Skip to content

Combatting Hate: Islamophobia and its impact on Muslims in Canada

Rampant Islamophobia is costing Canadian Muslims their peace of mind, their physical well-being and even their lives.

The Report

Executive Summary

On 29 January 2017, 46 people were attacked in the Great Mosque of Quebec during evening prayer. Six people were killed, five were seriously injured, and many others live with unimaginable trauma. Moreover, the psychological impacts of the Quebec mosque shooting continue to reverberate in Muslim communities across Canada.

Alarmingly, this tragedy was not an isolated incident. The Quebec mosque shooting has been followed by a series of other violent attacks against Muslim communities, including in Edmonton, Saskatoon, London, Mississauga and Toronto.

Muslims have been important contributors to Canadian society since before Confederation. Now representing 4.9% of the Canadian population,[1] Muslims continue to serve communities across Canada in countless ways. Despite their rich and varied contributions to Canadian society, Muslims are often unfairly vilified and marginalized.

The Standing Senate Committee on Human Rights (the committee) was disturbed to hear that incidents of Islamophobia are a daily reality for many Muslims, that one in four Canadians do not trust Muslims,[2] and that Canada leads the G7 in terms of targeted killings of Muslims motivated by Islamophobia.[3]

What is fueling the rise of Islamophobia, what are its effects, and how can we reverse these disturbing trends? These are the questions that prompted the committee to undertake its study on Islamophobia in Canada.

Evidence was gathered during site visits to Muslim communities in British Columbia (B.C.), Alberta, Ontario and Quebec, through written submissions, and in 21 public meetings featuring a wide range of experts and stakeholders. The committee heard from 138 witnesses during public meetings, as well as from many others who spoke to the committee informally during its visits to communities across the country.

The committee wishes to thank the many witnesses who shared their individual experiences of enduring Islamophobia, including incidents of physical violence, online harassment, bullying and discrimination. Their courage deserves recognition, and their experiences demand action.

In particular, the committee wishes to acknowledge the witnesses who recalled traumatic experiences. For example, in Edmonton, the committee heard powerful stories of Muslim women being physically and verbally assaulted, including at knifepoint. These stories were often difficult to share, but they provided the committee with valuable insights into the complex ways in which Islamophobia combines with other forms of prejudice in Canadian society.

Islamophobia is a complex phenomenon that takes many forms. Canada’s anti-racism strategy 2019–2022 states that Islamophobia:

Includes racism, stereotypes, prejudice, fear or acts of hostility directed towards individual Muslims or followers of Islam in general. In addition to individual acts of intolerance and racial profiling, Islamophobia can lead to viewing and treating Muslims as a greater security threat on an institutional, systemic and societal level.[4]

This report includes 13 recommendations based on witness testimony, data, and calls to action from Muslim communities. While there is no single solution to the complex problem of Islamophobia, the committee’s recommendations are designed to ensure that Muslims are empowered to live, work, and pray in safety, on an equal basis with all Canadians. Following the committee’s recommendations, this report is divided into four major sections, which outline what the committee heard over the course of its study and provide further context for the committee’s recommendations.

The first section of the report outlines the intersectional nature of Islamophobia. The committee heard that Islamophobia combines with other forms of prejudice, such as sexism, racism, ableism and homophobia, resulting in experiences of discrimination that are at once unique and tragically predictable.

The second section discusses hate-motivated crimes and the role of law enforcement and federal institutions in addressing them. The horrific acts of violence targeting Muslims in recent years have left Muslim communities feeling like they are constantly under attack and that they are physically unsafe. More needs to be done to strengthen legislative and policy frameworks to protect Muslim communities.

The third section discusses the role of the media and misinformation in the spread of Islamophobia, as well as avenues to confront this phenomenon. The media and the Internet often amplify and perpetuate hateful attitudes, but also have enormous potential to change harmful narratives of discrimination and hate. Similarly, the education system presents both challenges and opportunities for confronting hatred and ignorance, as it reflects the society in which it exists, but can also help change it for future generations.

The final section of the report outlines issues of systemic discrimination. Too often, individual acts of hatred are compounded by systemic Islamophobia, which persists – intentionally or not – through laws, policies and practices in a range of areas, including national security, secularism, workplace discrimination and the federal correctional system. For example, the committee heard extensive evidence of Muslim charities being disproportionately scrutinized by the Canada Revenue Agency without evidence showing that Muslim charities presented any additional risk. The federal government needs to comprehensively examine and correct the prejudices embedded in these and other areas of law and policy.

In summary, Islamophobia is present in Canadian society and in many of our institutions. This is an uncomfortable fact for many Canadians, but one that must be confronted head on. This report highlights numerous personal experiences as well as evidence and expert perspectives presented to the committee, pointing to the need for urgent action to reverse the alarming trajectory of Islamophobia in Canada.

The committee urges the federal government and all elements of Canadian society to take concrete action in response to this report and its recommendations. 


Recommendations

Recommendation 1

That the Government of Canada ensure that mandatory, regular training on Islamophobia and unconscious bias is in place for all employees throughout the federal government and its agencies, and that similar training is made available to the federal judiciary.


Recommendation 2

That the Department of Canadian Heritage develop a multimedia campaign and educational resources on Islamophobia that can be incorporated into classroom activities for various age groups, as well as professional training within the federal public service.


Recommendation 3

That the Government of Canada provide additional funding to address hate-motivated crimes, including to:

  • directly support affected individuals and communities;
  • support the development of national police standards and training, including specialized training for dedicated hate crime units;
  • provide more tools and resources to police forces to help them respond to hate crimes and hate-motivated incidents;
  • introduce a federal hotline for reporting hate-motivated crimes in cooperation with all existing provincial versions, raise awareness of the hotline, collect and regularly publish data, and train operators to refer callers to a range of federal and local services; and
  • enhance the Security Infrastructure Program, including by simplifying and providing additional support during the application process, considering a rebate-based system to ensure that communities have timely access to funding, and reducing the 50% cost-sharing requirement.

Recommendation 4

That the Department of Justice undertake public consultations – with a particular focus on affected communities – and introduce amendments to create specific Criminal Code offences for hate-motivated crimes.


Recommendation 5

That the Department of Canadian Heritage undertake a review of the role and effectiveness of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission in fulfilling its mandate with respect to the broadcasting policy for Canada, particularly the requirement to reflect the needs, interests and aspirations of racialized communities.

Recommendation 6

That the Department of Justice introduce legislation to provide a mechanism for human rights complaints relating to online hate similar to former section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act to ensure that individuals have timely access to justice.


Recommendation 7

That a parliamentary committee undertake a comprehensive review of Canada’s national security framework, as required by the National Security Act, 2017, and that this review include a particular focus on how to ensure proactive and meaningful transparency, and take into account systemic Islamophobia.


Recommendation 8

That the Department of Finance update the National Inherent Risk Assessment using the lens of intersectional Islamophobia.


Recommendation 9

That the Government of Canada introduce legislation requiring the Canada Revenue Agency to collect and publish data on religious organizations subject to audits and revocations, and to analyze such data to develop a strategy to reduce bias.


Recommendation 10

That the Minister of National Revenue review the mandate and functioning of the Review and Analysis Division of the Canada Revenue Agency, taking into account the conclusions of the pending review by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency.


Recommendation 11

That the Department of Justice introduce legislation to establish an independent civilian body to review decisions of the Canada Revenue Agency’s Charities Directorate and provide timely decisions on appeals.


Recommendation 12

That the Department of Justice introduce legislation to modernize the Employment Equity Act, including to ensure that intersectionality and Islamophobia are taken into account.


Recommendation 13

That Statistics Canada further invest in the proactive collection and dissemination of disaggregated data to better enable decision makers to take intersectional Islamophobia into account.

News Release

Ottawa – Rampant Islamophobia is costing Canadian Muslims their peace of mind, their physical well-being and even their lives, the Senate Committee on Human Rights said in a report released Thursday, November 2, 2023.

The report, Combatting Hate: Islamophobia and its impact on Muslims in Canada, outlines the committee’s findings from its year-long study into the sources of Islamophobia in Canada, incidents of discrimination, physical violence and online hate against Muslims, and the effects of these events on individuals and communities.

The committee makes 13 recommendations to address the disturbing rise of Islamophobia in recent years. The recommendations include calls for new educational campaigns and resources, new Criminal Code offences for hate-motivated crimes, and enhanced data collection by the Canada Revenue Agency’s charities directorate, which disproportionately scrutinizes Muslim charities.

While there is no single solution to the complex problem of Islamophobia, the committee’s recommendations are grounded in ensuring Canadian Muslims are empowered to live, work and pray in safety — and on an equal basis with their fellow citizens.

The committee is deeply grateful to the witnesses who testified for this study, particularly those who courageously shared their individual experiences of Islamophobia. The committee also extends its heartfelt thanks to the resilient Muslim communities that welcomed senators into their neighbourhoods, mosques and schools.

Quick Facts

  • The committee began its study on Islamophobia in June 2022. In total, 138 witnesses testified before the committee; many other people spoke to senators informally during the committee’s fact-finding mission to communities across Canada.
  • Muslims have lived in Canada since before Confederation. As of late 2022, they represent 4.9% of the Canadian population.
  • Within the Canada Revenue Agency’s Review and Analysis Division (RAD), three quarters of the decisions to revoke an organization’s charitable status were directed at Muslim charities, despite Muslim charities representing less than 1% of Canadian charities.

Quotes

“Islamophobia is an acute threat to Muslim Canadians and the committee believes urgent action by the federal government is needed to reverse this trend. We must commit to building a more inclusive country and to better protecting our Muslim relatives, friends, neighbours and colleagues.”

- Senator Salma Ataullahjan, Chair of the committee

“Violent incidences of Islamophobia have reached a disturbing and unprecedented level in Canada in recent years. Discrimination and hate-motivated attacks have long-standing and debilitating effects on individuals and communities. Concrete action must be taken to stem the tide of this rise in hate.”

- Senator Mobina S.B. Jaffer, member of the committee

“To effectively combat Islamophobia, it’s crucial to consider that its impact is shaped by its intersection with other forms of discrimination, including those related to gender, race, disability and sexual orientation. Our study found that this intersectionality can intensify the challenges faced by people with multiple marginalized identities.”

- Senator Amina Gerba, member of the committee

Associated Links

For more information:

Amely Coulombe
Communications Officer | Senate of Canada
343-575-7553 | amely.coulombe@sen.parl.gc.ca

Government Response

Senators who participated in this study

Salma Ataullahjan

Salma Ataullahjan
C - Ontario (Toronto)

Mobina S. B. Jaffer

Mobina S. B. Jaffer
ISG - British Columbia

Amina Gerba

Amina Gerba
PSG - Quebec (Rigaud)

Wanda Thomas Bernard

Wanda Thomas Bernard
PSG - Nova Scotia (East Preston)

David M. Arnot

David M. Arnot
ISG - Saskatchewan

Nancy J. Hartling

Nancy J. Hartling
ISG - New Brunswick

Fabian Manning

Fabian Manning
C - Newfoundland and Labrador

Ratna Omidvar

Ratna Omidvar
ISG - Ontario

Ex-officio members: The Honourable Senator Marc Gold, P.C. or Patti LaBoucane-Benson, The Honourable Senator Donald Plett or Yonah Martin

Other Senators who have participated in the study: The Honourable Senator Michèle Audette, The Honourable Senator Yvonne Boyer, The Honourable Senator Bev Busson, The Honourable Senator Andrew Cardozo, The Honourable Senator Jane Cordy, The Honourable Senator Dennis Dawson (retired), The Honourable Senator Pat Duncan, The Honourable Senator Leo Housakos, The Honourable Senator Victor Oh, The Honourable Senator Mohamed-Iqbal Ravalia, The Honourable Senator Paula Simons, The Honourable Senator Yuen Pau Woo.

Back to top