Skip to content

QUESTION PERIOD — Justice

Judicial Appointments

November 4, 2020


My question is for the Leader of the Government in the Senate. In the wake of the scandal surrounding the government’s judicial appointments, we learned recently that a number of people were being asked to make comments and recommendations on whether or not certain people should be considered for judicial appointments. For instance, when a lawyer from Drummondville named Christine was being considered to fill a judicial vacancy, the former Liberal member for Saint-Léonard—Saint-Michel, Nicola Di Iorio, strongly opposed the appointment because, according to him, Christine was a separatist born into a family of separatists. As for her legal expertise, Mr. Di Iorio didn’t appear to have anything bad to say in that regard.

Do you think it’s appropriate that judicial appointments, an essential pillar of our justice system, are being considered in a context of discrimination based on the political convictions of candidates to be appointed as judges by the Minister of Justice?

Hon. Marc Gold (Government Representative in the Senate) [ - ]

Thank you for the question. As a lawyer, I have full confidence in the Canadian justice system and the process that was put in place to ensure that those who are appointed to these positions are people who are qualified and of great integrity. As I already explained in this chamber just two days ago, the Minister of Justice has stated several times that he has never been pressured to make a judicial appointment. The decision is his alone. What he takes into consideration when it comes to appointments are the qualifications of the candidates, the legal skills, the needs of the court and of course the importance of diversity on the bench.

Let’s not be naive. The minister may not have been pressured. However, if there is bias against the people on the short list submitted to the minister, and if their political persuasion is the basis for the decision, the process is flawed and discriminates against the candidates.

Do you know whether there was bias in the case of Christine from Drummondville, because her husband was a former Conservative candidate in the riding of Drummondville?

Senator Gold [ - ]

Once again, senator, I can only repeat that the government has full confidence in the process. Judges are appointed on the basis of their legal skills.

Back to top