Skip to main content
APPA - Standing Committee

Indigenous Peoples

 

THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLES

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Tuesday, October 6, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Indigenous Peoples met with videoconference this day at 9 a.m. [ET] to study the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 14 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025; and, in camera, for the consideration of a draft report.

Senator Michèle Audette (Chair) in the chair.

[Editor’s Note: Portions of the proceedings were presented through an Inuktitut interpreter.]

[French]

[Translation]

The Chair: Kuei. Good morning. [Innu-Aimun spoken], the Anishinaabe people. Thank you for having us here again today. I will try to honour your history and, of course, your presence. I also acknowledge all the nations that have made it their home. As senators, we also come from territories rich in history.

[English]

Before we begin, I’d like to say that we all know there are amazing people who are translating for us, and it’s a gift. Today, some of this meeting will also be in Inuktitut, so Inuktitut will be translated into English and then English into French. I want to say thank you because we don’t hear our languages enough in this space, so it’s a great honour. Of course, we have to take care of the amazing people behind us who translate so that our voices can be heard across Canada on Turtle Island. Please don’t get too close to the mic with your devices, phones or computers for this important study.

Thank you for your cooperation. My name is Michèle Audette. I’m Innu and Québécoise, and I’m a senator from Nitassinan, which is what we call Quebec. I would like to invite my colleagues in this place to introduce themselves.

Senator Tucker: Good morning, everybody. My name is Senator Geeta Tucker. I represent Manitoba. I’m from Treaty 1 territory, which consists of the traditional lands of the Anishinaabe, Nehethowuk, Anishininewuk, Dakota and Denesuline peoples. It’s also the national homeland of the Red River Métis, and it’s home to many Inuit who live and work in Manitoba.

Thank you very much for having me as an observer today.

Senator Prosper: Hi, everyone. Welcome. Senator Prosper, senator for Mi’kma’ki, Nova Scotia.

[Interpretation]

Senator Karetak-Lindell: I am Nancy Karetak-Lindell from Arviat, Nunavut. I’m the Nunavut senator.

[English]

Nancy Karetak-Lindell, senator for Nunavut.

Senator McCallum: Senator Mary Jane McCallum, representing Manitoba, and I’m from Treaty 10.

Senator Tannas: Scott Tannas from High River, Alberta.

Senator Francis: Good morning. Brian Francis from Epekwitk, Prince Edward Island.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you, colleagues.

I would also like to acknowledge everyone listening to us across Turtle Island, people across Canada listening to us on SenVu.

Colleagues, we are continuing our study of the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 14 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025.

[English]

We are honoured to welcome at the table this morning the Government of Nunavut: the Honourable John Main, MLA, Premier of Nunavut, accompanied by Stephen Mansell, Chief Negotiator for Devolution. And via video conference, from Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., we welcome Gloria Uluqsi, President, accompanied by Dustin Fredlund, Chief Operating Officer.

We will have five minutes for opening remarks, after which the senators will ask questions. If you feel the five minutes is too short, you can add your thoughts during the question-and-answer period, of course.

We will start with Premier Main. The floor is yours.

[Interpretation]

Hon. John Main, M.L.A., Premier of Nunavut, Government of Nunavut: Thank you, Madam Chair. We’re representing our Nunavut government, and we’re happy to be here.

[English]

With me today is Stephen Mansell, the Chief Negotiator for Devolution, who is responsible for the Government of Nunavut’s implementation of the Nunavut Lands and Resources Devolution Agreement.

We’re happy to be here today to discuss Bill C-31. The Government of Nunavut is closely monitoring the progress of Bill C-31, in particular Division 14 of Part 4, which proposes amendments to the Territorial Lands Act. We recognize these amendments are intended to strengthen the Government of Canada’s ability to respond to matters involving national security, sovereignty and the national interest in the Arctic.

The Government of Nunavut strongly supports measures that protect Canada’s sovereignty and national security interests in the Arctic. The people of Nunavut are quite literally on the front line of Canada’s Arctic sovereignty, and Nunavummiut live, work, raise families and build communities across our vast territory. Inuit have been stewards of these lands and waters for generations, and Nunavut’s communities are an essential part of Canada’s continued presence in the Arctic.

For Nunavummiut, Arctic sovereignty is therefore not an abstract or distant national security issue. It is connected to our communities, our lands and our resources and the future of our territory. That is why measures to protect Canada’s sovereignty and security in the Arctic must also recognize the Government of Nunavut’s unique circumstances, the role of Inuit and the responsibilities that will be assumed by the Government of Nunavut through devolution.

The provisions in Bill C-31 amend the Territorial Lands Act, which is the principal federal statute governing the administration and management of federal Crown lands in Nunavut, including the administration of certain mineral rights. The act is particularly important to the Government of Nunavut because under the Nunavut Lands and Resources Devolution Agreement, responsibility for these Crown lands and the resources on them will be transferred from Canada to the Government of Nunavut on April 1, 2027.

Devolution is the culmination of many years of work by the Government of Nunavut, Canada and Inuit partners. It represents an important step in our territory’s evolution and in the exercise of greater territorial responsibility over our lands and resources. Nunavut is the last of Canada’s three territories to complete this transfer of land and resource responsibilities, marking an important step in Canadian nation building.

A central principle of our implementation work is “devolve then evolve.” The immediate objective is to ensure that the Government of Nunavut has the legislative, institutional and operational capacity required to assume its devolved responsibilities on April 1, 2027. Once that foundation is in place, the Government of Nunavut will have the ability to continue evolving its own approaches to the administration and management of its lands and resources.

That is why the Territorial Lands Act is particularly important to the current devolution process. The Government of Nunavut is required to mirror key federal legislative authorities, including the Territorial Lands Act, in its own legislation so that there is continuity when responsibility transfers over. Mirroring is intended to provide certainty and a seamless transition, allowing the Government of Nunavut to assume these responsibilities with limited disruption to communities, industry, Inuit organizations and other stakeholders.

The Government of Nunavut’s primary devolution implementation objective is to be ready for the transfer date of April 1, 2027. This requires a complete and functional legislative framework to be in place before the transfer of authority. The Government of Nunavut has therefore developed a proposed public lands act that mirrors the federal Territorial Lands Act as it currently exists. The public lands act was tabled during the spring 2026 sitting of our legislative assembly, and our implementation plan calls for formal introduction during the fall 2026 sitting to allow sufficient legislative review before the transfer date. That’s in a couple of weeks.

The timing of Bill C-31 creates a particular challenge. The Government of Nunavut cannot mirror federal provisions that have not yet been enacted. At the same time, delaying our public lands act until Bill C-31 is approved would create a significant risk to our ability to have the necessary lands legislation in place for April 1, 2027. The two legislative processes therefore need to proceed in parallel.

The Government of Nunavut is examining how, after the transfer date, provisions such as those in Bill C-31 could ultimately be reflected appropriately in territorial legislation while continuing with the legislation required to meet the devolution timeline.

We recognize that Canada has identified national security and sovereignty concerns that it believes require these new authorities. If the Government of Canada believes it needs these authorities before devolution, we support Canada having the ability to act on those concerns while it retains responsibility for these lands and resources.

To conclude, we believe we can support Canada’s responsibility to protect sovereignty and national security in the Arctic while respecting the integrity of the devolution process and giving the Government of Nunavut the appropriate time to determine how these new authorities could fit within our territorial legislative framework.

[Interpretation]

Thank you, Madam Chair and senators, for the opportunity to speak to you.

[English]

The Chair: Thank you.

We will continue, but before that, I just want to apologize to our witnesses who are on video conference because the entire Zoom or the team here in the room shut down for a second. You’re welcome to do your presentation, and, again, I apologize.

We have with us Gloria Uluqsi, President of Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., and she’s accompanied by Dustin Fredlund, Chief Operating Officer. Thank you for being with us today, and we will listen to your presentation.

[Interpretation]

Gloria Uluqsi, President, Nunavut Tunngavik Inc.: I’m happy to be here with Premier John Main and Senator Nancy Karetak-Lindell. I’m pleased to be here with you, and good morning to you all.

I am the President of Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., Gloria Uluqsi. I will be giving a presentation on Division 14 of Part 4 of Bill C-31 regarding lands. I’m Gloria Uluqsi, again, the President of Nunavut Tunngavik Inc.

[English]

I am here on behalf of Nunavut Inuit and to uphold and protect the rights and interests of Inuit in Nunavut. We recognize there may be circumstances where the Government of Canada requires the ability to limit or prevent the acquisition of certain interests in lands and resources or cancel certain permits, licences or leases to advance broader national priorities.

We understand these measures may help ensure that important lands and resources remain available for projects that support Canada’s long-term economic needs, interests, security and sovereignty.

We also acknowledge the recognition of the importance of Arctic sovereignty and security.

Inuit have lived on, travelled across and cared for these lands and waters for generations. Inuit knowledge, presence and stewardship are fundamental to Canada’s presence in the Arctic and have long contributed to Canada’s ability to assert and strengthen its sovereignty in the North. This is recognized in Article 15 of the Nunavut Agreement.

For that reason, any efforts to strengthen Canada’s presence and sovereignty in the Arctic must include Inuit as full and meaningful participants and partners. Development in Nunavut should not happen to Inuit; it should happen with Inuit. Nunavut is our homeland, and Inuit rights and interests are protected under the Nunavut Agreement. When decisions are made in partnership with Inuit, development is more likely to create lasting and meaningful benefits for Nunavut and its communities. This includes expanding economic opportunities for Inuit, creating employment and business development opportunities, building local capacity and ensuring that the benefits of development remain in the territory for future generations. If the Government of Canada is granted these authorities, they should be exercised carefully and transparently, with consideration given to the impacts on Inuit and Nunavut. There should be clear conditions, well-defined expectations and a commitment to ensuring that these decisions affecting Nunavut reflect both national priorities and the rights and interests of Nunavut Inuit. We see this as an important opportunity to ensure that national interests and Inuit interests are aligned. As we move closer to devolution, continued collaboration among Inuit, the Government of Canada and the Government of Nunavut will be essential. By working together, we can ensure resource development supports economic growth, strengthens Canada’s Arctic sovereignty and security, respects Inuit rights and delivers meaningful long-term benefits for the people and communities who call Nunavut home.

[Interpretation]

That is my conclusion. Thank you.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

[English]

[Indigenous language spoken]

Senator Tannas: I was wondering if I could ask for clarification from the President of Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. Were you at the table throughout any of the development process for this piece of legislation? And do you support what’s being proposed here?

Ms. Uluqsi: Thank you. It was prior to my time. I was not sitting at the tables, but my team has been sitting at those tables, and, yes, Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. was provided a copy of the bill earlier this year. We reviewed it and we express our support for the basic purpose. So, yes, we support it.

Senator Tannas: Thanks for that clarification. I appreciate it.

Senator Francis: This question is for both of our witnesses. To the best of your knowledge, how would Inuit rights and perspectives be considered before the “national interest” power is exercised, including through consultation with Inuit organizations, the Government of Nunavut and affected parties?

Mr. Main: Thank you. When it comes to the Inuit interest, I think it’s great that we have President Uluqsi with us today, and she can speak to that aspect. The Nunavut government has a very important relationship with Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. It’s established through the Nunavut Agreement, and we are required to work closely with Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. on a wide range of issues, as established in that agreement, and we embrace that and we view them as key partners to us as a public government in much of what we do.

I think in terms of the national interest, as you mentioned, what we’re trying to analyze from the Nunavut government’s side is how well our legislation mirrors the national interest. Is a Nunavut government minister going to have a piece of legislation that requires them to consider the national interest? We don’t believe that would be appropriate. It would be more along the lines of using the term “public interest.” We’re looking at jurisdictions like Ontario, Quebec and Nova Scotia that have that type of language in their statutes. But as I mentioned in my comments, we do need time to analyze this in order to look at whether we could mirror these provisions should they be established.

Ms. Uluqsi: This is very important for Inuit in Nunavut. Inuit should always be engaged right from the beginning and not considered in the middle or at the end. We really believe in collaboration and engagement with Inuit, and in saying that, we have a really good relationship, as Premier John Main stated, on multiple items. It’s really important for Nunavut Inuit to be consulted and really important for Inuit organizations to be engaged and consulted right from the beginning, not at the end.

Senator Francis: Thank you both.

Senator Karetak-Lindell: I was speaking with some people trying to find out how this new piece of legislation would affect land use planning. To put it on record, I did get some clarification, and this is to both of you, Gloria and John. How would the proposed amendments interact with the agreement — you covered it a bit — but mainly the land use planning?

Ms. Uluqsi: I can speak a little to it. Thank you for the question. At this point, to my understanding, these two files are totally separate, so I really can’t speak to the Nunavut land use plan because they are two different files.

John, if you want to say anything, I’m giving the floor to you.

Senator Karetak-Lindell: What about territorial land use planning? I’m trying to understand how all those pieces fit in with devolution coming in a very short time, and I know you want to make sure that everything is in place. It seems like Nunavut always has these immovable deadline dates. I was talking about April 1, 1999. Now you have April 1, 2027, as the devolution date, and you want to make sure everything is in place before the turnover with all that new authority.

[Interpretation]

Mr. Main: From our vision, we look at this differently within the planning and the land use plan in Nunavut when we look at it. When you look at the map, you should have many things implemented by now where the mining plagues and where it should be protected: the land. All those measures in place in the planning that we did in the land use planning exist there, but when we talk about Bill C-31, it affects more the resource development and the miners who would own and operate the resource development and who should be responsible to manage and oversee the policies that are taking place within the resource development areas. I would have to say land use planning.

[English]

They are in the same sphere in terms of land use and development in the territory, but they’re not necessarily dependent upon one another in terms of the land use plan. Thank you.

Senator Prosper: Thank you to our witnesses. I have a question for you, Premier Main. Thank you for your opening comments.

We had witnesses from the federal government commenting on this particular piece of legislation. There was some dialogue on national interests and, let’s just say, a lack of a definition for “national interest.”

I’m curious about your process with what you would consider the relevant Inuit leadership organizations within your vast territory that you are responsible for. How does that work with respect to that process of consultation with the relevant organization? How did it evolve as it relates to this particular piece of legislation? Please help me understand that further.

Mr. Main: Thank you. That’s precisely the type of question that we need to consider and analyze in terms of future Nunavut statutes that would reflect the public interest or use language around the public interest.

Specifically regarding how we would consult with Inuit and Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. as well as the regional Inuit associations that are also active or are land holders in terms of tenure in Nunavut — how we would work with them, we don’t know yet. We’re not there yet. I’m not trying to duck the question, but that is precisely the reason we’re saying that the timing of these proposed amendments is complicated for us, given that we are on a very fixed timeline with devolution.

Mr. Mansell has done an excellent job of keeping our government on track; we are on track. There are some 170 days between now and the transfer date. You can appreciate that in terms of the legislation and the processes there, it is not a lot of time to make amendments or give proper consideration.

Senator Prosper: Thank you.

Premier Main, just to further follow up on what you just mentioned — and I certainly appreciate your role, Mr. Mansell — it’s 170 days with parallel processes going on with respect to devolution. Can you highlight any key initiatives that are currently being undertaken because there were previous comments about national and Inuit interests? They’re aligned in terms of the intentions of sovereignty and Arctic security.

How does that translate in terms of your role on the ground when you’re working through devolution and this timeline of April 1, 2027?

Stephen Mansell, Chief Negotiator for Devolution, Government of Nunavut: Thank you for the good question, senator.

I think the Government of Nunavut would say the devolution process as a whole is an Arctic sovereignty process. It’s a government elected by a majority Inuit population finally making decisions in Nunavut for Nunavummiut and Inuit. Devolution itself is critical, but the Government of Nunavut, in partnership with Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., has also recently worked on Arctic sovereignty policies, and Nunavummiut Inuit communities are critical to Canadian sovereignty. The best way to advance sovereignty in the Arctic is having strong, funded communities in the Arctic to assert Canadian Arctic sovereignty. Thank you for the question.

Senator McCallum: Thank you for your presentations, and welcome to the Senate. Is your government involved in the Grays Bay Road and Port project?

Mr. Main: The Grays Bay Road and Port project is an Inuit-led private project. The Kitikmeot Inuit Association has an ownership stake in the company that’s leading that.

The Government of Nunavut’s involvement in these major Inuit-led projects is one of advocacy and potential partnership with the proponents.

Senator McCallum: Thank you.

My question doesn’t relate to this. The Nunavut Lands and Resources Devolution Agreement stipulates that Canada’s Territorial Lands Act and any regulations made under that act will be made inapplicable in respect of public lands by April 2027. Devolution would also cede federal Crown lands to the territorial government.

What is the broader purpose of amending the Territorial Lands Act in Bill C-31, given that the legislation is expected to be made inapplicable to public lands in Nunavut in six months’ time when the Nunavut Lands and Resources Devolution Agreement should come into force?

Mr. Main: Thank you for the question.

We’re not asking for these amendments to be delayed. We’re in support of the principle of what’s being put forward here in terms of Canada’s responsibility to protect Canadian sovereignty and national security in the Arctic. We’re in support of that.

However, we are pointing out the timing; we have a very short window of time between now and the transfer date. It is creating some complications for us. That being said, we are in support of Canada establishing these abilities and exerting sovereignty or security in the Arctic, including in Nunavut. We are in support.

Senator McCallum: You’re not concerned about it? There are no concerns with them doing this?

Mr. Main: The timing is our principal concern, as is how we would mirror the “national interest” language and how that would convert into an authority potentially within the Nunavut government in the future. Those are the complicating factors, but we’re not overly concerned. We do support the objective here. Thank you.

Senator Greenwood: Thank you to our guests for being here today in person and remotely. My questions have mostly been asked, but I would just like to hear you talk more about it.

Whenever I see the words “national interest,” it’s not very defined. Often, they speak about sovereignty and security, and then I think of mineral rights and those sorts of things, like the resources on that land and who has access and who will control them, et cetera. That plays in my head as I think about these issues.

I think of Inuit sovereignty because I’m hearing the Nunavut government, the federal government and Inuit — we’re not sure it’s an even playing field. Are there enough assurances for Inuit around Inuit sovereignty in this whole relationship? Are there enough assurances that they will have their voices at the table and have the same decision making as others do? Earlier, I think one of our guests said several times that they want to be included from the beginning.

What are the assurances as you move into this uncharted territory? You don’t know what you’re walking into; no one does. I’m thinking of Inuit sovereignty and Inuit rights being particularly vulnerable in this kind of situation as well.

What are the assurances in this whole scenario to ensure that those rights will be there in the ways that Inuit want them to be?

Ms. Uluqsi: Thank you for the question. It is a really good question.

When we think about sovereignty — and I’m going to be honest here: Sovereignty is new to Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. We are learning to navigate it with the Government of Nunavut as well as Inuit in Nunavut. That is all to say that when we’re talking about sovereignty, we really want to communicate our position at Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. on behalf of Inuit that, for us, sovereignty is — number one — about taking care of our people and being provided with appropriate funding to combat the housing crisis and the cost of food. To Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., on behalf of Inuit, those are the types of things that we need to take care of.

When we think about sovereignty, it’s not about these huge buildings or armies. It’s more about our basic needs being met. They should have been met 10 or 15 years ago, I’m going to be honest, but they haven’t been. We have huge housing shortages. We have a lot of challenges in Nunavut. However, we can do this through partnerships and collaboration.

Another one I can really think of is healing. We need those appropriate resources and funding to ensure that the lives of Nunavut Inuit will improve. That’s why we’re here: to advocate for Inuit to ensure that we improve their quality of life in Nunavut. This is our land. This is our home. We’re not going to be moving down south. Yes, we might move temporarily, but we will always be home.

The Chair: Thank you. That was a powerful answer.

Senator Pate: Thank you to all our witnesses.

Bill C-31 contemplates compensation for certain mineral rights holders affected by the “national interest” order, but it creates no comparable statutory mechanism for Inuit communities that could lose employment, royalties, contracting opportunities or other economic benefits because of the same order.

My question for Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. is: Do you view that asymmetry as a problem, and what form of accommodation or compensation should be available to affected Inuit?

For Premier Main, as a legislator, you have long advocated for the exploration of a guaranteed livable income, which is a proposal that Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami has advocated for Inuit as well. Would you see federal funding for a guaranteed livable income as a possible way to support communities in the event that a cancelled claim leads to economic instability?

Mr. Main: Thank you.

In that scenario, all options would have to be on the table. The cost of living is a huge challenge for Nunavut residents. President Uluqsi mentioned some of the ongoing crises that we have. It’s not one single crisis; there are multiple crises that we’re dealing with in Nunavut right now. The cost of living and food insecurity are two of them. Our government would want to do everything we can to support affected communities.

The other thing I want to get on the record, if you will allow me — and it’s regarding the previous question: Through the Nunavut Agreement, the Nunavut government is already bound to consult with Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. on a wide range of issues through Article 32 of the agreement. As well, our devolution agreement expressly acknowledges that Inuit rights under the Nunavut Agreement must be recognized. It’s included in there.

I also wanted to point out that Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. was a signatory to our devolution agreement, which puts us apart from the other territories in terms of their respective devolution processes. Thank you.

Ms. Uluqsi: Thank you.

Yes, conversations still really need to take place. There is still much to learn, and we always want to be at the table regardless and right at the beginning. I stated that during my introduction. Inuit have to be at the table right from the beginning and not at the end. It is really “nothing about us without us.”

The Chair: I can add that Premier Main did this with his head. I don’t know if you see me, President Uluqsi, so there is an agreement here with your powerful words.

[Interpretation]

Senator Karetak-Lindell: Thank you so much for being here.

[English]

In listening to some of the questions, I know that Arctic sovereignty is a real issue for us. It always has been, but it has been a national and international issue also. Talking about the Grays Bay Road and Port project, we know that some of the owners are foreign investors. In light of what’s been happening with Greenland and another country trying to take it over, it’s no doubt because of the minerals found there — minerals that we have in Nunavut.

Are you — either Gloria or John — concerned about some of the foreign ownership of these mines?

In the news, I noticed that the Mary River Mine project is undergoing some financial difficulties, and they want to sell off some of their assets. Who is going to buy those?

I worry about foreign ownership all the time, whether it’s foreign countries researching in Nunavut or China being in our waters over most of the summer months. We’ve always had a lot of research from other countries. I’ve never been comfortable with that because we want to make sure that Inuit own the land or are at least benefiting from resource development. We certainly need economic development in our territory but in a responsible way. It worries me when there is private foreign ownership of some of the mines.

What are the risks? Does this affect our Arctic sovereignty and national sovereignty?

Do you have any concerns about foreign ownership?

Mr. Main: Foreign ownership in itself isn’t too much of a concern. When you look at mining across the world, Canadian mining companies are very active internationally all around the globe.

It’s important for us to be open to investment from foreign interests. I think if we restricted access in terms of mining or industrial development in Nunavut only to Canadian companies, we would be seen as not a very attractive jurisdiction to invest in. But I do share some of the concerns that you expressed, senator, in terms of potential interests in Nunavut.

Because we’re so underdeveloped and because there’s been such an unfortunate history of underinvestment in Canada’s North, if we look all across the circumpolar world, almost every other country in the world has done a better job at building infrastructure in the North, in the Arctic, except for Canada. If you go around the circumpolar globe and you look at Nunavut, you’ll see a jurisdiction that has no roads, no railroads, no power lines and no fibre optic lines into it. With that unfortunate history of underdevelopment and underinvestment, my concern is that it’s made us vulnerable to potential foreign interests because if there is a vacuum there in terms of investment, it could look like an opportunity for foreign actors. So that is a concern of ours. Thank you.

The Chair: Thank you. Before I pass it over to the senator for the last question, I have a question for you, premier. I’m from Labrador. It’s not really north for you, but for me, it’s very north. Of course, there are many mining industries that have been there for the past 50-plus years, but is it possible to send us, in written form, what the standard is to make sure that when private investors come, they have to respect the environment or the — I don’t know how. When we are vulnerable, we might be tempted to say “yes” quickly. It’s not in your case, and it’s not what I’m saying to you. We do also have a duty to consult. I saw something interesting in one of your responses with the agreement and the relationship with President Uluqsi and the organization that she represents.

If you can send information about making sure you do protect or what your protocol or standard is when private investors come.

Mr. Main: We can certainly follow up with that information. It would provide some information about the Nunavut environmental assessment regime and land management. We can certainly follow up. Thank you.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

[English]

Senator Pate: Again, my question is for the premier, but the Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. witnesses and others could talk about this.

This bill clearly shows the intention of the federal government to fast-track resource extraction in the North, but we haven’t seen an equal focus on the well-known social and economic harms, particularly for Indigenous women, that come with the extractive industry, as well as the underlying economic inequalities that could leave some folks incredibly vulnerable, particularly women in the North. I’m curious from your perspective: Given the systemic overlooking of women’s voices when it comes to assessing the impacts of mining and other extractive industries on women, what kind of federal engagement do you think would be adequate for Inuit women? Of course, I want to hear from Inuit women themselves, in particular for the development of this legislation.

Mr. Main: Our government is keenly aware of the many different issues that are facing women in Nunavut, with Inuit women being disproportionately affected by many of the social issues that we do have.

From the government’s side, we do have the ability to influence operations of major industrial players in Nunavut. If we look at existing mines, we have Agnico Eagle who is active, and we have B2Gold who is active, and then we have — so we have four mines right now in the territory and three different companies. Each of those companies has legally binding benefit agreements with Inuit organizations.

But in terms of us as a public government, we also have the ability and, I believe, the duty to make efforts to address issues around our women being given opportunities in the workforce for careers and for advancement and our women being respected at the work site. Are there issues affecting women’s ability to pursue careers within that specific work site?

These are very real issues. I’m proud to lead a cabinet that’s made up of four men and four women, not including myself. That’s a first for Nunavut. There are some expectations of our government in terms of elevating these issues and giving them the attention that they deserve.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

[English]

Premier Main, I’m from Quebec, which you can tell from my little accent. As of yesterday, last night, we have a new government, the Parti Québécois. The value of that government — and I respect that because they are allowed — is to become a country one day. You mentioned that you are looking at different statuses, including the Quebec government. So I hope — and I’m sure you do — that Makivvik is involved or other Inuit organizations that are very powerful in Quebec and can have those discussions. One culture, one language, one nation is the value of the Parti Québécois when thousands of years of us have been there. So make sure — I’m sure you will — that the voice of Inuit in Quebec will be part of those discussions. I’m sure it will. Thank you.

That concludes this panel unless you want to add something, premier, about my comment or hope.

President Uluqsi wants to.

Ms. Uluqsi: I want to echo what our premier, John Main, just stated. I’m going to say this again. It’s very important to hear directly from Inuit. So we need to be given the opportunity to be listened to and to really speak about the issues that we’re facing. To kind of answer the question that the last senator asked, let Inuit speak and listen to Inuit — Inuit in Nunavut and Inuit who live in Ottawa, Winnipeg, Edmonton or Yellowknife. Listening is very important and also hearing directly from Inuit first-hand.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

This concludes the first part of our study.

For the second panel, we are pleased to welcome, by video conference, Ryan Barry, former executive director of the Nunavut Impact Review Board.

[English]

Thank you for being with us today, and we are now ready to hear your opening remarks, which will be followed by questions from senators.

Ryan Barry, Former Executive Director, Nunavut Impact Review Board, as an individual: Good morning and thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you for this opportunity to appear before you and provide my views on Bill C-31 as an experienced impact assessment practitioner, the Founder and President of Red Clay Environmental Solutions and the former executive director of the Nunavut Impact Review Board, or NIRB.

Throughout my career, my specific area of focus has been on implementing and improving regulatory frameworks in Nunavut and across Northern Canada.

Division 14 of Part 4 of Bill C-31 amends the Territorial Lands Act to grant the federal government expanded authority over mineral rights and land management in Nunavut in advance of Nunavut devolution scheduled for April 1, 2027. The federal government frames this amendment as a tool to protect overarching national security, critical minerals and Inuit rights. However, it appears to run counter to the objectives of transparency, certainty and predictability that the made-in-Nunavut regulatory process is known for.

While recognizing the limited time for which an amended Territorial Lands Act may apply to Crown lands in Nunavut, there remains potential for its enactment to create structural tensions, potential legal conflicts and procedural friction across several existing and proposed governance frameworks.

Resource development and land management in Nunavut are governed by the co-management institutions of the Nunavut Agreement and legislated through the Nunavut Planning and Project Assessment Act, or NuPPAA. NuPPAA outlines clear multi-jurisdictional pathways for land use planning and impact assessment. Division 14 introduces discretionary cabinet authority under the Territorial Lands Act to unilaterally prohibit prospecting, freeze mineral claims or cancel leases.

NuPPAA is anchored in the Nunavut Agreement, designed to provide certainty, predictable regulatory pathways and shared decision making for land and resource management. Exercising discretionary federal power to cancel mineral rights upstream via order-in-council introduces parallel federal discretion that is not explicitly contemplated in NuPPAA and bypasses established public review, technical screening and community consultation processes that are mandated under NuPPAA, creating regulatory uncertainty for industry proponents and local communities alike.

NuPPAA itself contains narrow, specific statutory exceptions for overriding federal action, such as explicit provisions related to national security or emergency situations. Division 14 establishes a broader, separate executive mechanism under the Territorial Lands Act based on general “national interest” criteria, which does not automatically trigger or integrate with NuPPAA’s defined emergency and security frameworks.

While Division 14 does not formally amend or repeal NuPPAA, it has the potential to create operational friction by establishing a federal top-down executive mechanism over mineral tenure that operates outside NuPPAA’s consensus-based co-management structure. Its practical validity depends on how cabinet orders respect the Crown’s duty to consult and the overarching constitutional authority of the Nunavut Agreement. Effective alignment hinges on effective operational protocols to ensure “national interest” interventions do not undermine local decision-making autonomy.

A point of concern that I would highlight for the committee’s consideration centres on who determines land use priorities in Nunavut and through what mechanisms, specifically the relationship between Division 14 of Bill C-31 and the development of a Nunavut land use plan by the Nunavut Planning Commission, or NPC.

The NPC is tasked with developing a territory-wide land use plan under Article 11 of the Nunavut Agreement and NuPPAA to establish a single, comprehensive framework for guiding resource management, conservation and economic development across the Nunavut Settlement Area.

On July 3, 2026, the draft Nunavut land use plan was returned to the NPC for further revision and refinement to address outstanding concerns and to better align with input from the signatories, local communities and industry stakeholders. The timeline for revising the 2023 draft plan and potential approval of the Nunavut land use plan are currently unknown.

Division 14 has the potential to align with several aspects of the draft Nunavut land use plan, including for complementary conservation area closures and support for strategic corridors and public infrastructure. It also has the potential to conflict with other aspects of the draft plan, including bypassing the co-management planning process, overriding the handling of grandfathered or existing mineral rights and prioritizing undefined national interest over local priorities balanced through public hearings and local input.

In summary, Division 14 provides the federal government with a rapid executive mechanism over mineral tenure that can either enforce the Nunavut land use plan’s conservation goals or override local land use designations in the name of national priorities. Because the Nunavut Agreement holds constitutional supremacy under section 35, any “national interest” order under Division 14 that directly contradicts the final approved Nunavut land use plan could face significant legal and political challenges.

In conclusion, I thank the honourable members of the standing Senate committee for this opportunity to appear and present my comments with respect to Bill C-31, and I would welcome any questions of the committee members.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Barry.

We will now begin the question period.

[English]

Senator Pate: Thank you very much for your testimony. The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls as well as research done by Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada have pointed to the fact that the social impacts and costs of mining, especially for Inuit women and their families, are often overlooked or underplayed in assessment processes.

I’m hoping you can speak to what steps are required to adequately assess the impacts of resource extraction on Inuit communities, particularly on Inuit women, including the increased risk of violence against women. Based on your experience, what steps would you recommend that the federal government take in order to ensure that Inuit women’s perspectives are adequately reflected in decision making under these measures?

Mr. Barry: Thank you very much. That’s a great question, and it has both a complex answer and a straightforward answer. My straightforward answer would be that the impact assessment process, when respected and when engaged with vulnerable communities and those who represent them, can be a very effective tool for addressing inequalities and addressing potential impacts. The art and science of impact assessment, as it is, is something that’s always evolving to reflect current contemporary issues. So it’s well used and adaptable for that.

My recommendation for how the federal government could take steps to better address these issues would be to ensure the integrity of the impact assessment process and to ensure that Inuit voices have sufficient time and resources to participate effectively and to advocate for these issues to be meaningfully addressed within the process and within complementary processes.

Senator Pate: Thank you very much. I would be very interested, if there’s time, to hear what your complex answer would be and also what steps you perceive will be taken in light of your experience as the former executive director of the Nunavut Impact Review Board.

Mr. Barry: Thank you again for the redirect.

In terms of more concrete steps that can be taken, in my experience both in Nunavut and at the federal level for impact assessment, the most effective means of ensuring these issues are addressed is by enabling meaningful public engagement throughout the process. When communities that would be impacted by resource development have the means through mechanisms like sufficient participant funding and sufficient time to be engaged in the process, where there are meaningful consultations undertaken by industrial proponents to develop their proposals that inform the impact assessment process, that is the best measure for ensuring that these issues get meaningfully addressed through the process.

Senator Pate: Thank you.

Senator Prosper: Thank you, Mr. Barry, for being here and for providing your testimony.

I have a question because I was listening to your testimony and some of the things I took note of are your mention of this particular bill being a federal top-down process with the risk of — or the operative determination is who determines land use priorities and through what mechanism. There is this idea of the prioritization of national interests over local priorities. We had a bit of dialogue on the lack of a definition for “national interest” within the context of this bill. I’m wondering what you can say with respect to that as it relates to your point about prioritizing national interests over local priorities. Thank you.

Mr. Barry: Thank you very much for the question. You’re right; I do point at that issue. I see it being problematic that “national interest” isn’t well defined. What I point to is NuPPAA, the federal legislation that implements Articles 11 and 12 of the Nunavut Agreement. It gives very specific, narrow uses for overriding “national interest.” It could be something like defence or security and having to go outside of the process because of an emergency, which has happened in the past, or it could be reasons of extreme national defence or things of that nature. I do see that “national interest” not being well defined could become a somewhat political determination for the government of the day. For the processes that are in place — which are built around respecting Inuit rights and local priorities — the more they can be respected, the better the territory and the country are for it.

Senator Prosper: Mr. Barry, by my reading, Division 14 gives the ability of the government to cancel licences, not issue them, or not allow for claims to be recorded or transferred. NuPPAA, on the other hand, allows the government to intervene and allow projects to proceed. If it’s in the national or regional interest, wouldn’t Division 14 then focus more on protecting and reducing impacts if it’s in the national interest? Could you provide a comment on that?

Mr. Barry: Thank you. I think that’s an interesting question.

I do see some potential for benefits where this legislation could be used to reinforce local priorities through the land use planning process. Where I see it being somewhat problematic is: As a practitioner in implementing it, my mind would go to what would happen if mineral lease rights were cancelled during an assessment. There’s no provision to address that, for example. I do see it being somewhat problematic from a number of perspectives around implementation.

I think having the ability to ensure that only those claims and leases and rights that are perceived to be in the national interest and the regional interest and filtering that somewhat can be helpful to ensure that only good projects go forward to the assessment process. Without having it well defined what “national interest” is and how they would be acted upon, it’s hard to comment further.

Senator Prosper: Thank you.

Senator Tannas: Senator Prosper just asked the very question I was going to ask. Thank you.

Senator McCallum: My question is also the same, but I’m still going to ask it. Clause 286 of Bill C-31 amends section 12 of the Territorial Lands Act, which deals with mining rights. It will create a new federal “national interest” power for mineral rights on Crown lands in Nunavut.

If the Governor-in-Council, on the recommendation of the Minister of Northern Affairs, is of the opinion that it is in the national interest, they may make an order affecting mineral tenure in Nunavut. Such an order could cancel mineral rights; freeze new claims; block leases, renewals and transfers; prohibit former licensees from reacquiring legal or beneficial interests in the affected claim or lease; and prevent lands covered by a cancelled claim from being reopened for prospecting for a specified period. Bill C-39, of course, is closely connected to this bill.

What will be the impact of Bill C-39 on Bill C-31? The Canadian government has been given authority to ignore most of Canada’s existing laws, including environmental laws. Would Bill C-39 be able to ignore agreements or laws that the Canadian government has with territorial and provincial governments, as well as Inuit and First Nations treaty rights? Can you give us an answer?

Mr. Barry: Thank you very much for the question. I’m not sure that I would have sufficient expertise to provide that answer regarding Bill C-39’s ability to override Bill C-31. I would be happy to follow up with a written submission after this.

You touched on how, nationally, it’s a very active time for updates and changes to impact assessment processes across the country. Many of us practitioners are directly involved in trying to understand how these legislative updates would change existing processes and still respect the rights of Indigenous Canadians and other Canadians. It’s something that we’re keenly studying and that we want to understand as well. I would be happy to follow up with a written submission.

Senator Clement: Good morning. Thank you for your presence and for your testimony here.

I’ve been listening to the testimony on this bill, and it feels like I’m hearing things that contradict each other a lot. There are concerns. We repeat the concerns about the lack of a definition for “national interest.” Yet I have also heard from witnesses that there’s agreement that we move forward. The premier said compellingly that there’s been so much lack of investment and it’s been terrible in terms of infrastructure, so we should do what we can in moving forward with this.

President Uluqsi was very compelling as well. Yes, we need to include women and listen to Inuit, but I want to understand what your criticism is because there have not been that many criticisms of this bill. You talked about the need for appropriate consultation. Do you feel, based on your experience, that’s going to happen? Do you feel there’s enough time for that to take place? Do you have confidence in how things have been done up until now that it will happen and that the government will actually listen to Inuit and Inuit women in particular?

Mr. Barry: Thank you for that question. The timing of this amendment and the narrow window for its application to Crown lands in Nunavut means that, come April 1, Crown lands are then under the control of the Government of Nunavut and the Territorial Lands Act would no longer apply to those lands. My understanding is that it would continue, post-devolution, to have a narrow application to federally controlled lands, and, of course, the Government of Nunavut has indicated its intention under the agreement to mirror this legislation to the extent practicable.

In terms of your question around consultation and if it has been adequate, I would have to respectfully defer to President Uluqsi and Premier Main for their opinions on that matter. What I can say is that I recognize there’s a narrow window for where certain implementation effects would take place. In my comments to you, I’ve been focused on what the problems are under the current system and where my criticisms would be about how this would work up until April 1, whereas it becomes somewhat narrower post-April 1.

Senator Clement: You concluded your comments by saying there might be a risk that local land use plans would be overtaken or overshadowed. Do you have any specific comments about which plans might be at risk of being overshadowed?

Mr. Barry: Certainly. There are two approved land use plans currently in Nunavut, and there’s been a tremendous amount of work done to develop a Nunavut-wide plan over the past decade, which does spend a lot of time discussing in detail the identified local priorities for development and conservation across the territory. I haven’t taken the time to identify any specific provisions in those plans that could be at risk, but I would be happy to look further into that and provide written feedback.

Senator Clement: That would be appreciated. Nia:wen. Thank you.

Senator Greenwood: Thank you to our witness for being here today. I have just a couple of questions for my own clarification. I think, earlier in your comments, you mentioned that there were mining agreements between Inuit and mining companies that currently exist, so I’m wondering: How does this impact their existing agreements?

I was also interested in something you said about the relationship between the proposed changes in the bill being rather top-down and how that will interface or be in relationship with the land use plan. I’m wondering: Could you talk a bit more about what your fears are around that kind of relationship that you spoke about?

Mr. Barry: Thank you.

To the first part of your question regarding Premier Main’s reference to the Inuit benefit agreements that existing mines have with Inuit organizations and how they’re used to move forward on some of the issues that are identified through impact assessment and to determine appropriate compensation, et cetera, I don’t think this proposed amendment would affect those existing agreements in any way. I wouldn’t expect it to.

For the other concerns I raised, in terms of having this kind of top-down cabinet discretion, in an extreme situation, I would say there would be a risk that one could simply bypass what the land use planning process has identified as priorities. An example is if there were areas identified as important for conservation, but the national interest dictated a mine must go there or some other development should be permitted to obtain rights for that area.

I hesitate to say that any of these would be legitimate concerns. I see no indications to believe that would be the case. There is a greater likelihood that this kind of amendment could be a tool to recognize that there is a lot of speculation that can occur with mining and staking, and this might be a practical means for the Government of Nunavut in future to address those speculative mine leases and make sure they don’t prevent the enactment of local priorities for conservation and development.

Senator Pate: Thank you again.

My question follows up on your response to Senator Clement. You mentioned there are a number of agreements that the Nunavut government and Nunavut writ large have spent years developing, looking at a variety of issues.

From your perspective, what if cabinet invoked proposed section 12.1 and cancelled the underlying mineral rights for an area where that process has been under way? From your perspective, would this legislation provide any mechanism for the Nunavut Impact Review Board’s evidentiary record or community input to inform cabinet before the decision is made?

Mr. Barry: Thank you.

I see nothing that would directly assure me of that, although, in terms of best practices, my hope is that such would be the case. The board’s processes for impact assessment are very transparent, and everything is publicly recorded and part of the public record.

So I would certainly expect and hope it would be the case that they would be considered.

Senator Pate: Thank you.

[Translation]

The Chair: Are there any other senators who have questions?

[English]

Senator McCallum: I’m sorry, but I didn’t thank you for your presentation.

Would you agree it is time for Inuit and First Nations to define “national interest” and have consultations with the federal government regarding their jurisdiction and sovereignty?

Mr. Barry: Yes, I believe anything that could be done to increase certainty around this proposed legislation and how it could be expected to be implemented, particularly around defining “national interest” and what that might mean for Inuit, would be very helpful.

[Translation]

The Chair: Thank you.

I believe that concludes the second panel.

[English]

Knowing that we still have a member of our first panel, I want to say thank you for when you spoke Inuktitut. For me, it was my first experience in this sacred or special space. Maybe some wise senators remember that it happened before — I’m talking about you, Senator Tannas; you’ve been here for a few moons. I want to say thank you. It was medicine for me. It was powerful. Thank you to the speakers and the panel.

Senator Prosper: Is there time for a question?

The Chair: Yes.

Senator Prosper: I just have a further question. Thanks, Mr. Barry, for providing your testimony.

How much of the land would transfer from federal Crown lands to Government of Nunavut-controlled lands with devolution? The thinking here is that, given the legal supremacy of the Nunavut Land Claims Agreement, wouldn’t the protection of Inuit rights and interests be respected by the federal government in that regard and the Government of Nunavut?

Mr. Barry: I’ll try to be direct: Yes, I believe it would continue to be respected by the Government of Nunavut. I have no reason to believe it would not be.

Senator Prosper: Thanks.

[Translation]

The Chair: We will conclude this panel.

[English]

I thank you, Mr. Ryan Barry.

We will now continue this meeting in camera. Thank you.

(The committee continued in camera.)

Back to top