THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLES
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Wednesday, October 28, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples met this day at 6:44 p.m. [ET] to examine and report on the Voices of Youth Indigenous Leaders events.
Senator Michèle Audette (Chair) in the chair.
[Translation]
The Chair: Before we begin our work this evening, I encourage everyone to silence their cellphones. Let’s also make sure we take care of our interpreters. I would ask everyone to avoid putting their earpieces, cellphones and laptops too close to the microphones. Thank you for your cooperation.
[Innu-aimun spoken]
I want to thank the Anishinaabe people for hosting us on their unceded territory, shared with other First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples, as well as everyone who has chosen to call this place home.
[English]
My name is Michèle Audette. I am from Quebec, and I am the Chair of the Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples. I wish to invite committee members participating in today’s meeting to introduce themselves.
Senator Prosper: Paul Prosper, Nova Scotia, Mi’kma’ki territory.
Senator Martin: Good evening. Yonah Martin from British Columbia.
Senator Pate: Hi. Kim Pate. I live here in the unceded, unsurrendered and, as we heard, unconquered as well as unreturned territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabeg people.
Senator Karetak-Lindell: Nancy Karetak-Lindell, Nunavut.
Senator Clement: Bernadette Clement, Ontario, more specifically Cornwall, on traditional Haudenosaunee and Mohawk territory.
Senator Tannas: I am Scott Tannas from High River, Alberta, the southern part of the province.
Senator Francis: Brian Francis, Epekwitk, Prince Edward Island.
Senator Sorensen: Karen Sorensen, Alberta, Banff National Park, Treaty 7 territory.
Senator Greenwood: Margo Greenwood, British Columbia.
[Translation]
The Chair: I would like to welcome everyone watching us on Senate ParlVU today, all the Canadians and the family members of the young leaders who are here with us.
Today we have the pleasure of welcoming a number of Indigenous youth from across the country as part of the 2026 edition of the Voices of Youth Indigenous Leaders program.
This annual event aims to amplify the perspectives and experiences of young First Nations, Inuit and Métis leaders, aged 18 to 35, who are driving meaningful change in their communities and beyond. The evidence gathered today will help inform the committee’s ongoing work.
We heard some very moving testimony from a number of participants this morning.
We will now continue with the next panel. Our colleagues will have an opportunity to ask questions once you have finished your presentations. Since we have a large group this evening, my fellow senators will have a shorter period of time to ask questions.
[English]
Our first witness at the table this evening is Dreyden George. Dreyden is from T’Sou-ke First Nation on Vancouver Island. I now invite Dreyden to give his opening remarks.
Dreyden George, as an individual: Good evening, everyone. My name is Dreyden George. I use he/him pronouns. I am from T’Sou-ke Nation within the Douglas Treaties, located in Coast Salish territory, also known as southern Vancouver Island, B.C.
I grew up and learned on our lands my entire life, where I had the opportunity to stay connected with and grow from my Elders’ teachings and family support. The values I hold of Indigenous rights being upheld, stewarding the land and being holistic in my perspective within the world came strongly from the teachings of my family and Elders.
I currently work to exercise and uphold these values within the current roles I have the privilege to hold. Within my nation’s community, I serve as the president and chair of the board for DAXET Development Corporation. It is our community’s economic development corporation. I further serve in that role for its subsidiaries, including CEK SNANET, TXIT, Neka Sol, and Cacet-IDL, which operate a gas station and convenience store, an aquaculture farm, a woodlot and a contracting company, respectively. We currently employ over 20 nation members, with additional members employed in contract roles across the area through our contracting company.
In my time here today, I would like to highlight the importance of helping build Indigenous-led economic improvement to address conditions that are faced on reserves. Many federal investments help Indigenous communities participate in economic activity, but fewer create conditions for long-term Indigenous ownership and wealth generation.
For example, while the Indigenous Loan Guarantee Program is a significant step, Indigenous communities often need equity, advisory support and investment readiness funding before they can take advantage of large-scale ownership opportunities.
Access to capital has historically been limited by barriers linked to the Indian Act and restrictions on using reserve lands as collateral. Further, access to long-term grant funding commitments is often unsecured or uncommitted from the government, leaving economic development planning to be on year-to-year cycles and communities not able to fully participate in needed long-term and higher-view economic planning at the nation level.
It is also important to highlight the current challenges within the economic development capacity of nations. There are very few frameworks and little guidance or legislative support for how nation members can properly register and operate businesses within nations.
Currently, many nations, including my own, do not have laws enacted or in place for business permitting, member-owned commercial development on treaty land nor how to open and start a small business on reserves. Oddly, I find more resources from the government and business associations on how non‑member and privately owned businesses can start business partnerships or operations on nation lands but almost nothing on Indigenous Peoples who want to become entrepreneurs for their community.
As an economic development organization concerned with key indicators of employment, financial health, health care participation and generational wealth, the lack of guidance or alignment as to how one would start a business on-reserve as a member is a challenge to our ability to assist in economic development that is Indigenous-driven.
Key challenges and questions arise for members. How is taxation affected? Who is responsible for permitting certain activities? What industry requirements and regulations are applied? Instead, what seemingly happens is nations accept perceptually “ideal” employment and profit-sharing agreements for non-Indigenous innovated or invented business models. These, at the same time, often contradict the responsibility of providing stewardship of the land.
It becomes a bleak choice for nations. In reality, they either can accept business and large commercial offers, often without legal or professional support to ensure they have appropriate assessments, for development advancements in their nation and for their members that often challenge land values, or they ignore them but then continually face the economic disparities we see today around income, employment, housing and education.
I recommend we look at expanding Indigenous equity financing programs beyond loan guarantees and establish a permanent Indigenous sovereign wealth fund to support community ownership of major projects.
Further, there needs to be the development of frameworks for nations to be aware of the implications and guidelines for developing commercial legislation in their nations.
Lastly, there have to be expanded efforts on federally invested and collaborated projects that do not see Indigenous communities as just resource partners. Indigenous communities should have the ability and opportunity to develop their own economic prosperity within their lands, and that should not require giving up their land rights or forgoing values toward land stewardship. In the current climate, nations see pipelines, mining and land exploitative projects, while rarely seeing any engagements in other sectors of business.
I now want to shift to my second topic and to speak to you as a student at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario. I’m currently studying economics and environmental studies. Being a university student is one of the most rewarding endeavours I have committed myself to.
This year I serve as the Alma Mater Society President and the representative and voice for over 21,000 undergraduate students. We employ over 600 paid student positions and 200 volunteer positions across 20 departments.
As the Alma Mater Society is the student government at Queen’s University, I work directly with Indigenous students, clubs and university staff and faculty to learn about the issues facing our Indigenous post-secondary students.
Therefore, I would like to quickly speak to the need for the federal government to increase investment in the Post-Secondary Student Support Program to address the funding gap. This is needed to adequately support Indigenous students.
Further, Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada should provide post-secondary institutions comprehensive documents outlining the intricacies of band funding and its relation to treaty rights, fund distribution and the choice of First Nations to provide financial support to their students.
A common factor I notice within the higher administration of publicly funded universities is explaining what I would presume is basic knowledge of the treaty system, particularly the funding process for status and sponsored students.
Lastly, Indigenous Services Canada, or ISC, should develop guidelines for post-secondary institutions to ensure access to post-secondary offered financial aid and support for all Indigenous students.
Many institutions, including my own up until recently, had not properly considered band sponsorship in their funding formulas for financial aid based on financial need.
I appreciate everyone’s time and the members of the committee for allowing me to speak today. I look forward to your questions.
Thank you. [Indigenous language spoken].
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much for your presentation. I invite you to use the earpiece for the French translation, Mr. George, because I will be chairing the meeting in French.
Do any senators have questions for our witness?
[English]
Senator Martin: Welcome to a fellow British Columbian, Mr. George. First of all, Dreyden, I missed the events of the day because of my schedule, but it is very nice to be the first questioner to a fellow British Columbian. I’m happy to see you here. Your presentation was packed with so much information, so I’m hoping to unpack some of that with a little more explanation.
You have a very impressive mini-bio here. Would you tell me about being chair and president of DAXET Development Corporation and your role on the Lands Advisory Board?
Obviously, you’re in school now, but I would love to hear more about the leadership role in B.C. you have taken to date.
Mr. George: Thank you for the question. As the chair and president of the DAXET Development Corporation, the main role is to report to the shareholders, which are the Chief and council, who hold the shares on behalf of the community of T’Sou-ke.
Outside of convening the typical board meeting business, I ensure we look at how we are implementing the Chief and council’s strategic vision in the economic subsidiaries that we have and then also the larger economic strategy of T’Sou-ke.
In regard to the Lands Advisory Board, I sit as chair and convene meetings and things like that. The Land Advisory Board, under the land code for T’Sou-ke, is where we make decisions that advise the Chief and council on how they choose to do zoning, allotments of lands or the long-term development of land, whether residential or commercial.
We also look at environmental emergency planning and environmental impact assessments on the reserve to make sure we are ready for housing development. Generally, anything lands based goes through that advisory board to ensure it has community engagement, as it is composed of community members, before it goes to the Chief and council.
Senator Martin: I don’t have any of these skills. You are demonstrating such incredible leadership already. I am looking at your major. Is it economics and environmental studies?
Mr. George: Yes.
Senator Martin: It’s just perfectly suited to what you have done. Can you share, from your studies, what you will take back and what are some areas you really want to improve when you finish your studies?
Mr. George: In regard to the transferability of my studies to the economy of T’Sou-ke, so to speak, I typically try to learn not just through academics but also professional development opportunities. Being the president of a student government provides a lot of opportunities to be able to understand how job relations work. We have over 10 services. We get to see the implications of improving employment opportunities for students and how that affects the student experience at university. I mirror that in T’Sou-ke.
Outside of that and in my economics degree, I usually like to focus on the critiquing side. That’s less so what benefits need to go into T’Sou-ke but the negative parts that T’Sou-ke should be avoiding in regard to traditional economic models or those that are more prominent within Canada.
That’s usually where I try to take most of my learning outside of the roles I have within Queen’s University.
Senator Pate: Welcome. Thank you very much for that. I am very interested in more information about the types of funding arrangements you think would be most beneficial for Indigenous young people.
Full disclosure, I personally think we should have free post‑secondary education. Then we would see, as in those countries that do, overall a far more educated and generally more informed population and, therefore, a more caring country. But that’s the world according to me, not you.
I’m interested in what you think and, in addition to what you have said, would recommend we look at in terms of the types of supports that would really assist young people you know who may not otherwise be going to school right now get an opportunity for post-secondary.
Mr. George: I think it is a bit of a twofold question. First, I would agree with your take on universal education. That would be super important.
In that regard, the Post-Secondary Student Support Program, or PSSSP, is built to not be universal and is inherently capped and competitive in its allocation, so members have to compete with each other based on their education. The aspect of trying to improve or address the disparity of educational outcomes for Indigenous People is, actually, innately not solved through that outcome.
That leads into the twofold part, which is, with regard to getting people into post-secondary education, that the biggest barrier is not once you graduate; it is leading up to high school and much earlier than that. If you are stressing about taking care of your family and your loved ones, making sure you have food on your table, finding where you are going to be sleeping the next day and stuff like that, it gets very hard to figure out or try to persevere with university or that path. There are many times when you think of just not doing that because it is a lot of work outside of that. Additionally, there is the financial component of getting into university.
I think I spent over $2,000 on application fees when I was trying to apply. There are a lot of hidden costs outside of tuition and books that make it hard for students to get to university and travel to university. But before that, much earlier in life, they might typically be in a socio-economic place that makes them not feel the confidence, the motivation or the encouragement by society around them to be able to attend.
Senator Prosper: Thank you, Mr. George, for being here.
Earlier in your testimony, you talked about how there were certain teachings from family and Elders that helped guide you, and I think you mentioned that you learned on the land your entire life. In part of your biography here, your statement says that you foster youth leadership and allow them to help recognize their own strengths.
Can you further expand upon some of those? Can you just delve a bit into those teachings and that experience you had growing up and how that allows you to occupy the space you do now in helping youth?
Mr. George: Thank you for the question. With regard to the teachings, my family’s teachings are very land-based, I would say, as many Indigenous cultures are, and they are very much about understanding the entire life cycle of when you are on the land and how you are affecting the water, the air and the land around you and making sure that you are thinking of the seven generations ahead.
With regard to specific values, it is about making sure that we see each other as a communal kind of resource, like a my‑success-is-your-success and your-success-is-my-success type of logic, instead of what can be a bit more possibly deceitful or selfish, in my opinion, in terms of how we approach certain topics or areas of policy.
With regard to how my family raised me, it was a lot around caring. I was raised in a house full of women. My dad was a fisherman, so he was out, oftentimes, for a month. It was mainly my sister, my girl cousin and my auntie who took care of me. In addition to my grandmothers, they have a major impact on my outlook on the world and the passion that drives me. That made me more confident in wanting to pursue more career paths.
My family was very adamant that I continue on the path of education and try to learn more about economics and things like that. I was the first one in my family to go to university. I take their values and their motivation into trying to get this education.
I also view it that my education is paid for by my community as a band-sponsored student, so it is my responsibility to make sure I am bringing that back and trying to have the biggest impact on the community.
Senator Prosper: Thank you.
Senator Clement: Hi. Thank you for being here.
Thank you to all the senators who introduced you, too, in the chamber and for the standing ovation. I thought that was a good moment for you but also for us. Thank you.
I was struck by what you were saying in terms of, when you are First Nations and into economic development, it is not just about resources.
I wonder if you could say more about other types of businesses that are, maybe, being held back by the bureaucracy that you talked about and what a community would look like once it has that better diversity of businesses.
Mr. George: When we are looking at businesses outside of resource extraction or development, in general, there is also a second one, which is tourism. That is a common one in Indigenous communities. But there are others around retail, manufacturing, hospitality and things like that and also, I would say, most importantly, professional services.
I recall the remarks about the North, for example. A lot of times costs get exacerbated. You have to pay for services that are down south because there isn’t a particular person with a certain degree or certification to do certain assessments and things like that, so then it increases the costs.
Those are examples of where not having that knowledge by our members in the community makes it so it is incrementally more expensive for us to do our own development. It also means that we are not able to circulate that money back into our T’Sou‑ke economy.
The challenge with not having diversified businesses is that, generally, you’re not able to fully situate yourself on the reserve. You have to make sure you are stretching yourself, depending on where your reserve is located.
In my reserve’s case, I am lucky to be in a town with a school and things like that right next to it. But there is not, of course, a hospital or anything, so we would have to drive and locate that. But it even gets more, I would say, bleak when you are going further north or more rural to try to make sure you have access to essential public services, and that is from a lack of having basic things, such as enough gas stations and hospitality, restaurants or professional services that provide higher-paying jobs. With those, that can mean that people have a proper, self-sustaining life on the reserve without having to go to a bigger city to be able to achieve those types of professional outcomes.
Senator Clement: One last thing: You were elected as the first president of the student body, right?
Mr. George: The first Indigenous president.
Senator Clement: The first Indigenous president. What is that like? I know there is good stuff to that. Are there challenging pieces to being the first?
Mr. George: I would say I am quite normalized to it. Usually, I was the first in a lot of rooms or the only, and if not the first, I was the second or something but still the only one. I guess the challenge is mostly trying to navigate that and making sure I’m not trying to speak as a monolith for Indigenous people. From a president’s point of view, it is about amplifying and centralizing other people’s voices and trying to lift them up to be able to have a particular perspective in decision-making rooms that might not have been there.
Additionally, of course, it is taking my own personal experience and trying to identify where there are oftentimes a lack of Indigenous representation, engagement and things like that with regard to academic policy and how grants are processed.
It is a lot of minute, little things that are often just overlooked because an Indigenous person wasn’t in the room or, at least, an Indigenous community was not engaged in the process.
[Translation]
The Chair: There are other senators who would like to ask questions. I would like to reassure the other panellists.
[English]
If possible, wrap up in 30 seconds, and then we will go to other senators.
Mr. George: Regarding the difficulties with being the first Indigenous president, I think it would be largely within any role of being the first. It is usually just the pressure of feeling as if you are making sure, first, that there will still be others coming after that but also, second, that in your time you are actually doing an adequate job in trying to represent Indigenous People or trying to push their voices and perspectives.
Senator Francis: Beyond increasing financial support or making it free, what are the top one to three actions the federal government should take to help First Nations students not only access education but also thrive from primary school through post-secondary studies?
Mr. George: Increase the Canada Student Grant, the federal one specifically. I study in Ontario, where the funding system is getting more difficult financially for students, especially if you do not have financial wealth going into university. It will be difficult upon graduating to pay back the Ontario Student Assistance Program, or OSAP, loans. If the federal government can help out, it will help the majority of students.
Other than that, increase the PSSSP funding. That one is underfunded. I would suggest looking at the delineation of the funding. For example, how much is going toward a living allowance? Because I go to school in Ontario but live in B.C., I’m ineligible for B.C. funding, but because I was not an Ontario resident before my time at school, I’m not eligible for Ontario funding. Any funding I receive has to be through Indspire, the New Relationship Trust and programs like that. The federal government should probably have a framework that provides guidance for measures to ensure we’re not excluding people or making people ineligible for financial aid based on band funding or treaty rights that are supposed to be entitled to them.
Senator Francis: Thank you.
Senator Martin: The question I had was one that Senator Prosper asked you about the Elders and teachers you had. You are very articulate. I have been listening to your responses.
You have been elected president. I know you have these leadership roles. I do not know if you serve on an elected council. Have you ever served on an elected council? Is that something you have thought about? Is politics on your radar? You are very well spoken and quite well rounded. Economics is a great foundation for politics, so I was curious about what is in your future.
Mr. George: First of all, I appreciate the compliments. Thank you. Ideally, at one point, I would like to run for Chief or council in my community.
My main goal is within the economic development realm. While I’m doing that, I would like to start my own business. Ultimately, my dream goal would be to serve as Chief or on council or, on the economic development side of things, as CEO and to have a business that makes passive income that I can put toward investing in my cousins’, nephews’ and nieces’ business ideas. In some sense, that would be capital investment but on a much smaller scale, I would say. That is the long-term view.
My grandma often says that I will end up as a politician, not in a positive tone. I would say that it is definitely not off the table. It is more about what I feel will have the biggest impact on my community and for long-term generational wealth.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. You might not be involved in politics right now, but I definitely see you becoming chief one day and telling Indigenous Services Canada that education is the key to lifting us out of poverty and dependency, and to achieving self-government. I would love to see you serving as chief and bringing about these changes in Ottawa. We will support you with bills and amendments.
[English]
I hope to see you as a Chief.
[Translation]
Thank you, Mr. George.
I’m going to move on to our next witness, Trinity Lafford-Desmond, who is from Paqtnkek Mi’kmaw First Nation in Nova Scotia, the same community as our colleague Senator Prosper.
Please go ahead, Trinity, with your opening remarks. Thank you.
[English]
Senator Prosper is very proud.
Trinity Lafford-Desmond, as an individual: [Indigenous language spoken]
Hello. My name is Trinity Lafford-Desmond. I am from Paqtnkek First Nation, Nova Scotia, and I identify as both Mi’kmaq and African Nova Scotian. I am currently a third-year electrical engineering student at Dalhousie University.
I am going to speak about the barriers I have faced in education and how those experiences have shaped my understanding of leadership and supporting Indigenous youth.
I graduated high school during peak COVID-19, in 2020, and began my engineering education online. The following year, I switched to a community college to pursue marine engineering. I was the only woman and Indigenous person in my class. I experienced several instances of racism and sexism from both instructors and classmates. I repeatedly spoke up about these issues because I wanted a more inclusive learning environment. However, my concerns were often ignored, and little changed.
The same challenges continued during my work terms. My skills were frequently questioned, and I struggled to feel respected in an environment where my co-workers were predominantly white men. Eventually, I decided to leave. I had one semester left in my program. I had received excellent grades that year — probably my best grades — and had multiple job opportunities. A faculty member even called to ask me to return. But I knew that going back would negatively affect my mental health.
Leaving was difficult. I had put years into my education, and I questioned whether I still had a future in engineering. After leaving marine engineering, I worked in solar installation and design. Through this work, I contributed to renewable energy projects in Mi’kmaw communities across Nova Scotia, including my own community of Paqtnkek.
Seeing how my engineering skills could benefit my own people gave me a renewed sense of purpose. I began to see engineering as more than a career; it was a way to contribute to my community and the future of Mi’kma’ki. This experience encouraged me to return to school and continue my electrical engineering degree.
Last summer, I also had the opportunity to work with X‑Project and Connecting Math to Our Lives and Communities with St. Francis Xavier University, helping to introduce Mi’kmaw and African Nova Scotian youth to science, technology, engineering and mathematics, or STEM, through workshops, activities, community visits and summer camps.
I helped youth explore STEM and learn about opportunities in post-secondary education. I was also able to share my own experiences as an Indigenous woman in engineering and answer questions about university.
This experience showed me how important it is for young people to see people like themselves in these fields. It is important for youth to have opportunities to explore their interests, build confidence and understand how their skills can benefit their communities.
I want young people to have the encouragement and support I needed when I was younger. I want them to know that they belong in STEM and that they can become leaders without having to sacrifice their well-being to get there.
My experiences have taught me that ability alone is not enough. Young people also need safe, respectful environments where they feel heard and supported. I believe institutions need clear processes for addressing racism and discrimination. When students speak up, their concerns should be taken seriously, and there should be accountability when those concerns are ignored.
Indigenous youth also need access to mentors, financial support and meaningful opportunities to participate in decisions that affect their communities. Their voices should be included from the beginning, not only after decisions have already been made.
My journey has not been straightforward. I left one engineering program, found my purpose through renewable energy work in my community and returned to pursue my degree. Now, through experiences like X-Project, I have the opportunity to help other youth see what is possible for themselves.
Indigenous youth have the ability to lead. We need to make sure they have the support, opportunities and safe environments to do so.
Wela’lin. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much.
[English]
Senator Sorensen: I am intrigued by your work with both Mi’kmaw and African Nova Scotian communities. Can you tell us about what these communities learn from one another or how you find commonality when you are working in each of those communities, overcoming historic discrimination and creating opportunities for future generations?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Thank you for your question. We have so much in common — it is insane — down to our humour, the way we interact with one another and hold our Elders at a high place.
I find the kids got along great with one another. We all know what it is like to be the only person of colour in a room. We all know what it is like to face discrimination. It is so beautiful how we are able to turn that around and make connections with one another and even find some humour in those situations.
Senator Sorensen: Tell me more about your work when you were engaged with a solar energy company installing and designing systems for Indigenous communities. Were the companies doing the installations target marketing to Indigenous communities? Was there an opportunity that you saw with the company that you were working for? How did that come about?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: They were installing the panels through government funding.
Senator Sorensen: Okay.
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: I had been looking for job opportunities for the summer. I saw they were hiring installers, which requires no experience. It is like working in construction. I was involved with them for one summer. We worked all over Nova Scotia, working from ground mounts to residential homes.
For the next summer, since I was in the engineering program, they hired me on their design team, where I was in the office working to create engineering drawings, plans and mapping out areas for the installation.
Senator Sorensen: I wish to say, personally, that maybe I should not be surprised there is still discrimination in this country, but I believed somehow that a university environment would be the least likely to have that discrimination occur. It is very sad, and I am sorry that has been your experience in an educational institution.
Senator Prosper: It is so nice to see you, Trinity. Thank you for sharing your story about being at an institution, facing several incidents of racism and sexism, having your best marks but deciding to leave for the sake of your mental well-being. It can be traumatic for many. You shifted. You pivoted. You started to get into, as you said, installing and designing solar systems, and, through the course of that, you decided to go back and pursue your education.
Was there something about that experience of working in Mi’kmaw communities, with the installation and design of solar systems, that got you to think about education again?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Usually, in engineering, it is very rare to have the opportunity to work in your own community, especially an Indigenous community. It was great to see the impact it had on people. Energy poverty is a big issue in Nova Scotia. Seeing people gaining that independence back through our work made me hopeful.
I’m funded by my band to go to school, and to be able to bring that back is so great.
Senator Prosper: There are so many who are proud. Thank you.
Senator Pate: One of the racist interpretations that many in this country have is that every Indigenous person could get a university or a college education if they wanted to because it is funded. Most of us around the table know that’s not true. Could you spell out a bit more what it means to get band support? How many people can be funded from your community at one time? I know it varies across the country.
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: This year only 11 students were funded by my band. Other students were denied and had to receive funding from different organizations.
It is special for me to be funded. I am very grateful. Even though we have the funding, that is only the first step. Getting to school and sitting in a classroom where you are the only Indigenous person and having that impostor’s syndrome — it never goes away. You are fighting it every day. Maintaining good grades while also battling that makes it 10 times harder.
That is all I have to say.
Senator Pate: Thank you.
Senator Clement: Thank you for being here. Thank you for talking so openly about mental health and also about your intersectionality. It is a superpower, but it is also something that can be challenging as well.
I have a couple of questions. I feel like, in these days of economic crises and unreliable — I will not quote Chrystia Freeland’s book — presidents, there is a move away from talking about anti-Black racism and reconciliation. How do you deal with that? That is the first part of my question.
The second part is this. I myself am a Black Canadian. Sometimes I feel like the system tells me there’s not enough for everybody. Some of my communities feel pitted against Indigenous communities in the sense that they are competing for resources and things. Do you ever feel that? Is there something you would do? How would you respond to that? There are two parts.
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Identifying as both Mi’kmaw and Black, there is a little bit of trying to balance that. I’m definitely more connected to my Indigenous side, as I live on-reserve. I have always lived on-reserve. I have stronger ties to my Indigenous family.
Sometimes it feels like, “Oh, I’m not Indigenous enough in certain situations,” or, in other situations, “I’m not Black enough.” It’s about having that balance, pulling from both sides and combining them to say, “I am me. I don’t have to be a certain way because of who I identify as.” I would say that about my intersectionality.
Sorry; what was the second part of your question?
Senator Clement: What do you think about the fact that anti-Black racism and reconciliation are perhaps taking a back seat to the economic talk? What would you want us to do about that, or what do you want to hear as a response?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Can I get back to you on that? I would have to think about that.
Senator Clement: Sure. The next point was: You were talking, in response to Senator Sorensen, about working in Black and African Nova Scotian communities and Indigenous communities. Do you ever feel like they are pitted against one another? Do you feel they could learn from one another as allies?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: In my community, there is a large Black population. There are many mixed kids in my community. I feel we have these ties that go back so far.
My great-grandfather, who was Black, used to be a bus driver for the community. When we have funerals or salites, people from the Black side of my family will come down to donate. We have so many ties to one another that I have never felt like we have been pitted against one another. I feel like we work well together.
Senator Clement: Thank you.
Senator Martin: Thank you for sharing your personal journey with us this evening.
I wanted to share with you that my daughter is from a mixed marriage. If you look at me, I’m an Asian woman. My husband is Caucasian. His great-great-grandmother was a princess from the Walla Walla Nation. I believe he is one sixteenth.
She would be in Asian circles and not look Asian, and then she would be with Caucasians and definitely look Asian. She was in‑between. I remember people would say that she is half-Korean.
I heard something that was helpful to me. We all get these definitions imposed on us. What I taught her and what I had learned is that she is 100% Korean — it’s in her DNA; she is a product of the two — and she is 100% Canadian. She is as strong as two people. It is not half-and-half but whole-and-whole. Now she has that sense of identity that I think is so important. I wanted to share that with you.
I want to talk about what you said about role models and how important they are. All of you are here, and I see the leadership ability in you and the greater potential as well. Why is there a lack of role models, perhaps, at this time? Do you see yourself as a role model? How will this experience and other things you have overcome allow you to be that role model? Do you play that role in some of the places you go at this time?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Yes, I definitely see myself as a role model. I really try to emulate someone that I would want to look up to. I had people in my life who were role models but none that were specifically in engineering. It is hard to find that representation, so I just try to be the best representation that I can be.
Senator Martin: You are a pioneer, so to speak. Are you mentoring, or do you find yourself with younger people who are looking to you as a role model now?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Yes. When I was working with X‑Project, I loved to answer their questions. I loved that they wanted to know about what I was doing. It showed that people are interested, and there is an interest there. They just need to see representation and think, “If they can do it, I can do it.”
Senator Martin: That is one of the keys. You need these role models, and then you can be a role model.
What do you think can be done to help you and your generation to have that connectivity? You have your relationship with your Elders. What would you like to see when it comes to creating something that will allow the role modelling to extend to the next generation and so on?
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: It would be great to have some sort of cohort for young Indigenous people to have a pathway to follow for engineering and connect with people. It could be a year when you have a group of students, and you get them to upgrade their courses first. You show them different industries and what it is like in the workforce. Throughout their schooling, you provide job opportunities that are close to their homes and alleviate that stress of trying to find co-ops and jobs. That would remove a lot of barriers, starting from high school.
Senator Martin: What you just said would be a perfect template for such an organization or — I don’t know — a service or program. You didn’t have any of that, did you? You had to navigate it on your own.
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: It does now exist at Dalhousie University, the university I go to. They just recently implemented that, but this never existed when I was going to university.
Senator Martin: I think you will be a great agent in making some of these changes happen. Congratulations.
Ms. Lafford-Desmond: Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. The part of your presentation, your brief, that really struck me, coming from a young woman who appears to have an old soul, someone with a lot of wisdom, is that young people’s voices need to be included right from the start of any endeavour, not after the decisions have already been made. I think it’s important to remember that, because we’re conducting a study on the duty to consult. We’ll be sure to pass along your message as we travel around and conduct our studies.
[Innu-aimun spoken]
I see no other comments from the senators.
[English]
You can hear a pin drop. I’m going to sleep well.
[Translation]
I have so much hope.
Our next guest, our third witness at the table, is Kyra Lustig. Kyra is a Red River Métis woman who now lives in Fredericton, New Brunswick. I will now invite Kyra to give her opening remarks.
[English]
Thank you.
Kyra Lustig, as an individual: Good evening, Madam Chair, esteemed committee members and fellow witnesses. My name is Kyra Lustig, and I’m here today as a Métis student leader. I am from Red River, more specifically Treaty 1 territory, yet I grew up out east in Quebec and New Brunswick.
As a White-presenting Indigenous student, I often feel like a ghost among faces. There’s a stigma that comes with my appearance. I sometimes feel left out of conversations about Indigenous identity and resources. Many of us face pressure to not utilize support systems designed for Indigenous students, feeling that we do not have the right to access them because we do not face the same overt discrimination. Yet, we carry the burden of reaffirming our identity, navigating a maze of expectations and assumptions and still have the effects of colonialism looming.
I am currently the Vice-President of Education at the St. Thomas University Student Union, or STUSU, in Fredericton, New Brunswick, as well as the Director of Membership for the Canadian Alliance of Student Associations, or CASA. In both of those roles, I connect with students across the country, advocating for their needs and amplifying their voices to all levels of government.
Through my work with the STUSU, I’ve spoken with students who share similar feelings to my own. One student who identifies as mixed but presents as White confided in me about their struggle to find community. They expressed frustrations, feeling invisible in discussions about Indigenous issues and often being overly questioned about their identity to access resources. Another student shared their experience of attending cultural events, where they felt out of place among others who visibly identified with their Indigenous culture.
These students’ stories show the need for inclusive spaces that recognize and affirm the identities of all Indigenous students.
Throughout my work with CASA, I’ve learned that these experiences are not unique to my own campus or to Eastern Canada. One student from British Columbia shared their story of being dismissed in discussions about Indigenous rights simply because they didn’t fit the stereotypical image of an Indigenous person. Just as members of my family have, their family also attended residential schools. This denial of their identity and generational trauma not only affects their mental health but also their ability to advocate for themselves and their communities.
In my poem, “Echoes of Home,” I find strength and resilience. Today, I hope to plant seeds for further dialogue.
The government has a critical role to play in addressing these issues, and I ask you to take these matters seriously. It is essential that people not only listen to the voices of Indigenous youth but also actively work to dismantle the systemic barriers that hinder our access to education and resources. This includes committing to meaningful consultations with Indigenous communities to understand their needs and aspirations fully.
We need to remove barriers for Indigenous students to access post-secondary education, but we also need to move beyond simply getting Indigenous students in the door of these institutions. We have to foster a sense of belonging and recognition of their culture within those institutions. We need to prioritize Indigenous history and culture to foster understanding and respect among all. I’m currently working on an allyship guide for non-Indigenous people within the Wabanaki Territory that is focused on fostering understanding and creating supportive environments for Indigenous Peoples across the Maritimes. While this is a start, there is much more to do, and we need collaboration to do so.
We need to actively combat and confront hurtful trends like residential school denialism, which dismisses the pain of survivors and perpetuates harmful narratives. We must ensure that the truth about residential schools is taught by Indigenous Knowledge Keepers to honour the experiences of survivors and their families and ensure this abhorrent era of history is not forgotten.
In closing, I urge the government to develop and encourage policies that promote inclusivity and support for all Indigenous students, regardless of how they present. This means investing in programs that foster cultural education, providing mental health resources and ensuring equitable access to academic support. It also means confronting denialism and misinformation head-on, ensuring that the true history and ongoing impacts of colonialism are taught and acknowledged within our education systems.
With that, I would like to thank the committee for asking me to appear, and I look forward to your questions. Thank you. Marsee.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much for talking about denialism, about what our families and loved ones went through in residential schools, as well as those who have returned to the land of the caribou.
[English]
Senator Prosper: Thank you, Ms. Lustig, for being here and sharing your perspective and your experience. You mentioned that people who have mixed parenting but present as White have a hard time finding community. They feel out of place. You also mentioned that they are faced with the burden of reidentifying their identities. Could you expand upon that a bit and just provide what some of that experience is from your experience?
Ms. Lustig: Of course. I currently study human rights. Within that, I learned a lot about prima facie discrimination, which is what most people would define as racism. That’s seeing someone with a different skin colour. That is where they would say, “Oh, you look Indigenous” or “You look like you are not White.” That’s usually where racism may stem from. However, being an Indigenous person but not looking Indigenous, we also face lateral violence. Other Indigenous students or even people who may not be students often see you saying that you are Indigenous. In looking to help and advocate for them and looking for these supports, you get a form of backlash. You get questioned, “Are you really Indigenous? Are you sure you are not a ‘pretendian’? Where are you from? Who is your family? Who are your ancestors?”
I myself and a lot of other students always feel the need to reaffirm it. We always feel the need to say, “I am from Red River. I am from Treaty 1. I know who my ancestors are.”
Senator Prosper: Thank you.
Senator Pate: Thank you very much for talking about human rights. When you were talking about the type of training you would like to see, can you expand more on that and at what levels you would like to see it? Is it at all levels of school and post-secondary?
Ms. Lustig: Yes, post-secondary definitely — it’s the field that I am currently in and that I work in — but also secondary school. When I went to high school, there were no other Indigenous people. When I told someone I was Métis, they said, “Oh, you are mixed.” I had to explain that I am not mixed; well, yes, I am, but that’s not what the definition of Métis is. I am from Red River. Métis is from Red River. I had to explain the definition of that.
It is just combatting that misinformation and also educating how people can be supportive and acknowledge and recognize the differences that our culture has from others and how important it is to know the history behind that.
Senator Pate: Would you see that as early as kindergarten and in child care centres as well?
Ms. Lustig: Most likely. I think it is always important to teach from a young age. I am seeing more and more where we are teaching young people what smudging means and how important it is for different cultures and families, as well as teaching them where you come from. When you ask most kids where they live or where they are from, they will be able to tell you, but sometimes other kids do not understand that. It is important that we start teaching at a young age. But education doesn’t end once you finish high school or go into university and finish university; education is something that must be continuously ongoing in all fields.
Senator Pate: Thank you.
Senator Karetak-Lindell: Thank you for sharing your story. Actually, thank you to all of you because we learned a lot listening to your presentations today. I am also on the Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights, and one of the issues we were dealing with regarding the hate crimes legislation was trying to make residential school denialism a crime. My amendments got through committee but not through the chamber. Over the summer, I worked with my staff and talked to different people. I’m trying to bring it up again in this committee. How can we deal with that, and what is the best way? What are the options that we have as a country to try to educate people about how harmful denialism is but also all the lateral violence that you talked about?
I’m bringing that to this committee. I really look forward to our committee doing a study on what we can do to combat that, what we can do to make people understand our rightful place in this country and what our history is.
I totally identify with what you are saying because some of my grandchildren go through that; they don’t look Inuk enough. I see it all over. Attitudes have to change. We all have to learn that we cannot just put a title on someone. One minute after meeting someone, we have a title or label for them.
I’m interested in the work you do. What kinds of things can we do in a community to combat lateral violence? Is it bringing different people to the school to speak to children? Is it Elders coming to schools to talk about residential schools? I went to a residential school, and I’m trying to teach my grandchildren my story. I think, for many of us, we don’t share our stories because we don’t really want our children or grandchildren to know the hardships that we went through, so maybe we end up protecting them from reality. I’m just looking for ways that we can educate people and share our stories.
Some of the witnesses’ testimony we heard in our Human Rights Committee was very hard to hear. It was also a learning curve for me. We all look at things differently, and we react to things differently. Something we are going to deal with for a very long time is trying to make people understand we are different, but we are all Canadians. We have to learn to live with each other, especially when there is so much unrest in the world today. Canada is looked upon as a safe haven; yet, we don’t clean up our own backyard either. If we are going to criticize other countries for abusing human rights, then we had better clean up our own backyard, too, and not abuse the people who are the original peoples of this country.
I’m very interested in what we can do in our own communities because that’s where the lateral violence usually starts. It is within our own communities.
Ms. Lustig: I think lateral violence begins a lot with colonialism and the notion of blood quantum or having the second-generation cut-off. I think that is something that really perpetuates that as well. A lot of Indigenous students tend to find out more about lateral violence or are in the midst of it more in secondary school or in high school or post-secondary because you have the chance to learn more about these things when you learn more about laws and human rights. It is something that is also generational and has been passed down.
All parts of education start with a conversation. I have had a lot of experience attending these different talking circles to discuss experiences of how Indigenous students or different marginalized students feel, whether they look like they are part of their culture or not and whether they feel like they fit in or not. I think it’s important that it has to start with a conversation. How that should look definitely changes within areas of the country. Education can start with a conversation, but it only matters if the other person is listening and wanting to make changes.
Senator Karetak-Lindell: That’s true. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. Are there any other comments or questions?
[English]
Senator Clement: Thank you for testifying. It is very painful what you said. I want to thank you all for being so courageous and for saying these really tough things.
I want to describe something that I experienced at a powwow in Akwesasne just a few weeks ago. There was a White-passing woman selling jewellery. She is an artist. She created this jewellery. She identifies as Mohawk. The person beside me buying the jewellery was questioning her identity, saying, “Did you make these? Are you actually from here?” She responded very patiently in the way that you did, explaining her lineage. I stood there wondering how I should react to that.
I was interested in hearing you talk about allies and working with allies. I thought she looked exhausted, having to constantly explain that. It sounds like it’s a lot of work to constantly be justifying who you are to the world. What should I have done in that moment as an ally? What would you want people to do in those moments to be a support? Do something or do nothing?
Ms. Lustig: I definitely think there is a difference between asking someone where they are from and trying to start a conversation with them and berating them by saying, “Are you really from there? Do you have status? Do you have your citizenship?” and continuously asking these questions. A lot of times, it does get frustrating and overexaggerated. What I find for myself is that I have heard claims that I’m a “pretendian” before, but it doesn’t bother me so much because I know where I am from. I know who I am. But other students don’t always have that choice, and it’s where we need to protect them as well.
Senator Clement: Where do you get your strength from then?
Ms. Lustig: Probably my mother. Both of my parents are veterans. My mom is the President of the Oromocto Legion.
Senator Clement: Thank you for sharing.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you. I also noticed that you’re wearing the veterans’ pin and the one just below it with the feathers.
[English]
Senator Francis: I want to follow up on what Senator Karetak-Lindell said earlier. I would like to hear your thoughts on the role the federal government should play in addressing the issues related to denialism.
If you had to ask the federal government to focus on one of the four priorities, what would they be and why? For example, would you like to see greater investment in public education and awareness, or would you like to see stronger measures to deter those who spread hatred, such as criminalization? I would like to hear your thoughts on that.
Ms. Lustig: I think those topics you bring up are extremely important. Putting more economic growth into education around these subjects is very important. However, people are only going to learn if they want to learn.
One thing you see a lot on social media is that the denialism of residential schools is very similar to the denialism of the Holocaust. In Canada, denying the Holocaust is a hate crime, but residential schools are not because it happened on our home turf. I think it’s really important to differentiate between the two.
While we can educate someone, they aren’t always going to listen. I myself am a criminology major, so when it comes to the law, I tend to be a bit of a nerd. I think it’s important that we differentiate between those. If one genocide is a hate crime, why isn’t the other?
Senator Francis: Good answer. Thank you.
[Translation]
The Chair: If we agree to conduct a study on denialism, which affects so many people, you will definitely be on the witness list, if I may say so. Thank you very much.
This brings us to the end of our time with you, which has been wonderful. Thank you.
We will now invite our next guest to come.
The last witness at the table this evening is Summer Wabasse. Summer is an Oji-Cree woman from Webequie First Nation in Ontario.
Please go ahead, Summer, with your opening remarks.
[English]
Summer Wabasse, as an individual: [Indigenous language spoken].
My name is Summer Wabasse. I am an Oji-Cree woman from Webequie First Nation, which is a remote, fly-in community in northern Ontario, Treaty 9 territory. However, I was raised off-reserve in Thunder Bay, and now I call Ottawa home.
As a youth advocate, I currently sit on Nishnawbe Aski Nation’s Oshkaatisak Council, as well as the Chiefs of Ontario’s Ontario First Nations Young Peoples Council. In my professional life, I work for a government relations firm here in Ottawa supporting First Nations in building relationships on Parliament Hill and beyond.
First, I will talk about my youth advocacy work, and then I’ll discuss post-secondary education, as many of my fellow witnesses also have. Then I will be addressing residential school denialism.
I began to get involved in politics over 10 years ago, first joining my constituency youth council, then working for my local MP and applying to and being accepted into programs such as Daughters of the Vote, which was run by Equal Voice. Throughout these experiences, I noticed a consistent pattern that young Indigenous women are often treated as exceptions, photo props or tokens rather than core partners and decision makers. There are many times when I’ve been invited to meetings as part of these roles that I hold, only to be told that I don’t have a formal speaking role or time on the agenda to speak. I have a seat at the table, but I am there as a token and not actually to give my opinion or make a decision. Even now, at 27, I am oftentimes the youngest in many of these rooms.
Though I am extremely grateful to be here today for this wonderful opportunity and program that you all put on, appearing before a Senate or parliamentary committee should not be a once-in-a-lifetime or once-a-year privilege for a lucky few youth. Civic engagement should be accessible for all Indigenous youth across the country.
There are so many barriers to participation, including financial, information and lack of leadership support, but one of the greatest barriers that I see in my work is actually bias: the idea that youth are naive or inexperienced, that, as a result, all we have to contribute to the discussion is our naivety and that we can’t possibly bring experience and value to decisions being made.
What I want for future generations of youth is that this not be a once-in-a-lifetime or once-a-year chance and that all First Nations youth have the opportunities that I had to get involved in politics, whether that be in their community, riding, province or country. I would love to see youth invited as witnesses at all Senate and parliamentary meetings to ensure such a big portion of our population’s voices are represented.
One specific committee I would really love to see youth at would be the special committee on Bill C-39. I was actually listening in on that committee yesterday afternoon, when we had some Grand Chiefs as witnesses. Funnily enough, I heard one of your colleagues — I can’t remember which one — asking one of them about what they thought about the bill and the issues regarding it. Though I think that was really well intentioned, to me, it just highlighted that we are inviting 60-year-old men here and asking them what the youth think. You can be inviting the youth here. There are clearly a lot of us who are willing to speak.
Building up youth leadership and enabling councils like the ones that I sit on to do the work that we do requires capacity and funding. I would like to see a shift from short-term micro grants and reimbursements to stable, multi-year funding for Indigenous youth councils and programming.
I will talk a little more about education. I moved here in 2019 to pursue post-secondary education at the University of Ottawa, where I earned a Bachelor of Commerce in 2022. During my time in the program, I did not meet a single other Indigenous student in my program, so I decided to get involved with my school’s Indigenous centre and their Indigenous Students’ Association. Those two things were a lifeline for me.
The experience I had and the network I built during my time at post-secondary have been so positively impactful on my life. It was so impactful that, after graduation, I decided to work for Algonquin College here in town, supporting Indigenous students in their student centre.
During my time as a student and then later supporting them in my professional role, I saw how the gap between post-secondary funding provided by bands and costs of living harmed Indigenous students. There is a need for increased Indigenous post-secondary funding to cover real living costs, including relocation and child care, so students can focus on education without financial strain.
When I relocated here for school, I moved to Ottawa specifically for the many opportunities it provided to be closer to the federal government. I saw Ottawa as a place so disconnected from the realities of a community like mine, and I wanted to bring my vision and voice to ensure people in power knew about our community’s issues and barriers that we face.
As a young Indigenous woman, I have seen my generation’s own hopeful optimism from 10 years ago, with the legalization of same-sex marriage in the U.S., the defeat of the Harper government and the incoming Trudeau one and the release of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada report, turn into cynicism as our world becomes more divided and radicalized due to social media algorithms, misinformation and under-regulated artificial intelligence, or AI.
There is a limit to the work that I can do as a youth leader and advocate. As members of the Senate, I ask you to consider doing more to confront the rise of residential school denialism through the creation and adoption of legislation to fight misinformation and penalize those who knowingly engage in it.
Meegwetch for your time today, and I welcome any questions.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much.
Do my fellow senators have any questions?
[English]
Senator Pate: Thank you for challenging us around whom we call as witnesses. We hear lots about the adage: Nothing about us without us. Nowhere is that more true. Of course, Indigenous youth are the fastest growing population in this country, so they really should be a part of the planning process.
Did you approach the clerk, by any chance, and let them know that you were interested in testifying at that special committee? If not, are you okay with us letting them know that you are interested? I think it would be incredibly valuable.
Ms. Wabasse: Yes, for sure. I did not submit myself to the Bill C-39 committee, but I helped to submit a lot of other people through my work. I know some of my friends, whom I work closely with in advocacy work, were also submitted. I didn’t submit myself because I wanted the opportunity to go to them. I know that we are all, ultimately, competing for a very small number of seats.
However, I would love to be submitted and speak to Bill C-39. Like most Indigenous people, especially youth, I have a lot of opinions on it.
Senator Pate: I don’t know if any of the rest of us are on the committee. I am not. Senator Prosper is. There we go. Excellent.
I would like to hear more about what you would like to see us doing around residential school denialism because many of us were incredibly — you heard Senator Karetak-Lindell, who introduced it at the Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights, and then to see it defeated in the Senate was beyond enraging for many of us and incredibly discouraging for lots of folks in the community.
Some of the discussion is: Should it be done the same way as Holocaust denial was done? Should there be some other mechanism? Do you have thoughts on that?
Ms. Wabasse: Yes, for sure. I definitely think that it needs to be done through a combination of more public education and also legislation. I think denialism, ultimately, comes from such a place of ignorance and truly not knowing, which festers, especially with different social media algorithms that continue to push this content to their users. Unfortunately, I think it has really festered under the ban of actual news sites on Meta.
I understand that the ban is actually from Meta to maliciously comply with Canadian laws, but I do think that’s severely harming our society as a whole. Something could be done around that piece of legislation to address the rise of misinformation in general.
I do believe in criminalizing denialism, similar to the way that we do criminalize Holocaust denialism.
Do I understand the different scales and different impacts? Of course. Ultimately, my fellow witness Kyra said it best. Just because it is on our home turf, I think it makes it a lot harder for Canadians and Canadians in positions of power, like politicians. It is breaking our concept of what Canada is and what it stands for. I think that is why people go to this instinct to deny what happened. We really have to look inward as Canadians and say that this was our people, generations like our grandparents and our parents. Even though that might seem really far from 2026, where we are today, I think the criminalization of it is completely necessary.
For the education part, when I went to high school, which was not long ago as I am here as a youth, we had one day when we learned about residential schools. During that day, the teacher pointed at me and my Indigenous friend — we were in a class of all White people — and was like, “Do you guys want to lead this discussion? Do you guys want to take the reins on this?” This was in an AP history class maybe about eight years ago. If that was the education that I formally received on residential schools, I can only imagine that the amount that the average Canadian has is significantly lower.
I think all of us need to remember what the baseline level of Indigenous knowledge and Indigenous experience is here in Canada, and it is a lot lower than many of us think. Most people don’t even know the difference between First Nations, Métis and Inuit if you speak to them, outside of these circles where you are working with Indigenous people.
Senator Pate: Thank you for that.
You spoke about the impact of social media, AI and those sorts of things. In other committees, they’ve looked at things like how to regulate those areas. Should there be bans on certain things, whether based on age, content or that sort of thing?
I would be very interested to hear from you as a young person. Again, it has often been from parents and adult figures who have suggested these sorts of things. I am not putting it all on you because you are the one here. I would be interested in your perspective on that, and if you do have some idea of what other young people think, that would be great, too.
Ms. Wabasse: As a young person, and as a younger person than I am today, I see social media as something that is so harmful, but, of course, I participate in it because, as many Indigenous members and my fellow witnesses here know, Facebook and Instagram are lifelines for Indigenous communities. They are a way of staying in touch with our families, especially when many of us have to or choose to move away from our homelands to pursue our education and jobs.
However, I do believe we need more regulations on AI, especially around young people specifically and protecting them. As someone who was on the internet when it was a bit more Wild West, before many regulations came in, I think we’re seeing that same type of environment with the extremely fast growth of generative AI.
To see what youth are actually doing with AI and what people of all ages, to be frank, are doing with it is extremely concerning.
I am aware of current legislation that has been introduced — I believe it is Bill C-34 — to help regulate that. I’m fully supportive of it at this point in time. I need to do a more thorough analysis.
The real challenge is truly finding enforcement for it. I was a 13-year-old faking my age to make a Facebook profile, like many youth do. I think that I used to put my birthdate in as 1996 so I could make accounts. Having rules there is not the same as enforcement and regulation, but there are ways around that now with advanced technology, such as having to upload identification or credit cards and that sort of thing.
Senator Pate: Thank you very much, and thank you for your work.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. Did you say you’re 27? That’s incredible.
[English]
Senator Prosper: Thank you, Ms. Wabasse, for sharing your perspective and your experience with us.
I wish to begin by saying that having this opportunity, for senators like ourselves, to have you before us in committee is a distinct privilege.
I wish to commend the staff. People have come together to really put in those hours. I know there were many applicants, but that work shows with all of you here. It is inspiring. It is something I look forward to every year. I make it a point not to miss it. It nourishes me and many of us in what we do, but, more importantly, it allows us to dream of what can be because we see it through your eyes and we hear it through your voices.
When I was Chief, one time many years ago, an Elder told me that a leader is someone who steps forward, and all of you have stepped forward in so many ways. Often, it was not just for yourselves but for so many people: people who are here today, people who will be here tomorrow and people who have been here but are no longer. You’re part of that cycle.
You talked about that experience with Indigenous youth councils and the need for programming. You referred to the Indigenous Students’ Association as a lifeline.
Can you tell me about how self-esteem plays a role with Indigenous youth and how it is important to nurture self-esteem?
Ms. Wabasse: Yes, for sure. When you are a youth, especially a teenager, your self-esteem oftentimes is already so low because there are so many changes happening in your life, especially when you are 18, 19, 20 and going to university. It is such a time of change.
I think back to when I was that age. Now, as I sit on the Oshkaatisak Council and the Chiefs of Ontario’s Ontario First Nations Young Peoples Council, I get a chance to meet many youth who are younger than I am, who are graduating or are still in high school. I have truly, over the past few years doing this work with these councils, seen youths’ lives change because they choose to get involved in our programming. We do annual youth gatherings. We do workshops in communities.
I have seen youth truly go from someone who is really shy and uncomfortable public speaking to people who are now organizing and speaking at protests and doing public speaking at these very same events where, a few years ago, they were so shy. I am also someone who, I find, came into my own doing this sort of work. I truly believe that self-esteem comes from a belief that you have a purpose and that you are working towards that and contributing your gifts to the world.
I have seen, through youth councils, people find their passions and get involved in politics. They are able to continue that cycle of meeting a youth who is a little shy and getting them to participate in something. Maybe they are not too sure about participating at first, but then, a few years later, that youth is running that workshop and being able to carry that on and on.
I think that self-esteem and youth councils are something that go hand in hand, honestly, because you feel so empowered. It builds your network up, too. You start to get a feel for when you enter the professional world, which is also such a great benefit.
[Translation]
The Chair: I would like to take a moment to add a comment. We have a lovely image of Alanis Obomsawin, who looked out for me when I was a baby, as well as my sons and many other folks. She supported so many people. Her work right over there says:
[English]
We cannot forget here children from residential schools are watching us every day.
[Translation]
They are here and they are watching us. Our clerk pointed that out to me, and I appreciate the reminder.
[English]
Senator Tannas: Thank you, Summer, for your testimony. I thank everyone for being here and for their testimony. I love to listen to this.
I try to come up with questions. I don’t feel worthy sometimes of asking the question and trying to tease something out. I love the stories of adversity, struggle, unfairness, racism and sexism that we hear but also of resilience and determination.
The strength that you all possess and also this weight of example are interesting. Being the first and having to demonstrate for people coming after you is something that few of us that aren’t of the lived experience understand. There is that weight of being an example, of not failing, of being successful.
It is interesting; it is almost the same story as new immigrants. It’s weird, isn’t it? You are Indigenous Peoples, the First Peoples, and the stories you are talking about are the same struggles that immigrants have when they come here. They are all the same kinds of things that you were talking about.
I wish you all persistence with your lives. In my own experience, it is how you gain the biggest impact over the course of your life and the contribution that you will make to your families but, more importantly, to the country and society. Look for it. Gather it. Use it throughout your lives. I wish you that.
Finally, I just want to say that it is an honour to be in the same room with you.
We have now listened to around 100 of you over the course of the last decade. It would be great if we could track people and keep in touch, because that will add to the story for you, for those who came before you and for those who come after. Maybe that is something we should look at doing.
Again, it was an absolute honour to meet you all and listen to your stories. Thank you.
Senator Clement: I love that suggestion. That is good. Thank you, Senator Tannas.
Hi. Thank you for being here.
Two things. You’re obviously interested in politics, so I am interested in how you connected to that interest and if it was through a youth council. Number two, let’s say that you are at the Bill C-39 committee. What you would tell us? You can follow up and send in briefs. What you would say to us right now about Bill C-39? As you know, we’re in the thick of it. I had those two things: your inspiration for politics, and tell us what you think of Bill C-39 right now.
Ms. Wabasse: My inspiration for politics really did come out of that exciting time, around when I was 15, in 2015, when I was seeing a lot of political change in the world. I had grown up under the Harper government. During that time, I saw the apology for residential schools, the election of Barack Obama in the United States and same-sex marriage being legalized in the United States. I was seeing a lot of social changes in a short time as my brain was forming.
I followed the 2015 election so intently, but I felt so powerless because I was too young to vote. I was only 16 at the time. I began to look for ways to get involved, which included hanging around the campaign. Justin Trudeau made a campaign stop in Thunder Bay, which was really exciting for me. I met my local MPs, networked with them and eventually joined their youth council, which led to many other opportunities, including joining even more youth councils, which I am still on to this day.
As for Bill C-39, I will save my testimony for that committee, but, in short, Indigenous Peoples want to partake in economic reconciliation. I have seen such an us-versus-them dynamic be fostered that Indigenous Peoples are saying no to all development. That’s simply not true at all. My community is the closest community to the Ring of Fire, which is a very contentious, potential major project, and my community has been doing a lot of work to grow this project. I have been hearing about this project since I was a small child. I’m 27 years old now. My community is getting funding to build roads. We’re currently a fly-in community.
There is a narrative here that Indigenous people don’t want to participate, and, because of that, we’re seeing legislation introduced to make us participate. Not all communities want the same level of development in their territory. I think that something like Bill C-5 or Bill C-39 sets a tone of “We’re going to do this, whether you like it or not,” which undermines what free, prior and informed consent, or FPIC, is.
I would like to see it repealed entirely. Will that happen? Who is to say? I would like to see many changes around the idea of what a region of national interest is. How do a nation’s rights actually become affected?
If we were going to build a mine development in downtown Gatineau, obviously all of the residents of the National Capital Region would want to be consulted and would probably want compensation for how their lives would change. I don’t think it is bad that Indigenous groups are asking for the same thing, including my own. We want to partake. We don’t want to be made to partake.
Senator Clement: What is the minimum age for being a senator? Thirty. Okay. Getting that on the record. Thank you for that.
[Translation]
The Chair: Thank you very much. That brings us to the end. A big thank you to Sébastien for working so hard to organize this event, along with Sara and Oana.
[English]
And, of course, SENgage. She is not here. She is helping the cute, cute Elder get back to her car. Chelsea, we love you. Thank you so much.
[Translation]
To the photographers, thank you very much.
[English]
You spent the entire day with us, so we will have beautiful memories through those pictures.
To the interpreter, wow.
[Translation]
Thank you very much. There was a page with us as well. Thank you for being part of this great adventure.
[English]
We have gifts. There are pictures.
(The committee adjourned.)