Skip to main content
AEFA - Standing Committee

Foreign Affairs and International Trade


THE STANDING SENATE COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE

EVIDENCE


OTTAWA, Thursday, June 4, 2026

The Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade met with videoconference this day at 11 a.m. [ET] to examine, and report on, such issues as may arise from time to time relating to foreign relations and international trade generally.

Senator Peter M. Boehm (Chair) in the chair.

[Translation]

The Chair: My name is Peter Boehm. I am a senator from Ontario and the chair of the Standing Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade.

I will now ask my fellow senators to introduce themselves.

[English]

Senator Adler: Charles Adler, Manitoba.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: I am Amina Gerba from Quebec.

[English]

Senator Woo: Yuen Pau Woo, British Columbia.

Senator Harder: Peter Harder, Ontario.

Senator M. Deacon: Welcome. Marty Deacon, Ontario.

Senator Coyle: Mary Coyle, Antigonish, Nova Scotia.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: I am Martine Hébert from Quebec.

[English]

Senator Al Zaibak: Mohammad Al Zaibak, Ontario.

The Chair: Welcome, senators. I would also like to welcome anyone who is watching us today across the country on ParlVU.

Colleagues, we are meeting today to discuss the situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Today, we have the pleasure of welcoming to the committee as an individual, Jon Allen, who, among other things that he has done in his illustrious foreign service career, is the former Canadian ambassador to Israel; from the World Food Programme, joining us from Rome, again, is Matthew Hollingworth, the Assistant Executive Director, Department of Programme Operations, also by video conference; and from Doctors Without Borders, in the room with us today, Michael Lawson, Humanitarian Representative to Canada.

Welcome to all of you. Thank you for taking the time to be with us today.

Before we hear your opening statements and proceed to questions and answers, I would ask everyone present in the room to please mute notifications on your devices.

We are ready to hear opening remarks. We will have our three witnesses sequentially: Mr. Allen first, followed by Mr. Hollingworth and Mr. Lawson.

Colleagues, also please observe the best practices on the cards in terms of the use of microphones and earpieces to protect our staff, particularly our interpreters.

Colleagues, our witnesses are with us for 90 minutes. This will be a longer session in terms of the segments. With that, you will have the pleasure of having four-minute segments for your questions. It is Christmas in June, I know.

We will go to Mr. Allen for his opening statement, followed by Mr. Hollingworth and Mr. Lawson.

Mr. Allen, you have the floor.

Jon Allen, Former Canadian Ambassador to Israel, as an individual: Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your invitation to speak to the committee today.

Let me begin, by way of introduction, by acknowledging that I am Jewish and confirm that I strongly support a state of Israel that is able to live in peace and security in a complex and difficult region.

At the same time, I am equally supportive of a Palestinian right to self-determination. I spoke a year and a half ago before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development in favour of Canada’s recognition of a Palestinian state. In my view, neither the 7.5 million Israeli Jews nor the 7.5 million Palestinians who currently live between the now-infamous Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea will be able to achieve that peace and security without both sides accepting the two-state solution.

Turning to the topic at hand, I’ll begin with the situation in Gaza. Following the announcement of the 20-point Trump peace plan in October 2025, a formal ceasefire began. The Israel Defense Forces, or IDF, occupied approximately 53% of Gaza, and Hamas and other forces controlled the rest. The agreement called for the gradual disarming of Hamas and for the withdrawal of Israeli forces to enable humanitarian supplies to begin to flow into the Gaza Strip in significant amounts and for a technical committee of apolitical Gazans with expertise in health, reconstruction, water and urban planning, et cetera, to begin to govern.

Unfortunately, to date, only limited amounts of humanitarian supplies have entered. The most important concerns, as you will hear, I am sure, relate to the lack of construction materials to enable Gazan refugees to move from tents to proper accommodation and the lack of water, food and proper medical care for the hundreds of thousands of sick and wounded Gazans living in an area one quarter of the size of the city of Detroit.

At the same time, and despite the ceasefire, some 1,000 Palestinians, including approximately 180 children and four IDF soldiers, have been killed in Gaza.

The former United Nations official Nickolay Mladenov, appointed under the Trump plan to manage the transition, has, to date, been unable to convince Hamas to begin disarming, to move the IDF back from its original line of control or to convince Israel to allow that technocratic committee to enter the Gaza Strip.

Indeed, Israel announced last week — without explanation — that it would begin occupying 70% of Gaza, a move that will only further exacerbate the humanitarian situation.

In sum, while I am thankful that the bombing of innocent Gazans has stopped, movement to a more permanent solution in Gaza is far from taking place, and President Trump and his advisers, on the file, have — as was predicted by many — become preoccupied with other files, including Iran and Ukraine.

Turning to the West Bank, the situation has gone from bad to worse. Two far-right Israeli ministers — Itamar Ben-Gvir, who is responsible for public security, including the police and prisons, and Bezalel Smotrich, who is the minister of finance with special responsibility for the West Bank — are the strongest supporters in the current Israeli cabinet for annexation by Israel of the entire West Bank. They also not only support but encourage the actions of certain settlers who regularly attack Palestinians, illegally evict them from their lands and destroy their herds and olive groves.

They have killed at least 19 Palestinians and wounded many others, often under the permissive eye of Israeli soldiers and the local police forces. None of those settlers have been convicted in those deaths, and few are ever even detained or charged for any of the increasing incidents of violence.

Most of these Israelis, the so-called hilltop settlers, live on land that, even under Israeli law, is Palestinian and has been stolen from Palestinians.

Recently, the Israeli government announced its approval of the establishment of the so-called E1 settlement that would effectively divide the West Bank in two, making a contiguous Palestinian state virtually impossible if it were to continue. The E1 has been opposed by successive Western governments, including the U.S., for over a decade.

Despite the above, in my view and in the view of Israeli experts, whom I trust, the two-state solution remains a realistic option. I am happy to explain why during the question period.

Two hundred and fifty thousand of the current 750,000 settlers would have to relocate or be removed. Much of what the current Israeli government has allowed would have to be undone, including transferring the administration of the West Bank from the IDF to the Israeli civil administration. As mentioned, two states is the only realistic outcome for these two peoples.

I will end, Mr. Chairman, by drawing your attention to a letter to the Prime Minister that I, and 189 former colleagues, recently signed and sent to him, encouraging the Prime Minister to take action to prevent further violence and Israeli government efforts to annex the West Bank, to work to expand humanitarian assistance in Gaza and to work with his counterparts in the West to bring about a real ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon.

Thank you very much.

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Allen.

We will go to Mr. Hollingworth, please.

Matthew Hollingworth, Assistant Executive Director, Department of Programme Operations, World Food Programme: Honourable chair, good afternoon to you.

Senators and distinguished witnesses, thank you once again for this opportunity today to speak about Palestine.

I’ll share an overview of the humanitarian and food security situation, as well as our work in both the Gaza Strip and in the West Bank, including the challenges we are facing and the support that we need.

Let me first mention that I have worked in Palestine and Gaza at various times in my career. I started there in 1997. I worked there in 2008, and I established the World Food Programme, or WFP, operations in Gaza in January 2024.

In Gaza, for approximately seven months now, after the October 2025 ceasefire, the situation remains deeply fragile. Violence affects civilians on a daily basis, while disarmament negotiations and the interim governance arrangements have been stalled.

There are growing concerns among Gazans and among Palestinians in Gaza today of a return to full-scale conflict, compounded by increased security incidents across the Gaza Strip in recent weeks, including airstrikes and drone activity daily. The recent announcement of the potential expansion of Israeli Defence Forces control to around 70% of the territory has raised the spectre of further pressure on communities and the intensification of the conflict.

Against this backdrop, the humanitarian response remains largely stuck in a life-saving, hand-to-mouth mode of operation, driven by severe access constraints and a highly volatile security environment. This makes planning and managing supply chains and the sustained delivery of assistance extremely difficult. Despite this, the World Food Programme continues to operate at scale daily. Last month, we reached approximately 1.2 million people with food assistance and around 400,000 people through cash-based transfers.

In addition, we are supporting bakeries that produce over 130,000 packages of fresh bread every day, and we continue to provide hot meals to 250,000 people every single day — critical given the level of displacement and the constraints with regard to access to affordable cooking fuel.

From a food security perspective, we have seen some improvement since the ceasefire began, driven by increased commercial and humanitarian flows. However, very importantly, dietary diversity is a really serious concern. Many households, many families, cannot afford fresh or nutritious food on a regular basis. Food prices are extremely sensitive to any indication that supplies may be constrained. Prices spiked at the onset of the regional conflict in February and have remained elevated ever since.

At the same time, operational constraints continue to have direct implications on food security. Limited crossing points, restrictions on the import of essential items and disruptions to supply chains all affect our ability to deliver consistently. Only one crossing exists today into the Gaza Strip — Kerem Shalom in the south. That is the only one allowed for humanitarian and commercial cargo. The Zikim crossing in the north was closed on May 24.

Gaza remains one of the most densely populated areas in the world, and, clearly, pressure on the infrastructure of that area is immense. In this context, many experienced humanitarian partners with very clear and strong operational capacities have been unable to maintain or resume operations since the deregistration policy for international NGOs was imposed by the Knesset in Israel.

In a highly volatile environment, WFP and humanitarian partners continue to lack the basic equipment required for safe operations due to these restrictions and delays on importing essential equipment. Essential equipment includes vehicles, armoured vehicles, spare parts, lubricants to keep those vehicles moving and many other pieces of equipment. Only 6 of our armoured vehicles, out of a fleet of 21, are functional today.

Early recovery efforts are also very seriously constrained, particularly due to restrictions on so-called dual-use items, which limit the provision of decent shelters, the rehabilitation of infrastructure and the restoration of basic services.

The World Food Programme also leads what we call the Logistics Cluster, which coordinates the transport and storage of the humanitarian response. In addition to this, we carry out road assessments, road repairs and debris removal to help maintain humanitarian access. But all of that is constrained, as we say, due to the lack of materials and equipment that go into the strip.

Now, let me just quickly talk about the West Bank, although obviously a lot of attention is still on Gaza.

As you have heard, military operations, movement restrictions and settler violence have all increased over time, driving displacement and the loss of livelihoods and, now, growing food insecurity. We are having to scale up our operations in the West Bank, and the trend is deeply worrying and needs sustained attention.

Today, across the West Bank, WFP supports a critical safety net for 350,000 people with a combination of food and cash-based transfers for the most vulnerable and food insecure communities — communities where, a few years ago, we would never have needed to provide assistance.

Honourable chair, senators and distinguished witnesses, Canada’s support is making a real difference at this critical moment. We urge you to continue funding the life-saving assistance that you do so well and to use your influence to press for humanitarian access and, ultimately, an end to this conflict and a genuine implementation of the ceasefire with all parties in this conflict.

Thank you, distinguished members, and I am happy to take questions.

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Hollingworth.

We go into the room now with Mr. Michael Lawson. You have the floor.

Michael Lawson, Humanitarian Representative to Canada, Doctors Without Borders: Great. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and to all the members of the committee, for inviting me to speak to you today about the humanitarian situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory of Gaza and the West Bank.

I am here as a representative of Doctors Without Borders — or Médecins Sans Frontières, better known as MSF — which is an independent medical humanitarian organization that has been one of the largest providers of direct medical care in Gaza since the start of the current conflict. We have also worked to support the daily water needs of Gaza’s population in a place where almost the entire water infrastructure has been destroyed. In the West Bank, MSF provides outpatient consultations, mental health care and a wide range of other health services.

Based on what we are witnessing through these activities, I can tell you that the acute humanitarian needs in both Gaza and the West Bank remain immense, and that access to essential services for populations in need continues to be unacceptably restricted.

In the West Bank, in particular, movement restrictions and insecurity have significantly reduced access to primary and secondary health care in already underserved communities. Patients often cannot reach clinics or hospitals, and health care workers are equally impeded from reaching patients. But I will focus my comments here on Gaza, where the Palestinian population has been experiencing a severe deterioration in health and wellbeing for more than two and a half years, driven by ongoing violence, repeated displacement, the destruction of critical infrastructure and the collapse of essential services.

Israeli government restrictions on the entry of humanitarian assistance, including medical items, fuel and materials needed to provide water, sanitation and shelter, have contributed to inhumane living conditions, leading to preventable illnesses and also death. Data from MSF-supported facilities between January and March of this year show an overwhelming burden of disease. Respiratory infections, such as pneumonia, are the leading cause of illness, accounting for most consultations and 80% of admissions to one of MSF’s pediatric hospitals, with infants making up two thirds of cases.

Unsafe living conditions and lack of access to water and hygiene are meanwhile driving widespread diarrheal and skin diseases.

Malnutrition levels are alarming. In the first three months of 2026, 383 children were admitted to MSF therapeutic feeding centres for acute malnutrition. One in four pregnant women admitted to our intensive care units is malnourished, contributing to poor birth outcomes and increasing risks for newborns.

The current situation in Gaza quite clearly constitutes an acute humanitarian emergency. The vast majority of people, an estimated 1.9 million, out of a population of just over 2 million, have been displaced from their homes, many of them multiple times since the conflict began. The humanitarian needs remain immediate and overwhelming.

I wish to emphasize this point because we have noted a growing tendency among some governments and humanitarian donors to characterize the current situation as being in a “post‑conflict” or “recovery” phase. This is decidedly not the case. There are urgent humanitarian needs in Gaza right now that are going unmet through a combination of untenable access restrictions imposed by the Israeli authorities and a tendency from others to view them through a non-emergency lens.

Clean water is a clear example. There is an engineered scarcity of water in Gaza, a territory that relies on measures including desalination and water trucking. An estimated 90% of Gaza’s water infrastructure has been destroyed by the ongoing conflict. MSF, in addition to our medical activities, has taken on a significant role in water production and distribution in the territory, since the lack of clean water is driving medical needs. Scabies, for example, which is an agonizing skin infection and has surged through Gaza in recent months, is driven by overcrowded living conditions, shared bedding and limited access to clean water for hygiene.

However, we routinely find our water provision efforts blocked. The equipment we need for water supply is consistently prevented from entering Gaza by Israeli authorities. Approximately one third of our requests to import water and sanitation-related equipment last year were rejected, or the requests went unanswered. This includes, as you’ve heard, water tanks, pumps, spare parts and materials for desalination.

Essential services like water trucking are also being deprioritized by humanitarian donors, despite the fact that few other options to provide clean water exist. A push toward rebuilding large-scale infrastructure is indeed necessary but cannot come at the expense of meeting immediate essential needs. Simply wishing Gaza to now be in recovery rather than in an emergency context is not enough to make it so.

More than two and a half years of conflict and violence have led to trauma, displacement and immense needs across both Gaza and the West Bank. Although the world’s attention has been drawn away by other crises, the situation facing Palestinians in both territories remains as dire as ever. Israeli authorities must stop blocking access to essential humanitarian assistance, and governments such as Canada’s must hold Israel accountable for those blockages while continuing to prioritize immediate humanitarian needs in this ongoing crisis.

Mr. Chair and distinguished members, thank you for having me here to speak with you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Lawson.

Colleagues, as I mentioned earlier, we will have four-minute segments, but that’s not an invitation to make your questions too long, just so you know. We will start with the deputy chair, Senator Harder.

Senator Harder: Thank you to both our witnesses for your statements, as well as your ongoing work in this area. It’s much appreciated.

My question is for Jon Allen. I would align myself with your preamble, and thank you for that. I would like you to explore the whole issue of the West Bank and the settler issue. I applaud the efforts you made to coordinate the letter that was sent to the Prime Minister.

My question more broadly is: Where is the leverage on getting the Netanyahu government to act in a fashion that allows for the resolution of or at least the promotion of the two-state solution to which you are devoting your efforts? And on the response, I’d like to ask about the leverage more generally, as well as, specifically, what can Canada do?

This won’t happen without leverage. I will make the assertion, just for you to spin off, that nothing will happen until Netanyahu is gone.

Mr. Allen: I would agree with you 100%, senator. When I was ambassador from 2006 to 2010, there were about 250,000 settlers in the West Bank. There are now 750,000. Of that 750,000, 500,000 are in what are called the settlement blocks that are part of a deal that will be negotiated once a deal, hopefully, is negotiated. They will stay, and there will be a swap for an equal amount of land for the Palestinians, but that still leaves 200,000 or so settlers. Obviously, there is a number in East Jerusalem as well. They will have to be dealt with.

In my view and, as I said, in the view of others, that is not impossible. What is impossible is any hope that the current government, the coalition with the prime minister and the two ministers I mentioned, but other very-far-right ministers as well — there is no question that they will not agree to stop the settlements. They will not agree to begin to negotiate with the Palestinians. Therefore, our hope has to be that in late September or October, depending on when the elections are, the Israeli people elect a new and different coalition.

It will not be a centre-left coalition. It will not be a social democratic party. It will not be like the old Isreal Labour Party. It will be centre right, and it will not move quickly to a two-state solution. Nor will the Palestinians, divided between Hamas in Gaza and a discredited Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, be ready to move toward that.

In addition, both sides continue to suffer trauma: the Israelis post-October 7, and the Palestinians on account of 70,000 or more deaths and hundreds of thousands injured as a result of the war in Gaza and the violence in the West Bank.

I don’t think immediate pressure from the government on the Netanyahu coalition will do anything. The Canadian government can’t act alone. The Canadian government alone, neither by virtue of its trade nor by virtue of its standing, will be able to move the Israeli government, this one or the next.

We have to work with the EU, which is, hopefully, now more likely to act with the defeat of the Orbán government. We have to act with Australia, New Zealand and the Nordics together. I noted —

The Chair: Sorry, I’m going to interrupt. We’ve gone over time.

Senator Al Zaibak: Thank you, Mr. Allen, for your opening remarks, for joining us today and for your continued efforts to find a viable resolution to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.

Reflecting on your interesting journey as a former Canadian diplomat, could you please share with us how your views of how the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and possible solutions have evolved since 2006? What events have shaped the evolution of your views? Why do you think that the two-state solution is still doable under the current circumstances and in the near future?

Mr. Allen: Well, while I was ambassador, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who had put forward the last offer to the Palestinians for a peace deal, resigned, and subsequently, Prime Minister Netanyahu was elected. Prime Minister Netanyahu has been opposed to a two-state solution for all of the almost 19 years that he has served as prime minister during two different times in Israel.

I guess what has moved me is the knowledge that the Palestinian people cannot continue to be oppressed. There has been an occupation, which the International Court of Justice has declared illegal in international law, and there have been settlements, which are declared illegal and which the Canadian government and all Western governments declare illegal. We, the West, have done very little about it. We speak out against it, but we do not pressure the Israeli government to act.

I have seen five different wars between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, and I watched what happened on October 7 and post‑October 7. I have only confirmed my view that this continuing occupation and oppression can only breed more violence. Only with a path toward a two-state solution can that violence end, and both of those peoples be able to begin with peace and security.

As I said, right now, they are both suffering trauma. They both have different narratives about how they have gotten to where they are. I understand those different narratives. But I firmly believe that, with real leadership that has vision and, most importantly, is prepared to deal with extremists on both sides — to deal with violent groups in Gaza and in the West Bank on the Palestinian side, and to deal with the likes of the Smotrich and Ben-Gvir’s and other right-wing extremists in Israel — they are the ones that have consistently tried to avoid peace. Neither of those sides wants peace. Each of those sides wants either a Palestine from the river to the sea or an Israel from the river to the sea. You have to deal with those extreme groups, and then you can begin to find a moderate centre and move toward a more peaceful solution.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you for all being here. You certainly represent important aspects of this. I’m going to ask a question to all of you first. I’m not sure how well you’ll be able to answer, but I want to ask it.

Preparing for this meeting, reading the brief, I see that $400 million has been committed to Gaza since 2023. A lot of it was for aid, but a lot of the aid has not gotten into where it needs to be. Do you have any intel or insight on where this money is being spent, if it is being spent?

I’m opening it up because there may be different perspectives from our panel. I can start with the ambassador if you don’t mind.

Mr. Allen: I’m not the best one to answer that. I think Mr. Hollingworth or the Médecins Sans Frontières representative would be better equipped to answer that.

Mr. Hollingworth: From our side, the funding that comes from Canada has been, as I said, absolutely critical for providing life-saving assistance to many hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in Gaza over the past few years. Indeed, while we have met many constraints and challenges, we have consistently been able to get aid in. There have been times, very clearly noted by us and the media, where we know that we were not doing enough, and there have been warnings of catastrophic hunger, catastrophic levels of malnutrition as well as all sorts of other multi-sector, cross-sector indicators that told us how much people were suffering.

But when we have had access, when the physical constraints like crossing points have been resolved, we have been able to avert the worst of the acuteness of humanitarian needs.

Unfortunately, let’s be very clear: the situation is far from over. It is extraordinarily fragile. You are talking about more than 2 million people that now fear that they are only going to live in an area 30% the size of what used to be one of the most highly densely populated areas in the world without livelihoods, farming areas and, for the most part, brick-and-mortar homes to live in. The vast majority live in tents in unsanitary situations with very little access to clean water, and at best, perhaps one good meal a day.

We are nowhere near being over, but every single penny that we can get — as long as the access and the humanitarian space is there — is being used wisely.

Mr. Lawson: We as MSF, for our operations in Gaza and in the West Bank, do not accept institutional funding from government donors, so we remain neutral and independent.

I will echo the previous comments to point out the fact that the humanitarian needs in Gaza, in particular, and in the West Bank, are immense. Humanitarian assistance has not been completely blocked. It is at the mercy, and the whim lately, of the Israeli authorities that slow it down to a trickle and then some go in.

To echo Mr. Hollingworth, when aid comes in, it is crucially needed, and it makes a life-saving difference. The people who live in Gaza are almost entirely dependent on humanitarian assistance.

What’s more, the longer this goes on, with these restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid, it is simply exacerbating the situation, so the needs are becoming more acute.

To point out the same factors, you have people continuing to live in camps who don’t have access to clean water or sanitation facilities. The fact is we are seeing an increase in disease spread and a number of negative health indicators. The needs are only going to grow.

With every passing day as the needs grow, it is more and more essential for humanitarian assistance to be directed toward the response in Gaza. The problem is that it is being restricted, and it is, again, at the mercy of gatekeepers for that assistance entering into the territory, which is just making the situation more difficult.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator Coyle: Thank you to all of our witnesses. This is really an important conversation, and as I think all of you have pointed out, it is time to get it back on the table and on people’s conscience and consciousness.

I have so many questions. Last week, we had a session, and I believe Mr. Hollingworth, you were here with us. We were speaking of Sudan and the humanitarian situation there. One of the things the witnesses last week spoke about was the role of the diplomatic community — Canada’s and others — in helping to really advocate on behalf of humanitarian organizations in terms of access; facilitate everything you need to be able to do your job well.

We heard from Mr. Allen that our neighbour to the south, Mr. Trump, is preoccupied, as we all know, with other files at the moment. That may be a good thing or a bad thing. I’m not sure. When he has gotten his hand in something, it is dangerous. But I’m wondering what are others doing to be helpful. What could be done to be helpful in this situation from our diplomatic community?

Mr. Lawson: I think the clearest and most specific answer is that any diplomatic leverage that is available should be brought to bear to insist that humanitarian assistance needs to get to the people who need it most. There is also the fundamental matter of international humanitarian law that must be upheld.

Israel has an obligation to ensure that there is access to the necessary humanitarian assistance that is required. That is not being upheld. So there also needs to be accountability for the fact that deliberate restrictions are being placed on essential needs and the assistance that is needed for essential needs.

From a diplomatic perspective, it is far from our ability as MSF to dictate how diplomats are going to do their jobs and how to exercise that leverage, but it is quite clear that, especially Canada and its allies, have an incredibly important role to be able to stick up, frankly, for basic humanitarian principles and basic global norms and not stand by quietly when they are being violated and we watch them being violated.

There are a number of pieces happening at once here, and it behooves the Government of Canada and this country to be able to speak up for upholding those principles and making a point of ensuring that, not only should the assistance get in and blockages be removed, but that violations of international humanitarian law, specifically, and of those core principles — people should be held to account for that, and there should be accountability in place.

Senator Coyle: Maybe I could ask Mr. Allen; actually, anybody could answer it. Are there examples that we know of currently where there is some effective diplomacy going on, maybe separate from the two-state solution in the long term but just moving these blockages that are in place to at least get that humanitarian aid in? Is there anything working? Is there something we can learn from that?

Mr. Allen: I can start, and then Mr. Hollingworth can continue.

I don’t think there is. I think the only government that is able to move the Israeli government is the Trump administration. It is quite clear. They have been effective in some ways. As you suggested, that hasn’t always benefited the Palestinians; in some ways, it has been the opposite. We did get a ceasefire. However, to be honest with you, as I mentioned to Senator Harder, this current government is immovable, relatively speaking.

Our government, for example, has spoken out a number of times about the situation. I have been very impressed with the current prime minister, who, as soon as he took office, joined with others in protesting what was happening in the West Bank and Gaza. He did so a second time with another group of countries, and then he joined with others in December 2025 in recognizing a Palestinian state and being critical of what was happening in the West Bank and in Gaza.

The Chair: Thank you. I’m sorry to interrupt again, but we must move on.

Senator Woo: Thank you to the witnesses, and thank you for your advocacy on this issue.

I want to pick up on Mr. Lawson’s comments in his previous answer to Senator Coyle that underscored that we are not talking about a sad situation of humanitarian need in Palestine; we’re talking about violations of international humanitarian law. The real wonder is why we haven’t responded more vigorously to these grave violations of international humanitarian law, to give my opinion. Mr. Allen, your letter, together with 189 diplomats, suggests to me that you and your colleagues feel that not enough has been done, and you, therefore, need to encourage the government to do more. However, I would like each of you, particularly the Canadians on this panel, to speculate why it has been so difficult for Canada to do more than issue statements. Let me offer four hypotheses, and please feel free to shoot them down.

The first is that there is still debate in this country among friends of Israel who would assert that it is unclear if, in fact, Israel has violated, in a grave way, international humanitarian law — the right to self-defence, Hamas and so on. That’s one excuse that’s been given.

A second one is the one that Senator Harder raised and which was discussed a little bit: There is no point; we can’t do anything effectively, anyway. Maybe we can do something if we are in alliance with other countries, but why bother? That is the second excuse.

The third one is the fear of acknowledging that Canada may have been aiding and abetting Israel’s violations of international humanitarian law because we continue to trade with a country that has been called out for its illegal occupations of Palestine, both in Gaza and the West Bank.

Finally, and perhaps the most difficult one is the charge of anti-Semitism when this government — any government — tries to criticize Israel harshly. This has come up very recently in the aftermath of the establishment of the Ministerial Advisory Council on Rights, Equality, and Inclusion, where Jewish groups have quickly criticized Mr. Carney for not identifying what they think is the core problem of anti-Semitism, which is criticism of Israel.

I would like each of you, if you are able, to respond to why it is that Canada finds it so difficult to do what seems to be obvious and what we would do in an instant in any other situation.

The Chair: This is going to be rather difficult to do in a minute between the three of you. Let’s start with Mr. Allen.

Mr. Allen: Going through your list, it is clear that there are violations of international humanitarian law. That shouldn’t be one of the reasons.

The “there is no point” excuse is perhaps a part of it, and it is also perhaps the fact that it is difficult to try to get the various groups together — as I said, the EU, Australians and us — to take action to actually impose sanctions, for example. We have imposed sanctions on individuals and settler groups, but we have not, for example, broken our free-trade agreement. There is no suspension mechanism, so we would have to break the free-trade agreement.

There is no question there is pressure from the Israeli Canadian diaspora. There always has been. There is pressure from all of our diaspora communities on their issues, but I think that pressure, to be honest, is less effective now against the Carney government than it has been in the past. As I mentioned, the Carney government has taken more steps than previous governments in this case. Nonetheless, they are still subject to those pressures.

I agree with you: What has quieted Palestinians in protesting in Canada and what concerns governments, especially a government like Germany, for example, or other Western governments, is the charge is anti-Semitism when it comes to criticizing Israel. It comes not from the diaspora community only; it comes from Prime Minister Netanyahu and his ministers. When legitimate criticism of his country is made, the charge is that you are supporting terrorism and anti-Semitism.

Of course, my view is that, by not calling out what is happening in the West Bank and Gaza, there is a complicity of silence. It is the silence and the failure sometimes, frankly, of the Jewish community not to speak out that I think makes people in Canada say, “Well, do they support everything Israel does? Do they support what happened in Gaza?”

Senator MacDonald: Last year, the Canadian government gave recognition to the Palestinian state. The Prime Minister put out a statement in September indicating that the Palestinian Authority had provided direct commitments to Canada and others in the international community on:

. . . much-needed reforms, including the commitments by Palestinian Authority President Abbas to fundamentally reform its governance, to hold general elections in 2026 in which Hamas can play no part, and to demilitarize the Palestinian state.

What are the current prospects for a Palestinian general election in 2026? How would you assess the state of efforts by the Palestinian Authority toward these political and other necessary reforms?

Mr. Allen: Without question, there has not been enough done. There have been local elections in the West Bank, but, frankly, mostly all Fatah candidates were elected; in other words, the party of the current president was elected.

In terms of disarming Hamas, that’s frankly not up to the Palestinian Authority. The Israelis have not allowed the Palestinian Authority to move into the West Bank to begin to even begin to govern there, along with a technocratic committee.

I agree with the implications of your question: Not enough has been done in that regard. What really needs to happen, as with the government of Israel, is that Mahmoud Abbas has to move from the scene, and a new, young, dynamic Palestinian group has to be able to run for elections and begin to govern there. There were commitments made. I don’t know how much pressure is being put on President Mahmoud Abbas or his prime minister, but more has to be done.

I would say, though, that in a situation of the kind of occupation that is going on in the West Bank, the activities that are going on in the West Bank, the fact that Israel is no longer paying the Palestinian government the taxes that it is owed, all the while that the Palestinian Authority government is helping Israel to prevent terrorism in their country — that doesn’t help the situation either.

So, it is a problem on both sides, but not enough has been done in regard to what you asked.

Senator MacDonald: Mr. Hollingworth, can you add anything to that?

Mr. Hollingworth: I cannot add anything to what has already been a very detailed response.

Senator MacDonald: Mr. Lawson, I’m just curious. You mentioned that about two thirds of the relief is getting through, but about a third isn’t. Is that arbitrary conduct at the border by individuals?

Mr. Lawson: That was a specific reference to the materials that we needed to run water desalination and distribution. That figure was that one third of the requests we made to import materials specifically for water distribution were either rejected or were not entered to.

In answer to your question is that arbitrarily done, I can say it is done with little to zero transparency and with little to zero consistency. We are unable to plan effectively. We are unable to assure the delivery of the materials we need to run the programs that we need to do. We’re talking about the distribution of something as essential as water. This is along with some of the other restrictions that are in place or put in place when we are given. For example, evacuation orders to leave the areas where we are carrying out desalination activities with very short notice. That has effectively and frequently moved essential water points out of access from us to be able to develop desalination and be able to move those forward, and to water access points as well.

So are they arbitrary? We don’t have visibility on the decision making, but are we able to plan effective humanitarian activities? No.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: Thank you to the witnesses for being here today and for everything they’re doing to keep us abreast of what’s going on.

My question is for the ambassador, Mr. Allen, whom I’d like to thank. I want to commend you for the courageous public position you’ve taken, as a Jewish person. Clearly, for non‑Jewish people, taking such a clear position isn’t easy. Thank you for that.

You mentioned Prime Minister Carney’s announcement that Canada would formally recognize the state of Palestine. What impact did that have on both Canada and Palestine?

Furthermore, the Foreign Affairs Minister, the Honourable Anita Anand, said that recognizing Palestinian statehood diplomatically and normalizing Canada-Palestine relations were two different things. How do you see that specifically?

Mr. Allen: Thank you, senator. I’m going to answer in English. Forgive my French.

[English]

My French is inadequate for these kinds of details.

To be honest, I don’t think that much has taken place in response as a result of the recognition by Canada, the U.K., France and a number of other countries. I think it has given hope to some Palestinians. It has sent a message, as we hoped, and I think what the government hoped, to the Israeli government that the two-state solution remains our policy and is important and that we’re not giving up on it. It is also a signal that the actions of attempted annexation are unacceptable. So, to that extent, it was and is important. Does it mean that we’re going to see a viable two-state solution tomorrow? No.

As to why we haven’t opened a formal embassy and accredited a formal ambassador, I think you will have to ask the foreign minister, but it may be related to the fact that enough of the conditions that were discussed by various Western governments with President Abbas haven’t progressed to the point where those governments want to take the next step.

Senator Gerba: And about Minister Anand’s declaration?

Mr. Allen: Which declaration was that, madam senator?

Senator Gerba: The minister stated that recognizing the Palestinian state is not recognizing the normalization of the relationship between Canada and this state.

Mr. Allen: Yes. That’s what I was referring to. We have recognized that, as a state, the next step would be to accredit a Palestinian ambassador in Ottawa and send a Canadian ambassador to Palestine. Right now, we have a representative office in Ramallah, and the Palestinians have a representative here in Ottawa. That next step of accrediting ambassadors simply hasn’t been taken because the government has decided, as I suggested, perhaps that not enough has been done by the Palestinian government to move on the commitments that it made that December in New York.

Senator Ravalia: Thank you very much to our witnesses for being here today. My question is directed to Michael Lawson. Given the ongoing attacks on medical personnel, shrinking resources, lack of functional hospitals and clinics, and the inability of international medical groups to get visas to get into Gaza and, obviously, a heavy strain on your own selves dealing not only with Gaza but with other international crises, is the medical system reaching a breaking point, or has it already collapsed in Gaza?

Mr. Lawson: Thank you for the question, senator. I would say, quite succinctly, that it has already collapsed. It has already reached a breaking point. It is not possible to offer a requisite level of care that is needed, even basic care, in Gaza with the resources that we have. It is impossible to run a hospital when you don’t know if you will have any electricity, power or medical supplies. All of this is inconsistent. All of this is unpredictable. Again, we are operating at the mercy of a system on which we have no visibility and no control. That’s not a health system. That is, at best, a bandage that is rapidly coming apart.

It is not a functioning health system. The people who are paying for that are the people of Gaza, who, again, as mentioned earlier, are not only without access to care, but are living in a state of acute deprivation, having been displaced, many of them multiple times over and living in a situation in which their health needs are rapidly deteriorating. It is, first of all, not a fit health system, and it is certainly not fit to meet the needs of people who are undergoing immense levels of deprivation and, frankly, trauma for quite a number of people.

That ranges from everything, again, from high levels of trauma to the fact that, just in terms of access to sanitation facilities, they don’t exist. There is no water coming. People have nowhere to go to the bathroom. It is an incredibly unhealthy environment. If you take that and layer on top the fact that you have a phantom of a health system that is unable to reliably run even basic operations — and I’m saying this as a representative of the medical organization that is doing a significant amount of the medical response in Gaza. But if we can get even basic supplies in because they are held up arbitrarily — we get the lists of the dual-use items and what is supposed to be allowed and what isn’t, but those lists change, and they change without notice. Even then, even when items don’t appear on that list and we’ve been given a green light to bring them in, they can still be held up.

I know I said “succinctly” at the beginning, and I haven’t been succinct, but I would say it has already passed a breaking point.

Senator Ravalia: Very briefly, Mr. Hollingworth, has the world forgotten about Gaza and Sudan? Have we created a two‑tier society where Ukraine is in the news, there are billions of dollars in aid, and it is in the media every day? It seems that these other communities that are in such desperate need have suddenly gone onto the second or third shelf. Am I imagining that?

Mr. Hollingworth: Thank you very much, senator. It is a very good question.

For a Palestinian in Gaza, the level of hopelessness and despair is off the charts. I can tell you, as someone who slept there for about two months at the beginning of 2024, when you wake up listening to quadcopters and drones and you go to sleep listening to quadcopters and drones, missiles firing, people being targeted and listening to bullets flying and shellfire all day, every single day, fired from the sea, from the air and from across the border, the level of hopelessness is great — but you know you can leave. If you are trapped there, and you don’t think that you, your mother, your father or your children can ever leave, it’s a different level of hopelessness.

From what I’ve seen, experienced and understand from my colleagues who are Palestinians in Gaza, it is different from Sudan, Afghanistan, Yemen or Somalia. All of those places that I mentioned can be added to a list of countries that are not spoken about enough, whose people suffer greatly every day from food insecurity, hunger, fear and deprivation, but nothing compares to being a Palestinian in Gaza today.

Senator Wilson: My question is probably best directed to Mr. Allen. You spoke in your answers about the disproportionate leverage of the U.S. in this situation. I have two questions in relation to that.

One, it seems to me that, as you outlined, the hope of getting the United States to embrace a broader two-state solution and put its heft behind it is not just unlikely but sounding impossible. What about them showing a shred of decency in terms of the humanitarian crisis and using their leverage to force Israel to allow that aid to get through? Is that something that we and our allies can exercise in discussions with the United States to try to make that happen, probably in a quieter way? Maybe that is happening.

Second, if we look at the recommendations outlined in your joint letter to the Prime Minister, it seems to me that, in order for those to have any effect, it would require a coalition of us and our other allies to work with us — we’ll say the middle powers — to have an effect. Doesn’t that, in turn, only increase the United States’ leverage further and entrench the situation more in terms of us not being able to influence them? I’m a little concerned about that.

Mr. Allen: Well, just dealing with the second point first, the idea is that only with that coalition could you exert the kind of influence that might, with a new government, tip the balance and send a signal. In other words, be as powerful as the United States in its inability or unwillingness to do anything. We would be acting in contrast to the United States by either imposing sanctions or responding in respect of free trade agreements.

I know that the government is regularly talking to our allies because they frequently issue these declarations. They issued one not long ago. I think they are all grappling with the problem that was raised by Senator Woo, which is just what we do and when we do it, et cetera.

I do think we should be working with them, and I think we should be coming up with a list of sanctions on individuals. They should be cutting off financing, insurance and access to banks for settler movements. I think they should be encouraging, in respect of Gaza, for example, and trying to make sure that NGOs and UN organizations like UNRWA that operate there should be free to do so and be able to act, as best they can, to alleviate the horrible humanitarian situation that you’ve heard about.

Could you repeat your first question?

Senator Wilson: Do you think there is any hope of us convincing the Trump administration to exercise its leverage to get aid through?

Mr. Allen: There should be. The 20-point plan talks about it. The 20-point plan also talks, in points 19 and 20, about moving toward a Palestinian state. But as I suggested in my remarks, the Trump administration seems to have forgotten about Gaza. It is now focusing its efforts on Lebanon because it is connected to Iran.

I think it is a good idea for various governments to approach the Americans and try to move them in that regard. We have to recall, of course, that this administration essentially abandoned USAID, which was the largest humanitarian and aid organization in the world, leaving thousands of people dying and dead from AIDS, Ebola and other diseases.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: Mr. Allen, you talked about trade agreements and the pressure countries can exert on Israel through trade.

Is there something specific Canada should do vis-à-vis its trade policy and trade agreement with Israel? Are there singular steps Canada should take independently?

Further to Senator Wilson’s point about middle powers that also have agreements with Israel, are there things Canada can do in partnership with its allies?

[English]

Mr. Allen: Senator, in our letter to the Prime Minister, we suggested that he inform the Israeli government of Canada’s intention to undertake an immediate review of the Canada-Israel Free Trade Agreement, with a focus in particular on rules of origin, to try and ensure that no products that come out of the West Bank are exported to Canada. That’s not an easy process, but it is something that the government could and should undertake. We also suggested that they might notify Israel of Canada’s intention to terminate the Canada-Israel Strategic Partnership within six months if Israel did not comply with a number of the requests that we had made. So that’s something else that could be done.

Our relationship, frankly, with Israel, both on the trade side and in terms of that, have the Israel Strategic Partnership, is quite minimal. The largest trading partner with Israel is the EU. They have any number of very significant research, development and innovation agreements, and there has been much talk in the EU about suspending those. They need to get consensus to do that, but were they to move, I could see the Canadian government, the U.K. and perhaps Australia moving in concert. We would certainly welcome that.

As I said to Senator Harder, I don’t think it will move this government, but it will send a signal to the next government that Israel doesn’t want to become any more of a pariah state than it is. In a sense, enough is enough in respect of settler violence and the desperate situation in Gaza, et cetera.

[Translation]

Senator Hébert: Thank you. I wanted to follow up on USAID and what Doctors Without Borders is seeing on the ground in that respect.

Mr. Lawson: That’s a good question.

[English]

In terms of the impact of the USAID cuts on their response in Gaza, it is very difficult for our organization to be able to quantify. We are a receiving organization and have never been of USAID funding.

What I can say quickly is that the USAID cuts, but also global levels of cuts to humanitarian assistance, have had a significant and debilitating impact on humanitarian operations around the world. We see this in virtually every place in which we operate. Médecins Sans Frontières usually tries to operate in places where no one else can reach. Now there are simply more of those because there are fewer and fewer actors, because most of those other actors do depend on institutional funding. We see immense gaps in basic humanitarian responses and increased —

The Chair: Thank you, Mr. Lawson.

Senator Adler: The question is to the former ambassador, Mr. Allen. Listening to our eloquent panel today, it is clear — not that it hasn’t been in the past — that the desperation of Palestinians in Gaza is almost immeasurable. I don’t know whether I’m asking about this because I happen to be a refugee and part of a refugee family. You cannot throw a rock anywhere in Canada, the United States or many countries in Europe without hitting someone who has benefited from refugee policies.

We all realize how absurd it is at the moment to continue to advocate for the two-nation state, because the facts on the ground conspire against it. Is it just as unbelievably impossible to think about a refugee program helping some of the people in Palestine?

Mr. Allen: There are two sides to that coin, senator. One is that we don’t want to encourage Palestinians to leave. Encourage them if they don’t want to leave because they will never be able to get back under this government and perhaps others. That’s always been a concern.

But I’m glad you raised the question because there was a program for 5,000 Palestinians to be able to leave Gaza, and for various — I would call them — bureaucratic/biometric/security reasons, very few have made it out. To go back to another analogy, hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians came to Canada and, of course, 40,000 Syrians did, but for a variety of reasons that I’ve not been able to untangle, the small number of 5,000 Gazans — some of whom were out of Gaza and in Egypt — have not been processed in any great numbers. This, despite a number of groups trying to figure out why, we’ve not been able to move that process forward.

The Chair: That brings us to the end of round one. I will ask a question of both Mr. Allen and Mr. Hollingworth. This is with respect to the Board of Peace, which was established by President Trump as the chair. He pointedly said that Canada would not be invited, and everybody else had to put a billion dollars up front for membership. It does not appear to have met formally in months. President Trump is distracted, as we pointed out.

The high representative briefed the Security Council in May. The board has been attempting to gather funds for reconstruction, but they are slow to come in. Some people are saying that the board has been deprioritized since the Iran war.

My question really is: Is this just a performative-type vehicle? Is it meant to somehow replace the specialized agencies of the United Nations? I would very much like a comment from Mr. Allen and from Mr. Hollingworth on this rather strange entity.

Mr. Allen: Thank you, senator. Yes, it was initially meant to replace UN agencies, much to the horror of the United Nations and most countries around the world. On the question of money that the President has or has not gathered, my understanding is no one has actually contributed the billion dollars. There were no guidelines for its expenditure, et cetera.

The board, under the President, has not met, as far as I know. It was perhaps to be chaired by the former prime minister Tony Blair. The one person who does seem to be acting is Nickolay Mladenov, the former UN official. He has been pressing the parties — Israel, in this case — to allow that technocratic committee to come in and to begin doing its analysis, at least in preparation for some reconstruction and greater flows of humanitarian aid. My understanding is that the Israeli government has not allowed that to happen so far.

So we have a Board of Peace that —

The Chair: Thank you.

Mr. Hollingworth, do you have any comment? Are you worried that the WFP will be taken over by the Board of Peace?

Mr. Hollingworth: If there is an entity that could do what the United Nations and the humanitarian community have provided to many Palestinians in Gaza over many decades, sadly, and if there were an organization that could do that, we would gladly support them. At this juncture, that doesn’t exist.

We don’t have direct conversations or contact with the Board of Peace as the World Food Programme. The United Nations does, and we work through our system, through our residents and humanitarian coordinator in the state of Palestine, who does meet and discuss with them. At this juncture, we have not seen any very significant actions taken. The U.S. government is still a supporter of humanitarian assistance for Palestinians in Gaza. It hasn’t been directed through the Board of Peace at this juncture. It is through the State Department of the U.S. government. Aryeh Lightstone, the chairman of the Board of Peace, is in contact with the UN leadership in Jerusalem on those programs. Again, at this juncture, it is more a name than an action.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator Harder: My question is for Mr. Hollingworth. You spoke of hopelessness and despair among the Palestinians. Isn’t that precisely the point of the IDF’s actions? If this continues and the level of humanitarian assistance is not able to be increased, where are we a year from now or six months from now?

Mr. Hollingworth: Thank you, senator. I can’t comment on the purported aims or objectives behind the manner in which Palestinians in Gaza are treated or, indeed, about humanitarian organizations that wish to have access and provide services. What I can say is that we have been through periods of very little access. We’ve been through periods where that significantly improves but never reaches the levels that we would like it to, and that we believe, based on evidence, we need to reach. We have a ceasefire presently, seven months in, which is more of a “less fire” than a ceasefire. We need to see that this improves.

We’ve been through periods where catastrophic hunger has been prevalent across the Gaza Strip, and we’ve been through periods where we’ve been able to minimize that and mitigate it. We’ve not seen, at any given time, a situation where we can start building back better or building back to what it was. The Gaza Strip today looks absolutely nothing like it did five years ago. For the most part, it is absolutely destroyed.

Putting people back on track to the way they once lived is an enormous task that will take decades, frankly.

The Chair: Thank you.

Senator Woo: I want to pick up on the questions by Senator Adler and Senator Harder. The comfort that we in the West give ourselves by defaulting to the two-state solution, as the solution in all respectable discussions on Israel-Palestine is the rigour to support the two-state solution, and I do as well. But when there is such an asymmetry of power, the two-state solution is not viable. Not to abandon the two-state solution, but, Mr. Allen, is there a different way of talking about the two-state solution that indicates some real awareness of how difficult it is to achieve and how much the Palestinians are the underdogs, and that they will never achieve a two-state solution unless something more than this rhetoric is trotted out each time there is an issue in the Israel-Palestine situation?

Mr. Allen: Unfortunately, senator, I don’t think there is another solution. People talk about confederations. Of course, people talk about a one-state solution. A one-state solution that would favour the Palestinians would be a democratic vote in all of the land between the river and the sea. That will not happen. The Israelis will not allow it. I understand where they are coming from.

Senator Woo: I’m not suggesting a different solution. Is there a different way of talking about the two-state solution that more accurately represents the situation and which allows us to take some action rather than simply trot out the two-state solution as the answer?

Mr. Allen: Most honest individuals understand the asymmetry that exists and the fact that there is an occupation and an open-air prison in Gaza. That reality, among people who are open to seeing reality, is well known. We all understand that, unless there is serious pressure put on Israel, they may not move in that direction. Unless, of course, as has happened in the past, a visionary leader goes from being fairly right wing to realizing that, if he really wants his people, as I said, to be able to live in peace and security, and not have to keep sending their children to war every two, three or four years, they will reach out and see if there is an opportunity.

It requires work on both sides, but, yes, I don’t have any quick and easy answers. I’m sorry.

The Chair: Thank you very much.

Senator M. Deacon: Hypothetically, if Hamas fully disarmed — and I know that it is very much a big “if” — do you envisage Israel withdrawing from Gaza? I’m asking the question because I’m looking at what is happening in the West Bank, and I have a hard time believing they will give up land in the Gaza Strip.

[Translation]

Senator Gerba: According to UNICEF, approximately 700,000 children in Gaza have been without formal schooling since October 2023, and nearly 98% of schools have been damaged.

How do you account for the fact that, despite the scale of the problem, the international community seems to be less engaged than it is in relation to other conflicts, for instance, the one in Ukraine?

[English]

Mr. Allen: To be honest, I’m not sure that the world has forgotten the Middle East because the Middle East appears on the front pages and on newscasts everywhere. There is so much happening in the Middle East right now, between Iran and Lebanon, et cetera, that it is just occupying so much space and the attention of governments.

It amazes me that the “Never again” can continue to happen and that there can be starvation in Sudan. I hear, frankly, from a lot of people who say, why are you paying so much attention to the Middle East? Look at what is happening in Sudan.

The world is in a bad place, and we don’t have leadership from the largest former power in the world. So, things are difficult. They should be better, and it is sad that all our governments — the U.K., our own and, of course, the Americans and others in Europe — have reduced their aid at a time when it is needed more than ever.

Can you remind me about the first question, senator?

Senator M. Deacon: Thank you. I asked hypothetically about if Hamas fully disarmed.

Mr. Allen: If they disarmed — it is a huge hypothetical, although there are plans that have been drawn up in terms of what happened in Northern Ireland, for there to be a slow and a real process for disarmament — and if the Israelis were prepared to withdraw as that process began, each withdrawing a bit, and then disarming a bit, that would be great. That’s what is supposed to happen.

Under this government, I don’t think it would happen. This government is now running for an election. They failed in Iran. They failed in Lebanon. All of this activity is an effort by Netanyahu to try to strengthen his position as the elections approach.

Between now and then, hard to know what another government would do in Gaza, but they have to do something; the situation has to change.

The Chair: Thank you very much. We’ve come to the end of our time. On behalf of the committee, I would like to thank Jon Allen, Matthew Hollingworth and Michael Lawson for your very thoughtful responses to our questions. It is clear that the situation in Gaza and the West Bank is a very serious one.

Colleagues, thank you for your contributions.

(The committee adjourned.)

Back to top