National Framework on Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder Bill
Third Reading
November 17, 2026
moved third reading of Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, as amended.
He said: Honourable senators, I rise today as the sponsor of Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, or FASD. I do so with gratitude for the thoughtful and collaborative work that has brought this bill to third reading.
At its core, Bill S-234 seeks to strengthen Canada’s response to FASD by bringing greater coordination, accountability and consistency to the considerable work already under way across the country. Its ultimate objective is to improve outcomes for individuals living with FASD, their families and caregivers.
FASD is a lifelong neurodevelopmental disability resulting from prenatal alcohol exposure. Its effects vary considerably from person to person and can include challenges with learning, memory, attention and emotional regulation. Diagnosis often requires multidisciplinary assessment, yet access to diagnostic services and ongoing supports remains inconsistent, particularly in rural and remote communities.
FASD is often described as an invisible disability. Individuals may experience significant challenges that are not immediately apparent to others. Without appropriate recognition and understanding, their needs may be overlooked, and difficulties arising from their disability may be mistakenly attributed to behavioural problems. These misunderstandings can have lasting consequences, affecting educational experiences, employment opportunities, relationships, mental health and interactions with health care, social services and the justice system.
Early recognition, appropriate accommodations and consistent, individualized supports can make a profound difference. Yet, too often, individuals and families must navigate fragmented systems to obtain the assistance they need.
Prevention is also an essential part of our response to FASD. Efforts to prevent prenatal alcohol exposure must be grounded in compassionate, evidence-based education and culturally appropriate approaches that avoid stigma and blame, while recognizing the dignity and value of individuals already living with FASD.
Colleagues, the importance of a coordinated national approach was reinforced during the Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology’s examination of Bill S-234. I wish to thank Senator Moodie for her leadership as chair and all the committee members for their thoughtful and collaborative consideration of this bill.
Over the course of four meetings, the committee heard from 17 witnesses and received 24 written briefs. These contributions brought together perspectives from federal departments, researchers, health care professionals, Indigenous organizations, advocates, parents and caregivers. I am grateful to each of these individuals and organizations for sharing their expertise, experiences and recommendations. Their contributions have helped strengthen this bill and deepen our collective understanding of the challenges faced by Canadians living with FASD.
In particular, I would like to thank our former colleague the Honourable Dan Christmas and his daughter Gail, whose guidance and lived experience have been invaluable throughout the development of this bill.
One of the central themes that emerged during the committee’s study was the importance of building upon the work that has already been done across Canada. Provincial and territorial governments, researchers, health care professionals and community organizations have made important contributions to FASD prevention, diagnosis and support. While critical gaps in knowledge and services remain, we must also ensure that existing expertise and initiatives are better coordinated and translated into meaningful improvements for individuals and families.
At the federal level, efforts to bring greater coordination and consistency have existed for decades. In 2003, Health Canada published a framework for action. This was an important starting point. It helped raise public awareness, encouraged collaboration across jurisdictions and contributed to the development of Canadian FASD diagnostic guidelines.
However, as we heard from representatives at the Public Health Agency of Canada, or PHAC, during their appearance before the Social Affairs Committee, that framework was largely aspirational. While it established a shared vision, it lacked clear performance indicators, a baseline against which to measure progress and sufficient accountability mechanisms. PHAC’s representatives acknowledged that implementation of the 2003 framework has been uneven across provinces and territories and that limited resources remain a significant challenge.
Bill S-234 seeks to address these shortcomings by establishing a clearer legislative foundation for federal action. It does so in three important ways.
First, it introduces greater legislative accountability. The bill requires the Minister of Health to develop and table a national framework within 18 months of the legislation coming into force, followed by a report on its implementation and effectiveness within five years of tabling. These requirements establish clearer expectations for federal action and provide Parliament with an opportunity to assess the progress being made. Importantly, the objective is not simply to produce another framework but to establish a process for identifying priorities, evaluating progress and highlighting areas requiring further attention.
Second, it strengthens collaboration and coordination. Representatives at PHAC emphasized that one of the federal government’s most valuable roles is that of a convenor, bringing together jurisdictions, Indigenous communities, individuals with lived experience, researchers, health care professionals and other stakeholders to share knowledge and identify effective practices.
Across Canada, there are already important initiatives supporting FASD prevention, diagnosis and intervention. However, these efforts are not always coordinated, and access to services can vary significantly depending on where an individual lives. A national framework offers an opportunity to learn from successful approaches, strengthen collaboration and identify opportunities to address gaps without duplicating programs that are already working effectively.
Third, it recognizes the need for a more comprehensive, evidence-informed approach to FASD. Significant gaps remain in our understanding of FASD across Canada, including its prevalence, the availability of services and the outcomes experienced by individuals throughout their lives. Without consistent and reliable data, it is difficult to identify unmet needs or determine where additional resources are most needed. A comprehensive national framework offers an opportunity to strengthen research and data collection, helping ensure that future policies and supports are informed by a clearer understanding of the needs of individuals living with FASD.
Bill S-234 is not intended to reinvent the wheel. Rather, it establishes a legislative foundation for bringing existing knowledge and expertise together, identifying gaps, establishing shared priorities and reporting on progress.
Honourable colleagues, while the fundamental purpose of the bill remains unchanged, the committee’s amendments have strengthened its commitment to Indigenous rights, reconciliation and meaningful participation in the development of the national framework. The bill, as amended, now explicitly incorporates the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Calls to Action 33 and 34. Call to Action 33 emphasizes the development of culturally appropriate FASD prevention programs in collaboration with Indigenous Peoples, while Call to Action 34 calls for reforms within the criminal justice system to better respond to the needs of individuals living with FASD.
The committee carefully considered the relationship between these justice-related measures and the scope of a national framework led by the Minister of Health. While the bill itself does not enact criminal justice reforms, it now requires the national framework to include measures aimed at reforming the justice system to better address the needs of individuals with FASD. This recognizes that the impacts of FASD extend beyond health care and that a meaningful national response requires coordination across departments and jurisdictions.
I thank Senator Muggli for bringing this forward, for her constructive and collaborative approach and for the work she has done in this area.
The committee also strengthened the bill’s provisions concerning Indigenous rights and consultation. The amendments explicitly recognize First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities, as well as Indigenous governing bodies and organizations that serve or represent them, among those to be consulted. They also require the national framework to include measures ensuring that it can be implemented in a manner consistent with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples while responding to the unique circumstances and needs of different Indigenous groups, communities and individuals.
Together, these amendments reinforce the importance of meaningful Indigenous participation and recognize that an effective national framework must respect the distinct rights, priorities and circumstances of Indigenous Peoples.
I thank Senator Greenwood for her thoughtful contributions to this work.
Throughout this process, I have remained mindful of the guidance I received from our late colleague former senator Murray Sinclair — may his soul rest in peace — who cautioned against reinforcing the misconception that FASD is an Indigenous-specific disability. FASD affects individuals and families in every part of Canada, across all communities and backgrounds. Recognizing the distinct rights and circumstances of Indigenous Peoples must go hand in hand with ensuring that the national framework responds to the needs of everyone affected by this disability. I believe the committee has struck that balance.
These amendments strengthen the bill’s commitment to reconciliation while preserving its fundamental purpose: providing a comprehensive, inclusive and population-wide national response to FASD.
In addition to these legislative amendments, the committee adopted observations highlighting the importance of continuity of support for individuals living with FASD throughout adulthood. Although FASD is a lifelong disability, access to support can diminish considerably as individuals transition out of school-based and youth services. I thank Senator Hay for bringing forward observations encouraging the Minister of Health to consider continuity of support across the lifespan, engage directly with adults living with FASD and include adult outcomes when reporting on the national framework.
These considerations are particularly important for young adults transitioning into employment, individuals receiving diagnosis later in life and families who must continually advocate for appropriate services.
Honourable colleagues, these considerations are not merely theoretical. They are reflected in the experiences of individuals living with FASD, several of whom recently wrote to me about what this legislation could mean in their lives.
Reinier deSmit, an advocate from Nova Scotia, received his FASD diagnosis at the age of 56. After decades of struggling to understand his challenges, he described how that diagnosis transformed his understanding of himself and even helped heal his relationship with his parents.
Myles Himmelreich, who has spent decades advocating for greater understanding of FASD, spoke candidly about the absence of appropriate services, particularly for adults.
He wrote:
We often hear people talk about individuals with FASD falling through the cracks in the system. I challenge that, because it’s not a crack if there’s not another side to step on. That’s a cliff.
R.J. Formanek similarly described the difficulties faced by young adults who lose access to services when they turn 18, emphasizing the need for greater continuity and consistency of support across Canada.
And Tanya, an adult living with FASD who received her diagnosis in Newfoundland and Labrador, shared how little individualized support was available to her afterward, despite finally having an explanation for the challenges she had experienced. She also offered an important reminder:
Too often, policies and services are developed without listening to the people who actually live with FASD every day. Nothing about us should be decided without us.
Honourable senators, these experiences remind us why this bill matters. Behind the policy discussions are individuals who have spent years seeking understanding, recognition and appropriate support. Their voices must be central to the development of a national framework that responds to their needs. I am sincerely grateful to each of these advocates for sharing their experiences and perspectives.
Throughout my years as a rural physician in Newfoundland and Labrador, I have come to appreciate the profound difference that early recognition, compassionate care and appropriate support can make in people’s lives. I have also seen the other side of the coin — how difficult it can be for individuals and families to navigate systems that are fragmented, under-resourced and lack coordination.
Bill S-234 on its own will not resolve all these challenges. However, it offers an important opportunity to bring greater coordination, accountability and sustained federal leadership.
My hope is that this framework will help us move toward a Canada where individuals living with FASD are better understood, families and caregivers are better supported, and access to appropriate services is not determined by geography or circumstance.
Honourable senators, I hope that we pass this bill unanimously and send a strong message to the other place.
Thank you. Meegwetch.
Thank you, Senator Ravalia, for your speech, which focused on those living with FASD, and for the work you have done.
Honourable senators, I rise in support of Bill S-234, which would establish a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. I really thank Senator Ravalia for his persistence.
I’d also like to thank the Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology for their important work and the amendments, so well described by Senator Ravalia.
Bill S-234 identifies FASD as a lifelong disability. This was reinforced in the testimony before the committee, but it is important to emphasize there is considerable evidence indicating that the effects of FASD can be substantially reduced through early intervention. I think it makes early diagnosis all the more important, and it’s the motivator behind so much that you have done, Senator Ravalia.
Colleagues, immediately before my appointment to the Senate, I was vice-chair of the Kids Brain Health Network, supported by the national Networks of Centres of Excellence. Our mandate was to advance and apply the latest research to improve the lives of children and families living with neurodevelopmental disabilities, including autism and FASD. That background is why I spoke in support of this bill’s predecessor, Bill S-253, in 2022. It died on prorogation, but I will briefly revisit the points I made then.
First, FASD can touch any family, in any community, regardless of income or background. Let’s be clear: Stigma and shame don’t prevent FASD; they only stand between families and the help they need, and make the harm worse.
About three in four Canadian women drink alcohol, a ratio that’s only slightly lower than among men. This matters because nearly half of all pregnancies in Canada are unintended, and roughly one in three women learn they are pregnant at six weeks or later. Consequently, many exposures happen before anyone knows.
Canada’s 2023 alcohol guidance is clear: There is no known safe amount when pregnant or trying to conceive. But that advice can’t help a woman who doesn’t know she’s pregnant. When mothers fear judgment, they don’t seek a diagnosis, and children who aren’t diagnosed don’t get support.
I personally believe the greatest risk facing children born with FASD is shame, and we have to really think hard about that in our own lives.
Second, inaction is enormously costly. At least 4% of Canadians — more than 1.5 million people — live with FASD, and the Canada FASD Research Network’s best estimate for North America is now 8%. That’s more than autism, cerebral palsy and Down’s syndrome combined.
Canada’s most comprehensive national cost study assumed a prevalence of just 1%, and it still found costs to be $1.8 billion a year, driven predominantly by lost productivity and corrections. At today’s estimates, the true cost is many times that amount.
Youth with FASD are 19 times more likely to be incarcerated than their peers. Without early diagnosis, effective treatment and ongoing support, we pay much more and for much longer. And that is only the financial cost; it says nothing of the toll on families and communities.
Third, early diagnosis works, but most Canadians can’t get one. Senator Ravalia has underlined this challenge, especially as it relates to rural and remote communities. Children need to be identified as at risk well before school age, when early interventions can have the greatest impact. Yet, a 2024 study by the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, or CAMH, found it took up to four and a half years to receive a diagnosis. It is also estimated that 98% of Canadians with FASD are undiagnosed or misdiagnosed.
In the Northwest Territories, there is no adult diagnostic clinic at all. A child who isn’t diagnosed doesn’t stop having FASD; they just meet it later in life, in a classroom that can’t support them or in a courtroom.
Fourth, we have the ability to support families through remote services. Canada leads the world in FASD research. What we lack is a reliable path from research to practice. It’s too common in this country: We have the innovators and the ability to do things differently, but we do not implement them. We leave it in studies and on the shelf.
In my home province of Nova Scotia, the Strongest Families Institute has shown that trained coaches can support families by phone and online. Its programs are designed for families raising a child with a neurodevelopmental disability, including autism and FASD. Similar programs exist elsewhere.
What matters most is that they are backed by proven results and that they meet families where they are and when they need help. Those of us who have raised kids know that at certain stages in life it is just too busy to get everything done. Kids with neurodevelopmental disabilities need the help, and families need it to be delivered reliably.
Colleagues, we need a framework that unites. FASD falls across health, education, social services and justice and across every level of government. When care is siloed, families fall through the cracks.
In 2022, I cautioned against the risk of pitting one disability community against another as we considered Bill S-203 on autism. That bill became law in 2023, and a national autism strategy followed in 2024. FASD families deserve the same as part of a broader, inclusive approach to neurodevelopmental disabilities as a whole, not one or another.
I am glad that Bill S-234 recognizes FASD in its preamble as one of the leading causes of neurodevelopmental disabilities, an addition from the previous version of this bill.
Colleagues, the case is stronger and more urgent than when we last debated the earlier version of this bill. Let’s pass Bill S-234 and send it to the other place without delay. Thank you.
Honourable senators, I rise today as the friendly critic of Bill S-234, An Act respecting a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, to support its passage at third reading.
For Canadians living with FASD, access to appropriate support can shape the course of a lifetime. When a disability goes unrecognized, a child may struggle in school without anyone understanding why. Families can spend years seeking help, only to discover that the services they need are unavailable where they live.
These gaps carry a human cost. Every person living with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, or FASD, deserves the opportunity to learn and participate fully in their community. Their rights should not depend on their postal code or their family’s ability to navigate disconnected systems.
Bill S-234 would establish a national framework to improve diagnosis and support through better coordination and professional training. The committee’s amendments strengthen it by requiring culturally appropriate prevention measures developed with Indigenous Peoples. They also require measures to better address the needs of people with FASD in the criminal justice system, reflecting the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Calls to Action.
I want to once again thank Senator Ravalia for his compassionate and sustained leadership. Bill S-234 offers a practical foundation for a more consistent national response. Its passage would move us closer to ensuring that Canadians living with FASD can receive appropriate support throughout their lives.
Thank you.
Are senators ready for the question?
Is it your pleasure, honourable senators, to adopt the motion?
Hon. Senators: Agreed.
(Motion agreed to and bill, as amended, read third time and passed.)