Skip to main content
SOCI - Standing Committee

Social Affairs, Science and Technology


THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL AFFAIRS, SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Thursday, October 8, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology met with videoconference this day at 10:30 a.m. [ET] to examine Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder.

Senator Rosemary Moodie (Chair) in the chair.

[English]

The Chair: Good morning. My name is Rosemary Moodie. I am a senator from Ontario and chair of this committee.

Before we begin, I’d like to go around the table and have senators introduce themselves.

Senator Burey: Good morning and welcome. Sharon Burey, Ontario.

Senator Senior: Good morning. Welcome. Paulette Senior, Ontario.

[Translation]

Senator Boudreau: Good morning. Victor Boudreau from New Brunswick.

Senator Arnold: Good morning. Dawn Arnold from New Brunswick as well.

Senator Petitclerc: Good morning. Chantal Petitclerc from Quebec.

[English]

Senator Hay: Good morning. Katherine Hay, Ontario.

Senator Cuzner: Good morning. Rodger Cuzner, Nova Scotia.

Senator Muggli: Good morning. Tracy Muggli, Saskatchewan, Treaty 6 territory.

The Chair: Today, we continue our examination of Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder.

For our first panel this morning, we welcome Nancy Poole, Director of the Centre of Excellence for Women and the Prevention Lead for the Canada FASD Research Network, and Dr. Svetlana Popova, Senior Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, or CAMH, and a professor affiliated with the University of Toronto, who is joining us by video conference. As individuals, we also have Dr. James Reynolds, Emeritus Professor, Queen’s University, and Jennifer Chandler, Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa.

Thank you for joining us today. For your opening statements, you will have five minutes, followed by questions from committee members.

Dr. Poole, the floor is yours.

Nancy Poole, Director, Centre of Excellence for Women’s Health: Honourable senators, thanks for the opportunity to speak today. I lead a virtual, non-profit research centre that’s based in Vancouver, hosted by BC Women’s Hospital, from where we work with others, across Canada and internationally, on improving girls’ and women’s health and increasing gender equity.

In this role, over the past three decades, I have focused on the highly stigmatized topic of women’s substance use, and I have led prevention research for the Canada FASD Research Network, known as CanFASD. I feel it’s really important to see prevention of fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, or FASD, as an issue of women’s health and social justice. I am proud of the contributions that I and the members of CanFASD’s Prevention Network Action Team have made to the understanding of and the action on FASD prevention over the past decade.

I am particularly proud of how we’ve been able to define and promote an internationally recognized four-level model of FASD prevention. The model shows just how complex the prevention of alcohol use in pregnancy is. It involves raising awareness through campaigns and health promotion strategies.

Second, it involves girls, women and gender-diverse individuals of child-bearing years having the opportunity for safe discussions about reproductive health, contraception, pregnancy, alcohol use and related issues with trusted health and social care providers.

The third level is providing specialized, supportive services for pregnant women who use substances and who have histories of violence and trauma and related health concerns. We need services that are culturally safe and accessible.

The fourth level is offering wrap-around programming for new mothers that promotes attachment between mothers and children and offers a range of services to support women’s, infant and child wellness.

I will offer just one idea from each of these four levels of prevention where the bill would make a critical difference to the work.

A national framework could, on the awareness level, recommend a mechanism for regular national awareness-raising campaigns about the risks of alcohol use by couples in both the preconception and perinatal periods.

On the discussion of alcohol use level, it could recommend how health and social care professionals receive training in evidence-based approaches to discuss alcohol use in pregnancy from national professional bodies, post-secondary educational institutions and other avenues.

On the level of provision of support during pregnancy, it could recommend how research funding can be instituted into the structural, informational, stress-related, health determinant and other influences on women’s alcohol use and the effective strategies for addressing these influences.

On the postpartum level, it could recommend action for increasing substance use recovery supports for women across this country and, specifically, increasing options for integrated treatment and support for mothers with their children.

Canada has made considerable contributions to the understanding of and action on FASD prevention over the past decade, yet significant barriers remain to having coordinated, compassionate, evidence-informed and systemic approaches to prevention of alcohol use in pregnancy, approaches that are tailored to differing levels of risk for women, their children and their families.

The elements of a framework, as identified in Bill S-234, would be a significant contribution to guide much-needed action. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you, Dr. Poole.

Dr. Popova, you have five minutes.

Dr. Svetlana Popova, Senior Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health: Honourable senators, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today.

For more than two decades, my research has focused on prenatal alcohol exposure, FASD, prevention, surveillance and the health and economic burdens. I strongly support a national framework for FASD for seven important reasons.

First, FASD is a significant public health issue, but we still do not know its true prevalence in Canada. Our population-based research in elementary schools in the Greater Toronto Area estimated that approximately 2% to 3% of children met diagnostic criteria for FASD. This tells us that FASD is not a rare condition. However, the burden is not evenly distributed.

When we look at certain special populations in Canada, including children in care and individuals involved with the correctional system, the reported prevalence of FASD is substantially higher than in the general population, yet Canada still lacks comprehensive, national FASD surveillance. We cannot effectively respond to a condition if we do not systematically measure its prevalence, distribution and impact.

Second, access to diagnosis and services is highly uneven across Canada. Where a person lives can significantly affect whether and how quickly they can obtain a FASD assessment and appropriate support. Our recent study found that waiting times for FASD assessment ranged from one month to four and a half years. These disparities can be particularly challenging for people living in rural, remote, northern and underserved communities, where specialized multidisciplinary expertise may not be readily available. A national framework can help establish common standards for timely and equitable access while strengthening diagnostic capacity across the country.

Third, FASD is a lifelong condition that affects multiple organs and systems of the body. Our research has identified more than 400 health conditions reported in individuals with FASD. But the impact extends beyond health care. People with FASD and their families may interact with education, mental health, social services, child welfare, employment, housing and the justice system.

We, therefore, cannot address FASD effectively through isolated programs or a single sector. We need a coordinated, life course approach.

Fourth, prevention requires national coordination and must start early. Young people should receive age-appropriate education in schools about alcohol, prenatal alcohol exposure and FASD before pregnancy may occur. A national framework can promote consistent, evidence-based prevention across Canada, together with screening, treatment and support.

Fifth, FASD carries a substantial economic burden. Our earlier research estimated the annual cost of FASD in Canada at $1.3 billion to $2.3 billion, and the true burden is likely substantially higher. A national framework can help reduce these costs by coordinating investment in prevention, early diagnosis and effective supports across Canada.

Sixth, we need national consistency without a one-size-fits-all approach. Currently, prevention, diagnosis and supports vary considerably across Canada. A national framework can establish common goals, standards and indicators while allowing provinces, territories and communities to determine how best to achieve them. The goal is not identical services everywhere but equitable access and consistent standards across Canada.

Finally, we need accountability. A national framework should establish clear baseline data and measurable indicators from the start. In five years, we should know whether prenatal alcohol exposure has decreased, diagnoses are earlier, waiting times and disparities have narrowed and supports for individuals with FASD and their families have improved.

Without measurement, we cannot know whether the framework is making a difference. Canada has the expertise. What we need is a coordinated national system connecting prevention, surveillance, diagnosis, services, research and policy. We have a national problem, and we need a coordinated national response. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you.

Dr. Reynolds, you have the floor.

James Reynolds, Emeritus Professor, Queen’s University, as an individual: Thank you, Madam Chair.

I’d like to thank the committee for the opportunity to address you today. I’m James Reynolds, Emeritus Professor in the Department of Biomedical and Molecular Sciences and the Centre for Neuroscience Studies at Queen’s University. My interdisciplinary research program spanned over 35 years and included both basic and clinical investigations on the mechanisms and consequences of prenatal alcohol exposure on the developing brain. I’ve held numerous leadership roles in my career, including serving as the Chief Scientific Officer for the Kids Brain Health Network, a national Network of Centres of Excellence focused on neurodevelopmental disabilities. Most recently, I was a member of the expert panel that helped guide the work of the Canadian Academy of Health Sciences in its review of the state of knowledge regarding FASD in Canada. My perspective of Bill S-234 is shaped by these experiences, and I am particularly pleased to see Jennifer Chandler on the call, who was the chair of that committee. I’m sure she will recognize a few of the ideas that I am about to share with you.

The committee has already heard from many individuals and organizations that have outlined the tremendous burden that FASD places on individuals, families and society. As Dr. Popova just pointed out — and I won’t repeat this other than to remind you — the direct and indirect costs associated with FASD run into the billions of dollars in Canada every year.

FASD has been recognized as a “national health concern” in Canada since the early 1990s. As you know and have heard, since 2003, the foundational Canadian policy document intended to guide collaborative efforts across all levels of government and community organizations has been the Public Health Agency of Canada’s document entitled Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD): A Framework for Action.

Since its release in 2003, the framework has undergone periodic review and evaluation of its impact. The most recent evaluation by the Public Health Agency of Canada in 2023 concluded that, despite having ambitious objectives, FASD‑dedicated funding is limited and important gaps to addressing FASD in Canada remain. Indeed, despite the growing evidence of the high prevalence and socio-economic burden of FASD in Canada, funding at the federal level for FASD initiatives has not changed substantially since 1999.

A key feature of a well-structured strategy is the recognition of the critical importance of effective mechanisms to ensure coordination and collaboration among the many different sectors of government that need to work together. This should include the explicit articulation of whom will participate, the governance structure and mechanisms for accountability. However, in Canada there is currently no national approach or strategy that defines the roles and responsibilities of all FASD key partners and stakeholders to help coordinate efforts. The absence of a clearly identified coordinating or “backbone” organization is a critical barrier, as the expectation that collaboration will occur without a supporting infrastructure is one of the most frequent reasons why it fails.

In my view, this is the critical gap that Bill S-234 provides an opportunity to address. In summary, despite over 30 years of recognizing FASD as a “national health concern,” relatively little has changed to improve the quality of life for individuals with FASD and their families. People with FASD continue to be overrepresented in child welfare and criminal justice systems and struggle within education systems that either fail to recognize them or do not understand their needs. The need for action is clear. The question is how and when we as a society will choose to respond to that need.

Thank you for your attention.

The Chair: Thank you, Dr. Reynolds.

Dr. Chandler, last but certainly not least, you have the floor.

Jennifer Chandler, Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, as an individual: Thank you very much to the committee for the invitation. I am honoured and very pleased to be here to speak with you.

For a tiny bit of background, I am a full professor of law cross-appointed to the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Ottawa. I teach medical and mental health law, including the health, criminal and human rights aspects of mental disorders, and I hold a Canada Research Chair (Tier 1) in the Law and Ethics of Brain Technologies and have written on the use of brain-related evidence in criminal cases in Canada.

As Dr. Reynolds mentioned, I was the chair of the federal government-sponsored panel responsible for a recent report on fetal alcohol spectrum disorder in Canada, and this was produced by the Canadian Academy of Health Sciences, sponsored by the Public Health Agency of Canada. I’m delighted to see both Dr. Popova and Dr. Reynolds, who were invaluable members of that committee and engaged with us in over a year’s work on what turned out to be a nearly 400-page report.

This report was based on extensive reviews of literature and policy documents, as well as a multi-pronged process of engagement with stakeholders across Canada. We were asked to address four key questions and also to analyze the implementation of the 2003 FASD framework. Since we are discussing a bill calling for a new national framework, I will start with a comment on our analysis of the 2003 FASD framework.

We found that it was extremely valuable. It did many things: It signalled a shared commitment, raised the profile of a significant public health concern and galvanized and supported a lot of the progress that has been made in the last 23 years. It was intended to be, on its own terms, loose, facilitative and not directive. It started a discussion, launched ideas and invited people — the provinces and stakeholders at all levels — to engage and find paths forward.

This was perhaps a strength at that time, but as we look around at more modern FASD frameworks, scanning, for example, what is going on in Australia, we see a move toward a tighter kind of framework. Some of the weaknesses in 2003 were a lack of concrete measures, clear roles and responsibilities, evaluation and accountability mechanisms, limited resources and, of course — and I don’t need to tell you about this — intersectoral and jurisdictional complexities. Some of those issues, like the jurisdictional complexities, have not gone away. You also heard from Dr. Popova and Dr. Reynolds about the need for accountability and evidence-based evaluation mechanisms to monitor impact and so forth to ensure a good use of resources going forward. There are these precedents around the world of attempting to move more in this direction in dealing with FASD.

The values of a national approach are also very clear. It signals importance at the highest level. It also helps to assist with coordination. It is true that provinces vary in the amount of resources they have. There is inefficiency in repeatedly reinventing the wheel. If information and best practices can be shared, that is efficient. Of course, I won’t reiterate the other reasons having to do with equity that were already mentioned.

It is true that a lot of the things that are needed have to be done at many levels of government, and this makes it challenging for the federal government to create a framework and then to make it happen. It requires buy-in at many different levels, but I also wanted to point out that some of the critical things that are needed fall squarely within the federal jurisdiction. One of these is addressing criminal justice issues. The Criminal Code and the federal penitentiary system are within federal control. I also remind people of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Calls to Action 33 and 34. Call to Action 34 expressly addresses criminal justice aspects.

I am sorry; I lost track of the time as I got into my topic here, but I will say one quick word about each of the four key issues we were asked to address in the report. One of them involved case identification and data collection challenges. This is critical. I won’t spend more time here. Dr. Popova is the expert. I would mention only that the problems of stigma and underdiagnosis most likely mean a dramatic underestimation of prevalence.

On the second aspect, you have Dr. Poole as the expert on strengthening prevention. Again, multi-level efforts are required, and there are also multiple different risk populations. People are at risk due to trauma, abuse, poverty and unmet mental health problems. There is also inadvertent exposure, before the pregnancy is known, in people who perhaps don’t face those risk factors. There is a heterogenous set of case origins to be considered in the context of prevention.

The third topic is supports needed for people with FASD. Here, much can be done to improve matters. The functioning of a system is complex and siloed. There are cut-offs, such as IQ cut‑offs for disability supports, that may exclude people who, nonetheless, face challenges in accessing support. I also mention the criminal justice system here.

Then there is the uptake of the FASD diagnostic guidelines. I found this was a very interesting part of our report —

The Chair: Dr. Chandler, you have officially run out of time. Could you wrap up, please?

Ms. Chandler: Okay. I would only say, as a last comment, there was a very interesting discussion about the importance of FASD diagnosis for some purposes, such as understanding prevalence and directing resources properly for prevention, but requiring causal evidence of alcohol use significantly causes difficulty for people who don’t have that evidence. If they can’t get the diagnosis, they may struggle to get FASD-specific supports.

There has been this call for a movement toward a different kind of diagnosis of complex neurodevelopmental disorders with alcohol mentioned where that is known. That’s one aspect that was important in our discussion of diagnostic guidelines. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you so much, Dr. Chandler.

We will now proceed with questions from committee members. For this panel, senators will have four minutes each for the question, and that includes the answer.

Senator Burey: Thank you to all of our guests for your dedication and hard work, your research knowledge and expertise and, obviously, your passion and care for Canadians.

There are so many questions to ask, but I wanted to, first of all, say hi to Dr. Reynolds, whom I met this weekend. He was an honouree for his esteemed work. Thank you for being here, and I’m sure all of you are esteemed as well.

Because of your research on the mechanisms and the subsequent consequences, what does it look like? We haven’t heard from any scientists. Tell us what the mechanisms are and what it leads to, and we only have three minutes.

Mr. Reynolds: Alcohol is a very, very simple molecule that has some of the most complex pharmacology of any psychoactive substance that we know. From a developmental perspective, it can interfere with every crucial step in the developing brain, from the creation of neurons to how they migrate to how they connect with each other to how they will function long term.

We have measured structural and functional changes across the brain. It is a global brain injury. It is expressed in different ways in different children. That’s a function both of the intrinsic characteristics of the child but also of their external environment.

I am giving a keynote address at an international FASD conference that’s hosted in Canada and being streamed to 12 or 15 countries in a couple of weeks, and this is what I will talk about. Alcohol, itself, is only the first insult. Many of these children then face trauma early in life. They are vulnerable to those traumas because of prenatal drug exposures and probably also the characteristics of the mother.

The outcome that will be felt is a consequence of not just alcohol exposure but then what transpires in that child’s life. This is what we know about children who go into the child welfare system. A typical presentation — I just wrote about this — is a child who is apprehended and then has three or four or five different homes that they live in before the age of five.

Do we really think that child is prepared, emotionally and mentally, to then go to school? They are not, and they will fail. When a child is raised in a nurturing, supportive environment, that’s an opportunity to mitigate the severity of the presentation. It is so variable because of the different factors that come into play from the mother, the child and their environment.

Senator Burey: Is there anything that we need that could improve this bill as it is now? Anyone can jump in. I’m thinking of Dr. Chandler. Professor?

Ms. Chandler: I had a look at the elements that are in the bill. I think our report would support everything that’s in there. One possibility might be — I don’t know if you want to hamper people putting the bill into effect — to direct attention toward gathering evidence of efficacy at systematic steps in the unfolding of the bill. It would be an important component of ensuring accountability, feedback and so forth.

Senator Hay: Thank you all for the work you are doing, day in and day out.

Dr. Poole, you started your remarks around stigma and being highly stigmatized. I do want to focus on that a little bit. With stigma, I want to use the word “blame.” They are hand in hand, but that’s a real action as well. There are stigma and blame on the individual, within families and within communities, and those are massive barriers. There is no question about it.

Could you speak to the stigma and blame that may be an unconscious bias throughout medical education, the health system itself, in family practice, in emergency departments, or EDs, for example? And then, in there, is the inequity of services, depending on where you live and how you identify and whatnot. Could you speak a little bit more about that?

Ms. Poole: A key part to this framework is this idea that we could really improve the education of health and social care providers and give them expertise in a whole range of things.

On the women’s side is this idea of really training on evidence-based, trauma-informed, empowering approaches to women who use substances. Pregnancy is such a great moment to be able to open that discussion in ways. It is kind of a window of opportunity when women really want to do the best for their children.

There is a real opportunity to increase our discussion competency within that time, as well as in general. It could really make a huge difference if women felt the person who is talking to them about alcohol is not going to judge them for that but is really going to get behind them and figure out how to hold the unit together and help them reduce or stop their use. Instead of thinking about the removal of children, we should think about how we make the mother-child unit work by supporting women’s health and helping them not use in pregnancy or helping them continue to not use as new mothers.

It is such a key point you’re making around the stigma. It is a huge barrier to prevention.

Senator Hay: If I can follow up to anyone around barriers. I think of the individual who might think it’s not that big of a problem or that they can handle it themselves or don’t want to share it.

Ms. Poole: And so often they say, “Oh, that’s for other women over there; that’s not me. I don’t have to think about this.” But everybody does. I think the stats say that — Svetlana can back me up on this — about 80% of women in Canada drink alcohol. We’re not pregnant all the time, but that means a lot of women have to stop if they want to have children who aren’t exposed.

We could really up our game in terms of helping make that a reality, where women know and are really supportive. Even if they haven’t been aware of their pregnancy and are still drinking, we could really get behind women to do the best they can from here on and not make that a barrier.

Senator Arnold: My question was very much around stigma as well. First of all, I’d like to thank the team for bringing together so many experts. It really feels like a very privileged place to be able to hear from all of you here today.

My question also is for Nancy or for anyone else on the stigma but more from a medical profession perspective. What would be some key things that could be done to educate there?

Ms. Poole: Wow, it’s like the answer that you had. I mean, this is my whole life’s work: thinking about how we can be more proactive in actually talking about alcohol in this country and making it not a taboo topic and a place where we can actually be comfortable in having conversations. I have had pediatricians say to me that the thing that holds them back in diagnosis or in identifying children with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder is that it’s challenging to find the moms, as that separation has already happened, and to have those conversations in ways that support women to really be able to speak their truth without feeling completely judged and blamed in lots of ways.

It is such a key point that we empower every social professional: the violence against women organizations, Indigenous organizations and everybody who has the opportunity to talk to a woman, whether it’s a medical person or a social worker. We need to get good at saying, “Here’s what we know. How does alcohol fit in your life? Do you need support in any way to reduce or stop it?” How can we get behind them instead of making them feel even more negatively towards themselves?

Ms. Chandler: I wanted to jump in also with a little bit about a broader legal perspective on the prevention problem. One of the points that came up in our evidence and discussions was a concern about different systems working at cross purposes. For example, women might be quite reluctant to disclose alcohol use if they’re concerned that the child welfare or child protection system might become engaged and they may lose their children. So it’s important to take into consideration that this is not solely a medical encounter, but it’s one that takes place in a broader, legal context, whereas some of the other structures may be impeding prevention efforts. Thank you.

Dr. Popova: I just wanted to mention that prevention must begin before pregnancy with age-appropriate education, support for reproductive health and screening and treatment for alcohol use problems. The earlier we start, the fewer problems we will have in the future.

Our recent school-based prevention study shows that children are very receptive to learning about the risks of alcohol use during pregnancy. Schools are an ideal place to start prevention and to talk about alcohol use in pregnancy and FASD, and providing age-appropriate education is absolutely necessary before young people begin making decisions about alcohol use and pregnancy.

Also, in terms of combatting shame and blame, we need to ensure that our medical doctors, family physicians and obstetricians ask women of child-bearing age and pregnant women about their alcohol use in order to detect such women who are at risk for delivering a baby with FASD. Of course, the language we use makes a huge difference; it should not be judgmental, blaming —

The Chair: Thank you to our witnesses. I’m sure more will come out in future questions.

Senator Osler: I’m Senator Flordeliz Osler from Manitoba. Before I get to my question, I want to touch on the prevention side of it. As you all know, modern public health agencies state that no amount of alcohol is safe or beneficial for health, especially in pregnancy. I’m commenting on this because the chamber yesterday had another discussion on another piece of legislation, and some of what was talked about was the cardiovascular benefits of moderate consumption of wine. What was interesting, as I’m sure you all know, is that a lot of those are older, observational studies with some biases, including the socio-economic status of the people who drink wine, who tend to be healthier, have higher education, earn more money and have better access to health care. But I won’t go there. It’s interesting how we’re having this discussion today compared to yesterday.

I’m going to start with Dr. Chandler and open it up to the others. My question is: Are there particular social factors, human rights or equity considerations that should guide the development of a national FASD framework, particularly in relation to people with FASD and their families who interact with health, child welfare or criminal justice systems? I’ll start with Dr. Chandler, and then we can open it up.

Ms. Chandler: Thank you so much for that question, and the answer is a resounding yes. Canada is a signatory to the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which commits us to providing supports for people with living disabilities and supporting inclusion and so forth.

We have human rights codes and Charter obligations as well of equality before the law, which would suggest a need to accommodate disability in the provision of governmental services. That extends not just to health and education but also to policing and correctional services. A reasonably decent argument could be made that there is an obligation to have a look at disability and the accommodation of disability in the criminal justice system.

I became interested in this topic reading a case from the North of a man with a very long criminal record who had never really had much of a chance, had FASD and was greatly affected by it and was facing a dangerous offender designation, which would be lifetime incarceration in a penitentiary. Everyone agreed that if he had support and escorted access to the community, he would not reoffend; it would not happen. The outcome was a penitentiary at a vast public expense and a lack of any good possible outcome for someone with a disability.

It’s a real challenge, and I think there are these human rights considerations that apply not just in the justice context but also in the provision of services that allow people with disabilities to be included.

This extends to the families. This extends to women who are at risk of having children with disabilities. There is a need for equitable access to supports and services to give effect to the Charter’s obligation of equality as well as our international obligations.

Senator Muggli: Thank you for being with us today. Ms. Poole, I’ll be asking a question of you today. By the way, I’ve been a long-time fan of your work and your support for us learning trauma-informed practices in Saskatchewan.

Ms. Poole, you co-authored a paper on the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Call to Action 33, I think, in 2019. Can you speak to the committee about the principles for implementing that Call to Action that you identified, and I wonder if you see value in specifically including responses to Calls to Action 33 and 34 in this strategy?

Ms. Poole: Great question. We have been really active on the prevention side, with walking with communities on prevention initiatives that really are in the spirit of Call to Action 33. And it’s really important work in how Indigenous communities have experienced trauma and colonization and its impact on alcohol, et cetera.

There are communities that are now coming to the place of walking forth on the prevention side. We’ve been working with Nunavik, and we’ve been working with lots of different communities of late. For me, I’d like to think we live and breathe the Calls to Action 33 and 34. They’re implied in the whole thing. You might be wiser about whether it needs to be added specifically and named specifically. All I can say is that we are all in on making those Calls to Action realized in the work that we do. I’m really glad that you raised that part of our work because it is fundamentally important.

Senator Muggli: Thank you.

Dr. Popova: I wasn’t part of that work, but in terms of the Indigenous population, we conducted a systematic literature review and meta analysis. We found that studies, for example, on the prevalence of maternal alcohol use basically don’t exist, and studies on the prevalence of FAS or FASD are 30 years old. In order to update our vision on the important indicators, such as maternal alcohol use and FASD, we need population-based studies in northern communities and remote areas. Some studies report that maternal alcohol use in northern communities is up to 56% during pregnancy, which is very concerning. To make it short, the national FASD framework may set the goal of obtaining these important indicators across different populations, including Indigenous populations, in Canada.

The Chair: Thank you very much, Dr. Popova.

Senator Senior: Thank you all for being here. I really appreciate the depth of your expertise that you bring to our conversation today.

I want to go down the line a little bit. My colleague here reminded me of what I usually ask about, which is really the impact that lands on so many people in various systems, not just in terms of child welfare systems but also in terms of corrections. That impact has been mentioned by several of you. I’m curious about whether there’s been any research done on the prevalence of folks in corrections and the link to FASD. I’ll start with you, Dr. Reynolds.

Mr. Reynolds: Unfortunately, the answer is yes and no. I’m aware of one comprehensive study in the criminal justice system that was actually done in the Yukon, in which every prison inmate underwent the multidisciplinary assessment for FASD. I think they found that somewhere between 20% and 25% of prison inmates could be diagnosed with FASD.

In the child welfare system, the reason children are often apprehended is neglect, abuse, or drug and alcohol exposure. Most often, it’s a combination of all three. They’re overrepresented for reasons that have to do with substance exposure and a continuing threat to their health early in life.

Ms. Poole: Dr. Dorothy Badry, who is part of the CanFASD Research Network, has done a lot of work on the prevalence in the child welfare system and has been particularly successful in working closely with the Alberta government on looking at prevalence and options for solutions. There is an enormous amount of work to be done on that. Another of the research leads in the CanFASD Research Network, Dr. Kaitlyn McLachlan at the University of Guelph, has been doing extensive research on the criminal justice system side and is about to launch a huge new web hub on empowering all the people involved in delivering the criminal justice system with better tools for assessing and supporting. I think it’s coming out next week. I just feel like these are important things, and Dr. Chandler has mentioned that as well. It is so critical that we work with all these different systems to think about how we can move forward to better support people with a disability.

Dr. Popova: I wanted to highlight that, indeed, FASD is dramatically overrepresented in vulnerable populations. Our research shows that prevalence is approximately 10 to 40 times higher in these special populations than in the general population. In Canada, the prevalence in children in care is up to 12%, but we know that this indicator is very underestimated because researchers used only passive surveillance. They looked at birth and medical records.

In Canadian correctional settings, we know that it affects about 15% of adults and up to 23% of youths.

When we compared Canadian data and global data with prevalence in different subpopulations, we found, based on all studies, the prevalence of FASD among children in care in some countries was 25% to 31% and more than 8% among special education populations. Overall, globally, the prevalence is up to 40 times higher compared to the general population.

The Chair: Thank you very much, Dr. Popova.

Senator Petitclerc: I believe my question will be for you, Dr. Reynolds, but I welcome other input.

We talked already — and thank you for this — on the importance of prevention, awareness, education and diagnosis. You did mention how we can mitigate that impact when there is prenatal alcohol exposure. I would like to have a sense of, in the case of an optimal framework, optimal funding and an optimal scenario, what is needed and what can make a big difference step by step: stakeholders, social plasticity and neuroplasticity, maybe. It’s a wide question.

Mr. Reynolds: It is, but it fundamentally comes down to the risk factors that exist that we know drive negative outcomes and trying to eliminate or mitigate those. So those risk factors for a child include, number one, prenatal alcohol exposure, then abuse or neglect and then multiple placements as a young child, preventing secure attachment, which we know is so critical to the social, emotional and mental health of kids. These are things we could do something about.

The automatic response has driven so much work here. There is fear of the system. When there is drug and alcohol exposure — it’s usually multiple drugs, not just alcohol — the automatic response has been that that child is at risk and that we must remove the child from that environment. Well, that’s inducing a second trauma when there are better approaches. Quite frankly, this is not something we would have to make up. This has been demonstrated.

One of the biggest studies that was ever done was actually done in the U.S. It was sponsored by Kaiser Permanente. They looked at what the impact would be of embedding a substance abuse counsellor in obstetrics and gynecology clinics to have that conversation, in a non-threatening way, with women early in pregnancy and throughout the pregnancy to support a drug-free pregnancy.

Then they looked at, for their interests, what the health and economic consequences were for the kids who went through clinics in which this happened. Shockingly — not to us — health outcomes were vastly improved and costs to the system were dramatically reduced. The cost-benefit analysis said that there was a 10-to-1 return on investment by putting the right supports in place at the right time, in the right place and in the right way to support reducing exposures during pregnancy and in a supportive, non-threatening approach.

Senator Boudreau: We’re talking about a national framework being required to fill the gaps. Everybody has talked about filling the gaps. I would suspect that FASD exists in every single community in the country, and we are a very large country with a lot of remote and rural communities.

I’m just trying to wrap my head around how a strategy can fill those gaps, which must be enormous in some cases. Maybe I can start with Dr. Chandler. In your opening remarks, you mentioned that Australia has a more modern framework and kind of got it right. Are there a few obvious things that you saw Australia put in their framework that might help us fill what seems to be a rather large number of gaps across the country?

Ms. Chandler: Yes, absolutely. Australia is a good example to look at as well because they are a federal country like ours. They have the same legacies and continuing effects of colonialism. There are many similarities.

To be honest, I’m sorry. I can’t tell you details about how they have tried to overcome the issues of size, sparse population and federal structures. That’s something that could be looked at with the group that is charged with putting in place this national framework to see if there are learnings from what they’ve done.

I think the learning from what they’ve done that sort of came home to me in the course of the work that we did on the panel was the recognition that without clear roles, responsibilities, accountability frameworks and metrics to measure impact, it becomes very hard to know if the investment is having any effect or if it is put in the right place.

In order to use money and the effort of people wisely, it is good to have a more buttoned-down approach, and that was something coming out very clearly from looking at the more modern approaches.

You’re entirely right. There may be things to learn about how to coordinate in a challenging environment like this. I know we’re short of time, but we talked about a range of different things, such as increasing access to diagnosis through mobile clinics, which would be able to move to northern and remote jurisdictions, to whether or not it is possible to do any of the diagnostic testing by video, which may be more challenging for very young people but might increase accessibility for older people.

In our report, we address some of the things that could be done to begin to grapple with some of the challenges of having a big, effective national strategy. I hope that answers, in some measure, your question.

Senator Boudreau: If Dr. Popova wants to add anything.

Dr. Popova: This is a very important point. Canada needs a national FASD framework because our current response remains fragmented. There are substantial differences across provinces and territories in prevention, diagnosis, services and support, and that is why we need a national framework that could establish clear priorities for FASD prevention and awareness, national surveillance and prevalence monitoring, which is super important. We need culturally appropriate, Indigenous-led approaches.

It would also establish common national goals and measurable indicators. Education, social services, child welfare and people with FASD in their families will be able to receive appropriate support, regardless of where they live in Canada. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you, Dr. Popova.

Now, Senator Cuzner, you wrap us up with the last question.

Senator Cuzner: I’ll take us home.

First off, exceptional panel, and kudos to the staff. I’m not asking anything medical out of respect for the esteemed colleagues around the table with the medical expertise. I’ll go to something more in my comfort zone: alcohol consumption. Stemming from comments that Dr. Poole made and Senator Osler made as well, it seems in Canada the worm is starting to turn a bit as far as awareness on alcohol, and I think we should be comfortable in speaking about it.

Year over year, for the past 10 years, beer consumption has gone down in the country. More and more people are drinking zero-alcohol beer. We had a senator speak yesterday about her newfound appreciation for zero-alcohol wine. Even in the province of New Brunswick, where they love their Alpine beer, the sales of zero-alcohol beer have doubled in the last year.

Because of what seems to be more awareness and a change in the attitude towards alcohol, is there data that shows a decrease in the numbers, or is it too early to determine that? Or would it be so minute that you couldn’t measure it as far as the occurrence of FASD?

Ms. Poole: I think it is a bit early. I sat on the scientific committee that developed Canada’s alcohol guidance. There’s so much to say about these issues, but with the no- and low-alcohol movement, it is a bit early to tell now.

This is an interesting anecdote from our meeting yesterday. One piece of research done by one of the people in the CanFASD Research Network shows this in terms of pregnancy and alcohol: Some of the women interviewed in the study actually said that they didn’t want to use low-alcohol products because people were still judging them. Because you can’t tell whether it is low- or no- or full-on alcohol, the stigma still came through the door, even for choosing that way of drinking.

I want to say that I love that question because it is encouraging that we are moving — lots more is still needed — toward being a bit more sober curious and drinking less and, where wanted, substituting the low- and no-alcohol alternatives.

Mr. Reynolds: It would be incredible if our population voluntarily solved this issue.

Let’s go to a point that I think you’ve heard many times, and Dr. Popova has tried to underline this: In order to know if that has had an impact, we have to know where we are today, and we don’t. Our ability and capacity to identify children, youth and adults with FASD are woefully inadequate in this country. Without having a solid foundation as our starting point, we will never know if we’ve actually progressed. The national approach to standards, surveillance and identification will give us that ability that we currently do not have.

The Chair: Dr. Reynolds, you got the last word.

Senators, this brings us to the end of this first panel.

I thank the witnesses for their exceptional contributions to this data.

Senators, before we welcome our next witness panel, I will provide a content warning for this part of this meeting. Today, we will be discussing lived experiences related to fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. This may be triggering to people in the room with us, as well as to those watching and listening to the broadcast. Mental health support for all Canadians is available by phone and text at 9-8-8.

For those of us in the room, should you need support during the meeting, a counsellor from Homewood Health is here with us today. At any time during this meeting, please signal the page or the clerk, and we will connect you.

Senators and parliamentary employees are also reminded that the Senate’s Employee and Family Assistance Program is available to them and offers short-term counselling for both personal and work-related concerns, as well as crisis counselling.

Joining us for this panel, we welcome Tammy Roberts, a parent; Dorothy Reid, a caregiver to individuals with FASD, who is joining us by videoconference; and Jennifer Wisdahl, Chief Operating Officer of FASD United. Thank you for joining us today.

For your opening statements, you will have five minutes, followed by questions from committee members.

Ms. Roberts, the floor is yours.

Tammy Roberts, Parent As an Individual: Thank you, Madam Chair and committee members. I am honoured to speak to you in support of Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder.

My name is Tammy Roberts. I am a settler. I live on beautiful Chief Drygeese Territory, the traditional land of the Yellowknives Dene First Nation and, more recently, the homeland of the North Slave Métis Alliance. I have called Yellowknife my home for just over 33 years.

I am here today as a northerner, a parent and an advocate for people with FASD. I trust my colleagues have done an excellent job educating you on prevention and explaining the ins and outs of this disability and the strengths and challenges that come along with it.

I want to come from a different angle. I want to come from the bottom so you can see the direct impact of the lack of resources.

There was no instruction manual in 1993, when I was first introduced to this disability, when a screaming infant was placed in my arms. I learned to parent him through trial and error. I have also learned more skills from the other 250 foster children who have lived with me over the years. My knowledge comes from supporting my nine children, who are now adults, who have been impacted by prenatal alcohol exposure. It also comes from advocating for youth aged 12 to 24 through the non-profit organization I lead that provides support and housing.

Where do all of these children and youth come from? They come from struggling families and communities that have little to no support and rigid systems that don’t change. The North is overburdened with addictions, homelessness and disrupted family systems.

I have been telling the same story over and over again so people understand how to support someone diagnosed with FASD. I tell my neighbours, teachers, medical professionals, the RCMP, lawyers, judges, family and friends. I’m tired of explaining that there is a different way to get the result they are looking for that is less damaging to the person with this disability. I am tired of telling people that they are the ones who have the capability to change the way they do things, not the person diagnosed with FASD. I keep telling the same story because it is important.

I thought caring for crying, shaking babies who were inconsolable was hard, but I can tell you that supporting a teen or a young adult who doesn’t fit into the world like everyone else is next level. Advocating for a diagnosis, housing, life skills and accommodations, especially in the North, is almost impossible due to the lack of resources.

Can you imagine not being able to transition from one thing to another, being someone who literally cannot handle change? Let me explain by telling you a true story.

I recently travelled from the North to support a young adult diagnosed with FASD through the worst nightmare. I agreed to escort her back home after she was stabilized in a hospital in another province. She had been living away from home for about a year on the streets of other cities in other provinces. She was struggling with addictions, domestic violence, human trafficking and who knows what else. This has been her story for many years, but she wanted to come home.

This was a planned day trip for me and another experienced support person. We expected challenges, but we adapted. She struggled, but she adapted.

People impacted by FASD are not able to predict, like you and me. We used techniques to support her like compromise, movement, noise-cancelling headphones, music and constant one-on-one.

We knew we had a fast turnaround for a connecting flight and ran to the gate, arriving nine minutes before it closed. To our surprise, they told us that our tickets had been changed because they didn’t think we would make it. But we did. We didn’t miss the gate. They missed the gate.

I advocated as hard as I could, but they wouldn’t let us on the plane, so this meant an overnight stay in a hotel in a large, strange city. Remember, this young person cannot handle change and had already made many transitions that day.

We did everything possible to provide support, but, ultimately, after a couple of hours, we lost her. It was too much for her, and she ran. We spent hours with authorities explaining her vulnerability, but it was too late. We missed that gate because she had already boarded a city bus and disappeared.

The inability for systems to accommodate her disability had a catastrophic impact on this young person’s life. This is why we need a national framework for FASD. We need systems and people to think differently and to make small changes that can make a huge difference. I pray she is found safe and can come home.

I have only scratched the surface with one story about one person. As a parent, I struggle with similar situations with my own children on a regular basis.

Why can’t we build systems that support these individuals instead of causing more trauma by trying to shove them into systems where they don’t fit?

I know that Bill S-234 will have a huge impact on the lives of so many people. When supporting this young woman, we all missed the gate. When considering Bill S-234, I beg you to make sure the gate is open so that you support a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder and we don’t have to share these stories over and over again. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you.

Ms. Reid, you have the floor. I ask you to prevail and stay within your time if you will. Thank you very much.

Dorothy Reid, Caregiver, As an Individual: Thank you for the opportunity to speak in support of Bill S-234. I am honoured to join you today from the traditional and contemporary lands of the Stó꞉lō people, who have cared for these lands since time immemorial.

My name is Dorothy Reid. I am the parent of two sons and three grandchildren who were all prenatally exposed to alcohol, yet only three of the five have been able to access FASD diagnostic services, despite the likelihood that they all meet diagnostic criteria.

I speak today from both my personal and professional experiences. I’m a clinical psychologist by training, and I spent many years with Correctional Service Canada, including developing interventions and supervising a rehabilitation unit for offenders with FASD and acquired brain injuries.

Upon retirement, I became involved with the Canada FASD Research Network, where I chaired the Family Advisory Committee for nine years. Today, I want to focus on one critical issue: access to diagnosis.

Diagnosis is often the gateway to appropriate supports, services and accommodations. Without it, individuals with FASD are frequently denied the help they need. I want to use my two sons to illustrate this reality.

My oldest son displayed many characteristics associated with FASD but was never appropriately diagnosed. He was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, or ADHD, and while medication improved his attention, it didn’t address the broader neurobehavioural challenges he faced. He struggled in school, left by Grade 9 and became involved with drugs, gangs and, later, the justice system. Like many individuals with undiagnosed FASD, he was repeatedly given conditions that were not consistently met. That led to breaches and increasingly serious involvement with the correctional system, both as a youth and as an adult.

Interestingly and ironically, I guess, he’s been able to access better services as a marginally housed, drug-addicted individual living in the Downtown Eastside in Vancouver.

My youngest son, by contrast, received a FASD diagnosis early in life. That diagnosis allowed us to access speech and language services, psychological support, educational consultation and specialized school programming. While advocacy was still required, the diagnosis gave us the foundation to secure appropriate accommodations. He remained connected in school, received consistent support and experienced a very different developmental pathway.

This difference extended into adulthood as well. When my youngest son became involved with the justice system, the Crown prosecutor understood his diagnosis and recommended interventions that supported both community safety and his success. Once again, that appropriate diagnosis made a huge difference.

I believe, as Ms. Chandler already said, we must look at this from a human rights lens. Canada is a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. For individuals with FASD, that would include timely diagnosis, treatment and accommodations in education, housing, employment and justice systems. Yet, as has been mentioned, diagnosis remains highly inconsistent across Canada. Too often, families must live in the right place, at the right time and know the right people and still navigate long wait-lists to obtain services. This inequity leaves many individuals without the supports they need and deserve.

Canada is internationally recognized for its leadership in FASD research. However, our diagnostic capacity has not kept pace. Families cannot benefit from research if they cannot access diagnosis, and I as a caregiver can’t advocate for my children appropriately without that diagnosis.

A national framework will not solve all these challenges overnight, but it is an essential first step to provide coordination, consistency and a shared vision for improving access to diagnostic support and services across the country.

As members of this committee, you have the opportunity to change outcomes for individuals with FASD and their families. I respectfully urge you to support Bill S-234 and recommend the development of a national FASD framework. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Reid.

Ms. Wisdahl, the floor is yours.

Jennifer Wisdahl, Chief Operating Officer, FASD United: Thank you, chair and honourable senators, for having me today. I’m Jennifer Wisdahl, the Chief Operating Officer of FASD United. We’re a national organization based in Washington, D.C., offering support and resources to people with FASD and those who care for them, regardless of where they live, including many families from Canada.

I co-led our policy work on the FASD Respect Act, which was the first stand-alone federal FASD legislation in the U.S. to become law in 20 years. That was made possible by the outreach of thousands and thousands of people with FASD and their families.

Although I work remotely in Washington, D.C., I live in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada. I’m also the proud mom of three young adults with FASD. So I come to this work with a foot and a heart in both countries.

FASD United supports Bill S-234. I know our systems are very different, and I’m not here to suggest Canada copy anything in the U.S. That is not my place nor my role. But I’d like to share some of what we’ve learned in building national policy on FASD within the U.S.

When our states worked on FASD independently, good programs grew in silos, and each state built its own from scratch. The national coordination that we have in the FASD Respect Act changes that. With shared groundwork, states and regions can focus more of their time on building culturally and linguistically appropriate programs for the people they serve. They can still build their own programs, but they don’t have to start from nothing.

Families don’t stop at a border when they are looking for help for a loved one. They will call and email anywhere in the world looking for help. Centralized coordination makes their job earlier.

We also learned that how a law frames FASD really matters. The FASD Respect Act shifts the federal focus from prevention and awareness to also include the lives and the full lifespan of people with FASD. Recognizing FASD as a disability and focusing on people living their best lives in the community with the right support builds awareness and reduces stigma at the same time. It moves us from preventing something perceived as a negative to supporting positive outcomes.

Passing a law is only a start, though. The committee has heard concern about a framework without resources, and we understand that well. Right now, in the U.S., we are working to secure the appropriations to fund the provisions of the FASD Respect Act, but in the meantime, we’re already seeing more collaboration between state and federal partners. This was never meant to be a bill just for show, and families are holding the government accountable for it.

We have also learned that a diagnosis isn’t the same as support, although you need a diagnosis to access it. Through our Family Navigator program, we hear from families who finally get a diagnosis and then have to hunt down services, on their own, one system at a time.

I know this at home, too. Even in my role, I still struggle to find the supports and services that are right for my own children. And not everyone has the privilege and access that I have. If it’s this hard for me, I think about the families who don’t know where to start.

What I hope for is simple, which is that wherever a person with FASD lives, the professionals they meet understand FASD and their family can find their way to the help that exists. People with FASD and their families should help build and evaluate that. Bill S-234 can help get Canada there, and families like mine are hoping that it does.

Thank you. I look forward to our conversation.

The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Wisdahl.

We will now proceed with questions from committee members. For this panel, senators will have four minutes for their questions, and that includes the answer. Please indicate if your question is directed to a particular witness or all witnesses.

Senator Burey: Thank you to all our witnesses, caregivers and parents. I am a pediatrician, and I am involved in diagnosis and assessments. I really thank you for your courage in being here and sharing those impactful and compelling stories.

My question is for Ms. Wisdahl. I know you had a preamble saying that you don’t want to tell us what to do in Canada, and I take that, but you’ve had some experience with coordination, data strategy and surveillance. I don’t know if you have had a chance to look at this bill so far. Is there anything that you think we need that should be in the bill regarding respect and dignity and the focus on the disability rights aspect?

Ms. Wisdahl: One of the things that we learned was that we really needed to speak to adults with FASD and that their voices needed to be heard in the room as well. Canada has some remarkable self-advocates who are known worldwide for their advocacy and their ability to speak on the topic.

I would suggest, very humbly, that adults with FASD be included in the conversation.

Senator Burey: Thank you.

Senator Hay: Thank you all for being here and for what I will call the work of angels. Thank you so much.

Ms. Roberts, you were speaking with the Yellowknifer last month or in the last couple of months about how support for people with FASD must never stop. This committee also received a note from a parent stating that support largely disappears at the age of 18.

My question is for both Ms. Roberts and Ms. Reid. What happens to young people with FASD when they age out? What should this framework guarantee or focus on or maybe dive deeper on to ensure that turning 18 isn’t a cliff that one falls off?

Ms. Roberts: My children all came from the child welfare system, whether I adopted them or they just never left. The idea of aging out is different ages across the country. In the Northwest Territories, it’s 23.

What I find with this disability from my own family is that my children with FASD continue to be successful because they have never left my home. So they live with me, and I provide them with the bits of support that they need in order to function. Everybody is unique and everybody is different, so I provide different support to different children in my home.

I have experienced through my own research, although I’m not a researcher, that eventually there comes a time when maturity does happen, and it is very late. I would say that it’s over the age of 30, when for others it would probably be at about 18. So having that additional support for an extended period of time is extremely important, as well as then continuing on with maybe even support with budgeting or relationships, those types of things.

Senator Hay: Thank you. Ms. Reid?

Ms. Reid: My experience varied with my two kids. But with my youngest son, we were able to get a lot of supports for him, and he stayed in school until he was 19. At that point, there were no transitional supports. We tried to find transitional supports, but he was at an age when he wanted to be independent. It was difficult to find supports that gave him enough distance from us and enough support for him. So, basically, he ended up taking off when he was about 20 years old, became involved with drugs and died of an overdose when he was 23.

With my oldest son, when he was in his mid-teens, we had to transition him to alternate care to get the services that he needed. His trajectory was very difficult until he was, as Tammy said, almost in his 30s. When he was in his 30s, things started to change. As I said earlier, he actually got better supports and services as a drug-addicted homeless person in the Downtown Eastside in Vancouver than he did while he was a young adult. Now he is actually fairly stable, living in single-room occupancy, or SRO, in Vancouver, but his health is so impaired. He is in his 40s, and he has the body of an 80-year-old.

Senator Senior: I just want to extend our appreciation to all of you for sharing your stories with us today. It is making a huge difference to the work that we’re doing and our ability to understand the issue from various sides, including from the perspectives you bring today.

I want to poke away a little bit, similar to Senator Hay, around the aging out of care. The Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights released a report last year called Nothing to Celebrate: The Crisis of Youth Aging Out of Care. In that report, it also identifies many elements of what leads to that, including FASD.

We know this to be true. Ms. Wisdahl, I’m curious about the work you’re doing in the U.S., and I’d like to hear a bit more about the impact on subpopulations, which we understand here in Canada, and the impact of poverty and other systems that come into play.

Ms. Wisdahl: Well, somewhat similar to Canada, we have remote populations that do not have access to health care, although the barriers to health care are more financial than in Canada. One of the things that is being worked on right now, for example, in the U.S. military health care system is a project that’s looking at hub-and-spoke diagnostic methodology and support methodology that can be delivered remotely via telehealth, which can be transitioned into the civilian population, so that’s looking at FASD amongst the military health care beneficiaries.

Looking at telehealth also in the State of Alaska, which has a lot of similarities in terms of size and remote populations, the State of Alaska has worked hard on telehealth and training to make diagnosis and care more accessible. It still hasn’t hit the mark to where it needs to be. Again, that’s very similar, but those types of projects are things that are covered under our national framework.

Also, looking at the foster care population, I am a former foster mom here in Canada. I also sit on the board of the National Foster Parent Association in the U.S., and this is an issue that we see time and time again.

Earlier, I was listening to one of the folks who was presenting. He mentioned five placements under the age of 5, and that describes my oldest child completely. I was his fifth mother by the time he was 5 years old, and it didn’t have to be that way. Had foster families received training on FASD and how to support people with FASD from day one, he might not have had to jump around quite a bit. Now, I wouldn’t get to be his mom, which would be a deficit for me, but he would have missed some of that trauma.

I just want to say very loud and clear, too, that my children are not a cautionary tale. My children are amazing human beings with hopes and dreams and unlimited potential with the right amount of support.

The Chair: Thank you.

Senator Petitclerc: Thank you so much. I want to say, like my colleagues, I really appreciate you not only sharing your stories and your lived experience but your lived expertise, too, because that’s how I receive it.

I want to go somewhere else a little bit. Is it your view that this framework should also address the importance of support to parents, and if so, what should that look like?

Ms. Roberts: Thank you. I think about this all the time, and it might be similar to — I don’t know — a doctor, where you can’t treat your own children, right? The role that I take on as a parent for my kids, who are adults now, is, in addition to financial support, so much like, “Why do I keep getting a stain on my shirt? Why doesn’t my door lock? How do I fix my dishwasher?” It’s constant support. I’m at an age when I want to just be able to enjoy being their mom. I don’t want to have all those other roles.

Finding that support would be so beneficial to parents and caregivers because that gives us the opportunity to just step back and be a mom. Sometimes those roles conflict, and it causes a lot of stress and challenges between the relationship that we have with our children because we’re also trying to be so many other roles in their lives.

Senator Petitclerc: I don’t know if other witnesses want to —

Ms. Reid: If I could just interject. In my role with the Family Advisory Committee, I had the opportunity to talk to many caregivers throughout Canada and in the United States, actually. One of the common threads was the strain of caring for children who were misunderstood and misdiagnosed. It is difficult to be able to continuously do the advocacy work that is necessary, constantly teaching people about our kids and about FASD in general and having to turn around every step of the way to provide education so that they could support our kids appropriately.

But one of the key things that came up over and over again was that comment about: What’s going to happen when I’m no longer here? That was a big fear for caregivers of individuals with FASD. They do well when we provide the support they need. Once we can no longer provide that support, whether it’s through the kid’s choice, because they want to go somewhere else, or our inability to continue to provide that because of age or all sorts of factors, what’s going to happen to them? Our biggest fear is that they’re going to fail because the community can’t support them.

So, yes, there needs to be support for caregivers involved in that to prevent burnout and to help us to regulate our own emotional state and health so that we can support them. But there also needs to be that lifelong planning.

Senator Osler: Thank you to all the witnesses for being here today. My question will build on, if not be exactly the same as, Senator Hay’s. I would suggest we start with our online witnesses first, Ms. Wisdahl and Ms. Reid, and then Ms. Roberts.

FASD is a lifelong disability, but many supports and services are focused on childhood. We’ve heard a little bit about how Canada’s current support system for people and their caregivers isn’t as good as it could be. So my question is: What specific recommendations would you have that should be in a national framework to support people with FASD in adulthood and even older adulthood?

Ms. Wisdahl: If I may, one of the big things is visibility. If we can’t find the resources and we have to hunt them down, even if they exist, they’re inaccessible. So having national visibility on resources available to young adults and adults where they exist is a big one.

I would also particularly appreciate resources that allow the young adult to be age appropriate because that’s what they want. They want to be able to be independent. So how can they be independent with safety? Job coaching would be incredibly helpful. Having people support them in navigating the medical system outside of their parents, because it can be awfully complex, and those kinds of things can be helpful, as well as peer support. How often do people with FASD get to speak with other adults with FASD who are also successfully adulting? Those are big pieces that I would hope for my children and that I’ve seen be successful elsewhere, but I will leave it to the other panellists.

Ms. Reid: One of the things I would suggest is trying, in some ways, to make sure that access to services is not based on IQ. That is one of the factors that keeps them from getting services that they may need. If their IQs are over 70, they don’t qualify for services for people with developmental disabilities in some ways.

Jennifer also talked about the importance of connecting people and allowing for or supporting mentorship between adults with FASD. I’ve seen the impact that it’s had, being involved in things like our Adult FASD Expert Collaboration Team with CanFASD or the FASD Changemakers with the United States, where adults have a chance to get together and support their self-advocacy skills. Developing self-advocacy skills for both adults and children — older youth — and also enhancing advocacy skills for parents and caregivers, I think, would be helpful.

Another thing I just want to throw in is that it’s really good that the framework has the report-back and accountability component of it. The period of waiting is too long, and it needs to repeat. I would really encourage a report back within a year and then every year following that because we need to keep the pressure up.

Senator Muggli: Ms. Reid, we’ll carry on with you if that’s okay.

In my former life, I was responsible for coordination of FASD diagnosis and some service provision, and we had two or three folks trained to perform the diagnosis. The funding we had was for one of the psychologists to travel up North one day a month to correctional facilities. You can’t get very much done.

I’m curious if you might be able to respond to why so few are able to diagnose and what can be done to move the dial on this.

Ms. Reid: Part of the difficulty is the complexity of the FASD diagnosis and the need for a multidisciplinary team to be able to do the diagnosis. That adds to the expense of it.

In my experience with Correctional Service Canada trying to get a diagnosis for adults, it was just cost prohibitive. That’s one of the barriers. The other barriers are geography and things like that.

There has been some really good work done, particularly in some of the provinces, to really train more pediatricians and medical people to recognize and identify people who need to be screened for the FASD diagnosis. Also, another problem that we’ve had is that there have not been good screening tools within places like the justice system. There is some work being done in that area.

The whole idea of being able to screen people to figure out who needs to go for the more expensive diagnosis would be helpful.

Another thing is the reluctance that was talked about before in terms of women acknowledging drinking during pregnancy. As I mentioned, I have three grandkids who were prenatally exposed; only one has been diagnosed. Part of the reason is because their mom — we had to take custody of those three kids. The mom started another family, and she was afraid that if she acknowledged drinking, she would lose those children. And justifiably, I have to say; it does increase the potential for the kids to be apprehended.

Getting women to acknowledge in a safe way and to talk to them in a respectful way about drinking during pregnancy is another factor that’s going to affect the ability to get a diagnosis.

Senator Muggli: Thank you.

Senator Arnold: I would like to thank you all for being here today and for your candour. As the parent of a neurodivergent child, so much of what you have said sounds incredibly familiar.

My question to you is: Do you have any tips or ideas on how to bridge government and community supports? We’ve heard over and over again how it’s so complicated and complex. There are different approaches in all these different provinces and different ideas on all of this.

I’m curious if you have any ideas of some barriers and what could be done about them. Is there any low-hanging fruit that you see?

Ms. Roberts: I can speak to that. Whether or not my children or adult children should be recognized as a person with a disability with the Canada Revenue Service, or CRA, shouldn’t be dependent on which doctor fills out the form and what support they have in answering the questions. That happens over and over again, so that would be a piece that can definitely be worked on more.

Senator Arnold: Anyone else?

Ms. Wisdahl: One of the things that we have done through the FASD Respect Act in the U.S. is to put in a national framework or a hub — it’s not there yet, but it’s part of the legislation — where everything can be found in one place.

I know CanFASD has amazing resources. Having access to those and making sure that everything is all in one place and that you can find it without having to go all over the place to find evidence-based practices or practice based — it’s very confusing, time-consuming and challenging.

That’s something that we’re working on in the U.S. Ensuring we have a centralized hub and a centralized repository for all of the supports and resources available to families can be very helpful.

Another thing we’ve done is we have a national Family Navigator program, where we have adults with FASD, parents and caregivers who are available to answer questions and help navigate systems. That has been very effective, and, as a matter of fact, we get calls from Canada all the time on that program.

We found that to be very useful, but it’s only as useful as the supports and services that are available to refer people to.

The Chair: Ms. Reid, I see you put your hand up. Go ahead.

Ms. Reid: Thank you.

The thing I would emphasize, too, is that in the national framework it does talk about consultation with different departments. There is the ability to encourage and, in fact, mandate intersectoral committees or conversations to be able to facilitate a breakdown of the silos within different areas.

One of the things you find with FASD is that it’s an exclusion criteria for many, many services. That’s one of the things that we need to change, and that can change by mandating that the different areas work together more effectively.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator Hay: Ms. Reid, I think I have this right: You led some research a while back and made some powerful points around how, for decades, studies have catalogued what people with FASD struggle with, and you acknowledge there is still not enough research being done. I acknowledge that.

When you went looking for research around the strength of young people and people with FASD, you found just 19 studies — and correct me if any of this is not correct — and within those 19 studies there were points made of real strength, self-awareness, perseverance, kindness, openness and hope.

I wonder if you could speak to that so that we see a balance around people with FASD.

Ms. Reid: Thank you. I think that’s really important. One of the reasons we wanted to do that research was because all the research that came out was deficit-based, looking at all the disadvantages that people have and looking at all the challenges they experience without really looking at the strengths that they have. And they have multiple strengths and abilities: creativity, energy, enthusiasm, an ability to articulate and a dedication to making the world a better place. It’s really discouraging that all they see are things like deficits or shortened lifespans or adverse outcomes.

We did that research to try to focus and change the perspective. We found that if researchers don’t ask about strengths, people will not report on strengths. The strengths are there, but if they’re not asking about them, they’re not going to hear about them.

We want to decrease the stigma that’s associated with FASD. If we can decrease the stigma, then we can likely increase a person’s ability to reach out for support and diagnosis. When a big, blaming, huge, negative cloud is hanging over everyone, why would anyone ever want to acknowledge, “I have FASD, and I need this help”? If we don’t decrease the stigma associated with FASD, we don’t encourage people to access the resources they need. It becomes about shame and blame and not hope.

Senator Hay: I agree. Also, people need to see themselves in seeking support. They can actually see themselves with their strengths. Would you recommend that parts of the framework speak to the strengths? Would that be something you would recommend?

Ms. Reid: Absolutely. There shouldn’t be anything written about FASD that doesn’t look at the balance. It should look at the challenges that people experience because those are important to recognize. Those things will prompt access to services and the provision of services. But you have to look at the strengths as well. In my treatment programs, I know we use those strengths to leverage interventions for some of the services they need. If you don’t look at the strengths as well, then you are really robbing yourself of that ability to use those strengths to accommodate some of the challenges that they have experienced and will experience.

Senator Hay: Thank you so much.

The Chair: I thank all the witnesses for their time and for bringing their perspectives, which have been invaluable to us today.

We also appreciate you, Ms. Wisdahl, for bringing the U.S. perspective as well.

The next meeting for the committee is planned for Wednesday, October 21, when the committee will hear from the sponsor of this bill, Senator Ravalia, and from former Senator Christmas. That panel will be followed by the clause-by-clause consideration of this bill.

I have a couple of reminders regarding clause-by-clause consideration meetings. Members who wish to propose amendments during clause-by-clause consideration of the bill should reach out to the Office of the Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel to ensure the amendments are drafted in the proper format and in both official languages. Those consultations should begin as soon as possible to allow for sufficient time for the drafting of your amendments.

After clause-by-clause consideration, the committee may wish to append observations to the report. These should be short and in both official languages. The Library of Parliament analysts may provide you or your staff with support in preparing draft observations for the committee’s consideration.

(The committee adjourned.)

Back to top