Skip to main content

Cutting Red Tape for All Canadians Bill

Second Reading--Debate Continued

November 17, 2026


Honourable senators, today I rise to speak about Bill S-7, Cutting Red Tape for All Canadians Act.

This massive bill brings about significant regulatory and administrative changes across 31 federal laws and 11 different departments. Clocking in at nearly 200 pages, its scope is massive and far-reaching. While there are many parts of this bill dealing with various topics, such as digital reforms, borders and natural resources, I will, as usual, focus my time on its agricultural impacts and implications.

Let’s start with the good.

According to the Canadian Federation of Agriculture, or CFA, Bill S-7 is generally a positive step for the agriculture sector. Reducing red tape and administrative burden, improving competitiveness, and accelerating access to inputs and technologies would all help farmers and producers with their bottom line and their workload. The CFA also flagged that many of the changes we see in Bill S-7 were in direct response to recommendations from the sector. It’s always refreshing to see government taking notes from stakeholders who know their own issues the best.

Part 1 of this bill is where we find most of the specific changes that would see positive movement for our farmers and producers.

First, we have the Advance Payments Program, which would become more streamlined with the passing of this bill. This move could help reduce the administrative burden with obtaining and repaying advances. Farmers and producers often face significant cash flow pressures as they deal with contracts and orders throughout the season, so timely access to financing would certainly be a win. Also, removing the requirement for the Minister of Finance to approve adjustments to advance limits would open up the ability to respond more quickly to changes in the economic environment.

Another positive element in Bill S-7 highlighted by the CFA is the recognition of foreign regulatory systems. Canadian farmers and producers can face significant competitive disadvantages when inputs and technologies are available in other countries and jurisdictions but are not available to them. Under Bill S-7, the Governor in Council would be able to recognize foreign regulations for feeds, fertilizers, seeds and veterinary biologics entering the Canadian market.

On paper, this could help with more timely approvals and reduce duplication, as long as our Canadian science and risk standards were maintained. Practically, we would have to see how the Governor in Council selects jurisdictions and products, and how quickly the necessary regulations could be put together. I will say more on that in a minute.

Among other positive changes are those that would be made to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, where a new system for electronic administration could reduce paperwork and improve efficiency. As we know, some rural communities face connectivity and digital access challenges, so we would have to see whether the implementation of a digital system streamlines the processes for our farmers and producers or makes it more difficult.

Unfortunately, not all parts of this bill offer clear, positive changes for the agricultural community. For example, the Canadian Seed Growers’ Association, or CSGA, has commented on foreign regulatory systems recognition, cautioning that it is vital to ensure that access to these systems does not turn into back door access into Canada or reduce the government’s responsibility to administer a modern, efficient and effective domestic approval system in our country.

The CSGA has also identified a grey area with regards to the details of the foreign regulatory systems. Does the government intend to use the regulatory authority for variety registration only, that is, the regulatory requirement that new crop varieties must meet before getting approval, or are they hoping to apply this new standard to plants with novel traits — those plant varieties that have a new characteristic — as well?

There are a few more questions on this section that deserve to be put on the record. For example, how are foreign regulators going to be verified? Why were certain products, like pesticides and veterinary medicals, excluded from the regulation of foreign systems?

Without clarity on those questions, it is hard to say what the environmental, safety and other risks could be when a new agricultural input or technology is made available in Canada through this system.

Another part of Bill S-7 that was flagged by the CSGA is the amendment that removes the authority of the minister to specify weed seeds by order, as defined in the Seeds Act. Presently, those are published in the Weed Seeds Order, which categorizes them based on their danger levels, specifying the amount of them allowed in any seed sample. For example, a prohibited noxious weed would not be allowed in any sample at any level.

The bill changes this current system, replacing it instead with a regulation-making authority.

The CSGA hopes to see a list of noxious weeds incorporated by reference so that changes to that list could be made in a timely manner.

I’ve also heard from the Grape Growers of Ontario, whose members are concerned with clauses 6 and 7 in Part 1 of Bill S-7. Clause 6 covers accessibility of information, and they are concerned that it might include access to proprietary grower information, which might affect their delegated regulatory powers. Clause 7 is concerning, as it could give the minister the authority to change marketing boards and other provisions, as required.

According to the Grape Growers of Ontario, those powers might affect the marketing board’s ability to represent their members, and they were not consulted prior to this decision. I would like to make note of the fact that they told us they were not consulted.

Colleagues, a bill of this broad scope requires extensive review. We need to listen to what our stakeholders have to say, and we must ask questions along the way so that we can give thorough sober second thought to Bill S-7.

One other question worth asking is why labour access through temporary foreign workers was not addressed by this bill, which is specifically intended to cut red tape and regulatory requirements. We’ve heard from so many voices in the agricultural community that labour concerns continue to bog down the sector, so I question why this wasn’t included or addressed in Bill S-7.

It is also important to ensure that Bill S-7 strikes a proper balance between Governor in Council decisions and ministerial responsibilities. Bill S-7 makes several such shifts in power, and it is only by studying the bill more closely and by listening to stakeholders that we can determine which responsibilities would be better suited as more rigid, but stable, legislation, and which would make sense to keep in regulation. This must be discussed as this bill moves forward through committee and third reading, and the solutions should reflect what will best answer the needs of the agriculture sector, not what is simply easiest for government.

Colleagues, as this bill proceeds to committee, let us continue asking these and many other vital questions and listening to stakeholders along the way. This will ensure that we give Bill S-7 the thought and study it needs as it continues through our chamber.

Thank you, meegwetch.

Back to top