THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN RIGHTS
EVIDENCE
OTTAWA, Monday, September 28, 2026
The Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights met with videoconference this day at 4:01 p.m. [ET] to study the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 10 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025; and, in camera, for consideration of a budget to examine and report on the health, safety, and wellbeing of 2SLGBTQI+ youth in Canada.
Senator Paulette Senior (Chair) in the chair.
[English]
The Chair: Good afternoon, honourable senators.
Before we begin, I would like to ask all senators and other in‑person participants to consult the cards on the table for guidelines to prevent audio feedback incidents. Please make sure to keep your earpiece away from all microphones at all times. We ask that you don’t touch the microphone. It will be turned on and off by the console operator. Please avoid handling your earpiece while your microphone is on. You may either keep it on your ear or place it on the designated sticker. Thank you all for your cooperation.
To begin, I’d like to acknowledge that the land on which we gather is the traditional, ancestral and unceded territory of the Anishinaabe Algonquin Nation. My name is Paulette Senior, senator from Ontario, and I am chair of this committee. I invite my colleagues to introduce themselves, beginning with our deputy chair.
Senator Bernard: I am Wanda Thomas Bernard. I’m joining from Mi’kmaw territory in Nova Scotia.
Senator Robinson: Good afternoon. I am Mary Robinson, representing Prince Edward Island.
Senator Karetak-Lindell: Nancy Karetak-Lindell, senator for Nunavut.
[Translation]
Senator Arnold: Good afternoon. Dawn Arnold from New Brunswick.
[English]
Senator K. Wells: Kristopher Wells, senator for Alberta, Treaty 6 territory.
Senator McCallum: I am Senator McCallum from Manitoba, Treaty 10 territory.
Senator Arnot: David Arnot from Saskatchewan. I live in the heart of Treaty 6 territory.
The Chair: Thank you.
Today, our committee begins its study on the subject matter of those elements contained in Division 10 of Part 4 of Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025. This division would make changes to the leadership structure of the Canadian Human Rights Commission, including transitional measures relating to the appointment of its Chief Commissioner.
To this, we are pleased to welcome, from the Department of Justice, Heather Watts, Director General and Senior General Counsel, Human Rights Law Section, Public Law and Legislative Services Sector; and Eric Nielsen, Senior Counsel, Human Rights Law Section. Welcome to you both. Thank you for joining us. We’ll invite you to provide your opening remarks, to be followed by questions from our members. I understand that Ms. Watts will deliver the remarks today on behalf of the department. I remind you that you have five minutes. The floor is now yours.
Heather Watts, Director General and Senior General Counsel, Human Rights Law Section, Public Law and Legislative Services Sector, Department of Justice: Thank you very much. Good afternoon, chair and honourable senators. We’re officials from the Department of Justice, as was stated. My name is Heather Watts. I’m the Director General and Senior General Counsel in the Human Rights Law Section, and I’m joined by my colleague Eric Nielsen, who is Senior Counsel in the Human Rights Law Section. We appreciate the chance to be here today to speak to you about the proposed amendments to the Canadian Human Rights Act that are set out in Part 4, Division 10 of Bill C-31.
The amendments we’re here to discuss today would implement an announcement made in Budget 2025. The budget stated:
The Canadian Human Rights Commission is introducing an organizational realignment and implementing a more streamlined structure, which includes consolidating the roles of the Chief Commissioner and Deputy Chief Commissioner.
In order to consolidate these roles, specific amendments to the Canadian Human Rights Act, or CHRA, as I will refer to it, are required. The offices of the Chief Commissioner and the Deputy Chief Commissioner are created by statute. The amendments in Bill C-31 would eliminate the role of the Deputy Chief Commissioner and make changes to address how those duties would be performed going forward.
First, by way of background, the CHRA establishes a system for complaints of discriminatory practices within the federal jurisdiction. Complaints may be filed with the commission, which screens them for admissibility and, in turn, may investigate, offer mediation, approve settlements and, where appropriate, refer matters to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. The commission also has a mandate to research and promote equality of opportunity in the federal jurisdiction.
The commission is comprised of a Chief Commissioner, a Deputy Chief Commissioner, an Accessibility Commissioner, a Pay Equity Commissioner and three to six other members.
The Chief Commissioner is the chief executive officer of the commission and has supervision over and direction of the commission and its staff and presides over meetings of the commission. In the event of absence or incapacity of the Chief Commissioner or if that office is vacant, the Deputy Chief Commissioner has all the powers of that position and may perform all the duties and functions of the Chief Commissioner. The position of Chief Commissioner is currently vacant. Since November 2022, the Deputy Chief Commissioner has been acting in the position and has had all the powers and functions of the Chief Commissioner.
Turning to the proposed amendments to the CHRA in Bill C-31, they are contained in three clauses. First, clause 275 would eliminate the office of the Deputy Chief Commissioner. It includes some minor wording adjustments to ensure the resulting provision is clear. Second, clause 276 would provide that acting duties, in the event of absence, incapacity or vacancy of the Chief Commissioner, would go to the full-time commissioner, other than the Accessibility Commissioner, with the most seniority. Finally, clause 277 would deem the current Deputy Chief Commissioner to be appointed as Chief Commissioner when the amendments come into force.
As a result of these amendments, the current Deputy Chief Commissioner would become the Chief Commissioner and there would no longer be a position of Deputy Chief Commissioner.
Finally, I should note that the commission is independent of the Department of Justice. While we’re pleased to answer questions about how these amendments are drafted and would operate, any questions about the commission’s budget and operations would have to be deferred to the commission itself.
Thank you. We’d be pleased to answer any questions from the committee.
The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Watts. We will now proceed with questions. I remind you that you have five minutes for your question, and that includes the answer, although there could be some leeway, considering how many questions we have at the moment.
Senator Bernard: Thank you, Ms. Watts, for your presentation. I would like to hear a bit more about the difference between the roles of the Deputy Chief Commissioner and the Chief Commissioner as well as the impact of no longer having that Deputy Chief Commissioner position.
Ms. Watts: Thank you very much for your question. As I indicated in my opening remarks, right now, the statute says that if the Chief Commissioner is incapacitated, the Deputy Chief Commissioner can act and carry out their roles and responsibilities.
The effect of this, as I indicated in this statement, would be that, once the Deputy Chief position has been eliminated, those acting responsibilities in the event of absence or incapacity fall to the full-time commissioner with the most seniority. In terms of the specifics of the roles that those two positions play right now, I’ll turn it over to my colleague Eric Nielsen.
Eric Nielsen, Senior Counsel, Human Rights Law Section, Department of Justice: I would add that the CHRA doesn’t assign any specific duties to the Deputy Chief Commissioner other than the acting responsibilities in the absence of the Chief Commissioner. There’s nothing spelled out in particular for the Deputy Chief Commissioner to do.
Senator Bernard: Help us understand, then. When the position has been filled, what has the Deputy Chief Commissioner been doing? What is the work? Give us what a typical week may look like for the Deputy Chief Commissioner when the Chief Commissioner is present.
Ms. Watts: As I said, we’re not the experts on the day-to-day operations of the commission itself. They would be best placed to answer those questions. However, as Eric said, because the statute doesn’t specifically define a role for the Deputy Chief Commissioner, my expectation would be that the Chief Commissioner can assign duties to the deputy as required. Again, as I indicated, they can act in the event of incapacity, but the specifics of the day-to-day ins and outs of how the commission itself operates are beyond the scope of what I can speak to.
Senator Bernard: Why is the position of the Deputy Chief Commissioner of the Canadian Human Rights Commission being eliminated? Why was that decision made? Was there consultation with the commission about that?
Ms. Watts: Thank you for the question.
What I can tell you generally and based on my knowledge and experience, as you know, when the government was elected, all government departments and agencies were asked to go through an expenditure review exercise where they had to identify potential cost savings and efficiencies in all their operations. The department went through that, as did the commission. The result of that expenditure review exercise, which was led by the Treasury Board and Finance, was Budget 2025. Within that is where the announcement was made that, as part of the reorganization and realignment of its operations, the commission would be eliminating the position of Deputy Chief Commissioner.
Senator Bernard: Thank you. I’m sure you’re aware that this committee did a study a few years ago on systemic sexism and anti-Black racism in the Canadian Human Rights Commission.
How does the elimination of this position in the commission — and possibly others — affect efforts to address anti-Black racism and systemic sexism in the Canadian Human Rights Commission itself?
Ms. Watts: Thank you very much for the question.
As you noted, this committee did a report on issues of systemic discrimination and racism at the commission. In response to that, then-Minister Virani tabled a government response to this committee. Attached to that response was an annex that was prepared by the commission itself, which I think set out the measures they intended to take specifically in response to that.
What I can tell you is, based on the information we have, part of this reorganization and realignment is meant to better serve Canadians, including those Canadians who bring forward claims of discrimination and racism to the commission. Beyond that, I don’t know that there’s much we can add.
Senator Bernard: Thank you.
Senator Arnot: How much money is the commission going to save by the elimination of this position?
Ms. Watts: Thank you for the question.
Based on the public information that I have, Budget 2025 indicated that, overall, the commission, by fiscal year 2029-30, would reduce their spending by $2.5 million overall. I can’t tell you the specific amount that would be from the Deputy Chief Commissioner position. However, if you look at the orders-in-council that appoint the Deputy Chief Commissioner, that would give you a sense of the salary range for that GIC appointment. There may be additional —
Senator Arnot: Do you have that figure?
Ms. Watts: Yes. When Ms. Malischewski was appointed in 2022, the salary range was between $198,900 and $234,000. She was then given acting pay as Chief Commissioner, but that was the salary range for the deputy position.
Senator Arnot: In the overall scheme of things, it isn’t that much money, in my opinion.
Do you know if the Winnipeg office of the Canadian Human Rights Commission still exists, which was designed to deal with Indigenous issues primarily? Half the Aboriginal people in Canada live in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta. Does that office still exist?
Ms. Watts: I wouldn’t be able to speak to whether that office exists.
Senator Arnot: I don’t think you’ll be able to answer most of my questions, but these are my concerns.
The Deputy Chief Commissioner would act to run the place or as second-in-command. The Chief Commissioner was and is really the external public face of the commission. I know Chief Commissioners travel across Canada and meet a lot of people, so then it’s going to be an Acting Chief Commissioner of some kind who is running the show, I would guess.
Ms. Watts: I can say that the commission has a number of commissioners, including, right now, the Chief Commissioner and the Deputy Chief Commissioner. In addition, just like other government agencies, there’s a public servant in charge of the day-to-day operations. I think the title of that is the Executive Director at the CHRC. When commissioners are out on travel status or doing those duties you mentioned, senator, that is who has the day-to-day responsibilities.
Senator Arnot: I notice that the commission successfully processes somewhere roughly around 700 complaints per year, but I also notice that the complaints went up exponentially in 2025 — basically from 1,360 to 2,190, a significant increase. If you’re only processing 600 or 700 cases and you’re taking in 2,100, it seems to me you would need a bigger budget.
Has the budget increased for the Canadian Human Rights Commission to properly process the number of complaints they’re getting? It’s clear that there are many more complaints coming in than ever before.
Ms. Watts: Thank you for the question.
As I said, Budget 2025 — and, I’m sorry, I don’t have the overall funding envelope for the commission before me, but the budget indicates a reduction over those numbers of fiscal years of $2.5 million.
What I can point to in terms of adequacy of resources is this: I’m sure some of you may have seen there was a Hill Times article on Friday about the commission that talked about the increasing number of complaints that they’ve received. There’s some potentially good news in there because it indicated that they have moved toward shorter processing times despite the number of complaints coming in. The article — and this is based on information provided by the commission — indicates that between July 2025 and July 2026, there was a 51% increase in accepted complaints awaiting resolution, which is what you had referred to, senator. Also, 30% more cases had been resolved during that same period. I think we can view that as some data that may be pointing to this realignment and reorganization internally that the commission has undertaken, what you’ll see referred to in their Departmental Plan and their annual report as a “One Commission” model. They may be achieving some efficiencies in how they deal with complaints, notwithstanding that the number of complaints has increased.
Senator K. Wells: I have a question for our guests.
You mentioned in your opening comments that this was part of a measure of a streamlining exercise. Can you describe a little bit about what specific governance or operational problem is being solved by eliminating this statutory position?
Ms. Watts: Again, my knowledge of the day-to-day operations at the commission is relatively limited. They described in their report the idea of the elimination of this Deputy Chief Commissioner position, plus the other internal changes they have made as this “One Commission” model. As I understand it right now, and as I said in my opening remarks, there are a number of functions that the commission carries out with respect to accessibility, pay equity and the CHRA complaint mechanism. They are internally reorganizing themselves to better support those functions as opposed into individualized mandates, but I think they would have to give you some more specifics as to what they’ve done.
I would note as well, to the extent it may be useful, in the Hill Times article, they had referenced — I’ll take you back. Their annual report indicated they weren’t sure when the expenditure review exercise was done and whether that was going to result in a reduction in the number of positions beyond the Deputy Chief Commissioner position because it wasn’t certain.
The information they provided in the Hill Times article indicates that they’re not going to have to go through further workforce adjustments, so they won’t have to lay off additional people. Beyond that, unfortunately, I can’t speak to what they’ve done with the mechanics internally.
Senator K. Wells: Would this recommendation to eliminate this position have come from the commission itself or from Justice?
Ms. Watts: The way the budget process works and the expenditure review exercise worked, each department and agency received a letter from the responsible ministers. They then provided submissions in response to that letter with their proposals for an expenditure reduction. In the case of the commission itself, while it reports to the Minister of Justice, it is arm’s-length, so it may have come directly from the commission itself. Our shop would not have been involved in that, and obviously the budget and review process is subject to confidence anyway.
Senator K. Wells: You say it may have. Did it? Where did this decision come from? Was it led by a federal government decision imposed upon the commission, or did this come from the commission as a way to address cutbacks?
Ms. Watts: Based on the information I have, savings were identified across town as part of the expenditure review exercises that culminated in the budget, so the announcement of the reduction of this position came through the budget. I think it may be safe to draw a line between all of us having done that work to identify efficiencies and the decisions taken, when those decisions are obviously made by the Minister of Finance and the Prime Minister.
Senator K. Wells: Since this position has been unfilled, was there a conversation about leaving it on the books and not filling it as a measure of budget reduction? We could come to a future point when it’s determined that this position is actually important and needed. It would be easy to fill the position if it weren’t eliminated through statute.
Ms. Watts: That’s a very good question. I don’t know the answer to that. Generally, through this expenditure review exercise, one of the things that the government has tried to do is provide certainty within the fiscal framework. Eliminating positions provides you with the certainty that position wouldn’t be filled moving forward. Beyond that, I can’t speak to it.
Senator K. Wells: Thank you. Given that, as you said, the Canadian Human Rights Commission is designed to operate independently from the government, what analysis would the Justice Department have done to examine the effect of consolidating the positions or eliminating this position, particularly in light of the importance of the commission’s institutional independence and governance?
Ms. Watts: As I understand it, because the commission has that arm’s-length relationship with the department, submissions they would make — and this would apply for expenditure reductions and when departments or agencies make asks for money — would not have flown through the Department of Justice. So in the shop where Eric and I work, we have what we call a policy responsibility for the CHRA, but we don’t get involved in day-to-day financial operations and decision making.
Senator K. Wells: Put another way, is there a concern at the Department of Justice that the elimination of this position could hamper the work of the Canadian Human Rights Commission? We’ve heard the concerns about complaints: how long it takes for a complaint to be processed or ultimately resolved and the fact that more complaints are coming. Are we now dealing with a cutback to a very senior-level position?
Ms. Watts: As I noted in my remarks, the position of Chief Commissioner has been vacant since 2022, and Ms. Malischewski was acting in that role following her appointment as Deputy Chief Commissioner and then provided acting pay. Effectively, the commission has been functioning without both of these two positions filled for four years. I would anticipate that the impact that has had on their operations was taken into account when the decisions were made around the budget, but again, we’re not part of that discussion.
Senator K. Wells: So would Justice not have done its own analysis of where this recommendation to cut this position came from, regardless of whether it came from Finance, the Prime Minister or the commission itself? Ultimately, it’s independent of Justice, but it’s obviously connected to the administration of justice in this country. Would Justice not have performed its own efficiency or operational analysis to determine that this is the right position to cut, rather than other positions?
Ms. Watts: There’s a lot to unpack there. As I said, any submissions around spending reductions would have gone from the commission into Finance and the Treasury Board. The role the department plays in that would be if someone were to come to us and ask for an analysis and questions and advice. Advice we may have or may not have provided to ministers and departments is subject to confidence, and we wouldn’t be able to share that with this table. As part of our overall responsibility for the Human Rights Act, we’re obviously concerned with ensuring that the commission and the tribunal are functioning properly and able to serve Canadians. We take all that information in when we do our policy recommendations, but that’s about all I can say about that. Thank you.
Senator McCallum: Considering the work that the Canadian Human Rights Commission does and how critical it is, will there be a review of the effects of the elimination of this position? If there was concern, how would that be handled?
Ms. Watts: As I mentioned, as part of our policy role, we’re always reading things like the Departmental Plan and their annual reports to see if things seem to be functioning correctly. Something I didn’t mention in my remarks that may be useful is this: Notwithstanding the elimination of the Deputy Chief Commissioner position, there are a number of other commissioners who are appointed, both with full-time and part-time status. The act gives the commission and the government the flexibility to appoint full-time versus part-time members, so that could help address workload issues if those were to arise following the elimination of this position.
Right now, for example, you might have a number of part-time commissioners, and when the term of one of those part-time commissioners ends, you could decide the volume of cases we’re seeing is such that we need more feet on the ground. Then we could appoint another full-time member rather than backfilling with a part-time member. There’s flexibility within the act to do that.
Senator McCallum: Let’s say two more commissioners that were part-time took full-time. Won’t that take away the savings they’re looking at by getting rid of the Deputy Chief Commissioner?
Ms. Watts: Potentially, yes. That would be for the commission to sort of manage within its financial envelope itself, but depending on the funding envelope, there could be flexibility to do that.
Senator McCallum: I wanted to state the concern I have with respect to the increase in cases. They’re getting more complex, and I’m looking at the First Nations policing units that have tabled a human rights complaint in Quebec. We have policing units — I just met with them last week — all across Canada with the same discriminatory process, except for Ontario. As people realize that is a route they can take, and I’m talking about First Nations, then there will be more cases coming in, and they’ll be more complex. But can you deal with that, then, by hiring more full-time commissioners?
Ms. Watts: I think that’s one thing that we’ve identified that you would have the flexibility to do within the existing structure, as it’s set out in the act. So even if the Deputy Chief Commissioner position is eliminated, you still have a number of other commissioners who could work on these files.
Senator McCallum: Thank you.
Ms. Watts: Thanks.
Senator Arnot: I have a quick question. Did you just mention there were new commissioners named?
Ms. Watts: No.
Senator Arnold: Oh, did you not say that? I thought you said there were some new part-time ones named already.
Ms. Watts: I indicated that, right now, there are a number of full-time and part-time members, and if a term for a part-time member were to run out, the act doesn’t say how many have to be full-time or part-time. Therefore, you could replace part-time with full-time if you had the funding to do so.
Senator Arnold: Thank you.
Senator Bernard: First, I’d like to ask a follow-up question to Senator McCallum’s and your response around the funding envelope and the flexibility. I think the term you used was “expenditure reduction.” I would use “budget cuts.”
Do you have flexibility within that funding envelope to determine what positions there might be? What flexibility do you have to determine how many full-time commissioners you may have, for example? Do you have that flexibility within the commission or is that managed by the Department of Justice?
Ms. Watts: No, the Department of Justice is not involved in the budgetary allocations that the commission receives. Right now, under the act, the commission has a Chief Commissioner, a Deputy Chief Commissioner, the other commissioners I named and three to six other commissioners. Notwithstanding the statutory elimination of the Deputy Chief Commissioner position — because that’s the one that’s in law — you have the remaining number of commissioners there. The commission and the government could, within the budget allocation that they receive, decide how they want to spend their money in terms of full-time versus part-time members.
Senator Bernard: Is that within the purview of the commission itself?
Ms. Watts: The appointments are made by the Governor-in-Council. In my experience, when vacancies come up at a commissioner tribunal, there would be consultations with the tribunal to figure out what their needs are, what the workload is like and, for example, if there is particular expertise they’ll need. Then when the Governor-in-Council makes those appointments, they can take that into account. One of the things they could take into account is full-time versus part-time membership.
Senator Bernard: I would like to follow up on Senator McCallum’s question and comment on the increase of the number of cases and their complexity. I would add that there would also be an increase in the number of hate crimes, some of which may come to the commission. We also know that many people don’t file because of the perception that their cases won’t be heard in a timely manner. Therefore, do you believe that the elimination of this position would have an impact on that timely access to justice for those who are filing complaints? Would it also lead to more awareness across the country in terms of what types of complaints can and should come before the commission?
Ms. Watts: Thank you for the question. To build on the last part of it, in terms of knowledge and awareness, one of the functions of the commission is to perform human rights promotion and education across the country so that Canadians understand what mechanisms are available to them, especially if they’ve been victims of discrimination. Often, we educate people on basic questions they may have, like, “Do I go to the federal commission or the provincial commission?” We do that outreach to make people aware. That’s within the commission’s mandate and responsibilities, so I expect, notwithstanding the elimination of this position, that work would continue. I think they’ve indicated in their annual report the types of activities that they’re undertaking.
Overall, the point that you and Senator McCallum have made about the increasing number and the increasing complexity of cases is certainly reflected in the annual reports and information that we’ve received, and that feeds into how they need to best determine their resources. As I said, part of the change the Acting Chief Commissioner is responsible for is performing this reorganizational alignment and asking if there are technology and process improvements they can make to try to deal with cases quicker. As I noted, the Hill Times article from last week indicated they seemed to have some early success in dealing with those cases because everyone in the system recognizes that we want not just for people to have access to these mechanisms but for those mechanisms to work in a timely manner.
The Chair: In light of the increasing cases and the new bill, it seems an odd time to be making a cut, particularly of such a leadership role, back-to-back with these bills. I’m trying to understand the rationale in terms of not the cut but this role, in particular, which I understand you’re saying has been vacant for some time. While we’re increasing the possibility for complaints to come to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, we’re making a cut of a leadership role. That’s an observation.
I’m also curious about whether AI is being used in the strategy to streamline cases.
Ms. Watts: I’ll do my best to answer your question. Bill C-9 was a measure the government brought forward to deal with hate crimes. A lot of amendments were to the Criminal Code. There was nothing about the Canadian Human Rights Act included in that legislation. So, to the extent there’s a trend of increasing hate and discrimination, I would imagine that, in addition to Criminal Code offences, there may be instances of discrimination that get brought to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, for example. That’s a fair assessment of what we’ve seen lately in the trends.
Unfortunately, I can’t speak to AI being used to streamline processes. You would have to ask the commission specifically what it is they’re doing to change their processes to make them more efficient.
The Chair: Thank you.
Senator Arnot: I suspect most of the questions I have and that some of the senators have had should be answered by the Canadian Human Rights Commission and not you. I understand you have a limited role here, but I will ask this question: One of the things the committee recommended a few years ago, in 2023, was an independent review of the experience of Black, racialized and Indigenous Canadian Human Rights Commission employees. Did the Department of Justice support that recommendation, and if so, how has the implementation of that recommendation been going from the Department of Justice’s perspective?
Second, this committee also recommended the appointment of a Black equity commissioner as an independent officer of Parliament. Did the Department of Justice support that recommendation? If so, has that been implemented and how is it going?
Ms. Watts: First, if my colleague has additional things to jump in on, I would welcome him to do so.
When I look at the government’s response filed to your report in May 2024, the Minister of Justice then was Mr. Arif Virani, and he submitted and signed the report.
There were a number of recommendations in the report, as you noted, senator, that apply across not just the Canadian Human Rights Commission but also the public service generally, such as the appointment of those individuals that you mentioned. Whether the department specifically supports that, the government as a whole supports and accepts certain recommendations.
In terms of the specifics of an appointment of an independent officer of Parliament and doing independent studies of the experiences of employees at the Canadian Human Rights Commission, I can’t speak to that. The commission tabled its own addendum to the government’s response, which explained the measures they were going to take internally to address these things.
I’m not sure if my colleague has anything additional to say.
Mr. Nielsen: I would mention that in the government response, which is the independent review of the conditions of the Canadian Human Rights Commission, or CHRC employees that the senator is referring to, they recognized Recommendation 9, which is as follows:
That the Government of Canada commission an independent review of the conditions of CHRC employees . . . with a particular focus on the experience of Black, racialized and Indigenous employees, and that the report be published by a specified date.
They say that options for undertaking such a review would be explored.
As Ms. Watts said, this was a government response, and there are a number of recommendations that related to various departments. That’s not one that we at the Department of Justice are able to speak to at the moment.
The recommendations that were specific to the Department of Justice were Recommendations 7 and 11. One was the recommendation about a fair, timely and effective human rights system. On that one, the government recognizes and welcomes the recommendation for a comprehensive review of the Canadian Human Rights Act and will explore options for undertaking such a review to better understand the challenges facing the system, particularly in light of the Senate’s findings.
So, I would separate those two reviews. One was about staff in the commission, which we’re not in a position to speak about, and the other deals with the policy design of the Canadian Human Rights Act, the statute itself. On that, the government will explore options for undertaking the review.
Senator Arnot: Are you saying you can’t answer the question of whether the review occurred, and if so, what action has been taken in any way pursuant to any review to get a more fair, effective and timely human rights system?
Ms. Watts: What I can say in response to that is that my colleague read out the wording about exploring options. Our shop is responsible for all the policies related to the Canadian Human Rights Act. As part of that ongoing work, we’re constantly monitoring trends, policy developments, what we’re seeing in cases, jurisprudence and what other jurisdictions are doing.
We take all those inputs, including reports such as yours, to help us think through what the policy solutions could be, if and when we are asked to bring forward, for example, legislative amendments by the minister. That policy thinking is always ongoing. It may not always be externally facing and obvious to people outside, but the role of a policy shop is to do that sort of ongoing review all the time as part of our policy function, even if it’s not publicly put forward.
The Chair: Do you expect regulations to be implemented following the potential assent of this bill? What would some of those regulations possibly be?
Ms. Watts: Are you talking about regulations under the Canadian Human Rights Act?
The Chair: No, Bill C-31.
Ms. Watts: The provisions before you today that amend the Canadian Human Rights Act do not require any regulations to implement them.
The Chair: Following up on the review question that was asked earlier, is it anticipated that there would be scheduled reviews with this significant change?
Ms. Watts: The bill that’s before you, unlike other pieces of legislation you may have seen, does not contain a specific review mechanism within it as part of the legislation itself.
The Chair: Thank you.
Senator McCallum: Mr. Nielsen, did you appear before the House of Commons on protecting freedom in 2012?
Mr. Nielsen: I think you remember that better than I do.
Senator McCallum: Did you do the same kind of work for this position, especially when we look at the impact on Charter rights for security, safety and non-discrimination? Many of the people who come before us focus on those issues. Can you comment on that?
Mr. Nielsen: Yes, that was a private member’s bill to repeal section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act, which was the hate speech provision. That’s a different type of amendment because it’s an amendment to the substance of the Canadian Human Rights Act. It removed one of the discriminatory practices. The Department of Justice is responsible for assessing that type of option and advising the minister on the advantages and disadvantages of that type of amendment.
It doesn’t involve the commission’s independence in the same way because it doesn’t relate to the day-to-day operations of the commission. It doesn’t tell them how much money to spend or how much money is available. It doesn’t affect appointments. It’s purely about the substance of the protections in the Canadian Human Rights Act. That type of amendment engages the Department of Justice’s policy responsibility and legal advisory responsibility in a much more direct way.
In contrast, this bill makes changes to the operations of the commission, or at least to the infrastructure of the commission. Also, it came through a budgetary process. We are not involved in the same degree. As Ms. Watts was saying, those discussions happen outside our purview.
Maybe I had more to say then — I don’t remember exactly what I said in 2012 — but it would not have been about the functioning of the commission, its budgets or the appointments. It only would have been about what section 13 was, how it operated, what would happen if it were gone and so on.
Senator McCallum: Do either of you have any concerns about having this Deputy Chief Commissioner removed that you should share with us?
Ms. Watts: As my colleague said, this type of amendment is different from the one he appeared on in 2012, which you obviously have a good memory for. As Eric said, that was about the substance of the types of protections available to individuals who come before the commission. This is not touching on who can bring a complaint, what that complaint looks like or the scope of that complaint. It has to do with the structure of the commission itself and eliminating a position.
As I indicated, notwithstanding the elimination of the position, there are a number of other commissioners that would still be there. They’ve not had both of those roles filled since 2022. So, considering the information we’ve received in the Departmental Plan and what was in the Hill Times article, it appears they have still been able to function and get through the cases notwithstanding the increase, and they have that flexibility to organize themselves in a way to adapt, as you indicated, to the increasing complexity and number of complaints that are brought before them.
Senator McCallum: Thank you.
The Chair: That brings us to the end of our panel. Thank you very much for taking the time to join us today. Your assistance with our study of this division of the bill is greatly appreciated. Clearly, we like to jog your memory as well.
For our second panel, we have the pleasure of welcoming, both by video conference, Hugh Scher, Barrister and Solicitor, Scher Law Professional Corporation, Human Rights and Constitutional Lawyer; and Linda Reif, Professor Emerita, Faculty of Law, University of Alberta. Welcome to you both.
We’ll begin by inviting you to provide opening remarks before we move to questions from members. We’ll start with Mr. Scher, followed by Professor Reif. The floor is now yours for five minutes each when you are ready.
Hugh Scher, Human Rights and Constitutional Lawyer, as an individual: Thank you very much. Good evening, Madam Chair, honourable senators and members of the public.
Some of you may recall my appearing before you as part of the hearings held relative to the report that you issued a couple years ago on anti-Black racism in the federal public service. My background in this field stems from 32 years of practising law, particularly in the field of labour, employment and human rights law. I serve as the senior lead counsel in the Black class-action lawsuit that is now up at the Court of Appeal. I also have the benefit of having served for seven years as the Chair of Human Rights to the Council of Canadians with Disabilities, Canada’s largest disability rights advocacy organization; as well as the President of ARCH, a legal resource centre for people with disabilities; and for a couple of years as the chair of labour and employment law and human rights law for the Ontario Bar Association.
Some of you may recall my representations from last time. Inconsistent with your report, I would have been the person who said that the CHRC is a system that is broken beyond repair. I would have been at that end of the spectrum of submissions that were made before you last time. I view the current changes being proposed as part of the legislative proposal to be an effort to, effectively, rearrange deck chairs on the deck of the Titanic as it’s already going down.
While I have no objection to the notion of the present Deputy Chief Commissioner being appointed to the position of Chief Commissioner, I don’t believe that a particular change in the structure of the management of the CHRC relative to both the Chief Commissioner and Deputy Chief Commissioner is necessary. As Senator Arnot has noted, the Chief Commissioner tends to take more of a public face, and the Deputy Chief Commissioner’s role, together with in-house counsel at the CHRC, has historically been more around the operations and the functioning of the internal workings — or non-workings — of the commission.
I would note that, relative to the recommendations made by this committee, they were not fundamentally incorporated. There was a recommendation to consider a tribunal-based model with direct access to the federal Canadian Human Rights Commission. That has not been considered or implemented. There was the recommendation to implement a Black commissioner as an officer of Parliament, much like the Auditor General, as a means of canvassing anti-Black racism and sexism across the federal public service and particularly relative to the issues governed by the Canadian Human Rights Commission. That has not taken place.
Recommendations were made in terms of an amendment to Canada’s employment equity framework. Hearings were held on that by an alternative panel that made recommendations to the government, which the government, to my understanding, accepted but has yet to implement. These included the implementation of a new category for employment equity of Black workers and LGBTQ workers, among other recommendations. Those recommendations were made well over two years ago, and nothing, to my understanding, has happened regarding them since. Certainly, they’ve not been implemented into the present regimes that are at issue here.
My concern in even considering the recommendations at issue in this legislation is that it almost gives credence to the notion that this change will somehow give effect to a series of positive changes or implementation of new policies that somehow will shift the CHRC toward its actual mandate of truly fulfilling Canada’s human rights investigations and mediation and resolution of complaints, rather than simply changing some of the internal workings in a way that, frankly, will have no meaningful effect on the long-term functioning — or dysfunctioning — of the commission.
My recommendation would be, as it was last time, to move forward again with a direct-access model for a tribunal-based Canadian Human Rights Commission in the same way they operate in British Columbia and Ontario. While it’s not a perfect system, in my view, it creates better opportunities in terms of the prospect of a guaranteed hearing for those that bring complaints. That presently does not exist and, frankly, the number of cases that are brought before the Canadian Human Rights Commission and that actually go to hearing is excessively low.
I am concerned that the use of gatekeeping mechanisms, such as mediation and investigations, are serving a sort of disservice to complainants because while they may get the numbers down and complaints resolved by way of resolutions, they don’t necessarily result in favourable or positive resolutions. They certainly don’t generally result in resolutions that are able to address systemic concerns, biases and barriers that tend to pervade and often underlie many of the complaints brought before the commission.
The Chair: Mr. Scher, I would ask you to wrap up your remarks, please.
Mr. Scher: I was just concluding. Thank you.
In that regard, I again maintain my suggestions to, first, implement a direct-access model; and, second, to appoint a Black equity commissioner as an officer of Parliament, akin to the Auditor General. I also maintain that these changes will not themselves be meaningful in terms of changing the culture at the CHRC.
I await your questions. Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you.
Professor Reif?
Linda Reif, Professor Emerita, Faculty of Law, University of Alberta, as an individual: Thank you very much for the opportunity to appear before you today. I have spent much of my career writing on national human rights institutions and international human rights law.
The Canadian Human Rights Commission is Canada’s national human rights institution. As such, it should have legal architecture and operating practices consistent with the authoritative international standards on national human rights institutions, called the UN Paris Principles. The Paris Principles emphasize the importance of the institution’s independence; pluralism; adequate resources; mandate to promote and protect all human rights; and interaction with the international human rights system.
The Paris Principles are fleshed out by the General Observations of the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions, or GANHRI. If an institution receives Global Alliance “A status” accreditation, this indicates that it fully complies with the Paris Principles. In addition to its reputational endorsement, “A status” also enables a national human rights institution to participate fully in UN human rights procedures, thereby fulfilling an important part of its mandate.
The Canadian Human Rights Commission has kept “A status” accreditation to date, but the Global Alliance continues to make recommendations for changes to its legislation to bring it into alignment with the Paris Principles.
To retain “A status,” amendments to the Canadian Human Rights Act must be made in a way that enhances the commission’s compliance with the Paris Principles and the General Observations. Any new statutory provisions and the conduct of the executive and legislative branches will be examined by the Global Alliance at the commission’s next re‑accreditation review.
I look at Bill C-31’s amendments to the legislation in this context. First, new section 26 eliminates the position of Deputy Chief Commissioner, a full-time commissioner who has priority to replace the Chief Commissioner temporarily in cases of incapacity, absence or position vacancy. This will reduce the total number of commissioners from 7 to 10 commissioners to 6 to 9 commissioners. New subsection 31(2) designates the most senior full-time member, other than the Accessibility Commissioner, to replace the chief temporarily.
The Paris Principles and General Observations are neutral on deputies. They are not required, but the standards contain certain protections for them if they are used. Operationally, a deputy is not needed as long as there is a sufficient number of other commissioners with some experience to handle current and projected workloads. For example, there will be more work if Canada signs and ratifies a human rights treaty that entails domestic oversight, often by national human rights institutions, such as the UN Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture with its national preventive mechanisms.
The international standards also hold that having inadequate resources to fulfill the commission’s mandates negatively impacts its independence. Accordingly, keeping the total number of commissioners to 7 to 10 would be prudent.
It is also important to have an objective and reasonable process for designating an Acting Chief Commissioner. New subsection 31(2) is objective and reasonable. It codifies a process, and the most senior full-time commissioner likely will have the most experience to serve as Acting Chief Commissioner. One concern, though, is that the exclusion of the Accessibility Commissioner also needs to be based on objective and reasonable grounds. Another is that the most senior commissioner may also be unavailable, so there should be a backup clause that designates the next most senior full-time commissioner in this event. This also means that there needs to be a sufficient number of full-time commissioners.
Second, the transitional deemed appointment of the Deputy Chief Commissioner as chief runs counter to the Paris Principles and the General Observations. While the international standards accept the appointment of the Chief Commissioner and other commissioners by the executive branch, they are very explicit that the selection and appointment process has to be clear, transparent, broad, pluralistic and participatory, enshrined in binding law, involve broad public advertising in civil society and use an independent selection body.
A circumscribed or non-existent executive or legislative branch search does not satisfy the standards. The Global Alliance is very critical of the appointment of a Chief Commissioner without a selection process or outside the normal process. Using an Acting Chief Commissioner for an overwhelmingly long period is another red flag.
I’ll stop at this point and thank you. I look forward to any questions you may have. Thank you.
The Chair: Thank you both for your presentations and your remarks. We will now proceed with questions from senators.
Senators, you each have five minutes for your question, and that includes the answer. I ask you to keep your questions succinct in an effort to allow us to have as many interventions as possible. I offer the first question to our deputy chair, Senator Bernard.
Senator Bernard: Thank you both for your testimony this evening. I’d like to ask a very basic question: What is your understanding as to why the position of Deputy Chief Commissioner is being eliminated? Why has it been vacant since 2022? What do you think is behind that?
Mr. Scher: First, there’s no justified explanation of which I am aware for no Deputy Chief Commissioner being appointed over the prolonged period of time.
It may be that the circumstances that gave rise to the removal of the last Deputy Chief Commissioner have served to delay that process. Nevertheless, I don’t think, fundamentally, it addresses broader systemic concerns.
Ms. Reif: I’m not privy to the behind-the-scenes information on either of the developments, but I would suggest that the elimination of the Deputy Chief Commissioner, because it reduces the total number of commissioners to six to nine, is probably a cost-saving initiative.
As I said, I don’t think that is a good idea because of possible currently developing or future developments, both in international law and domestic human rights law, that may require the larger size of the commission. Yes, there is flexibility in whether there be some part-time commissioners, and that can assist in cost savings. However, the GANHRI has indicated that there should be a sufficient number of full-time commissioners in the ratio between full- and part-time and that too many part-time commissioners go to reducing independence.
In terms of the transitional provision of a statutory provision appointing the deputy as the Chief Commissioner, as Mr. Scher indicated, there was a failed search a year or a year and a half ago that may be part of the potentially rushed situation. However, again, international standards require that there be a full participatory selection process. They indicate that doing this very quickly, through a legislative provision, is insufficient and that there needs to be something formally set up, which I think is quite possible to do and should be a permanent selection process. This, of course, takes some thought, but I think it’s a very wise thing to do.
Senator Bernard: What are the potential impacts of not having an open search for the director?
Mr. Scher: Obviously, it guarantees the present Deputy Chief Commissioner the role. It doesn’t allow for the kind of open-ended, inclusive, broad-based search that enables parties from different backgrounds and different experiences and others to be part of the selection process, which, as my colleague has recommended, would make for better practice in appointments of this nature.
Ms. Reif: Yes, you need to have diverse input into selection of the Chief Commissioner, given the importance of the Canadian Human Rights Commission for Canada overall. Yes, there can be in an advisory position an executive member of the selection committee, but there should be parliamentary representatives, human rights NGO representatives and professional experts so you get full input into a merits-based decision.
That’s not to say that the current Deputy Chief Commissioner is not the best person for the job, but there should be open advertisements and an open application so that all potentially qualified people for that kind of position can be evaluated. I think that goes to the independence of the commission, so that you don’t have overtly political influence in the appointment process, and it goes to public legitimacy. We want the public to feel that the commission is being run and led by the best person for the job. Those would be the main considerations.
The Chair: Thank you, Ms. Reif.
Senator Arnot: Thank you, witnesses. I have a question for Mr. Scher and a question for Professor Reif. Mr. Scher, does abolishing the Deputy Chief Commissioner advance the structural reforms you’ve articulated in the past in front of this committee, as you’ve reiterated here again today, or is it largely unrelated to that issue? And are we at risk of confusing administrative restructuring with substantive human rights reforms that, in your opinion, are required?
Mr. Scher: I think that’s exactly what the issue is. The administrative changes at issue here are basically intended or serving to mask the true deficits of problems of the system at large. It doesn’t go to the root of the problem. We can have Mother Teresa as the new Chief Commissioner, and it’s not going to change the barriers and systemic inequities that the current process has within it.
Senator Arnot: Professor Reif, is there a meaningful governance difference between having a deliberately appointed statutory deputy who automatically succeeds the Chief Commissioner, with responsibilities, and assigning those responsibilities to whichever full-time commissioner happens to have the greatest seniority? You could be appointing someone who has no real understanding of the day-to-day operations of a human rights commission. The second question for you is from the perspective of the Paris Principles and international best practices. For national human rights institutions, should Parliament be concerned with institutional resilience and succession as dimensions of that independence?
Ms. Reif: In terms of deputies, it’s not necessarily a bad idea to have a deputy. Will they always have the most experience? I guess that depends. If there is a lot of turnover in terms of the commissioners, then would a deputy necessarily have a lot of experience? You’d want to make sure that, when you’re looking at the entirety of the commission, you have a certain number of commissioners who have certain amounts of experience. One of the pros to having a deputy is that there’s an objective turnover to the next person in terms of capacity and so on. On the other side of the coin, you generally wouldn’t want to leave it open for the Chief Commissioner to choose who would be the person to replace them because there could be favouritism in that respect. It basically comes down to the question of whether the deputy will always have the best experience to take over or whether you have other commissioners who would be equally experienced. I think the latter holds true if you keep a certain number of commissioners — particularly the full-time commissioners who have that expertise and understanding.
In part, you’re looking at how the commission is run in conjunction with how the executive oversees the appointment process.
Senator Arnot: I have a follow-up question on that same issue. You’re an expert in these areas, and you’re fully aware of the Paris Principles. If you were designing the governance structure of Canada’s national human rights institution from those first principles, would you include a designated statutory second-in-command?
Ms. Reif: I see the pros and the cons to going in either direction.
I think not having a deputy and going to the most senior commissioner allows for a bit more flexibility. Would I have a deputy? I would say that is not needed.
The Paris Principles and the GANHRI General Observations are neutral on deputies. They don’t say they have to be there. I would look at if there is a sufficient number of full-time commissioners and if the structure of the commission, in terms of setting up full-time commissioners, allows for more than one commissioner with expertise and experience.
If I were to approach it, I would say you would want to minimize the number of part-time commissioners and maximize the number of full-time commissioners in terms of that ratio so you will always have full-time commissioners with experience and expertise.
Senator K. Wells: Professor Reif, you said that, with respect to the Paris Principles and various incarnations of human rights commissions, some have a Deputy Chief Commissioner and some don’t or are neutral on whether that’s a benefit.
Can you speak on, from your experience or what you know about the Deputy Chief Commissioner position in Canada, how that has operated in the past and if you see it as an important position? In essence, it’s maybe easy to eliminate a position that is currently unfilled without looking at its function and operation in the commission historically.
Ms. Reif: Unfortunately, I have not looked at the Deputy Chief Commissioner’s role historically to see how that has operated. It would change over time, depending on how the Chief Commissioner would work with the Deputy Chief Commissioner and the expertise of the Deputy Chief Commissioners as they’ve changed over time. Fundamentally, there’s nothing in the legislation that lays out the tasks of the Deputy Chief Commissioner, so it makes it a flexible position.
Senator K. Wells: Not being defined perhaps makes it a position that’s easily eliminated if it’s not exactly clear what it does. It maybe serves to complement the skills of a particular commissioner or the lack of experience that they may have that a deputy could provide, good senior management leadership often wanting to have a set of skills at a senior executive level.
If you had a choice here, as opposed to completely eliminating this position — as this legislation before us seems to dictate, simply as a means of saving the budget — would you simply leave the position unfilled for a number of years? Perhaps down the road this position may be needed. It’s sort of harder to bring something back that’s been eliminated through statute as opposed to simply filling it down the road when the option remains. Hopefully, that was clear.
Ms. Reif: Do you want me to give my opinion on that?
Senator K. Wells: In a way.
Ms. Reif: Further to my remarks, because of potential developments domestically and internationally, it’s better to keep the maximum number. You can eliminate the Deputy Chief Commissioner position, but I don’t think it would be a good idea to reduce the maximum number of commissioners to nine by taking away that position. What I think is more likely to occur and what I see happening internationally is — because national human rights institutions also include human rights ombudspersons — whether it’s a commissioner or an ombudsperson, they are appointed to deal with specific issues or areas. We already have that with the Canadian Human Rights Commission with the Accessibility Commissioner and the Pay Equity Commissioner.
I think the trend internationally is to say if Canada decides to ratify the UN Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture, they will have to designate a federal national preventive mechanism as well as provincial and territorial ones. The natural fit is for the Canadian Human Rights Commission, so you’ll probably have to designate a commissioner to deal with that. There might be another area where there’s much more work needed in the future and you will want to designate another full-time commissioner to do that work.
That may have to happen through legislation, but I think it gives the commission much more flexibility to not have the Deputy Chief Commissioner but to have the same number of commissioners in total to give the ability to the government — or to the Canadian Human Rights Commission if they want to do it informally — to have specific commissioners focus on specific issues.
Senator K. Wells: If I’m hearing you correctly, the concern may not be eliminating the Deputy Chief Commissioner but maintaining a current number of commissioners in general that would give that flexibility and robustness.
Ms. Reif: I would be in favour of keeping the current number of commissioners at the maximum of 7 to 10. On keeping or getting rid of the Deputy Chief Commissioner position, I’m not so adamant about that. It’s not to say that the deputy couldn’t also be designated to do something specific as well, although one would say they probably have a number of more institutional administrative duties. However, even there, that’s an ad hoc type of decision of the Chief Commissioner, probably, because there’s nothing in the legislation to require that.
Senator K. Wells: Thank you.
Senator Arnold: Thank you both for being here. It’s been a little challenging to get some answers tonight, so we really appreciate you being here.
My question builds a bit on Senator K. Wells’s question. Our last witnesses talked a bit about a recent The Hill Times article. I just looked at it, and it cites a 51% increase in complaints, yet efficiency is improving.
Similarly, have you seen more commissioners added or things happen in the world and suddenly someone that is part-time goes to full-time? I’m curious if you have seen increases when the demand is there.
Mr. Scher: To start, I have not seen any specific responsiveness by way of commissioner structure in terms of addressing increased demand or increased need in terms of specific issues, whether it’s systemic racism, systemic sexism or Aboriginal issues. Whatever the particular issue may be, I’ve not seen an increase or a fundamental shift in the way by which the commission responds internally through the commission structure to address those kinds of things.
Ms. Reif: In my survey of what is happening internationally, and what GANHRI and their accreditation process indicate, when you go to the Paris Principles, one of the fundamental standards is that national human rights institutions have to have adequate resources, both financial and human resources, to fulfill the mandates that they’ve been given.
What seems to be across the board in various countries around the world, whether they be human rights commissions or national human rights ombuds institutions, is that many of them are being given additional mandates over time, and we can see that in the Canadian Human Rights Commission as an example. However, this is not unique by any means. This is happening in a lot of these institutions around the world, and a very common criticism is that the institutions are not being given sufficient resources to handle all their mandates, including the new ones that they have been given. Inadequate resources are a common problem.
Senator Arnold: In conclusion, would your recommendation be, since you seem sort of neutral on this actual position, to maintain the number as between 7 and 10?
Ms. Reif: Yes, I would. Because of potential new work that may come up, I think it is possible to conserve resources by keeping a certain number of part-time commissioners. As per my earlier comments, you need a sufficient number of full-time commissioners in order to serve as backups in case of a need to replace the Chief Commissioner temporarily or for a longer period of time — though it shouldn’t be too long.
The Chair: Thank you. I’d love to insert a question here.
We heard from Ms. Watts, in relation to the article that Senator Arnold mentioned, that there has also been some streamlining, which probably led to the efficiency that she noted. I wonder if either of you has any commentary about that streamlining. Have you seen that? Are you aware of any AI tools being used to assist with that streamlining? In your world, Professor Reif, do you see that happening elsewhere?
Ms. Reif: Well, certainly budget-cutting and streamlining are commonly adopted by countries over time.
When I look at what’s happening with national human rights institutions, I would ask this question: Are you just looking at them in terms of saving money or should you look more holistically? In some of the research I’m currently doing, Canada made the decision a long time ago not to have a general, full-purpose ombuds institution at the federal level. As a result, they went to numerous thematic accountability institutions, where you have a lot of duplication and extra expenses. If you were to look at the non-judicial accountability institutions at the federal level holistically, including the Canadian Human Rights Commission — there are probably over 20 of them altogether — you could probably streamline things holistically by merging certain entities without having to make huge cuts.
When you look at the Canadian Human Rights Commission on its own, it’s a little bit artificial if the government wants cost-cutting overall. I find that rather unfortunate, but obviously, it seems like that’s the position that the Canadian Human Rights Commission is in at this point. I’m sure there are various ways to try to conserve resources, but at a certain point, it becomes difficult.
What I do see in the current years — and I’m certainly in favour of it — is that, up until the past few years, the Canadian Human Rights Commission didn’t feel as if it had the resources to engage much in their human rights promotion mandate, and education, training, research, public-awareness raising, advocacy and interaction with the international human rights system were overlooked. Beginning around 2022, the commission started to put more emphasis on that part of their mandate, which I don’t think costs a huge amount of money and can be very impactful. I’m glad they’ve been able to keep that up.
I think where a lot of resources have gone historically, and still go, are on the complaint-handling side of things, even with mediation and conciliation being used to try to streamline that. In this new era of budget-cutting, I would not want to see human rights promotion work fall by the wayside.
Mr. Scher: If I could add along the same line, I’m worried about the notion of streamlining, broadly speaking, from a cost-cutting perspective only, particularly where it may not take into account factors such as expertise, representativeness and the ability of the commission to meet its various mandates beyond simply the complaints aspect of it, as my colleague also suggested. For example, I would add the notion of systemic racism and systemic discrimination as an area where the commission has, frankly, been woefully inadequate in terms of addressing either complaints or taking on, on a proactive basis, these kinds of concerns.
Rather than streamlining, my interests would be in ensuring that the commission has the relevant expertise, supportive funding and mandate in order to pursue these areas of concern and that it’s effectively representative and responsive to the communities it serves as well, with a focus on expertise.
The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Scher.
Senator Arnot: If I could follow up with Mr. Scher, if Parliament could make additional changes to the Canadian Human Rights Act to address the problems you identified in 2023 and today, what would those be? What should the two biggest priorities be, in your opinion?
Mr. Scher: It would be a shift to a direct-access, tribunal-based model for the adjudication of human rights complaints and the use of the Canadian Human Rights Commission, much like the Ontario Human Rights Commission, in a way that’s committed to education, training, proactively taking on issues like systemic discrimination, et cetera, where they can build a unique expertise that would enable them to push forward on those kinds of issues or other issues that my colleague has set out. I think that’s the most significant change that would be necessary, and that’s been recommended since the initial report of the La Forest commission going back to 2001.
Senator Arnot: Thank you.
The Chair: Professor Reif, did you want to respond to that?
Ms. Reif: I can understand my colleague’s views on this. This has happened, as he’s mentioned, in several jurisdictions in Canada.
When it comes to the Paris Principles and GANHRI, though, they say that national human rights institutions must have both human rights promotion and protection mandates. While complaint handling is not mandatory, other protections work, like monitoring, reporting and inquiring is. In the past number of years, GANHRI has increasingly called on commissions that do not have the complaint-handling power to add it to their mandate, calling on their states to do so. Certainly, hiving off the human rights complaint-handling process to a tribunal is contrary to international standards and the standards that are developing.
Mr. Scher: I would note that it seems to me that you’d be able to do both by having an integrated system between the human rights-based complaints direct-access tribunal model and a human rights commission that’s dedicated to the oversight, educational and outreach functions that my colleague has suggested.
The Chair: Thank you both. You’ve left us with a lot to think about as we move to the next stage. Thank you for coming a few minutes early. On behalf of the committee, thank you for taking the time to appear before us today. Your testimony will be very helpful for our deliberations.
This concludes the public portion of our meeting today. Colleagues, with your agreement, I propose that we proceed in camera to discuss our report on the subject, as well as a few items of future business, including the budget of our proposed travel. Is it agreed?
Hon. Senators: Agreed.
(The committee continued in camera.)