Skip to main content

Question of Privilege

Speaker’s Ruling Reserved

October 29, 2026


Hon. Fabian Manning [ + ]

Honourable senators, as Chair of the Special Senate Committee on the Building Canada Strong Act, which is studying Bill C-39, I rise on a question of privilege pursuant to rule 13-4(a) of the Rules of the Senate.

I am raising this matter without notice because the circumstances giving rise to whether this qualifies as a question of privilege were determined after the deadline for providing written notice.

While I first learned about the potential breach last evening, I was led to believe by the committee clerk that the matter should be addressed through a point of order in the chamber and, therefore, did not believe there was a notice requirement. However, based on new information I received this morning, I am now convinced that this is a matter of privilege affecting the committee, its members and the privileges of all senators. I, therefore, raise it at the earliest opportunity to bring it to your attention.

Honourable senators, the question of privilege being raised concerns the unauthorized disclosure to an external stakeholder of the confidential work plan prepared for the Special Senate Committee on the Building Canada Strong Act, which is studying Bill C-39, as well as the contents of in camera deliberations and resulting targeted harassment of a member of that committee.

The work plan contained information intended to remain confidential in order to protect the integrity of the committee’s work and its deliberative processes. Its unauthorized disclosure raises serious concerns regarding the protection of confidential parliamentary materials, the integrity of the committee proceedings and the ability of the committee to discharge its mandate free from unauthorized external interference, with a particular concern that the disclosure led to the targeted harassment of at least one member of the committee. This consequence demonstrates the potential harm arising from the unauthorized release of confidential information concerning parliamentary work. It raises serious concerns that information entrusted to the parliamentary process may be used to target individual senators because of their involvement in committee proceedings, potentially exposing them to pressure, intimidation or harassment in the performance of their parliamentary duties.

The incident, therefore, raises concerns extending beyond the unauthorized disclosure of a confidential document. It calls into question the adequacy of the safeguards protecting confidential committee materials and the potential consequences for senators when such information is improperly shared with individuals outside of the parliamentary process. The resulting harassment risks undermining the conditions necessary for senators to carry out their responsibilities independently and without undue external pressure.

Under rule 13-1 of the Rules of the Senate, a violation of the privileges of any senator affects all senators and the ability of the Senate to carry out its functions. Rule 13-2(1) establishes the criteria for a question of privilege to be accorded priority, including that the matter directly concerns the privileges of the Senate, one of its committees or a senator; involves a grave and serious breach; and seeks a genuine remedy within the Senate’s authority for which no other parliamentary process is reasonably available.

Further, Appendix IV of the Rules of the Senate establishes a procedure for dealing with the unauthorized disclosure of confidential committee reports, documents and proceedings. It provides an examination of the circumstances surrounding the disclosure, including its source, nature, extent and actual or potential implications for the committee and the Senate.

In the present circumstances, disclosure of the confidential work plan and contents of in camera deliberations, together with the resulting targeted harassment of a committee member, warrants serious consideration of whether parliamentary privilege has been breached and whether the incident has impaired or threatens to impair the committee’s ability to conduct its work effectively and independently.

The matter is raised in order to seek an appropriate remedy within the Senate’s authority, including an examination of the circumstances surrounding the disclosure and its consequences.

Should the Speaker find that a prima facie question of privilege has been established, I am prepared to move the appropriate motion to refer the case to the Standing Committee on Rules, Procedures and the Rights of Parliament for investigation and report and to obtain such other remedies as the Senate considers appropriate.

The requested examination by the Rules, Procedures and the Rights of Parliament Committee should address the circumstances in which a confidential work plan was disclosed to an external stakeholder, including how the disclosure occurred and the extent of the information shared; the measures in place to protect the confidentiality of the work plan and the adequacy of those safeguards; the connection between the disclosure and the subsequent targeted harassment of a committee member, including the nature and seriousness of the consequences; the actual or potential impact of the disclosure and resulting harassment on the committee’s ability to fulfill its mandate and on the ability of its members to discharge their parliamentary responsibilities without intimidation or undue external pressure; and the appropriate measures to establish accountability, strengthen the protection of confidential committee materials and prevent similar instances in the future.

Honourable senators, I believe this matter satisfies the four criteria established under rule 13-2(1). First, I have raised this matter at the earliest opportunity.

Second, the matter directly concerns the privileges of the committee.

Third, the circumstances constitute a grave and serious breach because this matter is raised in the interest of preserving the privileges of the Senate, protecting the integrity and confidentiality of its committee proceedings and ensuring that senators can discharge their parliamentary duties without being subjected to targeted harassment arising from the unauthorized disclosure of information related to their work.

Fourth, the matter requires a remedy within the authority of the Senate, and no other parliamentary procedure is reasonably available to address this alleged breach. While there may be a question as to why it wouldn’t first be referred to the special committee itself for investigation, this is a special committee that is consumed with studying a specific piece of government legislation. As per its mandate of reference adopted on October 8 by the Senate, the Special Senate Committee on the Building Canada Strong Act, which is studying Bill C-39, would cease to exist once its final report is presented. Referring to that special committee would impede work on the legislation itself and could be argued as a future breach of privilege.

The seriousness of this incident warrants appropriate scrutiny and a determination of the measures necessary to safeguard the Senate’s proceedings, its committees and the members entrusted with carrying out their work.

For this reason, honourable senators, I respectfully ask the Speaker to find that a prima facie question of privilege has been established.

Hon. Duncan Wilson [ + ]

Honourable senators, as the senator who was taking part in an external meeting yesterday afternoon and learned of the breach of confidentiality around the committee’s draft work plan and also the deliberations of the steering committee and as the senator who reported the matter to our chair, I also wanted to add to Senator Manning’s commentary that what was communicated to me was not just the deliberations of the steering committee discussions but a significant, damaging misrepresentation of those deliberations. Thank you.

Honourable senators, I rise in support of Senator Manning raising this issue before the Speaker for an early ruling. I will state the fact that this incident has now cast a cloud over the committee’s work, especially in the context of the preparation for further meetings and hearings of the committee to ensure we can complete the necessary work with regard to this government legislation. I think the earliest opportunity you can rule on this matter will certainly clear the air for the committee to continue its work and have confidence among its members.

Hon. Pat Duncan [ + ]

Honourable senators, I am extremely troubled by the situation that occurred at the Special Senate Committee on the Building Canada Strong Act.

As you know, I’m not bilingual, but I still hope to be able to share my thoughts, given the seriousness of the situation.

This is a troubling situation that warrants our attention. I was reminded of the prayer offered at the opening of the Yukon Legislative Assembly: To the Creator, grant that we may make only sound, fair and wise decisions on behalf of the people we represent.

These words speak to the responsibility that all of us carry as honourable parliamentarians. Canadians count on us to approach the work before us thoughtfully, fairly and with sound judgment. This is particularly true when we speak to one another, how we speak of one another and how we represent this institution. Fundamentally, this responsibility depends on trust. We must be able to trust one another, to trust the processes under which we work and to have confidence that the conditions necessary for senators — our colleagues — to carry out their parliamentary duties will be respected.

Parliamentary privilege exists to protect the ability of parliamentarians to carry out our duties. This privilege protects the ability of Parliament itself to function effectively. When concerns are raised that may touch upon those privileges or the integrity of our proceedings, we all have a collective responsibility to ensure that they are considered through the proper process. It is our duty incumbent on every one of us. The position of trust that we hold dear is what allows us to represent this institution to the very best of our abilities. Where that trust may have been affected, we must look to identify the deficiencies and seek proper remedies.

Honourable colleagues, as a fellow member of the steering committee and as a member of this chamber, I share the concerns expressed in the question of privilege and the intent to make further inquiries, which may enable us to address this issue as appropriate as soon as possible. The circumstances that were presented today go to our very ability to freely express ourselves in committee and to regulate our affairs without obstruction or intimidation. As quoted in your recent Speaker’s ruling from a report by the Standing Committee on Privileges, Standing Rules and Orders from April 2000:

The violation of the confidentiality of in camera discussions undermines the confidence with which senators can discuss things freely, and affects their ability to carry out the work on behalf of the Senate.

Honourable senators, that is how we protect not only the rights and privileges of each one of us but also the integrity of the Senate and the trust that Canadians have in this institution.

Colleagues, thank you for your kind attention. Mahsi’cho. Thank you.

Hon. Flordeliz (Gigi) Osler [ + ]

Honourable senators, I want to thank Senator Manning for bringing this forward, and I want to thank all of my colleagues for their speeches today.

Let me read the definition: Parliamentary privilege consists of the special rights, powers and immunities that allow the Senate and individual senators to perform their constitutional and legislative functions free from external interference.

I heard from a fellow senator today about how they were impacted. I too would also appreciate it if the Speaker could evaluate this and provide a ruling as soon as possible so that senators and the committee can continue to do this important work. Thank you, Your Honour, for looking at this as soon as you can.

The Hon. the Speaker [ + ]

Thank you, Senator Manning, for bringing this question to the Senate’s attention, as well as all senators who participated in this debate. I will take this question under advisement. Thank you.

Back to top