THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON FISHERIES AND OCEANS
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Tuesday, November 3, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Fisheries and Oceans met with videoconference this day at 6:30 p.m. [ET] to examine and report on the commercial fisheries licensing regime on Canada’s Pacific Coast; and, in camera, for consideration of a draft agenda (future business).
Senator Fabian Manning (Chair) in the chair.
[English]
The Chair: Good evening. My name is Fabian Manning. I’m a senator for Newfoundland and Labrador and I have the privilege to chair this committee.
Today, we are conducting a meeting of the Standing Senate Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. Should any technical challenges arise, particularly in relation to interpretation, please signal this to myself or to the clerk and we will work to resolve the issue.
Before we begin, I would like to a take a few moments to allow the members of the committee to introduce themselves.
Senator Dhillon: Good evening. Thank you for being here. Baltej Dhillon, British Columbia.
Senator C. Deacon: Colin Deacon, Nova Scotia.
Senator Prosper: Paul Prosper, Nova Scotia, Mi’kma’ki territory.
Senator Cuzner: Rodger Cuzner, Nova Scotia, Unama’ki.
[Translation]
Senator Boudreau: I’m Victor Boudreau from New Brunswick.
Senator Surette: I’m Allister Surette from Nova Scotia.
[English]
The Chair: Thank you, senators. On November 18, 2025, the Standing Senate Committee on Fisheries and Oceans was authorized to examine and report on the commercial fisheries licensing regime on Canada’s Pacific Coast.
Today, under this mandate, the committee will be hearing from the following individuals: Martin Simard, Senior Director, Marketplace Framework Policy Branch, Department of Industry; and Safeena Alarakhia, Director, Financial Crimes Governance, Department of Finance, Canada.
On behalf of the members of the committee, I thank you both for being here. I understand that neither of you have opening remarks, which is something that we’re not used to here, but I’m sure we’ll adapt pretty quickly. We’ll proceed directly to questions from members of our committee. As usual, we’ll start with the vice-chair, Senator Dhillon.
Senator Dhillon: Thank you for being here this evening.
Maybe I can direct this to Ms. Alarakhia. We had FINTRAC here a while back. I’m not sure if you’re familiar with their testimony. You are? Wonderful. As you know, it was in June 2024 that they began receiving disclosures. In the first year, there were 16 disclosures to them, including from the Fisheries Committee and others, and also from the public, I would assume.
I read some of your notes and also your recommendations with respect to how we can better position ourselves when it comes to issues around managing illicit enterprises and illicit funds that ultimately become laundered through various legitimate businesses in Canada.
With respect to fisheries itself, we don’t have an ownership registry in B.C. There’s a lack of transparency. As recently as today, when we had some meetings with the halibut fisheries organization in B.C., there was discussion around that being absent and not knowing who the owners are and not knowing where those quotas are held.
I put some questions to FINTRAC about whether they could provide recommendations to POFO and also consider doing outreach in the community around what would be useful for them to receive when it comes to delivering on their mandate.
Would you take a few minutes to respond to that and offer your thoughts on how that would work? Do you have any recommendations or opinions on that?
Safeena Alarakhia, Director, Financial Crimes Governance, Department of Finance Canada: I will do my best to try to offer my views. For context, I’m the Director of Financial Crime Governance at the Department of Finance, in the Financial Sector Policy Branch. Our team is responsible writ large for policy development and coordination related to Canada’s federal anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing regime, the legislation and regulations, but also interdepartmental coordination, coordination with provinces and territories, and the private sector in developing policies in this area.
One of my responsibilities, specifically, is that I work on coordinating our national money laundering and terrorist financing risk assessment, which does include a brief assessment of money laundering and terrorist financing risks related to illegal and unregulated fishing.
There is a brief discussion in the public National Risk Assessment report, which was updated in 2025. It’s available on the Government of Canada and Department of Finance website.
Overall, from the money laundering and terrorist financing risk perspective, the threats posed by environmental crime generally — we’ve assessed both illegal and unregulated fishing along with other environmental crimes, such as wildlife trafficking globally. The threat assessment is that the risk, with respect to money laundering and terrorist financing, is low.
To put that into context, the threats that are the highest risk — again, from a money laundering perspective — are threats like drug trafficking, fraud and tax evasion. That rating is largely driven based on the proceeds of crime involved, how widespread a particular threat is and to what extent there are mitigating measures in place, although it’s an inherent risk assessment. These are some of the considerations, but a big driver of that rating is the value of proceeds of crime and the prevalence across Canada of a particular threat.
From that perspective, the risk assessment is sort of a foundational element that drives our policy development considerations with respect to whether a sector should be regulated under the PCMLTFA and its regulations, including a role for FINTRAC as the national anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing supervisor and financial intelligence unit, or whether there are other more targeted tools that might be able to address the risks.
Senator Dhillon: Maybe you can share with us how you conduct that risk assessment and what factors you take into consideration to arrive at that risk determination, given there’s no transparency around ownership.
Ms. Alarakhia: The first thing we do is consult with law enforcement partners. Specifically on the risk assessment for environmental crimes, we consulted with Environment and Climate Change Canada and their enforcement teams, as well as DFO, again, with their enforcement teams to try to understand what the risks are and the prevalence. They are involved in terms of developing the risk profile and in assessing the rating.
The ratings are based on a more or less quantitative methodology, although there’s some qualitative judgment driven by factors like the proceeds of crime, the sophistication of threat actors, whether organized crime is heavily involved in a particular industry or if there’s evidence of it, and if any enforcement cases exist. Those are the types of information that would go into that risk assessment.
Then, we consult with our federal regime partners in the anti‑money laundering and anti-terrorist financing regime. There are 13 federal agencies involved in our risk-assessment working group that validate and agree on the overall threat assessment ratings. We also consult with private sector and reporting entities under the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act, or PCMLTFA, on the report prior to publication to get general feedback on whether this matches with what they’re seeing.
Senator Dhillon: I certainly don’t want to oversimplify this. Having had experience in my previous life in understanding how threat assessments are conducted and knowing what we take into account to land on threat assessments, I would like to ask this question. Let me preface it by saying there’s no evidence, and that is used to determine the threat. The threat will mean there’s no evidence. It’s a cyclical Catch-22. Again, I did say I didn’t want to oversimplify it, but that is simply framing it.
If we’re receiving information from DFO or law enforcement agencies who are not detecting, engaging or investigating — and FINTRAC just started two years ago — based on that empirical evidence and that data; I don’t know if we’re taking into account human intelligence, or HUMINT, or any of those sources, but if that’s what we’re using, would it be fair for me to then assume because there’s no data there, that would not inform the threat in any way?
Ms. Alarakhia: Yes, I think that’s a fair characterization. The risk assessment is driven largely by the quality and availability of data. That’s why, in the context of threats or risks where there may be less reporting — for example, in sectors that are not squarely regulated under the PCMLFTA — and where there may not be large volumes of intelligence reporting, for example, we do try to consult extensively with our partners to the extent that they have cases that allow them to understand typologies and how money laundering occurs in relation to certain criminal activities.
Risk assessment is also iterative in the sense that the Department of Finance updates National Risk Assessment periodically, with the goal of updating it every three years, I think, going forward. The next iteration of that risk assessment will, hopefully, benefit from better data, given that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans is a disclosure recipient of FINTRAC financial intelligence, so there should be more objective data and information that can inform future risk assessments.
Senator Dhillon: I have one final question on this. Mr. Simard, please feel free to jump in at any point if you feel you have something to add. And don’t let me get away with anything. If I’m wrong, feel free to correct my assumptions.
Would you agree that having a registry that’s transparent and that we can look at to understand who the owners are would be useful in the overall effort to determine, make better assumptions about and better analyze the threat factor we are experiencing?
Ms. Alarakhia: Information is always helpful for assessing risks. From an anti-money laundering, risk understanding perspective, having that type of information could be helpful. I imagine there are probably other policy considerations in terms of establishing that kind of registry.
Senator Dhillon: Mr. Simard, is there anything that you would like to add?
Martin Simard, Senior Director, Marketplace Framework Policy Branch, Department of Industry, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada: I would like to build on that. I’m from the Department of Industry, as was mentioned, and I’m in charge of legislative policy for corporate law, so I was quite involved in the creation of the federal official registry.
To Ms. Alarakhia’s last point, whether a policy tool is warranted in a given sector — it will sound trite — will come down to an analysis of the cost of the measure versus the size of the problem and whether there’s a fit. It’s a cost-benefit analysis.
I can tell you that it is an endeavour to create a registry. In the federal context of corporate law, we were lucky because we already had the corporate registry for private corporations. It was just a matter of adding fields to a pre-existing database. It’s more than that because there’s some data that’s not public. That’s a novelty for the public registry, so there was some infrastructure to build.
You may have also heard from stakeholders that it’s one thing to have a registry; it’s another one to have good data in the registry. The cross-referencing of data, enforcement and awarding of penalties you’re able to do come down to compliance measures. There’s the concept of the registry. Then, there are the IT infrastructure and the compliance apparatus you need for it to be workable. I can tell you that I think the cost‑benefit was positive. It’s easier to say that after the fact for federal business corporations. In the specific sector of fisheries, that might be more a question for DFO, although I think I saw a commitment from the minister to go in that direction. I’m sure they will be better situated to speak to the specifics in that context.
Senator C. Deacon: We’re not looking at illegal or unlicensed fishing. That’s not the topic we’re after. We’re after what may be occurring within a licensed fishery. That’s number one.
The other thing I would like to know is what would be required to have the beneficial ownership registry apply to a federally regulated sector? DFO issuing licences for offshore fisheries in Canada means this would be a federally regulated sector. Right now, it’s confined to federally incorporated corporations. Many provinces are starting to come along, as I understand. I’d love to hear an update on that, but that’s separate.
I have to believe there’s an opportunity here to use a similar registry to have federally regulated industries and those who are licensed in the federally regulated sector fall under this law for a beneficial ownership registry. The fact that we don’t know, that it’s not public, that it’s not tracked who has beneficial ownership of the licences. We should know who the fishers on that boat are, whether they’re owners — and, if they’re not owners, who the owners are — where they have cross-ownership with other areas of the fishery and if they’re carrying out appropriate or inappropriate activities in all of that. It can’t be tracked if we don’t know any of it.
Mr. Simard: I can speak in generalities. I’m not going to try to evade the question.
To your point, if you want to establish a beneficial ownership registry, you need a federal head of power. That’s how we got to the registry for federally incorporated corporations. As you mentioned, for corporate law, at least, it is a shared jurisdiction. If you want a registry for provincially incorporated corporations, that’s under provincial powers, so that’s where you need to go.
I should have checked before coming here, but it’s not the only licensing regime at the federal government.
Senator C. Deacon: Absolutely.
Mr. Simard: I’m thinking of the spectrum licences. It would be interesting to see what others have done in analogous circumstances under another federal power that’s not corporate law.
The other consideration you may have already heard is the federal Privacy Act. In general, you need a statutory authorization to be able to gather information, and there are some principles. The main one is proportionality; what are you getting in terms of information and is it proportional to the public interest mandate that you’re having?
As a building block, a head of power and then a statutory anchor to be able to be covered under the Privacy Act, then it’s a matter of policy decisions.
Senator C. Deacon: That, as an objective of this committee — if it is an objective of this committee — is very achievable from a legislative standpoint; it has to be an objective of the government to put these things in place. We understand that. But it could be something we recommend that’s actionable, and we would just have to defend the proportionality and the risk that is being managed by doing so.
Mr. Simard: Again, not purporting to be the general counsel of my department, that’s the process we used, anyway. We needed a head of power and a statutory anchor. If you want to use our example, that’s how we got to it.
Senator C. Deacon: That’s great. Thank you. Under the PCMLTFA, that is once there are suspected risk factors, so I understand that absolutely.
But there are things that we are seeing and hearing that would indicate — for those on this committee that have more experience than I in the fishery — there are things that deserve attention that wouldn’t necessarily be picked up from what we’re seeing or are being picked up right now by the fisheries department’s broad stroke. At least, we’re certainly not hearing from them the concerns we’re hearing from fishers.
We’re also hearing about lease agreements to fish a certain quota that comes with, “You give me X amount of your catch off the books as part of your payment.” Whenever you start hearing things like that, and when it’s tens of thousands of dollars, you think, “That’s interesting. That’s not traceable funds.”
There are certainly signs that we are hearing that it appears, based on your initial comments, that you’re not necessarily hearing from a risk assessment that’s under way right now.
What advice would you have for us in terms of how do we understand to make sure the risk assessment incorporates the sorts of things that we are hearing? We don’t have enough knowledge of how it’s functioning today to be able to say we recommend this change. Based on the questions you’ve had so far, is there any guidance you could give us there?
Ms. Alarakhia: In terms of updating risk assessments and risk information, certainly discussions like these, where there is a particular interest in mitigating and understanding a certain risk better, we can work with our partners in the anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing regime. We have a risk assessment working group and partners to put this to them and try to do more research and look deeper.
I think DFO would be the starting point in terms of enforcement because they know the sector best, and they are more attuned to what their gaps are in information are.
Senator C. Deacon: And the challenge is, we haven’t heard these concerns from DFO. We’ve heard them from some of the regulated entities.
Ms. Alarakhia: Right. Our starting point would always be to work with the regulator or the federal agency. I know that there is information out in the public domain that documents some of these concerns. I think Peter German had put together a report as part of his work leading up to the Cullen Commission in British Columbia. It quite extensively documents the risks in B.C.
I’m not sure if there has been some follow up. When we’re looking at risk assessments, that’s another source of information that I should have mentioned. We do try to do a scan of any authoritative research or typologies that may be available.
The broader point in terms of the PCMLTFA, in terms of when we’re deciding whether a sector or a threat requires action under the PCMLTFA or being an entity being a disclosure recipient of FINTRAC financial intelligence, there are many risks. But I think one of the key questions, from a financial sector perspective — because the regime is based on transaction monitoring and reporting — is to what extent is a systemically important or gatekeeper-type sector for reporting purposes if we were to put obligations onto reporting entities, which are largely businesses that deal with high-value transactions, is an important factor in terms of fit in regulation under the PCMLTFA?
The decision to add the Department of Fisheries and Oceans as a disclosure recipient of FINTRAC financial intelligence was based on conversations and discussions with the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, understanding that they have an enforcement mandate largely based on illegal and unregulated fishing, where there is a benefit to having financial intelligence and having reporting entities, largely financial institutions, that would be dealing in transactions or seeing money that might be related to these illegal activities reported to support their enforcement mandate.
It’s not to suggest that there’s no risk in this sector, but I think it’s a question of whether the PCMLTFA is the right tool versus a more targeted type of tool.
Senator C. Deacon: We haven’t gone into this thinking that is necessarily the vector we were most concerned about. We are more focussed on the beneficial ownership registry and its application as a tool to better understand licence holders across the sector and who ultimately is the owner. We just haven’t gotten through that issue. I think we have that plan.
I’m still intrigued as to how you identify risk sectors and the extent to which you go and hear voices that are perhaps contradictory to the traditional ones. That may be an area that needs more work because we’ve got a snow-washing reputation as it relates to money laundering in this country, and we do need to continue to disrupt our traditional processes to become better at this. Thank you.
Senator Surette: I’m going to try to focus my questions completely on the beneficial ownership registry as it relates to the licensing regime in the fishery.
The challenge that we’re facing, in my opinion, is that we want to find out who owns the fish and who owns the quota on the West Coast. Added to that, because of the high price of purchasing quota fish, very few people can get into the business, so it means that it has to be somebody with deep pockets purchasing the quota.
What we are trying to get at is who owns the fish there, which means that if we had a beneficial ownership registry — and I don’t know if they qualify under what you mentioned as a federally regulated enterprise — would we be able to identify that company that owns the quota out there?
The challenge is that there are a few companies — from what we hear — that own the majority of the quota, and in order to get fish, you have to lease the quota from somebody that owns the quota.
What we are trying to get at and what they are asking for on the West Coast is a beneficial ownership registry for the fishermen and for who owns the quota. There is no such thing, at the present time, under the beneficial ownership registry. You cannot track these companies.
Nobody is within that system at the present time, not even the big corporations?
Mr. Simard: There is a lot to unpack there, so I will take a step back.
An interesting thing is to see the tools that already exist and then maybe work to identify the gap, or maybe how they could reinforce each other.
Canada has started on a journey of improving corporate transparency. Since 2016, I think, all federal, provincial and territorial finance ministers have agreed to work towards this.
The first step, which we called “phase 1” in our jargon, was to have all the provinces, territories and the federal government amend their corporate law to require that corporations know, themselves, who their beneficial owners are. Because sometimes wilful blindness is also a tool used by a crafty, bad actor.
Now, for corporations in most provinces, the laws have been changed, and provinces, on their corporate books, know who the ultimate individuals that control the business are. That is meant to pierce the layers. It is not because you are wholly owned by corporation A, which is wholly owned by corporation B, which is wholly owned by Martin Simard. The beneficial owner of the child here is Martin Simard. This is what they need to have in their corporate record, which is different from shareholders. Shareholders can be another legal person, and that’s where the chain cuts.
The second step, phase 2, was to centralize this information in registries available to law enforcement and the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada, or FINTRAC. Quebec was the leader. They did that with their corporate registry. Then the federal government did it. B.C. passed legislation, and the big news — and I am giving the update to Senator Deacon at the same time — was last week with Ontario introducing legislation to centralize the information of businesses that are incorporated.
The hook here is where the business is incorporated. The businesses that are incorporated in Ontario, moving forward, this information will be centralized and available, at least in part through the Ontario Business Registry. When you are doing due diligence, you will have access to this information.
This is really big news because about 40% of business corporations are incorporated in Ontario. If you add the federal government, Ontario, Quebec and B.C., it is about 80%. So 80% of businesses incorporated in the country, their corporate registrar in their province — or federally — will have access to the beneficial ownership information. A portion of it will be public, and a portion will be available to law enforcement, like the date of birth, for example, and citizenship and so on.
Now, in a world where many provinces have such tools, what’s the gap for the fisheries? If you know the corporation is that owns a fishing licence, technically, you would be able to know the corporation, go onto the relevant corporate registry and see who the beneficial owners are. That assumes that the relevant provinces have a registry.
In the Maritimes, for example, we don’t have centralized registries for now, and in B.C., it is not operational. There is a question mark here. You need the other piece to be able to cross‑reference.
If you do not have that piece, then you can decide to do it, I guess, fully just for the licence owner. Then there is a second question: Who needs to know this information? Does everybody need to know the ultimate beneficial owner of a fishing licence or only DFO, or only other fishermen or only police?
These are design questions I cannot answer for. They are for the sector to consider.
Then the last —
Senator Surette: Does this apply to the fishery, though?
I could be living in Atlantic Canada and have a quota on the West Coast.
Mr. Simard: That’s it.
Senator Surette: It is a Canadian resource, so the Canadian government, through DFO, allocates the fish to a company. A company can be anywhere.
Mr. Simard: Correct.
Senator Surette: I’m not sure if I follow how it relates to provinces.
Mr. Simard: I’m saying there is an additional tool that can be useful for fisheries and all sorts of functions across the economy, where there will be more — let’s call it — baseline transparency about corporations. But it is just a baseline. In certain sectors, you can decide that you need more information.
I am just trying to say that this thing is being built across the country where, when you want to know who the individual is that ultimately controls a corporation, you will have an additional tool to be able to identify that.
You have heard in this committee that there is the owner of the licence, but there is also the licensee, and who is actually fishing might be different. There is a leasing agreement, for example.
Senator Surette: We don’t have to complicate it that far, in my opinion. We just have to figure out who owns the quota. Who owns the quota is where the issue is, and that’s where they want to find out — it includes foreign ownership too. Is our Canadian resource being farmed out to foreign ownership?
To me, it is a simple issue that we just have to figure out who owns the fish out there, and who can answer that question? It has to be just DFO, from what I understand from you? There is no registry whatsoever that we could even attempt to go to?
On the West Coast, a lot of the fishers in the associations we have heard from just want to get to the beneficial ownership registry. What you seem to be saying is that it just doesn’t exist.
Mr. Simard: I will just say that it does not exist yet for all corporations incorporated in Canada. Then there is the question of foreign — so some foreign jurisdictions do have a transparency register, but not all of them.
If it is a U.K. corporation, you can go to the Companies House in the U.K. and see who the individual of significant control is of that U.K. corporation, but that’s not universal. Although, it is becoming more prevalent.
If you have a Canadian intermediary, eventually the corporate registry will help you, because they are the ones with the responsibility to tell you who their ultimate owner is, even if it is foreign. But if the immediate owner is foreign, then you may have a gap in terms of the domestic registry.
Senator Surette: If I can ask maybe one other question —
The Chair: Senator Deacon wants to interject on your last question, so I will allow him to do that.
Senator C. Deacon: I think what we are looking at is that we need to make a recommendation that DFO use a tool like the beneficial ownership registry and get to the ultimate owner of the licence of Canada’s natural resource.
The framework exists, but we don’t know if these are provincially registered companies or federally registered companies or offshore companies. We know nothing. This, at least, is a framework that could be used by DFO, I think, is probably where we are getting to.
That is what I am sensing.
Senator Surette: Yes, I agree.
The Chair: Senator Surette, do you have another question?
Senator Surette: No, I think that answered my question.
At the present time, you understand the issue of a tool, and we could copy it, and we can recommend. At the present time, you don’t know of any tool that can track who owns the quota on the West Coast?
Ms. Alarakhia: I will say that I am not entirely familiar with DFO’s licensing regime and the requirements in terms of how they track quotas.
Senator C. Deacon: Neither are we.
Ms. Alarakhia: Just from my experience in terms of anti‑money laundering and anti-terrorist financing regulations, I think that’s usually your starting point of who is regulating that sector.
As Mr. Simard alluded to, for example, if they allow quotas to be held by corporations — so the owner of a quota was a numbered corporation — the beneficial ownership registries that are being established can help shed light on who is behind that numbered corporation.
I think the regulatory regime is probably the most targeted way to address the problem of transparency would be with what the requirements are from DFO to know that information about who owns the quotas.
Senator Surette: Thank you.
Senator Prosper: Thank you to our witnesses here.
I have two questions, but the first is for you, Mr. Simard. My question deals with companies owned by First Nations. Many First Nations hold fishing licences through companies owned by the community. The registry excludes Crown corporations because the government owns them. How does it treat a company owned by a First Nation or a modern treaty government?
Mr. Simard: That is a good question. I know that some business development corporations owned by First Nations are incorporated federally. I don’t know if that’s the norm or if they are considered Crown corporations. I do know they in our registry, we do have some of them.
One of the reasons, for example, for the Canada Not-for-Profit Corporations Act — that’s a mouthful — but a non-share capital corporate statute. By that, I mean it is not like a societies act like we have in some provinces, which is for sport. It doesn’t define it necessarily for sports or cultural purposes; it is broader than that. One of the rationales back in 2010 was to allow some not‑for-profit businesses to be incorporated under that statute. I know that it was in part for some First Nations that wanted such a corporate vehicle not to make a profit but to nonetheless conduct business and then have returns for their community.
Senator Prosper: Some are listed or —
Mr. Simard: Yes, some are listed.
Senator Prosper: If some, is it a person or is it a corporate entity?
Mr. Simard: It’s a corporate entity. It is a legal person. They would not necessarily have an individual of significant control because, in a way, the whole community is the shareholders, right? They would not have a single person’s name with a date of birth owning this corporation. It would be the band as the legal entity.
Senator Prosper: Okay, thank you.
I have another question for Ms. Alarakhia and it deals with the Department of Finance’s risk assessment. Finance’s 2025 national risk assessment says that unclear ownership of some fishing quotas leaves West Coast markets open to money laundering. It also lists bribing Indigenous fishers who hold special Indigenous licences as one method used in illegal fishing.
Can you share what that evidence is based upon?
Ms. Alarakhia: I don’t have that information with me right now, but I can go back and try to provide some of the underlying information behind the public risk assessment.
Senator Prosper: Sure, thank you.
Senator Boudreau: I have been listening to this discussion, and I can’t help but feel that, in true government fashion, we are complicating things more than they would need to be here. When I think that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans issued the licences and the quotas, they determine how many licences get allocated every year and how much quota gets allocated every year. They, obviously, know who they are issuing these licences and quotas to. There has to be a database somewhere within the federal government, within DFO or elsewhere, that has all this information.
Now, I get that after the fact maybe it’s been sold to someone else, but then you follow the money, as they say. There has to be a way to trace this. I fail to understand why it is so complicated to come up with a federal registry when the federal government — in this case DFO — has 100% control of the resource and of who gets licences and who gets quotas. How is it so complicated?
Mr. Simard: Again, it is a good question for DFO. The only thing I will say is that it depends on how the legal framework has been done. If the information that is requested is the legal ownership of the quota and if they allow a natural person and a legal person, it is possible that what they have in their database is just a legal person, like corporation X. That would not give them the ultimate individuals who are in control of that corporation.
If their current legal framework is that to get a licence, you need to both provide the legal person and the beneficial owners, then they would have that information. It is a question of the design of the framework.
I have seen three models. There are models where they only ask for the legal person; where they ask for shareholders owning above 10% of the shares; and then you have the full individual who is in significant control concept, which is more than X per cent of shares or voting rights or indirect control. Because indirect control can be, “I only have 10% of the shares, but we have a covenant or shareholder agreements with all the others that have 10% that we only vote together on key decisions.” Well, that gives me an indirect control equivalent to more than 25%.
So there are degrees of granularity in what the regulator can ask in terms of information about ownership.
Senator Boudreau: As you say, there is a current legal framework in place —
Mr. Simard: Yes.
Senator Boudreau: — and that legal framework gives the department a certain amount of data, and that data is somewhere in a database.
Identifying a couple of extra questions on the form or on the annual report to get that information — I get the sense that this should be an easy fix, but that we are trying to involve so many different agencies now and departments in it that it just muddies the waters. At the end of the day, the DFO is issuing these licences and these quotas every year. So change the formula — change the form and the report — and add a couple of extra questions on the form that these people need to sign off on to get their licences and quotas.
Mr. Simard: I will return to my first comment. Yes, but, as a policy-maker, if I go through the motions, I need to think about the day after and what do I plan for them to report if it gets sold. I need to plan how I will verify that information and what penalties I will create if the information is incorrect. I am not saying it is super hard; I am just saying that they will need to go through the motions to design a system that is functional.
Senator Cuzner: There is great hope in that, as a policy thinker, that this is what has to be done. You are not saying it can’t be done. It has to and should be done. As Senator Boudreau and others have said, it should be DFO that is taking the lead on this.
Just with regard to the beneficial ownership registry, you say there is none in Atlantic Canada.
Mr. Simard: They have all changed their laws. So corporations that are incorporated in any of the provinces of the Maritimes need to have on their corporate books who their beneficial owners are. Police can request this information, and they have to hand it over.
What is not yet in existence in the Maritimes is a centralized point of registry, where, rather than the police going to the corporation and asking for this information, they can consult the registry. The added value of having the registry is that you are not tipping off the hand of the person you are investigating, and you can do recoupment as well, in terms of financial intelligence.
It is, again, a much more involved system that has costs. For smaller provinces, that is a significant consideration as well.
Senator Cuzner: So you say British Columbia has that system but it is not operational?
Mr. Simard: They have passed their law, but they have not —
Senator Cuzner: How long would that have been?
Mr. Simard: I want to say 2023; I think so.
Senator Cuzner: Are you getting a sense of when that would —
Mr. Simard: You would have to ask —
Senator Cuzner: Yes. Things are coming together.
You made mention of tools that really wouldn’t fit the bill to advance this issue. You said a more targeted tool would be necessary to get where we want to be. Do you have any suggestions as to what that tool might be?
Ms. Alarakhia: My comment was in the context of whether the PCMLTFA was the right tool. I think strengthening the quota licensing or regulation regime would be a targeted tool or approach. Something like a registry within DFO could be a more targeted tool than the PCMLTFA to regulate an entire sector. Under the PCMLTFA, if what is envisioned would be placing obligations on individual fishermen or fishing licence owners, that might be an overly broad approach to try to mitigate this risk, given there is licensing, a quota regime and a regulatory authority that would probably be the starting point for a more targeted approach.
Certainly, the relationship between FINTRAC and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, as a disclosure recipient, there are options to look at, things like the more reporting that FINTRAC gets, they can develop strategic intelligence and disseminate information on typologies that they might be seeing, for example, related to the trade in quotas and licensing. FINTRAC has a broad reach of businesses that accept money and that deal in financial transactions. That dissemination of strategic intelligence and potentially public-private partnerships are other types of targeted tools that could be considered, short of imposing new anti-money laundering obligations across the sector.
Senator Surette: With the system you have now, if I understand properly, you can track the corporation, but you are not to the point of tracking what you call the ISC, the individuals with significant control, or it is there but the public can’t see it?
Mr. Simard: It is there, and the public can see it.
Senator Surette: Can see it?
Mr. Simard: Yes. One of the other policy design considerations in setting up such a registry is your privacy versus what you are trying to achieve. The balance that we have chosen at the federal level — and it is very similar in Quebec, B.C. and Ontario — is to have the non-sensitive information public, such as the name of the individual who is ultimately in control. They can choose to have their business address public. They need to file their personal address, but if they have chosen to have a public business address, that’s what you see on the registry. The corporate registrar, the police and those who need to know have access to the residential address.
Also public is the date that they became in significant control, the date they stopped, the type of control being between 25% and 50% of shares or 50% and 75% of shares. The information that is not public is the most sensitive from a privacy perspective, such as date of birth, citizenship and tax jurisdiction. That is only for law enforcement. That’s the balance.
We’ve found it is helpful to have the top of the pyramid as public because that gives an anchor for all sorts of people to be able to use the registry. If I am a reporting entity — a bank, for example — and I’m doing my “know-your-client” and opening a file, and the client is claiming that the individual with significant control in their corporation is a certain person, I can go on the registry and see if the name matches. It could be a tool, for example, to support DFO or other regulators that want to have beneficial ownership information for regulatory purposes. That’s the balance so far.
Senator Surette: What exists so far is for bigger corporations, so if you translate that to the fishery and go to the other end with a small fishery, like one to three fishers in the boat, what would that entail for a corporation like that, which is their own little enterprise, to incorporate into a business registry? It is feasible, correct?
Mr. Simard: It is actually a universal measure that includes all corporations. Sometimes small corporations are at risk of money laundering, so it is a universal requirement.
What we’ve found is that, in fact, it is quite easy — I say this, and I’m sure the ears of small businesses are perking up. What I mean is that it is typically a single owner who is also the sole director and the sole individual with significant control. There is paperwork. When they do their annual filing now, they have an additional window where, after having asked if they are the director of the corporation, they ask if they are also the individual with significant control, so you need to understand what that means.
Once you understand the concept, it is not too onerous because of that reason, because the structure is super simple. I’m the sole shareholder, the sole director and the sole individual with significant control. There are some compliance costs, but we found them manageable in the federal registry.
Senator C. Deacon: I am going to stick with where we are and then ask another question about the federal registry.
Where I have come to — and tell me if I am wrong — is that if we believe this is important, we would like to ask the federal government to track the beneficial ownership of all licence holders and federal industries. This is one place where it is a federally regulated industry, and we would like to see the beneficial ownership being tracked. Then there are a bunch of conditions that would be in that, perhaps in addition to what is already being gathered by the DFO, such as shareholders above a certain level. We’d need to have some concept around that.
What information needs to be gathered, and who should have access to that information? Do you have any guidance about how you have structured that and how you think through who should have access?
Mr. Simard: That was a core thing. In fact, when Canada was developing its registry, there had just been a court case in Europe where they had more information publicly, and it got struck down as a violation of privacy rights in Europe. They had to reconceptualize who is entitled to have access to this information.
Among the concerns were, for example, what if I have a dispute with my neighbours on where the fence should be, and he wants to know all about everything I own and starts digging into my filings? It’s quite a process. It goes to who needs to know and proportionality, and that is how we got to the compromise of some information.
In terms of the expectation of privacy, nobody is forced to organize their affairs to a limited liability corporation. It is a benefit from the state to enter into limited liability, so the expectations of privacy are proportional to the benefit you get.
Senator C. Deacon: Many of my friends who are fishers are not incorporated. They are just individual owners.
Mr. Simard: Yes. It was deemed that these data points could be public and others would be better below the fold.
We have another two mechanisms I have not mentioned. Minors are not on the registry. That was part of our analysis. Now with fisheries it is maybe less relevant — or maybe it is relevant. I’m not familiar. If you have been put as the beneficial owner of a corporation for later in life and things like that, we wanted an extra layer of privacy for minors who are under the age of 18.
The other thing is, for sensitive sectors, you can ask for an exemption, but very few have been given. To provide an example, it would be a jeweller who doesn’t necessarily want everybody to know that they own jewellery in their name, for security reasons and to prevent people tracking down where they live and hijacking them. There is a process where you can ask for an exemption. You still need to file and police still have access to your information, but it’s not in the public registry. These are the kinds of features to consider.
Senator C. Deacon: Thank you. That is very helpful.
I remember asking Mark Schaan, a witness on the Banking Committee when the registry was completed and being launched, about whether the federal registry was aligned with the needs of the provinces, and he said that was a priority when building the federal registry.
What’s involved in a province? For example, in B.C., if they’re part of the federal registry, that makes sense in this situation that we’re specifically looking at. They would have B.C. corporations and federal corporations, and all that would be beyond that individual proprietor’s ownership, as such, non-incorporated ownership.
A lot of the information would already be available through the beneficial ownership registry. It is accessible, and the question is, what would be public? Am I correct in my understanding that there is an alignment there?
Mr. Simard: Yes, it’s very similar. The information that the corporations in B.C. are required to hold under the corporate books is very similar to the federal information. The legislation they’ve passed in terms of centralizing is very similar to federal. In fact, they predated it or the dates were close when we were working on this. It’s fairly aligned.
It’s only for corporations, though. If you have a licence owned by an individual —
Senator C. Deacon: A proprietorship is a separate thing altogether. I understand that.
Senator Surette: The added challenge for DFO is you have the corporation, but you have to find out where the quota is and you have to match the two. You can find the corporation, but you have to find who owns the quota. The information has to come from DFO. There’s no other way, correct?
Senator C. Deacon: A lot of what I think is useful for us is getting DFO to do that. All the beneficial ownership information already exists in another database. Linking the two gives us what we’re hoping to see happen. How much of it becomes public?
In Atlantic Canada, there’s no surprise when you see your neighbour has a lobster licence because you know they have a lobster boat. It’s no biggie. What we’re hearing in B.C. is who has the shrimp trawler, but who knows who has the licence?
Senator Surette: Maybe that’s one last question to our witness, if I could.
With the registry the way it is now, is there any of that component at the present time as to how much business they make? No. So this is something that would be added to any type of registry that we would be building.
Senator C. Deacon: It’s not CRA records or anything?
Mr. Simard: As part of the compliance part and making sure the data is accurate, there is an information-sharing allowance in the Income Tax Act to be able to cross reference the information, but it’s for the purpose of making sure that the information on the registry is correct. It is not for ISED to know how much revenue a corporation has done. We cannot know that. Only the CRA can know that.
The Chair: Thank you very much to our witnesses. Certainly, it’s an interesting conversation because from our conversation with FINTRAC leading to the conversation with you, it’s an eye-opener with all the different ways things are being done here. Your testimony and answers today will help us with some of the recommendations that I think will be forthcoming.
On behalf of committee members, I thank you for your time this evening and for being so open and transparent with your answers.
We will proceed to the in camera portion of our meeting. Thank you.
(The committee continued in camera.)