Skip to main content

Competition Act

Bill to Amend--Third Reading

November 19, 2026


Hon. Yonah Martin (Deputy Leader of the Opposition) [ + ]

Honourable senators, I rise today at third reading of Bill S-239, An Act to amend the Competition Act, also known as the Canadian prosperity act.

I would like to start by thanking our colleague Senator Klyne for sponsoring this bill and for his commitment to a more open and integrated Canadian economy. I would also like to thank the members of the Standing Senate Committee on Banking, Commerce and the Economy, the witnesses who appeared and the officials from the Competition Bureau, who helped us understand how this bill would work in practice.

At second reading, I said that I supported the bill’s intent, and I also raised several questions that I believed needed careful study.

Today, I would like to review how the bill has changed and how the committee examined those concerns.

Let me start with the goal. Barriers to trade within Canada are costly, even when Canadians cannot see them. They raise the prices families pay, limit where workers can use their skills and add costs for businesses that want to grow beyond their home province or territory. At a time when so many households are struggling with the cost of living and global trade has become less predictable, Canada cannot afford to keep its own domestic market divided.

Competition is one of the most effective tools we have to address these pressures. When businesses can enter new markets, consumers have more choice, prices come under downward pressure and companies have more reason to innovate. When rules prevent that, everyone pays more. That is why it makes sense to give the Commissioner of Competition, supported by the expertise of the Competition Bureau, a clear way to recommend changes to governments and to require federal institutions to respond publicly.

Honourable senators, the committee adopted three amendments. The first amendment, moved by Senator Fridhandler, broadens the commissioner’s recommendation power. As introduced, the bill limited recommendations for barriers to trade within Canada that unduly affect competition. As amended, the commissioner may make recommendations to improve the state of competition in the market or industry under inquiry or in a related market or industry in Canada.

This is a significant change. It means the response process would no longer be limited to one type of competition problem. That has some advantages. Unnecessary regulatory burdens do not always fit neatly into the category of an internal trade barrier, and Canadians benefit whenever governments are asked to examine rules that make markets less competitive.

However, I want to be clear that internal trade barriers must remain at the heart of this mechanism. At second reading, I urged that the focus remain on direct relief rather than expanded studies and on the sectors where barriers do the most harm, such as agriculture, energy, transportation and resource development. There are other sectors, but that’s just to highlight some key sectors. A broader recommendation power must not dilute that focus. I expect the commissioner to use this tool where it can deliver the most tangible benefits for consumers, workers and businesses.

The second amendment, moved by Senator Varone, provides that recommendations under this new power must not propose eliminating or modifying requirements, restrictions or other measures established or administered under the Food and Drugs Act, other acts administered by the Minister of Health or regulations, rules or orders made under those acts where those measures are intended to protect the health or safety of Canadians.

No one in this chamber wants competition policy to come at the expense of public health and safety. This amendment provides that assurance explicitly. At the same time, we should be honest about how broad the wording is. It covers modification as well as elimination, and it contains no exception for changes that would maintain the same level of protection while reducing duplication or unnecessary costs.

I raise this because good regulation and good competition policies are not opposites. At second reading, I spoke about mutual recognition: If a product or service meets safety and quality requirements in one province or territory, it should generally be accepted in others without repeated approvals.

The committee heard a similar message from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business. Its representatives emphasized that businesses are not asking governments to lower standards but to recognize that different rules can achieve the same outcomes.

Protecting health and safety and removing needless duplication can and should go hand in hand. Within the limits established by this amendment and through other available avenues, governments should continue to pursue competition-friendly ways to achieve legitimate public objectives.

The third amendment, also moved by Senator Fridhandler, makes two practical improvements. First, the 120-day period now begins when the report is delivered to the head of the institution, not when it is published. Second, the commissioner must publish responses and notices when a provincial institution does not respond on the commissioner’s website rather than on an unspecified public website.

These are sensible changes. Institutions will have a clear starting point for their response period, and Canadians will know where to find the record. I welcome all of these improvements to the bill’s transparency.

Honourable senators, I welcome the committee’s examination of the practical questions surrounding the bill, including its resource implications, the effectiveness of public accountability and the importance of cooperation among governments. These discussions helped clarify how the mechanism is intended to work. They also reinforced the need to distinguish between a useful tool for encouraging reform and a guarantee that reform will follow.

On resources, the sponsor’s office advised the committee that its consultations indicated additional resources would not be required, explaining that the bureau already carries out public policy advocacy and could undertake this work within its existing resources. I welcome that assurance, while recognizing the importance of monitoring the practical demands on both the bureau and the federal institutions required to respond. Implementation should remain efficient and respectful of taxpayers.

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business offered a helpful perspective on the bill’s potential and its limits. It supported the additional transparency and accountability measures, while acknowledging that this legislation would not eliminate remaining internal trade barriers on its own.

That is an important distinction. Requiring governments to explain their decisions publicly can create pressure for change, but a response is not the same as removing a barrier. The value of this mechanism will ultimately depend on what governments do with the recommendations they receive.

The committee also considered the limits of voluntary provincial and territorial responses. That cooperative approach respects our federal system, and I believe it is the right one. However, as the Canadian Federation of Independent Business emphasized, many remaining internal trade barriers fall outside federal jurisdiction. Success will therefore depend on governments choosing to engage. I encourage them to treat the commissioner’s recommendations as an opportunity to examine existing rules, explain their decisions and work together on practical improvements.

Finally, I welcome the committee’s discussion of public reporting and ways to assess progress. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business supported greater reporting, while cautioning that separating this bill’s effects from those of other internal trade reforms would be difficult. Even so, Canadians deserve to know whether recommendations are followed by action. I therefore encourage the commissioner and governments to track implementation and practical results over time. The test should not simply be how many reports are published or responses received but whether businesses face fewer obstacles, workers have greater opportunities and consumers benefit from stronger competition.

Honourable senators, despite some reservations, I believe that Bill S-239 is a constructive step forward. It draws on the expertise of the Competition Bureau to identify rules that hold back competition. It requires federal institutions to answer publicly. And it reinforces an important principle: Canada should be one economy, where goods, services and people can move freely from coast to coast to coast.

Removing these barriers is not only about economic efficiency. It is about lowering the cost of living, helping families keep more of what they earn, creating stable jobs and building a stronger fiscal foundation for our country through economic growth.

For these reasons, our Conservative caucus will support Bill S-239 at third reading. Again, I want to thank Senator Klyne for sponsoring this bill and the committee for doing a very good job on the improvements through the amendments that were made.

I hope that this bill will help turn good intentions into the concrete results Canadians deserve.

Thank you.

The Hon. the Speaker pro tempore

Are senators ready for the question?

The Hon. the Speaker pro tempore

Is it your pleasure, honourable senators, to adopt the motion?

Hon. Senators: Agreed.

(Motion agreed to and bill, as amended, read third time and passed.)

Back to top