THE SPECIAL SENATE COMMITTEE ON THE BUILDING CANADA STRONG ACT
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Monday, October 19, 2026
The Special Senate Committee on the Building Canada Strong Act met with videoconference this day at 12:01 p.m. [ET] to examine on the subject matter of Bill C-39, An Act respecting certain measures to strengthen the economy.
Senator Fabian Manning (Chair) in the chair.
[English]
The Chair: Senators and guests, before we proceed with our work today, I wish to take a moment to acknowledge the tragic events that occurred this past weekend at Canadian Forces Base Wainwright in Alberta.
On October 17, a live-fire-related training incident at the base claimed the lives of four members of the Canadian Armed Forces and left dozens more injured. The fallen service members have been identified as Sergeant Morgan Wong, Private Shaun Farrell, Private Aidan Goulding and Private Hayden Lykkemark.
As we reflect on this tragedy, our thoughts are with the families, friends and loved ones of those who lost their lives, with those who were injured and with the entire military community who are mourning an immeasurable loss.
We also extend our gratitude to the emergency responders, medical personnel and to all of those who provided assistance under exceptionally difficult circumstances.
I invite members and those present to join with me in observing a moment of silence in memory of those who lost their lives and in support of all those affected by this tragedy.
(Those present then stood in silent tribute.)
Thank you, senators. We will now proceed with our meeting. My name is Fabian Manning, I’m a senator from Newfoundland and Labrador and I have the privilege to chair this committee.
I will invite my colleagues to introduce themselves.
Senator Yussuff: Hassan Yussuff, Ontario.
Senator Boehm: Peter Boehm, Ontario.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I’m Julie Miville-Dechêne from Quebec.
[English]
Senator Duncan: Pat Duncan, Yukon.
Senator Patterson: Rebecca Patterson, Ontario.
[Translation]
Senator Quinn: I’m Jim Quinn from New Brunswick.
[English]
Senator Prosper: Paul Prosper, Nova Scotia, Mi’kma’ki territory.
Senator Cuzner: Rodger Cuzner, Nova Scotia.
Senator Mohamed: Farah Mohamed, Ontario.
[Translation]
Senator Clement: I’m Bernadette Clement from Ontario. I’m sitting in for Suze Youance.
[English]
Senator Wilson: Duncan Wilson, British Columbia.
[Translation]
Senator Gignac: I’m Clément Gignac from Quebec.
[English]
The Chair: Thank you, senators.
We are meeting today to begin our study of the subject matter of Bill C-39, An Act respecting certain measures to strengthen the economy.
For our first panel, we are pleased to welcome, from the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, Terence Hubbard, President; Stéphanie Johnson, Acting Vice-President, Strategic Policy and Programs Sector; from the Canada Energy Regulator, Tracy Sletto, Chief Executive Officer; Jonathan Timlin, Vice President of System Operations; Carly Milne, Vice President, Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation; and Sean Maher, Professional Leader, Environment and Socio-economics; and, from the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, Pierre Tremblay, President and Chief Executive Officer; Dean Haslip, Vice-President and Chief Science Officer; and Colin Moses, Vice-President, Regulatory Affairs Branch and Chief Communications Officer.
I realize, senators, that all of those named are not sitting right here at the table, but they are in the background; if we need to ask questions, they can come forward to the table.
Welcome, and thank you, all, for joining us here today. We will begin with your opening remarks before moving to questions from senators. We’ll start with Mr. Hubbard, followed by Ms. Sletto, then Mr. Tremblay. The floor is yours for five minutes when you are ready.
Terence Hubbard, President, Impact Assessment Agency of Canada: Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am pleased to be here today to discuss Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act and, in particular, amendments proposed to the Impact Assessment Act.
As noted, I am here with Stéphanie Johnson, Acting Vice‑President of Strategic Policy and Programs at the agency.
[Translation]
I would like to acknowledge that we are gathered on the traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabe Nation, which has long been the steward of the environment we share today.
The Impact Assessment Agency of Canada is responsible for reviewing major projects to support sustainable development, protect the environment and uphold the rights of Indigenous Peoples.
[English]
Given the rapidly changing world where uncertainty and instability are causing serious economic consequences here in Canada, Bill C-39 proposes legislative changes that would ensure that federal regulatory review processes are efficient and predictable, while maintaining the rigour that has always been there.
Proposed changes would modernize the regulatory and permitting system to simplify processes, reduce duplication and give investors certainty, while maintaining strong environmental protections and respecting Indigenous rights.
[Translation]
First, the bill proposes amendments to the Impact Assessment Act that will allow the federal government to complete reviews and make the necessary federal decisions within a maximum period of one year after the required information is received from the proponent.
The one-year time frame takes into account the time the government needs to carry out assessments, conclude consultations with Indigenous Peoples and the public, confirm the potential impact and mitigation measures, and make final decisions on project approval. I said “conclude consultations” because the one-year time frame applies only to the final phase of the assessment process. The agency identifies, and engages with, Indigenous groups likely to be affected by major projects well before this one-year period.
[English]
Second, Bill C-39 gives a clear mandate to the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, or IAAC, to coordinate assessment and federal permitting processes, including Crown consultations.
Under the current system, impact assessments and review processes for federal permits occur sequentially and separately from each other.
Under Bill C-39, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada would function as a federal review coordinator, working with other federal departments to ensure impact assessments for projects led by the agency can occur concurrently with reviews for federal permits required for those same projects.
The agency is well placed to assume this role. We have already re-engineered our processes to work more closely with federal permitting departments, helping proponents advance permitting during the impact assessment process. This has resulted in real efficiencies and reduced timelines for important major projects.
[Translation]
The third major change proposed in Bill C-39 is that the Canada Energy Regulator and the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission will be responsible for carrying out rigorous assessments and coordinating the permitting process with federal authorities for projects within their jurisdiction. This ensures that the best-placed regulator is at the helm.
[English]
The fourth key change relates to how we conduct Indigenous consultations. Fulfilling the duty to consult Indigenous Peoples for decisions that may impact their rights is critical to ensuring legally sound processes. It is a constitutional obligation.
Bill C-39 would formalize the role of the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada in coordinating Crown consultations. Through the creation of a Crown consultation hub, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada will work with federal authorities to ensure that Indigenous groups affected by a major project go through one clear and coordinated consultation process for each project, replacing multiple overlapping processes and reducing consultation fatigue.
[Translation]
It is important to note that the agency will continue to focus on early engagement, taking measures very early in the process, well before the one-year time frame begins, to identify, involve and consult Indigenous groups. We are well placed to assume this role. We have extensive experience integrating consultation into the assessment and decision-making process, with a focus on building meaningful relationships with Indigenous Peoples across the country.
[English]
Finally, the streamlined process I described will result in one federal decision. A single decision document would be issued at the end of the process by the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change and Nature, with all required federal approvals and enforceable conditions.
To conclude, I want to emphasize that the purpose of these proposed changes isn’t to remove requirements, protections or consultation, but rather to simplify processes and reduce redundancy. These changes would modernize systems already in place to ensure federal assessment and review processes support effective, efficient and responsible development of Canada’s resources.
Thank you for the opportunity to discuss this bill with you. I’m happy to respond to your questions.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Hubbard.
Ms. Sletto.
Tracy Sletto, Chief Executive Officer, Canada Energy Regulator: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good afternoon, honourable senators. Thank you very much for inviting the Canada Energy Regulator, or CER for short, as part of your pre‑study of Bill C-39.
I am accompanied here by Ms. Milne, Mr. Timlin and Dr. Maher from our organization.
I would also like to begin by acknowledging we are meeting on the unceded, ancestral and traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabe Nation, who have lived on and cared for the land now known as Ottawa since time immemorial.
My opening remarks will cover the CER’s mandate, provide information about our impact assessments, discuss our role in Crown consultation and outline some of the potential impacts of the legislative changes proposed in Bill C-39.
The CER is an independent federal regulator. We do not directly develop government policy or draft legislation. Questions on these matters are likely best directed to our colleagues in Natural Resources Canada, although we can certainly speak to our role in implementing Bill C-39.
[Translation]
The CER is responsible for regulating energy infrastructure to keep energy moving across the country in a safe, reliable, competitive and environmentally sustainable manner. We regulate for the complete life cycle of a project, from review, impact assessment and construction to operation, eventual abandonment and reclamation. We have an economic regulatory mandate, involving the regulation of pipeline tolls and tariffs and the export of energy. Lastly, we have a mandate to provide information on energy matters. We carry out all our responsibilities with respect for the rights and interests of First Nations, Inuit and Métis.
The tools we use to thoroughly review energy projects are the Canadian Energy Regulator Act, the filing manuals and the Canadian Energy Regulator Onshore Pipeline Regulations. Our impact assessments take into account a host of factors, including the environmental, health, social and economic effects of the project. The consultations we conduct on behalf of the Crown also take into account potential effects on the rights of Indigenous Peoples.
[English]
The CER, and the National Energy Board before it, have been conducting impact assessments, also known as environmental and socio-economic assessments, for more than 30 years. With the introduction of the Canadian Energy Regulator Act in 2019, the criteria for those assessments were updated to align closely with those used by the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada.
Bill C-39, together with recent amendments to the Impact Assessment Act’s Physical Activities Regulations, removes the requirement for integrated IAAC-led assessments on CER‑regulated projects. Thanks to our organization’s long history and deep expertise conducting impact assessments, as well as stringent regulatory frameworks for assessments under the Canadian Energy Regulator Act, we are confident the CER will continue to provide robust impact assessments and project reviews.
As an agent of the Crown, the CER continues to consult with First Nations, Métis, and Inuit throughout our regulatory processes, including project reviews, and we will encourage direct Indigenous participation to help identify and address potential project impacts. The commission’s process will continue to serve as the primary form for Crown consultation.
Reconciliation will remain central to our mandate and to how we approach implementation of the proposed legislative changes. We will continue to provide early and ongoing engagement with Indigenous Peoples, which reflects each energy project’s complexity and its potential impacts on Indigenous rights, while respecting community protocols, Indigenous knowledge and local capacity.
The proposed legislative changes in Bill C-39 reflect confidence in the CER’s ability to deliver robust, evidence-based decisions through efficient and streamlined regulatory processes. These changes would strengthen the CER Commission’s decision-making role, establish shorter statutory timelines for certain project applications, reaffirm the CER’s role in coordinating Crown consultation and expand our responsibilities for coordinating federal permitting processes.
The CER is well positioned to implement these changes. Our organization is made up of approximately 600 professionals, including engineers, scientists, inspectors, auditors, socio‑economic specialists, engagement specialists and economists who support the safe, efficient and environmentally responsible development of Canada’s energy infrastructure.
Our organization benefits from Indigenous representation throughout our staff and governing bodies, including an Indigenous Advisory Committee, which provides advice and guidance to our board of directors.
The CER has already taken steps to improve the efficiency of major project reviews, including streamlining application completeness reviews, clarifying commission decision factors, standardizing hearing procedures and managing motions more effectively. This work sets us up for success with the new shortened timelines proposed in Bill C-39.
In closing, I would like to thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak with you today, and I very much look forward to your questions.
The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Sletto.
Mr. Tremblay.
Pierre Tremblay, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission: Thank you, chair.
Honourable senators, good afternoon. I am the President and Chief Executive Officer of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, or CNSC.
[Translation]
Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today.
[English]
I would also like to acknowledge that we are gathered on the traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabe Peoples.
My opening remarks will outline the CNSC’s mandate and role as an agent of the Crown, the responsibilities proposed for the CNSC under Bill C-39 and how we will implement these changes while maintaining rigorous assessments, meaningful and Indigenous consultation and public participation.
For 80 years, the CNSC has served as Canada’s independent life cycle regulator, protecting the health, safety and security of all people in Canada and the environment.
[Translation]
The CNSC provides regulatory oversight throughout a nuclear facility’s entire lifespan — from site preparation and construction through operation, decommissioning and, ultimately, abandonment.
[English]
As an agent of the Crown, we are committed to building trust in advancing reconciliation with a focus on engagement and consultation with Indigenous nations and communities. This is carried out in a manner that respects and upholds Indigenous and treaty rights, honours the Crown’s obligations and aligns with the principles set out in the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act.
We are also carefully reviewing Friday’s Federal Court of Appeal decision on the matter of Canadian Nuclear Laboratories and Kebaowek First Nation to understand its implications for our work.
[Translation]
We remain dedicated to evolving our engagement and consultation approach to advance reconciliation through respectful, sustained relationships.
[English]
The proposed legislative changes in Bill C-39 have important implications for the CNSC and reflect confidence in our ability and readiness to deliver robust, science-based and risk-informed regulatory oversight for Canada’s nuclear sector without compromising safety, environmental protection and consultation and Canadians’ needs.
The amendments to the Impact Assessment Act proposed in Bill C-39 would establish the CNSC as the sole, responsible authority for conducting impact assessments for designated nuclear and uranium projects. It would also formalize the CNSC’s role in coordinating Crown consultation activities and related federal authorization processes for these projects.
The CNSC is well positioned to assume these responsibilities, having historically carried out consultation activities for many other projects. The change will support efficiency efforts and simplify the experience of Indigenous nations with a single point of contact.
[Translation]
The CNSC has worked closely with the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada for many years. Our organization is made up of more than 1,000 professionals, including engineers, scientists, inspectors and engagement specialists, whose expertise supports rigorous, evidence-based assessments and strong regulatory oversight.
[English]
Importantly, the proposed amendments would not change the fundamental requirements or rigour of impact assessments. Nuclear projects will be governed by the same legislation that defines IAAC-led assessments of non-nuclear projects. Projects will continue to undergo a comprehensive review, and opportunities for public participation will remain available. Indigenous consultation and engagement would continue to be central components of project assessment and regulatory decision making.
[Translation]
The CNSC’s rigorous licensing process will continue to ensure that proposed projects do not present unreasonable risks to the health, safety and security of all people in Canada and the environment.
[English]
If the amendments are adopted, we will manage the transition carefully and collaboratively. Existing relationships, consultation activities and commitments would be respected throughout the process. The CNSC has long-standing relationships with federal and provincial partners, Indigenous nations and communities, project proponents and licensees, host communities and with the public. These relationships provide a strong foundation for implementing any changes that may result from Parliament’s consideration of the legislation.
[Translation]
The added responsibilities will have resource implications, but we are preparing, and working to ensure that we have the capacity to meet those increased responsibilities.
[English]
In closing, the CNSC is prepared to take on the responsibilities proposed in Bill C-39, while maintaining the rigorous, transparent and evidence-based oversight that Canadians expect.
Thank you. My colleagues and I look forward to answering questions you may have.
The Chair: Thank you to our witnesses. We’ll go to our questions from our senators now.
Senator Yussuff: Thank you, witnesses, for being here today. My first question will go to Mr. Tremblay. Toward the end of your remarks, you said, “on reasonable risk.”
We’ve had a long history of nuclear safety in this country. We’ve had maybe one incident that I could remember in my lifetime, but I think it speaks remarkably to the rigour applied to nuclear safety throughout the country.
Obviously, this legislation is trying to provide a much-hastened way to have projects approved. Could you say for certain before this committee and Canadians that we’re not risking public safety in regard to the speed and the efforts of the government to get projects certified so they could proceed; in the background, of course, recognizing the history of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission in ensuring almost all of the nuclear facilities we’ve built in this country have had a tremendous track record that Canadians can be proud of?
Mr. Tremblay: Senator, thank you for that question. As noted in my remarks, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission — and prior to that the AECB — has for over 80 years assured safety for Canadians. Generally, it has been predominantly one technology, and there are new technologies moving forward.
I can give you, as an example, the Darlington New Nuclear Project, which is not a new technology project. Those projects take a long time to develop. We worked with the proponent — in this case it was Ontario Power Generation, or OPG, and the vendors — to assure ourselves that the design is robust and safety is assured.
So once we make the determination that the design has moved forward and that the power plant and the operators are in a position to proceed with their licence application, we’re prepared to do that in an efficient manner.
The timeframes that are laid out in the proposed bill are achievable, in our view, and are protective of both the environment and of the public.
This project, as an example that I am providing you, has been ongoing for over a decade. So when we get to the decision-making process, there’s been a lot of collaboration, a lot of reaching out to Indigenous communities and a lot of reaching out to the communities themselves. Our focus is on safety, and while there is a focus on efficiency, we will never compromise safety. That’s our number one objective for all Canadians.
The Chair: We’re trying our best to keep the questions and the answers to four-minute slots so everyone has an opportunity.
Senator Wilson: First of all, I should probably disclose that I spent the last several years of my career working very closely with Mr. Hubbard at the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, and I can attest to the professionalism of Mr. Hubbard and his entire team. At some point during this discussion, I’m hoping to get around to project timelines and have a conversation about that. And I can tell you that the timeline delays that we read about in the paper are not as a result of the work of the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada but other factors.
But I want to start with Indigenous consultation. With the movement of Indigenous consultation over to the Major Projects Office with those projects, I have been hearing from First Nations and reading in the media about concerns not just the timelines around the consultation, but their capacity to deliver this. We’re talking about quite a restructure of agency responsibilities with respect to Indigenous consultation.
I would be interested in hearing your thoughts in terms of how you are going to be prepared to implement this. You all spoke a little bit during your intros with respect to making sure that you have teams in place who have relationships and are able to actually deliver the quality consultation that we require.
Also, what perspective do you have on standing up these new consultation rules for groups like the new transportation agency that will look over transportation projects as well as what you know of what’s been happening with the Major Projects Office. We’re hoping to have them come here at some point as well.
Mr. Hubbard: Thank you for the question. It is an important one because Crown consultation is an overarching duty and cuts across all of our legislative frameworks. It is not impacted by the changes that are proposed in this bill, and our obligations remain in place. What is changing, though, is how we coordinate ourselves to be able to carry out those conversations and look to organize ourselves more efficiently to be able to carry out these consultations once rather than through a myriad of different approaches and processes.
We think that this will improve consultations in a number of ways, including addressing one of the long-standing concerns that we’ve heard from Indigenous partners across the country about consultation fatigue and being able to have a robust consultation with the right people, at the right time, to be inclusive of all of the issues that matter to the communities that we’re working with and be able to have all the partners at the table to ensure that we know who is responsible for each issue and can address those through these processes.
We have heard consistently that the one-year timeline can be a challenge and that the communities we are working with will need the capacity to be able to participate at the pace that the federal government is looking to move through these approaches and processes.
As Mr. Tremblay mentioned, our approach begins well before the clock starts, and we will be working with proponents across the country to encourage them to begin consultations early in their project planning process, to provide them support and advice in terms of how to engage communities and build partnerships ahead of regulatory applications. We will be starting our consultations with communities well in advance of the beginning of the one-year timeline as well. We think that’s feasible.
In terms of capacity federally, to be able to instrument these changes, we have re-engineered our approach and processes, including through new cooperation agreements we’ve put in place with provinces across the country to enable us to focus our time, energy and resources on those issues that matter most from a federal jurisdiction perspective, including allocating more capacity, time and energy to carrying out our consultations.
[Translation]
Senator Gignac: Welcome to the witnesses.
First, I want to applaud the government’s initiative, specifically, its desire to become more efficient and avoid duplication. That said, I’d like to hear from Ms. Sletto, from the Canada Energy Regulator.
In Quebec, the Bureau d’audiences publiques sur l’environnement, or BAPE, conducts environmental assessments. Are there plans to avoid duplication between the assessments required at the provincial and federal levels? Will the effort to avoid duplication be dependent on agreements between Ottawa and Quebec City? Is Mr. Hubbard or one of the officials from the Energy Regulator able to answer my questions?
Ms. Sletto: Thank you for your questions. I’d like to answer in English.
[English]
Your question, I think, speaks to the intent behind some of these changes, but I would say that the intent to avoid duplication of processes or have, to the extent possible, an integrated assessment process with other decision makers in the case that you reference with the province has been present in the CER’s work for some time. The opportunity to be thinking through how to ensure that we can rely on CER processes, to the extent possible, to satisfy assessments that may be required of other decision makers, I think, is something that is already under consideration and something that we should continue to pursue.
In the context of specifically provincial permitting decisions or provincial perming authorities, I think the opportunity to really engage — often, those are project-specific conversations, so not every project would be coming to the CER for a decision. The vast majority of the decisions and applications that come to the Canada Energy Regulator are fairly straightforward. By way of context, we’ve had over 5,000 decisions that have been made since 2019. The vast majority of those are related to fairly straightforward matters, like export permits. Those that are related to project-specific applications — and there have been several hundred — where we have an opportunity to design a process that really does pursue that streamlining approach and the elimination of duplication. We are very interested in pursuing those.
[Translation]
Senator Gignac: The BAPE is Quebec’s environmental review board. If a pipeline project is on the table, will both the Energy Regulator and the BAPE review it — as is the case now — or would an agreement be reached in advance to avoid duplicative processes?
[English]
Ms. Sletto: Exactly right. Your question is challenging for me to answer in the hypothetical. We have our decision makers, both in terms of our independent commission, which is responsible for its processes and for matters before the commission, as well as decision makers in the province that would need to ensure that they’re thinking through what those process options are. I can assure you that the conversations around ensuring and working among the CER and other permitting authorities — in this case, it would have been in the context of the Bureau d’audiences publiques sur l’environnement, or BAPE — I think that’s absolutely worth pursuing. I would suggest that that can really be tailored to the projects that might benefit. It wouldn’t be necessary in all types of decisions, but I agree with you, it’s worth pursuing.
Those conversations among the hearing or permitting authorities can absolutely occur. I know it’s been a topic of conversation among provincial and federal permitting authorities in the past.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: My question is for Mr. Hubbard.
You can answer in the language of your choice.
At the beginning of your opening statement, you specified that you were an independent agency. How, then, can you accept that, under Bill C-39, the government is allowing proponents to start project work before you’ve even finished your assessment? Isn’t that a bit hard to understand, given that you won’t know the full environmental impact? Just building a road can cause changes. Is this a lack of respect for the independent agency?
Mr. Hubbard: Thank you for your question.
To begin with, I may have misspoke. Unlike the commission and the regulator, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada is not an independent organization. We work closely with our federal colleagues on all decisions and activities. We must comply with all federal requirements and regulations.
[English]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I’m conscious of that. What I’m getting at is, how can you be seriously considered as an agency if work starts on a project while you’re still assessing the risk to nature?
Mr. Hubbard: It’s proposed within the legislation, yes, the opportunity to be able to grant authorization for some early works, but the intention is not to enable full-out project development in advance of overall project decisions.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: What would be the criteria? Why would we do that?
Mr. Hubbard: We will be developing more detailed policy guidance on these provisions moving forward. It is an enabling authority, but we have run into many instances over the years in which we could have enabled more efficient project development if there had been clear authority to enable certain activities to proceed in advance of a decision.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: You’re saying you have no independence, which means if the government decides to start work on the project and you feel it was not a good idea, would you just not say anything?
Mr. Hubbard: I need to better understand that question. We do provide advice to ministers in terms of decisions. We do take many of these decisions independently from government, so I’m not sure if there’s some confusion here in terms of the provisions that you’re referencing in Bill C-5 —
Senator Miville-Dechêne: No, Bill C-39, early work. If you don’t agree, if you think it’s a bad idea, what are you going to do?
Mr. Hubbard: There would not be early works authorized without the advice and guidance of the agency, including any proposed mitigation measures, to ensure this could happen in an environmentally sustainable way. I’m confident there wouldn’t be adverse impacts on areas of federal jurisdiction.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I think I’m done. Thank you.
The Chair: For now. Thank you, senator.
Senator Quinn: Thank you, guests, for being here this morning.
My first question is for Mr. Hubbard. Last week, I had a good briefing from departmental officials. I was observing as the critic in the Senate. I was interested in the regions of designation. I understood from our briefing last week that for a designated region — it doesn’t say how big or how small — where there may be a number of projects that can take place but that are similar in nature, the one review, or one criterion, would be applicable for each of those similar projects. Yet, in yesterday’s article, by Althia Raj, she talks about how there’s no requirement that assessment consider the types of projects that could be authorized in the region. Does she have it right?
If we use the Ring of Fire as an example, where there are mining activities and maybe there will be a designation of a certain region, could something other than a mine be considered under the designation where there’s been pre-work done on environmental assessment approvals?
Mr. Hubbard: The provisions in the bill to amend the Building Canada Act would not amend the Impact Assessment Act in this area. It would amend our enabling authority, so there is still a lot of work required to put all the policy constructs in place around the creation of these zones, but it would be necessary to carry out a regional assessment in advance of identifying any new zones or regions of national interest moving forward. In doing that, we would need to be clear about what sorts of activities would be carried out within that zone and any conditions would need to be established after that regional assessment on the development. It would necessarily need to be the types of activities —
Senator Quinn: I’m conscious of the time, so I want a little clarity. Did she have it right? I understood it would be similar projects, and she’s saying that, no, it can be any type of project within a designated region — for example, a mine or data centre. Has she gotten it right?
Mr. Hubbard: It could be, but those types of activities would need to be identified in the regional assessment and the provisions in creating that zone —
Senator Quinn: You’d come back and apply it against a new — okay. I wanted to get clarity because I was a little confused from last week.
Coming back to my colleague’s questions, I was going to ask about work commencing prior to an environmental assessment impact authority being provided. I’ll use the mine as an example again. Is that like a road going to a potential location? If that’s the case, then, how do you deal with things like the crossing of rivers and streams at the end of UPA or other species at risk where a road may cross sensitive areas? How can we allow work to begin without the full assessment, and the acts affected be designated and understood?
Mr. Hubbard: As I mentioned, some of this is still to be defined in terms of policy guidance on how these provisions will be applied, but the intention would not be to approve activities that would have potential for significant environmental effects in areas of federal jurisdiction. It would look at routine activities and things that could help advance project development, not advance the entire project —
Senator Quinn: Should words to that effect be put in the bill so it’s clear it’s not a carte blanche to build the road and —
Mr. Hubbard: There are provisions that enable us to put in conditions around those authorizations. We would be able to put in place any mitigation measures that are necessary to ensure that anything that is authorized is managed.
Senator Quinn: So we need to ensure clarity in this bill. That’s what you’re saying.
Senator Prosper: Thank you to our witnesses. I have a question, and I’ll look to Mr. Hubbard and Ms. Sletto to provide comments.
The government says regulations will be amended to allow assessment timelines to be paused when Indigenous consultation requires more time. How would an affected nation request a pause, and who would decide whether or not to grant it? And if I could just put one more question in there, with respect to capacity funding within the context of the proposed Crown consultation hub, what happens when a community cannot meet that proposed timeline funding-wise?
Mr. Hubbard: Thank you for the question. We did hear during consultations on the draft report that it is important to have provisions within the framework to enable timelines to be extended if required to meet our consultation obligations. It is intended that, in the regulatory framework, we include provisions that enable us to extend those timeframes. I believe it would be a ministerial decision that would enable the suspension of timelines and that would enable consultation obligations to be met. Obviously, the agency would have a big role in providing advice and support to the minister in determining whether increased time is needed to be able to discharge our constitutional obligations.
Senator Prosper: What happens if there’s no agreement consultation-wise if it goes beyond the extension? Who makes the decision, and is there any role the First Nation has with respect to that decision?
Mr. Hubbard: Certainly, there is a reciprocal obligation between the Crown and First Nations in carrying out consultations, so we would be working with our First Nations partners from the outset to carry out consultations within this approach and process and to provide advice in terms of the issues that we are seeing, and to the extent that there are real issues that require and would benefit from increased time before decision making, we will provide that advice to our minister.
Ms. Sletto: Similarly, in our bill, the proposed changes under Bill C-39 have specific provisions for making some amendments to how extensions could be considered or granted. It depends on the nature of the project that would be before the commission or before the Canada Energy Regulator. In some cases, it would be the commission that would determine whether a time limit needs to be extended. In some cases, it would be a commission’s recommendation to the minister, and the minister would determine that. It depends on the nature and type of project, and our bill has different categories of projects, which you will see in those provisions.
It’s typically through a hearing process that those issues are addressed, and I would say, as we’re working through those processes, but in the past, we’ve seen both parties involved in those conversations bring forward to the commission, or a panel of the commission, an issue with respect to the duty to consult or a request for more time, information or support to ensure that’s done. It could be that the panel or commission itself initiates a request for an extension. Ultimately, the responsibility to ensure that the duty to consult has been satisfied rests with those decision makers in the commission. In the case of those decisions made by the commission, it would be with the Governor-in-Council and the decisions that are left with them. That responsibility, I think, is important because those decision makers might end up needing time to ensure that the duty has been satisfied, and the advice that’s provided to those decision makers is sufficient to be able to assess impacts and provide the appropriate accommodation and mitigation of those implications.
It sounds like a complicated answer, but it does allow for flexibility in the provisions to make an appropriate decision, and there are different types of decision makers who would make that decision under the Canadian Energy Regulator Act.
Senator Mohamed: To all three witnesses, in assessing this bill, clearly you would have looked at risks and potential unintended consequences, so I’m wondering if each of you could please share what you saw as an unintended consequence of implementing this bill. On the flip side of that, what would you suggest is a good mitigation for that risk or unintended consequence, understanding that we want to also make sure that the implementation of this bill is optimized?
Mr. Tremblay: Thank you for the question, senator. From our standpoint, there are additional responsibilities coming to the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission.
We’ve had a safety and environmental and Indigenous consultation lens; we’ve not had a socio-economic lens, but we have been anticipating this. We work with Mr. Hubbard’s organization and understand the services they embrace, and so we’re mitigating that lack of knowledge.
By and large, what we’re finding is the work we do very much parallels what the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada has done. For example, Indigenous consultation. We’ve managed many files over the years where we are the lead and have that relationship. So there’s an increased level of effort and contact with Indigenous communities. There’s a registry, for example, that Mr. Hubbard’s organization has that is extremely good, and we intend on using.
So it’s a matter, really, of finding out where the best athletes are, what tools they’re using and embracing that. There is an impact on resources, and we’re working through that to understand. If this law were to move forward, we would move quickly to ensure there wasn’t a gap.
Senator Mohamed: Thank you.
Mr. Hubbard: Just to reiterate, we aren’t reducing or removing any environmental or consultation obligations through these proposed changes. We’re moving to advance these processes in a more efficient timeline. It really is the timeline pressures we’re facing to be able to deliver on these expectations.
We’re looking to reduce the risk and manage this by standardizing much of the routine parts of the process, to focus our time, energy and resources on the higher-risk, unique, project-specific issues that we’re facing, so we manage those parts robustly and ensure decisions factor in those core obligations.
Senator Mohamed: You don’t see any unintended consequences or risks you think you need to mitigate for?
Mr. Hubbard: We hear, and we’ve heard, that the timeline pressures are real. It’s going to require a concerted effort by all those involved in the processes to focus on the right issues in order to deliver this revised process successfully.
Ms. Sletto: I appreciate the question. As a safety and economic regulator, we really enjoy spending a lot of time thinking about questions on the risks.
I would answer in the way that speaks to risks associated with any change, and I would describe a few. One is the complexity of changes and a lack of clarity, or a potential lack of clarity. The mitigation to those risks, in any change, is to be transparent and clear, both in the process redesign elements of what is required out of a life cycle regulator when there’s a change to timeframes or a change to decisions of governance, but also to be really clear about the regulatory framework itself. What rules apply? What would be required in a filing manual? What kind of information is required in any decision?
I would say, in this regard, when we’re looking at changes that would shorten the timelines for decision making, one of the things that really helps position life cycle regulators — such as the CER — for success in navigating these changes with our partners and rights holders and stakeholders, is to really focus on things that can be managed outside of a specific hearing process, where issues can be identified early — with proponents, with the regulator, with communities that might be impacted by these projects or infrastructure — and mitigated and resolved before a hearing even takes place. That’s very effective.
The other thing we are very much investing in is relationship building and issue management over the life cycle of any project. When we’re thinking about the construction and operation of pipelines, for example, those relationships built over the long-term with those communities that are impacted help improve both the capacity of communities to work with us and our own capacity to understand what issues of concern there might be present in that infrastructure.
So what we see is almost a virtual circle of being able to continue those relationships and conversations over time. Those mitigations help to really strengthen the CER’s ability to focus attention on decisions needed in a hearing, and to issues that really need to be managed in that hearing. There are several things that can be managed both in advance of and later in the process.
Those relationships are key; collaboration is key. I would say that continued commitment to transparency, clarity and predictability of the process is going to be effective mitigation to some of the risks you might be thinking through.
Senator Mohamed: Thank you for that very thoughtful answer.
Senator Cuzner: Thank you. I believe this is probably for Mr. Hubbard. It’s a little off, but it’s a real life story.
I know my colleague, Senator Prosper, and I, being from Nova Scotia, we lived through the Sydney Tar Ponds remediation — a forty-hectare contaminated swath of land on the site of a former steel plant that was laden with a million tonnes of PCBs and PAHs. Now it’s the site of soccer fields and ball fields, and we had Aerosmith there last year, but it was once referred to as the most toxic site in North America, which wasn’t really helpful to our tourism sector.
But the timelines that have been brought up in past questions, when it came down to doing the final review on the tar ponds clean-up, it came down to a decision. The province was advocating for a comprehensive study, and the federal government was being pushed by Sierra Club Canada to do a full-panel review. At this time, Stéphane Dion was the minister of the environment, and Scott Brison was minister of public works, and they supported the full panel review. But they put stipulations around it that it be done within a year and that whatever remediation was chosen would be done within the envelope of the $400 million allocated between the provinces.
Is it common that a minister would put a timeline on a project like that? What would have been the secret sauce of getting it done within a year? Are there lessons from that experience that we can take, other than saying, we want it done in a year and within $400 million?
Can I leave those questions with you? The others can chime in too.
The Chair: Can we have an answer that’s shorter than the question?
Mr. Hubbard: I’ll endeavour to do my best. It is a good question. We’ve had a lot of experience looking at major projects across the country that we can learn from, both what worked and what didn’t.
One of the things that we’ve learned over the last number of years — and Senator Wilson alluded to one of the projects we worked on together — a lot of the delay can come from the information required to move into the regulatory process and being able to identify what’s needed to support decision making. To be able to focus on core issues that are going to matter and support decision making. Whether it’s a panel or whether it’s an agency-led assessment, clarifying up front what information is needed to support decision making and not having a moving target are things that we have clearly learned.
Whether that’s setting up an independent panel and giving them a clear mandate of the key issues to be addressed and resolved, or whether it’s the agency providing guidance to a proponent of what information and being clear up front about what the core issues are. Early engagement and consultations help to inform and identify those issues early on.
Cost is another driver on these things, for sure. Remediation projects, or any other investment, being able to control those costs.
One of the things included in this proposed bill is building requirements into the framework to ensure mitigation measures are technically and economically feasible. It’s something we’ve always built into the consultation approach and process, but this clarifies within the legislative framework that it is a requirement to consider and ensure, as regulators, that the conditions we’re putting in place around different aspects of project development can be feasibly implemented, and economics are a big part of that feasibility as well.
The Chair: Time is up.
Senator Duncan: Thank you to the panel for being here today. In the interests of time, maybe I could have an answer in writing as opposed to verbally. I’d just like to lay out the question.
The three territories have their own assessment processes in Bill C-69, which we debated some years ago. Nine sections of that act reference the various territorial agencies. These environmental and socio-economic assessments are based on modern treaty foundations and significant consultation and participation. We need to recognize that these boards are a work in progress. The Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board, or YESAB, is only 20-plus years old, for example. The recently approved in Royal Assent received on the TGG treaty in the Northwest Territories will give the community of Norman Wells and the TGG a seat on the Mackenzie Valley Review Board.
These newer agencies are also, as I said, a work in progress. The Government of Yukon has written to Minister LeBlanc about some of the current issues before YESAB. There is a list of them. They’ve also received recognition that Bill C-39 does not fundamentally change these processes in the North.
My question for Mr. Hubbard and Ms. Sletto is: Have we learned from these processes? At the same time, are we also offering some expertise, not in the Ottawa paternalistic manner, but in a here’s how we can help you manner? I’ve heard “capacity” and “relationship building.” Are we developing that relationship? We need to think with a lens that is not across the country but throughout the country.
Finally, can I just ask, in terms of the nuclear commission, there is significant talk of the development of nuclear energy and micro nuclear reactors for the North, which are desperately needed? Has your agency interacted with these three agencies in the North? Are you working with them toward possibly reviewing a project in the North? If I could, I’d like to have a response in writing.
The Chair: We have time for one answer.
Mr. Hubbard: You’re absolutely right. The Impact Assessment Act does not apply in the majority of the North. Those processes have been replaced by processes developed under land claim agreements. That said, we have established mechanisms to be able to share information and best practices with each of those organizations in each of the territories. We also have mechanisms federally and shared governance to be able to provide advice and support through our colleagues at Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada in the Northern Projects Management Office to ensure that those organizations can benefit from the same federal expertise that the agency benefits from regarding projects south of 60. So, yes, those mechanisms are in place, and, yes, we work together to share experiences to try to learn from each other.
Senator Boehm: I thank the witnesses for being here. I’m the Senate sponsor of this bill, so you can expect my questions to be exceptionally friendly and hopefully not cloyingly so.
We all agree that the intent of this bill is to move from sequential approvals to concurrent approvals, and we have, of course, the national interest that still needs to be refined. There is a certain amount of discretionary authority there.
I am wondering whether, in the development of this legislation, was there any look at best practices in other countries that have similar conditions as we do? So a large territory, bountiful resources, Indigenous populations — I’m thinking particularly of Australia, maybe New Zealand. Is there anything on the best-practices side that you would have looked at, or is this all a very sui generis Canadian project?
Mr. Hubbard: A lot of the proposed changes are really about better organizing our own federal house to be able to deliver on these assessments, but we do review developments in other jurisdictions. We do receive information from stakeholders about what’s working in other jurisdictions on an ongoing basis. Australia is one example. We also obviously look at what’s happening in developments in the United States, New Zealand, the U.K. and other organizations. We belong to an association called the International Association for Impact Assessment. We’re kind of widely recognized as part of that organization as one of the leaders in terms of our practices and approaches. But that doesn’t mean we can’t learn from others in terms of what they’re doing in this space and what jurisdictions around the world are trying to find ways to improve the efficiency of their processes to lead to better, faster decisions without compromising the reasons why these systems are in place and, in this case, our environmental obligations and consultation and duty to consult.
Senator Boehm: If I may, would you agree that if this all works, we could be an example for others?
Mr. Hubbard: Agreed.
Senator Boehm: Thank you.
Senator Clement: Hello, and thank you for your testimony and, indeed, for your work and careers.
I heard you all reference the economy in your comments. Many Canadians are worried about the economy, but also some are worried about the economy taking up so much space that other issues are not being protected. Some Canadians hear streamlining, cutting red tape and worry about what is taken off the table.
You’ve referenced how many people work for your agencies. Have you had cuts in your agencies? Because it seems to me like the government is not reducing obligations, but layering on potentially extra work for your organizations, and now you have to do the same amount of work, but in reduced timelines. Can you speak to the inherent contradictions in all of that?
Mr. Tremblay: Thank you for the question. It is top of mind. What we find — because we collaborate internationally with all nuclear authorities around the world, particularly with the U.S. and the U.K. — is there is a large focus on getting things done more efficiently.
We find those collaborations helpful because we generate ideas and thoughts on how to do things and how to use technology to improve the frequency of our oversights. I would say there is a recognition that the nuclear environment is a growing environment in Canada. We feel comforted that we’ve been given the resources necessary to do the work. That’s not to say that there isn’t oversight over the money that’s spent and the efficiency for Canadians. We feel that, and we ensure that we scrub our costs carefully.
But there is recognition. We have four major projects in the planning phase now, some for large reactors. We have the existing fleet in oversight. It’s a constant push and pull. I would say our international collaboration allows us to do more work with expertise that we wouldn’t necessarily have. For example, the BWRX-300 that is being constructed at Darlington is a boiling light water reactor. That’s not a technology we have overseen, but the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission is very familiar with that. We’ve worked with them to understand that technology, get our people competent and look at what inspections need to be done, and we’ve leveraged that. Those are just a few examples. I’m sure others can speak to that as well.
Ms. Sletto: Perhaps if I may. The start of your question was really focused on cuts, and I can confirm that the Canada Energy Regulator has not had any reduction in resources. We were exempted from the expenditure review, and part of our funding model for the energy regulator is a dynamic model, very much dependent on the work that the regulator has before it, but it’s also cost-recovered. The vast majority of our funds are recovered from the industry that we regulate.
But you spoke about resource demand. I think what we see right now is a change to our adjudication activity associated with this bill related to those elements that we’ve already outlined that are changing. The change in our process certainly requires a skillset that we need to resource and support in terms of process redesign. We have a very talented and skilled staff. They’re quite excited by the idea of being able to lean into that efficiency and lean into that regulatory improvement and regulatory excellence.
The key question for us is really how can we explore those efficiencies without compromise to our safety mandate and the duty to consult? And that’s a journey that the Canada Energy Regulator, we started some time ago. You would have seen pretty significant changes in the way that we approach red-tape reduction and some of those process efficiencies over the last several months.
We think we can go further in terms of being able to think through those process redesigns and changes that streamline, improve efficiency and capitalize and leverage digitization. We use tools like AI to help us with our processes, and I think this will be quite helpful.
That being said, if we see a significant increase in the number of projects that are coming before us to adjudicate, that’s a portion of, not the full extent of our work, or an increase in the infrastructure that we oversee. Currently, we oversee about 73,000 kilometres of pipeline infrastructure, for example. If that changes or we see a material shift in the work that’s required in our oversight mandate, that resourcing consideration will be present for us, but at present, these changes are ones that we’re managing through our own internal reallocation and building on the design and process efficiency work that we had under way.
[Translation]
Senator Martel: I think Bill C-39 is well intended, aimed at reducing delays and speeding up the process. We’ve seen that investors no longer want to invest in Canada, because the process takes too long and costs too much.
You talked about cooperating with the provinces. If a province refuses to approve a project that already has federal approval, what happens, practically speaking? Does the project go ahead anyways, or does the province’s right to refuse stand?
Mr. Hubbard: It depends. I can’t give you a single example or answer that covers all projects. It depends on whether the project is federal or provincial and who has the decision-making authority. In the case of federal projects, the government said that it wants to work closely with provinces to extend its support.
Senator Martel: From what I can tell, cooperation will be very important. Social licence is an issue that comes up a lot, and there’s something bothering me. Oftentimes, certain projects don’t move forward, because the social licence isn’t there. Is there a definition for social licence? Does it come from one person, three people? Does support have to be unanimous? Are people surveyed?
I think social licence is still vague. Is there a way to measure or ascertain where it stands?
Mr. Hubbard: Yes, of course, it’s vague, but it’s very important.
Senator Martel: How do you define it? It’s important, I agree. Do the majority of people have to be onside, two people? Social licence is a hard thing to define. According to some, there is no social licence in the city of Montreal, but there is in the regions. That’s why I’m asking.
Mr. Hubbard: When the government makes decisions, it has to have a clear understanding of the concerns of the public, Indigenous Peoples and other interest groups.
Senator Martel: Thank you.
[English]
Senator Patterson: I’m going to follow on with this question. Looking into the bill under Part 1, Division 1, clauses 70 to 90, which talk about a number of processes relating to how to make decisions when there is a disagreement, et cetera. But I’m not clear on the following, and if I can’t see it, maybe those watching can’t either: Can you simplify how an Indigenous nation, et cetera, can actually lodge a complaint? I ask because we have other examples in the federal government. This is going fast. This is where people feel uncomfortable, even the RCMP. You have the Police Complaints Commission. How can groups make a complaint? It talks about proponents, authorities, the minister’s role and that of the Governor-in-Council.
In a simple fashion, can you explain how complaints can be made — not just through the official bodies? There is a lot of decision making when the authority thinks it’s adequate. There are many terms like that, but if I’m the person with a grievance. If you’re able to come up with a Coles Notes version, that would be helpful. It is a number of sections that talk about who can do what, who can make decisions when, how long, what to do and how to suspend, but what I don’t see are the groups that Senator Martel was talking about or even if an Indigenous nation has a complaint. Thanks.
Ms. Sletto: That is a very large question; both of them are, obviously. I will observe that there are processes through quasi‑judicial bodies like the commission. The hearing process is designed to ensure that if parties have concerns, issues or impacts they want to raise for decision makers to consider, that process is designed to be able to adjudicate those kinds of matters. But I will also share how important it is to design and deliberately support engagement mechanisms outside of those processes because sometimes the concerns aren’t necessarily specific or related to a concrete matter that requires adjudication. Those can be matters that are best — and arguably appropriately — determined through those quasi-judicial processes. But the importance of designing relationships and having collaborative engagements outside of those processes and having a staff organization that values that, invests in that and sees engagement as fundamental to being able to help resolve issues are critical. I say that because there is a holistic conversation often regarding these kinds of issues, some of which require adjudication and some of which do not. Some require issue resolutions outside of those processes. That’s how I would attempt to answer your question.
Mr. Tremblay: If I could add to that the Canada Energy Regulator and the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission are lifetime regulators. We have a long-term relationship with those communities. We start from that premise. We establish a relationship and try to understand what their aspirations are, what their concerns are and their desire to participate. We start from that. In practical terms, we see an evolution. The proponents get into that community. If it’s a new community or if it’s an existing one, there are, possibly, legacy issues to deal with, but we get a very good sounding of the community’s issues and concerns. Typically, those move forward as proponents elaborate on their projects and as we start looking at things.
When the commission makes a decision, it makes three decisions around impact assessment and environmental protection; the safety and control areas — whether it is safe to do and is protective of the environment and the people; and the duty of the Crown. Has this duty been maintained, have there been proper discussions and have the issues been dealt with?
Typically, what happens is that these evolve. They start in a certain place and evolve with time, as the community has a better understanding of the potential impact and as they start working with the proponent. We certainly saw it in the mines in the Athabasca Basin of northern Saskatchewan, for example. There was a development of that relationship and a pull from those nations regarding whether they could get involved with the project, whether they wanted it and certain aspects of the project that were bothering them. It’s an evolution; it takes time to develop these things. If it doesn’t happen well before the application, it’s not going to go well for the proponent.
The Chair: Once again, I would like to thank our witnesses for taking the time to be with us this afternoon and answering our questions. I realize that there are many other questions. We didn’t reach a second round even though we had a list.
Honourable senators, we are now pleased to welcome, as individuals, Dr. Robert Gibson, Professor, School of Environment, Resources and Sustainability, University of Waterloo; and Arlene Kwasniak, Professor Emerita of Law, University of Calgary, via video conference. From West Coast Environmental Law, we have Anna Johnston, Staff Lawyer. Welcome, and thank you for joining us.
We will move to remarks, starting with Mr. Gibson, followed by Ms. Kwasniak and Ms. Johnston. The floor is yours for five minutes each.
Robert Gibson, Professor, School of Environment, Resources and Sustainability, University of Waterloo, as an individual: Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. I have been involved in assessment work for 50-some-odd years, so I should know something about the topic.
I would like to talk about three things: objectives, efficiencies and regional assessments.
Concerning objectives, Bill C-39 and other national-interest initiatives are meant to strengthen Canada’s resilience and other capacities to deal with increased political and economic turbulence, globally. However, we have had flying-by-the-seat‑the-pants experiences in applying the Building Canada Act without consistently applied criteria for national-interest projects.
Before moving on to national-interest regions, we need to establish clear objectives. For that, we need to understand the turbulence risks and the opportunities to be faced.
There are two main possibilities: Option one is that the current economic and political turbulence is exceptional, driven by forces south of the border and appropriately approached via a big and fast one-time response. That’s what we seem to have been assuming to date.
Option two, in contrast, is that many more fundamental drivers of turbulence are involved and will continue to get worse and are best approached through a long-term strategy as well as immediate action.
The many global drivers of turbulence now include worsening climate change; increasingly nationalistic, territorial and combative politics and economic aggression; concentration of wealth in fewer hands; declining ecological services; and rising migration pressures. All of these, and more, interact as a vicious cycle to increase global turbulence. If that’s to be faced, it would be prudent for the Senate to push for explicit national-interest objectives tied to a long-term resilience strategy and use these as guidance for transparent and defensible decisions on national-interest projects and regions.
My longer notes look at some implications should you like to pursue them.
Reducing process inefficiencies is also a worthy objective and also has options that need rethinking. Here the contrasting options of the current approach, which sees assessment and permitting as red tape to be removed or expedited to the extent possible, retaining only basic permitting to mitigate the worst environmental effects.
The more beneficial combination is the other option. That would centre on eliminating well-recognized actual inefficiencies, constitutional and administrative fragmentation, limited collaboration, poor alignment of requirements, performative practice and so forth, and focusing on what matters most. That is anticipating cumulative effects, finding the best alternatives and delivering multiple mutually reinforcing gains. Again, that’s open to discussion.
Finally, on regional assessments, as presented in Bill C-39, “regions of national interest” sound like sacrifice zones. If we really want positive regional as well as national futures, Bill C-39 must set out how regional assessments will ensure such futures. The current bill provides no useful guidance.
Appropriate specifics in Bill C-39 would require regional assessments to examine potential national and regional gains and risks and their distribution over the long-term, positive and adverse cumulative effects, major alternatives, opportunities for delivering multiple benefits efficiently and grounds for Indigenous consent and needs for continuing project support and regional governance arrangements.
Further specifics are needed for potentially appropriate processes. The recent temptation has sunk to speedy performative regional assessments done in a few months with no attention to cumulative effects or regional options beyond standard permitting. That seems cynical and useless.
Fortunately, we’ve had a wide range of past experience with flexible approaches to regional assessments and the equivalents in Canada. We can easily set out the fundamentals of what can work and what can’t. Again, there are particulars in my longer notes.
In closing, I’ve merely illustrated three areas where the agenda and substance of Bill C-39 are deeply problematic. Basic rethinking is needed throughout. The steps I’ve recommended would merely reduce deficiencies and misdirections.
Thank you for your consideration. I appreciate that these are difficult matters.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Gibson.
Ms. Kwasniak?
Arlene Kwasniak, Professor Emerita of Law, University of Calgary, As an individual: Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak to this extremely important bill. As we all know, a cornerstone of sustainable development is impact assessment because, through impact assessment processes, regulators and assess the environmental, social and economic consequences of proposed projects, to assist them in determining whether they should be approved and, if so, under what conditions.
Because of Impact Assessment, or IA — at least as we’ve known it — projects are better planned, less controversial and have reduced and mitigated environmental impacts.
Bill C-39, together with the earlier bill — Bill C-5, the Building Canada Act, now law — constitutes an exodus from the way the federal government has done its traditional role in assessment. In doing so, it has departed from some democratic processes traditionally characteristic of assessment legislation in various ways, including centralizing decision-making power, relying on increased executive discretion and permitting the departure from the rule of law.
I will talk about three things. I might not get to the third if you cut me off, and that would be fine; you can then rely on my notes. One is the timeframe. Another is a departure from the rule of law and comparison to emergency legislation. Then I have a bit on the alleged overlap and duplication, and some of the responses, which I think are questionable.
The timeframe for this review is completely unrealistic and unfeasible. The bill itself is 250 pages. It’s complex, multi-level and rife with legal, practical and constitutional and Charter issues that affect all Canadians. I will address only Part 1 of the bill, of course.
The importance of having federal impact assessment legislation is evidenced by the history and past consultation processes that the government has employed in reviewing proposed legislation and policy.
Going back to the Environmental Assessment and Review Process, or EARP, as we all remember from practically 40 years ago, that review going to the first Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, or CEAA, was five years. The subsequent reviews of the CEAAs were three to five years, taking you up to the Impact Assessment Act, which has its own review period, which would occur in 2029 if we waited that long.
All of this indicates the importance of the impact assessment and the need for the public and for all the other people involved in it and touched by it to be consulted not only with the review of the legislation but on the development of it.
This timeframe for Bill C-5 and Bill C-39 has been weeks or days even. It’s truly unacceptable. I recommend that you either make longer timeframes or just reject the bill in its entirety and start over so that the public and everyone who needs to be consulted can be involved in the planning and the development of the bill and not just in the review of a massive omnibus bill.
Second is the departure from the rule of law and comparison to emergency legislation. We know that the rule of law in a democratic society is extremely important, that the rule of law requires that all persons, institutions and entities, including the state itself, are accountable to laws, public and private, and that laws are publicly promulgated, equally enforced and independently adjudicated. We have the principle of supremacy of the law, so it can’t be changed arbitrarily or by the executive, and procedural and legal transparency is required.
Emergency legislation is meant, in part, to be able to depart from the rule of law because of a clear emergency. It could do things like depart from the way a law would normally treat events and activities. Emergencies are usually such things as floods and fires and war, those kinds of things. Yet Bill 39, and Bill C-5 for that matter, have been touted as responding to emergency-type situations, whether threats from the south or other economic threats. The responses given by making and putting forward these bills have been accompanied with a sense of urgency as if they’re dealing with true emergencies.
One might have to ask yourself if this is emergency legislation; at least it should follow the features that emergency legislation needs to have. For example, a clear definition of what the emergency legislation is answering to, clear evidence that there is an emergency that triggers a departure from ordinary rules of law, that the emergency measures are directly connected to the emergency and not overly broad, and that there are sunset clauses and short timeframes for declaration so that the standard rule of law is restored. Why would —
The Chair: I’m sorry, I’m going to have to move on to our next witness here now because our time is limited.
Ms. Kwasniak: Sure.
The Chair: Ms. Johnston.
Anna Johnston, Staff Lawyer, West Coast Environmental Law: Thank you for the invitation to appear today. It is an honour to be here.
In the panel before this one, you heard the bill does not remove or undermine environmental standards. With the utmost respect to those witnesses, I disagree.
In my legal opinion, if Bill C-39 passes, it will result in an unprecedented dismantling of our environmental law safety net and is on questionable constitutional ground.
Under the Building Canada Act, the cabinet will be able to designate entire deregulation zones in which the president of the King’s Privy Council will be required to issue eligible projects their approval, and projects will be deemed to have satisfied all legal requirements, even if they have not done so.
For example, following the regional assessment in the Ring of Fire, every mine, transmission line, road and other project in that 5,000 square kilometre expanse could be eligible for automatic approval, even if it will cause effects so significant they are banned by law.
The Species at Risk Act says that the competent minister can only permit activities that affect a listed species if she is of the opinion that doing so will not jeopardize its survival or recovery.
Bill C-39 will deem the minister to have formed that opinion even if a project could cause species extinction, and clause 103 requires the president to issue that permit in the form of the conditions document.
As with Bill C-5, those deeming an automatic approval clause effectively do an end-run around the court’s ability to review the reasonableness of the government’s decisions, which is what puts Bill C-39 on such shaky constitutional footing.
The cabinet may establish eligibility criteria for projects in these regional zones, but those criteria can be as simple as saying the proponents must have a project description.
As Dr. Gibson has noted, neither the Impact Assessment Act nor Bill C-39 prescribe regional assessment processes, considerations or outcomes.
Bill C-39 is silent about whether or how regional assessments will ensure environmental protection. The broad discretions that it confers allows those regional approaches to be nothing more than rubber stamps.
The bill also confers staggering powers on unelected officials.
It will allow the Canada Energy Regulator to do an end-run around the cabinet by letting the commission exempt pipelines of any length — pipelines that normally require cabinet approval — from the need to seek that approval in the first place.
Clause 103 will allow the president to delegate his power to issue or amend conditions documents for projects in regions of national interest to public servants, including the Major Projects Office.
I want to acknowledge it is a tremendous concentration of power to take authorities that are usually exercised by multiple ministers and hand them to one single cabinet minister. To allow that minister to then delegate that array of the cabinet’s responsibilities to the civil service raises grave concerns about accountability and transparency.
What is more, those officials can then subdelegate their duties to anyone in their department. The list goes on, but mindful of the clock, I’d like to stress that environmental laws are not red tape; they are a safety net. Bill C-39 shreds that safety net.
The bill is fundamentally flawed and irredeemable, and should be scrapped, but should the Senate not vote the bill down, we have identified amendments to help mitigate its most harmful effects.
To start, the bill should prescribe considerations and minimum standards for regional assessments so we can be better assured that they will deliver strong environmental outcomes; it should mandate that project eligibility criteria include minimum environmental requirements; it should be amended to remove or, at the very least, curtail ministers’ ability to weaken or remove existing conditions of approval; and the same should happen for the ability to authorize construction before assessments are completed.
We recommend deleting the clause that would let the energy regulator exempt pipelines of any length from approval processes, and we would like to see the sunset clauses kept and retain the current timing of public disclosure requirements for conditions documents.
I see that my time is up, chair. I will be happy to further elaborate in response to questions.
The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Johnston. We’ll go to our first question from senators.
Senator Yussuff: Thank you, witnesses, for being here.
All three of you, of course, provide quite an indictment on the changes this legislation proposes to enact. Is there anything positive in regard to this bill that you would support?
Ms. Johnston: As with Dr. Kwasniak, I would have to say I am only speaking to part 1. No, there is nothing in that bill that I think is salvageable.
I should caveat my comment about the Crown consultation hub. We are not an Indigenous organization and so can’t speak to that, but the bill is so fundamentally flawed that the damage it would cause both to democracy, the environment and communities’ well-being is too grave for this bill to pass.
Mr. Gibson: As I’ve argued, I think the basic objectives that underlie the bill are acceptable — necessary arguably — but the means by which they are to be adopted rely on assumptions that are not rationally defensible, given the evidence before us.
It’s quite clear that the kind of turbulence we now face is complex, long-lasting and requires a long plan. Doing things that sacrifice current commitments — kicking climate change down the road, yet again, since you started kicking it down the road in 1992 — is not acceptable, and that’s only one of the major considerations I’ve identified.
I think the difficulty is the fundamental approach that has been taken, not the objectives. I think, like many other people, the assessment processes that have grown up and expanded and entrenched and routinized themselves over the last 20 to 50 years, depending on where you are, are deeply problematic now and inefficient because they have tended to focus on routinized approaches instead of focusing on the big issues that we have a considerable record of doing very important improvements within Canada.
We can cite chapter and verse, should you wish, but they’re concerning big alternatives that make a difference to what the end result is, looking ahead to the legacy of our activities as opposed to just the immediate effects, considering those cumulative effects that interact, and considering positive effects where we could have mutually reinforcing gains if we looked at social and ecological considerations as something that could be complementary to the economic ones.
In the real world, outside of academia and administrative worlds, all those things are one, as we are constantly reminded by Indigenous Elders, in meetings like the Ring of Fire.
If we don’t consider those things together, we cause trade-offs that are avoidable. If we kick all those concerns down the road, we end up with bigger problems when the turbulence will be worse.
Senator Gignac: Thank you to our witnesses. My question is for Mr. Gibson.
Canada is a decentralized country. I’m a former Quebec minister of natural resources and economic development. I appreciate your opening remarks because it’s an arbitrage between economic necessities but, as well, protect the environment as we try to find the right balance here.
I’m surprised to see this concept of regions of national interest. How could Ottawa decide, whether it is Quebec, B.C. or Manitoba, that this region is in the national interest and what that means exactly? Do the provinces need a veto right? Some companies will find that a nice fast track. Okay, go to regions of the national interest; I can build there and forget the provinces.
I don’t know if you have any time to analyze that aspect of the definition, a region of national interest, so we have greater parameters to define that concept. How do we define national interest, by the way? It is like social acceptance — you know what I mean.
Mr. Gibson: I’m glad that I have limited time to answer that question because it’s really difficult.
In principle or practise, we face this question in times of constitutional rulings by the Supreme Court and by lower courts who will get there. Those rulings have tended to fragment further the authorities of federal and provincial players.
The reference decision, the reference ruling from 2023, emphasized both the question of trespassing on provincial jurisdiction and the necessity in that context of collaboration to resolve these issues. The court’s direction on that is sensible and clearly necessary.
We should be looking at these regional exercises as ones where we have federal, provincial, and Indigenous authorities — in some cases it would be territorial authorities — because that’s where the distribution of power, influence and capacity lies. I don’t think there’s any short way around that. That is necessary. The collaboration is not a deferral from one to another. It uses powers and capacities in coordinated ways against deep traditional resistance, as we know.
Nonetheless, I don’t think there’s any other option. You set yourself up for constant conflict and litigation if you don’t do that.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I too am a senator from Quebec, and I’m interested in the matter of provincial and federal environmental assessments.
Bill C-39 says that assessments can be conducted jointly and that the province’s or federal government’s assessment responsibility can be transferred to the other. I’d like you to talk about that. I want to know whether you think the measure will indeed shorten the process without affecting the substance of the assessment. In other words, will the project still be assessed properly, even if there’s only one assessment, or do you think there are risks?
[English]
Ms. Kwasniak: I’ll say the following: I have looked at the issue of overlap, duplication and all of that in the past. A lot of it is fear mongering.
There are all kinds of ways to address inefficiencies in legislation through harmonization and coordination. It is not possible to have an effective multijurisdictional assessment when one of the parties, who inevitably will be the federal government, would drop out and leave their considerations to the other. That’s because there are areas of exclusive jurisdiction in our Constitution. The expertise to understand those areas is at the level of government that has those. Indeed, the other level of government cannot even pass legislation that is directly in that area.
There is a lot to lose for things by substitution. What is lost is not justified by any efficiency gains. Indeed, I’m not clear that there are efficiency gains because there may be a lack of appropriate consultation, litigation resulting and other losses when you don’t have a coordinated or harmonized assessment.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: Do you have anything to add?
[English]
Mr. Gibson: Yes. I think the tendency toward substitution is attractive because it looks easy. We’ve had a range or set of cooperation agreements developed by the federal government and the provinces. The notion is entirely sound in my view. Its practice is insufficient.
The difficulty is that most of the agreements that I’ve seen have emphasized providing the possibility of deferral, effectively, to provincial processes that are not as comprehensive as the federal one.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: In defence, in Quebec it’s considered quite comprehensive.
Mr. Gibson: Yes. The processes are evolving in various places and directions. The experience we’ve had most is with British Columbia, where the processes are relatively similar. That has been quite positive, mostly. I’ve had opportunities for complaining, but nonetheless.
There’s certainly a history of more or less collaborative effort that has been effective. The key test is effective in the long run, not whether you can get it done quicker, whether you’re going to have less conflict and litigation, and more mutual understanding among the parties, including proponents, critics, communities and First Nations, Métis and Inuit.
We tend to have a short-term perspective on what counts as efficiency. If we had a longer view about this, looking to the legacies of these projects, we’d have a different set of conclusions.
Senator Prosper: Thank you to our witnesses for being here and sharing your testimony. I have a question for Ms. Johnston.
You mentioned earlier in your testimony in response to a question from Senator Yussuff that this bill is fundamentally flawed. However, I want to further get your thoughts on this extensive bill.
Which proposed change do you think presents the greatest risk of serious or irreversible environmental harm? What evidence would you put forward to support that? What specific amendment would you put forward to address that? I know there are many flaws here — it’s a tough question — if there was one of those.
I know you went through a number of those proposed amendments. For the record, I invite you to provide anything further in terms of what you think are some of the most important areas for review or changes.
Ms. Johnston: I’ll try not to be cheeky and respect your, “I only get one.” One area I didn’t elaborate on in my opening remarks is around the amendments that will allow the president of the Privy Council to weaken or remove pre-existing conditions of approval that another cabinet minister imposed under other legislation.
The reason why that is of such concern is because of the Roberts Bank Terminal 2 port expansion in Vancouver. That project went through an environmental assessment under the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act 2012, and when it was approved, the previous environment minister imposed conditions on it relating to the protection of the Southern Resident killer whale, which is an endangered species. Those protections relate to the proponent has to come up with a plan to ship at night because the noise from these ships can interfere with the hunting of orcas.
After the bill was tabled, government sources leaked to the media that one of the rationales for these amendments was because those conditions at Roberts Bank Terminal 2 impede the project’s ability to proceed. What this amendment in Bill C-39 does is allow the president of the Privy Council to go in and lift those conditions of approval, even though doing so could be the final nail in the coffin of the Southern Resident killer whale.
It is staggering to me that one project is worth more than an entire species. It is a breathtaking power to confer, to allow a cabinet minister to override the Species at Risk Act and to override the science-informed decision of one of his colleagues.
Senator Mohamed: Thank you for your comments today. I hear the concern and the red flags loud and clear. I’m very aware of that when I ask this question, but I want to understand. We just heard that there will be additional resources, and that there is a streamlining of efficiencies in a positive way.
I want to understand if there is actual evidence that suggests that a one-year process leads to bad or poor decisions, because I think there is a real pressure around what we can do to make sure that economically we’re sound, growing and that the decisions we take are futuristic and not just for now. We might have a difference of opinion on that, professor. But I really want to understand — where have we seen that a one-year timeline reduces the quality of the decisions that are taken? Have we seen that?
Mr. Gibson: I don’t have a good answer to that, but I’ll give Ms. Johnston a moment to think about it. What I’ve seen — and not just directly because of this bill — is that we have been narrowing assessment processes by eliminating the planning element.
Assessment has been traditionally, going back more than 50 years, a planning process where the requirements are meant to force proponents in the public and private sector to think about things they didn’t normally think about. You had to have a law to drive it. Those things typically were: what is the actual need that’s being addressed; what are the alternatives for meeting that purpose; and which of those alternatives is the most desirable in the public interest as opposed to whatever narrow interest a particular agency or corporation has? And that has been enormously beneficial.
The greatest savings and the greatest positive effect of assessment processes over the decades in many jurisdictions have been forcing people to think about broader alternatives. What we’re doing with assessment — and not just in this legislation — is another opposite, as Ms. Johnston was saying. What we’re doing in this legislation is almost entirely eliminating the planning element and almost entirely eliminating the consideration of alternatives in any serious way.
Consequently, all we’re doing, essentially, is coordinating permitting more effectively than we have in the past — that is not a bad idea in itself — so that we get rid of or we try to prevent the most immediate, significant and adverse effects.
Senator Mohamed: Are you saying that one year cannot accommodate a planning period of time? You’re saying it’s just not possible within that one year that the planning part — because I understand that it’s important to get all the different views, but can that not be done in the one year?
Mr. Gibson: It’s not just the different views; it’s also the key different alternatives.
Senator Mohamed: All the steps that you need to do.
Mr. Gibson: In theory, you could, but in practice I’m seeing zero of that. I’m seeing the exact opposite. It’s all being eliminated, and it’s not within the timed period anymore. It’s mostly dumped on proponents. The proponents are the ones the law originally targeted — well, these people have a particular set of objectives. They’re going to think within that box. They’re going to choose maybe some adjustments of how the tailings ponds are done that maybe would be more useful to them or to the environment. That’s a very narrow set of things.
If we had time, I would tell you the story of the Voisey’s Bay nickel mine, where the main alternative was to reduce the pace and scale of extraction so the mine would last longer than the seven years initially predicted. So there would be some potential benefits for local people and some benefits for capacity building. That’s what we get if we do that. If we don’t do that, we miss a huge opportunity to benefit.
Senator Mohamed: Thank you, professor.
Senator Wilson: My question is for Ms. Johnston first. It’s primarily to do with your comments about any length of the pipeline being able to delegate it to officials. So my understanding, and my reading of the legislation, is that it occurs when it’s under an area of national interest region, an area designated under schedule C. Is that correct?
Ms. Johnston: No. I don’t have the clause in front of me, but it’s an amendment to section 214 of the Canadian Energy Regulator Act. So currently, section 214 allows the commission to exempt pipelines up to 40 kilometres long from the need to apply and obtain a certificate. What Bill C-39 does is expand on that power so the commission could exempt a pipeline of any length from the requirement to obtain a certificate, regardless of where it is.
Senator Wilson: Okay, thank you. I’ll take a closer look. That was my question.
Senator Patterson: Dr. Gibson, I thought you had a very compelling statement. We heard what you had to say in terms of this does not appear to be balancing the needs of our long-term future along with the potential crisis or the crisis we’re facing right now. You talked about a resilient strategy. As you know, there are other G7 nations that have a resilient strategy. The U.K. is about to publish theirs.
From your perspective, what would you see within the strategy? Would you see it as a framework or a strategy? And how could that impact what we’re doing right now?
Mr. Gibson: The key thing is, if we’re looking further ahead — as opposed to just an immediate emergency — and are thinking that the emergencies will get worse or could, then we have a much more precautionary approach to how we approach things like major projects.
We would want to ensure that they are flexible and may not be vulnerable to further upsets of various kinds and that they actually do improve our autonomy. They improve our resource base for our capacities to do stuff, but don’t add to public debt, for example, in the short term.
If we have that kind of immediate emergency action that sacrifices good stuff and it acts to public debt in the short term, then we’re not thinking in the long term about what capacity we will need to have in 15 or 25 years when climate change is certainly worse, and most of the other things I have talked about will be worse unless we get really brilliant internationally. It’s a precautionary thing.
Secondly, it is much more efficient for overall lasting well‑being to have benefits socially, ecologically and economically at the same time. We have long talked about balancing these things, and we’re about 50 years past when that was adequate. Mitigation was only adequate maybe 50 years ago.
What we need to do is build economies, societies and ecologies that are mutually self-supporting and enhancing, so we’re not trading them off all the time. This is all fairly abstract. You can think of very practical circumstances where we try to get all these benefits at the same time, and you can easily see how, if you do that, it’s way more efficient. You have one project delivering multiple benefits that support each other, as opposed to trading off where you have vicious circles of decline.
Senator Patterson: For our other two witnesses, is there anything you would like to add, particularly from the environmental protection perspective, in a resilient strategy? How should it read?
Ms. Johnston: One of the things that I’m really concerned about in this bill is I think it cuts out public participation almost entirely, and this goes back to Senator Mohamed’s question. By condensing these timelines and having automatic approval functions, you’re not engaging the public in the important dialogues about which values really matter to them. Where do you hunt? Where do you fish? Where do you recreate? We need to be building and planning for the environment that works for communities and for the public. It can’t just be on the hands of proponents and government officials.
Senator Patterson: Thank you.
Ms. Kwasniak: I just want to mention that changing from sequential to concurrent makes this a strategy that is just really unworkable and illogical. Any reasonable environmental assessment and project approval framework would have to do it sequentially, or else you just make a mockery of the assessment level.
Senator Clement: Hello, and thank you for your testimony. I have questions for each of you, and it’s going to be around the rule of law and the courts.
Doing end runs around courts makes me very nervous because, in this country, we have been able to have groups use courts to make sure that the government is accountable.
Ms. Johnston, if you could say more about public disclosure and end runs around Federal Court appeals, I would appreciate that. If you could also comment because I know you were listening to the testimony before. We heard that people were excited about process redesign and that they were not intimidated by Bill C-39 because there were internal reallocations and maybe the use of AI. If you could comment on that, I would appreciate it.
Professor Kwasniak, it was so clear when you were speaking about Bill C-5 together with Bill C-39. I understand your point there. If you could also comment on doing end runs around courts and what Bill C-39 is doing, I would appreciate that.
Professor Gibson, we’re sort of feeling like the use of red tape is bad. Are we saying that those agencies were doing a bad job before? You suggested that we should be looking at the lack of collaboration that currently takes place rather than cutting red tape.
Ms. Johnston: Your first question is a key area of concern for us under the Building Canada Act. When Bill C-5 was going through Parliament, it was amended to have these public disclosure requirements of information related to the conditions document that’s placed on projects of national interest. That information includes things like what advice the minister received from various officials, whether the government followed that advice and justification for departure from that advice. All of that information has to be posted on the public registry 30 days before the conditions document is issued, and Bill C-39 flips that disclosure to 30 days after. We’re quite concerned about that because, under the Federal Courts Act, applications for judicial review have to be made within 30 days of the decision. It could be 30 days of notice of the decision. It’s a little bit grey, but our big concern is that if you’re timing the public disclosure with the deadline for applying for judicial review, the public doesn’t know, and Indigenous Peoples don’t know what grounds they might have for seeking that review. That’s a critical concern.
To the second part of your question, when Bill C-5 was tabled, the Prime Minister was on the public record saying this is transformative legislation because it flips the decision from whether a project goes ahead to how it goes ahead. These regions of national interest take that approach and put it on steroids by saying once a regional review of any length and duration has been done, projects would get their automatic approval with no public participation. I’d say that’s much more than a process change.
Senator Clement: Thank you. Professor Kwasniak?
Ms. Kwasniak: I don’t know if I have much to add to that. I have to admit, I have not examined the whole 250 pages of the bill enough to see if there are specific clauses that would remove the authority of the courts more than were there before. I would be happy to do that and provide an answer.
Other than that, the decrease of environmental impact processes will, therefore, take away any court opportunities to challenge how those processes were carried out, like the planning stage. Other than that, I’m afraid I don’t have anything to add.
Senator Quinn: Thank you, folks, for being here today.
I just want to follow up a little bit on the discussion that we had with both panels and in other places about the one-year timeframe. I’m questioning the whole process that leads to an informed decision by a minister that is fed by public servants who are trained in science and different fields and who review all types of things, including a proponent’s submissions about their project.
Are we going down a path that is going to make decision making compromised? What are we doing with our public service, where we have trained individuals who are very much involved in those types of careers? How do we deal with that interdepartmental tension that’s always there to say, “You’re going to do this in a year”? At a briefing, one of my colleagues, who was a very experienced public servant at a provincial level, said, “Good luck with that.”
I’d just like to hear some comments on that; in particular, the effect that it’s going to have on our public service and their confidence in doing the jobs they were hired to do.
Ms. Kwasniak: I agree with you. I think it should be the government that must justify that one-year limit and put forward the evidence that this is reasonable and will work and that the public service can respond to it and do all the studies and everything else they need to do in order to be part of that timeline.
Indeed, I know you’re asking us, and maybe some of my colleagues on this panel can address your question, but I think it’s really the government’s role to answer that question and to say why they put that one year forward. Maybe it’s to limit inefficiencies, but there are consequences from it that might be quite inefficient.
Ms. Johnston: I share your concerns, particularly with the one-year timeline. One of the long-standing issues with impact assessments is that we put a lot of onus on proponents at the project level to do the studies and the cumulative effect assessments that really can only be done accurately and comprehensively at the regional level. Proponents are not the ones who should be responsible for doing that.
The problem with the bill, as Dr. Gibson noted, is that regional assessments in the last five years have been carried out with a huge spectrum of success, from fairly comprehensive to not so much. Right now, there is one being undertaken regarding offshore drilling in Nova Scotia that is being done in six months. That’s not enough time to gain credible information and do the baseline studies to inform project-level decision making, which is why we’re recommending that the Senate consider amending the bill to require that if regional assessments are going to enable these regions of national interest, they, at the very least, consider certain information, have meaningful engagement and have legislated outcomes, rather than just be used as check box exercises. That would be the responsibility of the civil service to conduct much of that regional assessment work.
Senator Duncan: Thank you very much for your presentations.
The North — and I’m speaking of the three northern territories specifically — has had success with projects that have proceeded without any local consultation in the past. Canada is a very young country, and I think we’ve learned significantly from that and now have three young, but effective, development assessment agencies in operation that collaborate with the North. My understanding is that they’re protected under Bill C-39, that they aren’t touched and that the development assessment processes in the North, which are based on modern treaty negotiations, will not be impacted. In my read of Bill C-39, I could find no references either, and I understand that a minister who has territorial discussions has indicated that. Yet you have suggested we not move forward with Bill C-39. You’ve also talked about improvements to assessment capacity, and we heard from the earlier panels about the level of collaboration.
My question is: Do you not believe that perhaps we’ve learned from experience, and have you looked at the territorial assessment operations and considered them in the context of how we’re moving forward as a country? Instituting timelines, for example, is a significant issue for the current operation of the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board, or YESAB. They’ve asked for improvements to that because timelines have dragged on for too long. Are there not things we can learn from these three northern assessment agencies?
Mr. Gibson: Yes. As you suggest, it’s an ongoing learning process and one driven by modern land claim agreements. Therefore, it tends to be more integrated and more comprehensive with limitations, but territorial processes mostly have a regional foundation. The Yukon, for example, has regional planning, which is not as broad as you might want for all the cumulative effects you might want to consider for development futures, but nonetheless, you have the broader considerations, at least, available to be addressed at the regional scale. Where you have that, it’s much easier to know what the rules are if you’re a proponent or a government agency with infrastructure.
We do this all the time in urban centres. We have multiple levels and planning that tell you what you need to do. You can get a variance at a more specific level. We seem to be allergic to that at the assessment level, with great resistance to doing reasonably comprehensive regional assessments. They’re not easy, but they have been done successfully in the territories. They’ve been difficult in the territories. However, where they’re in place, they are very useful in guiding what you can do as a proponent in reducing the front end of assessment requirements legitimately because they’ve been addressed adequately. If we look at cumulative effects and alternative development futures at a regional scale, that makes it much easier to know what projects are desirable.
Senator Duncan: Do you not think, having protected those environmental agencies in Bill C-39, we’ve learned from them?
Mr. Gibson: We’ve learned not to touch them. I don’t know what kind of learning was involved in that. I wasn’t in the room. But yes, there is a good deal to be learned from them, and some of that learning is happening.
Senator Cuzner: Ms. Johnston, you made a comment off the top about this not being perceived as red tape. It’s more about checks and balances to make sure we develop in a sustainable manner — and I agree with you wholeheartedly. And Dr. Gibson’s point that there are inefficiencies and problematic aspects to the current structure that we have. However, I didn’t really get a response from either of you on Senator Mohamed’s question about whether there has been a study in recent history that looked at a year that was catastrophic or that wasn’t well done. I don’t think we got a response to that question.
To your recollection —
Ms. Johnston: Not that I’m aware of because this kind of timeline is unprecedented, to my knowledge, in Canada federally. I’d also point out —
Senator Cuzner: You haven’t seen a study done before about a year —
Mr. Gibson: There have been various critiques of practices in some provinces where decisions have been made quickly, and those critiques have mostly centred on what’s not considered because it turns out that, as the federal government’s process is now being practised and promised increasingly, it centres on coordinated permitting. If that’s an inefficient thing, which it probably is and certainly there is documentation of that, then coordinating the permitting is a great idea.
Senator Cuzner: Okay.
Mr. Gibson: But that means you have to have very detailed project design and engineering done when you enter the process if you want to get it done in a brief period of time. That means your assessment is of an already detailed, already fairly intense expenditure-level project at the starting point. What we have, then, is a one-year permitting process, not an assessment process.
If there are broader things, like cumulative effects, and broader alternatives and so forth, that’s out of the picture far more than it used to be, and it has always been a struggle. Either we have to build up regional assessments, or the equivalents, to deal with those types of issues, which is an excellent idea but hard to deal with, expensive to do everywhere and difficult to know exactly where you have to do them ahead of time. Or we have to do it in these kinds of projects. We have one year for every project that comes out under the assessment regimes.
Senator Cuzner: Drawing on your vast experience, of the assessments that have come in recent years, have any of them been a swing and a miss where they’ve caused harm to the area or to a specific project or community?
Mr. Gibson: For most of Canadian history, extracted resource economics is littered with the legacy effects that are —
Senator Cuzner: I used the tar pond one. I don’t think it was all that rigorous back in 1906.
Mr. Gibson: But they still —
Senator Cuzner: In recent years, with the current assessment regime that we use now, do we usually get it right?
Mr. Gibson: No.
Senator Cuzner: Could you cite some examples?
Mr. Gibson: Yes. I have emphasized the economic-social-ecological package, and in Canada, we are particularly weak on the economic part of the impact assessment. We have countless — well, not countless, but quite a few — assessments that have gone through where all that effort was done, all the consultations were done and all expectations were theorized, and the project never went ahead because it wasn’t economically viable, or they couldn’t persuade anyone who was going to invest that it was. It’s enormously inefficient.
We have had projects where assessment panels have said, “Don’t go ahead with this unless you do a rigorous economic review.” We can look at the Lower Churchill River Hydroelectric Generation Project, Site C and places in between. In Lower Churchill, the federal government had to bail out the province, which was going bankrupt because of cost overruns. We’re talking about major projects in the national interest that just scream potential for cost overruns.
Senator Cuzner: Nothing on the environmental assessment though —
The Chair: We have to move on.
Senator Cuzner: It was on the business.
Mr. Gibson: I’m taking the most extreme examples. We can think of a lot of cases where the environmental effects have been —
Senator Cuzner: Could you supply us with that after?
Mr. Gibson: Yes. The chair will not let me do that now.
The Chair: Not verbally, but you are welcome to put it in writing. I’m sure Senator Cuzner would love to have it.
Senator Prosper: I want to go back to regional assessments, which provide a mechanism for preapproval, subject to conditions. Correct me if I am wrong; the legislation doesn’t really provide anything further in terms of guideposts or anything of that nature. What should it contain to make it more environmentally defensible? Anything from the witnesses.
Ms. Johnston: I’ll go quickly and say Australia provides a really interesting example. About a year ago, the federal government in Australia passed its own fast tracking act that, among other things, provides for these regional zones, but they have been a lot more prescriptive. They call it bioregional planning, and bioregional plans should do things like identifying key priority environmental values, conservation zones and management pathways for effects. Those are some things that could be baked into this bill, I would say starting with purposes. The government has said that it intends to use these regional approaches to improve environmental outcomes, so put that in as a purpose. Put in considerations, and make sure that cumulative effects are robustly considered. Make sure that fostering sustainability pathways for ensuring the sustainability of values in the region is a purpose and a factor to consider in regional assessments. And that regional assessments have prescribed outcomes, such as plans for the sustainable management of resources within federal jurisdiction, like fisheries, migratory birds and navigable waters and for the well-being of Indigenous Peoples.
Senator Prosper: Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I agree with you that the executive is being given a lot of power, but I have trouble with the idea that the system doesn’t have a lot of red tape. For example, after the meeting, I was talking to the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission official, who said that the commission had all the environmental experts and specialists necessary to carry out environmental assessments as well. The Canada Energy Regulator told us the same thing. Why are there three bodies, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, the Canada Energy Regulator and the Canadian Nuclear Association, all saying they have the same environmental expertise? That’s one of the reasons why one of the agencies was cut out of the process for assessing major national projects. Is there overlap?
[English]
Ms. Johnston: Back in 2017, the federal government appointed an expert panel to review federal impact assessment processes. One of the key recommendations that came out of that process is that there be one central assessment authority to ensure consistency, credibility and independence. So with this change of putting the assessment responsibility back into the hands of various regulators, it goes against what the panel, after nearly two years of cross-country tours, listening to experts and talking to proponents, it goes against what that panel had recommended.
Mr. Gibson: The premise behind the expert panel and the premise behind the legislation we currently have is that it includes cumulative effects; it includes a broad range of factors. The premise behind expediting is that all we’re really interested in is permitting. That is the key difference.
The Chair: That concludes the work with this panel. I want to thank the panel of witnesses for taking the time to be with us today. I’m sorry to have to move things along, but we have many questions in a short period of time.
Honourable senators, for our third panel, we’re pleased to welcome Michael Powell, Vice President, Government Relations, Electricity Canada; Fernando Melo, Director, Policy and Government Affairs section, Canadian Renewable Energy Association, via video conference; and George Christidis, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association. Welcome, and thank you for joining us.
We’ll begin with your opening remarks before we move to questions from our senators. We will start with Mr. Powell, followed by Mr. Melo and Mr. Christidis.
The floor is yours for five minutes, Mr. Powell.
Michael Powell, Vice President, Government Relations, Electricity Canada: Thank you for inviting me to appear today and talk about this important bill. I am Vice President of Government Relations at Electricity Canada. We are the national voice for electricity in Canada. Our members generate, transmit and distribute power to homes and businesses in every province and territory.
Canada’s affordable and reliable electricity system is a key strategic advantage. It provides the foundation that drives growth across the economy. It is 2% of GDP, but it’s the first 2%, the foundation that enables the rest.
We’re also a climate success story. Canada has one of the cleanest grids in the world: More than 80% of the power produced in Canada is from non-emitting sources, and our sector has reduced emissions by almost 60% since 2005. This is a clean-energy advantage that will decarbonize other parts of the economy as we move forward.
But Canada must continue to grow the grid to keep this advantage. As outlined in the national electricity strategy announced in May — Powering Canada Strong: A National Strategy for an Electrified Canadian Economy — Canada will need to double our electricity supply over the next 25 years to meet new demands from electrification, new technologies and population growth. That means building more generation, more transition and more distribution infrastructure at pace and at scale. This is a $1-trillion opportunity for Canada, and we have to get it right.
Bill C-39 helps advance this objective. It simplifies the decision-making processes and accelerates permits and approvals for electricity projects that Canada needs.
The electricity sector is ready to build. The challenge is no longer a lack of ambition; it’s the need for regulatory systems that can match the pace, scale and urgency of the required investments. Permitting delays are not cost neutral; every additional month of uncertainty increases development risks, exposes projects to supply chain and interest rate volatility, contributes to workforce constraints and ultimately raises costs for Canadians.
The Building Canada Strong Act responds to those challenges. It creates a one-year federal review and decision timeline that will give utilities, investors, Indigenous partners and governments the regulatory certainty they need to commit capital. The bill and the accompanying cabinet directive also extend this one-year commitment beyond major projects. The full range of projects needed to double the grid and electrify the economy will now benefit from a more efficient and predictable regulatory environment. This is essential because we can’t double the grid through major projects alone; Canada’s future grid will be the result of thousands of additional smaller community-level investments to build a bigger, more modern and more resilient electricity system.
We’re also pleased to see the government move forward with the principle of “one project, one review.” Creating a single authority for nuclear projects and interjurisdictional transmission lines, as well as reducing duplication for offshore wind projects, will reduce complexities for building the next wave of electricity infrastructure. Reduced complexities means reduced project risks, which will drive investments and contain costs.
A single federal decision statement and a more coordinated federal approach to Crown consultations will further improve clarity for proponents.
Another important element of Bill C-39 is the requirement for decision makers to consider whether permitting conditions are technically, economically and practically feasible. Allowing regulators to consider factors, such as whether a permitting condition can be met by current technologies, will go a long way for ensuring the right projects get built.
Developing regulatory frameworks that provide certainty and predictability for investors while protecting the environment and rights of Indigenous Peoples must be an ongoing commitment. To that end, we think there are opportunities to leverage Bill C-39 with furthered targeted amendments to streamline electricity permits, particularly as it relates to the Fisheries Act. At present, the act is a barrier to the efficient operations of existing electricity infrastructure, primarily hydroelectric facilities that are the backbone of our clean energy supply. Amending the Fisheries Act to allow for a significance-based authorization regime that focuses on protecting fisheries and fish populations is needed to provide regulatory certainty for the hydro sector.
Our sector is ready. Investors are ready. Communities and Indigenous partners are ready to move projects forward. What is needed now is regulatory certainty and timely decision making. Bill C-39 provides an important foundation for this to happen, and with continued improvements, it can help us ensure that Canada sees this as a once-in-a-generation opportunity. Thank you for the opportunity, and I look forward to your questions.
Fernando Melo, Director, Policy and Government Affairs section, Canadian Renewable Energy Association: Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you on behalf of the Canadian Renewable Energy Association, or CanREA, to speak about Bill C-39.
The Canadian Renewable Energy Association represents more than 320 companies that are building the wind, solar and energy storage projects that will help power Canada’s future and current economy. Our members are investing billions of dollars across the country and are working closely with utilities, Indigenous communities, governments, unions and large electricity customers to expand Canada’s electricity system.
Canada’s renewable energy and energy storage sectors are having a moment: a clean energy investment super cycle. Driving it are federal policies, like the clean economy investment tax credits, Indigenous equity models and prevailing wages, helping retain skilled trades in the sector as well as regular provincial procurement.
As the new national electricity strategy recognizes, economic growth is tied directly to our nation’s ability to power itself with affordable and clean electricity. Recent national polling conducted by CanREA shows that affordability is the top electricity priority for Canadians in every region in this country. Like railways and highways before it, transmission enables new generation and resources, supports regional economic development, facilitates Indigenous participation in major projects and improves energy reliability and affordability. Governments across Canada are encouraging the development of critical minerals, manufacturing, data centres, transportation electrification and new housing starts. All of these objectives require significantly more electricity.
The Canada Energy Regulator, or CER, projects that national demand could grow from 26% to 85% by 2050, yet the infrastructure to move electricity from where it’s generated to where it’s needed is not being built at the pace required. About 24 gigawatts of wind, solar and storage, worth more than $45 billion, are already being procured today, but a project can clear every approval and still wait for a grid connection. That is why Bill C-39’s provisions that set clear timelines for reviewing transmission projects are so crucial.
CanREA members are pleased to see that this bill goes beyond recognizing transmission as a nation-building endeavour and has been put into action. Bill C-39 proposes to make the CER the single assessor for international and designated interprovincial power lines, the decisions due within a year of a completed application being received. That creates a stronger pathway for interties that improve reliability and energy security. Federal decisions on major projects have often taken more than five years, so this certainty on timelines will help accelerate the deployment of new transmission lines.
This bill also supports Canada’s vast offshore wind potential by proposing to assign an assessment of offshore renewable energy projects outside the current offshore corridor areas to the CER rather than an integrated review panel. That provides a clearer path for an emerging industry. Both these provisions will help get nation-building projects like Wind West over the line.
Honourable senators, Canada’s economic ambitions depend on access to affordable, reliable and increasingly clean electricity. The question is whether we will build the transmission infrastructure necessary to connect new sources of power to support growing demand and strengthen the ties between our regional electricity systems.
If I can leave you with one final thought for your deliberations, it’s this: Transmission enables renewables and energy storage. Thank you. I look forward to your questions.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Melo. Mr. Christidis?
George Christidis, President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association: Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. I am the President and CEO of the Canadian Nuclear Association, or CNA.
The CNA is the national voice of the nuclear industry, representing about 200 organizations across Canada, including uranium miners, electricity generators, technology developers, engineering firms, manufacturing and the broader nuclear supply chain.
We supervise approximately 14% of Canada’s electricity, supporting 89,000 jobs directly and indirectly, and it contributes to energy, social, and environmental, economic, competitiveness and medical innovation goals.
Canada is in an important moment. We face growing electricity demand, increasing global competition, geopolitical uncertainty and a renewed focus on energy security and economic sovereignty. Canada possesses extraordinary nuclear capabilities, from uranium resources to reactor technology, skilled workers and manufacturing. It is an internationally recognized player, globally.
The opportunity before us is it to translate these strengths into investment, infrastructure, jobs and long-term economic growth. The federal government’s electricity and nuclear energy strategies recognize this opportunity. But achieving our ambitions requires execution, and execution depends on a regulatory system that is rigorous, predictable, efficient and capable of supporting timely investment decisions.
In this context, the CNA welcomes Bill C-39 as a positive step toward regulatory modernization. I would like to highlight our four priorities.
First, integrating impact assessment into the regulatory framework of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, or CNSC. This is a reform that the nuclear industry has been advocating for over a number of years. It is consistent with the objective of one project, one review.
The CNSC is an independent, quasi-judicial regulator with internationally recognized expertise in nuclear safety and environmental protection. As a full life cycle regulator, it oversees nuclear facilities from development through operation, decommissioning and long-term oversight. Integrating the impact assessment into the CNSC framework offers an opportunity to reduce duplication, strengthen accountability and integrate our metal monitoring and mitigation requirements into ongoing regulatory oversight.
Some have questioned whether this integration could happen with environmental and health objectives. Our position is clear: Regulatory efficiency and regulatory rigour are not competing objectives. Canada must retain strong environmental and human health protections and oversight for public confidentiality. Our objective is not less regulation; it’s better regulation — rigorous, efficient, predictable and informed by specialized expertise.
Second, Indigenous consultation. We welcome the proposal for the CNSC to assume a clear leadership role in coordinating federal Indigenous consultation associated with nuclear projects. This can improve accountability, reduce duplication and provide greater clarity for Indigenous communities and project proponents. However, greater clarity is needed regarding consultation requirements, responsibilities and expectations, particularly in light of evolving jurisprudence.
Meaningful Indigenous consultation must remain central to nuclear energy’s development. Success requires early engagement, clear requirements, adequate institutional capacity and effective coordination among federal authorities. We encourage the government and the CNSC to clarify these responsibilities and ensure that their approach aligns with the broader federal consultation framework.
Third, a predictable and timely regulatory regime. We welcome efforts to improve regulatory timelines, including the objective of completing relevant assessments within one year. Predictable timelines matter to investors, project proponents, Indigenous communities and all participants in the regulatory process. However, a one-year review period is meaningful only if the requirements for entering that review are clear and predictable. If the formal timeline begins only once an application is deemed complete, delays could simply shift into the pre-review period.
We therefore encourage clear, proportional information requirements, transparent completeness, determinations and coordination between the impact assessment and subsequent licensing. The objective must be predictable across the entire regulatory process, not simply within one stage.
Fourth, reducing the regulatory burden and ensuring implementation. Bill C-39 is an important step, but legislative amendments alone will not deliver the outcome that Canada needs. Since 2024, the CNA has been working with the CNSC to identify opportunities to reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens and improve efficiency. Further opportunities remain to modernize processes, clarify requirements and improve decision making without compromising safety or environmental protection. Successful implementation would require clear guidance, adequate resourcing, specialized expertise and effective coordination across federal institutions. We also look forward to participating in Natural Resources Canada’s forthcoming review of the Nuclear Safety and Control Act. This provides another opportunity to strengthen Canada’s regulatory framework for the next generation of nuclear deployment.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I look forward to the questions.
The Chair: Thank you to our witnesses, and we’ll go to our first questions from senators.
Senator Yussuff: Thank you, witnesses, for being here. Gentlemen, you’re all fully aware that the majority of electricity grids are usually run by provinces. For the most part throughout our history, they have been built by provincial governments and regulated by provincial governments.
There is a national debate about having a national grid in this country, as the country’s needs expand more and more electricity as we try to decarbonize Canada. How do you see this legislation making that possible, given that we have to figure out if energy in Alberta can be helpful to Saskatchewan so it can get off coal power generation? Is electricity in Manitoba helpful to Ontario, so it is not so dependent on other forms of electricity? Maybe you could speak to that because this is one of the issues the country has been wrestling with as we’ve tried to decarbonize. Most of our history has been that we build additional power for the United States, not for Canadians coast to coast to coast. How will this bill allow that to happen, and what is your vision of making this possible?
Mr. Powell: You’re right, Canada has 13 different grids in every province and territory. One of the remarkable things over the past few years is we’ve seen more and more jurisdictions identify ways in which they can work together. That was manifested recently in a big announcement between Newfoundland and Quebec, which is a foundational deal that moves beyond 50 years of complexity. There has also been more work between Ontario and Quebec around power swaps, and recently, there was movement toward greater integration within Atlantic Canada and the Maritimes.
These are all important steps. A clearer set of rules for building the physical transmission infrastructure is going to be part of that. This gets back to the heart of what the national electricity strategy is looking for as well. Electricity Canada believes that the future grid is going to be all of the above and more generation of all the various types. The move toward non‑emitting technologies is going to have some long lead times. For example, Saskatchewan is pursuing — and I’m going to steal Mr. Christidis’s thunder — some new nuclear projects in the next few years. That will inevitably require transmission to take best advantage of them between jurisdictions. But all of this involves focus, planning and a consistent approach because the projects to build the system out are measured in decades, both to plan and build, in some cases, and also to operate in the long term.
The more we can get the pace moving quickly now, it helps us meet the urgency we need.
We need to build all that we have built in the last 100 years again in the next 25. That is the real test ahead of us, and that’s really where Bill C-39 moves things forward.
Mr. Christidis: Thank you for that question. It is fundamental that we take a multi-technology approach. We see that each province and jurisdiction is going to take a look at what is right for itself to make the appropriate decision. Yes, there is a commercial decision, but ultimately each province, which runs the grid, will make the right decision for itself. We feel that nuclear is part of that conversation. Like Mr. Powell, I point to more regional types of interconnections that make the most sense. The idea of a national grid is very difficult to visualize and conceptualize, particularly when you look at the timeframes and you look at what is needed to meet the energy demand goals and other objectives.
From the regional perspective, you’re seeing Saskatchewan, Alberta, and the Northwest Territories work together in exploring nuclear technologies. You’re seeing Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario and New Brunswick looking at nuclear technologies as well and how that could benefit their own grids. Each grid is looking at tripling to meet the economic and reliability goals.
Bill C-39 is a means by which we see that the government is on the right track to accelerate the deployment of these technologies to achieve those economic, social, environmental and national security goals.
I must say something about Bill C-39 and the context that we’re working in. We are not in 2017; we’re not in 2016. We’re in the right now. Energy security and energy production are at the core of a number of conversations, including what’s occurring in Alberta today and in other jurisdictions. A lot of this will impact how these projects proceed in meeting environmental requirements and Indigenous consultation. But the projects need to proceed because there is another layer of analysis that only you could provide as senators, which are the economic and national security benefits of deploying these technologies and infrastructure to create jobs and to get the economy growing in a space where we somewhat have our sovereignty with these technologies. I’ll leave it there.
Senator Wilson: My question is more to do with timelines. Both of you talked about the time that it takes to get to completeness and the time in the review process, which is now one year, as well as associated with other permits. Prior to this bill, we had a three-year timeline requirement. I personally have experienced leading a project through the environmental assessment process with a three-year timeline and a panel review, and it took 10 years to get from completeness to decision. Almost all of that time is because of things like stop clocks, additional studies that are required and other permits. Then when you do get to a decision, you still require Fisheries Act permits and the like.
So what specifically, when you look at this bill, is going to address those things? A one-year timeframe sounds like a great thing in a headline, but it sounds like we’ve all had the same experience of taking these projects through, and that headline is often not what the reality is. Where do you see this bill actually getting at being able to approach that kind of a timeline?
Mr. Christidis: Thank you for that question. From our perspective, it is exactly defining what it means to have that one‑year project timeline component of the bill, a definition that’s understood and guidance associated with those applications. We don’t want to be in a space where the pre‑application period becomes the delay. From our perspective, the definition of what is required to make those one-year commitments and information and submissions will be very key to meeting that type of timeframe from the one-year perspective.
Senator Wilson: We heard Mr. Hubbard today say in our first panel that the pre-permitting stuff is designed to do that under this investigation. Do you think that’s an accurate statement?
Mr. Christidis: We feel there is more definition that needs to be given in terms of guidance, but the bill is on the right track in terms of that one-year commitment. But a definition of what that could look like is quite important.
Mr. Powell: If I could add, there have already been other changes around the scope of Bill C-39 that were announced, like changes to the physical activity regulations, which adjust the sorts of things that would previously have been covered by the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada in the power space. Ultimately, we have to collectively pick up the pace in advancing projects. That’s on federal approvals, and that will have clarity around what goes into that application. It is on the regulatory process at the provincial level. It is about making sure we can get the supply chain and workforce sorted out so we can move forward. The demand for electricity isn’t going to change with an unstreamlined process. The only choice Canada has is to address these things and be clear about moving forward or we won’t be able to meet the needs of economic growth. That’s where the urgency of this is.
We’re happy to see this, and we’re looking forward to seeing it implemented. But you’re right, we have to keep focused on this. The test will be: can we deploy new megawatts on the system in a way that meets Canadians’ needs?
[Translation]
Senator Gignac: Thank you to the witnesses and welcome. There is no doubt that developing clean electricity is important, not just for the economy, but also for the fight against climate change. Thank you for the work you’re doing.
Back when I was Quebec’s natural resources minister, we worked very closely with Hydro-Québec on the development of all projects.
I’m trying to understand what Bill C-39 can do. You’ve talked a lot about interconnections between the provinces. Could I have an offshore wind project in Prince Edward Island or New Brunswick and be able to build transmission lines between Ontario and New Brunswick without going through Hydro-Québec? How does it work? How does this bill foster more interconnections? That’s what I’m trying to understand.
[English]
Mr. Powell: This doesn’t change that part of the planning process. It is important that the electricity strategy is not just permitting reform, and it is not just a suite of input tax credits, or ITCs. It is a conversation with provincial jurisdictions to see how we can do more of these sorts of connections. This doesn’t change the constitution.
When we look forward to how to build the system and the conversation that’s happening — and we saw some of it at the Energy and Mines Ministers’ Conference — we are looking at how different jurisdictions can coordinate as we move forward on what the future power system looks like. That’s already happening in some ways. Ontario and Quebec, as an example, have been doing capacity swaps, having Ontario absorb some of Quebec’s power in the summer when we’re in peak and then vice versa in the winter. That’s an important part of it. Ontario, if you were to check today, is probably exporting power to Quebec as it is.
These are the conversations that will happen. Facilitating a federal approval process for a transmission line will make things easier after we have the conversations on system planning between jurisdictions.
I’m already seeing that happen with my members on a regular basis. There is much greater coordination than there was before, but there are also many steps. In the near term, everyone needs more generation that will match the ability to share power or to transfer power between jurisdictions.
We just released a report in the last couple of weeks, looking at a very narrow case where there are opportunities for resilience from transmission. Some real opportunities exist for leveraging even the transmission we have between jurisdictions for extreme weather and those sorts of cases.
Senator Gignac: Do you have a concept of the regions of national interests in that bill? Does it mean, for example, that we can have a wind project and, by doing that, you bypass the provincial hearing on the environment and this kind of thing? Is it your understanding that, with regions of national interest, you can have some projects?
Mr. Powell: That’s not my understanding.
Senator Gignac: No? Okay.
Mr. Powell: I’ll have to double-check, but provincial planning for electricity systems is still on the economic and the permitting — not the “building things” permitting side. It is still pretty firmly in the provincial space. I don’t see that changing in the future.
Senator Gignac: Okay. Thank you.
[Translation]
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I too am trying to better understand what I sensed was some reservation about the fact that you’re being asked to provide all the information, to meet all the requirements, before the clock starts and the one-year assessment time frame begins. Do you think that’s asking too much? In talking to people, I learned that there was a lot of discussion between the proponent and the agency during the assessment process to see what improvements could be made on the proponent’s end. Do you see this system as counterintuitive, because it seeks to limit the assessment period to a year, when in fact, a proponent could have to spend a year prior to that putting their file together since they can’t know everything in advance? Tell me how you see the process, because I did sense some reservation on your part.
[English]
Mr. Christidis: From our perspective, and just to put it clearly, Bill C-39 points to the right direction. I think all proponents would like to have that year commitment. How that is implemented will matter. Without going on too far into the details of a specific project and how that would be implemented, the point is that there needs to be a clear understanding of the type of information and the definition of how that would be met up front.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: There has not been in the past?
Mr. Christidis: From our industry’s perspective, there has not been enough clarity to understand that the clock gets stopped and the process gets extended. This bill, from our view, our definition, seeks to address that. We’re saying that for this to be addressed, the definition of that year and the information and the guidance of that year will be quite relevant to understanding, so everyone concerned will have an understanding of that process.
To date, for our members and from our industry, there isn’t that level of certainty that needs to be done. However, the bill is the direction that we want to take.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: I get it.
Mr. Christidis: It might be the second step where the Canadian Nuclear Safety Act is examined. There might be additional refinements there. We are a little different because we are in a federal jurisdiction as the nuclear industry.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: Do you agree with every part of the bill, especially the part where the government has the power to authorize you to build before the assessment is over?
Mr. Christidis: That’s a difficult question.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: Yes, that’s why I’m asking it.
Mr. Christidis: I will say that we understand the government’s objective of wanting to have a lens on national projects that the government and, to an extent, the people would deem essential to proceed with. How that’s defined individually, of course, is up for discussion.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: Have you asked for it as a lobbyist?
Mr. Christidis: No. We have asked that nuclear be included, for example, in the national project list approach. This is a political conversation, of course, that the government has started. There is definitely an importance to understanding that there are certain projects that have a national impact and positive, economic, social, environmental and, even now, national security impacts. Again, I am hinting in my opening statements that we’re not in 2016, and that is probably why the government is considering mechanisms to take a look at certain projects and have the ability to say that those meet some national objectives that need to be considered with, of course, the required consultations, et cetera. But that is my understanding of what has driven the government to table this bill and this approach.
Senator Miville-Dechêne: Thank you.
Senator Prosper: I have a question for Mr. Powell and then one for Mr. Christidis.
Electricity Canada has made a commitment to early and meaningful Indigenous engagement with shorter project-review timelines. What funding time and access to technical expertise should affected First Nations receive to assess proposals and influence decisions?
Mr. Powell: This gets to the heart of the implementation of the Bill C-39 question. It’s our members who do the engagement. Across the board, there is an increasing and much greater commitment to engaging with partner communities and Indigenous groups well in advance and having them integrated in the planning process throughout.
These are complicated projects, though. As we look at what’s involved, making sure that those communities can have the right resources to engage meaningfully in the process is something that we’ve supported throughout.
That’s a step beyond Bill C-39. It speaks to — as Mr. Christidis was talking about — getting to the point where you have an application, and this bill focuses on the length of approvals that come afterwards. There is much more to do. A lot has been done to make sure the process of getting to that point is something where we could have across-the-board buy-in for the projects that need to go forward.
Senator Prosper: Thank you. Mr. Christidis, you mentioned in your testimony there is more clarity needed around consultation, especially in light of the evolving legal jurisprudence. The CNA’s engagement primarily acknowledges concerns about inadequate consultation and long-term impacts on Indigenous lands.
What requirements should a company’s faster nuclear project reviews do to assure affected First Nations have the time, funding and independent technical advice needed to assess proposals and influence decisions?
Mr. Christidis: Again, Indigenous consultation is imperative. That is the foundation point, from our view; our position as an industry.
The question becomes how Indigenous communities will be empowered to be part of that consultation, resourcing, expertise, information, et cetera; absolutely. For those Indigenous communities that want or are interested in the nuclear industry, what are the mechanisms, the loan guarantee and equity programs that are there? We’re very supportive of that.
But ultimately, the relationship between Canada and Indigenous nations is a constitutional conversation that industry struggles with. I’ll talk to my industry. I cannot talk to others. But that is at the heart of the question. How does the Government of Canada establish relationships with the First Nations so we all understand issues such as the scoping of that dynamic, the conversation and what nations are included or not included?
All industries have a difficult time finding its footing in that place. I’m telling you from my industry because it’s a constitutional nation-to-nation conversation that gets lost in the dialogue with the proponents. Of course, industry wants to be part of the solution. Proponents are involved at the local level, but ultimately, the conversations, as you well know, lead to that nation-to-nation conversation and scoping.
Our message to the government is that make sure that, in our case, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission is well resourced and is able to coordinate that Indigenous consultation piece from the government’s mechanics perspective that achieves the goals for the country, First Nations and the industry, but it really has to be driven and designed by the government in discussion with the First Nations.
Senator Prosper: Thank you.
Senator Duncan: Thank you for appearing. The previous witnesses were asked if there was anything worthwhile in the bill, and the answer was essentially to throw the baby out with the bath water. You’ve given a different perspective. Mr. Christidis, you said Bill C-39 is on the right track. Mr. Powell, you said it’s steps in the right direction. What are the essential elements of this bill? Do you have any specific further steps in the right direction that you would recommend for us?
Mr. Christidis: I touched on some of that in my points, so not to repeat them, but obviously, the “one project, one review” is definitely a good step. We’ve been advocating this as an industry for a long time.
The definition of the Indigenous consultation, as we discussed, is essential. The definition of what it means to have that one-year review again is an essential — and this is pointing in the right direction — and the proper resourcing of the regulator, which, in our case, is the world-renowned Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission. So it’s starting off in a very strong position, but it needs to have that looks further at efficiency and how we could reduce duplication that has nothing to do with safety in and of itself.
In order to meet these energy, employment and environmental goals, the country has to accelerate the deployment of these clean or non-emitting technologies that we’re part of. Therefore, our recommendations are based on that. We feel that Bill C-39 is pointing in the right way. It’s achieving a lot of the points that we’ve recommended. We recognize that. But the follow-through in terms of some of these definitional areas, as well as perhaps as the Canadian Nuclear Safety and Control Act itself is looked at, could address some of those other ongoing conversations that we feel have to happen to meet the government’s own goals, as outlined by the electricity strategy and the nuclear energy strategy.
Quite frankly, we do find multi-party support in our conversations for these. We also find multi-jurisdictional support, meaning — again, I’ll talk about my mandate through the nuclear industry. You can speak with the governments of Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario and New Brunswick. So, in a very unique time, it is part of a solution that is recognized to meet these common goals.
That’s the opportunity of Bill C-39. I think someone else raised this as well. This is just one of the key areas. The other key areas are following through on things like the financial models, the investment tax credits and also to get ready for workforce development. Our sector will create a significant number of jobs. It already is a significant employer. It will significantly create opportunities at a moment when we’re not sure what the employment and economic environment will be over the next few years.
Again, not to belittle anyone’s concerns or questions; they’re very valid, but as this country is looking at economic stability in the next 5 to 10 years, economic infrastructure and energy projects need to be enabled. Nuclear, yes, but also beyond. So it’s very important that this bill proceed and is reflected accordingly as we move forward with the other components as well.
Mr. Powell: Ditto. I would add, if we were adding bath water for the baby, there is an opportunity here to look at other legislative changes that will make it easier to streamline the operation of electricity projects. The biggest one is the Fisheries Act. There were changes made in 2019 that had a significant impact on operations; Sixty percent of the energy that is produced in Canada through electricity.
Those changes have a real impact. They are costing just one of my members up to $2 billion and losses of capacity. Two line changes to the Fisheries Act to focus on fish populations and fish habitat would have the impact of making it easier to operate electricity projects, freeing up the people in my member companies that are going to be doing the work to build new things from just keeping the ones that are running — doing paperwork for them with not really a material impact on the stewardship side.
I would suggest a couple of different parts of the bill in the Fisheries Act section to allow for the better and continued operation, as we have for the previous 50 years, of electricity infrastructure and hydroelectric dams would be well served.
Senator Clement: Hello, and thank you for your testimony. I heard you say, Mr. Christidis, that collaboration has been a sticking point between federal institutions. We actually heard that from the panel before you as well. But I’m wondering if Bill C-39 really gets at that. If that’s a major issue here in terms of getting jurisdictions to work together, is Bill C-39 just this blunt instrument? Should we not be focusing on collaboration?
All three of you represent sectors that are doing well. You have success stories galore to tell. So what was the problem with the impact assessment before that stopped you? That’s what I want you to address.
Mr. Christidis: Sure. Thank you for that opportunity.
Thank you, senator, for recognizing that. But the starting point of our industry is the $26 billion refurbishment projects in Ontario that were and are on time and on budget. That is the foundation piece of our industry. That led to these opportunities, where there are two large nuclear projects being considered in Ontario: small reactors and international connections. Our domestic market needs to proceed to enable those international markets in the nuclear space. We can talk further on that if you’d like.
From our perspective previously, there was a lot of uncertainty around the impact assessment. Two agencies. One agency was being created: the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission. We feel that Bill C-39 provides that clarity that, for us, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission is the agency, and the impact assessment portion will be part of their mandate as it relates to nuclear, as well as being the coordinator on First Nations consultation. For our industry, there’s a clarity that is recognized.
There are additional clarities that need to be had. For example, if you’re looking at impact assessment and the one-year project timeline, et cetera, I was asked what could be done further. It’s information from brownfields. Existing industrial sites have a wealth of environmental information. Some of it is transferrable between technologies. It isn’t a nuclear question; it’s an industrial question. Therefore, if this information has been had, could it not be applicable and recognized? That’s an example of efficiency that has nothing to do with safety; it has to do with recognizing other agencies that have collected this information, and you can use it, for example.
There are other spaces where, in the current context of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, there’s a regulatory burden that still needs to be addressed on non-safety issues, where the regulators ask to clarify information that other departments may have and, therefore, it inadvertently creates a backlog of regulatory requirements or discussions.
To go back to the central point for us, Bill C-39 recognizes and points in the right direction. It takes a number of key steps. There are some efficiencies that could be found. We do like those points that I’ve just made. From our perspective, this would be a major part of the package to enable the growth of our industry in a way that it would create jobs domestically and opportunities internationally.
Mr. Melo: To build on my colleague’s point, from a renewable energy and energy storage perspective, where the opportunity lies with this legislation is to allow a more regional approach. Many of you who have been in Atlantic Canada will know it’s quite windy, and there are many opportunities for interprovincial transmission that would allow other provinces — we’ll say Quebec — to take advantage of its great hydroelectric assets and store some of that for capacity swaps at a later time or allow better intertrading.
More transmission will allow better use of my members’ projects and their investments, which are often co-owned by Indigenous companies and communities. What this will do is allow more transmission to be built, especially in a regional aspect, relieving what’s known as line congestion, which I would point to my colleague, Mr. Powell, to speak to a bit further.
Mr. Powell: The only thing I’ll say is that a focused, single decision from the federal government’s coordinated approach is there. You’re right, we have a lot of success in our sector, and that’s because of the hard work and planning that has gone into these sorts of pieces, but we’re going to have to keep moving. If we want to double the grid in the next 25 years, that means doing everything that we’ve done over the last 125 years in the next — basically, five times faster. That is going to require us thinking differently and having a different level of focus. That means challenging all levels of government to approach these sorts of questions with a sense of purpose to meet that moment. We are looking at Bill C-39 and other measures the government is moving forward with, to really drill down on that.
Senator Cuzner: I think it’s only fair that I pose the question to you, as we posed it to the last panel, a question from my colleague about the instances of reviews that would have been complete within a year but were fraught with problems and missed the mark. We sort of extended it. We asked if they could comment on any projects or assessments that were done under the current system that blew up as well. They’re going to get back to us with some written responses on that, so I think it’s only fair to ask this panel.
Are you aware of proposed projects that would have been engaged in an assessment process and then saw the complications of it or where it was going to land, and they turned and ran away? I know it’s sort of like a lighthouse: How many ships don’t land on the rocks because the lighthouse is there? Are there investments that you’re aware of that, specifically, because of the review process, may have been scared off?
Mr. Powell: You’re right, it’s a hard question to answer. Maybe the way I’ll approach it, particularly with my privately owned members, who are independent power producers, they can invest in different jurisdictions. A complicated regulatory environment, which Canada has been notorious for, makes it harder to justify investing here versus somewhere else.
In the second piece, even for regular projects where there’s a case and you can move forward, the uncertainty of getting to a decision with which you can move forward to build adds cost and complexity. If you can bank on it being — 12 months is great, but even previously 24 or 36 months, and knowing for sure it was going to happen that way, then you can line up the stuff that you need to buy. Transformers and turbines are long lead time assets. Knowing that you will be able to have them at this point in time and that you can book work crews allows you to plan, coordinate and control costs, which makes for a more predictable, less risky project.
It’s not just whether an investment did not happen because we have a complicated regulatory environment. I’m sure that’s true for some, but a complicated regulatory environment makes all of a project harder to plan, which makes it harder to get things in on time and on budget, which ultimately ends up on customers’ bills.
Senator Duncan: Thank you for your presentation.
I’ve heard a lot of mention of collaboration with all of the provinces and not a lot of mention of the North. In Canada’s North, you will be hard pressed to find a community that’s not dependent on diesel fuel for electric generation.
Bill C-39 — you’ve lauded it — has a one-window, one-year type of approach. The three territories have environmental assessment processes that are essentially one window, one approach, and they have significant government-to-government-to-government relationships with First Nations.
My question is for both of you. How would Bill C-39, as you’re collaborating and lauding it, help your industry look north? For example, the nuclear industry?
Mr. Christidis: Thank you for that. Indeed, the conversations have already started. You will have noted, for example, the current conversation that was created with a memorandum of understanding between Saskatchewan, Alberta and the Northwest Territories, for example. There have been conversations in the North — in Iqaluit, for example — that are very dependent on diesel. In all instances, the issues and the conversations are very similar. People want to understand the regulatory regime, how it gets regulated and how nuclear waste is often dealt with, and we feel we have a very good story to tell, at least in the South.
There are particular challenges and opportunities that are associated with the North itself, whether it’s workforce development or financial models, that are a little more particular to be looked at, absolutely. From a perspective of understanding the potential for the nuclear industry, particularly the small reactors, there have been conversations that have occurred and they’re exploring, but it’s not at the point where decisions are pending and about to be made. Right now, the projects that are at the table, if I can put it in those terms, are the small modular reactors at Darlington, of which they’re building four, which will be a model for other provinces and jurisdictions that look at small reactors. Those produce about 300 megawatts, so they replace a coal plant. The same technology is being looked at in Saskatchewan and, eventually, potentially in Alberta and the like.
The North is interested. They’re trying to understand the size of their grids and what these technologies could or could not do. They are often interested in conversations about the very small reactors, which produce about 50 megawatts and are a little further out in time. That’s a bit of an evolution where those jurisdictions are, the technologies at play and how they match their grid, so there’s a lot more that needs to be discussed in those spaces.
Senator Duncan: If I might, you don’t have your eyes on Eielson Air Force Base’s application for a micro modular reactor in Fairbanks, Alaska, which is right on our border, do you?
Mr. Christidis: That is the defence side of the industry, which is very different, especially in the U.S. We’re not associated with that.
Senator Duncan: The Department of National Defence has been interested in micro reactors, which would be of tremendous benefit to the North. They are closer in reality, as I understand it, than the small modular reactors. Where are you with those and with working with the North on the micro reactors, particularly when we are hearing in the Yukon legislature about the threat of rolling brownouts this winter?
Mr. Christidis: Because it’s a defence initiative that has an application in the commercial space, we’re not directly involved with that particular project. If you’re asking me about that particular project, we’re not involved with it, but we’re involved in advocating for very small reactors to be part of the government’s Arctic strategy and the like, which would provide opportunities for communities to access that technology, so I’m answering that way.
Senator Duncan: Thank you.
Mr. Melo: I will respect the committee’s time on this. Bill C-39 will address many of my colleagues’ projects, but I will note the Canadian Renewable Energy Association’s members are already active in all three territories. In the Yukon, we’ve seen multiple wind and solar farms start to be examined and looked at, as well as the application of batteries.
We know the Department of National Defence has just launched an ideas research program to develop micro and modular wind turbines to help meet their needs in the Far North, specifically. Our members are actively involved, and I know my colleagues are engaged in that. There is something there, and we do hope this bill enables greater integration in those key areas.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Melo.
Senator Clement: I want to come back to your organizations, particularly the Canadian Nuclear Association, or CNA. Given that there’s been concern from Indigenous communities around consultation and some opposition to this bill — I know the CNA has an Indigenous relations council and a reconciliation plan — how does Bill C-39 square with that? Have you had an opportunity to consult your own council on this?
Mr. Christidis: Thank you for that question. Regarding our view of how we can enable Indigenous objectives, their own goals are aligned with our position. It’s about strengthening clarity regarding consultation, so we have an understanding, for example, of the federal role and the role in scoping those relationships. Those are conversations that we’ve had with our Indigenous reconciliation council, as well as our industry. From our perspective, the recommendations that we’ve made in the Indigenous space, if I understand the question correctly, are predicated on our industry view of how it could be helpful for Indigenous communities to consider the technologies that would meet their goals.
Senator Clement: Did you consult your council specifically on Bill C-39?
Mr. Christidis: We’ve had conversations on our council and in our regulatory affairs committees, and we share our positions.
Senator Clement: You share your positions, but do they agree?
Mr. Christidis: There are varying views that are often expressed, but ultimately, the position we table is the view by which the position is.
Senator Clement: That’s the position of the CNA?
Mr. Christidis: Yes, of the CNA. To be clear, our engagement with Indigenous communities is predicated on interested communities and communities that want to learn about the technology. We have an Indigenous ambassador program, for example, to pull communities to our conference, and it’s predicated on communities that want to understand what this technology is about and if it could meet their goals and how. We learn from them as much as they learn from us, quite frankly. We often learn from them how they view energy and economic development, and each community is different. What I’ve learned on my journey in this is that all these nations have a particular lens from which they view the opportunities and challenges they’re facing. Therefore, they’re looking at energy and infrastructure differently in each case. That is part of our learning, of course, and we’re looking at it from the nuclear perspective, but the broader conversation we often hear is about energy and economic and social development and the like. I want to make sure that’s understood.
Senator Clement: Thank you.
The Chair: I’d like to thank our witnesses for their presentations here today and the flow back and forth between the questions and answers from our senators. I’d also like to thank our senators for their participation.
Before we conclude, I’d like to advise the steering committee that we’ll be having a meeting immediately after this. The steering committee will be meeting to review a draft work plan that proposes an approach to study Bill C-39, with meetings organized around each of three parts.
This meeting focused on Part 1. Next week, we’ll focus on Part 2. I’d like to ask the committee to send witness suggestions to the clerk.
(The committee adjourned.)