QUESTION PERIOD — Environment and Climate Change
Carbon Tax
October 10, 2024
Senator Gold, recently the Canadian Trucking Alliance called on the federal parties to cut red tape and tax and to restore fairness for truckers. Their number one ask was to end the carbon tax. It’s not coming from us, Senator Gold. It is not talking points. It’s not sloganeering. It is coming directly from them. They are the men and women who work day and night often away from their own families in order to provide our families food, clothing, et cetera.
In their report, they stated that this year alone, the Trudeau carbon tax will add almost $2 billion annually to trucking costs. By 2030, those additional costs will be $4 billion. Over the 12-year phase-in of the Trudeau carbon tax, it will cost the trucking industry a total of an additional $26 billion.
Senator Gold, we already see razor-thin margins for these hard-working Canadians, and they are passing those costs along to consumers. Why won’t you admit that this is a cash grab — nothing more — is not fighting climate change and is pummelling the hard-working middle class?
Thank you for your question. This is not a cash grab. Yes, a price on pollution is a price on pollution and has a cost. It has a cost in order to cause a change in behaviour. It remains the case, Senator Housakos, and with your business background I assume you know — although it is perhaps an inconvenient truth, if I may gesture towards another domain — it is a fact that any alternative, none of which have been presented for our consideration, to addressing climate change would cost more whether it is a regulatory regime or the like. This remains what mainstream Conservative economists recognize is the most market sensitive, cost-effective and effective tool. The PBO would not disagree with that.
Senator Gold, all I know from my business experience is that this carbon tax is pummelling working-class Canadians because the costs are trickling down to them. It is going directly from the truckers to the customers at the grocery stores. That’s what happening with your carbon tax. I know your government, Prime Minister Trudeau and some independent senators are not particularly fond of the trucking industry, but I am because they are the lifeblood of this country. They put food and medicine on our tables. It’s simple what you need to do: Axe the tax and remove the pressure from middle-class Canadians.
It’s amazing how you can look into the hearts and minds of independent senators. You have accused us for seven and a half years of not being truly independent. You don’t know what we think. I assume that every senator in this place has respect for hard-working Canadians and for the difficult times that many of us are going through.