THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Thursday, October 8, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade met with videoconference this day at 10:30 a.m. [ET] to examine and report on such issues as may arise from time to time relating to foreign relations and international trade generally, specifically Canada-U.S. trade and the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement.
Senator Peter M. Boehm (Chair ) in the chair.
[Translation]
The Chair: My name is Peter Boehm. I am a senator from Ontario and chair of the Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade. I now wish to invite committee members participating in today’s meeting to introduce themselves.
[English]
Senator Adler: Charles Adler, Manitoba.
Senator Downe: Percy Downe, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island.
Senator Mohamed: Farah Mohamed, Ontario.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: Amina Gerba from Quebec.
[English]
Senator McCallum: Welcome to the Senate. Mary Jane McCallum, Treaty 10 territory, Manitoba region.
Senator Harder: Peter Harder, Ontario.
Senator Wilson: Duncan Wilson, British Columbia.
Senator M. Deacon: Marty Deacon, Ontario. Welcome.
Senator Coyle: Mary Coyle, Antigonish, Nova Scotia.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: Martine Hébert from Quebec.
[English]
The Chair: Thank you, and welcome, senators. I’d like to welcome all who may be watching us on ParlVU across the country or, indeed, listening to us on audio.
Colleagues, we are meeting today to discuss Canada’s trade relationship with the United States and the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, or CUSMA. It’s a follow-on from what we did yesterday, and we’ll be doing much more of that.
Today, we have the pleasure from welcoming to the committee, from the Canadian Steel Producers Association, John Cuddihy, Vice-President, Climate and Environment; and from the Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance, no stranger to this committee, Michael Harvey, Executive Director. Welcome to you both. Thank you for taking the time to be with us today.
Before we hear opening statements and proceed to questions and answers, I would ask everyone present to please mute notifications on their devices and also to observe the instructions regarding the use of the earpieces and the microphones so we can avoid any sonic difficulties that could be injurious to our technical staff, in particular, our interpreters.
We’re ready to hear opening remarks, followed by questions from senators. Mr. Cuddihy, you have the floor.
John Cuddihy, Vice-President, Climate and Environment, Canadian Steel Producers Association: Good morning, Mr. Chair and honourable senators. Thank you for the opportunity to address the Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade.
The Canadian Steel Producers Association, or CSPA, is the national voice of all primary steel producers, as well as some of the country’s largest steel consumers. Our 17 members supply essential materials to key sectors, such as the automotive, energy, construction and transportation sectors, driving jobs and economic growth across North America. Our 40 member facilities act as local industrial anchor institutions, supporting massive ecosystems of local suppliers, contractors, logistics providers and downstream manufacturers. Steel production is vital for Canada’s sovereignty and its long-term economic prosperity.
The previous 20 months have been challenging. Canada’s steel industry is facing evolving tariff burdens, growing pressures from ongoing threats to fair and open trade by the United States, uneven domestic demand, limited export opportunities and a high incidence of unfair import competition arising from global excess steel production capacity.
The Government of Canada has implemented important measures to support a level playing field for Canadian steel producers in their own domestic market, to support Canadian steel producers in pivoting their production to capture a larger share of the domestic market and to enforce trade remedies. These measures are all critical. Without them, we would be in much worse shape. However, there remains important work to be done for Canada to maintain a viable steel production sector.
The joint impacts of undifferentiated U.S. trade action and global overcapacity are hammering our industry. For the last 30‑plus years, we have had a fully integrated economy with the U.S. Historically, we have shipped about half our production, or about 6 million tonnes, to the United States to support their supply gap, which has typically been in the range of 26 million to 27 million tonnes annually. While notionally intended to reduce imports of unfairly traded steel, U.S. section 232 tariffs have perversely resulted in a drop in Canadian shipments to the U.S. of almost 60% as of the second quarter of 2026 in comparison with 2024, the last normal year. The two countries most impacted by the U.S. trade action are not bad actors but its two most integrated trading partners, and Canada is most significantly affected.
The U.S. has also specifically targeted steel-containing products, or derivatives, in the Canadian market. Compounding this situation, steel producers and our customers are also under significant pressure from offshore imports, which are also frequently unfairly traded.
So where does this leave us? What we understand fundamentally is that there is no going back. For a variety of reasons, the United States’ view on free trade, including North American free trade, has shifted, and some of the subsequent underpinning realities have the potential to endure longer than the current administration. There is potentially a deal to be had, and a deal should be pursued — and pursued vigorously — but it will likely not be the same north-south free flow of trade to which we had become accustomed and from which we all — Canada and the U.S. — benefited from enormously.
For steel, this highlights the importance of growing our share of Canada’s domestic market. And this is not a temporary adjustment while we await a return to fully integrated north-south flows. Canada’s steel producers are committed to serving a growing share of our domestic market over the long term.
This is where assistance is required, and I need to be clear: Our continued call for support and action is not to highlight a lack of effort on the part of the Government to date but a worsening situation that calls for deeper and even more concerted action. We need to deepen the protection of the Canadian steel market from unfairly traded steel to allow Canadian steel producers to compete on as level a playing field as possible. We also need the government to take additional action to protect our domestic customers, fabricators and advanced manufacturers of steel products. If they move south or disappear because they are being outcompeted by unfairly traded products, we lose our domestic market.
Adjustments to Canada’s trade remedy system would also support the steel sector in pursuing legal action against unfair trade practices and, equally importantly, supporting domestic derivative product manufacturers in pursuing legal action. It is useless for Canada’s steel producers to win a trade case only to have the downstream product made of that same material dumped into our market.
Lastly, I would like to highlight the federal Buy Canadian Policy and the importance of all levels of government adopting and expanding the application of the policy on prioritizing Canadian materials in federal procurements. The critical piece here is that Public Services and Procurement Canada’s materials policy includes provisions for steel melted, poured and fabricated in Canada. Because of the significant impact of human labour on cost, conventional 51% domestic content approaches allow the designation of steel sourced from anywhere in the world to be labelled “Product of Canada” following further manufacturing or production. True buy Canadian policies must reference steel melted and poured in Canada.
I would like to close by reiterating our appreciation of the measures taken to date but to reinforce that the road ahead of us, if the status quo continues, will be more than difficult.
Thank you for your interest in Canada’s steel sector. I welcome your questions.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
Michael Harvey, Executive Director, Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance: Thank you. It’s good to be back. I’d like to give you a heads up that I’m suffering back spasms today, so if I get a shot of discomfort in my face, it’s unlikely to do with anything any of you have said.
[Translation]
The Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance, or CAFTA, is a coalition of national organizations that advocate for a freer and fairer international trading environment for the agriculture and agri-food sector. Ninety per cent of Canadian farmers depend on trade. Our country exports over $100 billion worth of food products annually. Open and predictable access to global markets is critical to the sector’s prosperity.
[English]
I have the honour of representing Canada’s agri-food exporters and the Prime Minister’s Advisory Committee on Canada-U.S. Economic Relations, where we receive regular briefings on negotiations and have an opportunity to bring the concerns of our sector directly into those discussions.
Agriculture has, so far, largely remained outside the cycle of tariffs and retaliation. For members of the Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance, or CAFTA, it is critical it stays that way. The Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance has undertaken several missions to Washington, D.C., to meet with U.S. elected officials and staffers, as well as with agricultural organizations with whom we have long-standing relationships.
In mid-September, I was in Washington to meet with agriculture advocacy groups and the Canadian embassy. We have repeatedly heard from our U.S. counterparts that the U.S. agricultural sector overwhelmingly supports the renewal of CUSMA, a position also reflected in the U.S. Agricultural Coalition for USMCA.
Strong industry support is important to support the case for CUSMA within the United States and inform the administration’s considerations and decisions affecting the agreement. When speaking with American officials, we underlined that American consumers benefit from high-quality food at a lower cost when Canadian agri-food products are tariff free. For American and Canadian producers, the deep relationship America and Canada have built in agri-food production makes both of us stronger in relation to the rest of the world. We stressed in our meetings that the uncertainty of tariffs goes against American and Canadian interests. Our countries produce food together, with many products moving back and forth in highly integrated supply chains. Introducing uncertainty and risk into those supply chains makes all of us poorer.
Just last week, several CAFTA members and I were in Calgary for the Tri-National Agricultural Accord, which brings together ministers of agriculture from Canadian provinces and American and Mexican states. The discussions reinforce the importance of viewing agriculture as a North American relationship. Producers and processors in all three countries have spent decades building integrated supply chains under CUSMA and its predecessors. While other industries have been more central to the current trade dispute, the increased uncertainty of the current environment is bad for Canadian and U.S. agriculture producers and consumers. At the same time, CUSMA has played an important stabilizing role, as demonstrated by the exemptions that continue to exist, even as the agreement has come under stress. For CAFTA, the priority is to keep agriculture and agri‑food trade tariff free and predictable and to preserve the stability CUSMA provides to the North American agricultural relationship.
I look forward to answering your questions.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
I’d like to acknowledge that Senator Woo from British Columbia has joined the meeting.
Colleagues, we’ll move to questions. As usual, you have a maximum of three minutes. Please keep your preambles short and your questions concise. That, of course, applies to our witnesses as well in terms of responses.
Senator Coyle: Thank you to our witnesses. I have a quick question for each of you.
Mr. Cuddihy, when you talk about buying Canadian and pivoting the sector to the domestic market, what is it going to take to pivot? What share of the Canadian market do the Canadian steel industry and associated industries supply at the moment? What kinds of time horizons are we talking about and what kinds of actions?
Mr. Cuddihy: Historically, we would have shipped 50%, or half our production, south. In terms of imports to Canada, our market has been historically about 12 million to 13 million tonnes, so we would have been in the 50% to 60% range. I don’t have the precise number for you right now, but over the last 20 months, with the measures taken to date, our increases have been in the range of 3% to 5%. It’s small relative to the losses. These things take time.
We’re looking at pivoting the industry to new opportunities and identifying what other things we can do domestically, but, at the same time, putting up capital investment takes time. We also have to realize that we’re looking for opportunities while competing, in many cases, with unfairly traded steel. This is the challenge, and this is where the government’s actions are helpful. Further government action will be helpful in creating that level playing field on which we can compete. It does take time. The Strategic Response Fund has been helpful in helping members act on opportunities, but that whole process takes time. I think this is a question of years, not months.
Senator Coyle: Thank you.
Mr. Harvey, welcome back. Good to see you. You talked about the protections that remain under CUSMA. Could you explain that in a little more detail for us?
Mr. Harvey: Basically, there have been a couple of times when the U.S. has made decisions to impose tariffs on Canada but not on CUSMA-compliant products. That has meant that our sector has almost always been tariff free, with the exception, recently, under these section 338 tariffs, of some protein products. It’s both been something that’s kept us out of the tariff battle in direct terms and shown that the United States has a certain commitment to the agreement, which we take as a level of protection and something we have to keep fighting for.
Senator Coyle: Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: I’d like to follow up on what my colleague raised, because — as you said — the industry faces significant challenges in trying to capture a larger share of the Canadian market. We know there are major projects on the horizon and that the potential for the steel industry is enormous.
You touched on the issue of the “Buy Canadian” policy. You’re not the only industry arguing that it isn’t working as well as desired. Are you in discussions with the Major Projects Office to ensure that, with what lies ahead, you’ll have priority and that your members will be ready to supply the necessary materials?
[English]
Mr. Cuddihy: Yes, we have had conversations with the Major Projects Office. Certainly, the Major Projects Office has been receptive, and it’s clear they’ve heard the direction of the Prime Minister on the Buy Canadian Policy and the political commitment to that.
I will say that the devil is always in the details. On any given project, where the project is in the pipeline when it comes to the Major Projects Office has a big impact. As projects emerge, we’re working with them to say, “Given the state of play in any given context, what can we do in that space?” In the major project context, it’s a project-by-project engagement. More broadly, it’s about working with the government to look at how the policy gets adopted across departments, agencies and Crown corporations and if they are implementing the material side with the imports.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: Mr. Harvey, thank you for being here. I met with cattle producers yesterday at another committee meeting. In the current climate, there’s a lot of talk about the importance of diversifying our exports. However, producers are quite concerned about issues such as Mercosur, which could significantly impact the cattle industry.
With that in mind, do you think the direction Canada has taken so far regarding international agreements is the right one? Are there things we can do to help the industry? I understand that you have been less affected by tariffs. However, that does not mean one should not take precautions. Nor does it mean you will not be affected in the future.
What are your thoughts on that?
The Chair: Please keep your answer brief.
Mr. Harvey: We strongly support the government’s efforts to diversify our markets. We have said from the outset that “diversification” does not mean selling less to the United States — it means selling as much or more to the United States, in addition to diversifying markets.
We view this from a risk management perspective, especially for rapidly growing international markets in which people are eating better, earning more money and buying high-quality products. We do not sell low-cost products. We sell high-quality products — and we must seek out new markets in growing regions such as the Indo-Pacific.
[English]
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you for being here today.
Regarding the issue of tariffs, my question concerns tariffs south of the border. Recently Mesabi Metallics announced a $15‑billion investment for a steel plant in Iowa, slated to begin in 2030. The President suggested this announcement proves his tariffs are working. I worry such investments are a sign of the steel industry in the U.S. seeing tariffs, perhaps, as a permanent state of affairs that will outlast this administration or even create cracks on the ground and hard assets and investments that would make it hard for a subsequent administration to go back to cross-border integration.
What is your interpretation, as you work with your colleagues, of the recent announcement on that Iowa plant? Is it the start of something, or could it be more of a one-off?
Mr. Cuddihy: Commercial or corporate announcements of a plant at that stage are far from being real assets. It’s far from being realized. I would suggest there’s significant uncertainty in terms of what that looks like and on what timeline it actually arrives.
With that said, I would agree with you. I mentioned in my remarks that the underpinnings of the current situation suggest that tariffs could be with us for a while. From a financial perspective, where the United States is at suggests it may be difficult for them to remove tariffs across the board.
In terms of treating the world as it is, as opposed to as we’d like it to be, we anticipate that tariffs, in some measure, at some level, will be at play in the long term.
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you for that.
Let’s look at something that’s probably more real and in our face right now, which is our defence industrial strategy. I’m wondering if that whole bold strategy moving forward sent the right signal that these investments are incoming and dependable. How has it been for the steel industry to shift to meet these defence construction needs?
Mr. Cuddihy: The focus on defence and the investments going into that space are certainly positive developments for the steel industry. It’s incumbent on us to respond to that and to work with these industries to ensure there is as great a level of Canadian content as is possible. Again, that’s exactly the type of pivot some of our members are looking at. That’s up to our individual members, on a commercial basis, to do that, supported by government policy and the political drive to say, “Hey, let’s source this from Canadian producers.”
Definitely, investments have already been made that are bolstering capacity in that space, and I anticipate further investments that will allow Canadian steel producers to supply the military space.
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: Welcome back to our committee, Mr. Harvey and Mr. Cuddihy.
Clearly, we will not be able to replace the United States any time soon, but the Canadian government intends to double its exports outside the United States. I am delighted to hear you say, Mr. Harvey, that markets around the world are growing. Among these markets, Africa is one of the fastest-growing regions in demographic terms. It has rapidly increasing food needs, as it must feed 1.5 billion potential consumers. That number will rise to 2.5 billion in 2050.
In that context, what could the government of Canada do to position its agri-food sector in African markets? What measures would accelerate this diversification in Africa?
Mr. Harvey: I do very little business with Africa because, at the moment, like almost all my members, I don’t see it as a priority market. The grain industry exports a great deal to Africa. Our other members, however, know very little about Africa. They would need to get to know the continent before making it a priority, as they are currently doing very little work there. The supply chains are quite far away and it is difficult to export certain products, such as meat and processed goods. The oilseeds and pulses sectors may well be sectors with potential for the future. Aside from what the cereal industry is doing, there is relatively little activity at the moment.
Senator Gerba: I realize the distance is considerable, but do you feel it is further away than the Indo-Pacific region in terms of culture and distance?
Mr. Harvey: In terms of the current market, that is what my members are telling me, yes. They are focusing their efforts on markets where they believe they can grow fairly quickly and are placing greater emphasis on the Indo-Pacific region. It has more to do with supply chains than transportation links.
Senator Gerba: Would you therefore recommend that the government focus more of its efforts on establishing supply chains linked to Africa and that it keep your members much better informed about that potential? Is there anything else that needs to be done to ensure your members are informed and aware of what is currently happening in this market and in the agri-food sector?
Mr. Harvey: I’m not sure, senator. What I can see is that my members are prioritizing other regions where they currently see greater opportunities for growth.
Senator Gerba: All right.
[English]
Senator Harder: Thank you to our witnesses for being here.
Among the witnesses that we’ve had, there is a group of industries that tends to have very strong trilateral relations. There are other groups that are less cooperative if I can put it that way. I’d like to explore Mr. Cuddihy, the steel sector across North America, which is not one of the ones that has a lot of cooperation, if I can put it that way. To what extent is the Cleveland-Cliffs issue going to add difficulty to the issues around steel in any negotiations?
Mr. Cuddihy: I won’t speculate, senator. That’s a difficult situation in terms of international statements on the part of any given company and ownership structure. I would defer to Stelco to respond in terms of any given position.
Overall, it doesn’t change anything for us. We’re Canadian steel producers. We produce steel to serve our markets. Our interaction with the United States is highly integrated in terms of our customers and our clientele. It’s clear the United States steel industry is profiting enormously from the current situation, so the dynamics in that space are, I’ll say, above my pay grade.
Senator Harder: I get that. I thought that might be your answer.
Let me pursue this, then, from another angle. Your sector is one that has had ongoing trade issues, which have both predated Trump and followed Trump. Biden imposed sanctions, or tariffs, on steel. Are your American counterparts better equipped to utilize the policy instrument of tariffs than other sectors?
Mr. Cuddihy: Our legislative structures regarding tariffs in Canada and the U.S. are different. We don’t have the same section 232 legislative structure. We have a tariff quota structure that has been implemented. We’ve definitely seen the effectiveness of that. The effectiveness was better at the beginning and is now diminishing in the sense that we’re seeing a steady increase in imports, even though they’re reduced from where they were in 2025.
I wouldn’t say it’s any more effective. I would say the United States has come in at a 50% tariff, and we anticipate that we’re going to see action in the U.S. against certain countries that are importing significant levels and surging in steel imports despite the tariffs. The two systems are different but have similar capacity in terms of having an impact. What we need to do is dial ours in appropriately to be as rigorous and supportive as the 50% tariff in the U.S.
Senator Harder: — on the dumping side?
Mr. Cuddihy: Correct.
Senator McCallum: Thank you for your presentations. My question is for Mr. Harvey.
My first question is: What are the effects of national building projects on the lands they’re buying up that is currently being used for agriculture? My second question, which is connected, is: Water is not as abundant as many Canadians think. Then, there’s drought on top of that. How will that impact the agriculture industry in Canada?
Mr. Harvey: Thank you for the question.
For the first one, I don’t have that much to be able to share with you. It is not an issue that I work on, I’m afraid.
On the second question, I would say my members look at things largely through the perspective of improving agricultural techniques and science-based agriculture so that we can use less water. For instance, when we use new techniques around genetically modified organisms or gene splicing, that allows our farmers to use a lot less land, water and fertilizer. Increasing the amount of science that we apply to our production allows us to have a lot smaller environmental impact per amount of food.
Senator McCallum: One of the senators had asked a question, and she said that with national building projects, they are buying up massive amounts of agricultural land. That’s why I asked that question.
Mr. Harvey: Sorry, I have never heard of that, but it’s not something I work on directly.
Senator McCallum: So you’re not concerned about it?
Mr. Harvey: I only work on trade policy issues, so it’s not something that I’m responsible for. There are a lot of things in the sector that I hear when I’m at meetings. I hadn’t heard of that, but I don’t work on that issue.
Senator McCallum: Okay. Thank you.
The Chair: I have a question as well, and I’ll direct it to Mr. Harvey.
Senator Harder talked about trilateralization. I think, increasingly, there is more contact between Canada and Mexico at all levels. Of course, we’re sharing the pain in some ways.
I’m wondering whether these consultations that you mentioned in your statement, if this is something fairly recent, or does it provide an opportunity to look at best practices in all countries? Are we seeing more engagement with Mexico than we had before? I say this because, in future meetings of this committee, we are going to have some senior-level Mexican witnesses, so I would be interested in your comments.
Mr. Harvey: I would definitely say the cooperation has increased. There are different forums. The one I mentioned was the Tri-National Agricultural Accord, where it’s provinces and state departments of agriculture. We also have the Canada-Mexico agribusiness forum, which we expect will meet in Mexico again next year, in February. There are different environments.
One thing that is very interesting about our relationship with Mexico is our agriculture is very complementary. In Canada, often there are vast extensions of land, so we sell cereals, lentils and beans to Mexico. For the Mexican farmer, it’s interesting because it allows them to concentrate on products that have a higher value added for them, such as avocados and mangoes, which are not areas of Canadian expertise. We believe strongly in complementing each other’s products, selling what we do better and buying what we can’t.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: Mr. Harvey, I would like to revisit the issue of diversification. You spoke of the need to seek out international markets. You mentioned the Indo-Pacific, an attractive region for our products. Indeed, these markets are seeking our food products, particularly because of their quality and traceability. If memory serves or if my information is correct, we export a lot of processed products to these markets. It’s the other way around? I see. What I have heard, then, is that certain regions of the world offer more opportunities for processed products than for unprocessed ones. Can you tell me whether the Canadian industry is ready to face these challenges? Are we currently equipped to make the most of the opportunities in these regions of the world, for both raw and processed products?
Mr. Harvey: It is challenging for processed products. There are various reasons for this, but one of them is that almost every country prioritizes local food processing. It is therefore very difficult to break into the market with a product. Then there are transportation costs, the cold chain, and so on. Sales are lower. Sometimes efforts are made — I’m thinking of the pulse protein sector. Efforts are being made. If we want to capitalize on this, we need to strengthen local industry in Canada and improve our supply chains and transport sector so we can export as quickly and cost-effectively as possible while ensuring reliable delivery. In reality, countries are not looking for many processed products, as they prioritize local produce. It will not be easy to change that reality.
Senator Hébert: You mentioned transportation, and you’re not the only industry talking about it — forestry producers spoke to us about it yesterday. In terms of transportation, could Bill C-39 bring some —
Mr. Harvey: Yes, that’s a plus, because we’ve often seen, for example, the credibility of Canadian exporters undermined following disruptions to our transportation system, on the railways and at the ports. As a result, someone who has a contract but does not receive their goods will source them elsewhere next time if they feel there is no guarantee of receiving them. Anything that improves the efficiency and reliability of our transport systems will benefit our exports.
Senator Hébert: Thank you very much.
Senator Gerba: One quick comment. Mr. Harvey, there are markets for processed goods throughout Africa, such as beverages, for example. Certain countries in Africa consume Canadian beverages like sparkling wine — in other words, Canadian products are in high demand in those countries. We also import many products from Africa, including grapes from South Africa and mandarins and clementines from Morocco. There is therefore a problem, and we want to resolve it so that our exports can grow in those markets.
My question is for Mr. Cuddihy. Quebec remains a major producer and processor of steel. Several Quebec-based companies are directly involved in North American supply chains. What strengths can Quebec’s steel producers and processors bring to bear in their trade relations with the United States?
[English]
Mr. Cuddihy: Yes, Quebec is definitely a significant steel-producing region. One of the advantages in Quebec, certainly, is low-cost and low-carbon electricity. Quebec also has one of our only direct-reduced iron facilities. Steel making is kind of three steps. You have iron making, steel making and the rolling mills for the final production. The direct-reduced iron piece is among the most efficient from an environmental perspective and a climate perspective as well. It sets the benchmark for today.
I would say, certainly, from that perspective, the advantages that our producers in Quebec have are the availability of low-cost, low-carbon electricity — that’s big — and the availability of iron as well.
Senator Harder: My question is for Mr. Harvey. In your statement, you talked about your representation on the Prime Minister’s advisory committee. One of the roles we have in the Senate is to ensure that the appropriate consultation processes are in place, vigorous and working well.
Could you expand a bit on the role you’re playing and whether you’re satisfied with the rhythm of the consultations and the frankness of the discussions?
I think it’s important for us to put on the record that role, which is very important, that you represent in your sector.
Mr. Harvey: We’ve spoken, basically every meeting, with Minister LeBlanc, Madam Charette, Ambassador Wiseman, and quite often the Clerk of the Privy Council as well. They’ve been very open with us about the challenges they’re facing.
They’ve used us to get messages out to the Canadian public and to our sectors about the challenges they’re facing. I think they’ve been very open.
As a former diplomat, I already had a high level of confidence in our trade negotiators, to be honest, because I’ve worked right next to them in cubicles over the years. It was good for me to see the political level and how solid their knowledge is of the details. They’re working very hard and are not faced with a very easy negotiating environment.
It has also been interesting for me to see sectors such as steel that are suffering a lot more than we are. Not that our situation is great; we have all this political risk around us. But if you sit next to the steel sector, the aluminum sector, and the auto sector, you realize and feel a little bit better that someone else is really at the heart of things, frankly, and you feel some solidarity with them.
Senator Black: It’s good you’re sitting together then. Thanks very much.
Senator Coyle: This is for Mr. Cuddihy, and it’s another angle on this. I know that our steel industry is one of the toughest ones to decarbonize. Creating the green steel we all know we are going to need is tough, and it was tough already before we got into the trade tensions.
Can you talk about the impact of where we are now in this very harsh reality? What that is doing to those efforts that have been in place, as we’re on a certain track moving forward. What’s the impact there?
Mr. Cuddihy: Just as a starting point, it’s important to note Canada’s steel industry is among the most greenhouse-gas efficient in the world. Our blast furnaces are ranked number 1 in 2025, and our electric arc furnaces are ranked number 3 globally. When you’re buying Canadian steel, you are buying climate-friendly steel. That said, there is always room for improvement.
I guess I would say what the trade situation has done is affect the overall investment environment. When you’re fighting to find your lunch, you’re not worried about the utensils you’re using to eat it.
I think where folks are looking right now, in terms of investment opportunities, is really about harvesting the increased market share in Canada, and less focused on big picture, long-term, decarbonization initiatives, which require significant investment in the hundreds of millions to billions, depending on the investment opportunity. It’s not that it’s off the table; it’s just the second tier, in terms of focusing on what we can do right now to capture market share in Canada.
Senator Coyle: That’s what I expected you were going to say. I’ve been reading about it, and I think it’s affecting a lot of things. Thank you for that.
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you very much. Following up from Senator Harder, he talked about the Prime Minister’s table, Mr. Harvey. But I’m wondering about what you talked about in your introduction. I’m trying to image: The meeting you had was trilateral — Mexico-U.S.-Canada — and you are, as you so eloquently said, in a different spot, perhaps, than other sectors. The agreements have been, I’m going to say, more in favour — for lack of any other term — than some of our other sectors.
So when you were sitting at that table in September, how was that? How was that feeling of Canada and the U.S. and Mexico at the table? What are the things that you are working on very aggressively together? What are your takeaways when you come back to Canada to meet with your folks at home?
Mr. Harvey: Working aggressively is the opposite of the way those conversations are going. There’s quite a bit of avoiding very delicate subjects.
We were with the State Departments of Agriculture. The State Departments of Agriculture, all, when they’re at the table, support the trilateral agreement, are very supportive of USMCA.
They will also very quickly tell you they are not the federal administration, and they have basically no influence on the federal administration in terms of supporting the agreement. That is not totally true, but I think we all know there is an atmosphere in Washington that is a little bit different than in the past. People are nervous about speaking up because that can have consequences for them. They tell us a lot of things are said in private; not many things are said in public.
Those members of the U.S. agriculture sector that have spoken in public have had reactions from the White House, calls, and things said. So it’s difficult for them.
I think it’s very important for us to keep this connective tissue of the trilateral agreement working well so that when things change at the top level — and I’m confident they will, one way or another — that all this connective tissue will still be working well. I think that’s very positive.
We would like more to be said and more pressure put on the administration to change their position, but that’s not the world we live in.
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Senator Gerba, I have noted that this is your third question. This time is truly a gift on my part. Go ahead.
Senator Gerba: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I greatly appreciate it.
Mr. Cuddihy, you mentioned that you are trying to expand your local market. However, for several years now, North American producers have been concerned about the effects of global excess capacity in the steel sector. Does the Canada–United States–Mexico Agreement, or CUSMA, provide sufficient protection for Canadian producers against competition from countries with excess capacity?
[English]
Mr. Cuddihy: In the current context, I would suggest that if CUSMA were working effectively for steel, if the agreement were respected fully in the steel context, and we implemented our measures — together with the United States and Mexico — to protect our borders against dumped steel, which could be highly effective and create an integrated North American market, absolutely.
The Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement itself won’t protect us from dumped steel or global excess capacity. What it does is create a fluid market internal to North America. I would say the measures we have implemented: the tariff rate quota, the China metal import surtax, the surtax on derivatives, et cetera, those measures are extremely important to protect Canada’s domestic market. Regardless of where things go with the United States, those are fundamentally important. Further work to dial them in as we look at trends and as we look at increased pressure coming from even fair-trade-agreement countries, it’s important that we think about how those measures impact our domestic market.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: Thank you.
Should negotiations resume, do you have any specific recommendations to strengthen that CUSMA protection?
[English]
Mr. Cuddihy: Certainly. On the derivative side, on the steel product side, we’re looking at increasing the derivative’s rate to 50% from 25% and looking at expanding the scope of coverage. In that space right now, it covers 60 products. We had asked initially for 200 products. I think there’s probably a Goldilocks, middle ground where there’s work to be done to fine-tune what that could look like and ensure that we are protecting our clients and not causing any negative effects.
And then, on the tariff rate quota, there’s work to be done to dial in what the exact levels should be for fair trade and non-fair trade countries, as well as what the over-quota tariff rate should be.
As I mentioned earlier, there’s activity in the United States. We’re anticipating action by the U.S. administration on some, in this case, fair-trade-agreement partners because of surges in steel imports. We’re anticipating when those measures are taken, that’s going to have knock-on effects on the Canadian market.
So, again, we will have to look at how that is affecting us and how we dial those measures in further to address that?
Senator Gerba: Thank you.
[Translation]
Mr. Cuddihy: Thank you.
[English]
The Chair: I would like to ask the last question. It’s a question for you both. You represent associations that have been around for a long time. In the history of your associations, you’ve probably not had the kinds of pressures you face now. How much solidarity is in the group? Is everyone together and like-minded as the pressure increases and as time passes?
Mr. Cuddihy: Our strength comes from our solidarity. What I have witnessed from within the Canadian Steel Producers Association’s membership is an ability to come to the table and be frank about everyone’s individual reality and, at the same time, have open conversations about where can we take measures that benefit the group as a whole.
I have been impressed with the level of candour and respect that are brought to the table to ensure we are able to speak with one voice because if we are fractured, our influence and the message we bring would not carry as much weight.
The Chair: Thank you.
Mr. Harvey: In the agri-food sector, traditionally, some sectors are more focused on the domestic market, and others are agri-food exporters, so we have gotten agreements on how we work inside Canada on Canadian issues. The trade policy space is a more difficult one. We don’t disagree with each other on anything necessarily, but we don’t have the same sectoral interests. There are a lot of sectors where there is no way we could sell our products in Canada. These sectors exist because of exports, so our priority is always going to be market access and the ability to export our products.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
On behalf of the committee, I would like to thank John Cuddihy and Michael Harvey for their appearances and comments today. This is a huge national issue for us, as both of you well know. I dare say you may be back to see us in the future. Mr. Harvey, going back to your opening statement or preliminary remarks, all members of this committee hope that your back improves. Thank you very much.
For our second panel, we have four witnesses: Matt Conley, Director, Government Relations, Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters; Brian Kingston, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association; Flavio Volpe, President, Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association; and, by videoconference, Brendan Sweeney, President and Chief Executive Officer, Pacific Manufacturing Association of Canada. Thank you all for being with us today.
We have four witnesses, so we’re going to have to move with dispatch through the agenda. Mr. Conley, you have the floor.
Matt Conley, Director, Government Relations, Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters: Thank you to the chair and the members of the committee. I’m appearing on behalf of Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters. We represent 1.84 million workers, $208 billion in GDP and a sector that has built our country’s prosperity for 150 years.
Today, I would like to begin with a story. Not long ago, I attended a seminar here in Ottawa to mark the thirtieth anniversary of the original Canada-U.S. free-trade agreement. In the room, we had professors, auto executives, steel leaders and many other business owners. That day, they raised their glasses and boldly declared that an entire generation knew nothing but open and free trade between Canada, the U.S. and Mexico. The battles of the arguments of the 1980s were all settled, all over. There were problems that remained in the world that day, but we had solved that one.
Now here we are today. The people in the room were right about one thing: Free trade between Canada and the United States contributed to an entire generation of unprecedented shared prosperity, but they were wrong about one thing too. They forgot the first rule, that anything worth having only lasts if someone keeps fighting for it. Every generation inherits what the last one built. Every generation is asked to defend it, renew it or, in the hardest moments, rebuild it.
CUSMA is not a historical artifact. It’s a living framework, and now is the time to defend it.
[Translation]
I will talk to you about what we need to defend.
When manufacturers think of CUSMA, they think of its clear rules and trade between Canada, Mexico and the United States that protects each nation’s right to maintain a competitive industrial base. CUSMA is an effective framework that serves the interests of all three countries.
Manufacturers know that Americans are our friends, allies, cousins and family members. They are customers and suppliers. The relationship between Canada and the United States is over 150 years old. The friendship will always exist and will never be broken, even if there is friction and change.
That’s precisely why CUSMA matters. We must use this opportunity to modernize the agreement and create greater North American trade alignment.
[English]
Canadian manufacturers are operating in an extremely challenging environment today. There are long-standing gaps in investment, productivity and technology adoption that have significantly eroded Canada’s manufacturing competitiveness. U.S. tariffs have made that worse, disproportionately targeting manufactured goods, while repeated changes and continued threats create uncertainty.
When asked, more than 15% of manufacturers say they will be unable to sustain current operations beyond one year without additional support. Those aren’t just numbers on a page. Those are factories, workers and communities. We have to get this right. We don’t get a second chance.
Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters fully supports expanding trade relationships with allied countries like the United Kingdom, the EU, countries in the Indo-Pacific and the Caribbean, but for many manufacturers, diversification is not just a switch that you turn on and off. Many manufacturers primarily sell inputs to the United States, and exports travel north-south. To diversify, manufacturers need to develop more finished and semi-finished products. They also need to find a way to move them and ship them east-west. That’s going to take a very long time.
In the meantime, we need CUSMA to hold. The agreement is not just about today’s trade flows; it’s the bridge that keeps manufacturers viable while Canada builds new routes. No question, diversification is important, but our largest trading partner is and will always be the United States.
Here’s a strategic view I’d like to leave with the committee. A stronger, more productive Canadian manufacturing base is Canada’s best negotiating asset. Industrial capacity is a national strength. The investment that we make in the Canadian industry today is leverage that we can carry tomorrow.
Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters’s President and CEO, Dennis Darby, was honoured to sit on the Prime Minister’s Advisory Committee on Canada-U.S. Economic Relations and was able to bring forward the voice of manufacturers and provide feedback to the government. Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters thanks the government for the opportunity to be in the room so that we could press the issues that matter most to manufacturers. We will never stop advocating for our sector.
To those in the room, Canadian manufacturers have three asks. First, push for a renewed agreement with the United States for CUSMA that is as codified, enforceable and durable as possible. We know it’s not always possible and not always the case, but if it’s an opportunity to get back to the table, we would support it.
Second, support free and fair trade champions on both sides of the aisle. Whether it’s in Congress, governors’ mansions, state capitals or boardrooms, we know why CUSMA matters, but we need to amplify those voices to make sure they come through.
Third, we need to invest in Canadian manufacturing. The answer to instability abroad is strength at home, and we need to support legislation and government action that builds Canada’s manufacturing sector to face challenges in the years to come. Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you very much. Mr. Kingston, please.
Brian Kingston, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association: Thank you, Mr. Chair, honourable senators. I appreciate the invite to be here today.
The Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association, or CVMA, represents leading manufacturers of light- and heavy-duty motor vehicles. Our membership includes Ford, General Motors and Stellantis.
Our members have been operating here in the country for over 100 years. They are responsible for most of the auto production in Canada, having built over 100 million vehicles. Today, they are the largest employers, investors and innovators in the auto sector in Canada.
Tariffs and trade uncertainty are imposing significant costs on the integrated North American supply chain that threatens the long-term competitiveness of the industry. Since the imposition of U.S. section 232 tariffs on automobiles and parts, the U.S. has collected over US$51.3 billion in tariff revenue. The tariff costs facing Canadian-assembled vehicles now exceed C$7 billion.
As a result of these tariffs and Canada’s retaliatory measures, bilateral auto trade has declined significantly. U.S. light vehicle exports to Canada are down 25%, with Canadian light vehicle exports to the U.S. falling by 17%. The share of U.S.-built vehicles sold in Canada has declined from 43% in 2024 to 39% in 2025, and throughout the first half of this year, it’s sitting at 28%. This is weakening the competitiveness of the industry, and it’s benefiting competitors around the world. It is now more cost-effective to build a vehicle in Japan, Germany or Korea and export it to the United States than it is to build in the U.S., Canada or Mexico. That makes no sense.
With 92% of Canadian vehicle production destined for the U.S., there is simply no Canadian auto industry without U.S. access and North American integration. Diversification is not an option for this industry, as markets in Europe, Asia and South America are better served by assembly plants that are there. Canada’s market alone is sizeable, but it’s too small to justify large-scale manufacturing at the rates that we have right now.
Despite these challenges, we believe there is a mutually beneficial agreement available to Canada and the United States. Canada is the largest auto export market for the U.S. It’s the destination for more U.S. vehicle exports than Germany, Mexico, China and Korea combined. Not only that, but since the implementation of CUSMA, the U.S. has run an average automotive trade surplus with Canada of US$3.6 billion. This relationship works, and it works for America.
We are urging both governments to get back to the table and secure tariff relief. There is a deal available, but we must negotiate one if we are going to continue to have a manufacturing sector here.
Equally important to this is a successful review of CUSMA. CUSMA is the foundation for the integrated industry today. It provides certainty for manufacturers, it reinforces the integration of the supply chain and it facilitates regulatory development, which has been key to the automotive industry, as well as alignment. Ensuring alignment with the U.S. on the approach to China is going to be fundamental to a successful review of CUSMA.
The agreement that Canada struck with China to allow 49,000 electric vehicles, or EVs, into the country, which is equivalent to 30% of the EVs sold here last year, undermines our auto sector and puts the whole supply chain at risk. China does not adhere to the rules-based trade and investment principles that have been fundamental to the auto industry and, more largely, to the Canadian economy.
There are no guardrails in the agreement to ensure a level playing field for manufacturers that have invested here or to protect Canadians from cyber risks. We’re urging the government to reintroduce surtaxes on Chinese EVs and put a ban in place on Chinese connected vehicle hardware and software, aligned with what the U.S. has done. This will protect Canadians from foreign actors manipulating these technologies.
Last but certainly not least, as we navigate this period of trade turmoil, it is imperative that federal and provincial governments work together to improve industry competitiveness. We do not control U.S. trade policy, but we do control our own policy environment here at home, so we need a more predictable, competitive and achievable regulatory environment that incentivizes production in this country.
Specifically, we’re recommending that the Canada-specific greenhouse gas, or GHG, emissions regulations that are under development right now are based on market realities, supported by a credible development timeline and informed by rigorous cost-benefit analysis. The guiding principle here for the government should be ensuring that automakers that build cars in Canada and employ Canadians are not put at a competitive disadvantage to pure importers.
Thank you for the opportunity to be here. I look forward to your questions.
The Chair: Thank you very much. Mr. Volpe.
Flavio Volpe, President, Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association: Chair, honourable senators, thank you for the invitation.
For the automotive industry, CUSMA is not an abstract trade agreement; it is part of the architecture that makes the continental production system possible. We do not really trade automobiles with the United States; we make automobiles together. Canadian parts go into American vehicles. American parts go into Canadian vehicles. Components and tooling cross the border several times before a finished vehicle reaches a customer. That integration creates enormous value on both sides of the border, but integration cannot mean that Canada simply accepts its vulnerability.
The United States did not agree to renew CUSMA in its current form at the July review, but the agreement remains in force.
Now the United States Trade Representative, or USTR, has opened consultations in advance of the 2027 review. Companies making long-term investment decisions are living with that uncertainty.
My first point is that CUSMA compliance has to mean something. If a company builds a North American supply chain meets the rules of origin and organizes production around the agreement, those rules need to have value. We cannot build an integrated market if companies follow North American rules and still can’t get North American treatment. Canada should defend that principle clearly.
My second point is that Canada has to use the economic tools it controls at home more deliberately. Start with automotive. Canada is a major and profitable market for global automakers. We should think much more carefully about the relationship between an original equipment manufacturer’s, or OEMs, success selling vehicles in Canada and its commitment to manufacturing here.
I’m not suggesting that governments tell Canadians which vehicles to buy or that we violate our own trade obligations, but when governments design incentives, procurement programs, investment supports, remission frameworks and regulatory policies, there should be a meaningful advantage for companies that maintain and grow production in Canada.
If an automaker is gaining market share in Canada, we should be asking how Canada gains production share with that automaker. Canada should be more than just a sales territory, and the same principle applies to defence.
Canada is preparing to spend substantially more on defence and national security. That spending should strengthen our military capability but also Canada’s industrial capability.
The first question in a major procurement should be: What can we build here? Where Canadian manufacturers have the capability, we should contract Canadian companies. Where we need technology or platforms from allies, we should negotiate for Canadian production, technology transfer, intellectual property, supply chain participation and through-life support wherever practical.
Security is not simply owning equipment; it is having the domestic capacity to repair it, replenish it, modify it and sustain it when circumstances become difficult. We should not spend billions of Canadian taxpayer dollars building strategic industrial capacity somewhere else and then discover that we need to recreate it here.
None of this means turning away from the United States. Our geography, supply chains and 60 years of investment tell us otherwise. The United States will remain our largest customer and our most important industrial relationship, but there is a difference between integration and dependence.
Canada’s objective in the next phase of CUSMA should be to deepen the parts of the North American integration that make all three countries more competitive while protecting the productive capacity that makes Canada valuable within the system. That means strong rules of origin, and it means preventing third countries from using North America simply as a back door into the market. It means regulatory compatibility where it makes sense, and it means recognizing that economic security cannot be achieved by weakening the industrial base of one of your closest allies.
Canada is not going to outmuscle the United States. Our leverage comes from being difficult to replace. That is why our central economic strategy should be straightforward: Build things here that our allies, our citizens and our own governments need.
CUSMA matters enormously, and we should defend it, but no trade agreement can substitute for an industrial strategy. Canada should go into this period not simply as a reliable customer or a source of natural resources but as an indispensable producer.
Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
Mr. Sweeney, please.
Brendan Sweeney, President and Chief Executive Officer, Pacific Manufacturing Association of Canada: Good morning. Thank you for inviting me to contribute to this committee.
The Pacific Manufacturing Association of Canada, or PMAC, was created in March 2026 and represents the two largest automakers in Canada: Honda and Toyota. Honda and Toyota assemble more than 900,000 vehicles in Canada annually, representing 77% of total Canadian vehicle production, export approximately 80% of those vehicles to the United States, with virtually all of the remainder sold in Canada, and are the two largest importers of automotive parts from the United States.
At the same time, Honda and Toyota continue to operate five Canadian assembly plants at full capacity and have never laid off permanent employees, manufacture nearly three vehicles in Canada for every one that they sell in Canada, primarily assemble hybrid-electric vehicles, which reduce greenhouse gas emissions by up to about 30% when compared to equivalent gasoline-powered vehicles and are the two single largest consumers of Canadian-made steel.
As such, PMAC’s members are bearing the brunt of the illegal tariffs imposed by the United States.
PMAC’s members have developed certain competitive advantages when compared to U.S. assembly plants over the years. Those competitive advantages are closely related to the productivity and quality of Honda and Toyota’s Canadian assembly plants, which are a testament to the manufacturing workforce in Southern Ontario and the efficient and integrated trade networks facilitated by agreements such as CUSMA.
Another interesting fact is that Honda’s powertrain manufacturing facilities in Ohio and Toyota’s powertrain manufacturing facilities in West Virginia and Toyota’s battery manufacturing facility in North Carolina are the three largest exporters of automotive parts from the United States to Canada in dollar value.
When combined, those plants represent about one third of all automotive parts exports from the United States to Canada, again, in dollar value. The thousands of people working in those plants rely on Canadian assembly plants for their livelihoods, and they reside in communities where other employment opportunities tend to be limited, i.e., West Virginia.
Tariffs have eroded those competitive advantages. The threat of increased tariffs on January 1, 2027 — which is now only 85 days away — would erode them further. Immediate action is necessary to secure the long-term future of automotive manufacturing in Canada.
In the short term — and we are considering this to be from Canadian Thanksgiving to U.S. Thanksgiving — we are asking that the federal government provide relief at no cost to taxpayers through a tariff remission system, such as the one announced in February 2026 as part of the federal automotive strategy.
In the medium term — 2027-2028 — the federal government should focus on negotiating an interim agreement with the United States that establishes a lower, effective tariff rate that allows automakers to maintain production in Canada and that provides a pathway or a mechanism back to integrated, tariff-free trade of automotive products and, preferably, CUSMA, generally.
If that proves elusive — which it may — and if tariffs increase — which they may — the federal government should have a Plan B ready to support companies that manufacture vehicles in Canada. That Plan B must be developed in consultation with industry and communicated well before January 1, 2027.
In the long term — post-2028 — the federal government should focus on negotiating an agreement with the United States that re-establishes tariff-free trade of automotive products so that automotive manufacturers in Canada can re-establish competitive advantages and focus on investments in the next generation of vehicle technologies.
Thank you for having me, and I look forward to further discussion.
The Chair: Thank you very much.
We’ll proceed immediately to questions. As before, colleagues, you have three minutes. Keep your preambles concise if you can.
Senator Coyle: That was a long time ago when I put my hand up. There’s been so much information since then. I will go back to the original question I had, and it’s for Mr. Conley.
Your third recommendation or suggestion is that Canada should invest in the manufacturing sector here in order to help it adjust to a different market. We’re talking about diversification. In your testimony, you talked about how integrated many of our manufacturing — and we’ve just heard about auto but also other manufacturing industries, and because of that, it’s worked great. Now, with the current situation, there’s a lot of vulnerability built in, and it’s not going to be a switch that you can turn on to just diversify because your members are so tied in.
Could you tell us a little bit more about what that looks like?
I think you get the gist of my question.
Mr. Conley: Absolutely. Thank you so much. That’s an excellent question. We see it a lot from our members. With SMEs we represent everything from small- and medium-sized manufacturers — like foundries and breweries, Ford and Cenovus — and a lot of larger companies.
I completely agree that, for a lot of manufacturers, the biggest concern they have when they hear “diversification” is a lot of things they make are inputs; you hear about things like car bumpers and other types of product that go back and forth across the border.
We’re happy to hear the government wants us to pursue other diversification and other markets around the world, but that means more finished and semi-finished products; that means having to rethink how you diversify.
The smaller you are, the less room you have to maneuver. That’s what I hear all the time from manufacturers. It’s great to talk about going to the U.K., Argentina or South Korea, but how do we get there? The big thing we encourage the government to look at, especially if we want to look at other markets, is the trade harmonization piece, to make sure that regulatory standards — whether it’s labelling, whether it’s weights — or all those other pieces are standardized.
As you pointed out, it’s not a switch they can flip on overnight. For manufacturers, that’s been the challenge, and what keeps them up overnight trying to figure out: If I can’t sell to the U.S., if I have to look elsewhere to bolster and enhance my business, what does that look like? It’s still not clear to many manufacturers.
That’s where we and other industry associations come in and try to help them build from there.
Senator Downe: Thank you. Mr. Conley, in your remarks you mentioned you were at the thirtieth anniversary of the free trade agreement, but you recall it was very controversial at the time. The opponents of the agreement, at the time, said if this were agreed to, it would reduce Canada to nothing but an economic colony of the United States. That appears to be the current position of Donald Trump.
So, there may not be a deal. We may have to revert to the economy prior to a free trade agreement. And the convenience of dealing with our closest neighbour, and a significant economic force in the world, will be gone. Your members — I picked up from your presentation — very much want to deal as soon as possible. Setting that aside, do your members realize we may never revert to that?
Former Prime Minister Stephen Harper indicated Canada did the right thing walking away. Former Conservative Prime Minister Brian Mulroney had the deal agreed to at the time; things change.
How supportive are your members of the reality that we may not have a deal?
Mr. Conley: That’s an excellent question. Certainly, it’s one that we think about at CME all the time because of the diversity of our members.
To answer your question, absolutely; that’s something that is in the back of people’s minds. I think after the renewal came and went on July 1, and it wasn’t renewed, people started to wrap their heads around the fact of things being different. That was ramped up when the trade talks collapsed earlier last month.
You’re seeing a lot of manufacturers starting to look into that reality. Really, though, it depends on your vantage point of how you see that. If you’re a small business owner that sells 90% of their stuff to the U.S., that’s terrifying. That’s your business, your livelihood there. If you’re larger and have the ability to scale and diversify, you’re looking at your options. You’re calling up trade commissioners; you’re calling up banks to see how you can make things work? So it really depends.
The point in the last panel when you asked the question about does the association speak with one mind? We don’t, but that’s the beauty of the CME. We have manufacturers across the board that have different opinions. That’s why we bring them all together to make that voice.
But no question, the fact we may never get a deal is a reality that has come across.
Senator Downe: Part of it is the convenience of dealing with the United States. Similar culture, similar language, and so on. As I mentioned before, it’s easier to go to Boston to sell than it is to Argentina or South Korea. You can see a hockey game, a baseball game; it’s a lot of fun.
But that begs the question: Canada has signed all these free-trade agreements. What does the Government of Canada have to do to assist businesses to diversify more around the world? It’s been so easy to deal with the United States; it’s much harder. What can the government do to bridge that problem?
Mr. Conley: No question, we’re supportive of the free-trade agreements, and that’s great. The next step is regulatory harmonization, putting up the U.K. and Canadian standards and seeing how they align and how we make this simple. For a business owner, the business model needs to make sense of how they ship across the Atlantic.
Senator Adler: Pardon me, folks, if I get a little emotional about the auto industry, but in all the years I did media, I don’t know whether or not we would have had a private sector in media without the auto industry. Our major sponsors were auto dealers and other companies related to auto dealers. I have a particular fondness, if you don’t mind me saying so, for Mr. Volpe, who was one of our excellent guests over the years, giving us important information.
In the 1970s, there was no NAFTA or CUSMA but something called the Auto Pact. Are we at a point in our history where we might have to bite the bullet and see if we can negotiate an Auto Pact II if CUSMA is out of reach?
I don’t care which of our witnesses begins the response, but I’d like to get a response from all of the auto industry spokespeople here, if possible.
Mr. Volpe: I appreciate the question, senator. It’s good to be interviewed in person for once. Good to see you here in the Senate.
The idea that we might go back to an Auto Pact, or could we go back to an Auto Pact, assumes your counterparty wants to do that? Currently, the White House doesn’t want to do that. That was a two-party deal. The NAFTA and the CUSMA are three-party deals. That third party has been good for Canadian business as well. Canadian parts suppliers have invested in 120 plants in Mexico with 60,000 employees because they’re customers. The OEMs went there to assemble, and it’s given an opportunity to be globally competitive and repatriate some of those profits. If Donald Trump changes his mind, then maybe there is something there, but that’s the biggest hurdle.
Senator Adler: Thank you. Mr. Kingston?
Mr. Kingston: Yes, if we have to pursue a more managed trade relationship with the U.S., based on production numbers and trying to balance trade, I think that’s an option.
Every indication to me is there is still a deal to be had. I’m not willing to give up on access to the U.S. market for simple reasons: U.S. exports are down 22% globally of autos; auto production is down in the U.S. 2%; automotive employment is down over 1% in the States; and vehicle prices are up 10.4%. Every single metric shows the tariffs the U.S. has put in place are not benefiting the U.S. auto industry.
For those reasons, I’m going to remain permanently optimistic that there’s a deal to be had. It may look like an Auto Pact, but we have to continue to negotiate. If that’s not available, we have to think of other options to use our market to ensure companies build here, but I don’t think we need to go there yet.
Senator Adler: Would the witness online like to comment on the idea of biting the bullet and trying, as much as possible, to simply have an auto agreement with the U.S.?
Mr. Sweeney: Reverting to an agreement that was signed in 1965, no matter how successful and productive that agreement was, I don’t think that’s our first choice. There are concepts in the Auto Pact, such as building where you sell and selling where you build, that we could leverage for the future, whether that’s part of the end goal — a return to a completely integrated North American trade agreement — or if it’s something that’s auto‑specific, preferably in the interim. But to snap right back to an Auto Pact — that is not our first choice. Returning to integrated free trade with the United States and Mexico is the ideal option.
The Chair: Thank you very much. We’re over time on that one.
Senator M. Deacon: Thank you all for being here, in person and virtually. I really appreciate that, as it is quite an impacted sector.
I asked a question yesterday, and I’m going to bring it back to the table today. Having heard of the importance of integration and the belief of some of the things we can do.
Yesterday, I asked the Canadian Chamber of Commerce about how damaged our auto sector is due to the trade war up to this point, as we look forward to the next six months. They indicated that the jury was still out, but there has, no doubt, been damage to the broader North American auto industry, which reflects some of the data you have shared.
Can either country’s auto sector survive globally alone, or, at this moment, is it possible American leadership is taking its own industry down and taking us with it?
Mr. Kingston: We need each other to survive, particularly as competition from China increases. China now has the capacity to build almost 50 million vehicles per year. They are swamping markets around the world that don’t put up barriers. If the U.S. is going to try to attract investment into its market by damaging Canada and Mexico, it will not be able to compete with the Chinese auto juggernaut. We do need to work together, and that is why CUSMA, as the foundation for the industry, is so critical.
Mr. Volpe: The Center for Automotive Research in Michigan estimates that about $180 billion of tariff costs will be borne by the industry over the course of three years. Those are costs without a return on investment. Those are costs that don’t flow down through the supply chain or go to workers, and they don’t go to the tax base in those communities that help to make a competitive industry and competitive workforces.
Chinese products are arriving, without North American content, into North American markets. Mr. Conley talked about the deal with Canada, but really, much more importantly, I just came back from Mexico City, and the numbers there are $600,000 per year. Whatever you might think about the Chinese and Chinese competition, there is no American content on those vehicles, and there is no American content on vehicles made in Japan, Korea or Europe that are sold into that region. Canadian cars have $29 billion worth of American components in them, assembled every year and then sold back to Americans. It is one market that reinforces itself. We can’t survive without the American market, but Donald Trump will sink Detroit in the interim.
Senator M. Deacon: I would welcome if anyone would like to put the icing on that.
Mr. Sweeney: I agree with Mr. Volpe and Mr. Kingston. An integrated North American auto industry and market is ideal, especially if we can do so in a way, over time — and this is in 10, 20 or 30 years — that grows a Mexican middle class that can consume vehicles and add more oomph to the buying power of North Americans.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: Mr. Volpe, in your introduction, you spoke about Canada’s industrial policy, the need to review it and, looking ahead, to build and rebuild infrastructure here that will enable industry to participate in what lies ahead. Do you feel that this call from industry is being heard by our authorities, by the government?
[English]
Mr. Volpe: Yes, I do. We’re pushing open doors in Ottawa, in all the places that are either involved in procurement or planning for forced armaments and in the departments that finance those purchases. But I think what we need to do is look specifically at the language of procurement, the language of our trade agreements and our WTO obligations and see how much we can push for that procurement to require Canadian content.
There is idle Canadian capacity in manufacturing and manipulation of metals, plastics, powertrains and complex systems that could carry your kids to school but also protect those who are charged with protecting us. Have me back in a year, and I’ll let you know where some of those procurements have landed and provide an assessment to those.
[Translation]
Senator Hébert: Thank you. Mr. Kingston, I admire your optimism about a potential agreement with our southern neighbours. Indeed, as things stand, it may happen one day — but that day may well be a long way off. The arguments you raised are gaining ground across the States, but the walls of the White House are more resistant. It is clear that the U.S. administration is rather impervious to these arguments and not particularly receptive to them.
I’ll come back to the question asked by my colleague Senator Downe. Are your members prepared for a potential outcome that won’t necessarily be the one we’d like?
[English]
Mr. Kingston: First, I would say that I do believe there is a world in which the White House reacts to some of the data that we’re seeing coming out. With respect to the increase in vehicle prices, I don’t think the American consumer signed up for that. You are starting to see some resistance to tariff policies.
History tells us the impacts of protectionism are very negative, but unfortunately, it takes time for the impacts to take root and for consumers to feel it. I think we are still seeing that play out in the U.S., but the pressure is mounting.
In the interim, we do need the government to act on some of the domestic policies to help shore up the sector. We cannot offset a $7 billion tariff cost — that is not possible — but there are things that could be done to help companies that are building here be more competitive and reduce their costs. We have EV mandates in B.C. and Quebec that have been very damaging, and we have forthcoming GHG regulations that could cost billions if they are not done correctly. Those are things you can do immediately.
If we’re talking long-term no access to the U.S. market, it is going to be a different industry. Ninety percent of what we build goes to the United States. You would not build an assembly plant here just to service the Canadian market. The industry will persist, but it will be smaller.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: Once again, welcome to this committee. There is no doubt that the U.S. market is the most accessible one for our manufacturers. It is the most integrated and the most cost-effective. However, the United States has implemented significant programs to support industrial investment in recent years. Many observers are questioning their implications for the competitiveness of Canada’s manufacturing sector. Apart from Stellantis, which has decided to relocate its production to Illinois in the United States, have you observed any other such moves?
[English]
Mr. Kingston: No, and despite the challenges the tariffs put on the industry — Ford, for example, has put $5 billion into Oakville to retool the plant and build heavy-duty vehicles. General Motors is retooling right now for heavy-duty capacity in Oshawa. We continue to see investments being made in the industry here despite the tariffs.
Now, of course, if tariffs are in place long term, that $7 billion cost grows, and it becomes commercially challenging to make a light-duty vehicle in Canada if 90% of your sales go to the United States. Companies will have to recalibrate to make sure they can manage that, but it is a 2 million vehicle market per year.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: Pardon me. Actually, I meant that the United States has introduced incentives for Canadian or foreign investors who decide to invest in the United States. There is the case of Stellantis, which has announced it is moving from Brampton to Illinois. Have you seen other such investments leaving Canada?
[English]
Mr. Kingston: I understand. No, and the reason is simple, and the number Mr. Volpe shared points to it.
Right now, because of the U.S. tariff policy, it’s not just tariffs on vehicles. It’s also tariffs on aluminum and steel. It is costly to manufacture vehicles in the United States, with an estimated cost of $180 billion, so there’s an idea that companies are moving to the U.S. because of these other policies, for example, tax deductions provided by the U.S. government, and that they are not creating a competitive environment for automotive manufacturing. As a result, over the long term, I think this will erode their competitiveness. That’s why we need to get back to CUSMA, and I think we will at some point.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: I understand. Thank you.
[English]
Senator Mohamed: Mr. Conley, I want to come back to your members and understand how the tariffs and countermeasures have impacted them. Have they made it more difficult? Have they increased some pressure? I’d like to get a sense of it because you are small- and medium-sized businesses, and often that has a disproportionate impact. I wonder if you might make some comments.
Mr. Conley: That’s an excellent question. Our members hate tariffs.
Any time that there’s any kind of adjustment, even from a logistical standpoint, it’s difficult because they have to call their broker and figure out if this applies to them. They have to look at government websites to figure out where the supplies are. That’s just time that they’re spending not growing their business and not building their company. Any time we see counter-tariffs, it creates challenges and pressures — not to mention the tariffs themselves.
For a lot of the members, even though they prefer that the government get back to the table and talk with the Americans, they want a good deal, not just any deal. That is at the heart of it. “No tariffs please” is the number one message we get.
Mr. Volpe: Let me put it in two buckets. The section 232 tariffs and the national security tariffs on Canadian autos that Canada countered U.S. imports on are important for protecting the Canadian market. It’s also important to make the distinction between the companies that manufacturer vehicles here but then buy parts from Canadian factories and employ Canadian workers so they have a remission scheme. For those that import into Canada from the United States, there should be no penalty directed at them but no benefit either. I thought that was very good.
On the next set of tariffs, the section 338 tariffs and the Canadian counters required on those, I’ll infer the intent of the U.S. Department of Commerce. They don’t talk to me. I think they tried to avoid auto-part tariffs and Harmonized System, or HS, codes for their own industries, but there were a lot of additional codes that were in there that have had a seven- or eight-figure impact on Canadian part suppliers. I raise it because we’ve been working very closely with Finance Canada on the Canadian measures to understand if there are issues here that hurt their competitiveness and ability. We want to work through what some of what the remedies are. The section 338 tariffs are a little hairier than the section 232 tariffs, but Finance Canada has been a very good partner.
Senator Mohamed: Thank you.
Senator Wilson: My question is for our automobile sector folks. You all said in your presentations that a deal is available or doable. I would be interested in what that deal looks like.
Mr. Volpe: The deal that was on the table that we walked away from last month had an effective tariff rate that was higher than the average profit margin for making cars, so that wasn’t a good deal. I wouldn’t go back to that deal. In an industry where the average profit margin is 6%, a 7% cost in access to markets means those companies, none of which are charities or state owned, sooner or later, are going to have a tariff bill that costs more than setting up a new assembly factory on the other side of the border. If we go back to the table, the effective rate has to be zero. But if we end up somewhere in the interim, it has to be below the profit margin, and none of those companies are headquartered in Canada. No one will make a hometown decision, and you can’t expect publicly traded companies to do that.
Mr. Kingston: The ideal outcome, of course, is a return to duty-free trade. That is the first priority. If it’s an interim deal to get us through this period of instability, it has to be a low tariff rate. I won’t give you a number because it depends on each manufacturer, what they build and their investment in Canada, but it would have to be an ultralow rate to ensure we could continue to build and export the volumes we have historically.
Mr. Sweeney: What is also important to consider in this is there is a tariff impact, as mentioned, on vehicle manufacturers in the United States. As long as that is happening, it’s important to remember that there’s a delta. There is a difference between the effective tariff rate we’re paying in Canada and the effective tariff rate that an equivalent assembly plant is paying in the U.S., and that is dynamic in the United States, and they have the Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price, or MSRP, credit to offset those costs.
The only way that Ms. Charette, or anyone else from the negotiating team can really understand what that effective tariff rate is, is to consult with the manufacturers directly because they are all in a slightly different position. Again, ideally, that tariff rate is zero, and there is a mechanism to get back to tariff-free trade of automotive products.
Senator Downe: My question is for Mr. Kingston. In Mr. Sweeney’s presentation, he indicated the companies that he represents produce about 900,000 vehicles in Canada, 80% of which they ship to the United States. We all want to have a good deal that works for the Canadian automotive industry, but that may not happen. You were critical of the government’s decision to allow Chinese electric vehicles into Canada, but I’m sure you understand the quid pro quo was that many in this agriculture sector were pleased with that deal. If the worst scenario is our automotive industry is wiped out, like Australia’s was, we will be in a position to trade access to our market for advantages in other countries and other industries, and hopefully, workers can translate their skills to the defence industry, and we can build that up and have capacity in that.
Your objection to the EV is simply they are not doing work here, but in many ways, are we not supporting an old industry as the world quickly moves to EV production? You look at places like Norway where over 90% of the vehicles are electric now. This might be an opportunity for the government to support electric vehicle production and be ahead of the United States when their craziness eventually ends. Do you see any opportunities there?
Mr. Kingston: Not with China. I am deeply skeptical of China being an investor in Canada for numerous reasons, but the first is they have massive overcapacity at home. That is why they are exporting and dumping vehicles around the world. Sales in their domestic market are collapsing now, and they have way too much capacity. The idea that they would see it in their commercial interest to build plants in Canada to replace the original equipment manufacturers that are here now is not realist. There are very serious concerns around cybersecurity and forced labour in the supply chain. Those have been well documented, so we need to be conscious of that.
Ultimately, I do believe that we need to make sure that if you want to protect a market and keep a manufacturing sector, you have to use the 2 million vehicle sale market we have as the incentive to do that. The government has just given free access to Chinese manufacturers that don’t employ people here. Who is taking advantage of that quota right now? It is mainly Tesla, the same company whose CEO yesterday came out and said that Alberta and Saskatchewan should separate from this country.
I don’t understand what the government’s objective is by giving that free access to companies that are not adding anything to the Canadian economy.
Senator Downe: As I said earlier, the agriculture sector was quite happy they had access to the Chinese market because we let the vehicles in. I assume the decision the government made was on that basis.
The Chair: I would like to go to Mr. Sweeney because your comments were invoked at the beginning of Senator Downe’s question, and I’d like to ask you if you have a comment.
Mr. Sweeney: We are similarly cautious about engaging with China, particularly if it means engaging with Tesla.
For the record, a majority of the vehicles that our members — Honda and Toyota — are making in Canada today are electrified. They’re hybrid electric; there’s a real battery in there. And they are in high demand throughout North America.
I’m in a 2026 RAV4. It was one of the first to come off the line in Cambridge, Ontario, earlier this year. I’m getting 4.9 litres for 100 kilometres; that is a real difference.
This allows us to lay the foundation for longer-term progress in this. Right now there are substantial investments in vehicle electrification in Canada by the companies that are and have been making vehicles in Canada for decades.
The Chair: Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Gerba: My question is for Mr. Conley. Small- and medium-sized businesses make up the majority of Canadian businesses. However, only a minority — 15% — engage in international trade. What barriers do your members, the small- and medium-sized manufacturers, report to you when they are trying to increase their exports?
Mr. Conley: Manufacturing companies look at a number of factors when they consider engaging in international trade.
First, ports, trains and transportation vehicles to export products, but also regulatory issues. We need more harmonization with other countries to facilitate that. Those are the biggest barriers. Often, too, we have to find partners and buyers for the products.
There are opportunities, but many small businesses don’t necessarily have the resources to take advantage of them.
Senator Gerba: Could this committee help you send a message to the government? If so, what would the message be?
Mr. Conley: It would be to harmonize regulations, which is the most important thing. Of course, we like free trade agreements; that’s the first step. However, the next step is to create a business environment that allows those businesses to see which markets are within their reach.
Senator Gerba: We have agreements with almost every region of the world. Are your members aware of the agreements we’ve signed with other parts of the world, such as the Indo-Pacific or Europe?
Mr. Conley: Not really. Small businesses don’t have time to review the texts. We talk a lot to the Department of International Trade, asking it to make these texts more accessible, to provide a guide showing the business opportunities. Businesses need to see that this is a possibility, that this is something they can do. That’s one of the biggest challenges.
Senator Gerba: Thank you very much.
[English]
Senator Wilson: I have two questions. I’m not sure if we’ll have time to get to the second one.
The first is a variation of Senator Downe’s in relation to EVs. With the movement toward electric vehicles globally, does the U.S. administration’s, let’s call it, suppression of electric vehicle manufacturing put us at a competitive disadvantage in the future because we’re losing that capacity, knowledge and development here in North America?
Mr. Kingston: I actually think it creates an opportunity. If there’s one thing we’ve learned over the past decade from the way U.S. policy toward vehicles and emissions has been working, the U.S. has been following a sort of whiplash pattern. You get a Democrat President that puts in EV mandates or extremely stringent tail pipe regulations. Then the government changes, they get rid of them, and the industry has to continue to respond to that. That’s very problematic. Auto is a long lead-time industry. Billions of dollars deployed on your production plans.
It would be very helpful for the North American sector if we had a more reasonable and predictable approach to emissions and electrification that doesn’t go from extreme to extreme.
I mentioned the GHG regs here in Canada. They need to be achievable and something the companies can comply with. We need some sort of stability. We just had an EV mandate the government put on and then repealed because they realized it wasn’t going to work. That’s not the right path.
We are going to electrify. The industry is electrifying. It’s a bit slower in North America than in other parts of the world. Let’s put forward a plan that actually works for the industry and consumers and fund it. I think we will be well positioned, particularly given our mineral advantages.
Mr. Volpe: To Senator Downe’s question, and your comment about the industry in the past and future, the “V” in EV is vehicle.
Seventy-five percent of vehicles made by part suppliers end up in these massive, jigsaw-puzzle assembly plant assemblers put together. I say that because I know all the components that go into a vehicle, and I represent the entire supply chain.
We built Project Arrow as a demonstration. A designed, engineered, fully Canadian electric vehicle to say, what can we do? Who can do it? Who can I point their customers to?
There isn’t anything particularly exotic or new about Chinese electric vehicles that weren’t exotic or new in the 1990’s when GM made the EV1, or when the New York City cabs in the 2010’s and the 2020’s were made electric.
What we’re missing, and the biggest opportunity we’re missing, is if we get manufacturing locally — and that means continentally — then we have a path that is profitable for mineral extraction and processing to make cells that go into batteries that platform the technologies that we are world-leading in — from the KW, from Ottawa, Montreal, and Edmonton, that go on electric vehicles because they are 400 or 800 volt platforms.
If we concede that market to cars assembled somewhere else, we not only double down on the fact that Donald Trump has abandoned the opportunity to build them locally, but we give them away to someone who doesn’t buy them from us. That’s the challenge.
Senator Woo: Sorry for coming in and out. I have been toggling between this meeting and a meeting across the street where I’ve been hearing from EV manufacturers. They tell me they have been speaking with Chinese manufacturers who have an interest in assembly plants here and setting up manufacturing facilities.
Maybe they’re dreaming, but I’m trying to square the circle. My question for Mr. Kingston is whether you have had direct conversations with Chinese EV manufacturers, serious discussions about their interest in investing, in setting up supply chains and creating at least a genesis of a different kind of industry? Yes, vehicles are vehicles, but a different kind of industry that could, over time, augment and maybe supplant the old, internal combustion engine industry?
Mr. Kingston: No, I have not had direct conversations with those companies. They have approached and asked about the market, but they want market access. They don’t want to build here.
Senator Woo: Have you spoken to them about the possibility?
Mr. Kingston: No, that is not part of my job description.
Senator Woo: So you wouldn’t know?
Mr. Kingston: I do know, because I look at Europe and see what’s happening there.
Senator Woo: Spain?
Mr. Kingston: Yes, but those are kits. If we look at Chinese OEMs. When they invest abroad and build plants, they will do so through a kit. Their cost advantage is based off of low-labour wages in China. They’re not going to come here and build a plant with UNIFOR unionized labour. That is completely off the table and outside of the Chinese OEM model. I’m highly skeptical they would replace what we have here now.
Mr. Volpe: I have spoken, and continue to speak with, Chinese OEMs over the past decade. Exports from China in 2020 were under 1 million cars; last year there were 7 million cars.
The domestic market in China, this year, collapsed. Domestic demand collapsed by 6 million.
The objective of Chinese automakers is to find a consumer for their products. Their negotiations with different markets are about access and/or partial assembly, then send kits — think about Ikea — and then move the products that they’ve made. They’re not looking at this market and saying, “I’m going to manufacture a full-scale assembly plant here, 150,000 to 250,000 cars.” None of them have said that. They’re also not saying that because it doesn’t look as if they can get access to the U.S. market, which goes back to the same problem and the challenges that Canadian automakers have here.
What is also critically important to understand is, whether these cars come in parts, as kits or as fully assembled vehicles, the battery, which is the biggest commercial opportunity for a manufacturer in the electrification of vehicles, is 100% assembled in China with Chinese raw materials. Canada’s best opportunity in the electrification of the vehicle market is to make the business case for extraction, processing and assembly as a counter, a potential option for the Chinese.
We can remind consumers that there are battery-electric vehicles and electrified hybrid vehicles made in Canada. There’s also a project there that I would love to support from enthusiasts who want to throw money at Canadianizing us.
Bring them in. Whether they’re from China or coming in from Korea, there are a lot of Korean EV sales in this country that have no Canadian content or batteries in them. The reason the government said “let’s electrify” is to make the case on the critical minerals side, and we can’t make it by giving away the market to pure importers, regardless of whether they —
The Chair: Thank you very much. I’m sorry to interrupt you, Mr. Volpe, but we’re overtime in the meeting itself.
On behalf of the committee, I’d like to thank Matt Conley, Brian Kingston, Flavio Volpe and Brendan Sweeney for being great witnesses for us today. This is a very important subject we’re addressing, and I fully expect we’ll have you back in the future. Thank you very much.
(The committee adjourned.)