post-nominal letters would not be for donors themselves, but would instead be an impactful tool to stimulate curiosity and initiate conversation in the hopes other Canadians would be inspired to donate. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you all for your statements. We will now go to members for their questions.

Senator Bernard: Thank you all for your testimony this evening. It has been very helpful. I would like to ask a question of Mr. Thériault, first of all. You have laid out a number of concerns about this bill: the lack of qualitative evaluation, the use of the post-nominal letters — which the other panellists highly support — and the costs around staffing and administration.

Do you feel that any of those concerns could be addressed with any amendments to this bill?

Mr. Thériault: Yes, thank you very much for your question. I believe that, indeed, if the post-nominal granting remains part of the bill, it creates a requirement for preventing the misuse or misappropriation of the post-nominal, but it also creates an imbalance within the honour system. There are well over 50 medals that have been integrated into the Canadian honours system since its inception. None of them grant post-nominals. The exception is the Canadian Armed Forces decoration, which is rooted in an historical oddity that goes back to 1949, when it was created as a decoration and then turned into a medal.

I can provide a list of possible amendments that could make the program more palatable if you wish.

One thing is sure: It is difficult to change an act of Parliament, so any medals that are created through an act of Parliament — that act should be sufficiently general so it could be amended through an order-in-council later on.

Senator Bernard: If you have specific amendments that you could recommend, that would be helpful.

Mr. Thériault: I would do so with pleasure.

The Chair: The timeline to send it to us is as soon as possible as October 19 is the deadline. We would need it before that, if that is possible, Mr. Thériault. Thank you.

Senator Bernard: That would be very helpful. I have a question for Ms. Rozema. Thank you very much for sharing your own story. We heard from the previous panel that stories help create awareness. So I would like you to talk a bit more about your own experience in terms of awareness. You are supporting this bill based on your experience. Based on your experience, do you believe that this legislation would help increase the number of living donors?

Ms. Rozema: Thank you. It took me about two years to decide to donate an organ, and that was after seeing a post on social media requesting an organ, meeting somebody who had donated an organ and going to an event where organ donation was promoted that night.

Some people react instantly when they hear about organ donation, saying, yes, this is for me; but for others like me, it takes time. Seeds were planted, and I wanted to educate myself about the risks and the benefits. That was my experience.

The bill will encourage donors. It is about visibility and educating people. Seeds that can be planted in people’s minds about organ donation. For example, how many people realize you can donate part of your liver while you are still alive? That’s the key here in what the bill can accomplish. People can see that I’m just a regular person, and I can continue on in my life without any consequences.

Senator Bernard: A regular person would get invited to an event about living donorship?

Ms. Rozema: Can you repeat that?

Senator Bernard: You describe yourself as a regular person. You said one of the ways you heard about being a living donor was through an event. I’m wondering, how do people get invited to such events?

Ms. Rozema: This event was actually a hockey game. That evening, it was featured on a Jumbotron. The athletes were wearing jerseys in the colours of organ donation: green and white. It was educational. The Jumbotron showed what organs could be donated while living and which as a deceased donor.

Senator Bernard: Oh. That’s very creative. Thank you.

Senator K. Wells: This question is back to Mr. Thériault. You mentioned that including post-nominal recognition wouldn’t be normal; this would be the only case in terms of the awards that are administered, obviously, outside of things like the Order of Canada, which we are probably the most familiar with.

Could you elaborate on the concerns that this would bring forward, of having one out of a suite? Would you say that there would be a need to go backwards then and assess other deserving awards to add post-nominals? Would that only be able to be done through an act of Parliament, or would there be consideration from the Governor General or whoever administration the awards to look backwards at other awards? Perhaps it is hard to say which one is the most deserving of so many important awards that are administered.

Mr. Thériault: Thank you very much for your question. I can elaborate a little bit more about the concerns. It is very hard to wait between deeds or contributions to society, for instance, if we look at long service medals recognizing corrections service officers, police officers, coast guards, and the list goes on.

For 20 years of service, it’s called an exemplary service medal. It comes with a thorough reputational review conducted by a committee, a recommendation and an advisory committee. Twenty years of service and impeccable behaviour are required for a medal that comes with no post-nominal. Extending, for instance, by comparison, post-nominals granting to some form of tissue donations, plasma or blood donation — it depends where the threshold is placed. Is it 100? Is it 200? How does that compare with 20 years of a police officer facing difficult situations day in and day out?

This is where, in our honour system, there are always post-nominals for national orders at the top of the pyramid. You mentioned the Order of Canada. I know we have recipients of that here with us today. Decorations: bravery decorations and meritorious service decorations, for instance, come with post-nominals because people are vetted. We review the background of those people. When Canada confers an honour on somebody, it raises scrutiny. There’s a risk of misappropriation. There needs to be a reference possible for people to ensure they don’t misappropriate a post-nominal.

We often deal with the possibility of termination, cancellation and revocation, for instance, when a victim reports that a recipient of an honour has committed a terrible, indictable offence.

All amendments to an honours policy require an order-in-council. For all those other programs, that’s the way it is done. An honours policy is recognized as a prime ministerial prerogative. It is exercised by executive power.

Senator K. Wells: To your knowledge, has the Prime Minister endorsed this bill or this recognition?

Mr. Thériault: I have no knowledge of whether this has been endorsed or not. I’m sorry.

Senator K. Wells: Do you have a sense of what the cost of administering this would be for your office?

Mr. Thériault: The initial estimate is based on a plethora of tissue donation categories — platelets, full blood. It can go up depending on where the threshold for eligibility is located. If it is 200, for those most common forms of human tissue donation, it gets around 6,000 recipients per year. If the eligibility threshold is increased to a higher level, it’s different.

Senator K. Wells: Thank you.

[Translation]

Senator Arnold: Thank you very much for being with us this evening, Mr. Thériault.

[English]

Thank you for taking the time to suggest some changes. I think I heard you say this work is really important because, if it is an act of Parliament, we really have to do what it says.

You mentioned in your statement that we could potentially consider adding to an existing program. Could you flesh that out a bit for us, what that could look like?

Mr. Thériault: A program was created in 2015 called the Sovereign’s Medal for Volunteers. It recognizes extended volunteerism, interpreted as 10 years plus. This is an existing and successful program that recognizes hundreds of Canadians yearly. It already benefits from design, and we could insert, through an order-in-council, a recommendation that can be put forward to deciding authorities for creating a different division in that very same program. From a philosophical standpoint, it seems to be a seamless association; it’s a form of volunteerism. By creating a different division of that same program, we could expedite the creation of a program recognizing organ donation with a different ribbon, the same insignia, or something like this.

Senator Arnold: Understanding this is an act of Parliament, would it be best if anything we put forward is a little less prescriptive? As I sit here and listen, it sounds fairly murky. There’s a lot of work that needs to be done to add precision to all of this.

Mr. Thériault: I may give you an example. There’s only one other example of a Canadian honour created by an act of Parliament, and it happened in 1997: the Canadian Peacekeeping Service Medal. It says that Canadians who have deployed for X number of days on a peacekeeping mission are eligible to receive the medal. Back in those days, in order to join the Canadian Armed Forces, there was a requirement for Canadian citizenship. This has since changed. It places the military institution in a challenging situation when people are deployed on missions because there would possibly be people not recognized because they’re not Canadian citizens. The only change that can amend an act of Parliament is an act of Parliament, which makes the amendment process rather challenging.

Senator Arnold: Thank you.

Senator D. M. Wells: Ms. Rozema, thank you for what you’ve done, not just for the two people who received your organs or parts of your organs, but what you’ve done to set an example for so many Canadians and perhaps beyond Canadians as well.

Mr. Rolingher, thank you for your opening remarks; I appreciated them. It made me think of a couple of things, especially after hearing from Mr. Thériault. Relating to the post-nominals, Mr. Thériault said it’s too much money, it takes a lot of time, referenced that it’s a private member’s bill, and it would throw a wrench — I’m paraphrasing — into the honours program that’s established, that some people might represent the donation of the organs they’ve given, perhaps suggesting people — maybe like Ms. Rozema, for instance — that it’s the PM’s prerogative. Of course, we know the PM voted for this on April 22, 2026, as did Minister LeBlanc and all the ministers present. It was a unanimous vote in the House. The PM’s prerogative is there.

What do you say as a supporter of the post-nominal aspect of this? You heard the witnesses who appeared in panel one were all in favour. What is your comment on all these reasons why it should not happen versus your reasons why it should happen?

LCol. Rolingher: I’m going to try to follow your question. I’ll speak to why I think it should happen. Is that satisfactory?

Senator D. M. Wells: We heard many reasons why it shouldn’t happen. It takes too long; it’s too much money; it might remove the PM’s prerogative. There were many reasons.

LCol. Rolingher: It should happen because there are 40 million people in this country. We have 100,000, if we’re lucky, in the military who have a bulk of medals. There are a lot of Orders of Canada and provincial orders as well. We have to get out and touch the 40 million people. They’re the ones who have the organs we’re looking to be donated, who should do that because of altruistic reasons. If we don’t touch them, don’t get to them; it won’t happen. How do we do that? Post-nominals put someone’s name among the 40 million that someone else — any of us — can speak to and extol the virtues of that and get them to be the spokespeople who will say to the other 39,999,000, you should do what I did too. We just heard from somebody here who didn’t do it once but did it twice. My goodness, that woman should be a saint.

Why don’t we do that and make that happen? That’s what this would do. Post-nominals are in your name, on your name, and able to be spoken to. A medal is in your pocket, leaves when you die, and it’s done. A medal to me is just fine. I don’t want to take anything away from someone who deserves it. I want to take this and make it happen so we don’t have to deal with the scourge of having no donor available. The cost of me doing it? It costs you nothing.

Any of us, in any organization — and all of us are in some organization, be it a church of worship or the Rotarians or a hockey group or whatever it is — have a chance to interact with other people and talk about the person right next to you and say, “Did you know this person has a Living Donor Medal, or L.D.M.? Let me tell you what that’s all about.”

You’re not wearing it. You know it, because it’s on their name, and their name is probably somewhere or another — displayed on the Jumbotron at the Edmonton Oilers hockey game, for all I know.

That is how people begin to learn, and that’s what we did with Bell Let’s Talk, because I took people — not me, but others who had post-nominals — and said, “Here is what these people did; listen to what they have to say.”

We shouldn’t do this and take people who had, maybe, mental issues or addictions and hive them off in dark corners. No. Open up and listen to what their problem is, and let’s try to solve it, but be supportive and be Canadian. Be Canadian about it.

That’s what I see post-nominals doing. It is that fertilizer. It nurtures that tree to grow. It won’t happen overnight, but it will happen; I promise you that. Because the more people who will be recognized, and if they have it with their name, it’s not buried in a closet or in a drawer to be worn only on Remembrance Day. No. It’s there with them constantly every day of the year so that we can all then do our job, and the rest of us have to do this, too. We have to honour them. We have to bring them out and make them the spokespeople.

That’s what I believe a post-nominal will do. I’ve seen it happen with me, and I’ve seen it happen — and with money. Money is not the issue. If we want to equate that we’re not going to do this because of money, I would be appalled. I don’t think you’re going to do that. No, that won’t be the issue. We’ll find the money. We absolutely will. It’s just that we can do it even without money because we have the ability ourselves.

The Chair: Are there any other questions, senators? Perhaps, as you think about that, I can think of a question myself.

I am aware that this bill was amended to include blood donors in the House, and I think it’s blood donors who have donated over a certain number of times. We heard from the previous witness that there are about 44 or so who have donated over 1,000 times.

I would like to hear from you, Mr. Thériault and Mr. Rolingher. How do you see this impacting this bill and the recognition of this bill? Do you see any implications of that?

LCol. Rolingher: Well, if I understand correctly, how do we make this happen, and how could we take advantage of the situation and change things generally? Is this what you are asking?

The Chair: You’ve changed my question a bit. Do you see any implications for including blood donors in this bill beyond living organ donors?

LCol. Rolingher: I’m sorry. I’m having a hard time hearing. Could you speak to that question one more time?

The Chair: Yes. Are you concerned — I’ll put it that way — about the inclusion of blood donors, as it impacts those who are living organ donors?

LCol. Rolingher: No, I don’t see the distinction. Giving blood is giving something of yourself to save the life of another. As we have heard from others, we probably don’t have a whole bunch of blood, and we could do with more. If people are prepared on a consistent and constant basis to show their dedication to the program of giving something and giving a quantity of blood — and I’m not the one to ask — but something that would be an acceptable limit would, to me, be equal to saying, “I’m giving you a kidney or a piece of my liver.” I’ve given you something that can go to wherever these people are.

Sadly, I see nothing but grief coming at us with forest fires, floods and wars, so we need more of everything. Blood should not be distinguished as not being relevant or not being sufficient. If you show that the person is dedicated, the donor is dedicated to coming every three months — if that’s the limit — and I’ll do it consistently, and you can count on me. It’s like having money in the bank, and I’m paying the mortgage. I’ll pay that mortgage off, and then the house is mine. You have your life back because I will be there, and you can count on me.

If we had the ability to say that that money is coming in every three months or — money, blood, I know it’s not the same — but that’s my answer to that.

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Rolingher.

Mr. Thériault?

Mr. Thériault: I’m a bit concerned. I believe I was not precise enough, and I may have led people to believe that we’re not in support of this bill. It’s about where the eligibility threshold is.

If we’re talking about including blood donors, there’s no issue, but we need to make sure that Canadian Blood Services will participate and that they are the entity that is capable of providing the information to connect with the donors and make sure they’re willing to share their information with whomever is going to administer this program.

The Chair: Thank you for clarifying because I did hear you emphasize the importance of partnerships with Canadian Blood Services and others. Thank you.

Any other questions of our panellists?

Hearing none, we thank you so much on behalf of the committee for taking time to appear before us today. Your testimony will be very helpful as we consider this bill.

This concludes our scheduled public hearings of Bill C-234. During our next meeting on October 19, we intend to begin clause-by-clause consideration.

If you have not already done so, members are encouraged to contact the office of the clerk and parliamentary counsel should they wish to bring forward amendments. If you would like your amendments bundled and distributed in advance of the meeting, please share them with the clerk no later than Friday, October 16. Otherwise, please bring sufficient copies of your amendments with you, and we are suggesting 30 copies.

I now propose we proceed in camera to consider the draft report for our work on the Budget Implementation Act as well as the travel budget in relation to our study on 2SLGBTQIA+ youth. Do I have your agreement, colleagues?

Hon. Senators: Agreed.

(The committee continued in camera.)

Back to top